Suppressor cells in homograft tolerant rats.

If sufficient normal syngeneic lymphocytes to effect skin graft rejection are transferred to homograft tolerant rats, a prolonged period elapses before lymphoid cells from the recipient acquire normal levels of GvH responsiveness against tissues of which the donor was previously tolerant (Silvers and Billingham, 1970; Elkins, 1972; Miyamoto and McCullagh, 1974). Although the ability of lymphoid populations of such animals to mount GvH reactions can be demonstrated to reside in donor type cells during the weeks immediately after transfer, reactive cells are ultimately derived from the host itself (Elkins, 1973; Miyamoto and McCullagh, 1974). Not only are lymphoid cells from tolerant rats which have been injected recently with normal lymphocytes poorly responsive in a GvH assay, but they have been observed in some experiments to suppress the GvH activity of normal syngeneic lymphoid cells (Elkins, 1972; Atkins and Ford, 1972). It is not clear whether the cells mediating suppression of the normal lymphocytes were derived from the tolerant host itself or, alternatively, from the normal lymphocytes injected into it to terminate the tolerant state. The present experiments sought to delineate the origin of any suppressor cells within populations of lymphocytes collected from rats in which tolerance had recently been terminated. The indicate that suppression of the normal donor cells within such populations may be exerted by cells derived from the tolerant host.     

Regulation of the immune response in autoimmune NZB/NZW F1 mice. I. The spontaneous generation of splenic suppressor cells.

The lymphoproliferative responses of rat peripheral blood lymphocytes to phytohemagglutinin (PHA) were studied following treatment with single or multiple doses of cyclophosphamide. A dose-dependent lymphocytopenia was observed with both regimes. The remaining lymphocytes had decreased responses to PHA. Serum collected 24 hr after a single injection of cyclophosphamide and used at a concentration of 5% enhanced the response of cells from normal or cyclophosphamide-treated rats. Serum collected after a course of treatment did not have this effect, but it lacked the marked suppressive activity, at a concentration of 20%, which was shown by normal rat serum. The enhancing activity was not dialysable. Doses of cyclophosphamide adequate to abolish primary antibody production to sheep erythrocytes did not totally abrogate responsiveness to PHA. Thus, the pattern of immunological defects in cyclophosphamide-treated rats consisted of decreased primary antibody production, lymphocytopenia with a decreased response of the remaining lymphocytes to PHA, and diminution of serum suppressive activity.     

SPECIFIC positive and negative selection of rat lymphocytes reactive to strong histocompatibility antigens: activation with alloantigens in vitro and in vivo.

This study compares the functional properties of rat thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) after stimulation with strong alloantigens of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) either in vitro in preparative mixed lymphocyte interactions (MLI) or in vivo in systemic graft-vs-host (GVH) reactions. Comparisons were made of PHA responses and reactivity to the specific priming haplotypes or to third party haplotypes in analytical MLI and in GVH reactions either before or after the activated populations were "parked" in syngenetic T cell-deprived (B) rats. These comparisons can be summarized as follows: 1) TDL populations primed in bulk MLI cultures (MLI-TDL) slowed some evidence of specific positive selection when tested immediately; MLI responses to specific alloantigens were both relatively large and accelerated in tempo, whereas responses to third party alloantigens were diminished but also accelerated in tempo. Specific GVH responses were more marked than in third party recipients but they were also decreased relative to normal, and displayed an abberant dose/response slope. MLI-TDL populations tested after they had been stored in syngeneic B rats showed clear evidence of stable-specific positive selection; specific MLI and GVH responses were enriched relative to third party responses and also in comparison to normal, unselected TDL populations. This finding indicates that GVH and MLI reactivity are probably both functional capacities of the same lymphocyte subpopulation since positive selection by one function (MLI) also enriched for a second (GVH). 2) Parental strain TDL activated in vivo in the systemic GVH reaction in irradiated F1 animals and recovered from the thoracic duct 3 to 4 days later (late GVH-TDL) consisted mainly of blast cells, however, in contrast to MLI-TDL these populations showed no evidence of positive selection when tested before or after parking in B rats. MLI responses to specific alloantigens were minimal, and greatly reduced in magnitude compared to normal. GVH responses to specific haplotypes could be detected, but these were not enriched compared to normal, despite the content in the late GVH-TDL populations of a significant proportion of blast cells presumably activated by host alloantigens. 3) Early collections (less than 40 hr) of parental strain GVH-TDL collected from F1 recipients contained no blast cells and showed impressive degrees of negative selection; they were markedly depleted of both GVH and MLI activity to specific alloantigens but displayed normal reactivity to third party alloantigens. Moreover, specific negative selection was persistent in these populations parked for several weeks in B rats, and indication that a specific subpopulation of reactive cells had been physically eliminated. 4) PHA responses of both MLI- and GVH-activated TDL populations tested either before or after parking in B rats were approximately normal on a per T cell basis...     

