Long-lived bone marrow plasma cells are induced early in response to T cell-independent or T cell-dependent antigens

The signals required to generate long-lived plasma cells remain unresolved. One widely cited model posits that long-lived plasma cells derive from germinal centers (GCs) in response to T cell-dependent (TD) Ags. Thus, T cell-independent (TI) Ags, which fail to sustain GCs, are considered ineffective at generating long-lived plasma cells. However, we show that long-lived hapten-specific plasma cells are readily induced without formation of GCs. Long-lived plasma cells developed in T cell-deficient mice after a single immunization with haptenated LPS, a widely used TI Ag. Long-lived plasma cells also formed in response to TD Ag when the GC response was experimentally prevented. These observations establish that long-lived plasma cells are induced in both TI and TD responses, and can arise independently of B cell maturation in GCs.     

Two stages of b cell memory development expressing differential sensitivity to stimulation with thymus-dependent and thymus-independent antigenic forms

We have shown that spleen cells specifically primed to the decapeptide determinant (a.a. 103-112) of the thymus-dependent (TD) antigen, tobacco mosaic virus protein (TMVP), can be secondarily stimulated to antibody synthesis by either TD or TI forms of the decapeptide. Further, TD- and TI-responsive memory B cells consisted of overlapping populations which were indistinguishable by the specificity and isotype composition of the antibodies which they synthesized. In the present study, two functionally distinct but developmentally related memory B cell subsets were identified by their differential sensitivity to repeated in vivo stimulation with various combinations of TD and TI decapeptide antigens. One subset of memory B cells responded only to TMVP or decapeptide conjugated to succinylated human gamma-globulin (SHGG) with a strict requirement for carrier-primed theta-positive cells. Secondary challenge with these two TD antigens elicited antidecapeptide antibodies and specific memory regeneration. This TD-responsive memory B cell subset contained the precursors of a second memory B cell subset which was activated by decapeptide-Brucella abortus (TI.1 prototype), as well as by TMVP or decapeptide-SHGG. Stimulation of the second memory B cell subpopulation by decapeptide-BA (previously shown not to be dependent on conventional T cell help) was typified by differentiation into antibody-forming cells without significant memory regeneration.     

Cutting edge: germinal centers can be induced in the absence of T cells.

Immunization of mice containing mutations that inactivate the TCR Cbeta and Cdelta genes with the T cell-independent (TI) type 2 Ag (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl-Ficoll induces clusters of peanut agglutinin-binding B cells in the spleen. These clusters are histologically indistinguishable from germinal centers (GCs) typical of T cell-dependent immune responses. They are located in follicles, and contain mature follicular dendritic cells, immune complex deposits, and B cells that display the phenotypic qualities of conventional GC B cells. However, the kinetics of this TI GC response differ from T cell-dependent GC responses in being rapidly induced and of short duration. Moreover, the Ab V genes expressed in TI GCs have not undergone somatic hypermutation. Therefore, T cells may be required for B cell differentiation processes associated with the intermediate and latter stages of the GC reaction, but they are dispensable for the induction and initial development of this response.     

Functional heterogeneity of memory B lymphocytes: in vivo analysis of TD-primed B cells responsive to secondary stimulation with TD and TI antigens

The functional heterogeneity of memory B cells induced by a single determinant, consisting of a decapeptide representing amino acid residues 103-112 of tobacco mosaic virus protein (TMVP), was analyzed. Decapeptide specific antibodies were elicited in mice adoptively transferred with TMVP-immune spleen cells when challenged with TMVP, decapeptide conjugated to succinylated human gamma-globulin (SHGG), or decapeptide conjugated to Brucella abortus (BA). Whereas secondary stimulation by either TMVP or decapeptide-SHGG was dependent on appropriately primed T cells, stimulation by decapeptide-BA was independent of conventional T cell help. Furthermore, memory B cells responsive to TMVP (TD), decapeptide-SHGG (TD), or decapeptide-BA (TI. 1 prototype) were shown to consist of overlapping populations because adoptive recipients of TMVP-primed cells challenged simultaneously with TD and TI decapeptide antigens did not result in a higher antibody response than that elicited by one of the TD antigens injected alone. However, decapeptide-BA consistently induced a smaller antidecapeptide response than either TMVP or decapeptide-SHGG. This suggested that only a fraction of the memory B cell population which was activated by the original priming antigen (thymus-dependent) was also responsive to secondary in vivo stimulation by the priming hapten conjugated to Brucella abortus. Detailed analyses of the antibodies induced in the recipients of TMVP-immune spleen cells after secondary challenge with either TMVP, decapeptide-SHGG, or decapeptide-BA failed to distinguish between the responsive memory B cells; the antidecapeptide antibodies induced by all three immunogens shared the same fine specificities and immunoglobulin isotype composition. These data are viewed as further evidence that subsets of TD-primed B cells, which may display differential sensitivity to cross-stimulation with TD and TI forms of the antigen, represent distinct stages of memory B cell maturation within a common B cell lineage. In support of this conclusion, we establish a developmental relationship between TI and/or TD responsive decapeptide memory B cell in the following communication.     

