Localization of the Clostridium difficile cysteine protease Cwp84 and insights into its maturation process

Clostridium difficile is a nosocomial pathogen involved in antibiotic-associated diarrhea. C. difficile expresses a cysteine protease, Cwp84, which has been shown to degrade some proteins of the extracellular matrix and play a role in the maturation of the precursor of the S-layer proteins. We sought to analyze the localization and the maturation process of this protease. Two identifiable forms of the protease were found to be associated in the bacteria: a form of ～80 kDa and a cleaved one of 47 kDa, identified as the mature protease. They were found mainly in the bacterial cell surface fractions and weakly in the extracellular fraction. The 80-kDa protein was noncovalently associated with the S-layer proteins, while the 47-kDa form was found to be tightly associated with the underlying cell wall. Our data supported that the anchoring of the Cwp84 47-kDa form is presumably due to a reassociation of the secreted protein. Moreover, we showed that the complete maturation of the recombinant protein Cwp84(30-803) is a sequential process beginning at the C-terminal end, followed by one or more cleavages at the N-terminal end. The processing sites of recombinant Cwp84 are likely to be residues Ser-92 and Lys-518. No proteolytic activity was detected with the mature recombinant protease Cwp84(92-518) (47 kDa). In contrast, a fragment including the propeptide (Cwp84(30-518)) displayed proteolytic activity on azocasein and fibronectin. These results showed that Cwp84 is processed essentially at the bacterial cell surface and that its different forms may display different proteolytic activities.     

Variation in the surface layer proteins of Clostridium difficile

Surface layers (S-layers) form regular crystalline structures on the outermost surface of many bacteria. Clostridium difficile possesses such an S-layer consisting of two protein subunits. Treatment of whole cells of C. difficile with 5 M guanidine hydrochloride revealed two major proteins of different molecular masses characteristic of the S-layer on SDS-PAGE. In this study 25 isolates were investigated. A high degree of variability in the molecular mass of the two S-layer proteins was evident. Molecular masses ranged from 48 to 56 kDa for the heavier protein and from 37 to 45 kDa for the lighter protein. A further protein component of 70 kDa was detectable in all isolates. No cross-reaction was seen between the two major proteins from isolates that produced different S-layer patterns, and most S-layer proteins from isolates with the same or similar banding patterns did not cross-react. The S-layer proteins, when detected by a combination of Coomassie blue staining and immunoblotting, are a useful marker for phenotyping.     

Immunization of hamsters against Clostridium difficile infection using the Cwp84 protease as an antigen

Clostridium difficile is a pathogen responsible for diarrhoea and colitis, particularly after antibiotic treatment. We evaluated the C. difficile protease Cwp84, found to be associated with the S-layer proteins, as a vaccine antigen to limit the C. difficile intestinal colonization and therefore the development of the infection in a clindamycin-treated hamster model. First, we evaluated the immune response and the animal protection against death induced by several immunization routes: rectal, intragastric and subcutaneous. Antibody production was variable according to the immunization routes. In addition, serum Cwp84 antibody titres did not always correlate with animal protection after challenge with a toxigenic C. difficile strain. The best survival rate was observed with the rectal route of immunization. Then, in a second assay, we selected this immunization route to perform a larger immunization assay including a Cwp84 immunized group and a control group. Clostridium difficile intestinal colonization and survival rate, as well as the immune response were examined. Clostridium difficile hamster challenge resulted in a 26% weaker and slower C. difficile intestinal colonization in the immunized group. Furthermore, hamster survival in the Cwp84 immunized group was 33% greater than that of the control group, with a significant statistical difference.     

Surface proteins from Lactobacillus kefir antagonize in vitro cytotoxic effect of Clostridium difficile toxins

