Revision of the theory of phototropism in plants: a new interpretation of a classical experiment

Went's classical experiment on the diffusion of auxin activity from unilaterally illuminated oat coleoptile tips (Went 1928), was repeated as precisely as possible. In agreement with Went's data with theAvena curvature assay, the agar blocks from the illuminated side of oat (Avena sativa L. cv. Victory) coleoptile tips had, on an average, 38% of the auxin activity of those from the shaded side. However, determination of the absolute amounts of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) in the agar blocks, using a physicochemical assay following purification, showed that the IAA was evenly distributed in the blocks from the illuminated and shaded sides. In the blocks from the shaded and dark-control halves the amounts of IAA were 2.5 times higher than the auxin activity measured by theAvena curvature test, and in those from the illuminated half even 7 times higher. Chromatography of the diffusates prior to theAvena curvature test demonstrated that the amounts of two growth inhibitors, especially of the more polar one, were significantly higher in the agar blocks from the illuminated side than in those from the shaded side and the dark control. These results show that the basic experiment from which the Cholodny-Went theory was derived, does not justify this theory. The data rather indicate that phototropism is caused by the light-induced, local accumulation of growth inhibitors against a background of even auxin distribution, the diffusion of auxin being unaffected.Abbreviation IAA indole-3-acetic acid     

Evidence Inconsistent with the Blaauw Model of Phototropism

The Blaauw model of phototropism equates the inhibition of growthat the illuminated side of a unilaterally illuminated organwith the blue light inhibition of overall organ extension evidentwhen some shoots are exposed to uniform blue light However,a study of the growth responses of Avena coleoptiles exposedto omnilateral, equal bilateral, unequal bilateral and unilateralblue light has revealed some light induced growth rate changeswhich cannot be explained by the Blaauw model. The growth responsesof cells at the illuminated and shaded sides of phototropicallystimulated coleoptiles seem to depend on the existence of alight gradient across the whole organ rather than the absolutelevels of light at either side. Key words: Phototropism, Avena coleoptile, Blaauw hypothesis, Blue light, Growth inhibition     

Growth distribution during first positive phototropic curvature of maize coleoptiles*

Abastract Measurements of growth increments on the shaded and the irradiated sides of phototropically stimulated maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles, obtained over the entire fluence range of the first positive curvature, indicate that the curvature is induced by growth stimulation on the shaded side and compensating inhibition on the irradiated side (length increments on the coleoptile flanks were determined 100 min after 30 s phototropic induction with blue light). At high fluences of blue light, overall stimulation of growth takes place, but this tendency is largely eliminated when only the tip of the coleoptile is irradiated. Time courses for growth increments obtained for the maximum first positive response show that the growth stimulation on the shaded side and the growth inhibition on the irradiated side commence almost simultaneously 20-30 min after the phototropic induction. The growth on the irradiated side almost ceases, but the growth rate on the shaded side is doubled, relative to the control rate. The onset of differential growth migrates basipetally from the tip at a velocity similar to that for polar auxin transport. The first positive phototropic response of the coleoptile is concluded to be the consequence of lateral redistribution of growth, which is not necessarily accompanied by changes in the net growth. The results are consonant with the Cholodny-Went theory of tropisms, in which lateral redistribution of auxin is considered to be the cause of tropic responses.     

Hormonal Relations in the Phototropic Response: III. The Movement of C-labeled and Endogenous Indoleacetic Acid in Phototropically Stimulated Zea Coleoptiles

The effect of phototropic stimulation of Zea coleoptile tips on the distribution of both endogenous indoleacetic acid (IAA) and applied C¹⁴-labeled IAA was determined. The tips rested on bisected agar blocks. More IAA was found in the blocks under the shaded side of the coleoptile tips than those under the irradiated side. However, no significant difference was observed between the total amounts of IAA, endogenous or labeled, in the irradiated and shaded sides of the experimental system. In addition, less endogenous auxin was found in the shaded tissues than in their irradiated counterparts. It is suggested that phototropism following unilateral irradiation with first positive radiant densities might be a consequence of lateral inequalities in the ability of the irradiated and shaded tissues to transport auxin basipetally.     

