Adaptation to tRNA acceptor stem structure by flexible adjustment in the catalytic domain of class I tRNA synthetases

Class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) use a Rossmann-fold domain to catalyze the synthesis of aminoacyl-tRNAs required for decoding genetic information. While the Rossmann-fold domain is conserved in evolution, the acceptor stem near the aminoacylation site varies among tRNA substrates, raising the question of how the conserved protein fold adapts to RNA sequence variations. Of interest is the existence of an unpaired C-A mismatch at the 1-72 position unique to bacterial initiator tRNA(fMet) and absent from elongator tRNAs. Here we show that the class I methionyl-tRNA synthetase (MetRS) of Escherichia coli and its close structural homolog cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase (CysRS) display distinct patterns of recognition of the 1-72 base pair. While the structural homology of the two enzymes in the Rossmann-fold domain is manifested in a common burst feature of aminoacylation kinetics, CysRS discriminates against unpaired 1-72, whereas MetRS lacks such discrimination. A structure-based alignment of the Rossmann fold identifies the insertion of an α-helical motif, specific to CysRS but absent from MetRS, which docks on 1-72 and may discriminate against mismatches. Indeed, substitutions of the CysRS helical motif abolish the discrimination against unpaired 1-72. Additional structural alignments reveal that with the exception of MetRS, class I tRNA synthetases contain a structural motif that docks on 1-72. This work demonstrates that by flexible insertion of a structural motif to dock on 1-72, the catalytic domain of class I tRNA synthetases can acquire structural plasticity to adapt to changes at the end of the tRNA acceptor stem.     

Tripartite functional assembly of a large class I aminoacyl tRNA synthetase.

A 939-amino acid monomeric class I tRNA synthetase has been split into three inactive peptides. The three peptides spontaneously assemble in vivo to reconstitute active protein. Active tripartite complexes were demonstrated in vitro. The tripartite assembly of this synthetase increases by several-fold the size of a polypeptide that has been demonstrated to be assembled from more than two constituent pieces. The results indicate that contemporary single-chain tRNA synthetases or other large proteins could in principle develop from intermediates composed of non-covalent assemblages of multiple peptides.     

Activation of the pyrrolysine suppressor tRNA requires formation of a ternary complex with class I and class II lysyl-tRNA synthetases

Monomethylamine methyltransferase of the archaeon Methanosarcina barkeri contains a rare amino acid, pyrrolysine, encoded by the termination codon UAG. Translation of this UAG requires the aminoacylation of the corresponding amber suppressor tRNAPyl. Previous studies reported that tRNAPyl could be aminoacylated by the synthetase-like protein PylS. We now show that tRNAPyl is efficiently aminoacylated in the presence of both the class I LysRS and class II LysRS of M. barkeri, but not by either enzyme acting alone or by PylS. In vitro studies show that both the class I and II LysRS enzymes must bind tRNAPyl in order for the aminoacylation reaction to proceed. Structural modeling and selective inhibition experiments indicate that the class I and II LysRSs form a ternary complex with tRNAPyl, with the aminoacylation activity residing in the class II enzyme.     

Plasticity of recognition of the 3'-end of mischarged tRNA by class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

Certain aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases prevent potential errors in protein synthesis through deacylation of mischarged tRNAs. For example, the close homologs isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase (IleRS) and valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS) deacylate Val-tRNA(Ile) and Thr-tRNA(Val), respectively. Here we examined the chemical requirements at the 3'-end of the tRNA for these hydrolysis reactions. Single atom substitutions at the 2'- and 3'-hydroxyls of a variety of mischarged RNAs revealed that, while acylation is at the 2'-OH for both enzymes, IleRS catalyzes deacylation specifically from the 3'-OH and not from the 2'-OH. In contrast, ValRS can deacylate non-cognate amino acids from the 2'-OH. Moreover, for IleRS the specificity for a 3'-O location of the scissile ester bond could be forced to the 2'-position by introduction of a 3'-O-methyl moiety. Cumulatively, these and other results suggest that the editing sites of these class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases have a degree of inherent plasticity for substrate recognition. The ability to adapt to subtle differences in mischarged RNAs may be important for the high accuracy of aminoacylation.     

