Intracellular freezing: effect of extracellular supercooling.

Human erythrocytes were frozen on the stage of a cryomicroscope at accurately controlled constant-cooling rates with varying degrees of extracellular supercooling. The formation of intracellular ice was detected by direct observation of the frozen cells through the microscope. A significant coupling effect was determined between the minimum cooling rate necessary to produce intracellular freezing and the extent of supercooling. Increased degrees of extracellular supercooling reduced the range of cooling rates for which water would freeze within the cell. Specific data points were obtained at ΔT_SC = 0, ?5, and ?12 °C for which the corresponding transition cooling rates were respectively ?845, ?800, and ?11 °C/min.An explanation for the occurrence of this phenomenon is presented based on the physiochemical processes that govern the freezing of a cell suspension.     

Freezing injury to erythrocytes. I. Freezing patterns and post-thaw hemolysis.

The extent of hemolysis of human red blood cells suspended in different concentrations of glycerol and frozen at various cooling rates was investigated on the basis of morphological observation in the frozen state. Hemolysis of the cells in the absence of glycerol showed a V-shaped curve in terms of cooling rates. There was 70% hemolysis at an optimal cooling rate of approximately 10³ °C/min and 100% hemolysis at all other rates tested. Morphologically, a lower than optimal cooling rate resulted in cellular shrinkage, while a higher than optimal rate resulted in the formation of intracellular ice.The cryoprotective effect of glycerol was dependent upon its concentration and on the cooling rate. Samples frozen at 10³ and 10⁴ °C/min showed freezing patterns which differed from cell to cell. The size of intraand extracellular ice particles became smaller, and there was less shrinkage or deformation of cells as the rate of cooling and concentration of glycerol were increased.There was some correlation between the morphology of frozen cells and the extent of post-thaw hemolysis, but the minimum size of intracellular ice crystals which might cause hemolysis could not be estimated. As a cryotechnique for electron microscopy, the addition of 30% glycerol and ultrarapid freezing at 10⁵ °C/min are minimum requirements for the inhibition of ice formation and the prevention of the corresponding artifacts in erythrocytes.     

Ultrastructure before freezing,while frozen,and after thawing in assessing cryoinjury of mouse epididymal spermatozoa

Tails of mouse epididymides were treated as follows: control, unfrozen with and without cryoprotective agents (CPA); frozen (to below ?80 °C), slowly (8 °C/min), and rapidly (18 °C/sec), with and without CPA. Intracellular and/or extracellular location of CPA, at least glycerol, was influenced, respectively, by high (22 °C) or low (0 °C) exposure temperature. Standard procedures in electron microscopy were employed and the frozen state preserved by freeze-substitution. Motility before freezing and after thawing was the criterion of cryosurvival.Results showed no evidence of deleterious ultrastructural effects of freezing at rates compared, or of benefits of CPA, regardless of their cellular location. Differences were noted, however, in the appearance of spermatozoa in the frozen state, as a function of the rate of freezing but not as a function of the presence, absence, or location of either glycerol of DMSO. Rapidly frozen cells showed intracellular ice formation in the acrosome, neck, midpiece, and tail regions; there was no intranuclear ice, and extracellular ice artifacts were small. Slowly frozen cells showed large extracellular ice artifacts with evidence of shrinkage distortion due to the dehydration induced by extracellular ice. No spermatozoa survived any of the freezing treatments, showing the lethal effect of both extracellular ice during slow freezing and of intracellular and/or extracellular ice during rapid freezing.     

