Identification of a specific scar marker for detection of Tilletia foetida (Wall) Liro pathogen of wheat

Common bunt is one of the most important destructive diseases of wheat worldwide and is a domestic quarantined disease in China. However, a rapid and efficient method to identify the corresponding pathogens is currently limited. The objective of the present study was to develop a diagnostic molecular marker specific towards Tilletia foetida (Wall) Liro, a causal agent of the bunt disease. One specific DNA fragment for T. foetida (286 bp in length) was amplified using an Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism (AFLP) assay and, this fragment was cloned and sequenced. One pair of specific primers (SC(286-1)/SC(286-2)), which was designed according to the sequence, could specifically amplify the corresponding fragment in all of the T. foetida isolates employed from both the People's Republic of China and United States, whereas this fragment could not be amplified by the other fungal species tested. Therefore, a specific Sequence Characterized Amplified Region (SCAR) marker was developed. This SCAR marker could distinguish T. foetida from related pathogenic fungi efficiently and could be used for the early diagnosis of the common bunt of wheat in the field, and provide an efficient way for disease surveillance and disease forecasting in cereal crop.     

Characteristics of the Infection of Tilletia laevis Kühn (syn. Tilletia foetida (Wallr.) Liro.) in Compatible Wheat

Tilletia laevis Kühn (syn. Tilletia foetida (Wallr.) Liro.) causes wheat common bunt, which is one of the most devastating plant diseases in the world. Common bunt can result in a reduction of 80% or even a total loss of wheat production. In this study, the characteristics of T. laevis infection in compatible wheat plants were defined based on the combination of scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy and laser scanning confocal microscopy. We found T. laevis could lead to the abnormal growth of wheat tissues and cells, such as leakage of chloroplasts, deformities, disordered arrangements of mesophyll cells and also thickening of the cell wall of mesophyll cells in leaf tissue. What’s more, T. laevis teliospores were found in the roots, stems, flag leaves, and glumes of infected wheat plants instead of just in the ovaries, as previously reported. The abnormal characteristics caused by T. laevis may be used for early detection of this pathogen instead of molecular markers in addition to providing theoretical insights into T. laevis and wheat interactions for breeding of common bunt resistance.     

Development and validation of microsatellite markers for Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica) and loose smut (Ustilago segetum tritici) of wheat from related fungal species

Simple sequence repeats (SSRs) are preferred molecular markers because of their abundance, robustness, high reproducibility, high efficiency in detecting variation and suitability for high‐throughput analysis. In this study, an attempt was made to mine and analyse the SSRs from the genomes of two seed‐borne fungal pathogens, viz Ustilago maydis, which causes common smut of maize, and Tilletia horrida, the cause of rice kernel smut. After elimination of redundant sequences, 2,703 SSR loci of U. maydis were identified. Of the remaining SSRS, 44.5% accounted for di‐nucleotide repeats followed by 29.8% and 2.7% tri‐ and tetranucleotide repeats, respectively. Similarly, 2,638 SSR loci were identified in T. horrida, of which 20.2% were di‐nucleotide, 50.4% tri‐ and 20.5% tetra‐nucleotide repeats. A set of 65 SSRs designed from each fungus were validated, which yielded 23 polymorphic SSRs from Ustilago and 21 from Tilletia. These polymorphic SSR loci were also successfully cross‐amplified with the Ustilago segetum tritici and Tilletia indica. Principal coordinate analysis of SSR data clustered isolates according to their respective species. These newly developed and validated microsatellite markers may have immediate applications for detection of genetic variability and in population studies of bunt and smut of wheat and other related host plants. Moreover, this is first comprehensive report on molecular markers suitable for variability studies in wheat seed‐borne pathogens.     

Mapping of a resistance gene effective against Karnal bunt pathogen of wheat

A set of 130 wheat recombinant inbred lines (RILs) developed from a cross between parents susceptible (WL711) and resistant (HD29) to Karnal bunt (caused by Tilletia indica), were screened for 3 years with the pathogen populations prevalent in northern India. When 90 simple sequence repeats (SSRs) and 81 amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) loci were mapped on the RILs, markers on chromosomes 2A, 4B and 7B accounted collectively for about one-third of the variation in the disease reaction. The genomic region of largest effect, identified on the long arm of chromosome 4B, reduced Karnal bunt disease by half in three different experiments and accounted for up to 25% of the phenotypic variation for KB reaction. A closely linked SSR marker, GWM538, may be useful in marker-assisted selection for Karnal bunt resistance in wheat.     

