Fragile X Premutations Are Not a Major Cause of Early Menopause

Fragile X syndrome is an X-linked mental retardation condition that usually is due to a trinucleotide-repeat expansion in the FMR1 gene. Whereas full-mutation alleles (> 230 repeats) lead to fragile X syndrome, premutation alleles (approximately 60-200 repeats) are apparently non-penetrant. However, previous studies have suggested that female premutation carriers may have an increased incidence of premature menopause. To test this possible association, we screened for premutation alleles among 216 women with early menopause (at age < 47 years), 33 of whom had premature menopause (at age < 40 years), as well as among 107 control women, all of whom were ascertained solely on the basis of age at menopause. No full-mutation alleles were found; and only one premutation allele was found, but, it was in a member of the control group. These results are consistent with what would be expected on the basis of chance only. Our sample size was sufficient to rule out a > or = 3-fold increased risk of early menopause and a > or = 9-fold increased risk of premature menopause due to an FMR1 premutation, under a model considering the risk of both sporadic and familial early menopause. Likewise, our results rule out a > or = 4-fold increased risk of familial early menopause and a > or = 26-fold increased risk of familial premature menopause, under a less probable model in which only familial early menopause is considered. These results indicate that the fragile X premutation is not a major risk factor for early menopause and suggest that the risk of premature menopause to fragile X-premutation carriers may not be as great as that reported elsewhere.     

Prevalence of carriers of premutation-size alleles of the FMRI gene--and implications for the population genetics of the fragile X syndrome.

The fragile X syndrome is the second leading cause of mental retardation after Down syndrome. Fragile X premutations are not associated with any clinical phenotype but are at high risk of expanding to full mutations causing the disease when they are transmitted by a carrier woman. There is no reliable estimate of the prevalence of women who are carriers of fragile X premutations. We have screened 10,624 unselected women by Southern blot for the presence of FMR1 premutation alleles and have confirmed their size by PCR analysis. We found 41 carriers of alleles with 55-101 CGG repeats, a prevalence of 1/259 women (95% confidence interval 1/373-1/198). Thirty percent of these alleles carry an inferred haplotype that corresponds to the most frequent haplotype found in fragile X males and may indeed constitute premutations associated with a significant risk of expansion on transmission by carrier women. We identified another inferred haplotype that is rare in both normal and fragile X chromosomes but that is present on 13 (57%) of 23 chromosomes carrying FMR1 alleles with 53-64 CGG repeats. This suggests either (1) that this haplotype may be stable or (2) that the associated premutation-size alleles have not yet reached equilibrium in this population and that the incidence of fragile X syndrome may increase in the future.     

Transmission of double <Emphasis Type="Italic">FMR1</Emphasis> allelic premutations in a family

The fragile X mental retardation 1 (FMR1) gene is the only gene known responsible for fragile X related disorders, including fragile X syndrome (FXS), fragile X-associated primary ovarian insufficiency, and fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia. Although FMR1 premutation carriers are common, double mutations of the FMR1 gene is very rare. To our knowledge, only twelve such reports including twenty-three cases from fourteen families have been documented. We report here another family with a FXS family history in which the proband’s maternal grandmother had compound FMR1 gene premutations and we review twelve published papers associated with double allelic mutations. Our study and literature review indicated that compound premutations may have influences regarding the early onset of fragile X-associated primary ovarian insufficiency and severity of psychiatric issues, and less likely aggravate the cognitive deficits compared with one allele mutant patients. Further detailed studies of similar cases are needed to clarify the profile of double FMR1 premutaions.     

Analysis of a CGG sequence at the FMR-1 locus in fragile X families and in the general population.

