Effect of cyclophosphamide on suppressor cell activity in mice unresponsive to EAE.

Protection against experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) was induced in susceptible mice of (SJL/J X BALB/c)F1 hybrid, by injection of either mouse spinal cord homogenate, the small mouse basic protein, or Cop 1 in incomplete Freund's adjuvant, before EAE induction. It was demonstrated that the unresponsiveness induced by the three antigens is mediated by suppressor T cells residing in the spleen cell population and can be adoptively transferred to normal syngeneic recipients. Low dose of cyclophosphamide (20 mg/kg) administered 2 days before the encephalitogenic challenge abrogated the unresponsiveness to EAE and reverted the protected mice sensitive to disease induction. Cyclophosphamide was also active on adoptively transferred unresponsiveness, thus donors that had been treated with cyclophosphamide were unable to further transfer unresponsiveness to EAE. These results indicate the elimination by cyclophosphamide of suppressor cells that interfere with the effector mechanisms leading to EAE.     

Studies on the resistance to tolerance induction against human IgG in DDD mice. I. Organ differences of tolerogen susceptibility and cellular sites responsible for the resistance.

Cellular sites of the tolerogen resistance in DDD mice against human IgG (HGG) were examined by reconstitution experiments in which cells of various lymphoid organs from tolerized mice were transferred into lethally irradiated syngeneic recipients with or without the supplement of an excess number of untreated T or B cells. It was shown that T cells but not B cells in the spleen and bone marrow-locating B cells were tolerogen resistant. Kinetic profiles of tolerance induction were compared among thymus, lymph node, and spleen T cells. Thymus cells fall into unresponsive state as early as 2 days after the tolerogen (tHGG) injection when only partial tolerance was observed in lymph node T cells. By 1 week of tolerogen treatment, the tolerant state was completed in both thymus cells and lymph node T cells, while spleen T cells showed marked resistance. Tolerance induced in thymus cells and spleen T cells was of relatively short duration and responsiveness was completely recovered by 5 weeks after the injection of tHGG. At this time lymph node T cells still showed hyporesponsiveness. The differences in tolerance inducibility were also shown among different lymphoid organs in tolerogen dose response. Lymph node T cells were very sensitive to tolerance induction, giving no response even by the injection of 0.01 mg of tHGG. Thymus cells were much less sensitive with the gradual loss of responsiveness by increasing the amount of tHGG. In contrast, spleen T cells showed gradual resistance with increasing amount of tHGG, indicating that some positive response was evoked in spleen T cells by a relatively high dose of tHGG. These results seem to suggest that the tolerogen resistance of spleen T cells may be due to their capability of showing positive response against the tolerogenic material. This was also suggested by the fact that the treatment with cyclophosphamide following the tolerogen injection diminished completely the responsiveness against the subsequent challenge immunization.     

Suppressor cell regulation of encephalitogenic T cell lines: generation of suppressor macrophages with cyclosporin A and myelin basic protein.

Chronic relapsing experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (CR-EAE) can be adoptively transferred using myelin basic protein (BP)-specific helper T cell lines, and suppressor cells may be important in recovery from EAE. In order to generate suppressor cells, spleen cells obtained from BP-complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) inoculated SJL/J mice and from normal mice were cultured for 7 days with medium, with cyclosporin A (CsA), or with CsA and antigen (BP or purified protein derivative of mycobacterium (PPD)). Cultured spleen cells were assayed for suppressor activity in vitro by coculture with BP-specific and PPD-specific helper T cell lines derived from SJL/J mice. Immunized donor spleen cells cultured with cyclosporin A (CsA) and BP were potent inhibitors of T cell line proliferation, and suppressor activity was increased 17-fold compared with control splenocytes. The number of suppressor cells required to suppress PPD-specific line proliferation by 50% (I50) was significantly higher than the number required to suppress BP-specific line proliferation, suggesting an antigen-specific component to the suppression. The major effector cell required for suppression was a large granular Mac-1+ cell with the functional characteristics of a macrophage. Suppressor activity persisted after depletion of Thy 1.2+ cells, but suppression was no longer antigen-specific, suggesting that culture of spleen cells with CsA and BP may generate suppressor macrophages which are antigen-nonspecific and Thy 1.2+ suppressor cells which are antigen-specific. These suppressor cells may be important in the regulation of CR-EAE and the techniques described for their generation may prove useful for treatment and prevention of disease.     

