X-ray induced DNA double strand break production and repair in mammalian cells as measured by neutral filter elution.

This work presents a neutral filter elution method for detecting DNA double strand breaks in mouse L1210 cells after X-ray. The assay will detect the number of double strand breaks induced by as little as 1000 rad of X-ray. The rate of DNA elution through the filters under neutral conditions increases with X-ray dose. Certain conditions for deproteinization, pH, and filter type are shown to increase the assay's sensitivity. Hydrogen peroxide and Bleomycin also induce apparent DNA double strand breaks, although the ratios of double to single strand breaks vary from those produced by X-ray. The introduction of double strand cuts by HpA I restriction endonuclease in DNA lysed on filters results in a rapid rate of elution under neutral conditions, implying that the method can detect double strand breaks if they exist in the DNA. The eluted DNA bands with a double stranded DNA marker in cesium chloride. This evidence suggests that the assay detects DNA double strand breaks. L1210 cells are shown to rejoin most of the DNA double strand breaks induced by 5-10 krad of X-ray with a half-time of about 40 minutes.     

125I-induced DNA double strand breaks: use in calibration of the neutral filter elution technique and comparison with X-ray induced breaks

The neutral filter elution assay, for measurement of DNA double strand breakage, has been calibrated using mouse L cells and Chinese hamster V79 cells labelled with [125I]dUrd and then held at liquid nitrogen temperature to accumulate decays. The basis of the calibration is the observation that each 125I decay, occurring in DNA, produces a DNA double strand break. Linear relationships between 125I decays per cell and lethal lesions per cell (minus natural logarithm survival) and the level of elution, were found. Using the calibration data, it was calculated that the yield of DNA double strand breaks after X-irradiation of both cell types was from 6 to 9 X 10(-12) DNA double strand breaks per Gy per dalton of DNA, for doses greater than 6 Gy. Neutral filter elution and survival data for X-irradiated and 125I-labelled cells suggested that the relationships between lethal lesions and DNA double strand breakage were significantly different for both cell types. An attempt was made to study the repair kinetics for 125I-induced DNA double strand breaks, but was frustrated by the rapid DNA degradation which occurs in cells that have been killed by the freezing-thawing process.     

Lack of interference of DNA single-strand breaks with the measurement of double-strand breaks in mammalian cells using the neutral filter elution assay.

In this study, the effect of DNA single strand breaks (ssb) on the neutral (pH 9.6) filter elution of DNA from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO K1) cells containing DNA double strand breaks (dsb) was investigated. Protein associated ssb were induced by the inhibition of DNA topoisomerase I with camptothecin (cpt). Protein associated dsb were introduced by treating cells with the DNA topoisomerase II poison; etoposide (VP-16). Protein associated ssb and dsb were converted to ssb and dsb by proteinase K present in the lysis solution. In some experiments dsb were generated by the restriction endonuclease Pvu II. It was found that elution of DNA in the presence and absence of ssb was similar under neutral conditions. This finding is consistent with the view that the fast component of the bi-phasic repair kinetics observed in irradiated mammalian cells with the neutral filter elution technique is not attributable to the interference of ssb with the measurement of dsb, and thus suggests that the two components of repair observed with the neutral filter elution elution technique may represent two different types of dsb or modes of repair of dsb.     

Accumulation of DNA strand breaks during thymineless death in thymidylate synthase-negative mutants of mouse FM3A cells

Thymidylate synthase-negative mutants of cultured mouse cells were immediately committed to cell death upon thymidine deprivation, especially when the cells were synchronized in the S phase. Thymidylate deprivation induced single strand breaks in chromosome-size DNA strands, as measured by alkaline sucrose gradient sedimentation, giving rise to two peaks, one with large and the other with small fragments, the latter about the size of T4 DNA. An increase in the small DNA fragments paralleled that of thymineless death. Thymidine deprivation also produced double strand DNA fragments as determined by a method of neutral filter elution, and their extent paralleled that of cell death. Double-stranded DNA eluted through the filter sedimented as a single peak both in a neutral and in an alkaline sucrose gradient that coincided with that of the above small DNA fragments. Therefore, the strand breaks seemed to occur in some defined portions of the genome and in a specific manner compared to breaks induced by x-rays, which occurred rather randomly. Cycloheximide blocked both thymineless death and the production of the small DNA fragments. The strand breaks induced by thymidine starvation were not repaired but instead advanced on subsequent incubation of the cells in growth medium containing thymidine.     