Cell transfer studies in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

Thymectomized, irradiated adult CBA mice were restored with various combinations of bone marrow and thymus cells from nontolerant animals and from animals made tolerant to sheep erythrocytes or to hemocyanin with the drug cyclophosphamide. Mice reconstituted with tolerant marrow and thymus responded as well as those that received nontolerant cells. Thus it is concluded that the tolerant state of the transferred marrow and thymus cells is not a significant factor in the tolerant state of the recipient, and that antigenic diversity is restored in the interaction and proliferation of bone marrow and thymus cells that follow transfer.Thymectomized irradiated mice restored with thymocytes, in contrast to unoperated animals, require multiple antigen injections to demonstrate comparable immune response, but develop tolerance normally when treated with cyclophosphamide and antigen. Reconstitution with tolerant marrow and thymus cells resembles the recovery of immune responsiveness seen after lethal irradiation of tolerant mice; in both instances a complete breakdown of immunological tolerance is observed.     

Stimulation of antibody synthesizing lymphocytes in the rat by antigen reactive cells sensitized in vitro.

Lymphocytes obtained from rat spleens were sensitized in vitro to sheep erythrocytes. The sensitized lymphocytes did not synthesize antibody but when injected into unimmunized rats did stimulate antibody production to sheep erythrocytes. Analysis of the location of 7 and 19 S plaque-forming cells in the recipient rats indicated that these two antibody synthesizing cell populations arise from different lymphocytes. It was also found that the sensitized lymphocytes could react only with a limited number of antibody synthesizing cells.     

A study of the mechanism of Con A-induced immunosuppression in vivo

The plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) is suppressed in a dose-related manner when concanavalin A (Con A) is administered intravenously to mice prior to or after immunization with antigen. The magnitude of suppression as well as the duration of the Con A effect greatly depends on the concentration of antigen used for immunization. Although profound suppression of the anti-SRBC PFC response is observed in intact mice pretreated with Con A for 4-24 hr, spleen cells from these mice do not exhibit suppressive activity when transferred into normal recipients or when cotransferred with normal spleen cells into irradiated recipients. Moreover, the cells from Con A-treated mice respond as normal spleen cells to SRBC when transferred alone into irradiated hosts. Suppression of the anti-SRBC PFC is only observed when adoptive hosts of cells from Con A-treated mice are also injected with Con A within 48 hr (but not 72 hr) of cell transfer and immunization. This time course of responsiveness to the suppressive effects of Con A is similar to that observed in normal mice and in irradiated recipients of normal spleen cells. The immune response to SRBC is also suppressed in adoptive hosts of normal spleen cells that are pretreated with Con A 4-24 hr prior to irradiation and cell transfer. Although functionally inactive when transferred into adoptive hosts, spleen cells from mice pretreated with Con A for 4-24 hr can suppress a primary antibody response to SRBC in vitro. The suppressive activity, which cannot be detected in the spleens of mice when the interval between pretreatment and assay is longer than 24 hr, is present in a subpopulation that bears the Thy 1.2 and Lyt 2 phenotype. Taken together the results obtained in in vivo and in vitro functional assays suggest that a suppressor cell population is activated following in vivo treatment with Con A, but that the cells rapidly lose their state of activation when removed from a Con A environment. This phenomenon is in all probability responsible for the failure to demonstrate suppressive activity in the spleens of Con A-treated mice using in vivo functional assays.     

