Models for antigen receptor gene rearrangement. I. Biased receptor editing in B cells: implications for allelic exclusion.

Recent evidence suggests that lymphocyte Ag receptor gene rearrangement does not always stop after the expression of the first productively rearranged receptor. Light chain gene rearrangement in B cells, and alpha-chain rearrangement in T cells can continue, which raises the question: how is allelic exclusion maintained, if at all, in the face of continued rearrangement? In this and the accompanying paper, we present comprehensive models of Ag receptor gene rearrangement and the interaction of this process with clonal selection. Our B cell model enables us to reconcile observations on the kappa:lambda ratio and on kappa allele usage, showing that B cell receptor gene rearrangement must be a highly ordered, rather than a random, process. We show that order is exhibited on three levels: a preference for rearranging kappa rather than lambda light chain genes; a preference to make secondary rearrangements on the allele that has already been rearranged, rather than choosing the location of the next rearrangement at random; and a sequentiality of J segment choice within each kappa allele. This order, combined with the stringency of negative selection, is shown to lead to effective allelic exclusion.     

Relationship between the rearrangement of immunoglobulin genes, the appearance of a B lymphocyte antigen, and immunoglobulin synthesis in murine pre-B cell lines

Eighteen Abelson virus-transformed immature B cell lines were established and immunoglobulin biosynthesis, expression of a B lymphocyte antigen detected by a monoclonal antibody, and rearrangement of immunoglobulin genes in these cell lines were studied. Only one cell line (A1) synthesized micro-chains but no light chains, and the other cell lines synthesized no detectable immunoglobulins. None of the cell lines established had detectable membrane-associated IgM. Fifteen cell lines expressed a B lymphocyte antigen on their cell surfaces. In three cell lines, however, the majority (greater than 99%) of cells did not express this antigen. Heavy chain genes were rearranged on both chromosomes in all the cell lines, although one heavy chain gene was deleted in three cell lines. In 12 of 18 cell lines, one or both kappa-chain genes were rearranged. In six cell lines, however, both kappa-chain genes remained in embryonic form; lambda-chain genes were in embryonic form in all the cell lines. These results suggested the hierarchy of Ig gene rearrangements, beginning with mu and proceeding to kappa and then to lambda. JH rearrangement was also shown to precede the appearance of a B lymphocyte antigen. In three cell lines (A1-A3), which were considered subclones derived from a single common precursor, it was suggested that one rearranged JH gene was functional, and the other was nonfunctional, indicating that allelic exclusion already operated in pre-B cells.     

The pre-B-cell receptor: selector of fitting immunoglobulin heavy chains for the B-cell repertoire

In this Opinion article, I address the role of the pre-B-cell receptor (pre-BCR) in the development of antigen-specific B cells in terms of immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) variable-region repertoire selection, precursor B-cell differentiation and proliferation, and IgH allelic exclusion. Comparisons with the role of the pre-T-cell receptor (pre-TCR) in T-cell development raise provocative questions. Why do B- and T-cell lineages both use a surrogate chain - the surrogate light chain and the pre-TCR alpha-chain, respectively - as a step to develop their repertoires of antigen-recognizing cells? What are the functions of the pre-BCR and pre-TCR in lymphocyte differentiation and antigen-receptor allelic exclusion? This article, together with the accompanying article by Harald von Boehmer, hopes to answer some of these questions.     

VpreB1/VpreB2/lambda 5 triple-deficient mice show impaired B cell development but functional allelic exclusion of the IgH locus

At the precursor B cell stage during bone marrow B cell development, Ig muH chain associates with surrogate L (SL) chain, which is encoded by the three genes VpreB1, VpreB2, and lambda 5, to form the pre-B cell receptor (pre-BCR). Surface expression of the pre-BCR is believed to signal both proliferation and allelic exclusion of the IgH locus. Mice which lack either VpreB1/VpreB2 or lambda 5 show a lack of precursor B cell expansion but normal IgH allelic exclusion. This would suggest that one of either lambda 5 or VpreB can make a pre-BCR-like complex which is still able to signal allelic exclusion but not proliferation. To investigate this, we established mice lacking all components of the SL chain. These mice showed severely impaired B cell development which was similar to that previously found in mice lacking either lambda 5 or VpreB1/VpreB2. Surprisingly, the IgH locus was still allelically excluded and thus the SL chain appears not to be involved in allelic exclusion.     