Regulatory mechanism of delayed-type hypersensitivity in mice. I. Properties of memory cpells and suppressor cells for delayed-type hypersensitivity against ovalbumin.

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response in mice induced by sc injection of alum-absorbed ovalbumin (OA) was accelerated and enhanced by priming sc with a low dose of urea-denatured ovalbumin (UD-OA), 2 or more days earlier, whereas it was suppressed by priming sc with a high dose of UD-OA, 0 or more days earlier. The ability in primed mice to accelerate or suppress the DTH response could be transferred antigen specifically into cyclophosphamide (CY)-pretreated recipients or normal recipients by spleen cells from primed mice, but not by the T-cell-depleted spleen cells. Furthermore, the ability of spleen cells to transfer the acceleration or the suppression appeared transiently around 7 or 4 days after priming, although the acceleration or the suppression in donor mice persisted for a much longer time. Pretreatment with CY abolished the suppression of DTH response in high dose-primed mice and resulted in the acceleration of DTH response. These results suggest that the activity of DTH-related memory T cells which accelerate and enhance the response can be inhibited by suppressor T cells for the DTH response.     

Characterization of the suppressor cell(s) responsible for anterior chamber-associated immune deviation (ACAID) induced in BALB/c mice by P815 cells

Anterior chamber-associated immune deviation (ACAID) is a complex set of immune responses induced by the inoculation of antigens into the anterior chamber of the eye. Histocompatibility antigens, tumor-specific antigens, reactive haptens, and viral antigens have been shown to induce this phenomenon, which comprises the following specific host responses: high titer humoral antibodies, primed cytotoxic T cells, but specifically, impaired skin graft rejection and delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). Using the model system of ACAID induced by inoculation of P815 mastocytoma cells into the anterior chambers of H-2-compatible, but minor H-incompatible, BALB/c mice, we demonstrate that the impaired capacity of these animals to develop and express DTH is due to the activation of suppressor T cells. Generation of these cells requires an intact spleen, is not inhibited by cyclophosphamide pretreatment, and is abrogated by systemic treatment of the host with anti-I-J monoclonal antibodies. This splenic suppressor cell(s) can transfer suppression of DTH adoptively to naive syngeneic mice. One suppressor cell is Thy-1.2, Lyt-2.2, and I-Jd positive. A minority of these cells (or a second population of suppressor cells) also expresses the L3T4 surface marker. Suppression is exerted on the efferent limb of DTH expression, although afferent suppression is not excluded. P815-induced ACAID suppressor cells resemble similar cells induced by haptenated spleen cells inoculated into the anterior chamber of the eye. We propose that induction of these suppressor cells, whose target of action is selective for T DTH cells, but not for other types of T cells, is responsible for the phenomenon of immune privilege in the anterior chamber of the eye.     

Induction and persistence of suppression of contact hypersensitivity against bystander haptens and alloantigens in rats

The shift of suppression from a tolerizing hapten to a so-called bystander antigen was investigated in this study using contact hypersensitivity to trinitrochlorobenzene (TNCB) and dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB) and delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) to alloantigens in the rats as experimental models. Primary suppression of contact hypersensitivity was induced by intravenous injection of the water-soluble forms of TNCB and DNFB. A shift of the suppression to the bystander hapten was found if the tolerizing and bystander hapten were mixed and applied to the same area of skin during the sensitization procedure, but not if they were applied to separate areas of skin. With alloantigens, bystander suppression developed only when the sensitizing allogeneic cells were mixed with hapten-modified syngeneic cells. It was not induced by hapten-modified allogeneic cells. Once induced, such bystander suppression of the response to haptens persisted independently of the primarily tolerizing hapten, and it could be adoptively transferred with spleen cells. These results favour the concept that the bystander suppression is mediated by the non-specific action of suppressor cells generated specifically during the mixed sensitization rather than by an antigen bridge.     

Properties of ultraviolet light-induced suppressor lymphocytes within a syngeneic tumor system

It has been reported that ultraviolet light (uv) irradiation of normal C3Hf mice generates theta-positive suppressor lymphocytes which, as assayed by adoptive transfer studies, mediates susceptibility to transplanted syngeneic uv-induced tumors. We now report that the cells with suppressor activity can be recovered and enriched for using nylon wool columns. These suppressor cells are found in the nylon nonadherent fraction. Further, while uv irradiated mice are susceptible to supporting the growth of transplanted syngeneic uv tumors long after termination of the uv exposures, adoptively transferred suppression wanes and normal mice exhibit time-dependent recovery.     

