Foldability, enzymatic activity, and interacting ability of barnase mutants obtained by permutation of secondary structure units

Barnase, a well-characterized ribonuclease, has been decomposed into six modules (M1-M6) or secondary structure units (S1-S6). We have studied the foldability and activity of the barnase mutants obtained by permutation of the four internal modules (M2-M5) or secondary structure units (S2-S5) to investigate whether permutation of these building blocks is a useful way to create foldable and/or functional proteins. In this study, we found that one of the secondary structure unit mutants was expressed in Escherichia coli only when His102 was substituted by alanine, which is a catalytic residue of wild-type barnase. This mutant (S2354H102A) had ordered conformations, which unfolded cooperatively during urea-induced unfolding experiments. S2354H102A interacted with other barnase mutants to show a distinct RNase activity, although its own activity was quite weak. This interaction was specific, because S2354H102A interacted with only barnase mutants having His 102 and certain orders of the secondary structure units giving a distinct RNase activity. These results suggest that secondary structure units permuted in barnase mutants maintain their intrinsic "interacting ability" that is used for the folding of wild-type barnase, and the units can form certain conformations that complement those of the appropriate counterparts. Seven of 23 secondary structure unit mutants and only 2 of 23 module mutants had RNase activity. On the basis of the results of analyses of foldability and RNase activity of the mutants performed in this and previous studies, we conclude that secondary structure units are more suitable than modules as building blocks to create novel foldable and/or functional proteins in the case of barnase.     

Protein anatomy: structure and function of peptide fragments corresponding to the secondary structure units of barnase

Globular proteins can be decomposed into several modules or secondary structure units. It is useful to investigate the functions of such structural units in order to understand the folding units of proteins. In our previous work, barnase was divided into six peptide fragments corresponding to modules, and some of them were shown to have RNA-binding and RNase activity [Yanagawa, et al. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 5861-5865]. Barnase mutant proteins obtained by permutation of the structural units also had RNase activity [Tsuji, T. et al. (1999) J. Mol. Biol. 286, 1581-1596]. Here we investigated the structure and function of peptide fragments corresponding to secondary structure units of barnase. The results of circular dichroism spectroscopy indicated that some of the peptide fragments form helical structures in aqueous solutions containing over 30% 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol, and the S6 (94-110) peptide fragment is induced to form a beta-sheet structure in the presence of RNA. The S6 peptide fragment forms aggregate complexes with RNA. Electron microscopic analysis showed that the aggregate complexes were comprised of filaments. These results indicate that not only modules but also secondary structure units dissected from a globular protein have functional and structure-forming capabilities.     

Conformational characterization of designed minibarnase

We have designed a minibarnase by removing one module from barnase, a bacterial RNase from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. Barnase, consisting of 110 amino acid residues, is decomposed into six modules, M1-M6. Module is defined as a peptide segment consisting of contiguous amino acid residues that makes a small compact conformation within a globular domain. To understand the role of module in protein architecture, we analyzed NMR and CD spectra of a minibarnase, which lacked 26 amino acid residues corresponding to module M2. We demonstrated the formation of hydrophobic cores in the minibarnase similar to those of barnase. Although its conformational stability against acids and heat was reduced in comparison with barnase, the minibarnase retained cooperative folding character (two-state folding). Therefore, the folding of the minibarnase consisting of modules M1 and M3-M6 is independent to some extent of module M2. This finding may be useful for future module-based protein design.     

