MHC-restricted recognition of autologous melanoma by tumor-specific cytotoxic T cells. Evidence for restriction by a dominant HLA-A allele.

Autologous melanoma-specific CTL recognize a common tumor-associated Ag (TAA) in the context of HLA class I antigens. We have demonstrated that HLA-A2 can be a restricting Ag and, in T cell lines homozygous for HLA-A2, that CTL can be generated by stimulation with HLA-A2 allogeneic melanomas. In the current study, we have investigated T cell lines from patients who are heterozygous at HLA-A region locus, to determine the relative importance of each A-region allele in this MHC-restricted recognition of tumor. We have shown that HLA-A1 can be a restricting Ag, and that allogeneic melanomas expressing HLA-A1 can substitute for the autologous tumor in the generation of HLA-A1-restricted CTL. However, when T cell lines express both HLA-A1 and HLA-A2, the HLA-A2 allele governed restriction of the melanoma TAA. Three autologous-stimulated HLA-A1, A2 CTL lines all demonstrated restriction by the HLA-A2 allele, when examined in cytotoxicity assays, cold-competition assays, and proliferation assays. There was no evidence of restriction by the second HLA-allele, HLA-A1. Although the autologous-stimulated CTL use a single A-region allele for tumor recognition, the autologous HLA-A1, A2 tumors are lysed by both HLA-A1-restricted and HLA-A2-restricted CTL. The dominance of restricting alleles was further demonstrated when HLA-matched allogeneic melanomas were used as the stimulating tumor to generate tumor-specific CTL. Stimulation of the heterozygous (HLA-A1, A2) lymphocytes with HLA-A2-matched allogeneic melanomas resulted in CTL specific for the autologous tumor, and restricted by the HLA-A2 Ag. However, stimulation with an HLA-A1-matched allogeneic melanoma failed to induce tumor-specific CTL restricted by the HLA-A1 Ag. The data suggest there is a dominance of HLA-A region Ag at the level of the T cell, such that only one is restricting in the recognition of the autologous melanoma. At the level of the tumor, however, the TAA is expressed in the context of both HLA-A region alleles. We can generate specific CTL from lymph node cells or PBL and HLA-A region matched allogeneic melanomas; however, because most patients are heterozygous at the HLA-A region locus, an understanding of the dominant restricting alleles must be obtained so that an appropriately matched allogeneic melanoma can be selected.     

MHC-restricted cytotoxic response of chicken T cells: expression, augmentation, and clonal characterization

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted cytotoxicity of chicken lymphocytes was studied by using three reticuloendotheliosis virus (REV)-transformed cell lines as targets in 51Cr-release assays. The cell lines, designated RECC-UG5, RECC-UG6, and RECC-UG8, were developed from bone marrow cells of REV-infected line G-B1, line G-B2, and (G-B1 X G-B2)F1 chickens respectively. Effector cells were obtained from spleens of G-B1, G-B2, F1, and F2 chickens 7 days after inoculation of REV. The inbred G-B1 (MHC genotype B13/B13) and G-B2 (MHC genotype B6/B6) lines originate from a common partially inbred line. Initial studies with effector cells from G-B1 and G-B2 chickens showed that significant cytotoxicity occurred only with syngeneic target cells. The degree of cytotoxicity was markedly enhanced by neonatally treating effector cell donors with cyclophosphamide (CY) and delaying virus challenge until the birds were 4 wk old. Augmentation of cytotoxicity was presumed to be due to elimination of bursal-dependent suppressor T cells by CY. The results with spleen cells from REV-inoculated F2 birds clearly showed that cytotoxicity was MHC restricted; i.e., significant lysis only occurred if effector cells and target cells had a common B system antigen. Lysis of RECC-UG5 targets was three to four times higher than lysis of RECC-UG6 targets when effector cells were from heterozygous (B6/B13)F1 and F2 birds. Because these two target cell lines generally showed a similar degree of lysis by effector cells from syngeneic B homozygous birds, the differences obtained with effector cells from B heterozygous birds was most likely due to differences in the number of effector cells with specificity for each target line. Evidence for an additive cytotoxic effect, considered to be due to the lytic activity of two separate T cell clones, was obtained when F1 effector cells were tested with the F1-derived RECC-UG8 targets. The results of other experiments indicated that the effector cells were of T cell lineage and that their activity was probably directed against virus-induced antigens on the transformed target cells.     

Class I MHC-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition of cells infected with human cytomegalovirus does not require endogenous viral gene expression.

