Evolution of satellite DNAs from the genus Palorus--experimental evidence for the "library" hypothesis

Satellite DNA profiles have been characterized in the congeneric species Palorus ratzeburgii, Palorus subdepressus, Palorus genalis, and Palorus ficicola (Coleoptera, Insecta), each of which contains a single, A + T-rich satellite DNA comprising a considerable portion of the genome (20%-40%). These satellites exhibit insignificant mutual sequence similarity. Using PCR assay, it has been shown that all four sequences are present in each of the tested Palorus species: one of them is amplified into a high copy number or a major satellite, while the three others are in the form of low-copy-number repeats estimated to make up approximately 0.05% of the genome. Each of the four satellites is interspecifically high conserved concerning the sequence, monomer length, and tandem repeat organization. Major, as well as low- copy-number, satellites are colocalized in the regions of pericentromeric heterochromatin on all chromosomes of the complement. The low-copy-number satellites are dispersed between the large arrays of the major satellite over the whole heterochromatic block. Our results explain satellite DNA evolution, confirming the hypothesis that related species share a "library" of conserved satellite sequences, some of which could be amplified into a major satellite. Due to the evolutionary dynamics of satellite DNAs, the content of the "library" is variable; the elimination of some sequences parallels the creation of the new ones. Quantitative changes in satellite DNAs, induced by occasional amplification of satellite repeat from the "library", could possibly occur in the course of the speciation process, thus forming a species-specific profile of satellite DNAs.      

Similarity of Structural Features and Evolution of Satellite DNAs from Palorus subdepressus (Coleoptera) and Related Species

A novel highly abundant satellite DNA comprising 20% of the genome has been characterized in Palorus subdepressus (Insecta, Coleoptera). The 72-bp-long monomer sequence is composed of two copies of T₂A₅T octanucleotide alternating with 22-nucleotide-long elements of an inverted repeat. Phylogenetic analysis revealed clustering of monomer sequence variants into two clades. Two types of variants are prevalently organized in an alternating pattern, thus showing a tendency to generate a new complex repeating unit 144 bp in length. Fluorescent in situ hybridization revealed even distribution of the satellite in the region of pericentric heterochromatin of all 20 chromosomes. P. subdepressus satellite sequence is clearly species specific, lacking similarity even with the satellite from congeneric species P. ratzeburgii. However, on the basis of similarity in predicted tertiary structure induced by intrinsic DNA curvature and in repeat length, P. subdepressus satellite can be classified into the same group with satellites from related tenebrionid species P. ratzeburgii, Tenebrio molitor, and T. obscurus. It can be reasonably inferred that repetitive sequences of different origin evolve under constraints to adopt and conserve particular features. Obtained results suggest that the higher-order structure and repeat length, but not the nucleotide sequence itself, are maintained through evolution of these species. Received: 23 April 1997 / Accepted: 11 July 1997     

Detection of satellite DNA in Palorus ratzeburgii: analysis of curvature profiles and comparison with Tenebrio molitor satellite DNA.

Very abundant and homogenous satellite DNA has been found in the flour beetle Palorus ratzeburgii, representing 40% of its genome. Sequencing of 14 randomly cloned satellite monomers revealed a conserved monomer length of 142 bp and an average A+T content of 68%. Sequence variation analysis showed that base substitutions, appearing with a frequency of 2.3%, are predominant differences among satellite monomers. The satellite sequence is unique without significant direct repeats and with only two potentially stable inverted repeats. After electrophoresis of satellite monomers on native polyacrylamide gel retarded mobilities characteristic for curved DNA molecules are observed. The curvature profiles and DNA helix axis trajectory are calculated on the basis of three different algorithms. These calculations predict that P ratzeburgii satellite DNA forms a left-handed solenoid superstructure. Comparison of described features with other satellite DNAs reveals some striking similarities with satellite DNA from related species Tenebrio molitor, which belongs to the same family of Tenebrionidae. Both satellites are very abundant and homogenous with the same, highly conserved monomer length, although there is no homology at the nucleotide level. Their monomers, as well as multimers, exhibit very similar retarded electrophoretic mobilities. The calculated curvature profiles predict two bend centers in monomers of each satellite, resulting in a model of left-handed solenoid superstructures of similar appearance.     