Changes in the Phytohormone Levels in Wheat Calli as Affected by Salicylic Acid and Infection with Tilletia caries,a Bunt Pathogenic Agent

The role of salicylic acid (SA) in growth regulation and the change in the levels of phytohormones (IAA, ABA, and cytokinins) were studied in the wheat calli co-cultured with bunt pathogen Tilletia caries. Calli infection with T. caries resulted in the hypertrophied callus growth and simultaneous increase in phytohormone level. The addition of SA to the nutrient media decreased the callus growth induced by the pathogen, whereas the level of investigated phytohormones was not affected. In the SA-treated infected calli, the formation of necrotic lesions was observed in the zones of contact of the fungal mycelium with callus cells that limited pathogen growth. The authors suggest that the stabilization of the hormonal balance of plant cells at pathogenesis is one of the possible mechanisms of the SA protective action in vitro and in vivo. Hence, co-culturing wheat calli and T. caries fungus appeared to be a convenient model for assessing SA protective action.     

Development of a SCAR marker by inter-simple sequence repeat for diagnosis of dwarf bunt of wheat and detection of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Tilletia controversa</Emphasis><Emphasis Type="SmallCaps">Kühn</Emphasis>

Dwarf bunt of wheat, caused by Tilletia controversa Kühn, is a destructive disease on wheat as well as an important internationally quarantined disease in many countries. The primer ISSR818 generated a polymorphic pattern displaying a 867-bp DNA fragment specific for T. controversa. The marker was converted into a sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR), and specific primers (TCKSF3/TCKSR3) designed for use in PCR detection assays; they amplified a unique DNA fragment in all isolates of T. controversa but not in the related pathogens. The detection limit with the primer set (TCKSF3/TCKSR3) was 5 ng of DNA which could be obtained from 5.5 μg of teliospores in a 25-μL PCR reaction mixture.     

The Effect of the Common Bunt on the Growth of Wheat Seedlings and Calluses

The growth of wheat (Triticum aestivum L., cv. Zhnitsa) seedlings and calluses infected with spores of common bunt causal agent Tilletia caries (DC) Tul. was studied. Inoculation with the pathogenic fungus enhanced both in vivo and in vitro growth due to cell division activation and cell expansion. These growth characteristics were also retained in wheat calluses infected with T. caries and grown on the hormone-free Murashige and Skoog nutrient medium. This implies the production of hormone-like substances by the fungus itself or by the infected plant. At the phase of fungal penetration into the plants, infection resulted in IAA accumulation in seedlings. Later, the IAA content reduced to a control level and the phytohormone balance was shifted toward cytokinins. Similar changes in the IAA and cytokinin levels were observed during early fungus development on wheat callus tissues. Such a sequence of events is supposed to be required for successful fungal penetration and localization in plant tissues and for the establishment of compatible interactions between the pathogen and the host plant.     

Changes in the Levels of IAA,ABA, and Cytokinins in Wheat Seedlings Infected with Tilletia caries

The seedling growth and the content of endogenous phytohormones in wheat seedlings were estimated 3, 6, and 9 days after infection with the bunt pathogen (Tilletia caries) (DC.)TUL. The infection of a pathogen-susceptible species Triticum aestivum L. and a resistant species T. timopheevii Zhuk. resulted, respectively, in an increase and a decrease in the seedling growth and the IAA content as compared to the control. The cytokinin content increased in both species, and the increase in T. timopheevii was more rapid. The pathogen-induced increase in auxin content is suggested to enhance fungal invasion of plants. In the susceptible species, a high ABA concentration was retained for a longer period of time and could act as a factor of virulence. At the same time, in the resistant species, an increase in ABA content was transient and seems to trigger plant defense mechanisms.     

Development of Seed Immunoblot Binding Assay for Detection of Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica) of Wheat

Polyclonal antisera were produced in albino white rabbits against intact teliospores of Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica). The Immunoprobe generated was used for the development of Immunoblot binding assay for detecting Karnal bunt (KB) infections in wheat seed samples. The antiserum reacted strongly with intact teliospores of T. indica, Pantnagar isolate in agglutination reaction. Wheat grains with different grades of infection could be readily detected by Seed Immunoblot Binding Assay (SIBA). Karnal bunt infected wheat seeds when kept for vigour testing on nitrocellulose paper, formed a coloured imprint after the paper was immunoprocessed. The SIBA would not only be a better Indication of teliospores load on seed but also quality of seed in terms of vigour. This method is expected to be useful in routine monitoring of wheat lots for the presence of KB teliospores.     