The human pathogen CMV, is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in immunocompromised hosts. The CD8+ class I-restricted CTL response to CMV assists in preventing progression of CMV infection to life-threatening disease; however, the viral Ag recognized by CD8+ CTL are not well characterized. In general, virus-specific CTL recognize endogenously synthesized viral proteins processed and presented associated with class I MHC molecules. Although proteins or inactivated virions have been experimentally delivered to the cytoplasm to result in class I MHC presentation, this mode of Ag delivery to the class I processing pathway after natural viral entry has not been documented in humans. Our data demonstrate that the CMV-specific class I-restricted CTL response in individuals latently infected with CMV is predominantly specific for selected structural virion proteins introduced into the cell after viral penetration and efficient recognition occurs in the absence of de novo viral gene expression. This CTL response may provide a biological advantage for limiting the spread of infection after CMV reactivation because infected cells are lysed before viral assembly.     

Differences in the MHC-restricted self-recognition repertoire of intra-thymic and extra-thymic cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors

The MHC specificity of TNP-specific pCTL from the thymus and spleen of F1 leads to parent chimeras was evaluated. It was found that in the presence of exogenously added helper factor IL 2, thymic pCTL were restricted to recognizing TNP only in association with host MHC determinants, whereas splenic pCTL recognized TNP in association with either host or donor MHC determinants. Thus, the spleens of F1 leads to parent chimeras contain a pCTL repertoire that is not present intrathymically. Data are presented which suggest that such pCTL did nevertheless differentiate into functional competence in the chimeric host. These results are consistent with extra-thymic differentiation as the mechanism by which such nonthymically restricted pCTL may have developed.     

Role of endogenous peptides in murine allogenic cytotoxic T cell responses assessed using transfectants of the antigen-processing mutant 174xCEM.T2.

One model to explain the high frequency of alloreactive T cells proposes that allogeneic MHC molecules are recognized together with host cell-derived peptides. A model system was developed to investigate the relevance of this mechanism by expression of H-2Dd or H-2Ld in 174xCEM.T2 (T2) cells. This human cell line contains a mutation in its Ag-processing pathway that should restrict the association of endogenous peptides with cell surface class I molecules. CTL generated by stimulating C57BL/6 (H-2b) responder cells with H-2Dd or H-2Ld transfectants of the human B cell line C1R or the murine T cell lymphoma EL4 were assayed for their ability to recognize alloantigenic determinants on these transfectants. The major fraction of the H-2Dd-specific allogeneic CTL response, generated in a MLC or under clonal limiting dilution conditions, was composed of T cells that recognized H-2Dd expressed on C1R or EL4 cells, but failed to recognize this molecule on T2 cells. Clonal analysis indicated that approximately one-third of these CTL recognized determinants that were unique to H-2Dd expressed on C1R stimulator cells whereas the remainder recognized determinants that were also found on EL4 transfectants. Less than 10% of H-2Dd-reactive CTL recognized the T2 transfectant, and these clones also killed C1R-Dd and EL4-Dd. This result suggests that the great majority of H-2Dd-specific alloreactive CTL recognize determinants that are formed by a complex of H-2Dd with endogenous peptides that are absent or significantly reduced in T2 cells. Based on recognition of human or murine transfectants, these CTL exhibit some level of specificity for the structure or composition of the bound peptides. Examination of allogeneic CTL specific for H-2Ld revealed populations similar to those described for H-2Dd. In addition, a major new population was present that recognized determinants shared between C1R-Ld and T2-Ld but not present on EL4-Ld. These results are consistent with the idea that the alloreactive response to H-2Ld is also largely dependent on the presence of bound peptide. However, they also may indicate that the H-2Ld molecule expressed on T2 cells is occupied by one or more peptides that are shared with other human, but not murine, cells. The significance of these results to current models of alloreactivity is discussed.     

Inhibition of class I and class II MHC-restricted antigen presentation by cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for an exogenous antigen.

Ag in the extracellular fluids can be internalized, processed, and presented in association with class I MHC molecules on specialized APC in normal spleen. We examine the fate of these APC after they present Ag to a CTL. When splenocytes present exogenous OVA to CTL, their ability to subsequently present native Ag in association with both class I and class II molecules is inhibited. CTL do not inhibit the ability of splenocytes to present processing independent peptides with class I or class II molecules. Inhibition of Ag presentation is only observed in the presence of the specific Ag recognized by the CTL. This inhibition is MHC-restricted. In the presence of specific Ag, CTL inhibit the ability of APC to present unrelated Ag. However, bystander APC are not affected by activated CTL. Taken together these results indicate that when APC present exogenous Ag to CTL, they are inhibited or killed. The CTL that mediates this activity has a conventional CD4-CD8+ phenotype and utilizes a TCR-alpha beta. The potential significance of these findings and their possible relationship to phenomena associated with Ts cells are discussed.     

