Tools for T-RFLP data analysis using Excel

Background

Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis is a DNA-fingerprinting method that can be used for comparisons of the microbial community composition in a large number of samples. There is no consensus on how T-RFLP data should be treated and analyzed before comparisons between samples are made, and several different approaches have been proposed in the literature. The analysis of T-RFLP data can be cumbersome and time-consuming, and for large datasets manual data analysis is not feasible. The currently available tools for automated T-RFLP analysis, although valuable, offer little flexibility, and few, if any, options regarding what methods to use. To enable comparisons and combinations of different data treatment methods an analysis template and an extensive collection of macros for T-RFLP data analysis using Microsoft Excel were developed.

Results

The Tools for T-RFLP data analysis template provides procedures for the analysis of large T-RFLP datasets including application of a noise baseline threshold and setting of the analysis range, normalization and alignment of replicate profiles, generation of consensus profiles, normalization and alignment of consensus profiles and final analysis of the samples including calculation of association coefficients and diversity index. The procedures are designed so that in all analysis steps, from the initial preparation of the data to the final comparison of the samples, there are various different options available. The parameters regarding analysis range, noise baseline, T-RF alignment and generation of consensus profiles are all given by the user and several different methods are available for normalization of the T-RF profiles. In each step, the user can also choose to base the calculations on either peak height data or peak area data.

Conclusions

The Tools for T-RFLP data analysis template enables an objective and flexible analysis of large T-RFLP datasets in a widely used spreadsheet application.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-014-0361-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

毒死蜱乳油对辣椒根围土壤细菌群落结构的影响

【目的】了解有机磷杀虫剂毒死蜱对土壤细菌群落结构的作用。【方法】联合微生物平板计数法、末端限制性片段多态性分析,选择PRIMER 5进行群落结构分析,以研究不同浓度的毒死蜱对辣椒根围可培养和不可培养细菌群落结构的影响。【结果】毒死蜱施入后前30 d,3个处理组的可培养细菌较对照组具有显著差异(P0.05),但在第30天后,处理组可培养细菌数均能恢复到对照水平。采用PRIMER 5对T-RFLP数据进行多角度分析发现,HaeⅢ酶切片段中,对照组C3、处理组Y0和Z2的细菌群落结构较整体聚类较远。HhaⅠ酶切片段中,150μg/g的毒死蜱处理组(Z0)在第0天表现出最大的群落差异。ANOSIM表明,以不同浓度的毒死蜱分组,各组间细菌群落组成差异不显著(HaeⅢ:Global R=0.041,P=0.168;HhaⅠ:Global R=-0.04,P=0.842);以不同取样时间分组时,细菌群落组成差异显著(HaeⅢ:Global R=0.304,P=0.001;HhaⅠ:Global R=0.28,P=0.001)。经SIMPER分析所有TRFs可知,对群落丰度贡献最大的片段分别为TRF239、TRF240、TRF241。在线比对得到其代表菌群有芽孢杆菌属(Bacillus sp.)、梭菌属(Clostridium sp.)、葡萄球菌属(Staphylococcus sp.)、八叠球菌属(Sarcina sp.)、假单胞菌属(Pseudomonas sp.)等。【结论】高浓度的毒死蜱会对土壤细菌群落产生影响,抑制根围细菌生长,从而遏制植物的健康生长,因而有必要及时采取措施以减少大量重复使用毒死蜱所带来的危害。     

新疆低阶煤本源生物甲烷转化中微生物群落组成及变化

【目的】探究新疆低阶煤生物甲烷转化过程微生物群落组成及多样性。【方法】采用厌氧培养方法和末端限制性片段长度多态性技术(Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism,T-RFLP)分析新疆低阶煤本源微生物对甲烷转化及有机酸含量的影响,分析新疆哈密大南湖长焰煤生物甲烷转化过程中微生物群落动态变化。【结果】研究表明长焰煤和褐煤对本源微生物产甲烷影响较小,随着低阶煤生物甲烷转化时间的延长,甲烷产量呈上升趋势,转化60 d后长焰煤甲烷产量高达10.28 m L/g,挥发性有机酸(VFA)浓度则最低;微生物多样性指数变化不明显,不同转化时间微生物主要类群为放线菌门(Actinobacteria),拟杆菌门(Bacteroidetes),厚壁菌门(Firmicutes),变形菌门(Proteobacteria);甲烷菌的群落结构相对于细菌较简单,在整个低阶煤生物转化产甲烷过程中共有古菌类群为甲烷八叠球菌属(Methanosarcina)、甲烷盐菌属(Methanohalobium)、甲烷叶菌属(Methanolobus)、甲烷食甲基菌属(Methanomethylovorans),它们是构成群落结构的基本菌群。【结论】低阶煤生物甲烷转化过程微生物群落具有丰富的多样性,且不同时期多样性有较大差异。甲烷菌群落结构相对于细菌较简单,共有类群明显。     

