ESR spin-label studies of lipid-protein interactions in membranes

Lipid spin labels have been used to study lipid-protein interactions in bovine and frog rod outer segment disc membranes, in (Na+, K+)-ATPase membranes from shark rectal gland, and in yeast cytochrome oxidase-dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine complexes. These systems all display a two component ESR spectrum from 14-doxyl lipid spin-labels. One component corresponds to the normal fluid bilayer lipids. The second component has a greater degree of motional restriction and arises from lipids interacting with the protein. For the phosphatidylcholine spin label there are effectively 55 +/- 5 lipids/200,000-dalton cytochrome oxidase, 58 +/- 4 mol lipid/265,000 dalton (Na+, K+)-ATPase, and 24 +/- 3 and 22 +/- 2 mol lipid/37,000 dalton rhodopsin for the bovine and frog preparations, respectively. These values correlate roughly with the intramembrane protein perimeter and scale with the square root of the molecular weight of the protein. For cytochrome oxidase the motionally restricted component bears a fixed stoichiometry to the protein at high lipid:protein ratios, and is reduced at low lipid:protein ratios to an extent which can be quantitatively accounted for by random protein-protein contacts. Experiments with spin labels of different headgroups indicate a marked selectivity of cytochrome oxidase and the (Na+, K+)-ATPase for stearic acid and for cardiolipin, relative to phosphatidylcholine. The motionally restricted component from the cardiolipin spin label is 80% greater than from the phosphatidylcholine spin label for cytochrome oxidase (at lipid:protein = 90.1), and 160% greater for the (Na+, K+)-ATPase. The corresponding increases for the stearic acid label are 20% for cytochrome oxidase and 40% for (Na+, K+)-ATPase. The effective association constant for cardiolipin is approximately 4.5 times greater than for phosphatidylcholine, and that for stearic acid is 1.5 times greater, in both systems. Almost no specificity is found in the interaction of spin-labeled lipids (including cardiolipin) with rhodopsin in the rod outer segment disc membrane. The linewidths of the fluid spin-label component in bovine rod outer segment membranes are consistently higher than those in bilayers of the extracted membrane lipids and provide valuable information on the rate of exchange between the two lipid components, which is suggested to be in the range of 10(6)-10(7) s-1.     

Mattress model of lipid-protein interactions in membranes.

A thermodynamic model is proposed for describing phase diagrams of mixtures of lipid bilayers and amphiphilic proteins or polypeptides in water solution. The basic geometrical variables of the model are the thickness of the hydrophobic region of the lipid bilayer and the length of the hydrophobic region of the proteins. The model incorporates the elastic properties of the lipid bilayer and the proteins, as well as indirect and direct lipid-protein interactions expressed in terms of the geometrical variables. The concept of mismatch of the hydrophobic regions of the lipids and proteins is an important ingredient of the model. The general phase behavior is calculated using simple real solution theory. The phase behavior turns out to be quite rich and is used to discuss previous experiments on planar aggregations of proteins in phospholipid bilayers and to propose a systematic study of synthetic amphiphilic polypeptides in bilayers of different thicknesses. The model is used to interpret the influence of the lipid-protein interaction on calorimetric measurements and on local orientational order as determined by deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance.     

Spin-label ESR studies of lipid-protein interactions in thylakoid membranes

Lipid-protein interactions in thylakoid membranes, and in the subthylakoid membrane fractions containing either photosystem 1 or photosystem 2, have been studied by using spin-labeled analogues of the thylakoid membrane lipid components, monogalactosyldiacylglycerol, phosphatidylglycerol, and phosphatidylcholine. The electron spin resonance spectra of the spin-labeled lipids all consist of two components, one corresponding to the fluid lipid environment in the membranes and the other to the motionally restricted membrane lipids interacting directly with the integral membrane proteins. Spectral subtraction has been used to quantitate the fraction of the membrane lipids in contact with the membrane proteins and to determine the selectivity between the different lipid classes for the lipid-protein interaction. The fractions of motionally restricted lipid in the thylakoid membrane are 0.36, 0.39, and 0.53, for the spin-labeled monogalactosyldiacylglycerol, phosphatidylcholine, the phosphatidylglycerol, respectively. Spin-labeled monogalactosyldiacylglycerol exhibits very little preferential interaction over phosphatidylchline, which suggests that part of the role of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol in thylakoid membranes is structural, as is the case for phosphatidylcholine in mammalian membranes. Spin-labeled phosphatidylglycerol shows a preferential interaction over the corresponding monogalactosyldiacylglycerol and phosphatidylcholine analogues, in contrast to the common behavior of this lipid in mammalian systems. This pattern of lipid selectivity is preserved in both the photosystem 1 and photosystem 2 enriched subthylakoid membrane fractions.     