Secondary structural features of modules M2 and M3 of barnase in solution by NMR experiment and distance geometry calculation

Proteins consist of structural units such as globular domains, secondary structures, and modules. Modules were originally defined by partitioning a globular domain into compact regions, each of which is a contiguous polypeptide segment having a compact conformation. Since modules show close correlations with the intron positions of genes, they are regarded as primordial polypeptide pieces encoded by exons and shuffled, leading to yield new combination of them in early biological evolution. Do modules maintain their native conformations in solution when they are excised at their boundaries? In order to find answers to this question, we have synthesized modules of barnase, one of the bacterial RNases, and studied the solution structures of modules M2 (amino acid residues 24–52) and M3 (52–73) by 2D NMR studies. Some local secondary structures, α-helix, and β-turns in M2 and β-turns in M3, were observed in the modules at the similar positions to those in the intact barnase but the overall state seems to be in a mixture of random and native conformations. The present result shows that the excised modules have propensity to form similar secondary structures to those of the intact barnase. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

A mini-protein designed by removing a module from barnase: molecular modeling and NMR measurements of the conformation.

A globular domain can be decomposed into compact modules consisting of contiguous 10-30 amino acid residues. The correlation between modules and exons observed in different proteins suggests that each module was encoded by an ancestral exon and that modules were combined into globular domains by exon fusion. Barnase is a single domain RNase consisting of 110 amino acid residues and was decomposed into six modules. We designed a mini-protein by removing the second module, M2, from barnase in order to gain an insight into the structural and functional roles of the module. In the molecular modeling of the mini-protein, we evaluated thermodynamic stability and aqueous solubility together with mechanical stability of the model. We chemically synthesized a mini-barnase with (15)N-labeling at 10 residues, whose corresponding residues in barnase are all found in the region around the hydrophobic core. Circular dichroism and NMR measurements revealed that mini-barnase takes a non-random specific conformation that has a similar hydrophobic core structure to that of barnase. This result, that a module could be deleted without altering the structure of core region of barnase, supports the view that modules act as the building blocks of protein design.     

Localization of hydrogen-bonds within modules in barnase

Proteins in eukaryotes are composed of structural units, each encoded by discrete exons. The protein module is one such structural unit; it has been defined as the least extended or the most compact contiguous segment in a globular domain. To elucidate roles of modules in protein evolution and folding, we examined roles of hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic cores, as related to the stability of these modules. For this purpose we studied barnase, a bacterial Rnase from Bacillus amylolique-faciens. Barnase is decomposed into at least six modules, M1–M6; the module boundaries are identified at amino acid residues 24, 52, 73, 88, and 98. Hydrogen bonds are localized mainly within each of the modules, with only a few between them, thereby indicating that their locations are designed to primarily stabilize each individual module. To obtain support for this notion, an analysis was made of hypothetical modules defined as segments starting at a center of one module and ending at the center of the following one. We found that the hydrogen bonds did not localize in each hypothetical module and that many formed between the hypothetical modules. The native conformations of modules of barnase may be specified predominantly by interactions within the modules. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Induced expression of adipophilin mRNA in human macrophages stimulated with oxidized low-density lipoprotein and in atherosclerotic lesions

The RNase activity of barnase mutants obtained by the permutation of modules or secondary structure units was investigated. Four of the 45 mutants had weak but distinct RNase activity, and they had unique optimum pHs and temperatures like natural enzymes. One of the active mutants had an ordered conformation, but the others did not. An active mutant having disordered conformation formed an ordered conformation in the presence of GMP, which is an inhibitor of this mutant. These results indicate that the amino acid sequences derived from barnase have sufficient plasticity to be rearranged into different proteins with basal enzymatic properties.     