Genetic differences in lymphoid tissue reactivity during liver regeneration in mice of different lines]

The transfer of lymphocytes together with sheep erythrocytes from partially hepatectomized mice to syngenous lethally irradiated mice (CAB and C57BL) increased the number of antibody forming cells in the recipient's spleen. The lymphocytes of CBA mice acquired this ability much earlier after the operation (in 4 hours) than those of the C57BL mice (in 17 hours). After the transfer of lymphocytes in the semisyngenous system there was a decrease of antibody forming cells during subsequent recipient's immunization with sheep erythrocytes; this was the result of the graft versus host reaction. The latter reaction was less marked in the operated than in control mice. These changes also occurred earlier after the operation in the CBA than in C57BL mice.     

Cellular events in tolerance. II. Thymus-bone marrow cell cooperation in the immune response to BSA in Wistar Furth rats

Normal bone marrow cells from Wistar Furth rats were competent to transfer immune responsiveness to bovine serum albumin to thymectomised, irradiated, syngeneic recipients. When the bone marrow cells were taken from donors thymectomised early in life they were incompetent, but competence was restored by addition of normal thymus cells. It was concluded that normal Wistar Furth bone marrow cells contain some thymus-derived cells. Thymus cells from tolerant donors were less effective in cooperation with bone marrow cells, however the thymus cells appeared less tolerant than their donors.     

The xenogeneic effect. I. Antigen and mitogen-stimulated human lymphocytes produce a non-antigen-specific factor which reconstitutes the antibody response of T cell-deficient mouse spleen cells.

Modified Marbrook culture vessels with two chambers separated by a 0.2-mu porosity membrane have been utilized to show that antigen-stimulated human lymphocytes produce a soluble factor(s) which restores the ability of thymectomized, irradiated, and bone marrow-protected mice to mount a primary IgM plaque-forming cell response in vitro. In the initial experiments, the human lymphocytes plus antigen (sheep erythrocytes) were cultured in the lower chambers of the Marbrook vessels and the T cell-deficient mouse spleen cells plus sheep erythrocytes were cultured in the upper chambers. The response of the spleen cells was shown to be enhanced as a function of the number of human lymphocytes in the lower chambers. In subsequent experiments, the human lymphocytes were challenged with allogeneic lymphocytes or activated with a variety of T cell mitogens. Supernatants from these cultures, when placed in the lower chambers of the Marbrook vessels, were also capable of reconstituting the antibody-forming cell response of the mouse B cells. The results of the experiments are discussed in relation to a model of B cell induction which incorporates a non-antigen-specific "helpher" T cell.     

Interactions between B lymphocyte subpopulations. Augmentation of the responses of resting B lymphocytes by activated B lymphocytes