In this work, the ability of S-layer proteins from kefir-isolated Lactobacillus kefir strains to antagonize the cytophatic effects of toxins from Clostridium difficile (TcdA and TcdB) on eukaryotic cells in vitro was tested by cell detachment assay. S-layer proteins from eight different L. kefir strains were able to inhibit the damage induced by C. difficile spent culture supernatant to Vero cells. Besides, same protective effect was observed by F-actin network staining. S-layer proteins from aggregating L. kefir strains (CIDCA 83115, 8321, 8345 and 8348) showed a higher inhibitory ability than those belonging to non-aggregating ones (CIDCA 83111, 83113, JCM 5818 and ATCC 8007), suggesting that differences in the structure could be related to the ability to antagonize the effect of clostridial toxins. Similar results were obtained using purified TcdA and TcdB. Protective effect was not affected by proteases inhibitors or heat treatment, thus indicating that proteolytic activity is not involved. Only preincubation with specific anti-S-layer antibodies significantly reduced the inhibitory effect of S-layer proteins, suggesting that this could be attributed to a direct interaction between clostridial toxins and L. kefir S-layer protein. Interestingly, the interaction of toxins with S-layer carrying bacteria was observed by dot blot and fluorescence microscopy with specific anti-TcdA or anti-TcdB antibodies, although L. kefir cells did not show protective effects. We hypothesize that the interaction between clostridial toxins and soluble S-layer molecules is different from the interaction with S-layer on the surface of the bacteria thus leading a different ability to antagonize cytotoxic effect. This is the first report showing the ability of S-layer proteins from kefir lactobacilli to antagonize biological effects of bacterial toxins. These results encourage further research on the role of bacterial surface molecules to the probiotic properties of L. kefir and could contribute to strain selection with potential therapeutic or prophylactic benefits towards CDAD.     

Cwp84, a surface-associated protein of Clostridium difficile, is a cysteine protease with degrading activity on extracellular matrix proteins

Clostridium difficile pathogenicity is mediated mainly by its A and B toxins, but the colonization process is thought to be a necessary preliminary step in the course of infection. The aim of this study was to characterize the Cwp84 protease of C. difficile, which is highly immunogenic in patients with C. difficile-associated disease and is potentially involved in the pathogenic process. Cwp84 was purified as a recombinant His-tagged protein, and specific antibodies were generated in rabbits. Treatment of multiple-band-containing eluted fractions with a reducing agent or with trypsin led to accumulation of a unique protein species with an estimated molecular mass of 61 kDa, corresponding most likely to mature autoprocessed Cwp84 (mCwp84). mCwp84 showed concentration-dependent caseinolytic activity, with maximum activity at pH 7.5. The Cwp84 activity was inhibited by various cysteine protease inhibitors, such as the specific inhibitor E64, and the anti-Cwp84-specific antibodies. Using fractionation experiments followed by immunoblot detection, the protease was found to be associated with the S-layer proteins, mostly as a nonmature species. Proteolytic assays were performed with extracellular matrix proteins to assess the putative role of Cwp84 in the pathogenicity of C. difficile. No degrading activity was detected with type IV collagen. In contrast, Cwp84 exhibited degrading activity with fibronectin, laminin, and vitronectin, which was neutralized by the E64 inhibitor and specific antibodies. In vivo, this proteolytic activity could contribute to the degradation of the host tissue integrity and to the dissemination of the infection.     

Caulobacter crescentus synthesizes an S-layer-editing metalloprotease possessing a domain sharing sequence similarity with its paracrystalline S-layer protein

Strains of Caulobacter crescentus elaborate an S-layer, a two-dimensional protein latticework which covers the cell surface. The S-layer protein (RsaA) is secreted by a type I mechanism (relying on a C-terminal signal) and is unusual among type I secreted proteins because high levels of protein are produced continuously. In efforts to adapt the S-layer for display of foreign peptides and proteins, we noted a proteolytic activity that affected S-layer monomers with foreign inserts. The cleavage was precise, resulting in fragments with an unambiguous N-terminal sequence. We developed an assay to screen for loss of this activity (i.e., presentation of foreign peptides without degradation), using transposon and traditional mutagenesis. A metalloprotease gene designated sap (S-layer-associated protease) was identified which could complement the protease-negative mutants. The N-terminal half of Sap possessed significant similarity to other type I secreted proteases (e.g., alkaline protease of Pseudomonas aeruginosa), including the characteristic RTX repeat sequences, but the C-terminal half which normally includes the type I secretion signal exhibited no such similarity. Instead, there was a region of significant similarity to the N-terminal region of RsaA. We hypothesize that Sap evolved by combining the catalytic portion of a type I secreted protease with an S-layer-like protein, perhaps to associate with nascent S-layer monomers to "scan" for modifications.     