Use of the T-RFLP technique to assess spatial and temporal changes in the bacterial community structure within an agricultural soil planted with transgenic and non-transgenic potato plants

The aim of this study was to examine whether the terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis represents an appropriate technique for monitoring highly diverse soil bacterial communities, i.e. to assess spatial and/or temporal effects on bacterial community structure. The T-RFLP method, a recently described fingerprinting technique, is based on terminal restriction fragment length polymorphisms between distinct small-subunit rRNA gene sequence types. This technique permits an automated quantification of the fluorescence signal intensities of the individual terminal restriction fragments (T-RFs) in a given community fingerprint pattern. The indigenous bacterial communities of three soil plots located within an agricultural field of 110 m(2) were compared. The first site was planted with non-transgenic potato plants, while the other two were planted with transgenic GUS and Barnase/Barstar potato plants, respectively. Once prior to planting and three times after planting, seven parallel samples were taken from each of the three soil plots. The T-RFLP analysis resulted in very complex but highly reproducible community fingerprint patterns. The percentage abundance values of defined T-RFs were calculated for the seven parallel samples of the respective soil plot. A multivariate analysis of variance was used to test T-RFLP data sets for significant differences. The statistical treatments clearly revealed spatial and temporal effects, as well as spacextime interaction effects, on the structural composition of the bacterial communities. T-RFs which showed the highest correlations to the discriminant factors were not those T-RFs which showed the largest single variations between the seven-sample means of individual plots. In summary, the T-RFLP technique, although a polymerase chain reaction-based method, proved to be a suitable technique for monitoring highly diverse soil microbial communities for changes over space and/or time.     

Long-term monitoring of the succession of a microbial community in activated sludge from a circulation flush toilet as a closed system

The microbial diversity and community succession of a circulation flush toilet were investigated by terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism and cloning analyses. Clonal libraries of 16S rRNA gene on day 3 and day 127 were constructed. On day 3, 102 clones were sequenced; Proteobacteria and Bacteroidetes accounted for 27% and 45%, respectively. On day 127, Proteobacteria had increased to 43% and Bacteroidetes had decreased to 26% of a total of 100 clones. Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism peaks were identified by in silico analysis of clone libraries. The relative abundances of Nitrosomonas increased from 1% to 6% with commencement of nitrification and denitrification. Similarly, the relative abundance of terminal restriction fragments generated from Xanthomonas increased from 3% to 10%. Therefore, these bacteria could play a prominent role in this process. To reveal the relationship between stability of the microbial community and performance of the system, microbial community succession was visualized by multidimensional scaling analysis. The microbial community structure changed markedly, particularly during the start-up period of the system. The plots then became stable after the start of nitrification and denitrification. This result suggests that the succession of microbial community structure had a correlation with the performance of the system.     

Relative importance of nutrients and mortality factors on prokaryotic community composition in two lakes of different trophic status: microcosm experiments

The effect of nutrient resources (N and P enrichment) and of different grazing communities on the prokaryotic community composition (PCC) was investigated in two freshwater ecosystems: Sep reservoir (oligomesotrophic) and lake Aydat (eutrophic). An experimental approach using microcosms was chosen, that allowed control of both predation levels, by size fractionation of predators, and resources, by nutrient amendments. Changes in PCC were monitored by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) and terminal-restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP). The main mortality agents were (i) heterotrophic nanoflagellates and virus-like particles in Aydat and (ii) cladocerans in Sep. All the nutritional elements assayed (N-NO3, P-PO4 and N-NH4) together with prokaryotic production (PP) always accounted for a significant part of the variations in PCC. Overall, prokaryotic diversity was mainly explained by resources in Sep, by a comparable contribution of resources and mortality factors in lake Aydat and, to a lesser extent, by the combined action of both.     