Development of a sequence-characterized amplified region marker for diagnosis of dwarf bunt of wheat and detection of Tilletia controversa Kühn

Aims:  Dwarf bunt of wheat, caused by Tilletia controversa Kühn, is a destructive disease on wheat as well as an important international quarantined disease in many countries. The objective of this investigation was to develop a diagnostic molecular marker generated from amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) for rapid identification of T . controversa .
Methods and Results:  A total of 30 primer combinations were tested by AFLP to detect DNA polymorphisms between T. controversa and related species. The primer combination E08/M02 generated a polymorphic pattern displaying a 451-bp DNA fragment specific for T. controversa . The marker was converted into a sequence-characterized amplified region (SCAR), and specific primers (SC-01₄₉/SC-02₄₁₅), designed for use in PCR detection assays, amplified a unique DNA fragment in all isolates of T. controversa , but not in the related pathogens. The detection limit with the primer set SC-01₄₉/SC-02₄₁₅ was 10 ng of DNA which could be obtained from 11  μ g of teliospores in a 25- μ l PCR reaction.
Conclusions:  An approach to distinguish T. controversa from similar pathogenic fungi has been developed based on the use of a SCAR marker.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  Development of the simple, high throughput assay kit for the rapid diagnosis of dwarf bunt of wheat and detection of T. controversa is anticipated in further studies.     

Enhanced proteolysis leads to pre-mature cell death under the influence of elicitor like mycelial components from karnal bunt (tilletia indica) pathogen in wheat callus cultures

Calli raised from mature embryos of susceptible wheat cultivar WH 542 were used in the present study as in vitro bioassay system to study the influence of disease determinant(s) of Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica), a semi-biotrophic fungal pathogen of wheat. Influence of elicitor and conditioned medium (CM) prepared from fungal cultures of T. indica was investigated on induction of programmed cell death (PCD). Induction of PCD was observed as hypersensitive response (HR) in terms of browning at localized regions of callus cultures and induction of proteolytic enzyme(s). Elicitor treated calli showed higher induction of protease activity than untreated and CM-treated cultures, which showed not much change in the activity. It was further substantiated by gel protease assay and activation of caspase-3 like protein(s) in callus cultures that clearly suggested the presence of signaling molecule(s) in the fungal elicitor preparation rather than in conditioned medium. This study further demonstrated that only elicitor preparation possesses such molecule(s), which might be cell wall bound components, rather than secretory in nature as CM was unable to induce PCD in wheat callus cultivars.     

Determination of variability in monosporidial lines of Tilletia indica by RAPD analysis

Genetic variability in 23 monosporidial lines developed from five isolates of Tilletia indica causing Karnal bunt of wheat isolated from four wheat growing states of India was determined by using 19 rapid amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. Amplification profile generated with all the 19 primers produced 3–16 numbers of bands of 1.5–5 kb size. High level of polymorphism (95.2%) suggested wide range of variability. Maximum Jaccard's similarity coefficient (80%) was observed between KB2MsB and KB2MsC followed by KB5MsC and KB5MsE with 75% similarity, whereas it was minimum between KB3MsA and Kb4MsB (47%). The dendrogram derived from the fingerprint analysis with 19 RAPD primers by using UPGMA showed different levels of genetic similarity among monosporidial lines. At 35% genetic similarity, the monosporidial lines were grouped in two clusters. Some primers, viz., OPN-1, OPN-6, OPN-9, OPN-12, OPN-13, OPN-18, OPM-2, OPM-8, OPM-10, OPB-8, OPB-17 and OPB-20 showed 100% polymorphism. The RAPD fingerprint generated by OPN-1 and OPM-3 were analysed and showed high range of variation in genetic make-up of monosporidial lines.     