The Clostridium difficile cell wall protein CwpV is antigenically variable between strains, but exhibits conserved aggregation-promoting function

Clostridium difficile is the main cause of antibiotic-associated diarrhea, leading to significant morbidity and mortality and putting considerable economic pressure on healthcare systems. Current knowledge of the molecular basis of pathogenesis is limited primarily to the activities and regulation of two major toxins. In contrast, little is known of mechanisms used in colonization of the enteric system. C. difficile expresses a proteinaceous array on its cell surface known as the S-layer, consisting primarily of the major S-layer protein SlpA and a family of SlpA homologues, the cell wall protein (CWP) family. CwpV is the largest member of this family and is expressed in a phase variable manner. Here we show CwpV promotes C. difficile aggregation, mediated by the C-terminal repetitive domain. This domain varies markedly between strains; five distinct repeat types were identified and were shown to be antigenically distinct. Other aspects of CwpV are, however, conserved. All CwpV types are expressed in a phase variable manner. Using targeted gene knock-out, we show that a single site-specific recombinase RecV is required for CwpV phase variation. CwpV is post-translationally cleaved at a conserved site leading to formation of a complex of cleavage products. The highly conserved N-terminus anchors the CwpV complex to the cell surface. Therefore CwpV function, regulation and processing are highly conserved across C. difficile strains, whilst the functional domain exists in at least five antigenically distinct forms. This hints at a complex evolutionary history for CwpV.     

Patterns of sequence conservation in the S-Layer proteins and related sequences in Clostridium difficile

Clostridium difficile is the etiological agent of antibiotic-associated diarrhea. Among the factors that may play a role in infection are S-layer proteins (SLPs). Previous work has shown these to consist mainly of two components, resulting from the cleavage of a precursor encoded by the slpA gene. The high-molecular-weight (MW) subunit is related both to amidases from B. subtilis and to at least another 28 gene products in C. difficile strain 630. To gain insight into the functions of the SLPs and related proteins, we have further investigated the pattern of variability both at the slpA locus and at six nearby paralogs. Sequencing of the slpA gene from an S-layer group II strain and a variant S-layer group strain confirms a high degree of divergence in the low-MW SLP, which may result from diversifying selection. A highly conserved motif, however, is found at the C terminus in all low-MW subunits and may be essential for SlpA precursor cleavage. In strain 167, a variant cleavage product is present, suggesting a secondary processing site. Southern blotting analysis shows slpA-like open reading frames (ORFs) 2 to 7 to be conserved in all nine strains tested, with one exception: ORF2, which encodes a 66-kDa polypeptide coextracted at low pH with the main SLPs in strain 630, may be partially deleted in strain 167. Polymorphism within the slpA-ORF7 cluster may be more pronounced in the region proximal to the slpA gene. Unexpectedly, a high-MW subunit probe cross hybridizes to sequences outside the slpA locus, which appear to vary in number in different strains.     

Structural insights into the molecular organization of the S-layer from Clostridium difficile

Clostridium difficile expresses a surface layer (S-layer) which coats the surface of the bacterium and acts as an adhesin facilitating interaction of the bacterium with host enteric cells. The S-layer contains a high-molecular-weight S-layer protein (HMW SLP) and its low-molecular-weight partner protein (LMW SLP). We show that these proteins form a tightly associated non-covalent complex, the H/L complex, and we identify the regions of both proteins responsible for complex formation. The 2.4 Å X-ray crystal structure of a truncated derivative of the LMW SLP reveals two domains. Domain 1 has a two-layer sandwich architecture while domain 2, predicted to orientate towards the external environment, contains a novel fold. Small-angle X-ray scattering analysis of the H/L complex shows an elongated molecule, with the two SLPs arranged 'end-to-end' interacting with each other through a small contact area. Alignment of LMW SLPs, which exhibit high sequence diversity, reveals a core of conserved residues that could reflect functional conservation, while allowing for immune evasion through sequence variation. These structures are the first described for the S-layer of a bacterial pathogen, and provide insights into the assembly and biogenesis of the S-layer.     

Secretome analysis of Clostridium difficile strains

Clostridium difficile causes infections ranging from mild C. difficile-associated diarrhea to severe pseudomembranous colitis. Since 2003 new hypervirulent C. difficile strains (PCR ribotype 027) emerged characterized by a dramatically increased mortality. The secretomes of the three C. difficile strains CDR20291, CD196, and CD630 were analyzed and compared. Proteins were separated and analyzed by means of SDS--PAGE and LC-MS. MS data were analyzed using Mascot and proteins were checked for export signals with SecretomeP and SignalP. LC-MS analysis revealed 158 different proteins in the supernatant of C. difficile. Most of the identified proteins originate from the cytoplasm. Thirty-two proteins in CDR20291, 36 in CD196 and 26 in CD630 were identified to be secreted by C. difficile strains. Those were mainly S-layer proteins, substrate-binding proteins of ABC-transporters, cell wall hydrolases, pilin and unknown hypothetical proteins. Toxin A and toxin B were identified after growth in brain heart infusion medium using immunological techniques. The ADP-ribosyltransferase-binding component protein, which is a part of the binary toxin CDT, was only identified in the hypervirulent ribotype 027 strains. Further proteins that are secreted specifically by hypervirulent strains were identified.     