Folding and Stability of Chimeric Immunofusion VL-Barstar

A chimeric protein VL-barstar that comprises the VL domain of anti-human ferritin monoclonal antibody F11 and barstar, the naturally occurring inhibitor of bacterial RNase barnase, has been constructed for study of structure-function characteristics of chimeric immunoglobulin fused proteins. Such chimeric constructs may be potentially employed for development of bivalent/bispecific antibodies on the basis of the high affinity interaction between barstar and barnase (the association constant is about 10(14) M(-1)). We have developed a protocol for VL-barstar expression in E. coli and purification and refolding from inclusion bodies that yields a homogeneous and soluble form of this protein. Differential scanning calorimetry in combination with fluorescence and CD spectroscopy revealed that the VL-barstar formed well-resolved ordered secondary and compact tertiary structures. However, partial loss of tertiary interactions resulted in low stability of the recombinant protein and the lack of functional activity of the two constituent modules. These conformational features suggest that the protein might be referred to the class of native molten globules, which comprises partially unfolded conformations stabilized under physiological conditions. Since individually expressed VL domain and barstar retain completely folded conformation and stable spatial structure, the incomplete folding of the chimeric protein may be attributed to interaction between heterologous domains, which appears at the folding stage preceding formation of a system of tertiary interactions in both structural modules. The results provide evidence for non-native interactions between heterologous modules that may occur in chimeric proteins composed of taxonomically distinct fusion partners.     

N- and C-terminal fragments of a globular protein constructed by elongation of modules as a units associated for functional complementation

We have been interested in partially folded proteins with marginal stability and activity, because they have a potential to be mature proteins by artificial evolution. A module is defined as a contiguous peptide chain forming a compact region in a globular protein. Modules may be used as building blocks to create partially folded proteins. Barnase, a ribonuclease consisting of 110 amino acids, has been divided into six modules (M1-M6), four peptide fragments, M12 (1-52), M123 (1-73), M1234 (1-88) and M12345 (1-98), have been constructed by progressive elongation of the modules from the N-terminus. Only M12345 (1-98) had a partially folded conformation, but it lacked detectable RNase activity. A mixture of M12345 (1-98) with M56 (89-110) showed weak but distinct RNase activity. Unfolded M12345 (1-96) was constructed by removal of two residues from the C-terminus of M12345 (1-98). The mixture of M12345 (1-96) with M56 (89-110) also showed RNase activity. Further, the interaction endowed M12345 (1-96) with conformational stability. We propose that N- and C-terminal fragments obtained by successive elongation of modules would interact to be a complex with marginal stability and activity, which would be used for creating a mature complex by artificial evolution.     

Key elements for protein foldability revealed by a combinatorial approach among similarly folded but distantly related proteins

We have determined the key regions for protein foldability by creating multiple crossover libraries from two proteins that share similar fold but have low sequence identity and differ significantly in stability. One protein is the propeptide of a serine protease, subtilisin BPN', and the other is Pleurotus ostreatus proteinase A inhibitor 1 (POIA1). The propeptide has a compact structure when complexed with subtilisin but is unstructured when isolated, whereas POIA1 takes a stable structure. We selected four of the conserved amino acid residues for the boundaries of crossover sites and utilized these residues to make same cohesive-ends to assemble synthetic DNA fragments. Each segment has one or two secondary structure units, and the interchange of these structural elements produces 32 (= 2(5)) combinations, including the propeptide and POIA1. The stability of these mutants was first screened by formation of turbid zones on skim milk plates containing subtilisin BPN'. It was shown that six variants were foldable and structural units necessary for folding were identified. Further fragmentation and recombination of these mutants (the "multisection" method) revealed that two interactions between secondary structures are important; one is interaction between the loop-alpha1 and beta2-turn-beta3, and the other is hydrophobic interaction between the adjoining beta1 and beta4 strands. We were also able to specify the significant amino acid combinations for tolerance to proteolysis. These combinatorial methods not only elucidate how domains can be interchanged to make the whole protein foldable but also extract essential regions for the function, which is correlated with the instability of the molecule.     