In this study, we have characterized a CGG repeat at the FMR-1 locus in more than 100 families (more than 500 individuals) presenting for fragile X testing and in 247 individuals from the general population. Both Southern blot and PCR-based assays were evaluated for their ability to detect premutations, full mutations, and variability in normal allele sizes. Among the Southern blot assays, the probes Ox1.9 or StB12.3 with a double restriction-enzyme digest were the most sensitive in detecting both small and large amplifications and, in addition, provided information on methylation of an adjacent CpG island. In the PCR-based assays, analysis of PCR products on denaturing DNA sequencing gels allowed the most accurate determination of CGG repeat number up to approximately 130 repeats. A combination of a Southern blot assay with a double digest and the PCR-sequencing-gel assay detected the spectrum of amplification-type mutations at the FMR-1 locus. In the patient population, a CGG repeat of 51 was the largest to be stably inherited, and a repeat of 57 was the smallest size of premutation to be unstably inherited. When premutations were transmitted by females, the size of repeat correlated with risk of expansion to a full mutation in the next generation. Full mutations (large repeats typically associated with an abnormal methylation pattern and mitotic instability) were associated with clinical and cytogenetic manifestations in males but not necessarily in females. In the control population, the CGG repeat ranged from 13 to 61, but 94% of alleles had fewer than 40 repeats. The most frequent allele (34%) was a repeat of 30. One female had an allele (61 repeats) within a range consistent with fragile X premutations, while two other individuals each had a repeat of 52. This suggests that the frequency of unstable alleles in the general population may be approximately 1%.     

Expansion of the CGG repeat in fragile X in the FMR1 gene depends on the sex of the offspring.

Analysis of 139 mother-to-offspring transmissions of fragile X CGG triplet repeats revealed that the repeat expansion is enhanced in mother-to-son transmissions compared with mother-to-daughter transmissions. Evidence has been based on analysis of mother-offspring differences in the size of repeat (in kb), as well as on comparisons between proportions of male and female offspring with premutations, and full mutations, inherited from mothers carrying a premutation. Mean difference in the repeat size from mother-son transmissions was 1.45 kb, compared with mother-daughter transmissions of 0.76 kb. The difference is due primarily to a greater proportion of male than female offspring with full mutation from the premutation mothers and also to a higher frequency of reduction in repeat size from mothers to daughters than from mothers to sons. Our findings suggest the possibility of an interaction of the normal X homologue in a female zygote with the FMR1 sequence on the fragile X during replication to account for the lower level of expansion in mother-to-daughter transmissions relative to mother-to-son transmissions.     

A Multicenter Study on Genotype-Phenotype Correlations in the Fragile X Syndrome, Using Direct Diagnosis with Probe StB12.3: The First 2,253 Cases

We report the results of a 14-center collaborative study of genotype-phenotype correlations in 318 fragile X families; these families comprised 2,253 individuals, 1,344 of whom carried a fragile X mutation and 693 of whom had a typical full fragile X mutation. This study demonstrates that direct DNA diagnosis establishes the genotype at the FRAXA-FMR-1 locus. There was a significantly higher prevalence of “mosaic” cases among males who carry a full mutation (12%) than among females who carry a full mutation (6%); the mosaic males had a larger expansion than did the mosaic females. Mental status of premutated individuals did not differ from that of those with a normal genotype. Both the abnormal methylation of the FMR-1–EagI site and the size of the expansion were highly correlated with cytogenetics, facial dysmorphism, macroorchidism, and mental retardation (MR). Among female carriers of a full mutation, those with MR had significantly larger expansion than did those without MR. Among 164 independent couples, 3 unrelated husbands carried a premutation that suggests that the prevalence of fragile X premutations in the general population is ~0.9% of the X chromosomes. Our data validate the use of direct DNA testing for fragile X diagnosis as well as for carrier identification and support and complete the established relationships among the DNA results and the cytogenetic, physical, and psychological aspects of the disease.     

Compound heterozygosity at the FMR1 gene

Individuals affected with Fragile X syndrome are usually characterized at the DNA level by the presence of at least 200 CGG repeats in the 5' untranslated region of the FMR1 gene; this number of repeats is defined as a full mutation. Repeats that number 50-200 usually define those with premutations and are termed unaffected carriers. We report here a compound heterozygous female who carried CGG repeats in the FMR1 gene that fall within the premutation and full mutation ranges. The former appears to have been inherited from the father, whereas the latter is an expansion of the premutation carried by the proband's mother. Therefore, the offspring of the proband will carry a significant risk of being affected with Fragile X syndrome, and the paternal uncle and any cousins should be counselled for being at risk for this syndrome.     

