The spatially variable inhibition by water deficit of maize root growth correlates with altered profiles of proton flux and cell wall pH

Growth of elongating primary roots of maize (Zea mays) seedlings was approximately 50% inhibited after 48 h in aerated nutrient solution under water deficit induced by polyethylene glycol 6000 at -0.5 MPa water potential. Proton flux along the root elongation zone was assayed by high resolution analyses of images of acid diffusion around roots contacted for 5 min with pH indicator gel. Profiles of root segmental elongation correlated qualitatively and quantitatively (r(2) = 0.74) with proton flux along the surface of the elongation zone from water-deficit and control treatments. Proton flux and segmental elongation in roots under water deficit were remarkably well maintained in the region 0 to 3 mm behind the root tip and were inhibited from 3 to 10 mm behind the tip. Associated changes in apoplastic pH inside epidermal cell walls were measured in three defined regions along the root elongation zone by confocal laser scanning microscopy using a ratiometric method. Finally, external acidification of roots was shown to specifically induce a partial reversal of growth inhibition by water deficit in the central region of the elongation zone. These new findings, plus evidence in the literature concerning increases induced by acid pH in wall-extensibility parameters, lead us to propose that the apparently adaptive maintenance of growth 0 to 3 mm behind the tip in maize primary roots under water deficit and the associated inhibition of growth further behind the tip are related to spatially variable changes in proton pumping into expanding cell walls.     

Cell wall proteome in the maize primary root elongation zone. II. Region-specific changes in water soluble and lightly ionically bound proteins under water deficit

Previous work on the adaptation of maize (Zea mays) primary roots to water deficit showed that cell elongation is maintained preferentially toward the apex, and that this response involves modification of cell wall extension properties. To gain a comprehensive understanding of how cell wall protein (CWP) composition changes in association with the differential growth responses to water deficit in different regions of the elongation zone, a proteomics approach was used to examine water soluble and loosely ionically bound CWPs. The results revealed major and predominantly region-specific changes in protein profiles between well-watered and water-stressed roots. In total, 152 water deficit-responsive proteins were identified and categorized into five groups based on their potential function in the cell wall: reactive oxygen species (ROS) metabolism, defense and detoxification, hydrolases, carbohydrate metabolism, and other/unknown. The results indicate that stress-induced changes in CWPs involve multiple processes that are likely to regulate the response of cell elongation. In particular, the changes in protein abundance related to ROS metabolism predicted an increase in apoplastic ROS production in the apical region of the elongation zone of water-stressed roots. This was verified by quantification of hydrogen peroxide content in extracted apoplastic fluid and by in situ imaging of apoplastic ROS levels. This response could contribute directly to the enhancement of wall loosening in this region. This large-scale proteomic analysis provides novel insights into the complexity of mechanisms that regulate root growth under water deficit conditions and highlights the spatial differences in CWP composition in the root elongation zone.     

Maize lateral root developmental plasticity induced by mild water stress. II: Genotype-specific spatio-temporal effects on determinate development

Maize lateral roots exhibit determinate growth, whereby the meristem is genetically programmed to stop producing new cells. To explore whether lateral root determinacy is modified under water deficits, we studied two maize genotypes (B73 and FR697) with divergent responses of lateral root growth to mild water stress using an experimental system that provided near-stable water potential environments throughout lateral root development. First-order laterals of the primary root system of FR697 exhibited delayed determinacy when grown at a water potential of −0.28 MPa, resulting in longer and wider roots than in well-watered (WW) controls. In B73, in contrast, neither the length nor width of lateral roots was affected by water deficit. In water-stressed FR697, root elongation continued at or above the maximum rate in WW roots for 3 days longer, and was still 45% of maximum when WW roots approached their determinate length. Maintenance of root elongation was associated with sustained rates of cell production. In addition, kinematic analyses showed that reductions in tissue expansion rates with aging were delayed in the longitudinal, radial and tangential planes throughout the root growth zone. Thus, this study reveals large genotypic differences in the interaction of water stress with developmental determinacy of maize lateral roots.     

