Dynamics-function correlation in Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase: a spectroscopic and molecular dynamics simulation study

A single mutation (Val29-->Gly) at the subunit interface of a Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase dimer leads to a twofold increase in the second order catalytic rate, when compared to the native enzyme, without causing any modification of the structure or the electric field distribution. To check the role of dynamic processes in this catalytic enhancement, the flexibility of the dimeric protein at the subunit interface region has been probed by the phosphorescence and fluorescence properties of the unique tryptophan residue. Multiple spectroscopic data indicate that Trp83 experiences a very similar, and relatively hydrophobic, environment in both wild-type and mutant protein, whereas its mobility is distinctly more restrained in the latter. Molecular dynamics simulation confirms this result, and provides, at the molecular level, details of the dynamic change felt by tryptophan. Moreover, the simulation shows that the loops surrounding the active site are more flexible in the mutant than in the native enzyme, making the copper more accessible to the incoming substrate, and being thus responsible for the catalytic rate enhancement. Evidence for increased, dynamic copper accessibility also comes from faster copper removal in the mutant by a metal chelator. These results indicate that differences in dynamic, rather than structural, features of the two enzymes are responsible for the observed functional change.     

Comparisons of copper deficiency states in the murine mutants blotchy and brindled. Changes in copper-dependent enzyme activity in 13-day-old mice.

The activity of two copper-dependent enzymes, cytochrome c oxidase and copper, zinc-superoxide dismutase, was determined in six tissues of age-matched (13-day-old) copper-deficient mutant and normal mice. In the two mutants 'brindled' and 'blotchy', brain, heart and skeletal muscle had significant enzyme deficiencies. Cytochrome c oxidase was more severely affected than was superoxide dismutase. In these three tissues the degree of deficiency could be correlated with decreased copper concentration; however, enzyme activity was normal in liver, kidney and lung, despite abnormal copper concentrations in these tissues. In nutritionally copper-deficient mice, all six tissues showed decreased enzyme activity, which was most marked in brain, heart and skeletal muscle, the tissues which showed enzyme deficiencies in the mutants. Analysis in vitro of cytochrome c oxidase (temperature coefficient = 2) at a single temperature was found to underestimate the deficiency of this enzyme in hypothermic copper-deficient animals. Cytochrome c oxidase deficiency may therefore be sufficiently severe in vivo to account for the clinical manifestations of copper deficiency. An injection of copper (50 micrograms of Cu+) at 7 days increased cytochrome c oxidase activity by 13 days in all deficient tissues of brindled mice, and in brain and heart from blotchy mice. However, skeletal-muscle cytochrome c oxidase in blotchy mutants did not respond to copper injection. Cytochrome c oxidase activity increased to normal in all tissues of nutritionally copper-deficient mice after copper injection, except in the liver. Hepatic enzyme activity remained severely deficient despite a liver copper concentration three times that found in copper-replete controls. Superoxide dismutase activity did not increase with treatment in either mutant, but its activity was higher than control levels in nutritionally deficient mice after injection. This difference is probably due to sequestration of copper in mutant tissue such as kidney, but a defect in the copper transport pathway to superoxide dismutase cannot be excluded.     

Effect of local environment and protein on the mechanism of action of superoxide dismutase

Quantum mechanical simulations of the mechanism of action of superoxide dismutase (SOD) indicate that the presence of Arg-141 in the active site of the enzyme is responsible for the formation of an intermediate complex between superoxide and the enzyme in which the copper is not reduced. The analysis of the local environmental effects of Arg-141 shows that this residue prevents the reduction of copper by forming a hydrogen bond to superoxide and by generating an electric field in the active site that opposes the transfer of an electron from superoxide to copper. The protein enhances the effect of the opposing field generated by Arg-141. Local changes in the environment of the copper ion, simulated by stretching the Cu-NE2 (His-61) bond also do not induce an electron transfer from superoxide to copper. The protein increases the energies required for this stretch through the electric field it generates near the active site. These results are further support for the new proposed mechanism of action of SOD which is based on the inability of superoxide to reduce the cupric ion in the enzyme.     