Mouse B lymphocytes were fractionated from normal T lymphocyte-depleted spleen cell populations using discontinuous percoll gradients and were stimulated with rabbit F(ab')2 anti-mouse mu-specific antibodies (anti-mu) plus the supernatant of Con A-stimulated rat spleen cells (SN) as a source of lymphokines. The responses of small (mean volume 120 mu 3), dense (greater than 1.087 specific gravity), resting (least spontaneous thymidine incorporation) B lymphocytes were augmented by irradiated (4000 rad), larger (mean volume greater than 170 mu 3), less dense (less than 1.081 specific gravity), activated (greater spontaneous thymidine incorporation) B lymphocytes. Proliferation was augmented 2- to 4-fold and polyclonal antibody-forming cell responses three- to sixfold. Maximal augmentation of the responses of 5 X 10(4) resting B cells was obtained with 10(4) activated B cells. Augmenting activity was specific for activated B lymphocytes in that responses were not augmented by irradiated thymocytes, T lymphoblasts, macrophages, or additional supernatant. B lymphocytes activated in vitro by LPS or anti-mu also had augmenting activity. Augmentation of responses was maximal only when activated B lymphocytes were added simultaneously with anti-mu. The interaction between activated and resting B lymphocytes did not appear to be genetically restricted. Interestingly, the augmenting activity of activated B cells could be reconstituted by a combination of supernatant and cell membranes from these cells but not by either alone, suggesting that two components are required, one soluble and the other membrane-bound. Thus, a functional interaction has been demonstrated between B lymphocyte subpopulations which differ in their state of activation, and this interaction appears to involve a novel mechanism of action.     

Activated T lymphocytes within human solid tumors

Summary The majority of lymphocytes separated from tumor cell suspensions were T cells. Conjugates of T lymphocytes and tumor cells were often seen. Variable numbers of T cells exhibited signs of activation such as the ability to form stable E rosettes and attachment to normal and malignant cells (a phenomenon designated natural attachment: NA). A proportion of T cells activated in vitro by allogeneic stimulation regularly exhibit these properties. The T cell-tumor conjugates in the suspensions may represent the NA phenomenon, but they could also be the product of T cells that adhere on the basis of specific recognition of cell surface antigens.Abbreviations BBS balanced salt solution - E rosettes rosettes formed with sheep erythrocytes - EA rosettes rosettes formed with ox erythrocytes coated with anti-ox IgG - FCS fetal calf serum - MLC mixed lymphocyte cultures - NA natural attachment - PBL peripheral blood lymphocytes - SRBC sheep erythrocytes - T lymphocytes thymusderived lymphocytes     

Cellular events in protein-tolerant inbred rats. III. Antigen-reactive B cells in rats tolerant to human serum albumin.

Rats tolerant to human serum albumin (HSA) were injected with selected lymphocyte populations and challenged with HSA plus adjuvant to test for loss of tolerance. Thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) from normal or immune rats, either untreated or depleted of Ig-bearing cells or HSA-binding cells by affinity chromatography were all equally effective in restoring the HSA antibody response in previously tolerant recipients. In contrast, recirculating B cells (TDL from B rats) were not effective. The results indicated that unresponsiveness to HSA was a lesion of the T- but not the B-cell compartment. However, antibody affinity failed to mature to a high level in tolerant rats that were restored with T cells, and the response of transferred primed B cells into unresponsive recipients was inhibited, suggesting that the tolerant state was not merely due to a T-cell deletion.     

Depressed Cellular Formation of Antibody to Shigella Antigens In Vitro by Spleen Cell Cultures from Unresponsive Mice

Specific antibody plaque-forming cells (PFC) to Shigella-soluble antigen did not appear in spleen cell cultures from Shigella-tolerant mice, as occurred with similar cultures prepared from normal mice immunized with Shigella antigen prior to sacrifice. Cultures from tolerant mice also failed to form serologically detectable amounts of agglutinins in vitro. Exposure of cell cultures from tolerant mice in vitro to additional antigen had little or no effect on appearance of plaque-forming cells to Shigella. Spleen cells from normal control mice formed readily detectable levels of antibody, as well as specific antibody plaque-forming cells, after similar stimulation with antigen either in vivo or in vitro. The absence of antibody-forming cells in cultures prepared from spleens of tolerant mice was specific since such cultures, as well as those from normal control mice, formed numerous antibody plaques to unsensitized sheep erythrocytes in vitro after in vivo challenge of the mice with sheep erythrocytes. Tolerance to Shigella antigen, as assessed by absence of antibody-forming cells in vitro, persisted for several months. Spleen cell cultures from tolerant mice less than 3 to 4 months of age did not form significant numbers of antibody plaques, even after in vitro exposure to specific antigen. However, spleen cultures prepared from neonatally treated mice, approximately 6 to 8 months old, formed essentially normal numbers of specific PFC in vitro, indicating that the animals had "recovered" from tolerance and that their lymphoid cells were capable of responding to Shigella antigen in vitro. Absence of specific PFC in cell cultures from tolerant animals supports the concept that tolerance is due to a central failure of specific immunocompetent cells and not due to an inhibitory effect caused by either "excess" antigen or humoral antibody.     