Detection of satellite DNA in Palorus ratzeburgii: Analysis of curvature profiles and comparison with Tenebrio molitor satellite DNA

Very abundant and homogenous satellite DNA has been found in the flour beetle Palorus ratzeburgii, representing 40% of its genome. Sequencing of 14 randomly cloned satelite monomers revealed a conserved monomer length of 142 bp and an average A+T content of 68%. Sequence variation analysis showed that base substitutions, appearing with a frequency of 2.3%, are predominant differences among satellite monomers. The satellite sequence is unique without significant direct repeats and with only two potentially stable inverted repeats. After electrophoresis of satellite monomers on native polyacrylamide gel retarded mobilities characteristic for curved DNA molecules are observed. The curvature profiles and DNA helix axis trajectory are calculated on the basis of three different algorithms. These calculations predict that P ratzeburgii satellite DNA forms a left-handed solenoid superstructure. Comparison of described features with other satellite DNAs reveals some striking similarities with satellite DNA from related species Tenebrio molitor, which belongs to the same family of Tenebrionidae. Both satellites are very abundant and homogenous with the same, highly conserved monomer length, although there is no homology at the nucleotide level. Their monomers, as well as multimers, exhibit very similar retarded electrophoretic mobilities. The calculated curvature profiles predict two bend centers in monomers of each satellite, resulting in a model of left-handed solenoid superstructures of similar appearance.     

Preservation and High Sequence Conservation of Satellite DNAs Suggest Functional Constraints

Due to a high evolutionary turnover many satellite DNAs are restricted to a group of closely related species. Here we demonstrate that the satellite DNA family PSUB, abundant in the beetle Palorus subdepressus, is distributed in a low number of copies among diverse taxa of Coleoptera (Insecta), some of them separated for an evolutionary period of up to 60 Myr. Comparison of PSUB cloned from the species Tribolium brevicornis with the PSUB family previously characterized in Palorus subdepressus revealed high sequence conservation and absence of fixed species-specific mutations. The most polymorphic sites are those with ancestral mutations shared among clones of both species. Since the ancestral mutations contribute significantly to overall diversity, it could be proposed that a similar mutational profile already existed in an ancestral species. The pattern of variability along the satellite monomer is characterized by the presence of conserved and variable regions. The nonrandom pattern of variability as well as the absence of sequence divergence is also discerned for PRAT satellite DNA, cloned previously from two Palorus species and a distantly related Pimelia elevata. Since PRAT and PSUB are present in parallel in diverse taxa of Coleoptera, we propose that their long evolutionary preservation suggests a possible functional significance. This indication is additionally supported not only by the high evolutionary conservation of the sequences, but also by the presence of significantly conserved and variable regions along the monomers. [Reviewing Editor: Dr. Jerzy Jurka]     

Complex structural features of satellite DNA sequences in the genus Pimelia (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae): random differential amplification from a common 'satellite DNA library'

The major satellites of the nine species of the subgenera Pimelia s. str. and Amblyptera characterised in this paper are composed of longer monomers (500 and 700 bp) than those described previously in 26 Pimelia s. str. taxa (357 bp, a sequence called PIM357). Sequence analysis reveals partial similarity among these satellites and with the PIM357 monomers. The discrepancy between the phylogeny obtained based on three mitochondrial and two nuclear markers and that deduced from satellite DNA (stDNA) sequences suggests that the different Pimelia satellites were already present in a common ancestor forming what has been called a 'satellite DNA library'. Thus, the satellite profiles in the living species result from a random amplification of sequences from that 'library' during diversification of the species. However, species-specific turnover in the sequences has occurred at different rates. They have included abrupt replacements, a gradual divergence and, in other cases, no apparent change in sequence composition over a considerable evolutionary time. The results also suggest a common evolutionary origin of all these Pimelia satellite sequences, involving several rearrangements. We propose that the repeat unit of about 500 bp has originated from the insertion of a DNA fragment of 141 bp into the PIM357 unit. The 705-bp repeats have originated from a 32-bp direct duplication and the insertion of a 141-bp fragment in inverted orientation relative to a basic structure of 533 bp.     