Radiosensitization of Chinese hamster V79 cells by bromodeoxyuridine substitution of thymidine: enhancement of radiation-induced toxicity and DNA strand break production by monofilar and bifilar substitution

Bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) competes with thymidine (TdR) for incorporation into DNA of exponentially growing V79-171 cells. Such cells show an enhancement of the radiation response as determined by clonogenic survival and DNA damage measured by filter elution techniques after doses up to 15 Gy. The degree of radiosensitization for both survival and rates of alkaline and neutral elution are dependent on percentage BrdU substitution and independent of whether BrdU is in one strand only (monofilar) or both strands (bifilar) of the DNA duplex: e.g., for 16% BrdU substitution distributed either monofilarly or partially bifilarly, there is an enhancement factor for Do of 1.55. At this percentage substitution, the enhancement factor for the rate of alkaline elution is 1.75 and that for the rate of neutral elution is 1.54. The greater the percentage BrdU substitution, the larger was the enhancement ratio for survival and radiation-induced strand breaks in both monofilarly and bifilarly substituted cells. The increase in cell radiosensitivity caused by BrdU substitution shows a better correlation with the increase in radiation-induced double-strand breaks than with the increase in radiation-induced single-strand breaks.     

Measurement of radiation-induced DNA damage using gel electrophoresis or neutral filter elution shows an increased frequency of DNA strand breaks after exposure to pH 9.6

The filter elution technique using nondenaturing conditions is widely used to assay DNA double-strand break (DSB) induction and repair. It has been reported that in the measurement of strand breaks higher rates of elution and of initial rejoining are obtained at pH 9.6 compared to pH 7.2. In the present experiments neutral elution at pH 7.2 and 9.6 were compared in the assay of damage to DNA induced by X rays, 125I decay, and restriction enzyme digestion, in an effort to explain this discrepancy and to determine whether the higher rate of elution observed at pH 9.6 corresponds to a greater number of DSBs. X-ray damage to cellular DNA resulted in significantly different elution profiles at the two pH values. In contrast the elution profiles of the DSB induced by intragenomic 125I decays or restriction endonuclease were independent of the pH of the elution buffer. When gamma-irradiated SV40 DNA was exposed to pH 7.2 or 9.6 elution buffer prior to analysis by gel electrophoresis, a significantly greater number of DNA DSBs were detected in the DNA exposed to pH 9.6. We conclude that X and gamma radiation produce lesions (pH 9.6-labile lesions), in proportion to dose, that have the potential of becoming measurable DSBs following incubation under the mildly alkaline condition of pH 9.6. The data suggest that these lesions may result from single-hit events.     

Apurinic site induction in the DNA of cells heated at hyperthermic temperatures

The induction of DNA damage in cells heated at hyperthermic (43-48 degrees C) temperatures was determined by alkaline filter elution and alkaline sucrose gradient-sedimentation analysis of cell DNA denatured at pH 13.0. A class of DNA lesion which converted to strand breaks during denaturation of DNA at pH 13.0 was produced randomly throughout the cell DNA at temperatures as low as 43 degrees C. Induction of this lesion occurred with a T0 of 90 and 10 min at 45 and 48 degrees C, respectively. We estimate that these pH 13.0-detectable DNA lesions are produced in the cell DNA with a frequency of approximately 75 and 660 per min of heating at 45 and 48 degrees C, respectively. Since the lesions were quantitatively converted to DNA strand breaks at pH 13.0 with a half-time of 30 min, or less, we suggest that these pH 13.0-detectable DNA lesions are heat-induced, abasic DNA sites. The induction of these lesions does not appear to be directly involved in the initial heat-induced inhibition of DNA synthesis. The presence of these lesions cannot be excluded as an explanation for the long-term inhibition of replicon initiated in heated cells.     