The role of surfactant proteins in DPPC enrichment of surface films

A pressure-driven captive bubble surfactometer was used to determine the role of surfactant proteins in refinement of the surface film. The advantage of this apparatus is that surface films can be spread at the interface of an air bubble with a different lipid/protein composition than the subphase vesicles. Using different combinations of subphase vesicles and spread surface films a clear correlation between dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) content and minimum surface tension was observed. Spread phospholipid films containing 50% DPPC over a subphase containing 50% DPPC vesicles did not form stable surface films with a low minimum surface tension. Addition of surfactant protein B (SP-B) to the surface film led to a progressive decrease in minimum surface tension toward 1 mN/m upon cycling, indicating an enrichment in DPPC. Surfactant protein C (SP-C) had no such detectable refining effect on the film. Surfactant protein A (SP-A) had a positive effect on refinement when it was present in the subphase. However, this effect was only observed when SP-A was combined with SP-B and incubated with subphase vesicles before addition to the air bubble containing sample chamber. Comparison of spread films with adsorbed films indicated that refinement induced by SP-B occurs by selective removal of non-DPPC lipids upon cycling. SP-A, combined with SP-B, induces a selective adsorption of DPPC from subphase vesicles into the surface film. This is achieved by formation of large lipid structures which might resemble tubular myelin.     

Effects of melittin on lipid-protein interactions in sarcoplasmic reticulum membranes.

To investigate the physical mechanism by which melittin inhibits Ca-adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) activity in sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) membranes, we have used electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy to probe the effect of melittin on lipid-protein interactions in SR. Previous studies have shown that melittin substantially restricts the rotational mobility of the Ca-ATPase but only slightly decreases the average lipid hydrocarbon chain fluidity in SR. Therefore, in the present study, we ask whether melittin has a preferential effect on Ca-ATPase boundary lipids, i.e., the annular shell of motionally restricted lipid that surrounds the protein. Paramagnetic derivatives of stearic acid and phosphatidylcholine, spin-labeled at C-14, were incorporated into SR membranes. The electronic paramagnetic resonance spectra of these probes contained two components, corresponding to motionally restricted and motionally fluid lipids, that were analyzed by spectral subtraction. The addition of increasing amounts of melittin, to the level of 10 mol melittin/mol Ca-ATPase, progressively increased the fraction of restricted lipids and increased the hyperfine splitting of both components in the composite spectra, indicating that melittin decreases the hydrocarbon chain rotational mobility for both the fluid and restricted populations of lipids. No further effects were observed above a level of 10 mol melittin/mol Ca-ATPase. In the spectra from control and melittin-containing samples, the fraction of restricted lipids decreased significantly with increasing temperature. The effect of melittin was similar to that of decreased temperature, i.e., each spectrum obtained in the presence of melittin (10:1) was nearly identical to the spectrum obtained without melittin at a temperature approximately 5 degrees C lower. The results suggest that the principal effect of melittin on SR membranes is to induce protein aggregation and this in turn, augmented by direct binding of melittin to the lipid, is responsible for the observed decreases in lipid mobility. Protein aggregation is concluded to be the main cause of inactivation of the Ca-ATPase by melittin, with possible modulation also by the decrease in mobility of the boundary layer lipids.     