Equilibrium,quasi-equilibrium,and nonequilibrium freezing of mammalian embryos

The first successful freezing of early embryos to −196°C in 1972 required that they be cooled slowly at ∼1°C/min to about −70°C. Subsequent observations and physical/chemical analyses indicate that embryos cooled at that rate dehydrate sufficiently to maintain the chemical potential of their intracellular water close to that of the water in the partly frozen extracellular solution. Consequently, such slow freezing is referred to as equilibrium freezing. In 1972 and since, a number of investigators have studied the responses of embryos to departures from equilibrium freezing. When disequilibrium is achieved by the use of higher constant cooling rates to −70°C, the result is usually intracellular ice formation and embryo death. That result is quantitatively in accord with the predictions of the physical/chemical analysis of the kinetics of water loss as a function of cooling rate. However, other procedures involving rapid nonequilibrium cooling do not result in high mortality. One common element in these other nonequilibrium procedures is that, before the temperature has dropped to a level that permits intracellular ice formation, the embryo water content is reduced to the point at which the subsequent rapid nonequilibrium cooling results in either the formation of small innocuous intracellular ice crystals or the conversion of the intracellular solution into a glass. In both cases, high survival requires that subsequent warming be rapid, to prevent recrystallization or devitrification. The physical/ chemical analysis developed for initially nondehydrated cells appears generally applicable to these other nonequilibrium procedures as well.     

Freezing injury to erythrocytes. II. Morphological alterations of cell membranes.

Morphological alterations of human red blood cell membranes were examined with the cells containing different concentrations of glycerol being subjected to rapid rates of cooling, approximately 10⁴ and 10⁵ °C/min, and subsequent rewarming. Small membrane defects, similar to holes, were observed in specimens frozen with and without 10% glycerol. Various degrees of roughness were found on the surface of the cells at all freezing rates tested. The membrane alterations were reduced with increasing glycerol concentration, although roughness also appeared on the surface of the cells in 30% glycerol suspensions, frozen rapidly, and rewarmed to ?80 or ?60 °C. The cell membrane surface texture correlated with the growth of intra- and extracellular ice particles. There was also a positive correlation between these alterations and post-thaw hemolysis. It is concluded, therefore, that morphological alterations appearing on the erythrocyte membranes may be a manifestation of freezing damage.     

Deep supercooling enabled by surface impregnation with lipophilic substances explains the survival of overwintering buds at extreme freezing

The frost survival mechanism of vegetative buds of angiosperms was suggested to be extracellular freezing causing dehydration, elevated osmotic potential to prevent freezing. However, extreme dehydration would be needed to avoid freezing at the temperatures down to ?45°C encountered by many trees. Buds of Alnus alnobetula, in common with other frost hardy angiosperms, excrete a lipophilic substance, whose functional role remains unclear. Freezing of buds was studied by infrared thermography, psychrometry, and cryomicroscopy. Buds of A. alnobetula did not survive by extracellular ice tolerance but by deep supercooling, down to ?45°C. An internal ice barrier prevented ice penetration from the frozen stem into the bud. Cryomicroscopy revealed a new freezing mechanism. Until now, supercooled buds lost water towards ice masses that form in the subtending stem and/or bud scales. In A. alnobetula, ice forms harmlessly inside the bud between the supercooled leaves. This would immediately trigger intracellular freezing and kill the supercooled bud in other species. In A. alnobetula, lipophilic substances (triterpenoids and flavonoid aglycones) impregnate the surface of bud leaves. These prevent extrinsic ice nucleation so allowing supercooling. This suggests a means to protect forestry and agricultural crops from extrinsic ice nucleation allowing transient supercooling during night frosts.     

Osmotic response of individual cells during freezing. I. Experimental volume measurements

The osmotic response of yeast to freezing was measured as a function of cooling rate and degree of extracellular supercooling. Thirteen experimental trials were conducted on a cryomicroscope in which incremental size changes of individual cells were recorded photographically, and the corresponding volume variations were measured using a digital computer image analysis algorithm. Plots were obtained of normalized cell volume as a function of temperature. Cellular dehydration during freezing was progressively inhibited with increasing values of cooling rate and extracellular supercooling. Normalized cell volume changes were not a function of the relative initial cell size. A constant volume plateau occurred for conditions under which intracellular ice formation was expected.     

Cooling of rabbit kidneys permeated with glycerol to sub-zero temperatures.