Ordered and coordinated rearrangement of the TCR alpha locus: role of secondary rearrangement in thymic selection

The Ag receptor of the T lymphocyte is composed of an alphabeta heterodimer. Both alpha- and beta-chains are products of the somatic rearrangement of V(D)J segments encoded on the respective loci. During T cell development, beta-chain rearrangement precedes alpha-chain rearrangement. The mechanism of allelic exclusion ensures the expression of a single beta-chain in each T cell, whereas a large number of T cells express two functional alpha-chains. Here we demonstrate evidence that TCR alpha rearrangement is initiated by rearranging a 3' Valpha segment and a 5' Jalpha segment on both chromosomes. Rearrangement then proceeds by using upstream Valpha and downstream Jalpha segments until it is terminated by successful positive selection. This ordered and coordinated rearrangement allows a single thymocyte to sequentially express multiple TCRs with different specificities to optimize the efficiency of positive selection. Thus, the lack of allelic exclusion and TCR alpha secondary rearrangement play a key role in the formation of a functional T cell repertoire.     

Allelic exclusion in rat kappa immunoglobulin chains: extent of Jk rearrangement in normal B lymphocytes

The frequency of normal rat peripheral B lymphocytes stained for surface immunoglobulin kappa allotypes a and b in (a X b) F1 heterozygotes was assessed by two-colour immunofluorescence on a fluorescence-activated cell sorter. The upper limit to the frequency of double- stainers was 8% among all kappa-positive cells, though it was not resolved how far cytophilic antibody accounted for these. Cells expressing each allotype singly were isolated and the extent of rearrangement of the genes encoding the joining-kappa segment on the expressed and non-expressed chromosome were independently assessed. The expressed allele was found to be virtually completely rearranged while the non-expressed allele showed approximately 45-60% rearrangement. The implications of this substantial non-productive rearrangement for models of allelic exclusion are discussed.     

Attenuation of IL-7 receptor signaling is not required for allelic exclusion

Allelic exclusion prevents pre-B cells from generating more than one functional H chain, thereby ensuring the formation of a unique pre-BCR. The signaling processes underlying allelic exclusion are not clearly understood. IL-7R-dependent signals have been clearly shown to regulate the accessibility of the Ig H chain locus. More recent work has suggested that pre-BCR-dependent attenuation of IL-7R signaling returns the H chain loci to an inaccessible state; this process has been proposed to underlie allelic exclusion. Importantly, this model predicts that preventing pre-BCR-dependent down-regulation of IL-7R signaling should interfere with allelic exclusion. To test this hypothesis, we made use of transgenic mice that express a constitutively active form of STAT5b (STAT5b-CA). STAT5b-CA expression restores V(D)J recombination in IL-7R(-/-) B cells, demonstrating that IL-7 regulates H chain locus accessibility and V(D)J recombination via STAT5 activation. To examine the effects of constitutively active STAT5b on allelic exclusion, we crossed STAT5b-CA mice (which express the IgM(b) allotype) to IgM(a) allotype congenic mice. We found no difference in the percentage of IgM(a)/IgM(b)-coexpressing B cells in STAT5b-CA vs littermate control mice; identical results were observed when crossing STAT5b-CA mice with hen egg lysozyme (HEL) H chain transgenic mice. The HEL transgene enforces allelic exclusion, preventing rearrangement of endogenous H chain genes; importantly, rearrangement of endogenous H chain genes was suppressed to a similar degree in STAT5b-CA vs HEL mice. Thus, attenuation of IL-7R/STAT5 signaling is not required for allelic exclusion.     

Models for antigen receptor gene rearrangement. II. Multiple rearrangement in the TCR: allelic exclusion or inclusion?