Phospholipid packing and hydration in pulmonary surfactant membranes and films as sensed by LAURDAN

The efficiency of pulmonary surfactant to stabilize the respiratory surface depends critically on the ability of surfactant to form highly packed films at the air-liquid interface. In the present study we have compared the packing and hydration properties of lipids in native pulmonary surfactant and in several surfactant models by analyzing the pressure and temperature dependence of the fluorescence emission of the LAURDAN (1-[6-(dimethylamino)-2-naphthyl]dodecan-1-one) probe incorporated into surfactant interfacial films or free-standing membranes. In interfacial films, compression-driven changes in the fluorescence of LAURDAN, evaluated from the generalized polarization function (GPF), correlated with changes in packing monitored by surface pressure. Compression isotherms and GPF profiles of films formed by native surfactant or its organic extract were compared at 25 or 37 °C to those of films made of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC), DPPC/phosphatidylglycerol (PG) (7:3, w/w), or the mixture DPPC/POPC/palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylglycerol (POPG)/cholesterol (Chol) (50:25:15.10), which simulates the lipid composition of surfactant. In general terms, compression of surfactant films at 25 °C leads to LAURDAN GPF values close to those obtained from pure DPPC monolayers, suggesting that compressed surfactant films reach a dehydrated state of the lipid surface, which is similar to that achieved in DPPC monolayers. However, at 37 °C, the highest GPF values were achieved in films made of full surfactant organic extract or the mixture DPPC/POPC/POPG/Chol, suggesting a potentially important role of cholesterol to ensure maximal packing/dehydration under physiological constraints. Native surfactant films reached high pressures at 37 °C while maintaining relatively low GPF, suggesting that the complex three-dimensional structures formed by whole surfactant might withstand the highest pressures without necessarily achieving full dehydration of the lipid environments sensed by LAURDAN. Finally, comparison of the thermotropic profiles of LAURDAN GPF in surfactant model bilayers and monolayers of analogous composition shows that the fluorophore probes an environment that is in average intrinsically more hydrated at the interface than inserted into free-standing bilayers, particularly at 37 °C. This effect suggests that the dependence of membrane and surfactant events on the balance of polar/non-polar interactions could differ in bilayer and monolayer models, and might be affected differently by the access of water molecules to confined or free-standing lipid structures.     

Combinations of fluorescently labeled pulmonary surfactant proteins SP-B and SP-C in phospholipid films

Hydrophobic pulmonary surfactant (PS) proteins B (SP-B) and C (SP-C) modulate the surface properties of PS lipids. Epifluorescence microscopy was performed on solvent-spread monolayers of fluorescently labeled porcine SP-B (R-SP-B, labeled with Texas Red) and SP-C (F-SP-C, labeled with fluorescein) in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) (at protein concentrations of 10 and 20 wt%, and 10 wt% of both) under conditions of cyclic compression and expansion. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) spectroscopy of R-SP-B and F-SP-C indicated that the proteins were intact and labeled with the appropriate fluorescent probe. The monolayers were compressed and expanded for four cycles at an initial rate of 0.64 A2 x mol(-1) x s(-1) (333 mm2 x s x [-1]) up to a surface pressure pi approximately 65 mN/m, and pi-area per residue (pi-A) isotherms at 22 +/- 1 degrees C were obtained. The monolayers were microscopically observed for the fluorescence emission of the individual proteins present in the film lipid matrix, and their visual features were video recorded for image analysis. The pi-A isotherms of the DPPC/protein monolayers showed characteristic "squeeze out" effects at pi approximately 43 mN/m for R-SP-B and 55 mN/m for F-SP-C, as had previously been observed for monolayers of the native proteins in DPPC. Both proteins associated with the expanded (fluid) phase of DPPC monolayers remained in or associated with the monolayers at high pi (approximately 65 mN/m) and redispersed in the monolayer upon its reexpansion. At comparable pi and area/molecule of the lipid, the proteins reduced the amounts of condensed (gel-like) phase of DPPC monolayers, with F-SP-C having a greater effect on a weight basis than did R-SP-B. In any one of the lipid/protein monolayers the amounts of the DPPC in condensed phase were the same at equivalent pi during compression and expansion and from cycle to cycle. This indicated that only minor loss of components from these systems occurred between compression-expansion cycles. This study indicates that hydrophobic PS proteins associate with the fluid phase of DPPC in films, some proteins remain at high surface pressures in the films, and such lipid-protein films can still attain high pi during compression.     