Trypanosoma cruzi: Effect on B-cell-responsive and -responding clones

During the course of Trypanosoma cruzi infection in C57BL/6 mice, which are relatively resistant to the parasite, the hosts developed antibody activity against previously unencountered antigens. The anti-sheep erythrocyte and antitrinitrophenyl antibody levels increased rapidly from Day 7 of infection, reached a peak by the 21st day, and were maintained at this level through 120 days postinfection in these mice. In contrast, highly susceptible C3H(He) mice did not have demonstrable antibody responses to SRBC or TNP during the 24-day infection period. Autoantibody activity against the selfantigens presented on isologous erythrocytes or thymocytes, however, were reduced in infected C57BL/6 mice. No significant reduction in autoreactivity to the self-antigens on erythrocytes or thymocytes was observed in C3H(He) mice infected with T. cruzi although a trend of reduced autoresponsiveness toward erythrocytes appeared to be developing by the time of death. C57BL/6 mice immunized with sheep erythrocytes as neonates and infected with T. cruzi as adults, or adult mice primed with low doses of sheep erythrocytes prior to infection, had elevated antibody responses to sheep erythrocytes unless the mice were immunized with sheep erythrocytes during the course of infection, in which case suppression of the response against sheep erythrocytes resulted. The nonspecific synthesis of immunoglobulins in infected C57BL/6 mice was, in part, a result of the lymphocyteactivating properties of T. cruzi-associated antigens. The T. cruzi-associated antigens induced proliferative and differentiative responses in spleen cells in vitro. It is proposed that the T. cruzi-associated antigens differentially affect lymphocytes capable of responding to antigen and those lymphocytes previously stimulated by antigen.     

Mechanism of tolerance to VI-antigen of Salmonella typhi induced by cyclophosphane

High dose Vi-antigen treatment and injection of cyclophosphamide 46 to 48 hours later induced in mice a state of immunological unresponsiveness remaining stable in adoptive transfer. Only low amounts of the antigen were revealed in the blood and spleen of tolerant animals 2 to 3 weeks after the tolerogenic treatment. No T-suppressors were found in the spleen of tolerant mice--the cells of tolerant mice failed to suppress the immune response of normal lymphocytes when transferred together to the irradiated recipients, or to induce tolerance in normal mice. Normal spleen cells restored partially the immune responsiveness in tolerant animals. The results obtained suggest that cyclophosphamide tolerance was due to deletion or the long-term inactivation of the immunocompetent cells.     

Modulation of immune response by bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS): multifocal effects of LPS-induced suppression of the primary antibody response to a T-dependent antigen.

Spleen cells from mice injected with 2 to 50 microgram bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) have a reduced capacity to make an antibody response in vitro to trinitrophenylated sheep erythrocytes (TNP-SRBC) when tested 1 to 7 days later. Recovery is gradual, and these cells are full functional 2 weeks after in vivo LPS treatment. Unresponsiveness resides in the nonadherent splenic cell populations, and can be shown to have a suppressive cell component, which is irradiation sensitive and has somme characteristics of a thymus-derived lymphocyte (T cell). In addition, neither bone marrow-derived lymphocytes (B cells) nor T cells in the spleens of LPS-treated mice are functionally normal in their abilities to cooperate during an antibody response in vitro. LPS-B cells cooperated poorly with nylon wool-enriched T cells from normal mice but cooperated well with irradiated carrier-primed T cells or nylon wool-purified splenic T cells from carrier-primed mice. LPS-T cells have a reduced capacity to interact with normal B cells and appear to contain a suppressor cell component. These results indicate that the effects of exposure of immunocompetent cells to LPS are multifocal and can include suppression as well as stimulation of antibody formation.     