Analysis of growth during phototropic curvature of cress hypocotyls

Abstract. Growth rates throughout an organ curving phototropically under continuous, unilateral while light were monitored by lime-lapse photography of cress hypocotyls marked into 1 mm sections by two rows of ion-exchange beads. Curvature resulted from an integrated sequence of changes in growth rate on each side of the organ, but the actual patterns of change and, therefore rales of curvature, differed within even this one species, depending upon the immediate pretreatment of the seedlings. Transference of seedlings from darkness to unilateral irradiation gave immediate growth inhibition on both sides of the organ. Curvature resulted from differential recovery of growth rate, being seen first on the shaded side, most prominently in the apical regions; only 2h after initial exposure to light did growth recover on the lit (lower) side. On the other hand, transfer of seedlings from omnilateral to unilateral irradiation of the same intensity resulted in simultaneous growth inhibition on the irradiated side and stimulated growth on the shaded side: this growth stimulation of the shaded side was greater than occurred in totally darkened control plants.     

Phototropism in hypocotyls of radish. VI. No exchange of endogenous indole-3-acetic acid between peripheral and central cell layers during first and second positive phototropic curvatures

Using a physicochemical method, the distribution of endogenous indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) was measured in the peripheral and central cell layers, as well as in the illuminated and shaded sides of phototropically stimulated radish hypocotyls (Raphanus sativus var. hortensis f. gigantissimus Makino). The IAA was evenly distributed over the illuminated and shaded sides in the first and second positive phototropic curvatures induced by a pulse or a continuous unilateral illumination with blue light. Also, no net exchange of the IAA between the peripheral and central cell layers was observed during these curvatures. These results suggest that phototropism of radish hypocotyls cannot be described by the Cholodny-Went theory.     

NPH3- and PGP-like genes are exclusively expressed in the apical tip region essential for blue-light perception and lateral auxin transport in maize coleoptiles

Phototropic curvature results from differential growth on two sides of the elongating shoot, which is explained by asymmetrical indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) distribution. Using 2 cm maize coleoptile segments, 1st positive phototropic curvature was confirmed here after 8 s irradiation with unilateral blue light (0.33 μmol m(-2) s(-1)). IAA was redistributed asymmetrically by approximately 20 min after photo-stimulation. This asymmetric distribution was initiated in the top 0-3 mm region and was then transmitted to lower regions. Application of the IAA transport inhibitor, 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA), to the top 2 mm region completely inhibited phototropic curvature, even when auxin was simultaneously applied below the NPA-treated zone. Thus, lateral IAA movement occurred only within the top 0-3 mm region after photo-stimulation. Localized irradiation experiments indicated that the photo-stimulus was perceived in the apical 2 mm region. The results suggest that this region harbours key components responsible for photo-sensing and lateral IAA transport. In the present study, it was found that the NPH3- and PGP-like genes were exclusively expressed in the 0-2 mm region of the tip, whereas PHOT1 and ZmPIN1a, b, and c were expressed relatively evenly along the coleoptile, and ZmAUX1, ZMK1, and ZmSAURE2 were strongly expressed in the elongation zone. These results suggest that the NPH3-like and PGP-like gene products have a key role in photo-signal transduction and regulation of the direction of auxin transport after blue light perception by phot1 at the very tip region of maize coleoptiles.     