The aims of this study were to investigate if kidney preservation could be enhanced by cooling of the organs to high sub-zero temperatures after depression of their freezing points by addition of glycerol, and to study whether the added amounts of this compound would confer protection to the organs during freezing and thawing at slow rates.Glycerol was added and removed gradually by continuous, hypothermic perfusion, and the post-preservation viability was assessed by autotransplantation.Brief cooling to ?5 °C of kidneys perfused with 3 m glycerol was found to be compatible with life-sustaining posttransplant function, whereas no kidneys stored at that temperature for 5 days survived.Slow cooling af kidneys glycerolized to 3 m to ?80 °C was associated with a marked increase in vascular resistance after thawing, and none of such frozen kidneys functioned after transplantation. They showed immediately after revascularization severe impairment of the circulation, and vascular damage was observed by light microscopy. The use of 5 m glycerol for cryoprotection attenuated this rise in vascular resistance and reduced the release of the endocellular enzyme, lactate dehydrogenase after thawing, indicating less cellular damage although no kidneys functioned after grafting.It is suggested that the mechanical effect of interstitial and intravascular ice formation is a major factor in damage to intact organs during freezing, and that further injury is produced by incomplete removal of the cryoprotectant before transplantation.     

Change in overwintering mechanism of the Cucujid beetle, Cucujus clavipes

Overwintering larvae of the Cucujid beetle, Cucujus clavipes, were freeze tolerant, able to survive the freezing of their extracellular body fluids, during the winter of 1978–1979. These larvae had high levels of polyols (glycerol and sorbitol), thermal hysteresis proteins and haemolymph ice nucleators that prevented extensive supercooling (the supercooling points of the larvae were ? 10°C), thus preventing lethal intracellular ice formation. In contrast, C. clavipes larvae were freeze suspectible, died if frozen, during the winter of 1982–1983, but supercooled to ～ ? 30°C. The absence of the ice nucleators in the 1982–1983 larvae, obviously essential in the now freeze-susceptible insects, was the major detected difference in the larvae from the 2 years. However, experiments in which the larvae were artifically seeded at ? 10°C (the temperature at which the natural haemolymph ice nucleators produced spontaneous nucleation in the 1978–1979 freeze tolerant larvae) demonstrated that the absence of the ice nucleators was not the critical factor, or at least not the only critical factor, responsible for the loss of freeze tolerance in the 1982–1983 larvae. The lower lethal temperatures for the larvae were approximately the same during the 2 winters in spite of the change in overwintering strategy.     

Relation of ice formation to ultrastructural cryoinjury and cryoprotection of rough endoplasmic reticulum

Ultrastructural observations on the frozen state of pancreatic acinar cells were correlated with results of parallel studies before freezing and after thawing, as to cryoinjury and cryoprotection.Data support an hypothesis of freezing injury based upon intracellular ice and solution effects during rapid and slow freezing, respectively. The basis for superiority of extracellular over intracellular glycerol in cryoprotection was demonstrated in terms of these factors.Evidence is offered to explain the ultrastructural cryoinjury and cryoprotection of rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER) seen after thawing, relative to the combined effects of freezing rate and glycerol. Slow freezing, in combination with the presence of extracellular glycerol, provided sufficient dehydration to almost completely suppress intracellular ice formation, yielding minimal ultrastructural alteration of RER. Greatest cryoinjury, expressed as extensive conversion of RER into sphere-like vesicles, was induced by the extensive intracellular ice formation which accompanied rapid freezing. A mechanism is suggested to explain physical damage of RER by intracellular ice.     

Cell preservation in a programmed cooling machine: the effect of variations in supercooling

When cells are cryopreserved in programmed cooling machines, they supercool to a variable and uncontrolled extent. Experiments were carried out with three cell-types (human peripheral lymphocytes, Chinese hamster lung fibroblasts, and mouse lymphoma cells) to determine whether there was any effect of supercooling on cell survival. Samples were cooled at 1 °C min^?1 in the presence of 12% v/v dimethyl sulphoxide (Me₂SO) to ?100 °C, and then thawed rapidly in a 37 °C water bath. There was no correlation between the extent of supercooling or the maximum cooling rate after freezing and cell survival, but the time taken for the sample temperature to return to the temperature at which freezing occurred did influence the survival of the two tissue culture cell lines. These results are interpreted on the basis of current theories according to which cells require sufficient time to lose water as they cool in order to avoid subsquent intracellular freezing, but must be cooled sufficiently rapidly to minimise solution effects. It is concluded that the variations in supercooling that occur in programmed cooling machines present no particular difficulties, providing appropriate cooling rates are chosen.     