The utilization of copper and its role in the biosynthesis of copper-containing proteins in the fungus, Dactylium dendroides

Aspects of the utilization of copper by the fungus, Dactylium dendroides, have been studied. The organism grows normally at copper levels below 10 nM. Cells grown in medium containing 30 nM copper or less concentrate exogenous metal at all levels of added copper; copper uptake is essentially complete within 15 min and is not inhibited by cycloheximide, dinitrophenol or cyanide. These results indicate that copper absorption is not an energy-dependent process. The relationship between fungal copper status and the activities of three copper-containing enzymes, galactose oxidase, and extracellular enzyme, the cytosolic, Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase and cytochrome oxidase, has also been established. The synthesis of galactose oxidase protein (holoenzyme plus apo-enzyme) is independent of copper concentration. Cells grown in copper-free medium (less than 10 nM copper) excrete normal amounts of galactose oxidase as an apoprotein. At medium copper levels below 5 micrometer, new cultures contain enough total copper to enable the limited number of cells to attain sufficient intracellular copper to support hologalactose oxidase production. As a result of cell division, however, the amount of copper available per cell drops to a threshold of approx. 10 ng/mg below which point only apogalactose oxidase is secreted. Above 5 micrometer medium copper, holoenzyme secretion is maintained throughout cell growth. The levels of the Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase respond differently in that the protein itself apparently is synthesized in only limited amounts in copper-depleted cells. Total cellular superoxide dismutase activity is maintained under such conditions by an increase in activity associated with the mitochondrial, CN(-)-insensitive, manganese form of this enzyme. Cells grown at 10 micrometer copper show 83% of their superoxide dismutase activity to be contributed by the Cu/Zn form compared to a 17% contribution to the total activity in cells grown at 30 nM copper, indicating that the biosynthesis of the Cu/Zn and Mn-containing enzymes is coordinated. The data show that the level of copper modulates the synthesis of the cytosolic superoxide dismutase. In contrast, the cytochrome oxidase activity of D. dendroides is independent of cellular copper levels obtainable. Thus, the data also suggest that these three enzymes utilize different cellular copper pools. As cells are depleted of copper by cell division, the available copper is used to maintain Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase and cytochrome oxidase activity; at very low levels of copper, only the latter activity is maintained. The induction of the manganisuperoxide dismutase in copper-depleted cells should have practical value in the isolation of this protein.     

Biosynthesis and Cellular Distribution of the Two Superoxide Dismutases of Dactylium dendroides

The synthesis and subcellular localization of the two superoxide dismutases of Dactylium dendroides were studied in relation to changes in copper and manganese availability. Cultures grew normally at all medium copper concentrations used (10 nM to 1 mM). In the presence of high (10 μM) copper, manganese was poorly absorbed in comparison to the other metals in the medium. However, cells grown at 10 nM copper exhibited a 3.5-fold increase in manganese content, while the concentration of the other metals remained constant. Cultures grown at 10 nM copper or more had 80% Cu/Zn enzyme and 20% mangani enzyme; the former was entirely in the cytosol, and the latter was mitochondrial. Removal of copper from the medium resulted in decreased Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase synthesis with a concomitant increase in the mangani enzyme such that total cellular superoxide dismutase activity remained constant. The mangani enzyme in excess of the 20% was present in the non-mitochondrial fraction. The mitochondria, therefore, show no variability with respect to superoxide dismutase content, whereas the soluble fraction varies from 100 to 13% Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase. Copper-starved cells that were synthesizing predominantly mangani superoxide dismutase could be switched over to mostly Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase synthesis by supplementing the medium with copper during growth. Immunoprecipitation experiments suggest that the decrease in Cu/Zn activity at low copper concentration is a result of decreased synthesis of that protein rather than the production of an inactive apoprotein.     

The utilization of copper and its role in the biosynthesis of copper-containing proteins in the fungus, Dactylium dendroides

Aspects of the utilization of copper by the fungus, Dactytium dendroides, have been studied. The organism grows normally at copper levels below 10 nM. Cells grown in medium containing 30 nM copper or less concentrate exogenous metal at all levels of added copper; copper uptake is essentially complete within 15 min and is not inhibited by cycloheximide, dinitrophenol or cyanide. These results indicate that copper absorption is not an energy-dependent process. The relationship between fungal copper status and the activities of three copper-containing enzymes, galactose oxidase, an extracellular enzyme, the cytosolic, Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase and cytochrome oxidase, has also been established. The synthesis of galactose oxidase protein (haloenzyme plus apo-enzyme) is independent of copper concentration. Cells grown in copper-free medium (< 10 nM copper) excrete normal amounts of galactose oxidase as an apoprotein. At medium copper levels below 5 μM, new cultures contain enough total copper to enable the limited number of cells to attain sufficient intracellular copper to support hologalactose oxidase production. As a result of cell division, however, the amount of copper available per cell drops to a threshold of approx. 10 ng/mg below which point only apogalactose oxidase is secreted. Above 5 μM medium copper, holoenzyme secretion is maintained throughout cell growth.The levels of the Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase respond differently in that the protein itself apparently is synthesized in only limited amounts in copper-depleted cells. Total cellular superoxide dismutase activity is maintained under such conditions by an increase in activity associated with the mitochondrial, CN^?-insensitive, manganese form of this enzyme. Cells grown at 10 μM copper shown 83% of their superoxide dismutase activity to be contributed by the Cu/Zn form compared to a 17% contribution to the total activity in cells grown at 30 nM copper, indicating that the biosynthesis of the Cu/Zn and Mn-containing enzymes is coordinated. The data show that the level of copper modulates the synthesis of the cytosolic superoxide dismutase. In contrast, the cytochrome oxidase activity of D. dendroides is independent of cellular copper levels obtainable. Thus, the data also suggest that these three enzymes utilize different cellular copper pools. As cells are depleted of copper by cell division, the available copper is used to maintain Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase and cytochrome oxidase activity; at very low levels of copper, only the latter activity is maintained. The induction of the manganisuperoxide dismutase in copper-depleted cells should have practical value in the isolation of this protein.     