Differential expression profiles of growth-related genes in the elongation zone of maize primary roots

Growth in the apical elongation zone of plant roots is central to the development of functional root systems. Rates of root segmental elongation change from accelerating to decelerating as cell development proceeds from newly formed to fully elongated status. One of the primary variables regulating these changes in elongation rates is the extensibility of the elongating cell walls. To help decipher the complex molecular mechanisms involved in spatially variable root growth, we performed a gene identification study along primary root tips of maize (Zea mays) seedlings using suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) and candidate gene approaches. Using SSH we isolated 150 non-redundant cDNA clones representing root growth-related genes (RGGs) that were preferentially expressed in the elongation zone. Differential expression patterns were revealed by Northern blot analysis for 41 of the identified genes and several candidate genes. Many of the genes have not been previously reported to be involved in root growth processes in maize. Genes were classified into groups based on the predicted function of the encoded proteins: cell wall metabolism, cytoskeleton, general metabolism, signaling and unknown. In-situ hybridization performed for two selected genes, confirmed the spatial distribution of expression shown by Northern blots and revealed subtle differences in tissue localization. Interestingly, spatial profiles of expression for some cell wall related genes appeared to correlate with the profile of accelerating root elongation and changed appropriately under growth-inhibitory water deficit.     

Growth of the maize primary root at low water potentials : I. Spatial distribution of expansive growth

Seedlings of maize (Zea mays L. cv WF9 × Mo 17) were grown in vermiculite at various water potentials. The primary root continued slow rates of elongation at water potentials which completely inhibited shoot growth. To gain an increased understanding of the root growth response, we examined the spatial distribution of growth at various water potentials. Time lapse photography of the growth of marked roots revealed that inhibition of root elongation at low water potentials was not explained by a proportional decrease in growth along the length of the growing zone. Instead, longitudinal growth was insensitive to water potentials as low as − 1.6 megapascal close to the root apex, but was inhibited increasingly in more basal locations such that the length of the growing zone decreased progressively as the water potential decreased. Cessation of longitudinal growth occurred in tissue of approximately the same age regardless of spatial location or water status, however. Roots growing at low water potentials were also thinner, and analysis revealed that radial growth rates were decreased throughout the elongation zone, resulting in greatly decreased rates of volume expansion.     

Genetic variability of oxalate oxidase?activity and elongation in water-stressed primary roots of diverse maize and rice lines

A previous study of maize primary roots under water stress showed pronounced increases in oxalate oxidase activity and apoplastic hydrogen peroxide in the apical region of the growth zone where cell elongation is maintained. We examined whether increased oxalate oxidase activity in water-stressed roots is conserved across diverse lines of maize and rice. The maize lines exhibited varied patterns of activity, with some lines lacking activity in the apical region. Moreover, none of the rice lines showed activity in the apical region. Also, although the genotypic response of root elongation to water stress was variable in both maize and rice, this was not correlated with the pattern of oxalate oxidase activity. Implications of these findings for root growth regulation under water stress are discussed.     

Abscisic acid accumulation maintains maize primary root elongation at low water potentials by restricting ethylene production

Previous work showed that primary root elongation in maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings at low water potentials (psi(w)) requires the accumulation of abscisic acid (ABA) (R.E. Sharp, Y. Wu, G.S. Voetberg, I.N. Saab, M.E. LeNoble [1994] J Exp Bot 45: 1743-1751). The objective of the present study was to determine whether the inhibition of elongation in ABA-deficient roots is attributable to ethylene. At a psi(w) of -1.6 MPa, inhibition of root elongation in dark-grown seedlings treated with fluridone to impose ABA deficiency was largely prevented with two inhibitors of ethylene synthesis (aminooxyacetic acid and aminoethoxyvinylglycine) and one inhibitor of ethylene action (silver thiosulfate). The fluridone treatment caused an increase in the rate of ethylene evolution from intact seedlings. This effect was completely prevented with aminooxyacetic acid and also when ABA was supplied at a concentration that restored the ABA content of the root elongation zone and the root elongation rate. Consistent results were obtained when ABA deficiency was imposed using the vp5 mutant. Both fluridone-treated and vp5 roots exhibited additional morphological symptoms of excess ethylene. The results demonstrate that an important role of ABA accumulation in the maintenance of root elongation at low psi(w) is to restrict ethylene production.     