Role of uncultured human melanoma cells in the proliferation of autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes.

The role of uncultured melanoma cells in the proliferation of autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) was investigated. Uncultured autologous tumor cells by themselves induced modest, but significant, proliferation in 10 of 13 (77%) CTL clones and in only two of nine non-CTL clones. Uncultured allogenic melanoma cells mostly failed to induce CTL proliferation. Autologous tumor-induced CTL proliferation declined with increasing age of the culture. It did not correlate with IL-2 receptor-alpha expression or was not inhibited by addition of anti-IL-2 antibody to the culture. It was inhibited by pretreatment of tumor cells with anti-MHC class II, but not -MHC class I mAb. IL-2 alone was sufficient for the potent proliferation of five of nine CTL clones. In all these five CTL clones, autologous tumor cells suppressed IL-2-induced proliferation. The remaining four CTL clones, however, required both uncultured autologous melanoma cells and IL-2 for the proliferation. IL-4 or IL-6, in particular IL-6, facilitated IL-2-induced CTL proliferation, but not their cytotoxicity. In summary, uncultured melanoma cells by themselves induced modest levels of CTL proliferation in the context of MHC class II antigens, whereas they suppressed IL-2-induced CTL proliferation in more than half of the clones.     

Activation of MHC-restricted rat T cells by cloned syngeneic thyrocytes

We have previously demonstrated that rat thyrocytes express MHC class II Ag (RT1.B&D) in response to IFN-gamma. To determine whether MHC class II-positive thyrocytes can be recognized by MHC-restricted T cells, we used our clone of rat thyroid cells (1B-6) derived from the Fisher rat thyroid cell line (FRTL-5) and known to express MHC class II Ag in response to recombinant rat IFN-gamma. CD4+ and CD8+ normal syngeneic Fisher rat spleen T cells were selected by flow cytometry and averaged greater than 96% purity. We demonstrated that irradiated MHC class II-positive but not class II-negative 1B-6 thyrocytes stimulated CD4+ T cells in a primary sensitization reaction over 4 days. In contrast, CD8+ T cells had no response in similar experiments. This stimulation of CD4+ T cells was dose dependent for 1B-6 thyrocytes and was abrogated by anti-rat MHC class II mAb (MRC OX-6). Autoreactive (Fisher) and alloreactive (Buffalo) T cell lines and isolated CD4+ T cells derived from these lines, which were developed against Fisher rat spleen cells, similarly recognized MHC class II Ag expressed on 1B-6 cells but had no detectable response to 1B-6 MHC class II-negative thyrocytes or MHC class II-positive human thyroid cells. The CD4+ T cell recognition of 1B-6 cells via MHC class II Ag supports our previous data with autologous human thyroid T cell co-cultures and is indicative of an autospecific role for thyrocytes in the development of autoimmune thyroiditis.     

Role of lymphokine-secreting CD8+ T cells in cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses against vaccinia virus

The present study has examined the relative role of CD4+ and CD8+ Th cells in the generation and reactivation of antivaccinia virus memory CTL responses. We show that mice primed in vivo to vaccinia virus generate in vitro antivaccinia virus memory CTL responses through both CD4+ and CD8+ Th cell pathways, with the CD4+ Th pathway being the more prominent of the two. In addition, we show that vaccinia virus-specific CD8+ Th cell function is mediated through production of lymphokines, including IL-2, and that the CD8+ Th cell component in the CTL response is labile, decreasing progressively with increasing time after in vivo priming. Thus, this study demonstrates the existence of two phenotypically distinct Th cell pathways in the generation of antivirus CTL responses.     

Detection of cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for synthetic peptides of gp160 in HIV-seropositive individuals.

Four synthetic peptides corresponding to the IIIB sequence of gp160 of HIV were recently reported to stimulate Th cell function by PBL from HIV-infected, asymptomatic patients. In the present report, we used these same peptides to demonstrate CTL activity in a similar patient population. EBV-transformed B-cell lines from asymptomatic, HIV seropositive and seronegative control donors were pre-incubated with the peptides. Fresh PBL from 19 (76%) of 25 HIV seropositive donors lysed autologous targets pulsed with at least one of the four peptides. Autologous targets pulsed with two non-immunogenic peptides were not lysed. PBL from none of the eight HIV seronegative controls lysed peptide-preincubated autologous targets. The CTL activity was mediated by T cells, was predominantly MHC class I restricted, and was increased by in vitro restimulation of PBL with the peptides. HLA A-2 was identified as a restricting element for all four peptides in different patients, and for three of the peptides in the same donor. HLA-A1 or -B8 may also present some of the peptides. Thus, the same peptides can be recognized by human Th cells and class I MHC-restricted CTL.     