Divergent mechanisms of frost-hardiness in two populations of the gall fly, Eurosta solidaginsis

Two populations of the gall fly Eurosta solidaginsis utilize different strategies to endure seasonal exposure to temperatures below freezing. Both populations are freezing tolerant. In north temperate populations, supercooling points rise from ?10.2°C to ?6.2°C following exposures to temperatures below freezing. This level is maintained throughout winter and ensures frequent and prolonged periods of tissue freezing. South temperate populations depress the supercooling point to ?14.2°C during autumn and early winter, and this depression precludes extracellular ice formation during periods of supra-optimal temperature fluctuations. During mid-winter, supercooling points rise to the same level as in northern groups.Both populations accumulate three principal cryoprotective agents following first frost exposures (glycerol, sorbitol and trehalose). Cryoprotectants levels do not peak in northern populations until 4–6 weeks after first frost. In southern populations the accumulation profile is characterized by a high initial rate of synthesis, a protective overshoot and pronounced seasonal fluctuations. The relative survival advantages of each strategy are discussed.     

Sensitivity of human embryonic stem cells to different conditions during cryopreservation

Low cell recovery rate of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) resulting from cryopreservation damages leads to the difficulty in their successful commercialization of clinical applications. Hence in this study, sensitivity of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) to different cooling rates, ice seeding and cryoprotective agent (CPA) types was compared and cell viability and recovery after cryopreservation under different cooling conditions were assessed. Both extracellular and intracellular ice formation were observed. Reactive oxidative species (ROS) accumulation of hESCs was determined. Cryopreservation of hESCs at 1 °C/min with the ice seeding and at the theoretically predicted optimal cooling rate (TPOCR) led to lower level of intracellular ROS, and prevented irregular and big ice clump formation compared with cryopreservation at 1 °C/min. This strategy further resulted in a significant increase in the hESC recovery when glycerol and 1,2-propanediol were used as the CPAs, but no increase for Me₂SO. hESCs after cryopreservation under all the tested conditions still maintained their pluripotency. Our results provide guidance for improving the hESC cryopreservation recovery through the combination of CPA type, cooling rate and ice seeding.     

Investigating cryoinjury using simulations and experiments. 1: TF-1 cells during two-step freezing (rapid cooling interrupted with a hold time)

There is significant interest in designing a cryopreservation protocol for hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) which does not rely on dimethyl sulfoxide (Me₂SO) as a cryoprotectant. Computer simulations that describe cellular osmotic responses during cooling and warming can be used to optimize the viability of cryopreserved HSC; however, a better understanding of cellular osmotic parameters is required for these simulations. As a model for HSC, the erythroleukemic human cell line TF-1 was used in this study. Simulations, based on the osmotic properties of TF-1 cells and on the solution properties of the intra- and extracellular compartments, were used to interpret cryoinjury associated with a two-step cryopreservation protocol. Calculated intracellular supercooling was used as an indicator of cryoinjury related to intracellular ice formation. Simulations were applied to the two-step cooling protocol (rapid cooling interrupted with a hold time) for TF-1 cells in the absence of Me₂SO or other cryoprotectants and optimized by minimizing the indicator of cryoinjury. A comparison of simulations and experimental measurements of membrane integrity supports the concept that, for two-step cooling, increasing intracellular supercooling is the primary contributor to potential freezing injury due to the increase in the likelihood of intracellular ice formation. By calculating intracellular supercooling for each step separately and comparing these calculations with cell recovery data, it was demonstrated that it is not optimal simply to limit overall supercooling during two-step freezing procedures. More aptly, appropriate limitations of supercooling differ from the first step to the second step. This study also demonstrates why high cell recovery after cryopreservation could be achieved in the absence of traditional cryoprotectants.     

