Sex ratio distortion in bovine sperm correlates to recombination in the pseudoautosomal region

A total of 2122 single sperm from 35 bulls belonging to six different paternal half-sib groups were analysed with respect to two markers in the bovine pseudoautosomal region (PAR) and sex-specific loci on the X and Y chromosomes, respectively. A segregation ratio significantly different from 1:1 was observed in a test over all families, with a higher proportion of X-bearing gametes (53.5%). The analysis of recombination conducted separately for X- and Y-bearing sperm showed that X-bearing sperm cells possess highly significant individual and between-family variability in recombination rate, whereas Y-bearing sperm show linkage homogeneity. To test whether the two phenomena are related, different logistic regression models were fitted to the data. The results show that sex ratio significantly correlates with changes in recombination rate among X-bearing but not among Y-bearing sperm. Different hypotheses to explain these observations are discussed.     

Separation of X- and Y-chromosome-bearing murine sperm by free-flow electrophoresis: evaluation of separation using PCR.

The effectiveness of separation of murine X- and Y-bearing sperm by free-flow electrophoresis was evaluated by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The ratio of X- and Y-bearing sperm from cauda epididymis was analyzed before and after free-flow electrophoresis. A Y-chromosome-specific sequence (pY353/B) and an autosomal sequence (myogenin) were used to estimate the ratio between X- and Y-sperm in the separated fractions. Cauda epididymal mice sperm were separated into two peak fractions under the electric field. Each peak fraction contained sperm of normal shape, however, the motility of the sperm was extremely diminished after separation by electrophoresis. DNA was extracted from 10(4) sperm from each fraction and from the unseparated sperm, and Y-chromosome specific PCR was performed. The PCR experiment revealed that fraction No. 16 (the peak near the cathode) was a Y-sperm rich fraction, whereas fraction No. 22 (the peak near the anode) was a Y-sperm poor one. These results suggested that murine X- and Y-sperm could be successfully separated by free-flow electrophoresis. Analysis of the chromosome-specific sequence by PCR was demonstrated to be a direct and adequate method to evaluate the separation of X- and Y-sperm.     

Sex preselection: laboratory validation of the sperm sex ratio of flow sorted X- and Y-sperm by sort reanalysis for DNA

Laboratory validation is essential in developing an effective method for separating X and Y sperm to preselect sex. Utilizing sexed sperm from a particular experiment to test fertility and achieve the subsequent phenotypic sex without knowing the likely outcome at conception is too costly for most applications. Further, research advances need to be built on an ongoing assessment with respect to the collection of data to continue progress towards achieving a successful outcome. The Beltsville Sperm Sexing Technology, which is based on the sorting of X- and Y-bearing sperm through the process of flow-cytometric sperm sorting, is also well suited for validation in the laboratory by "sort reanalysis" of the sperm X- and Y-bearing fractions for DNA content. Since the sexing technology is based on the use of Hoechst 33342, a permeant nuclear DNA stain for sorting X- and Y-bearing sperm, it also can be the marker for determining the proportions of X and Y populations by sort reanalysis. The process consists of using an aliquot of the sorted sperm and sonicating to obtain sperm nuclei. The uniformity of the nuclear staining is re-established through the addition of more Hoechst 33342. Separate analysis of each aliquot produces a histogram that is fitted to a double gaussian curve to determine proportions of X and Y populations. The relative breadths of the distributions of DNA of X- and Y-bearing sperm within a species affects interpretations of the histogram. Sort reanalysis is consistently repeatable with differences in X/Y DNA equal to or greater than 3.0%. This information on sex ratio of the sperm then provides the precise tool by which one can predict the outcome in terms of sex, from a particular sample of semen. Simple analysis of unsorted sperm to determine the proportions of X- and Y-bearing sperm based on DNA content is also an effective tool for validating sperm-sex ratio, whether it is in a sample assumed to be 50:50 or predicted to be something other than 50:50. This simple analysis provides for a check on the potential sex ratio of any sample of semen.     