Roles of cysteine proteases Cwp84 and Cwp13 in biogenesis of the cell wall of Clostridium difficile

Clostridium difficile expresses a number of cell wall proteins, including the abundant high-molecular-weight and low-molecular-weight S-layer proteins (SLPs). These proteins are generated by posttranslational cleavage of the precursor SlpA by the cysteine protease Cwp84. We compared the phenotypes of C. difficile strains containing insertional mutations in either cwp84 or its paralog cwp13 and complemented with plasmids expressing wild-type or mutant forms of their genes. We show that the presence of uncleaved SlpA in the cell wall of the cwp84 mutant results in aberrant retention of other cell wall proteins at the cell surface, as demonstrated by secretion of the proteins Cwp66 and Cwp2 into the growth medium. These phenotypes are restored by complementation with a plasmid expressing wild-type Cwp84 enzyme but not with one encoding a Cys116Ala substitution in the active site. The cwp13 mutant cleaved the SlpA precursor normally and had a wild-type-like colony phenotype. Both Cwp84 and Cwp13 are produced as proenzymes which are processed by cleavage to produce mature enzymes. In the case of Cwp84, this cleavage does not appear to be autocatalytic, whereas in Cwp13 autocatalysis was demonstrated as a Cys109Ala mutant did not undergo processing. Cwp13 appears to have a role in processing of Cwp84 but is not essential for Cwp84 activity. Cwp13 cleaves SlpA in the HMW SLP domain, which we suggest may reflect a role in cleavage and degradation of misfolded proteins at the cell surface.     

Evaluating secretion and surface attachment of SapA, an S-layer-associated metalloprotease of Caulobacter crescentus

Caulobacter crescentus is used to display foreign peptides at high density as insertions into the surface (S)-layer protein (RsaA). Many recombinant RsaA proteins, however, are cleaved by SapA, a 71-kDa metalloprotease, suggesting a role in maintaining S-layer integrity. When overexpressed on a multicopy plasmid SapA was detected on the surface by fluorescent antibody only if RsaA and the O-side chain of LPS that mediates S-layer attachment were removed by mutation, indicating an outer membrane location beneath the S-layer. Secretion was mediated by the RsaA type 1 transporter since secretion was eliminated in transporter deficient strains or by C-terminal deletions in SapA (the presumed location of type 1 secretion signals). Secretion was required to become an active protease; mass spectrometry suggested this might be due to N-terminal processing during secretion, a feature shared with other type 1-secreted proteases. Overexpression leads to additional processing C-terminal to the protease domain, producing a 45-kDa protein. This was demonstrated to be self-processing. Deletion analysis revealed the C-terminal 100 amino acids were sufficient for anchoring and secretion. When protein G was fused to the last 238 amino acids of SapA it was secreted, surface attached and bound immunoglobulin, indicating potential for foreign protein display.     

Serratia marcescens S-layer protein is secreted extracellularly via an ATP-binding cassette exporter, the Lip system

The Serratia marcescens Lip exporter belonging to the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) exporter is known to be involved in signal peptide-independent extracellular secretion of a lipase and a metalloprotease. Although the genes of secretory proteins and their ABC exporters are usually all reported to be linked in several Gram-negative bacteria, neither the lipase nor the protease gene is located close to the Lip exporter genes, lipBCD . A gene ( slaA ) located upstream of the lipBCD genes was cloned, revealing that it encodes a polypeptide of 100 kDa and is partially similar to the Caulobacter crescentus paracrystalline cell surface layer (S-layer) protein. The Lip exporter-deficient mutants of S . marcescens failed to secrete the SlaA protein. Electron micrography demonstrated the cell surface layer of S . marcescens . The S-layer protein was secreted to the cultured media in Escherichia coli cells carrying the Lip exporter. Three ABC exporters, Prt, Has and Hly systems, could not allow the S-layer secretion, indicating that the S . marcescens S-layer protein is strictly recognized by the Lip system. This is the first report concerning secretion of an S-layer protein via its own secretion system.     

Heterogeneity of S-layer proteins of Lactobacillus acidophilus strains.