The use of DNA analysis for diagnostics of hereditary premature ovarian failure

Methods of DNA-analysis of 769G --> A mutations in INHalpha1 gene and CGG-repeats polymorphism in FMRI gene have been developed for creating test-systems for genetically caused forms of premature ovarian failure (POF) diagnostics. The frequency of 769G --> A mutation among women population in Ukraine was established and, by preliminary calculations, makes up 2.8%. Results of analysis of CGG-repeats numbers in FMRI gene in the group of 215 women (oocyte donors) revealed five persons with CGG-repeats numbers, that exceeds the normal one (42 copies). Thus the frequency of persons with allels with high risk of premutation in FMRI gene is 2.3%. The results of our research confirm the actuality of genetic tests of mutations in INHalpha1 and FMR1 genes among the women of reproductive age with the purpose of POF prognosis and prevention the birth of children with fragile X syndrome.     

A female compound heterozygote (pre- and full mutation) for the CGG FMR1 expansion

Fragile X syndrome is the most common cause of inherited mental retardation. The incidence has been estimated to be 1 in 1250 males and 1 in 2000 females. Molecular studies have shown that 95% of fragile X syndrome cases are caused by the expansion of a CGG triplet in the FMR1 gene with hypermethylation of the adjacent CpG island. In spite of the high incidence of this syndrome, a female with both FMR1 genes in the expanded form has never been reported. We present here a female from the Canary Islands presenting mental retardation and attention problems. Molecular analysis has revealed that both of her FMR1 genes have the CGG expansion, one with a premutation and the other with a full mutation. We have studied the CGG repeat in the FMR1 gene in 64 members of her family and detected 33 normal individuals, 14 carriers with the premutation (1 male and 13 females), and 18 individuals with full mutations (8 males and 10 females). The index case illustrates that the possibility of both parents being carriers of the fragile X syndrome premutation should be considered in consanguineous families or in small communities. Received: 4 April 1996 / Revised: 3 May 1996     

Study of FMR1 gene association with ovarian dysfunction in a sample from the Basque Country

Premature ovarian failure (POF) is defined as cessation of menses before the age of 40. The most significant single gene associated with POF is the Fragile X Mental Retardation 1 gene (FMR1). In the present work we screened women with fertility problems from the Basque Country in order to determine, whether in these women, FMR1 CGG repeat size in the intermediate and premutation range was associated with their pathology, and whether intermediate and premutation carriers had endocrine signs of diminished ovarian function, using the most established measure of ovarian reserve, the gonadotropin FSH. A patient sample of 41 women with ovarian insufficiency and a control sample of 32 women with no fertility problems from the Basque Country were examined. The patient sample was classified into three categories according to the results of the retrospective assessment of their ovarian function. In group 2 of patients, women with irregular cycles, reduced fecundity and FSH levels ≥ 10 IU/l, there is a significant increase in the number of intermediate and premutation FMR1 alleles (35–54 CGG repeats). In group 3 of patients, women with amenorrhea for at least four consecutive months and FSH levels ≥ 10 IU/l, a significant increase in the number of intermediate FMR1 alleles (35–54 CGG repeats) was found in patients compared with controls. In this group all the patients had a serum concentration > 40 IU/l. The results suggest that in the analysed Basque sample the FMR1 gene has a role in the aetiology of POF. However, elevated FSH levels are more related to the menstrual cycle pattern than to the CGG repeat size.     

The fragile X premutation in carriers and its effect on mutation size in offspring.

The pattern of inheritance in the fragile X (fra(X)) mutation follows a multistage intergenerational process in which the premutation evolves into the full mutation and the characteristic phenotype of the fra(X) syndrome after passing through oogenesis or a postzygotic event. Findings from our multicenter study confirm a strong direct relationship between fra(X) premutation size in the mother and probability of a full mutation in offspring with the mutation. Remarkably, the best-fitting equations are nonlinear asymptotic functions. The close approximation to both the logistic model and Gompertz suggests a process of accumulation of errors in DNA synthesis, as has been proposed previously. We also note that a larger-than-expected number of daughters of transmitting males have premutations that are smaller than their fathers', and that proportion is significantly higher than the proportion of daughters whose premutations are smaller than their mothers'. Intergenerational decreases in premutation size have been reported in other trinucleotide-repeat disorders and also appear to be parent-of-origin specific. Thus, while intergenerational expansion to the full mutation in fra(X) may manifest a postzygotic event, decreases in mutation size may occur during or prior to meiosis.     