Outer sphere mutations perturb metal reactivity in manganese superoxide dismutase

Tyrosine 34 and glutamine 146 are highly conserved outer sphere residues in the mononuclear manganese active site of Escherichia coli manganese superoxide dismutase. Biochemical and spectroscopic characterization of site-directed mutants has allowed functional characterization of these residues in the wild-type (wt) enzyme. X-ray crystallographic analysis of three mutants (Y34F, Q146L, and Q146H) reveal subtle changes in the protein structures. The Y34A mutant, as well as the previously reported Y34F mutant, retained essentially the full superoxide dismutase activity of the wild-type enzyme, and the X-ray crystal structure of Y34F manganese superoxide dismutase shows that mutation of this strictly conserved residue has only minor effects on the positions of active site residues and the organized water in the substrate access funnel. Mutation of the outer sphere solvent pocket residue Q146 has more dramatic effects. The Q146E mutant is isolated as an apoprotein lacking dismutase activity. Q146L and Q146H mutants retain only 5-10% of the dismutase activity of the wild-type enzyme. The absorption and circular dichroism spectra of the Q146H mutant resemble corresponding data for the superoxide dismutase from a hyperthermophilic archaeon, Pyrobaculum aerophilum, which is active in both Mn and Fe forms. Interestingly, the iron-substituted Q146H protein also exhibits low dismutase activity, which increases at lower pH. Mutation of glutamine 146 disrupts the hydrogen-bonding network in the active site and has a greater effect on protein structure than does the Y34F mutant, with rearrangement of the tyrosine 34 and tryptophan 128 side chains.     

Aberrant Copper Chemistry as a Major Mediator of Oxidative Stress in a Human Cellular Model of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis

We have investigated the response to oxidative stress in a model system obtained by stable transfection of the human neuroblastoma cell line SH-SY5Y with plasmids directing constitutive expression of either wild-type human Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase or a mutant of this enzyme (H46R) associated with familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. We report that expression of mutant H46R Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase induces a selective increase in paraquat sensitivity that is reverted by addition of D-penicillamine. Furthermore, expression of this mutant enzyme affects the activity of the endogenous wild-type enzyme both in basal conditions and in copper overloading experiments. Our data indicate that aberrant metal chemistry of this mutant enzyme is the actual mediator of oxidative stress and that concurrent impairment of the activity of wild-type endogenous enzyme compromises the cell's ability to respond to oxidative stress.     

Functional and crystallographic characterization of Salmonella typhimurium Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase coded by the sodCI virulence gene

The functional and three-dimensional structural features of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase coded by the Salmonella typhimurium sodCI gene, have been characterized. Measurements of the catalytic rate indicate that this enzyme is the most efficient superoxide dismutase analyzed so far, a feature that may be related to the exclusive association of the sodCI gene with the most pathogenic Salmonella serotypes. The enzyme active-site copper ion is highly accessible to external probes, as indicated by quenching of the water proton relaxation rate upon addition of iodide. The shape of the electron paramagnetic resonance spectrum is dependent on the frozen or liquid state of the enzyme solution, suggesting relative flexibility of the copper ion environment. The crystal structure (R-factor 22.6%, at 2.3 A resolution) indicates that the dimeric enzyme adopts the quaternary assembly typical of prokaryotic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutases. However, when compared to the structures of the homologous enzymes from Photobacterium leiognathi and Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae, the subunit interface of Salmonella Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase shows substitution of 11 out of 19 interface residues. As a consequence, the network of structural water molecules that fill the dimer interface cavity is structured differently from the other dimeric bacterial enzymes. The crystallographic and functional characterization of this Salmonella Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase indicates that structural variability and catalytic efficiency are higher in prokaryotic than in the eukaryotic homologous enzymes.     