This series of papers addresses the effects of continuous Ag receptor gene rearrangement in lymphocytes on allelic exclusion. The previous paper discussed light chain gene rearrangement and receptor editing in B cells, and showed that these processes are ordered on three different levels. This order, combined with the constraints imposed by a strong negative selection, was shown to lead to effective allelic exclusion. In the present paper, we discuss rearrangement of TCR genes. In the TCR alpha-chain, allelic inclusion may be the rule rather than the exception. Several previous models, which attempted to explain experimental observations, such as the fractions of cells containing two productive TCRalpha rearrangements, did not sufficiently account for TCR gene organization, which limits secondary rearrangement, and for the effects of subsequent thymic selection. We present here a detailed, comprehensive computer simulation of TCR gene rearrangement, incorporating the interaction of this process with other aspects of lymphocyte development, including cell division, selection, cell death, and maturation. Our model shows how the observed fraction of T cells containing productive TCRalpha rearrangements on both alleles can be explained by the parameters of thymic selection imposed over a random rearrangement process.     

Allelic modulation in Paramecium aurelia heterozygotes. Study of G serotypes in syngen 1

Summary The systematic study of heterozygotes for the g locus controlling G serotype in Paramecium aurelia syngen 1, shows that a phenomenon of allelic exclusion exists. This phenomenon of exclusion happens either systematically, almost systematically or randomly, depending on the studied combination of alleles (Table 2). For a given combination of alleles, it is always the same allele which is excluded. Back-cross experiments indicate that the observed allelic modulation is not dependent upon a simple or classical type of regulatory system. It seems to be characteristic of a given allelic interaction.This phenomenon of allelic exclusion resembles the well-known phenomenon of mutual exclusion occurring between different loci which govern the surface antigens corresponding to the different serotypes of Paramecium aurelia. Both cases of exclusion (inter-allelic or intergenic) might involve an original mechanism of inter-regulation between proteins belonging to the same molecular family and fulfilling similar functions but under different physiological conditions.     

The requirement for pre-TCR during thymic differentiation enforces a developmental pause that is essential for V-DJβ rearrangement

T cell development occurs in the thymus and is critically dependent on productive TCRβ rearrangement and pre-TCR expression in DN3 cells. The requirement for pre-TCR expression results in the arrest of thymocytes at the DN3 stage (β checkpoint), which is uniquely permissive for V-DJβ recombination; only cells expressing pre-TCR survive and develop beyond the DN3 stage. In addition, the requirement for TCRβ rearrangement and pre-TCR expression enforces suppression of TCRβ rearrangement on a second allele, allelic exclusion, thus ensuring that each T cell expresses only a single TCRβ product. However, it is not known whether pre-TCR expression is essential for allelic exclusion or alternatively if allelic exclusion is enforced by developmental changes that can occur in the absence of pre-TCR. We asked if thymocytes that were differentiated without pre-TCR expression, and therefore without pause at the β checkpoint, would suppress all V-DJβ rearrangement. We previously reported that premature CD28 signaling in murine CD4(-)CD8(-) (DN) thymocytes supports differentiation of CD4(+)CD8(+) (DP) cells in the absence of pre-TCR expression. The present study uses this model to define requirements for TCRβ rearrangement and allelic exclusion. We demonstrate that if cells exit the DN3 developmental stage before TCRβ rearrangement occurs, V-DJβ rearrangement never occurs, even in DP cells that are permissive for D-Jβ and TCRα rearrangement. These results demonstrate that pre-TCR expression is not essential for thymic differentiation to DP cells or for V-DJβ suppression. However, the requirement for pre-TCR signals and the exclusion of alternative stimuli such as CD28 enforce a developmental "pause" in early DN3 cells that is essential for productive TCRβ rearrangement to occur.     