Reassembly of lipid-protein complexes of pulmonary surfactant. Proposed mechanism of interaction

We studied the interaction at 37 degrees C between a major apolipoprotein of pulmonary surfactant and 11 mixtures of lipids. The experiments were carried out in the presence of either 3 mM Ca2+ or 10 mM EDTA. The amount of apolipoprotein associated with lipid was independent of Ca2+. However the binding was sensitive to the percentage of gel-state lipid in the vesicles, and the amount of apolipoprotein in the recombinant lipoprotein complex decreased as the percentage of fully saturated phospholipid was reduced. Maximum association of the apolipoprotein occurred with lipid vesicles containing 85% 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and 15% 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-1-glycerol or 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycerol. Fluorescence measurements on the apolipoprotein indicated that the tryptophan side chains were in a relatively hydrophobic environment, and that the wavelength of maximum fluorescence emission was not changed upon the binding of lipid. The results suggest that the principal mode of interaction between the apolipoprotein and lipids of surfactant is hydrophobic bonding. The most extensive binding occurs with lamellar lipids in a gel that would be expected to have inhomogeneities in packing density due to the presence of acidic phospholipids or other glycerolipids. The role of Ca2+ in this interaction has not been fully determined. Although it is not needed to effect the binding of the lipids and the apolipoprotein, it does influence the physical state of the complex, and possibly the stoichiometry of lipid to protein. Some of the processes mediated by Ca2+ in this interaction may be analogous to those observed in membrane fusion. Thus, Ca2+ probably causes segregation of the lamellar phospholipids into domains, inducing vesicular disruption and fusion. This lipid aggregates about hydrophobic sites on the protein, thereby forming high molecular weight reassembly complexes.     

Lipid-lipid and lipid-protein interactions in chromaffin granule membranes: A spin label ESR study

The ESR spectra of six different positional isomers of a stearic acid and three of a phosphatidylcholine spin label have been studied as a function of temperature in chromaffin granule membranes from the bovine adrenal medulla, and in bilayers formed by aqueous dispersion of the extracted membrane lipids. Only minor differences were found between the spectra of the membranes and the extracted lipid, indicating that the major portion of the membrane lipid is organized in a bilayer arrangement which is relatively unperturbed by the presence of the membrane protein. The order parameter profile of the spin label lipid chain motion is less steep over the first half of the chain than over the section toward the terminal methyl end of the chain. This ‘stiffening’ effect is attributed to the high proportion of cholesterol in the membrane and becomes less marked as the temperature is raised. The isotropic hyperfine splitting factors of the various positional isomers display a profile of decreasing polarity as one penetrates further into the interior of the membrane. No marked differences are observed between the effective polarities in the intact membranes and in bilayers of the extracted membrane lipids. The previously observed temperature-induced structural change occurring in the membranes at approx. 35°C was found also in the extracted lipid bilayers, showing this to be a result of lipid-lipid interactions and not lipid-protein interactions in the membrane. A steroid spin label indicated a second temperature-dependent structural change occurring in the lipid bilayers at lower temperatures. This corresponds to the onset of a more rapid rotation about the long axis of the lipid molecules at a temperature of approx. 10°C. The lipid bilayer regions probed by the spin labels used in this study may be involved in the fusion of the chromaffin granule membrane leading to hormone release by exocytosis.     