ANS fluorescence detects widespread perturbations of protein tertiary structure in ice

Freeze-induced perturbations of the protein native fold are poorly understood owing to the difficulty of monitoring their structure in ice. Here, we report that binding of the fluorescence probe 1-anilino-8-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) to proteins in ice can provide a general monitor of ice-induced alterations of their tertiary structure. Experiments conducted with copper-free azurin from Pseudomonas aeruginosa and mutants I7S, F110S, and C3A/C26A correlate the magnitude of the ice-induced perturbation, as inferred from the extent of ANS binding, to the plasticity of the globular fold, increasing with less stable globular folds as well as when the flexibility of the macromolecule is enhanced. The distortion of the native structure inferred from ANS binding was found to draw a parallel with the extent of irreversible denaturation by freeze-thawing, suggesting that these altered conformations play a direct role on freeze damage. ANS binding experiments, extended to a set of proteins including serum albumin, alpha-amylase, beta-galactosidase, alcohol dehydrogenase from horse liver, alcohol dehydrogenase from yeast, lactic dehydrogenase, and aldolase, confirmed that a stressed condition of the native fold in the frozen state appears to be general to most proteins and pointed out that oligomers tend to be more labile than monomers presumably because the globular fold can be further destabilized by subunit dissociation. The results of this study suggest that the ANS binding method may find practical utility in testing the effectiveness of various additives employed in protein formulations as well as to devise safer freeze-drying protocols of pharmaceutical proteins.     

Module-intron correlation and intron sliding in family F/10 xylanase genes

Xylanases are classified into two families, numbered F/10 and G/11 according to the similarity of amino acid sequences of their catalytic domain (Henrissat, B., Bairoch, A., 1993. New families in the classification of glycosyl hydrolases based on amino acid sequence similarities. Biochem. J. 293, 781-788). Three-dimensional structure of the catalytic domain of the family F/10 xylanase was reported (White, A., Withers, S.G., Gilkes, N.R., Rose, D.R., 1994. Crystal structure of the catalytic domain of the beta-1,4-glycanase Cex from Cellulomonas fimi. Biochemistry 33, 12546-12552). The domain was decomposed into 22 modules by centripetal profiles (Go, M., Nosaka, M., 1987. Protein architecture and the origin of introns. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 52, 915-924; Noguti, T., Sakakibara, H., Go, M., 1993. Localization of hydrogen-bonds within modules in barnase. Proteins 16, 357-363). A module is a contiguous polypeptide segment of amino acid residues having a compact conformation within a globular domain. Collected 31 intron sites of the family F/10 xylanase genes from fungus were found to be correlated to module boundaries with considerable statistical force (p values <0.001). The relationship between the intron locations and protein structures provides supporting evidence for the ancient origin of introns, because such a relationship cannot be expected by random insertion of introns into eukaryotic genes, but it rather suggests pre-existence of introns in the ancestral genes of prokaryotes and eukaryotes. A phylogenetic tree of the fungal and bacterial xylanase sequences made two clusters; one includes both the bacterial and fungal genes, but the other consists of only fungal genes. The mixed cluster of bacterial genes without introns and the fungal genes with introns further supports the ancient origin of introns. Comparison of the conserved base sequences of introns indicates that sliding of a splice site occurred in Aspergillus kawachii gene by one base from the ancestral position. Substrate-binding sites of xylanase are localized on eight modules, and introns are found at both termini of six out of these functional modules. This result suggests that introns might play a functional role in shuffling the exons encoding the substrate-binding modules.     

Design of multivalent complexes using the barnase*barstar module

The ribonuclease barnase (12 kDa) and its inhibitor barstar (10 kDa) form a very tight complex in which all N and C termini are accessible for fusion. Here we exploit this system to create modular targeting molecules based on antibody scFv fragment fusions to barnase, to two barnase molecules in series and to barstar. We describe the construction, production and purification of defined dimeric and trimeric complexes. Immobilized barnase fusions are used to capture barstar fusions from crude extracts to yield homogeneous, heterodimeric fusion proteins. These proteins are stable, soluble and resistant to proteolysis. Using fusions with anti-p185(HER2-ECD) 4D5 scFv, we show that the anticipated gain in avidity from monomer to dimer to trimer is obtained and that favorable tumor targeting properties are achieved. Many permutations of engineered multispecific fusion proteins become accessible with this technology of quasi-covalent heterodimers.     