Effect of soil aggregate size on methanogenesis and archaeal community structure in anoxic rice field soil

In anoxically incubated slurries of Italian rice field soil, CH(4) production is initiated after a lag phase during which ferric iron and sulfate are reduced. The production of CH(4) was affected by the size of soil aggregates used for the preparation of the soil slurry. Rates of CH(4) production were lowest with small aggregates (<50 and 50-100 μm), were highest with aggregates of 200-2000 μm size and were intermediate with aggregates of 2000-15000 μm size. The different amounts of CH(4) accumulated were positively correlated to the concentrations of acetate, propionate and caproate that transiently accumulated in the slurries prepared from different aggregate sizes and also to the organic carbon content. The addition of organic debris that was collected from large-size aggregates to the aggregate size fractions <200 and <50 μm resulted in an increase of CH(4) production to amounts that were comparable to those measured in unamended aggregates of 200-2000 μm size, indicating that CH(4) production in the different aggregate size fractions was limited by substrate. The distribution of archaeal small-subunit rRNA genes in the different soil aggregate fractions was analyzed by terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism which allowed seven different archaeal ribotypes to be distinguished. Ribotype-182 (consisting of members of the Methanosarcinaceae and rice cluster VI), ribotype-389 (rice cluster I and II) and ribotype-820 (undigested DNA, rice cluster IV and members of the Methanosarcinaceae) accounted for >20, >30 and >10% of the total, respectively. The other ribotypes accounted for <10% of the total. The relative quantity of the individual ribotypes changed only slightly with incubation time and was almost the same among the different soil aggregate fractions. Ribotype-389, for example, slightly decreased with time, whereas ribotype-182 slightly increased. At the end of incubation, the relative quantity of ribotype-182 seemed to be slightly higher in soil fractions with larger than with smaller aggregates, whereas it was the opposite with ribotype-80 (Methanomicrobiaceae) and ribotype-88 (Methanobacteriaceae). Ribotype-280 (Methanosaetaceae and rice cluster V), ribotype-375 (rice cluster III), ribotype-389 and ribotype-820, on the other hand, were not much different among the different soil aggregate size fractions. However, the differences were not significant relative to the errors encountered during the extraction of polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-amplifiable DNA from soil. In conclusion, soil aggregate size and incubation time showed a strong effect on the function but only a small effect on the structure of the methanogenic microbial community.     

不同品种酿酒葡萄根围、叶围微生物群落结构特点解析

【目的】了解不同品种酿酒葡萄根围、叶围细菌群落结构。【方法】以不同品种酿酒葡萄根围、叶围样品为分析材料,采用末端限制性片段长度多态性(T-RFLP)技术研究根围、叶围细菌群落结构,并对细菌群落多样性进行分析。【结果】不同品种葡萄根围微生物优势菌群为变形菌门,不同品种葡萄叶围微生物优势菌群为放线菌目。根围Simpson指数大小顺序为白福尔琼瑶浆白诗南赛美蓉白玉霓米勒长相思,Shannon指数与Simpson指数基本保持一致。叶围Simpson指数最大的为白诗南,最小的为米勒,与Shannon指数基本吻合。【结论】葡萄细菌群落结构综合多样性指数和品种以及定殖部位密切相关。     

再生水补水对河道底泥细菌群落结构的影响

以北京市永定河麻峪湿地再生水补水口附近河道底泥为研究对象,应用末端限制性片段长度多态性(Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism,T-RFLP)技术探究再生水补水口附近底泥细菌群落结构的空间差异特征以及环境因子所产生的影响,并借助典范对应分析(Canonical Correspondence Analysis,CCA)方法分析麻峪湿地底泥细菌群落结构空间差异特征的形成原因。分析结果表明:河道底泥微生物群落对再生水的净化主要发生在距补水口1200m的范围内,随着再生水与上游来水径向混合净化渐变过程,在补水口2000m处河道底泥微生物群落结构与河道再生水补水口上游趋于相似。基于样点聚类结果的群落结构多样性分析表明随着再生水净化过程的实现微生物综合多样性指数呈现下降的趋势,从均匀度指数的变化趋势看,再生水补水口具有最高均匀度指数,补水口下游1200米处由于非优势菌群所占相对丰度最低以及偶见菌群缺失,导致群落结构比较单一、群落多样性和均匀度指数都最低。CCA方面分析结果表明再生水补水口上游细菌群落与因累积效应形成的重金属有密切关系,补水口出口底泥细菌群落则主要受到总磷和总有机碳的影响较大,而再生水补水与上游来水汇水径向渐变过程可能与氨氮净化具密切关系。研究区的主要优势菌种为假单胞菌属、贪食菌属和芽孢杆菌属,是与再生水中有机碳、氮降解具有密切关系的菌属。     