Nucleotide sequences of HS-α satellite DNA from kangaroo rat dipodomys ordii and characterization of similar sequences in other rodents

The most common repeated nucleotide sequences of the highly repetitive satellite HS-α fraction from kangaroo rat Dipodomys ordii was determined using ribosubstitution methods. This sequence was α nucleotides long and represented about 25% of the total HS-α satellite DNA, while the remaining DNA was composed of sequence variants related to the most common sequence. The sequences of the commonest of these variants are reported. Furthermore, the most common repeated sequence was identical to that reported for the α satellite of guinea pig Cavia porcellus. The α satellites of guinea pig, Cavia porcellus, pocket gopher, Thomomys bottae and antelope ground squirrel, Ammospermophilus leucurus, are shown to have sequences in common with the kangaroo rat. This implies that the simplest repeated sequences of mammalian satellite DNAs may persist over much longer evolutionary times than previously thought.Attempts to explain the very rapid quantitative changes in satellites whose sequence is strongly conserved have led us to consider that they might have a role in sympatric speciation. Among the novel features of the model presented is that fluctuations in satellites could be due to “speciation genes.” Such genes would confer a strong selective advantage in certain situations, and could explain the many puzzling instances in which large numbers of new related species have appeared over a short evolutionary span.     

Classification and molecular organization of satellites elucidated by phylogenetic network analysis - examples from Triturus salamanders and Palorus beetles

A phylogenetic network of 244 satellite DNA sequences across five species of aquatic salamanders (genus Triturus) revealed four types of satellite DNAs in a 'p'-shaped 1-2*-3-4-2* arrangement. Analysis of dimer and trimer DNA sequences revealed a prevalence of homosequential (e.g. 1-1, 2-2) and particular (1-4 and 2-3) heterosequential repeat motifs. Genetic diversity across types and species phylogeny indicated that type 1 and type 4 are derived from types 2 and 3. Support was also found for alternating motifs in Palorus flour beetle tandem repeats. The results were statistically significant, whether or not the underlying satellite DNA phylogenies were robust under bootstrap analysis.     

The biological significance of variation in satellite DNA and heterochromatin in newts of the genus Triturus: an evolutionary perspective

The functional and evolutionary significance of highly repetitive, simple sequence (satellite) DNA is analysed by examining available information on the patterns of variation of heterochromatin and cloned satellites among newts (family Salamandridae), and particularly species of the European genus Triturus. This information is used to develop a model linking evolutionary changes in satellite DNAs and chromosome structure. In this model, satellites accumulate initially in large tandem blocks around centromeres of some or all of the chromosomes, mainly by repeated chromosomal exchanges in these regions. Centromeric blocks later become broken up and dispersed by small, random chromosome rearrangements in these regions. They are dispersed first to pericentric locations and then gradually more distally into the chromosome arms and telomeres. Dispersal of a particular satellite is accompanied by changes in sequence structure (for example, base substitutions, deletions, etc.) and a corresponding decrease in its detectability at either the molecular or cytological level. On the basis of this model, observed satellites in newt species may be classified as 'old', 'young', or of 'intermediate' phylogenetic age. The functions and effects of satellite DNA and heterochromatin at the cellular and organismal levels are also discussed. It is suggested that satellite DNA may have an impact on cell proliferation through the effect of late-replicating satellite-rich heterochromatin on the duration of S-phase of the cell cycle. It is argued that even small alterations in cell cycle time due to changes in heterochromatin amount may have magnified effects on organismal growth that may be of adaptive significance.     