Dynamic structures of globular proteins with respect to correlative movements of residues calculated in the normal mode analysis

Dynamic structures of globular proteins are studied on the basis of correlative movements of residues around their native conformations, which are computed by means of the normal mode analysis. To describe the dynamic structures of a protein, the core regions moving with strong positive or negative correlations to other regions of the polypeptide chain are detected from the correlation maps of the movements of residues. Such core regions are different, according to the definition, from the regions defined from a geometrical point of view, such as secondary structures, domains, modules, and so on. The core regions are actually detected for four proteins, myoglobin, Bence-Jones protein, flavodoxin, and hen egg-white lysozyme, with different folding types from each other. The results show that some of them coincide with the secondary structures, domains, or modules, but others do not. Then, the dynamic structure of each protein is discussed in terms of the dynamic cores detected, as compared with the secondary structures, domains, and modules.     

Can non-mechanical proteins withstand force? Stretching barnase by atomic force microscopy and molecular dynamics simulation

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) experiments have provided intriguing insights into the mechanical unfolding of proteins such as titin I27 from muscle, but will the same be possible for proteins that are not physiologically required to resist force? We report the results of AFM experiments on the forced unfolding of barnase in a chimeric construct with I27. Both modules are independently folded and stable in this construct and have the same thermodynamic and kinetic properties as the isolated proteins. I27 can be identified in the AFM traces based on its previous characterization, and distinct, irregular low-force peaks are observed for barnase. Molecular dynamics simulations of barnase unfolding also show that it unfolds at lower forces than proteins with mechanical function. The unfolding pathway involves the unraveling of the protein from the termini, with much more native-like secondary and tertiary structure being retained in the transition state than is observed in simulations of thermal unfolding or experimentally, using chemical denaturant. Our results suggest that proteins that are not selected for tensile strength may not resist force in the same way as those that are, and that proteins with similar unfolding rates in solution need not have comparable unfolding properties under force.     

Histidine residues at the N- and C-termini of alpha-helices: perturbed pKas and protein stability.

A single histidine residue has been placed at either the N-terminus or the C-terminus of each of the two alpha-helices of barnase. The pKa of that histidine residue in each of the four mutants has been determined by 1H NMR. The pKas of the two residues at the C-terminus are, on average, 0.5 unit higher, and those of the residues at the N-terminus are 0.8 unit lower, than the pKa of histidines in unfolded barnase at low ionic strength. The conformational stability of the mutant proteins at different values of pH has been measured by urea denaturation. C-Terminal histidine mutants are approximately 0.6 kcal mol-1 more stable when the introduced histidine is protonated, both at low and high ionic strength. N-Terminal mutants with a protonated histidine residue are approximately 1.1 kcal mol-1 less stable at low ionic strength and 0.5 kcal mol-1 less stable at high ionic strength (1 M NaCl). The low-field 1H NMR spectra of the mutant proteins at low pH suggest that the C-terminal histidines form hydrogen bonds with the protein while the N-terminal histidines do not form the same. The perturbations of pKa and stability result from a combination of different electrostatic environments and hydrogen-bonding patterns at either ends of helices. The value of 0.6 kcal mol-1 represents a lower limit to the favorable electrostatic interaction between the alpha-helix dipole and a protonated histidine residue at the C-terminal end of the helix.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Mechanism of protein folding

The high structural resolution of the main transition states for the formation of native structure for the six small proteins of which Phi-values for a large set of mutants have become available, barstar, barnase, chymotrypsin inhibitor 2, Arc repressor, the src SH3 domain, and a tetrameric p53 domain reveals that for the first 5 of these proteins: (1) Residues that belong to regular secondary structure have a significantly larger average fraction of native structural consolidation than residues in loops; (2) on the other hand, secondary and tertiary structures have built up to the same degree, or at least a high degree, but nonuniformly distributed over the molecule; (3) the most consolidated parts of each protein molecule in the transition state cluster together, and these clusters contain a significantly higher percentage of residues that belong to regular secondary structure than the rest of the molecule. These observations further reconcile the framework model with the nucleation-condensation mechanism for folding: The amazing speed of protein folding can be understood as caused by the catalytic effect of the formation of clusters of residues which have particularly high preferences for the early formation of regular secondary structure in the presence of significant amounts of tertiary structure interactions.     