Transiently misacylated tRNA is a primer for editing of misactivated adenylates by class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The genetic code depends on amino acid fine structure discrimination by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. For isoleucyl- (IleRS) and valyl-tRNA synthetases (ValRS), reactions that hydrolyze misactivated noncognate amino acids help to achieve high accuracy in aminoacylation. Two editing pathways contribute to aminoacylation fidelity: pretransfer and post-transfer. In pretransfer editing, the misactivated amino acid is hydrolyzed as an aminoacyl adenylate, while in post-transfer editing a misacylated tRNA is deacylated. Both reactions are dependent on a tRNA cofactor and require translocation to a site located approximately 30 A from the site of amino acid activation. Using a series of 3'-end modified tRNAs that are deficient in either aminoacylation, deacylation, or both, total editing (the sum of pre- and post-transfer editing) was shown to require both aminoacylation and deacylation activities. These and additional results with IleRS are consistent with a post-transfer deacylation event initiating formation of an editing-active enzyme/tRNA complex. In this state, the primed complex processively edits misactivated valyl-adenylate via the pretransfer route. Thus, misacylated tRNA is an obligatory intermediate for editing by either pathway.     

Single sequence of a helix-loop peptide confers functional anticodon recognition on two tRNA synthetases.

The specific aminoacylation of RNA oligonucleotides whose sequences are based on the acceptor stems of tRNAs can be viewed as an operational RNA code for amino acids that may be related to the development of the genetic code. Many synthetases also have direct interactions with tRNA anticodon triplets and, in some cases, these interactions are thought to be essential for aminoacylation specificity. In these instances, an unresolved question is whether interactions with parts of the tRNA outside of the anticodon are sufficient for decoding genetic information. Escherichia coli isoleucyl- and methionyl-tRNA synthetases are closely related enzymes that interact with their respective anticodons. We used binary combinatorial mutagenesis of a 10 amino acid anticodon binding peptide in these two enzymes to identify composite sequences that would confer function to both enzymes despite their recognizing different anticodons. A single peptide was found that confers function to both enzymes in vivo and in vitro. Thus, even in enzymes where anticodon interactions are normally important for distinguishing one tRNA from another, these interactions can be 'neutralized' without losing specificity of amino-acylation. We suggest that acceptor helix interactions may play a role in providing the needed specificity.     

Sequence and structural aspects of functional diversification in class I alpha-mannosidase evolution.

MOTIVATION: Class I alpha-mannosidases comprise a homologous and functionally diverse family of glycoside hydrolases. Phylogenetic analysis based on an amino acid sequence alignment of the catalytic domain of class I alpha-mannosidases reveals four well-supported phylogenetic groups within this family. These groups include a number of paralogous members generated by gene duplications that occurred as far back as the initial divergence of the crown-group of eukaryotes. Three of the four phylogenetic groups consist of enzymes that have group-specific biochemical specificity and/or sites of activity. An attempt has been made to uncover the role that natural selection played in the sequence and structural divergence between the phylogenetically and functionally distinct Endoplasmic Reticulum (ER) and Golgi apparatus groups. RESULTS: Comparison of site-specific amino acid variability profiles for the ER and Golgi groups revealed statistically significant evidence for functional diversification at the sequence level and indicated a number of residues that are most likely to have played a role in the functional divergence between the two groups. The majority of these sites appear to contain residues that have been fixed within one organelle-specific group by positive selection. Somewhat surprisingly these selected residues map to the periphery of the alpha-mannosidase catalytic domain tertiary structure. Changes in these peripherally located residues would not seem to have a gross effect on protein function. Thus diversifying selection between the two groups may have acted in a gradual manner consistent with the Darwinian model of natural selection. CONTACT: bishogr@millsaps.edu.     