Observations on centromeric heterochromatin and satellite DNA in salamanders of the genus Plethodon

DNA from Plethodon cinereus cinereus separates into two fractions on centrifugation to equilibrium in neutral CsCl. The smaller of these fractions has been described as a high-density satellite. It represents about 2% of nuclear DNA from this species, and it has a density of 1.728 g/cm³. It is cytologically localized near the centromeres of all 14 chromosomes of the haploid set. In P. c. cinereus the heavy satellite DNA constitutes about 1/4 of the DNA in centromeric heterochromatin. The nature of the rest of the DNA in centromeric heterochromatin is unknown. The number of heavy satellite sequences clustered around the centromeres in a chromosome from P. c. cinereus is roughly proportional to the size of the chromosome, as determined by in situ hybridization with satellite-complementary RNA, and autoradiography. Likewise the amount of contromeric heterochromatin, as identified by its differential stainability with Giemsa, shows a clear relationship to chromosome size. — The heavy satellite sequences identified in DNA from P. c. cinereus are also present in smaller amounts in other closely related forms of Plethodon. Plethodon cinereus polycentratus and P. richmondi have approximately half as many of these sequences per haploid genome as P. c. cinereus. P. hoffmani and P. nettingi shenandoah have about 1/3 as many of these sequences as P. c. cinereus. P. c. cinereus, P. c. polycentratus, and P. richmondii all have detectable heavy satellites with densities of 1.728 g/cm³. Among these forms, satellite size as determined by optical density measurements, and number of satellite sequences as determined from hybridization studies, vary co-ordinately. P. c. cinereus heavy satellite sequences are not detectable in P. nettingi, P. n. hubrichti, or P. dorsalis. The latter species has a heavy satellite with a density of 1.718 g/cm³, representing about 8% of the genomic DNA, and two light satellites whose properties have not been investigated. The heavy satellite of P. dorsalis is cytologically localized in the centromeric heterochromatin of this species. — These observations are discussed in relation to the function and evolution of highly repetitive DNA sequences in the centromeric heterochromatin of salamanders and other organisms.     

Isolation of low-copy-number sequences that neighbor satellite DNA in mammals

To investigate the role of satellite DNA in eukaryotic genomes, we isolated from an African green monkey (Cercopithecus aethiops) genomic library cloned segments containing the previously described deca-satellite linked to low-copy-number genomic sequences. Three such clones were obtained. The low-copy-number sequences in the three clones do not cross-hybridize suggesting that they derive from different genomic loci. The structure of one of the clones, λAMkA, is described in detail. Subcloned segments containing the low-copy-number sequences from λAMkA anneal to monkey, human and mouse genomic DNA. The subcloned probes were used to select clones containing homologous sequences from a second, independent monkey library as well as from human and mouse genomic libraries. Several of the newly isolated monkey clones hybridized to probes containing the species-specific deca- and -satellites, confirming the genomic association of the low-copy-number sequence in λAMkA with satellite DNA. Moreover, several of the human and mouse clones hybridized to species-specific human and mouse satellite DNAs, respectively. These experiments indicate that the low-copy-number sequence in λMkA and its association with satellite DNA is conserved in primates and rodents.     

Evolution of the structure and composition of house mouse satellite DNA sequences in the subgenus Mus (Rodentia: Muridea): a cytogenomic approach

The composition and orientation of the house mouse satellite DNA sequences (minor, major, TLC) were investigated by a FISH and CO-FISH approach in 11 taxa belonging to three clades of the subgenus Mus. Using a phylogenetic framework, our results highlighted two distribution patterns. The TLC satellite, the most recently discovered satellite, was present in all clades but varied quantitatively among species. This distribution supported its appearance in the ancestor of the subgenus followed by independent evolution in species of each clade. In contrast, the minor and major satellites occurred in only two clades of the subgenus indicating the simultaneous and recent amplification of these sequences. In addition, although qualitative differences in the composition and orientation of the satellite sequences were observed among the taxa, none of the features studied were unique to the house mouse and could account for the extensive chromosomal plasticity evidenced in Mus musculus domesticus.     