DNA conformation of Chinese hamster V79 cells and sensitivity to ionizing radiation

Chinese hamster V79 cells grown for 20 h in suspension culture form small clusters of cells (spheroids) which are more resistant to killing by ionizing radiation than V79 cells grown as monolayers. This resistance appears to be due to the greater capacity of cells grown in contact to repair radiation damage. Attempts to relate this "contact effect" to differences in DNA susceptibility or DNA repair capacity have provided conflicting results. Two techniques, alkaline sucrose gradient sedimentation and alkaline elution, show no difference in the amounts of radiation-induced DNA single-strand breakage or its repair between suspension or monolayer cells. However, using the alkali-unwinding assay, the rate of DNA unwinding is much slower for suspension cells than for monolayer cells. Interestingly, a decrease in salt concentration or in pH of the unwinding solution eliminates these differences in DNA unwinding kinetics. A fourth assay, sedimentation of nucleoids on neutral sucrose gradients, also shows a significant decrease in radiation damage produced in suspension compared to monolayer cultures. It is believed that this assay measures differences in DNA conformation (supercoiling) as well as differences in DNA strand breakage. We conclude from these four assays that the same number of DNA strand breaks/Gy is produced in monolayer and spheroid cells. However, changes in DNA conformation or packaging occur when cells are grown as spheroids, and these changes are responsible for reducing DNA damage by ionizing radiation.     

Organ specificity of DNA damaging activity of dioxidine]

Dioxidine 2, 3-di (oxymethyl) quinoxaline-1,4-dioxide induced DNA breaks in lung cells of mice in vivo. The DNA was analysed for single strand breaks by alkaline elution assay. DNA damaging activity of dioxidine was compared with the activity of methyl methane sulfonate, N-nitrosomorpholine and 4-nitroquinoline-1,4-oxide.     

A filter incubation method for the determination of potentially crosslinkable sites in DNA in mammalian cells

A method for the determination of DNA monoadducts capable of forming interstrand crosslinks in mammalian cells is described. Such monoadducts were produced by brief treatment of cells with cis-diamminedichloro-Pt(II) (cis-DDP), 1-(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (ClEtNU), L-phenylalanine mustard (L-PAM), or diaziridinylbenzoquinone (AZQ). The method is an alkaline elution procedure in which the DNA from lysed cells is incubated on polycarbonate filters at pH 10 and 37 degrees C. During this incubation, the progressive formation of interstrand crosslinking was observed in drug-treated cells. In the case of ClEtNU and AZQ, DNA strand breaks also formed, due to the presence of labile lesions in the DNA. This made quantitation of interstrand crosslinks difficult for these drugs. For cis-DDP and L-PAM, however, there was no significant production of strand breaks and the assay for interstrand crosslinks was quantifiable.     

Filter elution analysis of the effect of alpha-difluoromethylornithine on X-ray-induced DNA damage in 9L cells

We used the filter elution technique to study DNA single- and double-strand scission under denaturing alkaline and nondenaturing conditions in X-irradiated 9L rat brain tumor cells. The amount of DNA damage determined by the alkaline elution assay was similar for different lysis conditions (sodium dodecyl sulfate and sarkosyl) and DNA fluorometric assays (Hoechst 33258 and 3,5-diaminobenzoic acid dyes). Therefore, results of the filter elution assay obtained with the various methods can be compared directly. Using these assays, we found that there was no significant change in the susceptibility to X-ray-induced DNA damage, measured either as single- or double-strand breaks, in 9L cells depleted of polyamines by treatment with alpha-difluoromethylornithine. Results obtained by filter elution are different from results obtained with viscoelastometry, which suggests that the two methods may resolve the effects of changes in DNA structure in different ways.     

Detection of ionizing radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks by filter elution is affected by nuclear chromatin structure

Chinese hamster ovary cells were irradiated with 250 kVp X rays and analyzed for the presence of DNA double-strand breaks using either polycarbonate filter elution or pulsed-field agarose gel electrophoresis at neutral pH. Reduction in DNA length detected by filter elution was produced as a nonlinear function of increasing radiation dose, with a quasi-threshold at low total dose, and as a first-order function of increasing radiation dose as detected by gel electrophoresis. The quasi-threshold observed with filter elution was eliminated when nuclei were isolated from irradiated cells and their chromatin relaxed in a buffer containing low-molarity monovalent cation prior to analysis by filter elution. The results suggest either that the chemical structure of the DNA double-strand breaks produced by low-LET radiation necessitates a DNA relaxation step before they can be detected accurately by filter elution, or that at low total radiation dose a DNA complex forms on the polycarbonate filter.     