Different adaptations of the same peptide motif for tRNA functional contacts by closely homologous tRNA synthetases

The N73 nucleotide at the end of the tRNA acceptor stem is commonly used by tRNA synthetases for discrimination. Because only a few synthetase-tRNA cocrystal structures have been determined, understanding of the molecular basis for N73 discrimination is limited. Here we investigated the possibility that, for at least some synthetases, the capacity to recognize different N73 nucleotides resides in the variable sequence of the loop of motif 2, a motif found in all class II enzymes. In the cocrystal of the class II yeast aspartyl-tRNA synthetase, atomic groups of the G73 discriminator of tRNAAsp interact with three side chains of the enzyme. We examined lysyl-tRNA synthetase, a close structural homologue of the aspartyl enzyme. Different substitutions were introduced into the Escherichia coli enzyme (A73 discriminator) to make its loop more like that of the human enzyme (G73 discriminator). Our data show that the loop of motif 2 of the lysine enzyme makes tRNA functional contacts, as predicted from the structural comparison. And yet, the E. coli enzyme with the "humanized" loop sequence had the same quantitative kinetic preference for A73 versus G as the wild-type enzyme. We conclude that discriminator base selectivity in the lysine enzyme requires residues in addition to or other than those in the loop of motif 2. Thus, even tRNA synthetases that are close structural homologues may use the same RNA binding element to make functional contacts with places (in the acceptor stem) that are idiosyncratic to each synthetase-tRNA pair.     

Catalytic activity of aminoacyl tRNA synthetases and its implications for the origin of life. I. Aminoacyl adenylate formation in tyrosyl tRNA synthetase

The changes in the catalytic activity resulting from amino acid substitutions in the active site region have been theoretically modeled for tyrosyl tRNA synthetase (Tyr-RS). The catalytic activity was calculated as the differential stabilization of the transition state using electrostatic approximation. The results indicate that charged residues His45, His48, Asp78, Asp176, Asp194, Lys225, Lys230, Lys233, Arg265, and Lys268 play essential roles in catalysis of aminoacyl adenylate formation in Tyr-RS, which is in general agreement with previously known experimental data for residues 45, 48, 194, 230, and 233. These catalytic residues have also been used to search for sequence homology patterns among class I aminoacyl RSs of which HIGH and KMSKS conserved sequence motifs are well known. His45 and His48 belong to the HIGH signature sequence of class I aminoacyl tRNA synthetases (aRSs), whereas Arg265 and Lys268 can constitute a part of the KMSKS charge pattern. Lys225, Lys230, and Lys233 may be part of the conservative substitution pattern [HKR]-X(4)-[HKR]-X(2)-[HKR], and Asp194 is part of the new GSDQ motif. This demonstrates that the three dimensional charge distribution near the active site is an essential feature of the catalytic activity of aRS and that the theoretical technique used in this work can be utilized in searches for the catalytically important residues that may provide a clue for a charge residue pattern conserved in evolution. The appearance of patterns I-IV in Arg-, Gln-, Met-, Ile-, Leu-, Trp-, Val-, Glu-, Cys-, and Tyr-RS indicates that all these enzymes could have the same ancestor.     

Nested Evolution of a tRNALeu(UAA) Group I Intron by both Horizontal Intron Transfer and Recombination of the Entire tRNA Locus

The origin and evolution of bacterial introns are still controversial issues. Here we present data on the distribution and evolution of a recently discovered divergent tRNA(Leu)(UAA) intron. The intron shows a higher sequence affiliation with introns in tRNA(Ile)(CAU) and tRNA(Arg)(CCU) genes in alpha- and beta-proteobacteria, respectively, than with other cyanobacterial tRNA(Leu)(UAA) group I introns. The divergent tRNA(Leu)(UAA) intron is sporadically distributed both within the Nostoc and the Microcystis radiations. The complete tRNA gene, including flanking regions and intron from Microcystis aeruginosa strain NIVA-CYA 57, was sequenced in order to elucidate the evolutionary pattern of this intron. Phylogenetic reconstruction gave statistical evidence for different phylogenies for the intron and exon sequences, supporting an evolutionary model involving horizontal intron transfer. The distribution of the tRNA gene, its flanking regions, and the introns were addressed by Southern hybridization and PCR amplification. The tRNA gene, including the flanking regions, were absent in the intronless stains but present in the intron-containing strains. This suggests that the sporadic distribution of this intron within the Microcystis genus cannot be attributed to intron mobility but rather to an instability of the entire tRNA(Leu)(UAA) intron-containing genome region. Taken together, the complete data set for the evolution of this intron can best be explained by a model involving a nested evolution of the intron, i.e., wherein the intron has been transferred horizontally (probably through a single or a few events) to a tRNA(Leu)(UAA) gene which is located within a unstable genome region.     