Labile sulfur in human Superoxide dismutase.

1. The nautre of the intense absorption band at 320 nm of the copper and zinc-containing enzyme superoxide dismutase, from human red blood cells, has been investigated. The band does not depend on the metal prosthetic groups of the enzyme, as it is still present in the apo protein. When, however, copper alone is removed from the enzyme with a treatment involving the use of cyanide, the band is also lost. Nevertheless the copper-free protein is able to recover both the enzyme activity and the native electron paramagnetic resonance spectrum as easily as the apo protein. 2. A number of other treatments are able to abolish the band. They include reaction with reducing agents such as dithiothreitol, sulfite, borohydride, exposure to denaturants such as guanidine HCl and sodium dodecyl sulfate, and exposure to pH values below pH 3 or above pH 13. 3. Four sulfur atoms per protein molecule were found to be associated to the 320-nm chromophore on the basis of quantitative determinations following reaction with cyanide or sodium borohydride. 4. A molar absorption coefficient of 1150 M-1 cm-1 was determined per each chromophoric group. In spite of this relatively high value and unusual stability, a persulfide group, R-S-SH, seems to be the most likely structure for this chromophore. 5. Bovine and equine superoxide dismutase do not show spectral or chemical evidence for such a group. This, and the recovery of activity and spectral properties of copper in the cyanide-treated human enzyme, indicate that labile sulfur is not associated with the superoxide dismutase activity of this protein.     

Superoxide dismutase isoenzymes in bovine and human milk

The presence of superoxide dismutase in bovine and human milk was investigated by ultrafiltration, gel filtration, and isoelectric focusing. Conclusive evidence for the presence of this enzyme in both milks is presented. The molecular weight of the enzyme was estimated by gel filtration on Sephadex G-100 to be 30,000, which is consistent with reported values for the copper, zinc form of superoxide dismutase. In addition, enzyme activity was inhibited by cyanide, thus eliminating the possibility that the enzyme was present in the manganese form. Several isoenzymes were detected by isoelectric focusing in polyacrylamide gel, and the isoenzyme pattern in bovine milk was the same as that found for bovine plasma, suggesting that milk superoxide dismutase originates from plasma. It may be that the presence of copper, zinc superoxide dismutase in milk is important for the maintenance of its oxidative stability.     

Polymers of Cu/Zn Superoxide Dismutase Produced by Cross-Linking with Glutaraldehyde

Soluble polymers of bovine Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) have been prepared using the homobifunctional cross-linking reagent, glutaraldehyde. A form of the enzyme, a tetramer. with a molecular weight of 64, 000 has been purified by gel filtration. The functional properties of the tctrarner have been investigated. Reconstitution with copper and zinc was required for full activity. After metal reconstitution, the specific activity of the tetramer was shown to be close to 90% that of the native dimerism enzyme.

The serum half-life of the tetramer in rats was found to be increased by a factor of six when compared with native superoxide dismutase. The tissue distribution of the two forms was also found to be direrent with the tetrarner accumulating predominantly in the liver.     

The role of copper atoms in the cytochrome oxidase reaction]

It was found that cytochrome oxidase from bovine cardiac muscle possesses marked superoxide dismutase activity. Superoxide dismutase activity is inhibited by cyanide and azide or by alkaline or thermal treatments. This activity is also suppressed by chelating agents, e.g. bathocuproin. The data obtained indicate that superoxide dismutase activity of cytochrome oxidase is due to the copper atoms of the enzyme. The experiments on the copper-containing subunit support this conclusion. Possible physiological significance of superoxide dismutase activity of cytochrome oxidase is discussed.     

Polymers of Cu/Zn Superoxide Dismutase Produced by Cross-Linking with Glutaraldehyde

Soluble polymers of bovine Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) have been prepared using the homobifunctional cross-linking reagent, glutaraldehyde. A form of the enzyme, a tetramer. with a molecular weight of 64, 000 has been purified by gel filtration. The functional properties of the tctrarner have been investigated. Reconstitution with copper and zinc was required for full activity. After metal reconstitution, the specific activity of the tetramer was shown to be close to 90% that of the native dimerism enzyme.

The serum half-life of the tetramer in rats was found to be increased by a factor of six when compared with native superoxide dismutase. The tissue distribution of the two forms was also found to be direrent with the tetrarner accumulating predominantly in the liver.     