Clinical experience with flow cytometric separation of human X- and Y-chromosome bearing sperm

Numerous methods to separate human X- and Y-bearing sperm have been reported with unconfirmed separation after DNA analysis and inconsistent birth results. Successful flow cytometric separation of sperm resulting in alteration of the sex ratio of young born has been demonstrated in several animal species. Flow cytometric separation of human X- and Y-bearing sperm (MicroSort) has been confirmed after DNA analysis by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Pregnancies and births have resulted from the use of MicroSort after intrauterine insemination (IUI), in vitro fertilization (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI).     

Experimental demonstration that mammalian oocytes are not selective towards X- or Y-bearing sperm

Mammalian oocytes are thought to be neutral as for X- or Y-bearing sperm selection is concerned, and penetration of an oocyte by an X- or a Y-bearing sperm is considered a random event. This assumption is mainly based on a posteriori evidences of a nearly equal sex ratio at birth, but it has never been experimentally demonstrated. We have designed a simple experiment, which allowed the penetration of an oocyte by more than one sperm and the further sexing by PCR of each single pronucleus present within the ooplasm. For the first time, we provide experimental evidence that mammalian oocytes do not play a selecting role since a single oocyte may be simultaneously fertilised by both X- and Y-bearing sperm.     

Sperm chromosome analysis in a man heterozygous for a paracentric inversion of chromosome 7 (q11q22)

Summary Human sperm chromosomes were studied in a man heterozygous for a paracentric inversion of chromosome 7 (q11q22). The pronuclear chromosomes were analysed after in vitro penetration of golden hamster (Mesocricetus auratus) eggs. Ninety-four sperm chromosome spreads were examined, of which 34 contained the normal number 7 chromosome and 59 the inverted 6. This segregation was significantly different from the expected 1:1 ratio. The number of X- to Y-bearing sperm was 48 and 46 respectively. No sperm contained a recombinant chromosome caused by a crossover within the inversion. The frequency of chromosomal abnormalities in other chromosomes was 9.6%, which is not significantly different from the frequency observed in normal donors (8.9%) in our laboratory. These result suggest that the risk of chromosomally unbalanced sperm is not high for this paracentric inversion.     

Sex preselection in rabbits: live births from X and Y sperm separated by DNA and cell sorting

Intact, viable X and Y chromosome-bearing sperm populations of the rabbit were separated according to DNA content with a flow cytometer/cell sorter. Reanalysis for DNA of an aliquot from each sorted population showed purities of 86% for X-bearing sperm and 81% for Y-bearing sperm populations. Sorted sperm were surgically inseminated into the uterus of rabbits. From does inseminated with sorted X-bearing sperm, 94% of the offspring born were females. From does inseminated with sorted Y-bearing sperm from the same ejaculates, 81% of the offspring were males. The probability of the phenotypic sex ratios differing from 50:50 were p less than 0.0003 for X-sorted sperm and p less than 0.004 for Y-sorted sperm. Thus, the phenotypic sex ratio at birth was accurately predicted from the flow-cytometrically measured proportion of X- and Y-bearing sperm used for insemination.     

Sperm chromosome analysis of a man heterozygous for a pericentric inversion of chromosome 3

Using a procedure in which human sperm were allowed to fertilize zona-free golden hamster (Mesocricetus auratus) eggs in vitro, the sperm chromosomes of a man heterozygous for inv(3) (p11q11) were analyzed. When the chromosomes were Q-banded, the inverted chromosome had the bright centromeric band on the short arm rather than on the long arm, as was seen in the normal No. 3. One hundred and eleven sperm chromosome spreads were examined, of which 64 contained the normal chromosome and 47 the inverted one. This was not significantly different from the expected 1:1 ratio. No sperm containing a chromosome imbalance caused by a crossover within the inversion were seen. Ten (8.1%) of the sperm contained chromosome abnormalities unrelated to the inversion. The ratio of X- to Y-bearing sperm was 55:45.     