Satellite Ic: a possible link between the satellite DNAs of D. virilis and D. melanogaster.

In this study, we isolated and characterized a previously undetected cryptic satellite DNA comprising 0.1% of the total nuclear genome of D. virilis. This satellite is hidden from detection in neutral CsCl by satellite I and is therefore designated cryptic satellite I or Ic. Sequence analysis reveals that Ic is the repeating heptanucleotide [poly d(AATATAG): d(CTATATT)]. It is more closely related to the three simple sequence satellite DNAs of D. melanogaster, a distantly related species, than it is to any of the major D. virilis satellite DNA sequences. Ic may therefore be a link between the simple sequence satellites of D. virilis and D. melanogaster. As an extension of this theory, we have constructed a "family tree" linking the satellites of D. virilis and D. melanogaster by a series of "simple" operations. Only one intermediate required by this evolutionary scheme has not yet been identified.     

Sequence of PRAT Satellite DNA ``Frozen' in Some Coleopteran Species

The intriguing diversity of highly abundant satellite repeats found even among closely related species can result from processes leading to dramatic changes in copy number of a particular sequence in the genome and not from rapid accumulation of mutations. To test this hypothesis, we investigated the distribution of the PRAT satellite DNA family, a highly abundant major satellite in the coleopteran species Palorus ratzeburgii, in eight species belonging to the related genera (Tribolium, Tenebrio, Latheticus), the subfamily (Pimeliinae), and the family (Chrysomelidae). Dot blot analysis and PCR assay followed by Southern hybridization revealed that the PRAT satellite, in the form of low-copy number repeats, was present in all tested species. The PRAT satellite detected in the species Pimelia elevata has been sequenced, and compared with previously cloned PRAT monomers from Palorus ratzeburgii and Palorus subdepressus. Although the two Palorus species diverged at least 7 Myr ago, and the subfamily Pimeliinae separated from the genus Palorus 50–60 Myr ago, all PRAT clones exhibit high mutual homology, with average variability relative to the common consensus sequence of 1.3%. The presence of ancestral mutations found in PRAT clones from all three species as well as the absence of species diagnostic mutations illustrate extremely slow sequence evolution. This unexpectedly high conservation of PRAT satellite DNA sequence might be induced by a small bias of turnover mechanisms favoring the ancestral sequence in the process of molecular drive.     

Sex chromosome associated satellite DNA: Evolution and conservation

Satellites visible in female but not in male DNA were isolated from the snakesElaphe radiata (satellite IV, p = 1.708 g · cm^–3) andBungarus fasciatus (BK¹ minor, p=1.709 g · cm^–3). The satellites cross hybridize. Hybridization of³H labelled nick translated BK minor satellite DNA with the total male and female DNA and/or chromosomes in situ of different species of snakes revealed that its sequences are conserved throughout the snake group and are mainly concentrated on the W chromosome. Snakes lacking sex chromosomes do possess related sequences but there is no sex difference and visible related satellites are absent. The following conclusions have been reached on the basis of these results. 1. The W chromosome associated satellite DNA is related to similar sequences scattered in the genome. 2. The origin and increment in the number of the W satellite DNA sequence on the W chromosome is associated with the heterochromatinization of the W. 3. Satellite sequences have become distributed along the length of the W and resulted in morphological differentiation of sex chromosomes. 4. Evolutionary conservation of W satellite DNA strongly suggests that functional constraints may have limited sequence divergence.     

Evolution of Satellite DNAs in a Radiation of Endemic Hawaiian Spiders: Does Concerted Evolution of Highly Repetitive Sequences Reflect Evolutionary History?