Models for antigen receptor gene rearrangement. III. Heavy and light chain allelic exclusion

The extent of allelic exclusion in Ig genes is very high, although not absolute. Thus far, it has not been clearly established whether rapid selection of the developing B cell as soon as it has achieved the first productively rearranged, functional heavy chain is the only mechanism responsible for allelic exclusion. Our computational models of Ag receptor gene rearrangement in B lymphocytes are hereby extended to calculate the expected fractions of heavy chain allelically included newly generated B cells as a function of the probability of heavy chain pairing with the surrogate light chain, and the probability that the cell would test this pairing immediately after the first rearrangement. The expected fractions for most values of these probabilities significantly exceed the levels of allelic inclusion in peripheral B cells, implying that in most cases productive rearrangement and subsequent cell surface expression of one allele of the heavy chain gene probably leads to prevention of rearrangement completion on the other allele, and that additional mechanisms, such as peripheral selection disfavoring cells with two productively rearranged heavy chain genes, may also play a role. Furthermore, we revisit light chain allelic exclusion by utilizing the first (to our knowledge) computational model which addresses and enumerates B cells maturing with two productively rearranged kappa light chain genes. We show that, assuming that there are no selection mechanisms responsible for abolishing cells expressing two light chains, the repertoire of newly generated B lymphocytes exiting the bone marrow must contain a significant fraction of such kappa double-productive B cells.     

Novel recombinations of the IG kappa-locus that result in allelic exclusion

Allelic exclusion of Ig H and L chain gene loci serves to ensure that a B cell expresses a single specificity antibody. The analysis of Abelson murine leukemia virus transformed cells that rearrange the kappa-locus during growth in cell culture has provided the opportunity to characterize intermediate steps in Ig gene rearrangement. By sequential cloning of an Abelson murine leukemia virus transformed cell line we have observed a novel two-step pathway that results in a rearrangement of a V kappa gene segment into the J-C kappa intron. This type of rearrangement effectively excludes functional kappa expression from that allele. A truncated mRNA product resulting from the V kappa signal exon splicing to the C kappa exon is diagnostic of these unique rearrangements. In addition to demonstrating a novel mechanism for allelic exclusion, the two-step pathway described serves to explain how V-intron recombination products were generated in previously described cell lines.     

Surface immunoglobulin on rabbit lymphoid cells. III. Double expression and separate endocytosis of surface immunoglobulin allotypes on heterozygous lymphocytes demonstrated by immunoelectron microscopic labeling.

The expression of immunoglobulin b locus (k chain) allotypes on the surface of rabbit peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL's) is examined using an indirect double immunoelectron microscopic labeling technique. Ferritin and whelk hemocyanin individually conjugated to allotypically specific IgG are used as ultrastructurally identifiable molecular markers. These indicators are coupled to lymphocyte surface immunoglobulin (Ig) allotypic determinants by an antiallotype antibody linkage. Human red blood cells, conjugated with IgG of a specific allotype and used as test cells, demonstrate the absolute specificity and high efficiency of the ultrastructural labeling technique. Specific labeling on rabbit PBL's shows that 65–75% of the cells are positive for surface Ig. Lymphocytes from homozygous donors (b4b4 or b6b6) are labeled specifically with only the appropriate allotypic labeling system. Thirty-three percent of the PBL's from heterozygous donors (b4b6) express both allotypes (allelic inclusion) on the cell surface; the remaining proportion of Ig-bearing cells have only one detectable allotype present (allelic exclusion). We conclude that approximately 50% of the Ig-bearing PBL's demonstrate allelic inclusion for the b locus allotypes. On allelically included heterozygous lymphocytes, both allotypic determinants can undergo specific endocytosis. Endocytosis of one allotype on heterozygous cells can be induced by stimulation with antiallotypic serum without affecting the surface appearance of the other allelic marker (separate endocytosis).     

The PI3K p110delta is required for down-regulation of RAG expression in immature B cells

At the immature B cell stage the BCR signals the down-regulation of the RAG genes and Ig L chain (LC) allelic and isotype exclusion. The signaling pathway that regulates these events is poorly characterized. We demonstrate that immature B cells from mice deficient in the PI3K catalytic subunit p110delta fail to suppress RAG expression and inappropriately recombine kappa and lambda LC loci. In addition, in the presence of the autoantigen, clonal deletion and receptor editing still takes place, demonstrating that these processes are independent of p110delta. These results demonstrate a role for p110delta in the regulation of RAG gene expression and thereby LC allelic/isotype exclusion.