Fragile X gene instability: anchoring AGGs and linked microsatellites.

Interspersed AGGs within the FMR1 gene CGG repeat region may anchor the sequence and prevent slippage during replication. In order to detect the AGG position variations, we developed a method employing partial MnlI restriction analysis and analyzed X chromosomes from 187 males, including 133 normal controls (117 with 20-34 and 16 with 35-52 repeats), plus 54 fragile X premutations with 56-180 repeats. Among controls, the interspersed AGG positions were highly polymorphic, with a heterozygosity of 91%. Among the control samples, 1.5% had no AGG positions, 25% had one, 71% had two, and 3% had three. Among the fragile X premutation samples, 63% had no AGG, while 37% had only one AGG. Analysis of premutation samples within fragile X families showed that variation occurred only within the 3' end of the region. Thus, the instability was polar. Controls with > or = 15 pure CGG repeats were associated with the longest alleles of two nearby microsatellites, FRAXAC1 with 20-21 repeats and DXS548 with 202-206 bp and with increased microsatellite heterozygosity. The association of long pure CGG regions, as with fragile X chromosomes, with the longer and more heterozygous microsatellite alleles suggests they may be related mechanistically. Further, our results do not support a recent suggestion that the frequency of fragile X alleles may be increasing. Finally, analysis of a set of nonhuman primate samples showed that long pure CGG tracks are variable in size and are located within the 3' region, which suggests that polar instability within FMR1 is evolutionarily quite old.     

FMR1 Premutation Is an Uncommon Explanation for Premature Ovarian Failure in Han Chinese

Background

In premature ovarian failure (POF), cessation of menstruation occurs before the expected age of menopause. Approximately 1% of women are affected. FMR1 premutation was reported to be responsible for up to 3.3%–6.7% of sporadic POF and 13% of familial cases in Caucasians, while the data was absent in Chinese population. Therefore, the impact of FMR1 CGG repeat on ovarian reserve is needed to be investigated in large Chinese cohort.

Methods

The number of FMR1 CGG repeat was determined in 379 Han Chinese women with well-defined 46, XX non-syndromic sporadic POF and 402 controls. The age of menopause onset in respect to CGG repeats was further analyzed.

Results

The frequency of FMR1 premutation in Han Chinese POF was only 0.5% (2/379), although it was higher than that in matched controls (0%, 0/402), it was much lower than that reported in Caucasian with POF (3.3%–6.7%). The prevalence of intermediate FMR1 (41–54) was not increased significantly in sporadic POF than that in controls (2.9% vs. 1.7%, P = 0.343). However, POF patients more often carried a single additional CGG repeat in a single allele than did fertile women (allele-1: 29.7 vs. 28.8, P<0.001; allele-2: 32.6 vs. 31.5, P<0.001). POF patients with both alleles of CGG repeats outside (below or above) the normal range (26–34) showed an earlier age of cessation of menses than those with two alleles within normal range (hom-high/high vs. norm: 20.4±4.8 vs. 24.7±6.4, p<0.01; hom-low/high vs. norm: 18.7±1.7 vs. 24.7±6.4, p<0.01).

Conclusions

FMR1 premutation seems to be an uncommon explanation for POF in Han Chinese. However, having both alleles with CGG repeats outside the normal range might still adversely affect ovarian aging.     

The fragile X premutation: into the phenotypic fold

Premutation alleles (55-200 CGG repeats) of the fragile X mental retardation 1 gene (FMR1) are known to contribute to the fragile X phenotype through genetic instability and transmission of full mutation alleles (>200 repeats). There is now mounting evidence that the premutation alleles themselves contribute to clinical involvement, including premature ovarian failure among female carriers and a new tremor/ataxia syndrome among older male carriers. Recent observations also provide direct evidence of dysregulation of the FMR1 gene in the premutation range, which may explain many of the clinical observations.     