Sonic hedgehog is produced by follicular dendritic cells and protects germinal center B cells from apoptosis

The Hedgehog (Hh) signaling pathway is involved in the development of many tissues during embryogenesis, but has also been described to function in adult self-renewing tissues. In the immune system, Sonic Hedgehog (Shh) regulates intrathymic T cell development and modulates the effector functions of peripheral CD4(+) T cells. In this study we investigate whether Shh signaling is involved in peripheral B cell differentiation in mice. Shh is produced by follicular dendritic cells, mainly in germinal centers (GCs), and GC B cells express both components of the Hh receptor, Patched and Smoothened. Blockade of the Hh signaling pathway reduces the survival, and consequently the proliferation and Ab secretion, of GC B cells. Furthermore, Shh rescues GC B cells from apoptosis induced by Fas ligation. Taken together, our data suggest that Shh is one of the survival signals provided by follicular dendritic cells to prevent apoptosis in GC B cells.     

Evolution in miniature: selection, survival and distribution of antigen reactive cells in the germinal centre

Productive immune responses to T-cell-dependent antigens ultimately generate two long-lived compartments: memory B cells and bone marrow-resident plasma cells, which both arise from within germinal centres. The ability of a B-cell clone to populate these effector compartments requires its descendents to outcompete those of other clones participating in the response. Selection occurs at several stages of the response and the criteria differ at these different stages. While affinity predominates as the key, underlying driving force of selection, there is a distinction made at the point at which germinal centre cells initiate entry into the plasma cell and memory B-cell compartments. Becoming a plasma cell requires high affinity and cannot be subverted by blocking cell death, while becoming a memory B cell is dependent on survival alone. While such survival is typically mediated by affinity within the GC, the distinction has important mechanistic implications.     

Distinct subpopulations of IgG memory B cells respond to different molecular forms of the same hapten.

Spleen cells from mice primed with the thymus-dependent antigen trinitrophenyl keyhold limpet hemocyanin several months earlier can be cultured in vitro to give vigorous IgG antihapten PFC responses to thymus-dependent (TD) and thymus-independent (TI) forms of the same hapten. Here we show that the IgG memory precursors that respond to these two forms of the hapten constitute functionally distinct subpopulations. We have designated these subpopulations as B1gamma and B2gamma to represent secondary precursor cells responding to TI and TD antigens, respectively. Three types of evidence for these subpopulations are presented: 1) In vitro secondary IgG responses to TD and TI forms of the TNP hapten are additive when both forms are added to the same culture. 2) The precursor frequencies for the TD and TI antigens are additive, but addition is not observed between two TD or two TI antigens. 3) Each population can be selectively eliminated by BUdR and light treatment without affecting the other population. The ontogenetic relationships between these subpopulations are discussed in relation to all presently proposed subpopulations B1mu, B2mu, B1gamma, and B2gamma.     

Molecular programming of B cell memory

The development of high-affinity B cell memory is regulated through three separable phases, each involving antigen recognition by specific B cells and cognate T helper cells. Initially, antigen-primed B cells require cognate T cell help to gain entry into the germinal centre pathway to memory. Once in the germinal centre, B cells with variant B cell receptors must access antigens and present them to germinal centre T helper cells to enter long-lived memory B cell compartments. Following antigen recall, memory B cells require T cell help to proliferate and differentiate into plasma cells. A recent surge of information - resulting from dynamic B cell imaging in vivo and the elucidation of T follicular helper cell programmes - has reshaped the conceptual landscape surrounding the generation of memory B cells. In this Review, we integrate this new information about each phase of antigen-specific B cell development to describe the newly unravelled molecular dynamics of memory B cell programming.     