Selection and separation of X- and Y- chromosome-bearing mammalian sperm

Preselection of the gender of offspring is a subject that has held man's attention since the beginning of recorded history. Most scientific hypotheses for producing the desired sex of offspring address separation of X- and Y-bearing sperm, and most have had limited, if any success. Eight of these hypotheses and their experimental verifications are discussed here. Three hypotheses are based on physical characteristics of sperm, one on supposed differences in size and shape, another on differences in density, and a third on differences in surface charge. There has been no experimental verification of differences based on size and shape, and the results from attempts to verify separation of X- and Y-bearing sperm based on density have been mixed. Electrophoresis may provide a method for separating X-and Y-bearing sperm, but it is currently unproven and would be of little practical utility, since sperm motility is lost. A fourth hypothesis employs H-Y antigen to select preimplantation embryos. This method reliably produces female offspring, but does not permit the selection of male offspring and does not work on sperm. There are two applications of the theory that X- and Y-bearing sperm should be separable by flow fractionation. Flow fractionation using thermal convection, counter-streaming sedimentation, and galvanization is highly promoted by its originator but has not gained wide acceptance due to lack of independent confirmation. Flow fractionation by laminar flow is said to provide up to 80% enrichment of both X- and Y-bearing sperm; however, this method also has not been confirmed by other workers or tested in breeding trials. The sixth theory discussed is that of separation through Sephadex gel filtration. This method may provide enrichment of X-bearing sperm, but, again, other experimenters have not been able to adequately confirm the enrichment. The best-known approach to sperm separation is that employing albumin centrifugation, yet even with this method, not all researchers have been able to confirm a final fraction rich in Y sperm, and trials in animals have given contradictory results. The most reliable method for separating X- and Y-bearing sperm is use of flow cytometric and flow sorting techniques. These techniques routinely separate fractions with a purity greater than 80% and can be above 90%. Unfortunately, these methods do not always work for human samples. Furthermore, as with electrophoretic approaches, the methods identify and separate only chemically fixed sperm and provide limited biological applications. Generally accepted experimental laboratory procedures for verification of proportions of X- and Y-bearing sperm are lacking. Staining of sperm with the fluorochrome dye quinacrine will identify a structure known as the “F-body” in human sperm and sperm from a few primates. The dye does not work other mammalian sperm. Its validity as a measure of sperm genotype is the topic of debate. We have used two methods to verify claims of separation of sperm. flow cytometry, and in vitro fusion. One can use flow cytometry to test the efficiency of separation of sperm samples. We tested seven commercial methods for the separation of bovine sper, and none were found of result in enrichment. We also used in vitro fusion of human sperm to denuded hamster ova to test enrichment of Y-bearing sperm from the albumin separation process. out results demonstrated no Y-bearing-sperm enrichment from this process. Scientific problems impeding the success of separation seem to be under investigation with an ever-increasing rate. Hybridization probes for DNA sequences specific to the X or Y chromosome may be the next appropriate technology to test of the selection and separation of X- and Y-chromosome-bearing mammalian sperm.     

Effect of sex-sorting on the ability of fresh and cryopreserved bull sperm to undergo an acrosome reaction

