Structures of p53 cancer mutants and mechanism of rescue by second-site suppressor mutations

We have solved the crystal structures of three oncogenic mutants of the core domain of the human tumor suppressor p53. The mutations were introduced into a stabilized variant. The cancer hot spot mutation R273H simply removes an arginine involved in DNA binding without causing structural distortions in neighboring residues. In contrast, the "structural" oncogenic mutations H168R and R249S induce substantial structural perturbation around the mutation site in the L2 and L3 loops, respectively. H168R is a specific intragenic suppressor mutation for R249S. When both cancer mutations are combined in the same molecule, Arg(168) mimics the role of Arg(249) in wild type, and the wild type conformation is largely restored in both loops. Our structural and biophysical data provide compelling evidence for the mechanism of rescue of mutant p53 by intragenic suppressor mutations and reveal features by which proteins can adapt to deleterious mutations.     

Genetic selection of intragenic suppressor mutations that reverse the effect of common p53 cancer mutations.

Several lines of evidence suggest that the presence of the wild-type tumor suppressor gene p53 in human cancers correlates well with successful anti-cancer therapy. Restoration of wild-type p53 function to cancer cells that have lost it might therefore improve treatment outcomes. Using a systematic yeast genetic approach, we selected second-site suppressor mutations that can overcome the deleterious effects of common p53 cancer mutations in human cells. We identified several suppressor mutations for the V143A, G245S and R249S cancer mutations. The beneficial effects of these suppressor mutations were demonstrated using mammalian reporter gene and apoptosis assays. Further experiments showed that these suppressor mutations could override additional p53 cancer mutations. The mechanisms of such suppressor mutations can be elucidated by structural studies, ultimately leading to a framework for the discovery of small molecules able to stabilize p53 mutants.     

Molecular mechanisms of functional rescue mediated by P53 tumor suppressor mutations

We have utilized both molecular dynamics simulations and solution biophysical measurements to investigate the rescue mechanism of mutation N235K, which plays a key role in the recently identified global suppressor motif of K235/Y239/R240 in the human p53 DNA-binding domain (DBD). Previous genetic analysis indicates that N235K alone rescues five out of six destabilized cancer mutants. However, the solution biophysical measurement shows that N235K generates only a slight increase to the stability of DBD, implying a rescue mechanism that is not a simple additive contribution to thermodynamic stability. Our molecular simulations show that the N235K substitution generates two non-native salt bridges with residues D186 and E198. We find that the nonnative salt bridges, D186-K235 and E198-K235, and a native salt bridge, E171-R249, are mutually exclusive, thus resulting in only a marginal increase in stability as compared to the wild type protein. When a destabilized V157F is paired with N235K, the native salt bridge E171-R249 is retained. In this context, the non-native salt bridges, D186-K235 and E198-K235, produce a net increase in stability as compared to V157F alone. A similar rescue mechanism may explain how N235K stabilize other highly unstable β-sandwich cancer mutants.     

Effects of oncogenic mutations and DNA response elements on the binding of p53 to p53-binding protein 2 (53BP2)

The tumor suppressor p53 is frequently mutated in human cancers. Upon activation it can induce cell cycle arrest or apoptosis. ASPP2 can specifically stimulate the apoptotic function of p53 but not cell cycle arrest, but the mechanism of enhancing the activation of pro-apoptotic genes over cell cycle arrest genes remains unknown. In this study, we analyzed the binding of 53BP2 (p53-binding protein 2, the C-terminal domain of ASPP2) to p53 core domain and various mutants using biophysical techniques. We found that several p53 core domain mutations (R181E, G245S, R249S, R273H) have different effects on the binding of DNA response elements and 53BP2. Further, we investigated the existence of a ternary complex consisting of 53BP2, p53, and DNA response elements to gain insight into the specific pro-apoptotic activation of p53. We found that binding of 53BP2 and DNA to p53 is mutually exclusive in the case of GADD45, p21, Bax, and PIG3. Both pro-apoptotic and non-apoptotic response elements were competed off p53 by 53BP2 with no indication of a ternary complex.     

Functional studies of mutations in the human protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene in variegate porphyria.