Expression of the mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase ZmMEK1 in the primary root of maize

We have analyzed changes in the distribution and abundance of a mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase (MAPKK) enzyme (EC 2.7.1.37) known as ZmMEK1. in root apices of Zea mays L. under normal growth conditions, and after treatments that alter patterns of proliferation, as a means to assess the potential physiological role of the MAP kinase cascade in growth and development. The ZmMEK1 protein is most abundant within immature tissues such as the roots and leaves of seedlings, and is nearly undetectable in mature leaf tissue. Along the longitudinal axis of growing roots, ZmMEK1 mRNA and protein are abundant throughout the apical 12 mm. Two anti-ZmMEK1 antibody-reactive proteins can be resolved within the apical 4 mm of the root, spatially coinciding with the meristem and distal elongation zone. Phosphatase treatments suggest that both immunoreactive bands are forms of ZmMEK1 that differ in their state of phosphorylation. Expression of ZmMEK1, histone H4 and cyclin-dependent protein kinase (CDK) in roots after 7 days of exposure to low temperature and during a 48-hour recovery period was monitored during the coincident alterations in growth. Levels of ZmMEK1 mRNA and protein within these roots were indistinguishable from those of control roots. However, a slower-migrating form of ZmMEK1 temporally coincided with the observed increase in CDK levels during the transition into proliferative activity. We demonstrate that the ZmMEK1 MAPK activator is expressed and is differentially phosphorylated within the root meristem and distal elongation zone. We suggest that post-translational modifications of the protein regulate the function of ZmMEK1 within the root. Changes in ZmMEK1 phosphorylation state correlate with changes in proliferation in the root apex.     

Growth of Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings under water deficit studied by control of water potential in nutrient-agar media

We have characterized the growth responses of Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings to water deficit. To manipulate the water potential, we developed a method whereby the nutrient-agar medium could be supplemented with polyethylene glycol (PEG 8000); PEG was introduced into gelled media by diffusion, which produced media with water potential as low as -1.6 MPa. For dark-grown plants, hypocotyl growth had a hyperbolic dependence on water potential, and was virtually stopped by -1 MPa. In contrast, primary root elongation was stimulated by moderate deficit and even at -1.6 MPa was not significantly less than the control. That these results did not depend on a direct effect of PEG was attested by obtaining indistinguishable results when a dialysis membrane impermeable to PEG was placed between the medium and the seedlings. For light-grown seedlings, moderate deficit also stimulated primary root elongation and severe deficit reduced elongation only partially. These changes in elongation were paralleled by changes in root system dry weight. At moderate deficit, lateral root elongation and initiation were unaffected and at higher stress levels both were inhibited. Primary root diameter increased steadily with time in well-watered controls and under water deficit increased transiently before stabilizing at a diameter that was inversely proportional to the deficit. Along with stimulated primary root elongation, moderate water deficit also stimulated the rate of cell production. Thus, A. thaliana responds to water deficit vigorously, which enhances its use as a model to uncover mechanisms underlying plant responses to water deficit.     

Inhibition of maize primary root elongation by spermidine: Effect on cell shape and mitotic index

Spermidine applied for 18 h to intact maize seedlings through their roots reduces root growth 70%, and the effect is reversible. Histological observations of longitudinal sections of 0.4-cm root apical segments from 2-day-old maize seedlings grown for 18 h in 0.5 m CaSO₄ solution with or without 1 mm spermidine contribute to the explanation of spermidine-dependent slow root growth. In the meristematic zone a strong reduction of the mitotic index and in the elongation zone an inhibition of cell elongation occur simultaneously. Cell shape analysis along the growth axis of the maize root apex expressed in terms of form factor (FCircle) values substantiates the dual effect of spermidine on mitotic activity and cell elongation.Abbreviations PA polyamine(s) - Spm spermine - Spd spermidine     