Constitutive activation of the mu opioid receptor by mutation of D3.49(164), but not D3.32(147): D3.49(164) is critical for stabilization of the inactive form of the receptor and for its expression

The roles of conserved aspartates in the third transmembrane domain of the rat mu opioid receptor (RMOR) were explored with mutations of D3.32(147) and D3.49(164). D3.49(164) in the highly conserved DRY motif was mutated to 13 amino acids. Except for the D3.49(164)E mutant, each mutant displayed little or no detectable [(3)H]diprenorphine binding, and pretreatment with naloxone greatly enhanced binding. D3.49(164)H, -Q, -Y, -M, and -E mutants were further studied. D3.32(147) was substituted with A or N. All seven mutants exhibited similar binding affinities for the antagonist [(3)H]diprenorphine as the wild-type. The D3.49(164)H, -Q, -Y, and -M mutants, but not the D3.49(164)E and D3.32(147) mutants, exhibited enhanced basal [(35)S]GTPgammaS binding which was comparable to the maximally activated level of the wild-type and was related to expression levels. Naloxone, naltrexone, and naloxone methiodide significantly inhibited the basal [(35)S]GTPgammaS binding of the D3.49(164) mutants, indicating inverse agonist activities. Treatment of the D3.49(164)Y mutant with pertussis toxin greatly reduced the basal [(35)S]GTPgammaS binding, demonstrating constitutive activation of Galpha(i)/Galpha(o). The D3.49(164)H, -Y, -M, and -Q mutants had higher affinities for DAMGO than the wild-type, which were not significantly lowered by GTPgammaS. Thus, mutation of D3.49(164) to H, Y, M, or Q in RMOR resulted in receptor assuming activated conformations. In contrast, the D3.49(164)E mutant displayed significantly lower basal [(35)S]GTPgammaS binding and reduced affinity for DAMGO. Upon incubation of membranes at 37 degrees C, the constitutively active D3.49(164)Y mutant was structurally less stable, whereas the inactivated D3.49(164)E mutant was more stable, than the wild-type. Computational simulations showed that the E3.49 side chain interacted strongly with the conserved R3.50 in the DRY motif and stabilized the inactive form of the receptor. Taken together, these results indicate that D3.49 plays an important role in constraining the receptor in inactive conformations.     

Maps of preferential conformation of dipeptides in the structural regions of globular proteins

According to X-ray crystallographic analysis of 46 globular proteins the probability of dipeptides frequency in alpha-helical beta-sheet and random coil conformations has been studied on the basis of which the maps of preferentially conformational state of dipeptide in different elements of secondary structure of proteins have been obtained.     

The effects of disulfide bonds on the denatured state of barnase

The effects of engineered disulfide bonds on protein stability are poorly understood because they can influence the structure, dynamics, and energetics of both the native and denatured states. To explore the effects of two engineered disulfide bonds on the stability of barnase, we have conducted a combined molecular dynamics and NMR study of the denatured state of the two mutants. As expected, the disulfide bonds constrain the denatured state. However, specific extended beta-sheet structure can also be detected in one of the mutant proteins. This mutant is also more stable than would be predicted. Our study suggests a possible cause of the very high stability conferred by this disulfide bond: the wild-type denatured ensemble is stabilized by a nonnative hydrophobic cluster, which is constrained from occurring in the mutant due to the formation of secondary structure.