Induced suppression of the efferent phase of contact sensitivity in rats

A study of the immunosuppressive systems of rats has been conducted with special attention to whether suppressor cells can be induced to down-regulate the efferent limb of contact sensitivity. Contact sensitivity (CS)1 was induced in DA rats 5 days after immunization with trinitrochlorobenzene (TNCB). Intravenous pretreatment of naive rats with TNP-coupled syngeneic spleen cells 7 days before sensitization suppressed the induction of CS by 60%. Suppression of the inductive phase of CS could be transferred adoptively into syngeneic rats with spleen cells of such tolerized animals. Cell fractionation studies showed the OX8+ (CD8) T cell population (cytotoxic/suppressor) was responsible for the suppression in the afferent phase of CS. Such cells were incapable of suppressing preexisting CS. To investigate whether suppression could be induced for the efferent phase, spleen and peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) from rats tolerized by administering TNP-spleen cells iv plus epidermal paintings with TNCB were adoptively transferred into recipients sensitized 4 days earlier. Both spleen cells and PEC suppressed the efferent phase of CS but PEC did so more efficiently. Separation of splenic cells revealed the suppressors to be CD8+ T cells. Furthermore, separation of PEC into plastic adherent and nonadherent cells showed the nonadherent (T cell enriched) cells to be noneffective alone. The adherent subpopulation conveyed suppression but did so more effectively upon addition of the T cells. Thus, T cells and macrophages may operate in concert to achieve suppression of the efferent limb of CS. PEC from tolerized rats suppressed performed CS of any specificity but only after the suppressor cells were triggered with the same antigen that induced them. Since both the afferent and efferent phases of CS have now been shown to be suppressable, two separate suppressor mechanisms may be operable in rats.     

Features of KLH-induced suppression in vivo: Characterization of two pathways of suppression

Keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) given at high dose (4 mg ip) in mice induced a state of unresponsiveness related to the activation of suppressor T cells. An early pathway of suppression is observed within the first 24 hr following KLH injection and is characterized by its cyclophosphamide (CPM) sensitivity and by the specificity of its effector phase, at the level of KLH helper T cells. A late pathway of suppression occurs at Day 3 following KLH injection and is characterized by its CPM resistance and the nonspecificity of its effector phase acting at the B-cell level. Indeed the anti-FLu antibody response to FLu Ovalbumin or thymus-independent antigen FLu LPS were found altered when these antigens were given with TNP KLH. These two pathways of suppression were found to last 8 months. These results suggest that KLH can trigger in an independent manner two pathways of suppression characterized by different CPM sensitivity and different target cells.     

Characterization of two suppressor cells that together prevent in vivo development of cytolytic T cells to hapten-altered self

Two suppressor cell populations that interact to down-regulate in vivo development of the cytolytic T-cell (CTL) response to trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-SC) have been further characterized. Suppressor cells induced by the iv injection of trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic spleen cells possess Thy 1.2 antigen. Their precursors are insensitive to pretreatment of host animals with cyclophosphamide (CY). Suppressor cells that arise after dermal sensitization with trinitrochlorobenzene are also Thy 1.2 antigen positive but their precursors are sensitive to pretreatment with CY. These characteristics of the two suppressor T cells (Ts) are identical to those of the two Ts that are generated by similar methodologies and that together suppress contact sensitivity (CS) to picryl chloride. Neither the CS nor CTL response was suppressed when host animals possessed only one set of Ts. In contrast to suppression of CS at the efferent phase, development of CTL was suppressed only when the two Ts were present early during sensitization (afferent phase). Since the results point to several similarities between the two sets of Ts that are active in the down-regulation of the CS and CTL responses, it is suggested that the two dissimilar immune responses directed to the same hapten, namely CS and CTL, may be controlled by the same suppressor cells. Since it appears that the two sets of Ts interact to affect different phases of the CS and CTL responses, down-regulation of each must be accomplished through different mechanisms.     

Specific suppression of the immune response by HGG tolerant spleen cells. I. Parameters affecting the level of suppression.