Interaction of auxin, light, and mechanical stress in orienting microtubules in relation to tropic curvature in the epidermis of maize coleoptiles

Summary Changes in the orientation of cortical microtubules (longitudinal vs. transverse with respect to the long cell axis) at the outer epidermal wall of maize coleoptile segments were induced by auxin, red or blue light, and mechanical stresses (cell extension or compression produced by bending). Immunofluorescent techniques were used for the quantitative determination of frequency distributions of microtubule orientation. Detailed kinetic studies showed that microtubule reorientations are temporally correlated with the simultaneously measured changes in growth rate elicited by auxin, red light, or blue light. Growth inhibition induced by depletion of endogenous auxin produces a longitudinal microtubule pattern that can be changed into a transverse pattern in a dose-dependent manner by applying exogenous auxin. A mid-point pattern with equal frequencies of longitudinal and transverse microtubules was adjusted at 2 mol/1 auxin. Bending stress applied under these conditions adjusts permanent, maximally longitudinal and transverse microtubule orientations at the compressed and extended segment sides, respectively, quantitatively mimicking the responses to differential flank growth during phototropic and gravitropic curvature. During tropic curvature the changes in microtubule pattern reflect the distribution of growth rather than the distribution of auxin. The microtubule pattern responds to auxin-dependent growth changes and mechanical stress in a synergistic manner, confirming the functional equivalence of these factors in affecting microtubule orientation. Similar results were obtained when segment growth was altered by blue or red light instead of auxin in the presence or absence of mechanical stress. It is concluded from these results that growth changes, elicited by auxin, light, etc., and mechanical stress affect microtubule orientation through a common signal perception and transduction chain.Abbreviations IAA indole-3-acetic acid (auxin) - MT cortical microtubule     

植物下胚轴向光弯曲机制研究进展

植物向光弯曲生长主要是由于其向光和背光面生长素的不对称分布引起。近年来研究发现,在不同强度的蓝光单侧照射下,植物可能存在不同的向光弯曲调节机制。目前,关于向光素PHOT1介导弱蓝光引起的下胚轴弯曲研究较为详细,即PHOT1感受蓝光后,与其下游的信号蛋白NPH3、RPT2和PKS1相互作用,调控生长素运输蛋白的活性及定位,诱导生长素的不对称分布引起向光弯曲。PHOT1和PHOT2以功能冗余方式调节强蓝光引起的植物下胚轴向光弯曲,NPH3可能作为共享调节因子,引发不同的信号转导通路实现功能互补。此外,其他光受体、激素、蛋白激酶、蛋白磷酸酶以及Ca2＋也参与了植物向光弯曲的调节。本文就近年来有关植物下胚轴向光弯曲信号组分及可能的网络关系进行总结,并对该研究领域存在的问题及今后可能的研究方向进行展望。     

Phototropic stimulation does not induce unequal distribution of indole-3-acetic acid in maize coleoptiles

Distribution of endogenous diffusible auxin into agar blocks from phototropically stimulated maize coleoptile tips was studied using a bioassay and a physicochemical assay, to clarify whether phototropism in maize coleoptiles involves a lateral gradient in the amount of auxin. At 50 min after the onset of phototropic stimulation, when the phototropic response was still developing, direct assay of the blocks with the Avena curvature test showed that the auxin activity in the blocks from the shaded half-tips was twice that of the lighted side, at both the first and second positive phototropic curvatures. However, physicochemical determination following purification showed that the amount of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) was evenly distributed in the blocks from lighted and shaded coleoptile half-tips at both the first and second positive phototropic curvatures. The even distribution of the IAA was also confirmed with the Avena curvature test following purification by HPLC. These results indicate that phototropism in maize coleoptiles is not caused by a lateral gradient of IAA itself and thus cannot be described by the Cholodny-Went theory. Furthermore, the lower auxin activity in the blocks from the lighted half-tips suggests the presence of inhibitor(s) interfering with the action of auxin and their significant diffusion from unilaterally illuminated coleoptile tips.     