Molecular and functional evolution of class I chitinases for plant carnivory in the caryophyllales

Proteins produced by the large and diverse chitinase gene family are involved in the hydrolyzation of glycosidic bonds in chitin, a polymer of N-acetylglucosamines. In flowering plants, class I chitinases are important pathogenesis-related proteins, functioning in the determent of herbivory and pathogen attack by acting on insect exoskeletons and fungal cell walls. Within the carnivorous plants, two subclasses of class I chitinases have been identified to play a role in the digestion of prey. Members of these two subclasses, depending on the presence or absence of a C-terminal extension, can be secreted from specialized digestive glands found within the morphologically diverse traps that develop from carnivorous plant leaves. The degree of homology among carnivorous plant class I chitinases and the method by which these enzymes have been adapted for the carnivorous habit has yet to be elucidated. This study focuses on understanding the evolution of carnivory and chitinase genes in one of the major groups of plants that has evolved the carnivorous habit: the Caryophyllales. We recover novel class I chitinase homologs from species of genera Ancistrocladus, Dionaea, Drosera, Nepenthes, and Triphyophyllum, while also confirming the presence of two subclasses of class I chitinases based upon sequence homology and phylogenetic affinity to class I chitinases available from sequenced angiosperm genomes. We further detect residues under positive selection and reveal substitutions specific to carnivorous plant class I chitinases. These substitutions may confer functional differences as indicated by protein structure homology modeling.     

Lengsin is a survivor of an ancient family of class I glutamine synthetases re-engineered by evolution for a role in the vertebrate lens

Lengsin is a major protein of the vertebrate eye lens. It belongs to the hitherto purely prokaryotic GS I branch of the glutamine synthetase (GS) superfamily, but has no enzyme activity. Like the taxon-specific crystallins, Lengsin is the result of the recruitment of an ancient enzyme to a noncatalytic role in the vertebrate lens. Cryo-EM and modeling studies of Lengsin show a dodecamer structure with important similarities and differences with prokaryotic GS I structures. GS homology regions of Lengsin are well conserved, but the N-terminal domain shows evidence of dynamic evolutionary changes. Compared with birds and fish, most mammals have an additional exon corresponding to part of the N-terminal domain; however, in human, this is a nonfunctional pseudoexon. Genes related to Lengsin are also present in the sea urchin, suggesting that this branch of the GS I family, supplanted by GS II enzymes in vertebrates, has an ancient role in metazoans.     

Origin and evolution of group I introns in cyanobacterial tRNA genes.

Many tRNA(Leu)UAA genes from plastids contain a group I intron. An intron is also inserted in the same gene at the same position in cyanobacteria, the bacterial progenitors of plastids, suggesting an ancient bacterial origin for this intron. A group I intron has also been found in the tRNA(fMet) gene of some cyanobacteria but not in plastids, suggesting a more recent origin for this intron. In this study, we investigate the phylogenetic distributions of the two introns among cyanobacteria, from the earliest branching to the more derived species. The phylogenetic distribution of the tRNA(Leu)UAA intron follows the clustering of rRNA sequences, being either absent or present in clades of closely related species, with only one exception in the Pseudanabaena group. Our data support the notion that the tRNA(Leu)UAA intron was inherited by cyanobacteria and plastids through a common ancestor. Conversely, the tRNA(fMet) intron has a sporadic distribution, implying that many gains and losses occurred during cyanobacterial evolution. Interestingly, a phylogenetic tree inferred from intronic sequences clearly separates the different tRNA introns, suggesting that each family has its own evolutionary history.     