Growth maintenance of the maize primary root at low water potentials involves increases in cell-wall extension properties, expansin activity, and wall susceptibility to expansins

Previous work on the growth biophysics of maize (Zea mays L.) primary roots suggested that cell walls in the apical 5 mm of the elongation zone increased their yielding ability as an adaptive response to low turgor and water potential (psi w). To test this hypothesis more directly, we measured the acid-induced extension of isolated walls from roots grown at high (-0.03 MPa) or low (-1.6 MPa) psi w using an extensometer. Acid-induced extension was greatly increased in the apical 5 mm and was largely eliminated in the 5- to 10-mm region of roots grown at low psi w. This pattern is consistent with the maintenance of elongation toward the apex and the shortening of the elongation zone in these roots. Wall proteins extracted from the elongation zone possessed expansin activity, which increased substantially in roots grown at low psi w. Western blots likewise indicated higher expansin abundance in the roots at low psi w. Additionally, the susceptibility of walls to expansin action was higher in the apical 5 mm of roots at low psi w than in roots at high psi w. The basal region of the elongation zone (5-10 mm) did not extend in response to expansins, indicating that loss of susceptibility to expansins was associated with growth cessation in this region. Our results indicate that both the increase in expansin activity and the increase in cell-wall susceptibility to expansins play a role in enhancing cell-wall yielding and, therefore, in maintaining elongation in the apical region of maize primary roots at low psi w.     

Increased endogenous abscisic Acid maintains primary root growth and inhibits shoot growth of maize seedlings at low water potentials

Roots of maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings continue to grow at low water potentials that cause complete inhibition of shoot growth. In this study, we have investigated the role of abscisic acid (ABA) in this differential growth sensitivity by manipulating endogenous ABA levels as an alternative to external applications of the hormone. An inhibitor of carotenoid biosynthesis (fluridone) and a mutant deficient in carotenoid biosynthesis (vp 5) were used to reduce the endogenous ABA content in the growing zones of the primary root and shoot at low water potentials. Experiments were performed on 30 to 60 hour old seedlings that were transplanted into vermiculite which had been preadjusted to water potentials of approximately −1.6 megapascals (roots) or −0.3 megapascals (shoots). Growth occurred in the dark at near-saturation humidity. Results of experiments using the inhibitor and mutant approaches were very similar. Reduced ABA content by either method was associated with inhibition of root elongation and promotion of shoot elongation at low water potentials, compared to untreated and wild-type seedlings at the same water potential. Elongation rates and ABA contents at high water potential were little affected. The inhibition of shoot elongation at low water potential was completely prevented in fluridone-treated seedlings during the first five hours after transplanting. The results indicate that ABA accumulation plays direct roles in both the maintenance of primary root elongation and the inhibition of shoot elongation at low water potentials.     

Mitogen-activated protein kinase is involved in the symbiotic interaction betweenBradyrhizobium japonicum USDA110 and soybean

Mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) plays an important role in mediating the intracellular transmission and amplification of extracellular stimuli. We examined whether MAPK is involved in the signaling process during the early step of nodule formation. A genistein induced culture filtrate (GCF) ofBradyrhizobium japonicum was prepared for inducing an early response by soybean root hairs via Nod factor. Upon treatment, several types of deformations were seen, demonstrating that GCF contains active Nod factor molecules. In-gel kinase assays showed that treating soybean roots with GCF induced the rapid activation of two protein kinases (molecular masses of 47 kD and 44 kD), which phosphorylate myelin basic protein (MBP). To identify the activated kinase, we prepared an antibody againstGMK1 (Glycine max MAP kinase 1), based on information from SIMK (an alfalfa MAP kinase) and a soybean EST database. An immunocomplex kinase assay with the GMK1-specific antibody revealed that the 47-kD kinase in GCF-treated seedlings is indeed GMK1. Consistent with many other MAP kinases, GMK1 is likely to be under post-translational regulation. Considering these results and previous reports from soybean, GMK1 seems to be a signaling mediator with a broad range of stimuli, including a fungal elicitor, wounding, and the symbiotic interaction between soybean and B.japonicum.     