Silent development of memory progenitor B cells

T cell-dependent immune responses generate long-lived plasma cells and memory B cells, both of which express hypermutated Ab genes. The relationship between these cell types is not entirely understood. Both appear to emanate from the germinal center reaction, but it is unclear whether memory cells evolve while obligatorily generating plasma cells by siblings under all circumstances. In the experiments we report, plasma cell development was functionally segregated from memory cell development by a series of closely spaced injections of Ag delivered during the period of germinal center development. The injection series elevated serum Ab of low affinity, supporting the idea that a strong Ag signal drives plasma cell development. At the same time, the injection series produced a distinct population of affinity/specificity matured memory B cells that were functionally silent, as manifested by an absence of corresponding serum Ab. These cells could be driven by a final booster injection to develop into Ab-forming cells. This recall response required that a rest period precede the final booster injection, but a pause of only 4 days was sufficient. Our results support a model of memory B cell development in which extensive affinity/specificity maturation can take place within a B cell clone under some circumstances in which a concomitant generation of Ab-forming cells by siblings does not take place.     

Pulmonary infection with influenza A virus induces site-specific germinal center and T follicular helper cell responses

Protection from influenza A virus (IAV) challenge requires switched, high affinity Abs derived from long-lived memory B cells and plasma cells. These B cell subsets are generated in germinal centers (GCs), hallmark structures of T helper cell-driven B cell immunity. A full understanding of the GC reaction after respiratory IAV infection is lacking, as is the characterization of T follicular helper (T(FH)) cells that support GCs. Here, GC B cell and T(FH) cell responses were studied in mice following pulmonary challenge with IAV. Marked GC reactions were induced in draining lymph nodes (dLNs), lung, spleen and nasal-associated lymphoid tissue (NALT), although the magnitude and kinetics of the response was site-specific. Examination of switching within GCs demonstrated IgG2(+) cells to compose the largest fraction in dLNs, lung and spleen. IgA(+) GC B cells were infrequent in these sites, but composed a significant subset of the switched GC population in NALT. Further experiments demonstrated splenectomized mice to withstand a lethal recall challenge, suggesting the spleen to be unnecessary for long-term protection in spite of strong GC responses in this organ. Final studies showed that T(FH) cell numbers were highest in dLNs and spleen, and peaked in all sites prior to the height of the GC reaction. T(FH) cells purified from dLNs generated IL-21 and IFNγ upon activation, although CD4(+)CXCR5(-) T effector cells produced higher levels of all cytokines. Collectively, these findings reveal respiratory IAV infection to induce strong T helper cell-driven B cell responses in various organs, with each site displaying unique attributes.     

Role of MHC class II on memory B cells in post-germinal center B cell homeostasis and memory response

We investigated the role of B cell Ag presentation in homeostasis of the memory B cell compartment in a mouse model where a conditional allele for the beta-chain of MHC class II (MHC-II) is deleted in the vast majority of all B cells by cd19 promoter-mediated expression of Cre recombinase (IA-B mice). Upon T cell-dependent immunization, a small number of MHC-II(+) B cells in IA-B mice dramatically expanded and restored normal albeit delayed levels of germinal center (GC) B cells with an affinity-enhancing somatic mutation to Ag. IA-B mice also established normal levels of MHC-II(+) memory B cells, which, however, subsequently lost MHC-II expression by ongoing deletion of the conditional iab allele without significant loss in their number. Furthermore, in vivo Ag restimulation of MHC-II(-) memory B cells of IA-B mice failed to cause differentiation into plasma cells (PCs), even in the presence of Ag-specific CD4(+) T cells. In addition, both numbers and Ag-specific affinity of long-lived PCs during the late post-GC phase, as well as post-GC serum affinity maturation, were significantly reduced in IA-B mice. These results support a notion that MHC-II-dependent T cell help during post-GC phase is not absolutely required for the maintenance of memory B cell frequency but is important for their differentiation into PCs and for the establishment of the long-lived PC compartment.     

Fyn Kinase Is Required for Optimal Humoral Responses

The generation of antigen-specific antibodies and the development of immunological memory require collaboration between B and T cells. T cell-secreted IL-4 is important for B cell survival, isotype switch to IgG1 and IgE, affinity maturation, and the development of germinal centers (GC). Fyn, a member of the Src family tyrosine kinase, is widely expressed in many cell types, including lymphocytes. This kinase is known to interact with both the B cell and T cell receptor (BCR and TCR, respectively). While Fyn deletion does not impair the development of immature T cells and B cells, TCR signaling is altered in mature T cells. The current study demonstrates that Fyn deficient (KO) B cells have impaired IL-4 signaling. Fyn KO mice displayed low basal levels of IgG1, IgE and IgG2c, and delayed antigen-specific IgG1 and IgG2b production, with a dramatic decrease in antigen-specific IgG2c following immunization with a T-dependent antigen. Defects in antibody production correlated with significantly reduced numbers of GC B cells, follicular T helper cells (T_FH), and splenic plasma cells (PC). Taken together, our data demonstrate that Fyn kinase is required for optimal humoral responses.     