Gravitropism and Phototropism of Maize Coleoptiles: Evaluation of the Cholodny-Went Theory Through Effects of Auxin Application and Decapitation

It was investigated whether or not gravitropism and phototropismof maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles behave as predicted by theCholodny-Went theory in response to auxin application, decapitationand combinations of these treatments. Gravitropism was inducedat an angle of 30° from the vertical, and phototropism,by a pulse of unilateral blue light. Either tropism of the coleoptilewas inhibited by IAA, applied as a ring of IAA-lanolin pasteto its sub-apical part, and by decapitation. The dose-responsecurves for the effects of applied IAA on tropisms and growthof intact coleoptiles as well as the time courses of tropismsinduced in decapitated coleoptiles could be explained by thethree conclusions in the literature: (1) the tip of the coleoptileis the site of auxin production, (2) lateral translocation ofauxin in gravitropism occurs along the length of the coleoptile,and (3) lateral translocation of auxin in phototropism occursin the coleoptile tip. By examining the effects of decapitationmade at different distances from the top and of IAA appliedto the cut surface of decapitated coleoptiles, it was indicatedthat auxin is produced in the apical 1 mm zone of an intactcoleoptile and that lateral auxin translocation for phototropismtakes place in an apical part that somewhat exceeds the zoneof auxin production. (Received October 14, 1994; Accepted December 26, 1994)     

Distribution of Endogenous Indole-3-acetic Acid and Growth Inhibitor(s) in Phototropically Responding Oat Coleoptiles

The relationship between the flank growth of oat (Avena sativaL. cv. Victory) coleoptiles and the distribution of endogenousindole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and growth inhibitor(s) in the coleoptileswas studied for the second positive phototropic curvature inducedby a continuous unilateral illumination with white light (0.1W.m^–2). The phototropic curvature was caused by growthinhibition at the lighted side and growth promotion at the shadedside. Using electron capture detection gas chromatography, weanalyzed the distribution of endogenous IAA in phototropicallyresponding oat coleoptiles and found that the IAA was evenlydistributed over the lighted and shaded sides during the phototropicresponse; there was also no detectable difference in the amountsof IAA between phototropically stimulated and non-irradiatedcoleoptiles. By contrast, oat coleoptile straight-growth testresults showed that the amount of unknown acidic growth inhibitor(s),different from abscisic acid, increased in the lighted halfof the coleoptiles and decreased in the shaded half, as comparedto the amount in the non-irradiated half. These data suggestthat the phototropic curvature of oat coleoptile is inducedby a difference in lateral flank growth through a lateral gradientof endogenous growth inhibitor(s) rather than of IAA. (Received February 10, 1988; Accepted July 29, 1988)     

Auxin Balance in the Avena Coleoptile

Coleoptiles of Avena possessed the capacity to degrade infiltrated indole-3-acetic acid (IAA). This activity decreased along the length of the coleoptile from apex to base on the bases of fresh weight, dry weight and protein; the apical 1 cm segment degraded more IAA than segments from other parts of the coleoptile. The naturally occurring inhibitor of the IAA oxidase activity increased in concentration up to 20 mm from the coleoptile apex; beyond, it decreased gradually towards the base. The spatial distribution of this inhibitor does not explain the gradient in IAA oxidase activity. Growth in length of the coleoptile and the IAA inactivating capacity of the apical 1 cm segment, increased 5- and 4,4-fold, respectively, between the ages of 70 and 130 h; but auxin secretion into agar platelets by the apical 2 mm of the coleoptile registered only a 2.7-fold increase. Deseeding and derooting the seedlings reduced the subsequent growth, diffusible auxin content and the IAA oxidase activity of the coleoptiles; derooting proved to be more deleterious than deseeding. A parallel reduction was evident in auxin content and IAA degrading activity following these treatments. Application of the cytokinin 6-benzylaminopurine (BAP) to coleoptiles of derooted seedlings failed to influence their capacity to degrade IAA. Nor was the activity of the aldehyde oxidase, which converts indole-3-acetaldehyde (IAAld) to IAA, affected by such treatment.     