An S-layer (surface regular array) was found in the cell wall from six out of ten strains of Lactobacillus acidophilus examined by electron microscopic observations. All of the six strains which were shown to carry the S-layers belonged to the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) homology group A, but not to B, which had been classified by Johnson et al (Int. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 30: 53-68, 1980). On the other hand, the other four strains which possessed no S-layers were in the homology group B. The apparent molecular weights of the S-layer proteins ranged from 41 to 49 kDa as estimated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Of the S-layer proteins from the six strains, three were susceptible to chemical cleavage with N-chlorosuccinimide, giving different peptide maps. All of the six S-layer proteins were fragmented by limited proteolysis with Staphylococcus aureus V8 protease, and gave markedly different peptide patterns by the subsequent peptide mapping analysis, except that the peptide maps of the S-layer proteins from the two strains which were in the same subgroup were identical.     

Clostridium difficile has two parallel and essential Sec secretion systems

Protein translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane is an essential process in all bacteria. The Sec system, comprising at its core an ATPase, SecA, and a membrane channel, SecYEG, is responsible for the majority of this protein transport. Recently, a second parallel Sec system has been described in a number of gram-positive species. This accessory Sec system is characterized by the presence of a second copy of the energizing ATPase, SecA2; where it has been studied, SecA2 is responsible for the translocation of a subset of Sec substrates. In common with many pathogenic gram-positive species, Clostridium difficile possesses two copies of SecA. Here, we describe the first characterization of the C. difficile accessory Sec system and the identification of its major substrates. Using inducible antisense RNA expression and dominant-negative alleles of secA1 and secA2, we demonstrate that export of the S-layer proteins (SLPs) and an additional cell wall protein (CwpV) is dependent on SecA2. Accumulation of the cytoplasmic precursor of the SLPs SlpA and other cell wall proteins was observed in cells expressing dominant-negative secA1 or secA2 alleles, concomitant with a decrease in the levels of mature SLPs in the cell wall. Furthermore, expression of either dominant-negative allele or antisense RNA knockdown of SecA1 or SecA2 dramatically impaired growth, indicating that both Sec systems are essential in C. difficile.     

S-layer anchoring and localization of an S-layer-associated protease in Caulobacter crescentus

The S-layer of the gram-negative bacterium Caulobacter crescentus is composed of a single protein, RsaA, that is secreted and assembled into a hexagonal crystalline array that covers the organism. Despite the widespread occurrence of comparable bacterial S-layers, little is known about S-layer attachment to cell surfaces, especially for gram-negative organisms. Having preliminary indications that the N terminus of RsaA anchors the monomer to the cell surface, we developed an assay to distinguish direct surface attachment from subunit-subunit interactions where small RsaA fragments are incubated with S-layer-negative cells to assess the ability of the fragments to reattach. In doing so, we found that the RsaA anchoring region lies in the first approximately 225 amino acids and that this RsaA anchoring region requires a smooth lipopolysaccharide species found in the outer membrane. By making mutations at six semirandom sites, we learned that relatively minor perturbations within the first approximately 225 amino acids of RsaA caused loss of anchoring. In other studies, we confirmed that only this N-terminal region has a direct role in S-layer anchoring. As a by-product of the anchoring studies, we discovered that Sap, the C. crescentus S-layer-associated protease, recognized a cleavage site in the truncated RsaA fragments that is not detected by Sap in full-length RsaA. This, in turn, led to the discovery that Sap was an extracellular membrane-bound protease, rather than intracellular, as previously proposed. Moreover, Sap was secreted to the cell surface primarily by the S-layer type I secretion apparatus.     

Clostridium difficile cell wall protein CwpV undergoes enzyme-independent intramolecular autoproteolysis

Clostridium difficile infection is a leading cause of antibiotic-associated diarrhea, placing considerable economic pressure on healthcare systems and resulting in significant morbidity and mortality. The pathogen produces a proteinaceous array on its cell surface known as the S-layer, consisting primarily of the major S-layer protein SlpA and a family of SlpA homologs. CwpV is the largest member of this family and is expressed in a phase-variable manner. The protein is post-translationally processed into two fragments that form a noncovalent, heterodimeric complex. To date, no specific proteases capable of cleaving CwpV have been identified. Using site-directed mutagenesis we show that CwpV undergoes intramolecular autoproteolysis, most likely facilitated by a N-O acyl shift, with Thr-413 acting as the source of a nucleophile driving this rearrangement. We demonstrate that neighboring residues are also important for correct processing of CwpV. Based on protein structural predictions and analogy to the glycosylasparaginase family of proteins, it appears likely that these residues play key roles in determining the correct protein fold and interact directly with Thr-413 to promote nucleophilic attack. Furthermore, using a cell-free protein synthesis assay we show that CwpV maturation requires neither cofactors nor auxiliary enzymes.