Effect of recent antigen exposure on the functional expression of B cell subpopulations

We investigated whether the definition of functional B cell subpopulations changes after the exposure of B cells to specific antigen. Recent in vivo priming with fluorescein- (FL) coupled T-independent (TI) antigens leads to an augmentation of the subsequent in vitro responses of B cells to FL-coupled TI antigens, including FL-polymerized flagellin, FL-lipopolysaccharide, and FL-Brucella abortus, as well as a FL-coupled T-dependent (TD) antigen, FL-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH). This effect, which is evident 7 days after priming, is of short duration in that B cells from FL-Ficoll injected mice display normal responsiveness 3 wk after priming. When mice are primed with FL-KLH, the TD antigen, B cells responsive to a subsequent FL-KLH challenge are expanded, but not short-term cross-priming for any of the TI antigen challenges is observed. Limiting dilution precursor analysis shows that B cell populations responding to different FL-coupled TD and TI antigens overlap in unimmunized animals. FL-TI antigen priming induces not only quantitative changes in the responding B cells (increased precursor frequencies) but also results in functional changes in FL-specific B cells. The primed B cells now respond to FL-hapten in a carrier-restricted manner and behave as independent (non-overlapping) subpopulations. We suggest that B cell responses to different forms of the same hapten are influenced in part by their recent "history" of antigenic exposure.     

Immunopotentiation by SGP and Quil A. II. Identification of responding cell populations

The adjuvants SGP (a starch-acrylamide polymer) and Quil A (purified saponin) were shown to markedly augment antibody responses to T-independent (TI) antigens, suggesting that their adjuvant effects may be at least partially mediated through B cells. The ability of both adjuvants to augment primary responses to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-Ficoll (TI-2 antigen) in athymic nude mice further suggested these adjuvants affect B cells. SGP, however, did not induce a response to the T-dependent (TD) antigen dinitrophenyl-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (DNP-KLH) in athymic nude mice, indicating it was unable to replace the requirement for T-helper cells for responses to TD antigens. Responses to TNP-lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were augmented by SGP in CBA/N X Balb/c immune defective (xid) mice. However, SGP was unable to induce a response to TNP-Ficoll in xid mice. The SGP and Quil A augmented responses to TNP-Ficoll were completely inhibited by the mitotic inhibitor, Velban, indicating that SGP and Quil A increased the plaque-forming cell (PFC) response primarily by stimulating cell proliferation, and not by recruitment of antigen-reactive cells. The effects of the adjuvants on secondary responses were investigated using adoptive transfer experiments. SGP and A1(OH)3 both increased the induction of hapten-specific memory B cells in mice primed with DNP-KLH. SGP, Quil A, and A1(OH)3 also increased priming of carrier specific T cells. Priming of memory B cells with DNP-KLH and either A1(OH)3 or SGP was prevented when T cells were depleted with anti-lymphocyte serum (ALS) at the time of antigen priming, indicating that the augmentation of memory B-cell priming by SGP and A1(OH)3 was dependent on the presence of functional T cells. SGP and Quil A were both unable to augment memory cell induction to the TI antigen, TNP-Ficoll, even though both adjuvants markedly augmented primary IgM and IgG responses to this antigen. Based on these results, it is suggested that SGP and Quil A can mediate their adjuvant effects primarily by a direct or indirect effect on B cells although the adjuvants may also affect T cells to some extent.     

Single and coexpression of CXCR4 and CXCR5 identifies CD4 T helper cells in distinct lymph node niches during influenza virus infection

Influenza virus infection results in strong, mainly T-dependent, extrafollicular and germinal center B cell responses, which provide lifelong humoral immunity against the homotypic virus strain. Follicular T helper cells (T(FH)) are key regulators of humoral immunity. Questions remain regarding the presence, identity, and function of T(FH) subsets regulating early extrafollicular and later germinal center B cell responses. This study demonstrates that ICOS but not CXCR5 marks T cells with B helper activity induced by influenza virus infection and identifies germinal center T cells (T(GC)) as lymph node-resident CD4(+) ICOS(+) CXCR4(+) CXCR5(+) PSGL-1(lo) PD-1(hi) cells. The CXCR4 expression intensity further distinguished their germinal center light and dark zone locations. This population emerged strongly in regional lymph nodes and with kinetics similar to those of germinal center B cells and were the only T(FH) subsets missing in influenza virus-infected, germinal center-deficient SAP(-/-) mice, mice which were shown previously to lack protective memory responses after a secondary influenza virus challenge, thus indicting the nonredundant functions of CXCR4- and CXCR5-coexpressing CD4 helper cells in antiviral B cell immunity. CXCR4-single-positive T cells, present in B cell-mediated autoimmunity and regarded as "extrafollicular" helper T cells, were rare throughout the response, despite prominent extrafollicular B cell responses, revealing fundamental differences in autoimmune- and infection-induced T-dependent B cell responses. While all ICOS(+) subsets induced similar antibody levels in vitro, CXCR5-single-positive T cells were superior in inducing B cell proliferation. The regulation of T cell localization, marked by the single and coexpression of CXCR4 and CXCR5, might be an important determinant of T(FH) function.     