Unequal Distribution of 6-methoxy-2-benzoxazolinone (MBOA) is the Main Reason for Phototropism in Maize Coleoptiles

The distribution of 6-methoxy-2-benzoxazolinone (MBOA) which is induced by blue light stimulation in maize ( Zea mays L. ) coleoplile was investigated by HPLC analysis. The results showed that: 1. The MBOA content on the irradiated side of the coleoptile was 1.5 fold more than that on the shaded side. 2. There was little change of IAA on both sides of the coleoptile which was treated with phototropic stimulation. 3. The growing coleoptile bent towards the side which was treated with MBOA, 5,6-dimethoxy-2-benzoxazolinone (DMBOA) or 2-chloro-5,6-dimethoxy-2-benzoxazolinone ( C1-DMBOA). The above results indicated that the phototropic bending of the coleoptile was attributed to unequal distribution of MBOA.     

Isolation and identification of a light-induced growth inhibitor in diffusates from blue light-illuminated oat (Avena sativa L.) coleoptile tips

The amounts of two growth inhibitors in diffusates from illuminatedhalves of phototropically stimulated oat (Avena sativa L.)coleoptile tips were larger than those from shaded halves. The less polarinhibitor was isolated from diffusates from oat coleoptile tips illuminatedwithblue light, and identified as uridine from ¹H NMR spectrum. Thedistribution of endogenous uridine in diffusates from the illuminated andshadedsides of coleoptile tips unilaterally exposed to blue light for 3, causing a first positive phototropic curvature, and fromdark-control tips, was determined using a physicochemical assay. The uridineconcentration was significantly higher in the diffusates from the illuminatedside than in those from the shaded side and the dark-control. Uridine inhibitedthe growth of etiolated oat coleoptile tips at concentrations of 30 and above. These results suggest that uridine plays a role inthe phototropism of oat coleoptiles.     

IAA transport during the phototropic responses of intact Zea and Avena coleoptiles

Summary Transport of indolyl-3-acetic acid (IAA) was studied during the phototropic responses of intact shoots and detached coleoptiles of Zea mays L. and Avena sativa L. The use of a high specific activity [5-³H]IAA and glass micropipettes enabled asymmetric application of the IAA to be made to individual coleoptiles with minimal tissue damage.A unilateral stimulus of 2.59×10^-11 einstein cm^-2 of blue light, probably in the dose range of the first positive phototropic response, caused significant net lateral movement of radioactivity from [5-³H]IAA away from the illuminated side of intact shoots and detached coleoptile apices of both Avena and Zea. The magnitude of the net lateral movement was 15.3% in Zea seedlings and 12.3% in Avena seedlings. Chromatographic analyses indicated that the movement of radioactivity reflected that of IAA. A phototropic stimulus of 1.24×10^-7 einstein cm^-2, which was probably in the second positive dose range, caused significant lateral movement of radioactivity in intact shoots and detached coleoptiles of Zea but not of Avena.In intact Zea seedlings, neither phototropic dosage affected the longitudinal transport of IAA. In intact Avena seedlings, first positive stimulation inhibited longitudinal transport only when the IAA was applied to the illuminated side of the coleoptile, but second positive stimulation inhibited basipetal movement of IAA regardless of the side of application.Exposing the intact seedlings to red light before phototropic stimulation abolished lateral transport after a first positive stimulus in Zea and in Avena.Phototropic stimulation can thus induce a lateral transport of IAA towards the shaded side of the coleoptiles of both Zea and Avena seedlings, and can affect longitudinal movement of IAA in the coleoptile of Avena. However, since phototropic curvature was observed under certain conditions in the absence of either of these effects, the extent to which they are involved in the induction of asymmetric growth in a stimulated coleoptile has yet to be resolved.     

Mediation of tropisms by lateral translocation of endogenous indole-3-acetic acid in maize coleoptiles