Kinetics properties of Cu,Zn-superoxide dismutase as a function of metal content

The kinetics of bovine Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase were studied by pulse radiolysis. To ensure the absence of catalytically active free copper, commercially obtained holo-superoxide dismutase was demetallated, and the apo-superoxide dismutase concentrations were determined by isothermal titration calorimetry prior to reconstitution with defined amounts of copper and zinc. The catalytic rate constant was determined as a function of ionic strength over the range of 4-154 mM, and of the copper and zinc content. The catalytic rate constant increases with ionic strength up to (1.5 +/- 0.2) x 10(9) M(-1) s(-1) at an ionic strength of 15 mM, and then decreases. At pH 7 and 50 mM ionic strength, k = (1.2 +/- 0.2) x 10(9) M(-1) s(-1), and at a physiologically relevant ionic strength of 150 mM, it is (0.7 +/- 0.1) x 10 (9) M(-1) s(-1). The effect of ionic strength is ascribed to the inhomogeneous electric field generated by the surface charges of superoxide dismutase. The value of the catalytic rate constant at 50 mM is ca. 2-fold smaller than earlier values reported in the literature. The relationship between copper content and the catalytic rate constant shows that addition of more than a stoichiometric amount of copper cannot be masked efficiently by EDTA. The possibility exists that earlier reported values were based on experiments contaminated with trace amounts of copper.     

Regulation of superoxide dismutase synthesis in Candida albicans

The synthesis of superoxide dismutase [SOD: EC 1.15.1.1] in response to various cultural conditions was examined in Candida albicans, an opportunistic yeast which causes candidiasis in immunosuppressed patients. SOD plays an important role in protecting cells from the oxidative damage of superoxide radicals. Maximum SOD activity was found after 72 hrs of yeast growth. The optimum pH and temperature for the SOD activity were 7 and 40 °, respectively. The major SOD activity was found in the cytosol fraction and the level of extracellular SOD was very low. The enzyme was stimulated to varying degrees by cholic acid, procaine and tocopherol. On the basis of inhibitor studies and other enzyme properties, the isolated enzyme from C. albicans is identified as copper and zinc superoxide dismutase. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Photosynthetic apparatus of chilling-sensitive plants. XI. Reversibility by light of cold- and dark-induced inactivation of cyanide-sensitive superoxide dismutase activity in tomato leaf chloroplasts

(1) The inactivation of cyanide-sensitive, copper- and zinc-containing superoxide dismutase activity in chloroplasts following cold and dark storage of both detached leaves and growing tomato plants is accompanied by a decrease in copper and zinc content in both chloroplast preparations and butanol extracts of the enzyme. In contrast, this treatment of chloroplast preparations affects neither superoxide dismutase activity nor copper and zinc content. (2) Copper- and zinc-containing superoxide dismutase is not reactivated following the 2–3 h illumination of cold- and dark-stored detached leaves. However, prolonged illumination of growing seedlings results in the restoration of both the enzyme activity and copper and zinc content in chloroplasts. (3) The data suggest that the dissociation of copper, and probably of zinc, from the enzyme during cold and dark treatment of either detached leaves or growing plants and reincorporation of the metals following the illumination of intact plants are responsible for the reversible inactivation of chloroplast cyanide-sensitive superoxide dismutase of chilling-sensitive plants.     

Protection of Methanosarcina barkeri against oxidative stress: identification and characterization of an iron superoxide dismutase

Methanosarcina barkeri is a methanogenic archaeon that can only grow under strictly anoxic conditions but which can survive oxidative stress. We have recently reported that the organism contains a monofunctional catalase. We describe here that it also possesses an active iron superoxide dismutase. The enzyme was purified in three steps over 130-fold in a 14% yield to a specific activity of 1500 U/mg. SDS-PAGE revealed the presence of only one band, at an apparent molecular mass of 25 kDa. The primary structure determined from the cloned and sequenced gene revealed similarity to iron- and manganese superoxide dismutases. The highest similarity was to the iron superoxide dismutase from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum. The enzyme from M. barkeri was found to contain, per mol, 1 mol iron, but no manganese in agreement with the general observation that anaerobically growing organisms only contain iron superoxide dismutase. The enzyme was not inhibited by cyanide (10 mM), which is a property shared by all iron- and manganese superoxide dismutases. The presence of superoxide dismutase in M. barkeri is noteworthy since a gene encoding superoxide dismutase (sod) has not been found in Archaeoglobus fulgidus, a sulfate-reducing archaeon most closely related to the Methanosarcinaceae.