Correlation between Calmodulin Activity and Gravitropic Sensitivity in Primary Roots of Maize

Recent evidence indicates a role for calcium and calmodulin in the gravitropic response of primary roots of maize (Zea mays, L.). We examined this possibility by testing the relationship between calmodulin activity and gravitropic sensitivity in roots of the maize cultivars Merit and B73 × Missouri 17. Roots of the Merit cultivar require light to be gravitropically competent. The gravitropic response of the Missouri cultivar is independent of light. The occurrence of calmodulin in primary roots of these maize cultivars was tested by affinity gel chromatography followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis with bovine brain calmodulin as standard. The distribution of calmodulin activity was measured using both the phosphodiesterase and NAD kinase assays for calmodulin. These assays were performed on whole tissue segments, crude extracts, and purified extracts. In light-grown seedlings of the Merit cultivar or in either dark- or light-grown seedlings of the Missouri cultivar, calmodulin activity per millimeter of root tissue was about 4-fold higher in the apical millimeter than in the subtending 3 millimeters. Calmodulin activity was very low in the apical millimeter of roots of dark-grown (gravitropically nonresponsive) seedlings of the Merit cultivar. Upon illumination, the calmodulin activity in the apical millimeter increased to a level comparable to that of light-grown seedlings and the roots became gravitropically competent. The time course of the development of gravitropic sensitivity following illumination paralleled the time course of the increase in calmodulin activity in the apical millimeter of the root. The results are consistent with the suggestion that calmodulin plays an important role in the gravitropic response of roots.     

Electrophysiological responses of maize roots to low water potentials: relationship to growth and ABA accumulation

The maintenance of root elongation is an important adaptive response to low water potentials (psi(w)), but little is known about its regulation. An important component may be changes in root cell electrophysiology, which both signal and maintain growth maintenance processes. As a first test of this hypothesis, membrane potentials (E(m)) were measured within the cell elongation zone of maize (Zea mays L.) primary roots. Seedlings were grown in oxygenated solution culture, and low psi(w) was imposed by the gradual addition of polyethylene glycol. Cells hyperpolarized approximately 25 mV in response to low psi(w), and after 48 h resting potentials remained significantly hyperpolarized at psi(w) lower than -0.3 MPa compared with roots at high psi(w). Inhibitor experiments showed that the hyperpolarization was dependent on plasma membrane H(+)-ATPase activity. Previous work showed that accumulation of abscisic acid (ABA) is required for the maintenance of maize primary root elongation at low psi(w). To determine if the mechanism of action of ABA involves changes in root electrophysiology, E(m) measurements were made during long-term exposure to low psi(w). Steady-state resting E(m) were measured in regions in which maintenance of cell elongation was dependent on ABA accumulation (2-3 mm from the apex), or in which elongation was inhibited regardless of ABA status (6-8 mm from the apex). E(m) was substantially more negative in ABA-deficient roots specifically in the 2-3 mm region. The results suggest that set-points for ion homeostasis shifted in association with the maintenance of root cell elongation at low psi(w), and that ABA accumulation plays a role in regulating the ion transport processes involved in this response.     

Effects of low water potential on cortical cell length in growing regions of maize roots

Roots growing under low water potential commonly exhibit a marked decrease in growth rate and in diameter. Using median longitudinal sections of fixed maize (Zea mays L. cv WF9 × Mo 17) seedling roots, we investigated the cellular basis for these effects. Cortical cells in the shortened elongation zone of water stressed roots were longer than cortical cells in the comparable location of well-watered roots. Nearly twofold differences in cell length were seen in the region 2 to 4 millimeters behind the root apex. The shortened growth zone, however, leads to a final mean cortical cell length approximately 30% shorter in the stressed roots. These differences were present regardless of the age of the control roots. These data, and the slower growth rate seen in water-stressed roots, suggest that the water deficit causes a significant reduction in the rate of cell supply to the cortical cell files.