Assessment of anaerobic wastewater treatment failure using terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis

AIMS: The suitability of genetic fingerprinting to study the microbiological basis of anaerobic bioreactor failure is investigated. METHODS AND RESULTS: Two laboratory-scale anaerobic expanded granular sludge bed bioreactors, R1 and R2, were used for the mesophilic (37 degrees C) treatment of high-strength [10 g chemical oxygen demand (COD) l(-1)] synthetic industrial-like wastewater over a 100-day trial period. A successful start up was achieved by both bioreactors with COD removal over 90%. Both reactors were operated under identical parameters; however, increased organic loading during the trial induced a reduction in the COD removal of R1, while R2 maintained satisfactory performance (COD removal >90%) throughout the experiment. Specific methanogenic activity measurements of biomass from both reactors indicated that the main route of methane production was hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis. Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (TRFLP) analysis was applied to the characterization of microbial community dynamics within the system during the trial. The principal differences between the two consortia analysed included an increased abundance of Thiovulum- and Methanococcus-like organisms and uncultured Crenarchaeota in R1. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicated that there was a microbiological basis for the deviation, in terms of operational performance, of R1 and R2. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: High-throughput fingerprinting techniques, such as TRFLP, have been demonstrated as practically relevant for biomonitoring of anaerobic reactor communities.     

水葫芦根际细菌群落结构多样性分析

【目的】了解水葫芦根际细菌群落结构。【方法】运用末端限制性片段长度多态性(Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism,T-RFLP)技术分析富营养化水体中水葫芦根际和水葫芦近、远水样的细菌群落特征及多样性,结合克隆文库技术和培养法分析根际的细菌种群类型。【结果】同一时期水葫芦根际细菌多样性(Shannon-Weiner指数H′或Simpson指数D)更高,水葫芦近水样次之,远水样最小。10月份的细菌多样性高于5月份的。通过水葫芦根际细菌的克隆文库可知变形杆菌门(Proteobacteria)是水葫芦根际细菌的主要类群,占总群体的65.1%,包括噬菌弧菌(Bacteriovorax sp.)、Dechloromonas sp.、Leptothrix sp.、红螺菌科(Rhodospirillaceae)、Rhodoferax sp.和红环菌科(Rhodocyclaceae)等。T-RFLP图谱显示159 bp为最大优势菌,247 bp为第二大优势菌,对照克隆文库及培养结果分析247 bp属于γ-Proteobacteria,159 bp为不动杆菌(Acinetobacter sp.)。【结论】水葫芦根际细菌的群落结构丰富,不同时段水葫芦根际细菌的丰度略有变化,主要类群为变形杆菌门。     

Ranking the magnitude of crop and farming system effects on soil microbial biomass and genetic structure of bacterial communities

Biological soil characteristics such as microbial biomass, community structures, activities, and functions may provide important information on environmental and anthropogenic influences on agricultural soils. Diagnostic tools and detailed statistical approaches need to be developed for a reliable evaluation of these parameters, in order to allow classification and quantification of the magnitude of such effects. The DOK long-term agricultural field experiment was initiated in 1978 in Switzerland for the evaluation of organic and conventional farming practices. It includes three representative Swiss farming systems with biodynamic, bio-organic and conventional fertilization and plant protection schemes along with minerally fertilized and unfertilized controls. Effects on microbial soil characteristics induced by the long-term management at two different stages in the crop rotation, i.e. winter wheat after potato or corn, were investigated by analyzing soil bacterial community structures using analysis of PCR-amplified rRNA genes by terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism and ribosomal intergenic spacer analysis. Application of farmyard manure consistently revealed the strongest influence on bacterial community structures and biomass contents. Effects of management and plant protection regimes occurred on an intermediate level, while the two stages in the crop rotation had a marginal influence that was not significant.