Ultrastructural cryoinjury and cryoprotection of rough endoplasmic reticulum

One phase of a study on cryosurvival and cryoprotection of mammalian cells, in terms of ultrastructural alteration of rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER) within rat pancreatic acinar cells, is presented. Small (2–3 mm) squares of tissue, 0.7–0.9 mm in thickness, were compared as unfrozen controls, with (w) and without (wo) glycerol pretreatment (15% $\text{v}\text{v}$ in mammalian Ringer's solution) at 0 °C and 22 °C (to regulate glycerol permeability); as well as parallel frozen-thawed samples, after combinations of slow (3.8 °C/min) freezing (SF) and rapid (38 °C/sec) freezing (RF) with either slow (1.5 °C/min) thawing (ST) or rapid (8 °C/sec) thawing (RT). Regimens compared were SFRT, SFST, RFRT, and RFST, all w and wo glycerol pretreatment at 0 °C and 22 °C. Tissue from each treatment was prepared for electron microscopic observations. The results on rates of freezing and thawing and relative cryoprotection of intracellular and extracellular glycerol under conditions described are intended to serve as a correlative basis for subsequent parallel studies on function (protein synthesis) and ultrastructure of the frozen state. They now indicate the following: (1) Cryoinjury of RER, which occurred during all treatments compared, was manifested in irregularity, dilatation, vesiculation, and altered matrix density of cisternae, and ribosomal derangement or disjunction. Least injury was shown by some disorientation and dilatation with increasing degrees of damage involving accentuation of these and other alterations. Such ultrastructural alterations to RER are not unique to cryoinjury, since they have been induced by treatments and agents other than freeze-thawing in experimental pathology. (2) Cryoinjury is unique, however, in that it can be regulated to demonstrate a spectrum of degrees of injury to cells and their organelles, immediately after cryoexposure. Controlled cryoinjury is suggested as a research tool for studies on injury, in general, on an ultrastructural-functional level. (3) Glycerol is injurious or toxic during pretreatment. Toxicity, which resembles cryoinjury, is greater during 22 ° C (intracellular) than 0 °C (extracellular) glycerol pretreatment, especially with respect to dilatation of cisternae. (4) Extra-cellular glycerol is cryoprotective during both slow and rapid freezing followed by either slow or rapid thawing, while little or no cryoprotection is afforded when glycerol is located simultaneously in the intracellular and extracellular location. (5) Rate of freezing is more important than rate of thawing as a factor in cryosurvival. Rapid freezing is more injurious than slow freezing, in the absence of glycerol or in the presence of extracellular glycerol, with slight or no differences seen as a function of thawing rate. Neither rate of freezing nor rate of thawing is of serious consequence when glycerol is intracellular. (6) Rate of thawing has importance after slow freezing, when slow thawing is more injurious than rapid, but not after rapid freezing, either in the presence or absence of extracellular glyeerol.     

Freezing tolerance and avoidance in high-elevation Hawaiian plants

Freezing resistance mechanisms were studied in five endemic Hawaiian species growing at high elevations on Haleakala volcano, Hawaii, where nocturnal subzero (°C) air temperatures frequently occur. Extracellular freezing occurred at around -5°C in leaves of Argyroxiphium sandwicense and Sophora chrysophylla, but these leaves can tolerate extracellular ice accumulation to -15°C and -12°C, respectively. Mucilage, which apparently acted as an ice nucleator, comprised 9 to 11% of the dry weight of leaf tissue in these two species. Leaves of Vaccinium reticulatum and Styphelia tameiameiae were also found to tolerate substantial extracellular freezing. Dubautia menziesii, on the other hand, exhibited the characteristics of permanent supercooling; a very rapid decline in liquid water content associated with simultaneous intracellular and extracellular freezing. However, in those species that tolerate extracellular freezing, the decline in liquid water content during freezing is relatively slow. Osmotic potential was lower at pre-dawn than at midday in four of the species studied. Nocturnal production of osmotically active solutes may have helped to prevent intracellular freeze dehydration as well as to provide non-colligative protection of cell membranes. Styphelia tameiameiae supercooled to -9·3°C and tolerated tissue freezing to below -15°C, a unique combination of physiological characteristics related to freezing. Tolerance of extracellular ice formation after considerable supercooling may have resulted from low tissue water content and a high degree of intracellular water binding in this species, as determined by nuclear magnetic resonance studies. The climate at high elevations in Hawaii is relatively unpredictable in terms of the duration of subzero temperatures and the lowest subzero temperature reached during the night. It appears that plants growing in this tropical alpine habitat have been under selective pressures for the evolution of freezing tolerance mechanisms.     