Development of a SCAR marker for molecular detection and diagnosis of Tilletia controversa Kühn,the causal fungus of wheat dwarf bunt

Tilletia controversa Kühn (TCK) is an important quarantine pathogen that causes wheat dwarf bunt and results in devastating damage to wheat production. The fungus is difficult to be distinguished from T. caries and T. laevis, which cause wheat common bunt, based on morphological, physiological and symptomatological characteristics of the pathogens. The traditional detection of the fungus can be a long and tedious process with poor accuracy. The inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) technique has been used for identifying molecular markers for detection of TCK. Of 28 ISSR primers screened, ISSR-859 amplified a specific 678 bp DNA fragment from all TCK isolates but not from any isolates of the common bunt fungi or other pathogenic fungi tested. Based on the fragment sequence, a pair of sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR) primers was designed, which amplified a 372 bp DNA fragment specifically in TCK. The SCAR marker was detected using as low as 1 ng template DNA of TCK, and was also detected using broken teliospores and DNA from asymptomatic wheat samples. We developed the SYBR Green I and TaqMan Green I and TaqMan real-time polymorphism chain reaction methods to detect TCK with the detection limit of 0.1 fg with asymptomatic wheat samples. Further work is needed to develop a rapid test kit for this pathogenic fungus using the designed specific primers.     

Development of a PCR marker for rapid identification of the Bt-10 gene for common bunt resistance in wheat.

In western Canada, the Bt-10 resistance gene in wheat (Triticum aestivum) is effective against all the known races of common bunt caused by Tilletia tritici and T laevis. The genotypes of 199 F2 plants, originated from a cross between BW553 containing Bt-10 and the susceptible spring wheat cultivar 'Neepawa,' were established in greenhouse and field inoculation studies. A ratio of 1:2:1 resistant : heterozygous : susceptible was observed for bunt reaction, indicating that Bt-10 was expressed in a partially dominant fashion. A polymorphic DNA fragment, amplified using RAPD, and previously shown to be linked to Bt-10 was sequenced and SCAR (sequence characterized amplified region) primers devised. However, SCAR primers failed to amplify the polymorphic fragment. Restriction of PCR products with DraI revealed a polymorphic fragment of 490 bp resulting from a single base pair difference between lines possessing Bt-10 and those lacking the gene. As per the base pair difference, FSD and RSA primers were designed to generate a 275-bp polymorphic DNA fragment. Both 275- and 490-bp polymorphic fragments were present in all of the 22 cultivars known to carry Bt-10, and absent in all 16 cultivars lacking Bt-10. A 3:1 ratio was observed for presence: absence of the 275-bp marker in the F2 population. Using Southern analysis, the 490-bp fragment was effective in differentiating homozygous resistant plants from those heterozygous for Bt-10, based on its presence and the hybridization signal strength. A 1:2:1 resistant : heterozygous : susceptible ratio was also observed for the molecular marker and corresponded to 88% of the phenotypes deduced from the original F2 population. The molecular marker was estimated to be between 1.1 cM and 6.5 cM away from the Bt-10 resistance gene, based on the segregation analysis. Segregation analyses of Bt-10 and the 275-bp marker, evaluated in three different Canada Prairie Spring (CPS) wheat populations, demonstrated a segregation ratio of 3:1 for the molecular marker in two of the populations. These results demonstrated that the PCR marker system using the FSD and RSA primer pair permitted a rapid and reliable identification of individual lines carrying the Bt-10 gene for resistance to common bunt.     

小麦矮腥黑穗菌差异片段筛选与分子检测体系的建立

采取随机扩增DNA多态性(Random amplified polymorphic DNA,RAPD)引物介导的半特异PCR技术(RAPD primer mediated hemi-specific PCR,RM-PCR),在从不同地域征集的18个小麦矮腥黑穗菌(Tilletia controversa Kühn,TCK)菌株和29个小麦网腥黑穗病菌(Tilletia caries(DC)Tul,TCT)菌株的总基因组DNA中筛选鉴定出TCK独有的大小为1322bp差异基因组片段。根据该片段序列设计筛选出2对特异性引物CQUTCK2/CQUTCK3和CQUTCK4/CQUTCK5,均可以从18个TCK菌株的菌丝体和冬孢子DNA中稳定地扩增出747bp和200bp的单一靶带DNA,而在29个TCT菌株的菌丝体或冬孢子DNA均无任何扩增产物。以腥黑穗菌属通用引物对CQUK6/CQUK7为内置对照,可以确定被检样品是否含PCR抑制物质进而判断检测体系是否正确,同时有效地排除样品检测结果的假阳性和假阴性。采用建立的TCK特异PCR检测技术体系,实现简单而快速地鉴定小麦矮腥黑穗菌冬孢子或罹病小麦组织中侵染菌丝体的目的。     