The autosomal dominant disorder, variegate porphyria (VP), results from mutations in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPOX) gene. We have investigated the effects of 22 disease-associated missense mutations in this gene on enzyme activity. Mutants were generated in the expression plasmid pHPPOX by site-directed mutagenesis. They were screened for PPOX activity by complementation of the Escherischia coli strain SAS38X which lacks PPOX activity. Ten mutants (G40E, L85P, G232R, de1281H, V282D, L295P, V335G, S350P, L444P, G453V) had no detectable PPOX activity. PPOX activity of the remaining 12 mutants (L15F, R38P, L73P, V84G, D143V, R152C, L154P, V158M, R168H, A172V, V290L, G453R) ranged from less than 1% to 9.2% of wild-type activity. Our findings show that all 22 mutations substantially impair or abolish PPOX activity in a prokaryotic expression system and add to the evidence that they cause VP.     

Crystal structure of a superstable mutant of human p53 core domain. Insights into the mechanism of rescuing oncogenic mutations

Most of the cancer-associated mutations in the tumor suppressor p53 map to its DNA-binding core domain. Many of them inactivate p53 by decreasing its thermodynamic stability. We have previously designed the superstable quadruple mutant M133L/V203A/N239Y/N268D containing the second-site suppressor mutations N239Y and N268D, which specifically restore activity and stability in several oncogenic mutants. Here we present the x-ray structure of this quadruple mutant at 1.9 A resolution, which was solved in a new crystal form in the absence of DNA. This structure reveals that the four point mutations cause only small local structural changes, whereas the overall structure of the central beta-sandwich and the DNA-binding surface is conserved. The suppressor mutation N268D results in an altered hydrogen bond pattern connecting strands S1 and S10, thus bridging the two sheets of the beta-sandwich scaffold in an energetically more favorable way. The second suppressor mutation N239Y, which is located in close proximity to the DNA-binding surface in loop L3, seems to reduce the plasticity of the structure in large parts of loop L3 as indicated by decreased crystallographic temperature factors. The same is observed for residues in the vicinity of the N268D substitution. This increase in rigidity provides the structural basis for the increase in thermostability and an understanding how N268D and N239Y rescue some of the common cancer mutants.     

Structure and Function of p53-DNA Complexes with Inactivation and Rescue Mutations: A Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

The tumor suppressor protein p53 can lose its function upon DNA-contact mutations (R273C and R273H) in the core DNA-binding domain. The activity can be restored by second-site suppressor or rescue mutations (R273C_T284R, R273H_T284R, and R273H_S240R). In this paper, we elucidate the structural and functional consequence of p53 proteins upon DNA-contact mutations and rescue mutations and the underlying mechanisms at the atomic level by means of molecular dynamics simulations. Furthermore, we also apply the docking approach to investigate the binding phenomena between the p53 protein and DNA upon DNA-contact mutations and rescue mutations. This study clearly illustrates that, due to DNA-contact mutants, the p53 structure loses its stability and becomes more rigid than the native protein. This structural loss might affect the p53-DNA interaction and leads to inhibition of the cancer suppression. Rescue mutants (R273C_T284R, R273H_T284R and R273H_S240R) can restore the functional activity of the p53 protein upon DNA-contact mutations and show a good interaction between the p53 protein and a DNA molecule, which may lead to reactivate the cancer suppression function. Understanding the effects of p53 cancer and rescue mutations at the molecular level will be helpful for designing drugs for p53 associated cancer diseases. These drugs should be designed so that they can help to inhibit the abnormal function of the p53 protein and to reactivate the p53 function (cell apoptosis) to treat human cancer.     

Structural distortion of p53 by the mutation R249S and its rescue by a designed peptide: implications for "mutant conformation"

Missense mutations in the DNA-binding core domain of the tumour suppressor protein p53 are frequent in cancer. Many of them result in loss of native structure. The mutation R249S is one of the six most common cancer-associated p53 mutations ("hot-spots"). As it is highly frequent in hepatocellular carcinoma, its rescue is an important therapeutic target. We have used NMR techniques to study the structural effects of the R249S mutation. The overall fold of the core domain is retained in R249S, and it does not take up a denatured "mutant conformation". However, the beta-sandwich had increased flexibility and, according to changes in chemical shift, there was local distortion throughout the DNA-binding interface. It is likely that the R249S mutation resulted in an ensemble of native and native-like conformations in a dynamic equilibrium. The peptide FL-CDB3 that was designed to rescue mutants of p53 by binding specifically to its native structure was found to revert the chemical shifts of R249S back towards the wild-type values and so reverse the structural effects of mutation. We discuss the implications for a rescue strategy and also for the analysis of antibody-binding data.     