Phylogeny of lymphocyte heterogeneity: the cellular requirements for in vitro antibody responses of channel catfish leukocytes

Three functionally distinct leukocyte subpopulations were isolated from the peripheral blood of channel catfish. Surface immunoglobulin-positive (sIg+) and sIg- lymphocytes were isolated by an indirect "planning" procedure employing monoclonal antibodies specific for channel catfish Ig. A third population composed of macrophages was isolated by adherence to baby hamster kidney cell microexudate-coated surfaces. Functional features of these three cell types were established by assessing their role(s) in primary in vitro anti-hapten PFC responses to known murine thymus-dependent (TD) and thymus-independent (TI) antigens. The results indicated that anti-hapten PFC responses to a TI antigen required the presence of sIg+ lymphocytes and macrophages. In contrast, all three cell types were required for responses to TD antigens. Furthermore, the results of studies involving the depletion of antigen-reactive lymphocytes demonstrated that both hapten-specific sIg+ cells and carrier-specific sIg- cells were required for anti-hapten responses to TD antigens. These studies provide direct evidence that catfish have separable B cells (sIg+ lymphocytes), T helper cells (sIg- lymphocytes), and accessory cells (macrophages) quite similar to those seen in higher animals.     

Reduced Number of Transitional and Naive B Cells in Addition to Decreased BAFF Levels in Response to the T Cell Independent Immunogen Pneumovax?23

Protective immunity against T cell independent (TI) antigens such as Streptococcus pneumoniae is characterized by antibody production of B cells induced by the combined activation of T cell independent type 1 and type 2 antigens in the absence of direct T cell help. In mice, the main players in TI immune responses have been well defined as marginal zone (MZ) B cells and B-1 cells. However, the existence of human equivalents to these B cell subsets and the nature of the human B cell compartment involved in the immune reaction remain elusive. We therefore analyzed the effect of a TI antigen on the B cell compartment through immunization of healthy individuals with the pneumococcal polysaccharide (PnPS)-based vaccine Pneumovax^®23, and subsequent characterization of B cell subpopulations. Our data demonstrates a transient decrease of transitional and naïve B cells, with a concomitant increase of IgA⁺ but not IgM⁺ or IgG⁺ memory B cells and a predominant generation of PnPS-specific IgA⁺ producing plasma cells. No alterations could be detected in T cells, or proposed human B-1 and MZ B cell equivalents. Consistent with the idea of a TI immune response, antigen-specific memory responses could not be observed. Finally, BAFF, which is supposed to drive class switching to IgA, was unexpectedly found to be decreased in serum in response to Pneumovax^®23. Our results demonstrate that a characteristic TI response induced by Pneumovax^®23 is associated with distinct phenotypical and functional changes within the B cell compartment. Those modulations occur in the absence of any modulations of T cells and without the development of a specific memory response.     

Foxp3+ follicular regulatory T cells control the germinal center response

Follicular helper (T(FH)) cells provide crucial signals to germinal center B cells undergoing somatic hypermutation and selection that results in affinity maturation. Tight control of T(FH) numbers maintains self tolerance. We describe a population of Foxp3(+)Blimp-1(+)CD4(+) T cells constituting 10-25% of the CXCR5(high)PD-1(high)CD4(+) T cells found in the germinal center after immunization with protein antigens. These follicular regulatory T (T(FR)) cells share phenotypic characteristics with T(FH) and conventional Foxp3(+) regulatory T (T(reg)) cells yet are distinct from both. Similar to T(FH) cells, T(FR) cell development depends on Bcl-6, SLAM-associated protein (SAP), CD28 and B cells; however, T(FR) cells originate from thymic-derived Foxp3(+) precursors, not naive or T(FH) cells. T(FR) cells are suppressive in vitro and limit T(FH) cell and germinal center B cell numbers in vivo. In the absence of T(FR) cells, an outgrowth of non-antigen-specific B cells in germinal centers leads to fewer antigen-specific cells. Thus, the T(FH) differentiation pathway is co-opted by T(reg) cells to control the germinal center response.