Previous studies indicate that sex-sorted sperm exhibit different physiology, including fertilizing capacity, from non-sorted sperm. However, differences between X- and Y-bearing sperm in their ability to undergo an acrosome reaction have never been investigated. This study determined the ability of non-sorted and sex-sorted sperm to undergo the acrosome reaction prior to and after cryopreservation. Sperm were treated with dilauroylphosphatidylcholine (PC12) to induce the acrosome reaction and the percentages of live-acrosome-reacted sperm and dead sperm were evaluated. The X- and Y-bearing sperm reacted similarly to the PC12 treatment, regardless of whether sperm were assessed prior to or after cryopreservation. Fresh control sperm exhibited lower percentages of live sperm (60%) than either X- or Y- sorted sperm (69-74%, P<0.05). Percentages of live control sperm were also lower after thawing (29-35%) than sex-sorted sperm (55-58%, P<0.05). Control and sex-sorted fresh sperm responded similarly to PC12 treatment. However, sex-sorted cryopreserved sperm exhibited higher percentages of live-acrosome-reacted sperm (23%) than control sperm (9%, P<0.05) after 40 min without PC12 treatment. In addition, cryopreserved control sperm treated with 79 microM PC12 exhibited higher percentages of live-acrosome-reacted sperm than sex-sorted sperm. In conclusion, X- and Y-bearing sperm responded similarly to PC12 treatment. In addition, fresh sexed and non-sorted sperm responded similarly to PC12 treatment. However, cryopreserved sex-sorted sperm underwent an acrosome reaction more rapidly in the absence of PC12 (over a 40 min period) than the non-sorted sperm. Therefore, sex-sorting induced changes in sperm membranes that accelerated the acrosome reaction process in sperm after cryopreservation.     

Determination of Y chromosome aneuploidy in human sperm nuclei by nonradioactive in situ hybridization.

Sperm nuclei from eight normal, healthy donors were hybridized in situ with the biotin-labeled Y-specific pHY2.1 DNA probe to evaluate the X:Y ratio, the location of the Y chromosome, and the frequency of Y aneuploidy in human sperm. The streptavidine-horseradish-peroxidase and DAB detection system used permitted the unequivocal identification of sperm heads with zero, one, or two hybridization signals and proved superior to either quinacrine staining or radioactive in situ hybridization. The low incidence of 0.27% of sperm nuclei with two Y chromosomes that was found is similar to the frequency of XYY males among newborns. The average proportions of X- and Y-bearing sperm nuclei were 50.3% and 49.4%, respectively, corresponding to the expected 1:1 ratio. The Y heterochromatin was located in the central part of the nucleus in 58% of the Y-carrying sperm cells.     

Sperm chromosome analysis of a man heterozygous for a pericentric inversion of chromosome 20

Summary The sperm chromosomes of a man heterozygous for inv(20)(p13q11.2) were analyzed. Twenty-six sperm chromosome complements were examined, of which fourteen contained the normal chromosome, and twelve the inverted chromosome. None of the sperm complements contained a recombinant chromosome 20. The frequency of structural chromosomal aberrations unrelated to the inversion was 11.5% (3/26). Numerical aberrations were not observed. The percentages of X- and Y-bearing sperm were 56% and 44%, respectively, which was similar to the expected 11 ratio.     

Evidence for differential maturation of reciprocal sperm segregants in the murine Rb(6.16) translocation heterozygote.

The fertilizing ability of unaged sperm and those aged experimentally in the cauda by surgically ligating the corpus epididymis in males carrying the Rb(6.16) translocation was studied. Chromosomally normal females were inseminated with unaged sperm delivered by males mating at 3-day intervals, and aged sperm were studied after matings on 6-14 postoperative days. The sperm chromosome complement was analyzed in first-cleavage metaphase zygotes after sequential G- and C-banding of the chromosomes. Of 283 metaphasic zygotes in the control group, 183 (or 64.7%) were analyzed and showed a ratio of 2.7:1 for chromosomally normal and balanced segregants of the translocation, deviating significantly (P less than 0.001) from the expected 1:1. The ratio of X- to Y-bearing sperm also deviated from expected (P less than 0.01) mostly due to a significant deficiency (P less than 0.05) of balanced sperm that were X-bearing. Fertilized oocytes were recovered from matings of 10 males on days 6-8 postoperatively, and, of 139 metaphasic one-cell zygotes, 101 (or 72.3%) were analyzed. These showed a Mendelian ratio of 1:1 for normal and balanced segregants. The sex ratio in the aged group (57Y:41X) also showed no deviation from 1:1. The results, which reveal significant physiological distortions for both the segregation and the sex ratios in males heterozygous for the Rb(6.16) translocation, suggest that differential maturation of the translocation-bearing sperm and the chromosomally normal reciprocal exists. The findings further support the concept that sperm chromosomal complement affects their maturation and function, and that factors on chromosome 6 and the X or Y chromosome additively affect sperm function.     