Rotavirus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes cross-react with target cells infected with different rotavirus serotypes.

Splenocytes from adult C57BL6 (H-2b) mice orally inoculated with nonmurine rotaviruses lysed syngeneic rotavirus-infected target cells. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) were responsible for this cytotoxic activity. Cytotoxic activity was (i) detected 7 days after primary oral inoculation; (ii) not detected in uninoculated animals; (iii) specific for rotavirus-infected target cells; (iv) eliminated by treatment with Thy 1.2-specific immunoglobulin M and complement; and (v) restricted at H-2Db. In addition, rotavirus-specific CTLs cross-reacted with target cells infected with different human or animal rotavirus serotypes. Heterotypic protection against rotavirus challenge may be mediated by cross-reactive CTLs.     

MHC-restricted, glycopeptide-specific T cells show specificity for both carbohydrate and peptide residues

We examined the antigenic specificity of two T cell hybridomas elicited against the disaccharide galabiose attached to the fifth residue of the I-Ak binding peptide 52-61 of lysozyme. By making changes in the saccharide molecule and in the peptide, we conclude that the outer galactose residue of the galabiose moiety is directly recognized by the T cells together with the exposed side chains of the peptide. The overall spatial display of this galactose moiety on the 52-61 peptide is likewise important.     

CD8 is needed for development of cytotoxic T cells but not helper T cells.

A mutant mouse strain without CD8 (Lyt-2 and Lyt-3) expression on the cell surface has been generated by disrupting the Lyt-2 gene using embryonic stem cell technology. In these mice, CD8+ T lymphocytes are not present in peripheral lymphoid organs, but the CD4+ T lymphocyte population seems to be unaltered. Cytotoxic response of T lymphocytes from these mice against alloantigens and viral antigens is dramatically decreased. Proliferative response against alloantigens and in vivo help to B lymphocytes, however, are not affected. These data suggest that CD8 is necessary for the maturation and positive selection of class I MHC restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes but is not required on any of the intermediate thymocyte populations (CD8+CD4-TcR- or CD4+CD8+TcRlow) during the development of functional class II MHC restricted helper T cells.     

T lymphocyte responses to non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens. I. Role of Ly-1+2+ T cells as cytotoxic effectors and requirement for Ly-1+2+ T cells for optimal generation of cytotoxic effectors

Cytotoxic effector T cells specific for non-H-2 histocompatibility (H) antigens were examined for phenotypic expression of lymphocyte differentiation (Ly) antigens. Virtually all H-Y-specific cytotoxic effectors generated in mixed lymphocyte culture were Ly-1+2+ T cells. H-3-specific effectors comprised both Ly-1+2+ and Ly-1-2+ T cells. However, cytotoxic effectors specific for multiple non-H-2 H antigens were predominantly Ly-1-2+ T cells. The optimal generation of H-Y- and H-3-specific effectors required Ly-1+2+ T cells; optimal generation of multiple non-H-2 H antigen-specific effectors required an interaction between Ly-1+2- and Ly-1-2+ T cells. These observations suggest that the identity of the target H antigen in part determines the Ly type of responsive T cells. Our observations suggest that 2 alternative pathways of T cell response exist for non-H-2 H antigens. The first pathway involves an interaction between Ly-1+2- helper T cells and Ly-1-2+ cytotoxic effector precursors. The 2nd pathway simply involves the response of Ly-1+2+ T cells proliferating and generating H antigen-specific cytotoxic effectors.     

The predominance of CD8+ T cells after infection with measles virus suggests a role for CD8+ class I MHC-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in recovery from measles. Clonal analyses of human CD8+ class I MHC-restricted CTL

Stimulation of PBMC, in children recovering from acute measles, with autologous EBV-transformed and measles virus (MV)-infected lymphoblastoid cell lines (B-LCL) expanded primarily MV-specific CD8+ T cells. A large number of CD8+ T cell clones were obtained either by passaging of bulk cultures at limiting dilutions or by direct cloning of PBMC without previous stimulation in bulk culture. The MV-specific CD8+ T cell clones responding in a proliferative and a CTL assay were found to be class I MHC restricted. In contrast, CD4+ MV-specific T cell clones, which were generated by the same protocol, recognized MV in association with class II MHC molecules. Analysis of processing requirements for Ag presentation to CD8+ and CD4+ T cell clones, measured by the effect of chloroquine in a proliferative T cell response, revealed that both types of T cells recognized MV Ag processed via the endogenous/cytoplasmic pathway. Thus, these studies indicate that, as in most other viral infections and in contrast to previous suggestions, the class I MHC-restricted CTL response by CD8+ T cells may be an important factor in the control and elimination of MV infection. Therefore, the role proposed for CD4+ class II-restricted T cells in recovery from measles needs to be reevaluated.     