Visualization of intracellular ice crystals formed in very rapidly frozen cells at −27 °C

Tumor cells of an ascites sarcoma of rat were primarily frozen very rapidly with the original host ascitic fluid at ?27 °C by the spraying method. Frozen specimens were fractured and replicated at about ?100 °C under vacuum by a special spray-sandwich method for freeze-etching, and the morphological appearance of ice crystals formed in and around the frozen cells were observed by electron microscopy.The cells cooled very rapidly at ?27 °C actually froze intracellularly, and intracellular ice crystals ranged from 0.03 to 0.5 μm in grain size due to the initial freezing rate of the specimens. In the cells having granulous intracellular ice crystals less than 0.05 μm in grain size, cytoplasmic organelles seemed to maintain their original structures.We suggested in our previous report that these tumor cells, frozen very rapidly at temperatures above ?30 °C, survived intracellular freezing as long as they remained translucent, and optically no ice crystals appeared within them, as seen in intact unfrozen cells. It may therefore be concluded that the tumor cells frozen very rapidly at temperatures near ?30 °C actually freeze intracellularly and probably maintain their viability as long as the size of individual intracellular ice-crystals is kept smaller than 0.05 μm, although the exact critical size of innocuous intracellular ice crystals is uncertain.     

The Siberian timberman Acanthocinus aedilis: a freeze-tolerant beetle with low supercooling points

Larvae of the Siberian timberman beetle Acanthocinus aedilis display a number of unique features, which may have important implications for the field of cold hardiness in general. Their supercooling points are scattered over a wide temperature range, and some individuals have supercooling points in the low range of other longhorn beetles. However, they differ from other longhorn beetles in being tolerant to freezing, and in the frozen state they tolerate cooling to below −37°C. In this respect they also differ from the European timberman beetles, which have moderate supercooling capacity and die if they freeze. The combination of freezing tolerance and low supercooling points is unusual and shows that freezing at a high subzero temperature is not an absolute requirement for freezing tolerance. Like other longhorn beetles, but in contrast to other freeze-tolerant insects, the larvae of the Siberian timberman have a low cuticular water permeability and can thus stay supercooled for long periods without a great water loss. This suggests that a major function of the extracellular ice nucleators of some freeze-tolerant insects may be to prevent intolerable water loss in insects with high cuticular water permeability, rather than to create a protective extracellular freezing as has generally been assumed. The freezing tolerance of the Siberian timberman larvae is likely to be an adaptation to the extreme winter cold of Siberia.     

Freezing monolayers of cells without gap junctions

Cells in monolayers have been reported to be more susceptible to freezing injury than the same cell type frozen in dispersed suspensions. There appears to be an enhanced susceptibility to intracellular freezing in the monolayers, which is thought to be facilitated by the presence of gap junctions allowing the spread of ice between neighbouring cells. MDCK Type II cells do not form gap junctions in monolayer culture. When frozen at rates of 0.2 to 10 degrees C/min, monolayers in 10% (v/v) propane-1,2-diol or dimethyl sulphoxide showed little influence of cooling rate on survival. This suggested that, in the absence of gap junctions, cells in monolayers did not display enhanced susceptibility to intracellular freezing. In contrast, however, monolayers frozen in glycerol showed a marked increase in cell damage when cooled at rates higher than 0.5 degrees C/min. This does not necessarily counter the suggestion that lack of gap junctions mitigates intracellular freezing as there is evidence that glycerol may itself promote intracellular freezing.     

Interaction of rate of latent heat removal during freezing and rates of subsequent cooling and warming on survival of the blood protozoan, Babesia rodhaini

Babesia rodhaini parasites in murine blood containing 1.5 m DMSO were frozen at two rates, as judged by the duration of the “freezing plateau”, then cooled to ?196 °C and rewarmed at two rates to detect interactions between the duration of the plateau and rates of subsequent cooling and rewarming. Infectivity tests showed that fast and slow freezing (plateau times of about 1 sec and 30 sec, respectively) had similar effects on parasite survival when cooling was at 130 °C/min and warming was at 800 °C/min. However, when either the cooling rate was increased to 3500 °C/min or the warming rate was decreased to 2.3 °C/min, fast freezing decreased parasite survival more than did slow freezing. It is suggested that fast freezing accentuated the damaging effects of fast cooling and slow warming by increasing intracellular ice formation.