A method for cytogenetic analysis of boar spermatozoa using hamster oocytes.

In this paper, the authors detail a method for displaying boar spermatozoa chromosomes using heterospecific zona-free hamster oocyte penetration technique. Semen samples from two Large-White boars having a normal spermogram were studied. The first one had a normal karyotype (38,XY), the second carried a reciprocal translocation rcp(3;7)(p1,3;q2,1). After in vitro fertilization by capacitated sperm, culture and cytogenetic analysis of hamster eggs we obtained metaphase spreads of spermatozoa chromosomes. The ratio of X- and Y-bearing spermatozoa was 49.2% and 50.8%, respectively.     

Analysis of sperm chromosome complements from a man heterozygous for a pericentric inversion of chromosome 1

Human sperm chromosomes were studied in a man heterozygous for a pericentric inversion of chromosome (1)(p31q12). Q-banded pronuclear chromosomes were analyzed after in vitro penetration of golden hamster oocytes. A total of 159 sperm were examined: 54% bearing the inverted chromosome 1 and 46% the normal chromosome 1. These frequencies are not significantly different from the theoretical 11 ratio. There were no recombinant sperm with duplications or deficiencies, suggesting that a pairing loop failed to form or that crossing-over was suppressed. The frequency of abnormalities unrelated to the inversion was 5% for numerical, 8.8% for structural, 2.5% for numerical and structural, values not significantly different from control donors studied in our lab. The frequencies of X- and Y-bearing sperm were 46% and 54%, respectively, not significantly different from the expected value of 50%. This is the fifth pericentric inversion studied by human sperm chromosome analysis; recombinant chromosomes have been observed in two of the five cases. Some of the factors associated with an increased risk of recombinant sperm appear to be inversion size greater than 30% of the chromosome and chromosome breakpoints in G-light bands.     

The relationship between paternal age, sex ratios, and aneuploidy frequencies in human sperm, as assessed by multicolor FISH.

We studied the frequencies of X- and Y-chromosome-bearing sperm, diploidy and disomy for chromosomes 1, 12, X, and Y in sperm from 10 normal men aged 21-52 years, to determine whether there was any relationship between donor age and any of these variables. Multicolor FISH was used to control for lack of probe hybridization and to distinguish diploid sperm from disomic sperm. A minimum of 10,000 sperm per donor was evaluated for each chromosome, for a total of 225,846 sperm studied. Sperm were considered disomic if two fluorescent signals were separated by a minimal distance of one signal domain. The mean frequencies of X- and Y-bearing sperm were 50.1% and 49.0%, respectively; not significantly different from 50%. There was no correlation between paternal age and "sex ratio" in sperm. Similarly, there was no association between the frequency of diploid sperm (mean, .16%; range, .06-.42%) and donor age. For disomy frequencies, there was no relationship between donor age and disomy 12 (mean, .16%; range, .10%-.25%), XX (mean, .07%; range, .03%-.17%), and XY sperm (mean, .16%; range, .08%-.24%). There was a significant increase in the frequency of YY sperm (P = .04; mean, .18%; range, .10%-.43%) and disomy 1 sperm (P = .01; mean, .11%; range, .05%-.18%) with donor age. In summary, our results do not support a correlation between paternal age and sex ratio or diploidy.     

哺乳动物精子分离方法的研究进展

分离X、Y精子,用于人工授精或体外受精,是目前实现哺乳动物性别控制的最有效手段。本文对哺乳动物精子分离及分离精子纯度评估方法的研究历史及现状作一回顾和总结。     

Sex ratio in normal and disomic sperm: evidence that the extra chromosome 21 preferentially segregates with the Y chromosome.