The risk of fragile X premutation expansion is lower in carriers detected by general prenatal screening than in carriers from known fragile X families

The Fragile X syndrome is the most common cause of inherited mental retardation. For a female premutation carrier, the risk of having a child with a full mutation is positively correlated with the size of the premutation. The current study was performed to evaluate the risk of premutation expansion in the offspring of average-risk carriers detected by general prenatal screening. Over a 4-year period, 9,660 women underwent DNA screening for FMR1 mutation/premutation at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center. A premutation was defined as a CGG repeat number >50 in the 5' untranslated region (UTR) of exon 1 in the FMR1 gene. The study included only individuals with no family history of X-linked mental retardation or known FMR1 mutations. A premutation was found in 85 women (1 in 114), 68 of whom consented to have prenatal diagnoses in 74 pregnancies. The abnormal allele was transmitted to the offspring in 44 pregnancies. Of these, no change in allele size was noted in 35 pregnancies (79.6%), and expansion within premutation range was evident in 4 pregnancies (9%). In 5 pregnancies (11.4%), expansion to the full mutation was noted. This occurred only in carriers having more than 90 repeats. We conclude that the likelihood of Fragile X premutation expansion to full mutation is significantly lower in individuals ascertained by general prenatal carrier testing than in those from known Fragile X families.     

FMR1 repeat sizes in the gray zone and high end of the normal range are associated with premature ovarian failure

Premature ovarian failure (POF) is the occurrence of menopause before the age of 40 and affects 1% of the female population. Whereas the etiology of POF is largely unexplained, FMR1 premutation carriers are known to be at increased risk of POF compared with the general population. The FMR1 premutation alleles have 55–200 copies of a CGG repeat in the 5 untranslated region of the FMR1 gene. However, functional effects on gene expression may occur even for repeat sizes in what has been considered the normal range. To evaluate the role of the FMR1 repeat in POF, repeat sizes were examined in 53 women with idiopathic POF, 161 control women from the general population, and 21 women with proven fertility at an advanced maternal age. A significant increase in the number of FMR1 alleles between and including 35 and 54 CGG repeats was found in the POF patient population; 15 of 106 (14.2%) POF alleles were between and including 35 and 54 repeats, whereas only 21 of 322 (6.5%) alleles in the general population (P=0.02) and 2 of 42 (4.8%) alleles from women with proven late fertility (P=0.09) were of this size (P=0.01 versus combined controls). The effect was also significant for comparisons of genotype repeat size (repeat size weighted by the relative activity of the two FMR1 alleles) and biallelic mean (average size of the two alleles). These results are clinically relevant and suggest that the FMR1 gene plays a more significant role in the incidence of POF than has previously been thought.     

Molecular diagnosis of the fragile X and FRAXE syndromes in patients with mental retardation of unknown cause in Mexico

The fragile X syndrome (Fra-X) is the most common cause of inherited mental retardation with X-linked semi-dominant inheritance. The prevalence of Fra-X in the Mexican population is unknown. The aim of this population screening study was to determine if Fra-X or FRAXE mutations are the cause of a number of cases of mental retardation in a sample of Mexican children with mental retardation of unknown cause (MRUC) and to stress the importance of performing molecular analysis of the FMR-1 gene in all patients with MRUC. We report here the direct analysis of CGG and GCC repeats within the FMR-1 and FMR-2 genes, respectively, in 62 unrelated patients with MRUC. Two male index cases had the CGG expansion, although they did not express the Xq27.3 fragile site cytogenetically. Fra-X diagnosis was highly suspected on a clinical basis in one of the patients, but not in the other. Both mothers were found to be premutation carriers. The molecular studies of FMR-1 showed that the proportion of MRUC patients with Fra-X is 3.2%. This frequency was not significantly different to that reported in most populations. As reported in other series, no patients with FRAXE were found in our sample. Our findings confirm that the molecular analysis of the FMR-1 gene is necessary in MRUC patients to achieve unequivocal diagnosis of fragile X syndrome, carrier premutation detection and for accurate genetic counseling.