Calcium interactions in pulmonary surfactant

The surfactant properties of natural bovine pulmonary surfactant, its lipid extracts and acetone precipitates of lipid extracts have been examined with an artificial alveolus model, the pulsating-bubble surfactometer. At bulk concentrations of 0.4% (wt./vol.) phospholipid in saline, all three preparations exhibited surfactant activity, i.e., were capable of reducing the surface tension of the pulsating bubble to approx. 27 dynes/cm at maximum bubble radius and to near zero at minimum bubble radius. At a concentration of 0.1% (wt./vol.) in saline, only natural surfactant was effective. Acetone-precipitated surfactant at 0.1% (wt./vol.) achieved these criteria in the presence of 5 mM calcium, but 15-20 mM calcium was required to restore the surfactant activity of lipid extract surfactant. Chemical analysis revealed that lipid extraction decreases the protein content but does not alter the endogenous calcium levels. A calcium requirement for natural surfactant could only be demonstrated after repeated treatment with chelators for divalent cations. Surfactant activity was restored by low levels of calcium or high levels of magnesium. Paradoxically, a calcium requirement could not be demonstrated by treating acetone-precipitated lipid extract with chelators. The subtle differences noted between natural, lipid extract and acetone-precipitated lipid extract surfactant with the pulsating-bubble assay show that the latter preparations do not represent simplified model systems for the natural product.     

The role of chromophore in the lipid-protein interactions in bacteriorhodopsin-phosphatidylcholine vesicles

By fluorescence and phase properties of a 1-acyl-2-[8-(2-anthroyl)-octanoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine probe, the influence of the chromophore on the phase transition of bacteriorhodopsin–lipid vesicles was investigated. It was observed that removal of the chromophore led to the down-shifting of the phase transition temperatures. The temperatures corresponding to the beginning and ending of the gel–liquid phase transition were also influenced. This demonstrated that the liquid phase is reached more easily when the chromophore is bleached. The results indicate that removal of the chromophore alters the protein–lipid interactions. It is suggested that this alteration might be related to the change in the lipid molecular packing.     

Atomic force microscopy studies of functional and dysfunctional pulmonary surfactant films, II: albumin-inhibited pulmonary surfactant films and the effect of SP-A

Pulmonary surfactant (PS) dysfunction because of the leakage of serum proteins into the alveolar space could be an operative pathogenesis in acute respiratory distress syndrome. Albumin-inhibited PS is a commonly used in vitro model for studying surfactant abnormality in acute respiratory distress syndrome. However, the mechanism by which PS is inhibited by albumin remains controversial. This study investigated the film organization of albumin-inhibited bovine lipid extract surfactant (BLES) with and without surfactant protein A (SP-A), using atomic force microscopy. The BLES and albumin (1:4 w/w) were cospread at an air-water interface from aqueous media. Cospreading minimized the adsorption barrier for phospholipid vesicles imposed by preadsorbed albumin molecules, i.e., inhibition because of competitive adsorption. Atomic force microscopy revealed distinct variations in film organization, persisting up to 40 mN/m, compared with pure BLES monolayers. Fluorescence confocal microscopy confirmed that albumin remained within the liquid-expanded phase of the monolayer at surface pressures higher than the equilibrium surface pressure of albumin. The remaining albumin mixed with the BLES monolayer so as to increase film compressibility. Such an inhibitory effect could not be relieved by repeated compression-expansion cycles or by adding surfactant protein A. These experimental data indicate a new mechanism of surfactant inhibition by serum proteins, complementing the traditional competitive adsorption mechanism.     

ESR studies of spin-labeled membranes aligned by isopotential spin-dry ultracentrifugation: lipid-protein interactions.