In humans, deviations from a 1:1 male:female ratio have been identified in both chromosomally normal and trisomic live births: among normal newborns there is a slight excess of males, among trisomy 18 live borns a large excess of females, and among trisomy 21 live borns an excess of males. These differences could arise from differential production of or fertilization by Y- or X-bearing sperm or from selection against male or female conceptions. To examine the proportion of Y- and X-bearing sperm in normal sperm and in sperm disomic for chromosomes 18 or 21, we used three-color FISH (to the X and Y and either chromosome 18 or chromosome 21) to analyze >300,000 sperm from 24 men. In apparently normal sperm, the sex ratio was nearly 1:1 (148,074 Y-bearing to 148,657 X-bearing sperm), and the value was not affected by the age of the donor. Certain of the donors, however, had significant excesses of Y- or X-bearing sperm. In disomy 18 sperm, there were virtually identical numbers of Y- and X-bearing sperm; thus, the excess of females in trisomy 18 presumably is due to selection against male trisomic conceptions. In contrast, we observed 69 Y-bearing and 44 X-bearing sperm disomic for chromosome 21. This is consistent with previous molecular studies, which have identified an excess of males among paternally derived cases of trisomy 21, and suggests that some of the excess of males among Down syndrome individuals is attributable to a nondisjunctional mechanism in which the extra chromosome 21 preferentially segregates with the Y chromosome.     

Simultaneous detection of X- and Y-bearing human sperm by double fluorescence in situ hybridization

Double fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to detect sex chromosomes in decondensed human sperm nuclei. Biotinylated X chromosome specific (TRX) and digoxigenin-labeled Y chromosome specific (HRY) probes were simultaneously hybridized to sperm preparations from 12 normal healthy donors. After the hybridization, the probes were detected immuno-cytochemically, using two different and independent affinity systems. Ninety-six percent of the 12,636 sperm showed fluorescent labeling, of which 47.4% were haploid X and 46.8% were haploid Y. A frequency of 0.46% of XX-bearing sperm (0.28% disomic, 0.18% diploid) and 0.38% YY-bearing sperm (0.21% disomic, 0.17% diploid) was found. The overall proportions of X- and Y-bearing sperm in the ejaculates were 47.9% and 47.2%, respectively, which was not significantly different from the expected 50:50 ratio. In addition 0.21% of cells appeared to be haploid XY-bearing sperm, 0.62% were diploid XY-bearing cells, and 0.05% of cells were considered to be tetraploid cells. The application of double FISH to human sperm using X-chro-mosome and Y-chromosome probes has allowed a more accurate assessment of the sex chromosal complements in sperm than single FISH method and quinacrine staining for Y-bodies. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Effect of timing of artificial insemination on sex ratio

For a number of years, the time of insemination or mating during estrus has been believed to influence the sex ratio of offspring, with early insemination resulting in more females and late insemination, more males. Possible mechanisms of altering the sex ratio include facilitating or inhibiting the transport of either X- or Y-chromosome-bearing sperm through the reproductive tract, preferential selection of sperm at fertilization, or sex-specific death of embryos after fertilization. In livestock species, there is evidence for preferential selection of X- or Y-bearing sperm, based on the maturational state of the oocyte at fertilization. In deer and sheep, early and late insemination appears to skew the sex ratio toward females and males, respectively. In cattle, conflicting reports on the effect of time of insemination on sex ratio make the premise less clear. Many of the published studies lack adequate observations for definitive conclusions and/or are based on infrequent observations of estrus, making it difficult to assess the effect of time of insemination on sex ratio. It is likely that any effect of time of insemination on sex ratio in cattle is relatively small. Evidence is accumulating that treatments used for synchronization of estrus or ovulation in cattle may influence the sex ratio.