A structure-based approach to designing non-natural peptides that can activate anti-melanoma cytotoxic T cells

Tumor antigens presented by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules and recognized by CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) may generate an efficient antitumor immune response after appropriate immunization. Antigenic peptides can be used in vivo to induce antitumor or antiviral immunity. The efficiency of naked peptides may be greatly limited by their degradation in the biological fluids. We present a rational, structure-based approach to design structurally modified, peptidase-resistant and biologically active analogues of human tumor antigen MAGE-1.A1. This approach is based on our understanding of the peptide interaction with the MHC and the T cell receptor and its precise degradation pathway. Knowledge of these mechanisms led to the design of a non-natural, minimally modified analogue of MAGE-1.A1, [Aib2, NMe-Ser8]MAGE-1.A1, which was highly peptidase-resistant and bound to MHC and activated MAGE-1.A1-specific anti-melanoma CTLs. Thus, we showed that it is possible to structurally modify peptide epitopes to obtain analogues that are still specifically recognized by CTLs. Such analogues may represent interesting leads for antitumor synthetic vaccines.     

Predominant T cell receptor gene elements in TNP-specific cytotoxic T cells.

H-2b class I-restricted, TNP-specific CTL clones were obtained by limiting dilution cloning of either short term polyclonal CTL lines or spleen cells of TNP-immunized mice directly ex vivo. Sequence analyses of mRNA coding for TCR alpha- and beta-chains of 11 clones derived from CTL lines from individual C57BL/6 mice revealed that all of them expressed unique but clearly nonrandom receptor structures. Five alpha-chains (45%) employed V alpha 10 gene elements, and four of those (36%) were associated with J beta 2.6-expressing beta-chains. The alpha-chains from these four TCR, moreover, contained an acidic amino acid in position 93 of their N or J region-determined sequences. Clones isolated directly from spleen cells carried these types of receptors at lower frequency, 27% V alpha 10 and 19% J beta 2.6, indicating that bulk in vitro cultivation on Ag leads to selection for these particular receptors. However, even in TNP-specific CTL cloned directly ex vivo, V alpha 10 usage was increased about fivefold over that in Ag-independently activated T cells in H-2b mice (4 to 5%). The selection for V alpha 10/J beta 2.6-expressing cells was obtained repeatedly in other TNP-specific CTL lines from C57BL/6 mice but not in FITC-specific CTL from the same strain or in TNP-specific CTL lines from B10.BR (H-2k) or B10.D2 (H-2d) mice. We conclude from this (a) that the selection for V alpha 10/J beta 2.6+ T cells is driven by the complementarity of these receptors to a combination of TNP and MHC epitopes and (b) that predominant receptor structures reflect the existence of a surprisingly limited number of "T cell-relevant" hapten determinants on the surface of covalently TNP-modified cells.     

Role of de novo protein synthesis in target cells recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for vesicular stomatitis virus.

The requirements for viral and host protein synthesis in the generation of target antigens for cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) was evaluated by using vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) inactivated by UV irradiation (UV-VSV). EL4 target cells incubated with UV-VSV were recognized and lysed by anti-VSV CTL, indicating that de novo synthesis of viral proteins was not required for the generation of antigens recognized by antiviral CTL. Anti-VSV CTL from H-2b mice primarily recognize determinants derived from the VSV N protein bound to the class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigen H-2Kb. Comparison of a cloned CTL line representing this specificity and a heterogeneous population of anti-VSV CTL showed that determinants other than that recognized by the cloned CTL were generated more efficiently from UV-VSV. By using vaccinia virus recombinants that express deletion fragments of the N protein, it was shown that these additional determinants were probably derived from VSV proteins other than the N protein. The protein synthesis inhibitor emetine was used to determine whether newly synthesized host proteins were required for antigen generation. The addition of emetine to target cells prior to or at the time of the addition of UV-VSV inhibited lysis by anti-VSV CTL. This inhibition could be due to depletion of newly synthesized MHC molecules from intracellular membranes. This hypothesis was supported by using brefeldin A to delay membrane protein transport in target cells during the time of incubation with emetine and UV-VSV, which resulted in partial reversal of the effect of emetine. These results suggest that newly synthesized class I MHC molecules are required for the generation of antigens recognized by anti-VSV CTL.