After adoptive transfer, the spleen cells from mice made tolerant to human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells. However, this suppressive activity in the spleen cells of tolerant mice is only present for a brief period after treatment with tolerogen. Spleen cells from animals injected 10 days earlier with tolerogen reduce the immune response of an equal number of normal spleen cells by 75%. Spleen cells from mice made tolerant 40 days previously are, however, no longer suppressive, even though they remain completely unresponsive. These data suggest that active suppression of antigen-reactive cells is not the mechanism responsible for maintaining tolerance to HGG, but rather is only transiently associated with the tolerant state. Further evidence in favor of the separation of the tolerant state from suppressive activity is that complete suppression of the normal spleen cell response requires either a high ratio of tolerant to immune competent cells or a delay in the antigenic challenge of the reconstituted recipients. By contrast, such manipulations are not required to demonstrate the complete unresponsiveness of the tolerant cells after adoptive transfer.     

Tolerance and contact sensitivity to DNFB in mice. VII. Functional demonstration of cell-associated tolerogen in lymph node cell populations containing specific suppressor cells.

Adoptive tolerance to contact sensitivity to DNFB is mediated by suppressor T cells. These cells are induced by iv injection of the hapten DNB-SO₃. Experiments were carried out to investigate the question of simultaneous transfer of tolerogen (DNB-SO₃ or its conjugation product DNP) with the suppressor cells. The results showed that tolerant lymph node cells pretreated in vitro with anti-TNP serum before transfer were unable to induce unresponsiveness to DNFB. Tolerant cells treated with either anti-TNP serum which had been passed over a TNP-affinity column or with polyvalent anti-immunoglobul in serum were not inhibited. These results functionally demonstrate that LN cell populations containing DNFB suppressor cells have accessible hapten (e.g., DNP) associated with their membrane, which is necessary for induction of adoptive tolerance. The hapten (tolerogen) appears to be bound directly to the cell surface rather than as an immune complex.     

A quantitative immunohistochemical comparison of actively versus adoptively induced experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in the Lewis rat

A quantitative immunohistochemical comparison of actively and adoptively induced experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) in the Lewis rat was performed. Since the methods of EAE induction of these two systems and the kinetics of disease appearance are different, while the histopathology, disease manifestations, duration, and severity are similar, this study sought to identify any differences which exist at the level of the target organ. The number of cells expressing the T helper (W3/25) or suppressor/cytotoxic (OX-8) phenotypes and the number of Ia-positive cells found in the spinal cord of animals given EAE by one of the two methods were compared at two time points at which maximal similarities should exist. The results show that during acute adoptively induced EAE the inflammatory infiltrate contains a larger number of T helper (TH) cells per unit area than in acute active EAE. With the resolution of clinical signs of EAE, the disappearance of cells from the spinal cord is more rapid in adoptive EAE. In contrast, the inflammatory infiltrate and Ia-positive parenchymal cells persist in active EAE following recovery. These results suggest that actively and adoptively induced EAE may differ with respect to the effector mechanisms and/or the mechanisms of recovery at the level of the target organ.     

Tolerance induced by TNP-derivatized syngeneic erythrocytes: evidence for cooperation between hapten-specific T and hapten-specific B lymphocytes in the immune response.

Tolerance to the DNP haptenic determinant was induced with a single i.v. injection of trinitrophenylated syngeneic red blood cells. The tolerant state lasted 1 month and was stable on transfer to irradiated thymectomized syngeneic recipients. Suppressor activity was found soon after injection of tolerogen but was lost before the termination of tolerance. The unresponsive state could be reversed by adding normal thymus cells to tolerant spleen cells but not by normal bone marrow cells. LPS when given with immunogen restored the normal immune response in tolerant mice. Thus the injection of TNP-MRBC induced partial immune unresponsiveness which was characterized by the induction of T cell suppressor activity and by a hapten-specific helper T cells tolerance. Finally, these studies suggest a cooperative interaction between DNP-specific T lymphocytes and DNP-specific B lymphocytes in the immune response to DNP-BGG.     

Generation of suppressor T cells after local immunization with histocompatibility antigens

Subcutaneous (sc) hind-foot immunization (HFI) of mice with allogeneic spleen cells can induce a state of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) as well as a state of suppression of DTH. This paper deals with the suppression induced by HFI. The state of suppression could be adoptively transferred by spleen cells and lymph node cells between Days 3 and 7 after HFI only. However, in the hind-foot-immunized mice the state of suppression lasted at least 25 days. The suppressor cells expressed the Thy-1+, Lyt-1-2+ phenotype and suppressed DTH antigen-specifically. The suppressor cells, however, also suppressed DTH responses to unrelated third-party alloantigens, provided the latter were administered during the induction of DTH together with the same alloantigens that were used for HFI. The HFI-induced T-suppressor cells suppressed the induction phase of DTH (i.e., the proliferative activity of the draining lymph node cells after secondary sc immunization), but not the expression phase of DTH (i.e., the activity of previously activated DTH effector T cells). H-2D compatibility between the donors of the HFI-induced T-suppressor cells and the recipients was required for the adoptive transfer of suppression. The differences in effect of local immunization versus systemic immunization on the induction and functional activity of T-suppressor cells are discussed.     