Immunoglobulin-positive mononuclear cells in human peripheral blood: detection by mixed anti-globulin and direct anti-globulin-rosetting reactions.

Ig-bearing mononuclear cells were identified in Ficoll-Hypaque preparations of human peripheral blood by using mixed anti-globulin (MAG) and direct anti-globulin rosettes; indicator cells consisted of sheep erythrocytes coated with human F(ab')2 or anti-F(ab')2 antibody, respectively. Of the cell population isolated from 10 normal subjects, a mean of 68% was lymphocytes. However, fewer than 50% of the cells with detectable surface Ig were lymphocytes. On viable cell preparations using chromic chloride-treated sheep erythrocytes (CrCl3SRBC) coated with anti-F(ab')2 antibody, a mean of 20.1% of the lymphocytes formed rosettes, i.e., were B. Up to 6% of peripheral blood lymphocytes formed mixed Ig-rosettes and E-rosettes. On viable lymphocytes using F(ab')2-coated CrCl3SRBC, MAG rosettes were insensitive in detection of B lymphocytes. Formaldehyde treatment of lymphocytes increased the number of B cells detectable to 25.5% of the lymphocyte population. Study of T-enriched and B-enriched populations showed that the observed increase in B cell reactivity was real and not due to MAG-rosetting T cells. A one-stage procedure for T and B lymphocyte separation is described.     

The immunological status of mice during the generation of cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance.

Tolerance to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) has been induced by a combination of high doses of antigen and treatment with cyclophosphamide (CY). The influence of CY alone or in combination with SRBC has been investigated by using the treated animals as recipients for normal spleen cells. CY treatment appears to produce a mouse which is severely depleted of B cells. The injection of large doses of SRBC together with CY, in a schedule which induces tolerance, generates an environment which suppresses the production of antibody-forming cells by passively transferred normal spleen cells. However, transfer of cells from tolerant mice to irradiated mice failed to demonstrate the presence of suppressor cells.     

A rapid method for the isolation of human peripheral null lymphocytes.

We describe here a new technique for the isolation of human peripheral null lymphocytes: cells lacking detectable surface immunoglobulin as well as receptors for sheep erythrocytes. The double rosette technique described employs a combined negative selection for Ig⁺ cells by specific anti-Ig-coated sheep erythrocytes and E rosette selection for T cells. This singlestep procedure facilitates the isolation of null cells from large cell populations and can be completed in less than 2 hr. The isolated null subpopulation represents less than 5% of the total peripheral mononuclear cells and is at least 85–90% pure by sensitive surface marker analysis. The null subpopulation is shown to be highly enriched for effectors of both antibody-dependent cytotoxicity against autologous lymphocytes and spontaneous cytotoxicity against the K562 leukemia blast cell line. Application of this technique will allow further characterization of the effector populations for ADCC and NK as well as differentiation of T and B cell precursors.     

Cytotoxic T-lymphocyte and spontaneous killer cell activity against human T- and B-lymphoid cell lines.

We have investigated cell-mediated immune responses to cultured human T- and B-cell lines. Two effector mechanisms were explored and found to have different capabilities for mediating cytotoxic reactions. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes were generated by stimulation with irradiated B-cell lines and demonstrated cross-reactive cytotoxicity against these lines but not against T-cell lines. Unseparated mononuclear cells showed spontaneous cytotoxicity for both T- and B-cell lines; however, T-cell lines appeared more susceptible. Cell separation procedures were employed to determine functional differences in effector cells. In contrast to cytotoxic T lymphocytes induced in vitro, spontaneous killer cells (SKC) were shown to be nylon wool adherent, non-T lymphocytes with receptors for IgG-coated sheep erythrocytes.