A split-ubiquitin-based assay detects the influence of mutations on the conformational stability of the p53 DNA binding domain in vivo

Many mutations in the human tumor suppressor p53 affect the function of the protein by destabilizing the structure of its DNA binding domain. To monitor the effects of those mutations in vivo the stability of the DNA binding domain of p53 and some of its mutants was investigated with the split-ubiquitin (split-Ub) method. The split-Ub-derived in vivo data on the relative stability of the mutants roughly correlate with the quantitative data from in vitro denaturation experiments as reported in the literature. A variation of this assay allows visualizing the difference in stability between the wild-type p53 core and the mutant p53(V143A) by a simple growth assay.     

Common conformational effects of p53 mutations

The tumor suppressor gene p53 has been identified as the most frequent target of genetic alterations in human cancers. Most of these mutations occur in highly conserved regions in the DNA-binding core domain of the p53 protein, suggesting that the amino acid residues in these regions are critical for maintaining normal p53 structure and function. We previously used molecular dynamics calculations to demonstrate that several amino acid substitutions in these regions that are induced by environmental carcinogens and found in human tumors produce certain common conformational changes in the mutant proteins that differ substantially from the wild-type structure. In order to determine whether these conformational changes are consistent for other p53 mutants, we have now used molecular dynamics to determine the structure of the DNA-binding core domain of seven other environmentally induced, cancer-related p53 mutants, namely His 175, Asp 245, Asn 245, Trp 248, Met 249, Ser 278, and Lys 286. The results indicate that all of these mutants differ substantially from the wild-type structure in certain discrete regions and that some of these conformational changes are similar for these mutants as well as those determined previously. The changes are also consistent with experimental evidence for alterations in structure in p53 mutants determined by epitope detectability using monoclonal antibodies directed against these regions of predicted conformational change.     

Molecular mechanisms of disease for mutations at Gly-90 in rhodopsin

Two different mutations at Gly-90 in the second transmembrane helix of the photoreceptor protein rhodopsin have been proposed to lead to different phenotypes. G90D has been classically associated with congenital night blindness, whereas the newly reported G90V substitution was linked to a retinitis pigmentosa phenotype. Here, we used Val/Asp replacements of the native Gly at position 90 to unravel the structure/function divergences caused by these mutations and the potential molecular mechanisms of inherited retinal disease. The G90V and G90D mutants have a similar conformation around the Schiff base linkage region in the dark state and same regeneration kinetics with 11-cis-retinal, but G90V has dramatically reduced thermal stability when compared with the G90D mutant rhodopsin. The G90V mutant also shows, like G90D, an altered photobleaching pattern and capacity to activate Gt in the opsin state. Furthermore, the regeneration of the G90V mutant with 9-cis-retinal was improved, achieving the same A(280)/A(500) as wild type isorhodopsin. Hydroxylamine resistance was also recovered, indicating a compact structure around the Schiff base linkage, and the thermal stability was substantially improved when compared with the 11-cis-regenerated mutant. These results support the role of thermal instability and/or abnormal photoproduct formation in eliciting a retinitis pigmentosa phenotype. The improved stability and more compact structure of the G90V mutant when it was regenerated with 9-cis-retinal brings about the possibility that this isomer or other modified retinoid analogues might be used in potential treatment strategies for mutants showing the same structural features.     

Familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis-associated mutations decrease the thermal stability of distinctly metallated species of human copper/zinc superoxide dismutase

We report the thermal stability of wild type (WT) and 14 different variants of human copper/zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD1) associated with familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (FALS). Multiple endothermic unfolding transitions were observed by differential scanning calorimetry for partially metallated SOD1 enzymes isolated from a baculovirus system. We correlated the metal ion contents of SOD1 variants with the occurrence of distinct melting transitions. Altered thermal stability upon reduction of copper with dithionite identified transitions resulting from the unfolding of copper-containing SOD1 species. We demonstrated that copper or zinc binding to a subset of "WT-like" FALS mutants (A4V, L38V, G41S, G72S, D76Y, D90A, G93A, and E133Delta) conferred a similar degree of incremental stabilization as did metal ion binding to WT SOD1. However, these mutants were all destabilized by approximately 1-6 degrees C compared with the corresponding WT SOD1 species. Most of the "metal binding region" FALS mutants (H46R, G85R, D124V, D125H, and S134N) exhibited transitions that probably resulted from unfolding of metal-free species at approximately 4-12 degrees C below the observed melting of the least stable WT species. We conclude that decreased conformational stability shared by all of these mutant SOD1s may contribute to SOD1 toxicity in FALS.