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in mice: Adoptive transfer of disease is modulated by the presence of natural suppressor cells

Normal, untreated syngeneic recipients of lymphocytes from mice with experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) do not generally express adoptively transferred disease. Cell transfer of EAE is more successful when syngeneic recipients are treated with cyclophosphamide (CY) prior to the injection of donor cells. Normal, untreated recipients that do not develop EAE after receiving EAE donor lymphocytes are also unresponsive to subsequent encephalitogenic challenge. Those CY-treated recipients that fail to develop EAE after cell transfer do develop EAE after subsequent challenge. After reconstitution with normal splenic lymphocytes, CY-treated recipients do not develop EAE after subsequent challenge. These findings suggest the presence of an intrinsic natural suppressor cell subpopulation in naive mice which modulate the expression of adoptively transferred T lymphocytes.Special Issue dedicated to Dr. Elizabeth Roboz-Einstein.     

Immune suppression with supraoptimal doses of antigen in contact sensitivity. I. Demonstration of suppressor cells and their sensitivity to cyclophosphamide.

Immunologic suppression was induced in a mouse model of contact sensitization to DNFB by using supraoptimal doses of antigen. In these studies, in vivo measurement of ear swelling as an indication of immunologic responsiveness correlated well with measurement of in vitro antigen-induced cell proliferation. This unresponsiveness was specific, since supraoptimal doses of DNFB did not interfere with the development of contact sensitivity to another contactant, oxazolone. The decrease in responsiveness is a form of active suppression, as lymphoid cells from supraoptimally sensitized donors transferred suppression to normal recipients. Furthermore, pretreatment with cyclophosphamide (Cy) reversed the suppression seen in supraoptimally sensitized animals but had no effect on the optimal sensitization regimen. These results indicate that supraoptimal doses of contactants can activate suppressor cells and that precursors of these cells are sensitive to Cy. Such suppressors regenerate within 7 to 14 days after Cy treatment. The ability of Cy pretreatment to affect supraoptimal sensitization without affecting optimal sensitization confirms other reports indicating that the observed results of Cy treatment depend critically upon the dose of antigen used.     

Suppressor cells in contact sensitivity. Effect on T cells helping antibody production to picryl chloride.

T cells from mice injected with picryl sulfonic acid have previously been shown to suppress the effector and possibly other phases of contact hypersensitivity reactions to picryl chloride. In this report we examine their effect on T cells helping the early direct anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response of mice painted with picryl chloride. They did not directly inhibit the activity of the helper cells but did inhibit the ability of mice to generate helper cells after skin painting. The suppressor cells were T cells as tested by passage through nylon wool columns and sensitivity to anti-θ serum. Viable syngeneic cells were required for suppression and their effect was specific. The suppressor cells could not be generated in adult thymectomized mice but could be produced in mice treated with high doses (200 mg/kg) of cyclophosphamide. These properties are distinct from those of suppressor T cells produced following immunization with picryl chloride but are the same as those of other suppressor cells induced by PSA which inhibit contact hypersensitivity.     

Studies on the mechanism of suppression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis induced by myelin basic protein-cell conjugates

The mechanism of suppression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) induced in Lewis rats by pretreatment with myelin basic protein (MBP) coupled to syngeneic spleen leukocytes (SL) was examined. Studies on the kinetics of the tolerance induction showed that pretreatment with MBP-SL suppressed EAE if given 7 but not 3 days before the disease-inducing injection of MBP in Freund's complete adjuvant. Treatment with cyclophosphamide 48 hr before administration of MBP-SL completely abolished the suppression of EAE. Transfer of lymph node and spleen cells from MBP-syngeneic erythrocyte conjugate (MBP-RBC) but not MBP-SL-pretreated rats resulted in suppression of disease in recipients subsequently given a disease-inducing injection of MBP. Administration of MBP coupled to SL from the histocompatible rat strain F344 resulted in suppression of the MBP-induced proliferative response of spleen cells from Lewis rats which had been given a disease-inducing injection of MBP. Taken together these results are consistent with the suppression of EAE induced by MBP-SL being mediated by suppressor T cells.