Variability of Indian Isolates of Tilletia indica Assessed by Pathogenicity and Molecular Markers

Twenty isolates of Tilletia indica collected from sites in North and North‐western India showed pathogenic variation on 18 host differentials. Sixteen aggressive pathotypes were identified on the basis of percent coefficient of infection (PCI). Two major clusters were apparent in the dendrogram; cluster 1 comprised 13 isolates and cluster two consisted of seven isolates. One of the isolate Kashipur had a high PCI on most of the host differentials compared to other isolates. Polymerase chain reaction‐based random amplified polymorphic DNA (PCR – RAPD) analysis also divided isolates into two major clusters, one comprising of 5 isolates collected from hill and foot‐hill sites and another group comprising of 15 isolates collected from plain sites. Thus, the clusters identified based on PCI did not match closely with those identified by molecular analysis based on RAPD. Although diversity among the isolates of T. indica was absent in the rDNA‐ITS region, our study based on pathogenicity and molecular markers confirms the existence of great diversity in the pathogen, also shifting of ‘hot spot’ areas from one place to another within Karnal bunt prevailing areas.     

Isolation of a species-specific mitochondrial DNA sequence for identification of Tilletia indica, the Karnal bunt of wheat fungus.

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from five isolates of Tilletia indica was isolated and digested with several restriction enzymes. A 2.3-kb EcoRI fragment was chosen, cloned, and shown to hybridize with total DNA restricted with EcoRI from T. indica and not from a morphologically similar smut fungus, Tilletia barclayana. The clone was partially sequenced, and primers were designed and tested under high-stringency conditions in PCR assays. The primer pair Ti1/Ti4 amplified a 2.3-kb fragment from total DNA of 17 T. indica isolates from India, Pakistan, and Mexico. DNA from 25 isolates of other smut fungi (T. barclayana, Tilletia foetida, Tilletia caries, Tilletia fusca, and Tilletia controversa) did not produce any bands, as detected by ethidium bromide-stained agarose gels and Southern hybridizations. The sensitivity of the assay was determined and increased by using a single nested primer in a second round of amplification, so that 1 pg of total mycelial DNA could be detected. The results indicated that the primers which originated from a cloned mtDNA sequence can be used to differentiate T. indica from other Tilletia species and have the potential to identify teliospores contaminating wheat seeds.     

Evaluation of RAPD, ISSR and AFLP Markers for Characterization of the Loose Smut Fungus Ustilago tritici

Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD), inter simple sequence repeat (ISSR) and Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism (AFLP) profiling were evaluated for assessing the extent of genetic variation among the isolates of Ustilago tritici (Pers.) Rostr., which causes the loose smut disease of wheat.Thirty random decamer primers, six random primer pairs, four SSR primers such as (GACA)₄, (GATA)₄, (CAA)₅ and (GTG)₅ and nine combinations of AFLP selective primers were used to characterize nine isolates of the fungus. These isolates were collected from infected earheads of seven commercial wheat cultivars grown at eight different locations in Haryana, which is a major wheat growing state in the North-West Plain Zone of India. The RAPD and ISSR primers generated 21 0 scorable amplified fragments, all of which were monomorphic among the isolates.The AFLP primer combinations generated 239 fragments out of which 193 were polymorphic. All the isolates could be precisely differentiated from each other employing AFLP and grouped into two distinct clusters.The molecular classification partly corresponded with geographic distribution and host origin of the isolates. AFLP profiling was found superior to RAPD and ISSR and can be effectively utilized for further characterization of loose smut pathogen.     

Effect of chitooligosaccharides on peroxidase isoenzyme composition in wheat calli cocultured with bunt causal agent

Effects of chitooligosaccharides (COS) on the activity of peroxidase and its isoenzyme composition were investigated in cocultures of wheat calli (Triticum aestivum L.) with common bunt fungal pathogen (Tilletia caries (DC) Tul.). COS elevated the activity of readily soluble form of peroxidase: at concentrations of 0.01 and 1 mg/l, peroxidases with isoelectric points (pI) of about 3.5 and 9.8 and at concentration of 100 mg/l—those with pI of 4.3–5.2 were activated. It was shown that treatment with COS boosted the resistance of wheat calli to T. caries, inducing the accumulation in the cell wall of pathogen-specific isoperoxidases, especially its anionic isoform with pI ∼ 3.5. The ultimate indicator of defense responses is quick lignification of cultured cell walls under the effect of COS in the contamination area.