Satellite DNAs are known for an unusual and nonuniform evolution characterized by rapid evolutionary change between species and concerted evolution leading to molecular homogeneity within species. In this paper we use satellite DNAs for phylogenetic analysis of a rapidly evolving lineage of spiders and compare the phylogeny with a hypothesis previously generated based on mitochondrial DNA and allozymes. The spiders examined include almost all species within a monophyletic clade of endemic Hawaiian Tetragnatha species, the spiny-leg clade. The phylogeny based on satellite sequences is largely congruent to those produced by mtDNA and allozymes, except that the satellite DNA yields much longer branches, with higher levels of support for any given node. Closely related species that have differentiated ecologically within an island are well resolved with satellite DNA but much less so with mtDNA. These results suggest that Tetragnatha stDNA repeats seem to be evolving gradually and cohesively during the diversification of these endemic Hawaiian spiders. The study also reveals gain–loss of satellite DNA copies during species diversification. We conclude that satellite DNA sequences may potentially be very useful for resolving relationships between rapidly evolving taxa within an adaptive radiation. In addition, satellite DNA as a nuclear marker suggests that hybridization or peripatry could play a possible role in species formation that cannot be revealed by mitochondrial markers due to its maternal inheritance.This article contains online supplementary data.Reviewing Editor: Dr. Rafael Zardoya     

Satellite DNAs contain sequences that induced curvature

The repeating units of mouse, rat, and alpha-monkey satellites have been cloned. All three show properties that are characteristic of curved DNA: (i) their migration in polyacrylamide gels is slower than predicted from their sequences, and (ii) they appear as curved molecules when visualized by electron microscopy. All three satellite repeats contain runs of d(A.T)n greater than or equal to 3 residues that are likely to be responsible for their curvature. From analysis of 20 different satellite DNA sequences, we conclude that, in satellite DNA, adenine residues show a high tendency to cluster in groups of three or more.     

Repeated sequences in the DNA of Drosophila and their localization in giant chromosomes

It is shown by isopycnic density gradient centrifugation that the DNAs of the sibling species Drosophila hydei, Drosophila neohydei and Drosophila pseudoneohydei differ regarding the numbers and proportions of satellite DNA bands. An overwhelming proportion of all repetitive nucleotide sequences of the DNA is contained in these satellite fractions. The majority of the satellites are species specific despite the close phylogenetic and cytological relationship between the three species studied. — By in situ hybridization experiments it is demonstrated that the various satellite sequences occupy different positions within the chromosomes. All types of localization patterns, from a wide spread occurrence in all chromosomes to an apparent restriction to kinetochore regions of single chromosomes, have been observed. Main band DNA, on the other hand, in its hybridization behavior reflects the DNA distribution according to the banding pattern in giant chromosomes. Generally satellite sequences seem to be included in -heterochromatic chromosome regions but no relation to the heterochromatin of the Y-chromosome was found. — Renaturation studies support various evidence that satellite sequences occur in tandemly repetitious units. At least some of this repetitious material seems to be linked to non-satellite DNA sequences or to DNA of other satellites.     

Detection and location of three simple sequence DNAs in polytene chromosomes from virilis group species of Drosophila

In vitro synthesized RNAs complementary to the three satellite DNAs of Drosophila virilis have been used in a series of in situ hybridization experiments with polytene chromosomes from virilis group species. Gall and Atherton (1974) demonstrated that each of the satellites of D. virilis is comprised of many repeats of a distinct, seven base pair long, simple sequence. With few exceptions, copies of each of these simple sequences are detected in the chromocenters of all virilis group species. This is true even in species which do not possess satellite DNAs at buoyant densities corresponding to those of the satellite DNAs of D. virilis. Small quantities of the three simple sequences are also detected in euchromatic arms of several different species. The same euchromatic location may contain detectable copies of one, two, or all three simple sequence DNAs. The amounts of simple sequences at each location in the euchromatin may vary between species, between different stocks of the same species, and even between individuals of the same stock. The simple sequences located in the euchromatin appear to undergo DNA replication during formation of polytene chromosomes unlike those in heterochromatin. The locations of the euchromatic sequences are not the results of single chromosomal inversion events involving heterochromatic and euchromatic breakpoints.