Development of tRNA synthetases and connection to genetic code and disease

The genetic code is established by the aminoacylation reactions of aminoacyl tRNA synthetases, where amino acids are matched with triplet anticodons imbedded in the cognate tRNAs. The code established in this way is so robust that it gave birth to the entire tree of life. The tRNA synthetases are organized into two classes, based on their active site architectures. The details of this organization, and other considerations, suggest how the synthetases evolved by gene duplications, and how early proteins may have been statistical in nature, that is, products of a primitive code where one of several similar amino acids was used at a specific position in a polypeptide. The emergence of polypeptides with unique, defined sequences--true chemical entities--required extraordinary specificity of the aminoacylation reaction. This high specificity was achieved by editing activities that clear errors of aminoacylation and thereby prevent mistranslation. Defects in editing activities can be lethal and lead to pathologies in mammalian cells in culture. Even a mild defect in editing is casually associated with neurological disease in the mouse. Defects in editing are also mutagenic in an aging organism and suggest how mistranslation can lead to mutations that are fixed in the genome. Thus, clearance of mischarged tRNAs by the editing activities of tRNA synthetases was essential for development of the tree of life and has a role in the etiology of diseases that is just now being understood.     

Divergence in noncognate amino acid recognition between class I and class II lysyl-tRNA synthetases

Lysine insertion during coded protein synthesis requires lysyl-tRNA(Lys), which is synthesized by lysyl-tRNA synthetase (LysRS). Two unrelated forms of LysRS are known: LysRS2, which is found in eukaryotes, most bacteria, and a few archaea, and LysRS1, which is found in most archaea and a few bacteria. To compare amino acid recognition between the two forms of LysRS, the effects of l-lysine analogues on aminoacylation were investigated. Both enzymes showed stereospecificity toward the l-enantiomer of lysine and discriminated against noncognate amino acids with different R-groups (arginine, ornithine). Lysine analogues containing substitutions at other positions were generally most effective as inhibitors of LysRS2. For example, the K(i) values for aminoacylation of S-(2-aminoethyl)-l-cysteine and l-lysinamide were over 180-fold lower with LysRS2 than with LysRS1. Of the other analogues tested, only gamma-aminobutyric acid showed a significantly higher K(i) for LysRS2 than LysRS1. These data indicate that the lysine-binding site is more open in LysRS2 than in LysRS1, in agreement with previous structural studies. The physiological significance of divergent amino acid recognition was reflected by the in vivo resistance to growth inhibition imparted by LysRS1 against S-(2-aminoethyl)-l-cysteine and LysRS2 against gamma-aminobutyric acid. These differences in resistance to naturally occurring noncognate amino acids suggest the distribution of LysRS1 and LysRS2 contributes to quality control during protein synthesis. In addition, the specific inhibition of LysRS1 indicates it is a potential drug target.     

On the evolution of structure in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases.

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are one of the major protein components in the translation machinery. These essential proteins are found in all forms of life and are responsible for charging their cognate tRNAs with the correct amino acid. The evolution of the tRNA synthetases is of fundamental importance with respect to the nature of the biological cell and the transition from an RNA world to the modern world dominated by protein-enzymes. We present a structure-based phylogeny of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. By using structural alignments of all of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases of known structure in combination with a new measure of structural homology, we have reconstructed the evolutionary history of these proteins. In order to derive unbiased statistics from the structural alignments, we introduce a multidimensional QR factorization which produces a nonredundant set of structures. Since protein structure is more highly conserved than protein sequence, this study has allowed us to glimpse the evolution of protein structure that predates the root of the universal phylogenetic tree. The extensive sequence-based phylogenetic analysis of the tRNA synthetases (Woese et al., Microbiol. Mol. Biol. Rev. 64:202-236, 2000) has further enabled us to reconstruct the complete evolutionary profile of these proteins and to make connections between major evolutionary events and the resulting changes in protein shape. We also discuss the effect of functional specificity on protein shape over the complex evolutionary course of the tRNA synthetases.