Alkaline elution of rat testicular DNA: Detection of DNA strand breaks after in vivo treatment with chemical mutagens

The alkaline elution technique was used to measure DNA strand breaks in rat testes after intraperitoneal injection of several chemicals known to cause heritable mutations in rodents. Methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl methanesulfonate, methylnitrosourea, and ethylnitrosourea all produced single strand breaks in rat testicular DNA. For both of these pairs of homologous alkylating agents the relative potency was methyl analog ethyl analog. Strand breaks produced by MMS appeared rapidly (within 2 h) in rat testicular DNA and were partially repaired within 24 h. Studies with low doses of MMS indicate that the assay has the sensitivity to detect DNA strand breaks in the testis after a dose of only 5 mg/kg. Variability in DNA elution profiles for individual control animals and for individual animals given identical doses of MMS was small. In contrast to the results with known mutagens, intraperitoneal injection of nonmutagens such as dimethyl sulfoxide, phenol, and Triton X-15, did not produce strand breaks in testicular DNA.These data indicate that this assay detects DNA strand breaks in the rat testis. The results of several heritable mutagens and nonmutagens are qualitatively predictive of mutagenic activity in the testis.     

Alkaline elution of rat testicular DNA: detection of DNA cross-links after in vivo treatment with chemical mutagens

The alkaline elution technique was used to measure DNA damage in the rat testis after intraperitoneal injection of 3 chemicals known to cause heritable mutations in rodents. These 3 chemicals are triethylenemelamine (TEM), mitomycin C, and cyclophosphamide. All three of these chemicals produced DNA damage which was readily detectable by alkaline elution. Both TEM and mitomycin C produced DNA interstrand cross-links, although TEM was a more potent cross-linker on an equimolar basis than mitomycin C. Cyclophosphamide produced both DNA cross-links and DNA strand breaks. Alkaline elution in the absence of proteinase K indicated that some of the strand breaks appeared to be closely associated with protein. These studied indicate that the alkaline elution technique is capable of detecting DNA damage in mammalian germ cells produced by chemical mutagens. This technique may prove useful as a screening tool for identifying chemicals which cause heritable mutations in mammals.     

Overnight lysis improves the efficiency of detection of DNA damage in the alkaline comet assay

The ability to detect DNA damage using the alkaline comet assay depends on pH, lysis time and temperature during lysis. However, it is not known whether different lysis conditions identify different types of DNA damage or simply measure the same damage with different efficiencies. Results support the latter interpretation for radiation, but not for the alkylating agent MNNG. For X-ray-induced damage, cells showed the same amount of damage, regardless of lysis pH (12.3 compared to >13). However, increasing the duration of lysis at 5 degrees C from 1 h to more than 6 h increased the amount of DNA damage detected by almost twofold. Another twofold increase in apparent damage was observed by conducting lysis at room temperature (22 degrees C) for 6 h, but at the expense of a higher background level of DNA damage. The oxygen enhancement ratio and the rate of rejoining of single-strand breaks after irradiation were similar regardless of pH and lysis time, consistent with more efficient detection of strand breaks rather than detection of damage to the DNA bases. Conversely, after MNNG treatment, DNA damage was dependent on both lysis time and pH. With the higher-pH lysis, there was a reduction in the ratio of oxidative base damage to strand breaks as revealed using treatment with endonuclease III and formamidopyrimidine glycosylase. Therefore, our current results support the hypothesis that the increased sensitivity of longer lysis at higher pH for detecting radiation-induced DNA damage is due primarily to an increase in efficiency for detecting strand breaks, probably by allowing more time for DNA unwinding and diffusion before electrophoresis.     

Quiescent human lymphocytes do not contain DNA strand breaks detectable by alkaline elution

On the basis of qualitative assays, quiescent lymphocytes have previously been reported to have numerous DNA strand breaks, which are thought to be repaired after mitogenic stimulation by a process associated with poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation. Using alkaline elution, a very sensitive assay for quantifying DNA single-strand breakage, we found no evidence for a high frequency of DNA strand breaks in unstimulated human peripheral blood lymphocytes. No differences in elution profiles were observed between unstimulated lymphocytes and lymphocytes 4 or 48 h after addition of the mitogen phytohemagglutinin (PHA). Furthermore, addition of 3-aminobenzamide (3AB), an inhibitor of poly(ADP-ribose) synthetase, or aphidicolin, an inhibitor of DNA polymerase alpha, did not increase the amount of DNA eluting from the filter after PHA stimulation. In contrast to reported studies of mouse splenic lymphocytes, we found that human lymphocytes were able to replicate and divide in the presence of the ADP-ribosylation inhibitor. Human lymphocytes were also capable of proliferating in nicotinamide-free medium, with or without 3AB, indicating that ADP-ribosylation is not a requirement for lymphocyte differentiation. We therefore consider it unlikely that peripheral human lymphocytes contain significant numbers of strand breaks that play any role in their stimulation or differentiation in response to PHA.     

Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate imbalance. 5-Fluorodeoxyuridine-induced DNA double strand breaks in mouse FM3A cells and the mechanism of cell death

The mechanism of cytotoxic action of 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (FdUrd) in mouse FM3A cells was investigated. We observed the FdUrd-induced imbalance of intracellular deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) pools and subsequent double strand breaks in mature DNA, accompanied by cell death. The imbalance of dNTP pools was maximal at 8 h after 1 microM FdUrd treatment; a depletion of dTTP and dGTP pools and an increase in the dATP pool were observed. The addition of FdUrd in culture medium induced strand breaks in DNA, giving rise to a 90 S peak by alkaline sucrose gradient sedimentation. The loss of cell viability and colony-forming ability occurred at about 10 h. DNA double strand breaks as measured by the neutral elution method were also observed in FdUrd-treated cells about 10 h after the addition. These results lead us to propose that DNA double strand breaks play an important role in the mechanism of FdUrd-mediated cell death. A comparison of the ratio of single and double strand breaks induced by FdUrd to that observed following radiation suggested that FdUrd produced double strand breaks exclusively. Cycloheximide inhibited both the production of DNA double strand breaks and the FdUrd-induced cell death. An activity that can induce DNA double strand breaks was detected in the lysate of FdUrd-treated FM3A cells but not in the untreated cells. This suggests that FdUrd induces the cellular DNA double strand breaking activity. The FdUrd-induced DNA strand breaks and cell death appear to occur in the S phase. Our results indicate that imbalance of the dNTP pools is a trigger for double strand DNA break and cell death.     

Measurement of DNA-protein crosslinks in mammalian cells without X-irradiation

To study the mechanisms of formation and repair of DNA-protein crosslinks in mammalian cells, the best general method to assay these lesions is the Kohn membrane alkaline elution procedure. Use of this sensitive technique requires the introduction of random strand breaks in the DNA by X-irradiation to reduce the very high molecular weight so that it elutes off the filter at an appropriate rate. This report describes an alternative method for fragmenting the DNA in the absence of X-irradiation equipment. Convenient reproducible elution rates of DNA from various mouse and human cells in culture without X-irradiation result from elution through polyvinyl chloride filters with 75 mM sodium hydroxide (0.33 ml/min) instead of the standard 20 mM EDTA-tetrapropylammonium hydroxide, pH 12.2 (0.03 to 0.04 ml/min). Dose-dependent retardation of the DNA elution was observed over the range 0 to 30 microM trans-platinum(II)diamminedichloride, and proteinase K treatment during cell lysis restored the elution rate to that of the untreated control cell DNA. In the absence of X-irradiation, this elution method measures DNA-protein crosslinks with higher sensitivity and equivalent reproducibility as the air-burst procedure.     

Fractionation of DNA from mammalian cells by alkaline elution.

The method of alkaline elution provides a sensitive measure of DNA single-strand length distribution in mamalian cells and is applicable to a variety of problems concerning DNA damage, repair, and replication. The physical basis of the elution process was studied. The kinetics of elution above the alkaline transition pH were found to occur in two phases: an initial phase in which single-strand length is rate limiting, followed by a phase in which elution is accelerated due to the accumulation of alkali-induced strand breaks. The range of DNA single-strand lengths that can be discriminated by elution above the alkaline transition pH was estimated by calibration relative to the effects of x ray, and was found to be 5 X 10(8)-10(10) daltons. Shorter DNA strands elute within the pH transition zone, which extended from pH 11.3 to 11.7 when tetrapropylammonium hydroxide was used as base. This elution was relatively rapid, but was sharply limited by pH, according to the length of the strands: the length of the strands eluted increased with increasing pH. Alkaline elution was inhibited by treatment of cells with low concentrations of nitrogen mustard, a bifunctional alkylating known to cross-link DNA. On investigation of the possibility that DNA subclasses may differ in their elution behavior, satellite L strands were found to elute more slowly from cells exposed to a low dose of x ray than did the bulk DNA.