Electron spin resonance (ESR) studies have been performed on spin-labeled model membranes aligned using the isopotential spin-dry ultracentrifugation (ISDU) method of Clark and Rothschild. This method relies on sedimentation of the membrane fragments onto a gravitational isopotential surface with simultaneous evaporation of the solvent in a vacuum ultracentrifuge to promote alignment. The degree of alignment obtainable using ISDU, as monitored by ESR measurements of molecular ordering for both lipid (16-PC) and cholestane spin labels (CSL), in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) model membranes compares favorably with that obtainable by pressure-annealing. The much gentler conditions under which membranes may be aligned by ISDU greatly extends the range of macroscopically aligned membrane samples that may be investigated by ESR. We report the first ESR study of an integral membrane protein, bacteriorhodopsin (BR) in well-aligned multilayers. We have also examined ISDU-aligned DPPC multilayers incorporating a short peptide gramicidin A' (GA), with higher water content than previously studied. 0.24 mol% BR/DPPC membranes with CSL probe show two distinct components, primarily in the gel phase, which can be attributed to bulk and boundary regions of the bilayer. The boundary regions show sharply decreased molecular ordering and spectral effects comparable to those observed from 2 mol% GA/DPPC membranes. The boundary regions for both BR and GA also exhibit increased fluidity as monitored by the rotational diffusion rates. The high water content of the GA/DPPC membranes reduces the disordering effect as evidenced by the reduced populations of the disordered components. The ESR spectra obtained slightly below the main phase transition of DPPC from both the peptide- and protein-containing membranes reveals a new component with increased ordering of the lipids associated with the peptide or protein. This increase coincides with a broad endothermic peak in the DSC, suggesting a disaggregation of both the peptide and the protein before the main phase transition of the lipid. Detailed simulations of the multicomponent ESR spectra have been performed by the latest nonlinear least-squares methods, which have helped to clarify the spectral interpretations. It is found that the simulations of ESR spectra from CSL in the gel phase for all the lipid membranes studied could be significantly improved by utilizing a model with CSL molecules existing as both hydrogen-bonded to the bilayer interface and non-hydrogen-bonded within the bilayer.     

The role of lipid-protein interactions in amyloid-type protein fibril formation

Structural transition of polypeptide chains into the beta-sheet state followed by amyloid fibril formation is the key characteristic of a number of the so-called conformational diseases. The multistep process of protein fibrillization can be modulated by a variety of factors, in particular by lipid-protein interactions. A wealth of experimental evidence provides support to the notion that amyloid fibril assembly and the toxicity of pre-fibrillar aggregates are closely related and are both intimately membrane associated phenomena. The present review summarizes the principal factors responsible for the enhancement of fibril formation in a membrane environment, viz. (i) structural transformation of polypeptide chain into a partially folded conformation, (ii) increase of the local concentration of a protein upon its membrane binding, (iii) aggregation-favoring orientation of the bound protein, and (iv) variation in the depth of bilayer penetration affecting the nucleation propensity of the membrane associated protein. The molecular mechanisms of membrane-mediated protein fibrillization are discussed. Importantly, the toxicity of lipid-induced pre-fibrillar aggregates is likely to have presented a very strong negative selection pressure in the evolution of amino acid sequences.     

Selectivity of lipid-protein interactions

The spin label ESR and intrinsic fluorescence quenching methods of determining the selectivity of interactions of lipids with integral membrane proteins are summarized. The selectivity patterns of phospholipids, fatty acids, and steroids are reviewed for a variety of integral proteins. Where appropriate, correlations are established with biochemical assays of the effects of specific lipids on enzymatic activity and transport function.     

Structure–function correlations of pulmonary surfactant protein SP-B and the saposin-like family of proteins

Pulmonary surfactant is a lipid-protein complex secreted by the respiratory epithelium of mammalian lungs, which plays an essential role in stabilising the alveolar surface and so reducing the work of breathing. The surfactant protein SP-B is part of this complex, and is strictly required for the assembly of pulmonary surfactant and its extracellular development to form stable surface-active films at the air–liquid alveolar interface, making the lack of SP-B incompatible with life. In spite of its physiological importance, a model for the structure and the mechanism of action of SP-B is still needed. The sequence of SP-B is homologous to that of the saposin-like family of proteins, which are membrane-interacting polypeptides with apparently diverging activities, from the co-lipase action of saposins to facilitate the degradation of sphingolipids in the lysosomes to the cytolytic actions of some antibiotic proteins, such as NK-lysin and granulysin or the amoebapore of Entamoeba histolytica. Numerous studies on the interactions of these proteins with membranes have still not explained how a similar sequence and a potentially related fold can sustain such apparently different activities. In the present review, we have summarised the most relevant features of the structure, lipid-protein and protein–protein interactions of SP-B and the saposin-like family of proteins, as a basis to propose an integrated model and a common mechanistic framework of the apparent functional versatility of the saposin fold.