Abstract. The hypothesis that tropic responses result from lateral auxin gradients was examined in coleoptiles of red-light-grown maize ( Zea mays L.) by measuring endogenous IAA (indole-3-acetic acid) using a physicochemical method. Phototropic stimulation (unilateral blue light; 8s at 0.33 μmol m⁻²s⁻¹) was found to induce a lateral gradient of solvent-extractable IAA in a subapical zone (2-7mm from the tip). The gradient occurred in advance of the bending response, with a decrease of IAA in the irradiated half and a compensatory increase in the shaded half. The maximal gradient measured was about 1:2 (irradiated: shaded). Diffusible IAA, obtained from the cut end of an excised coleoptile tip (3mm long, with its base split by 1mm), was similarly redistributed between the two sides, indicating that IAA is laterally translocated in the tip and that the resulting IAA gradient migrates to the subapical zone. A smaller gradient was induced in a basal zone (12-17mm from the tip). This gradient was initiated about 20 min later than that at the subapical zone, in agreement with a similar delay of bending observed in this zone. Gravitropic stimulation (60° from the vertical) also resulted in a lateral gradient of extractable IAA in the subapical zone, the gradient preceding the bending response. It is concluded that the tropisms of maize coleoptiles are mediated by IAA gradients, which are most likely caused by lateral IAA transport as the Cholodny-Went theory of tropisms describes. From IAA measurement data, the mean velocity of basipetally-polar transport of endogenous IAA was estimated to be 12 mm h⁻¹.     

Interactions of microtubule disorganizers, plant hormones, and red light in wheat coleoptile segment growth

Growth response of coleoptile segments excised from 3-day-old seedlings of wheat (Triticum vulgare cv. Baart) to gibberellic acid, indoleacetic acid, and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, to red light, and to several microtubule disorganizers depends on the initial position of the excised segment in the intact coleoptile. Red light, 660 nm, stimulates the growth of the apical cells, but inhibits markedly the growth of the cells in the basal region of the coleoptile. The effects of red light are independent of sucrose, gibberellic acid, indoleacetic acid, and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, even though these substances themselves markedly affect the growth of the coleoptile segments. Concentractions of the microtubule disorganizers, vinblastine sulfate, cupric chloride, urea, and colchicine, which do not alter significantly the growth of the dark control apical segments, substantially repress the promotive effects of red light or auxin on the increase in length of the apical cells of the coleoptile. This suggests that stimulation by red light and by auxin involves microtubule production. Microtubule disorganizers repress the growth of elongating cells of the coleoptile, yet on the other hand, auxin and irradiation do not alter significantly the response of basal cells to the microtubule disorganizing agents. We hypothesized that light and growth regulators induce polymerization of nonaggregated microtubule subunits, resulting in faster growth.     

Auxintransport und Phototropismus

Summary Short illumination of excised coleoptiles (with or without apex) inhibits the subsequent transport of IAA-2-¹⁴C in these sections during darkness.To a certain extent the inhibition is dependent both on the light intensity and on the duration of illumination. Only the blue region of the visible spectrum is effective.The light induced inhibition is due to a decrease of the quantity of IAA transported; on the other hand, the velocity of transport remains unchanged.The inhibition of auxin transport can be observed only if coleoptiles contain endogenous or fed auxin during the preceding illumination period. Besides illumination inhibition of auxin transport can also be brought about by incubation of coleoptile sections with a previously illuminated IAA/FMN solution.Auxin transformed by peroxidase operates in the same way. The different oxidation products of IAA in the solutions used were identified: The only product which inhibits elongation growth and auxin transport was 3-M. The conversion of IAA to 3-M is accomplished by crude cell-free extracts from corn coleoptiles.An increased formation of labeled 3-M from IAA-2-¹⁴C during illumination of coleoptiles could be demonstrated.Since 3-M is not actively transported in coleoptiles, it must be assumed that 3-M functions as an inhibitor of auxin transport only at its site of formation.It is concluded that the phototropic curvature of coleoptiles and stems is triggered by the photooxidative formation of 3-M from IAA in the side exposed to light. The flow of growth substances will be partly blocked by 3-M in this side and can be directed to the shaded side.On the strength of these findings some phenomena of phototropism (transmission of stimulus, mneme, quantum yield) can easily be explained.

---

Abkürzungen FMN Flayinmononucleotid - IES Indol-3-essigsäure - 3-M 3-Methylenoxindol - NES -Naphthylessigsäure Herrn Prof. Dr. L. Brauner zum 70. Geburtstag in Dankbarkeit gewidmet.