Poly-l-glutamic acid derivatives as multifunctional vectors for gene delivery. Part A. Synthesis and physicochemical evaluation

This paper describes the synthesis and evaluation of a series of multifunctional poly-l-glutamic acid derivatives that can be used as vectors for gene delivery. They readily form polyelectrolyte complexes with DNA, resulting in a reduced surface charge and size of the DNA. The formation of a polymer-DNA complex and the stability toward serum albumin was analyzed by ethidium bromide fluorescence measurements and agarose gel retardation studies. Most polymers, except those with more than 80% imidazoles, are able to condense calf thymus DNA, thus forming complexes with sizes varying between 105 and 172 nm. The surface charge of the complexes was determined at different charge ratios by zeta potential measurements. The buffering properties of the polymers were determined via titration studies. The results show that the polymers are able to buffer the endosomal environment, although to a smaller extent than polyethyleneimine. The first part of this study is devoted to the synthesis and the physicochemical evaluation of the multifunctional polymers and their use as carriers for genetic information. The second part, to be published subsequently, discusses the biological evaluation of the polymers and their complexes with DNA.     

Poly-l-glutamic acid derivatives as multifunctional vectors for gene delivery. Part B. Biological evaluation

Cationic polymers, such as poly-l-lysine (pLL) and polyethyleneimine (pEI), are receiving growing attention as vectors for gene therapy. They form polyelectrolyte complexes with DNA, resulting in a reduced size of the DNA and an enhanced stability toward nucleases. The major disadvantages of using both polymers for in vivo purposes are their cytotoxicity and, in the case of pEI, the fact that it's not biodegradable. In this work, we investigated the interaction between a series of cationic, glutamic acid based polymers and red blood cells. The MTT test was used to investigate the cytotoxicity of the complexes. The ability of the polymers to stabilize DNA toward nucleases was investigated. Transfection studies were carried out on Cos-1 cells. The results from the haemolysis studies, the haemagglutination studies, and the MTT assay show that the polymers are substantially less toxic than pLL and pEI. The polymers are able to protect the DNA from digestion by DNase I. The transfection studies show that the polymer-DNA complexes are capable of transfecting cells, most of them with poor efficiency compared to pEI-DNA complexes.     

Development of multicomponent DNA delivery systems based upon poly(amidoamine)-PEG co-polymers

PEGylated polyamidoamine (PAA) polymers were investigated for the production of sterically stabilised DNA delivery systems. Comparison of a PEGylated polymer (NG47) with a non-PEGylated polymer (NG49) showed similar binding of co-polymer to DNA by displacement of ethidium bromide (EB) and DNA melting studies. Gel electrophoresis, turbidimetric analysis and PCS demonstrated differences in the colloidal properties of the complexes, which were attributable to the formation of soluble complexes by the PEGylated co-polymer. However, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) showed that the resulting complexes containing poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) were not well condensed, susceptible to degradation by nucleases, and thus not suited for in vivo delivery. The poor properties of the PEGylated co-polymer were attributed to an excess of PEG. However, polymer blends of NG47 and NG49 at defined ratios of polymer to co-polymer and total repeating units (RUs) to nucleotide, spontaneously formed complexes with a range of desirable properties. These included small size and polydispersity, high particle density, low surface charge and resistance to nuclease degradation. Complexes made with PEGylated polymer alone, and the polymer blends both suffered from a reduced polyfection activity. This was attributed to a low surface charge on the complex, which reduced interactions with the cell membrane and consequent uptake of the particles into the cell.     

Evaluation of lipid-based reagents to mediate intracellular gene delivery

We characterized different cationic lipid-based gene delivery systems consisting of both liposomes and nonliposomal structures, in terms of their in vitro transfection activity, resistance to the presence of serum, protective effect against nuclease degradation and stability under different storage conditions. The effect of lipid/DNA charge ratio of the resulting complexes on these properties was also evaluated. Our results indicate that the highest levels of transfection activity were observed for complexes prepared from nonliposomal structures composed of FuGENE 6. However, their DNA protective effect was shown to be lower than that observed for cationic liposome formulations when prepared at the optimal (+/-) charge ratio. Our results suggest that lipoplexes are resistant to serum up to 30% when prepared at a 2:1 lipid/DNA charge ratio. However, when they were prepared at higher (+/-) charge ratios, they become sensitive to serum for even lower concentrations (10%). Replacement of dioleoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) by cholesterol enhanced the resistance of the complexes to the inhibitory effect of serum. This different biological activity in the presence of serum was attributed to different extents of binding of serum proteins to the complexes, as evaluated by the immunoblotting assay. Studies on the stability under storage show that lipoplexes maintain most of their biological activity when stored at -80 degrees C, following their fast freezing in liquid nitrogen.     

Aggregation of fragmented chromatin associated with the synthesis of products of its treatment with nuclease

Isolated cell nuclei were incubated with nucleases followed by extraction of chromatin with a low salt buffer. With an increase of nuclear chromatin degradation with DNAse I or micrococcal nuclease, solubilization of deoxyribonucleoprotein (DNP) by a low salt buffer increases, reaching a maximum upon hydrolysis with 2-4% nuclear DNA and then decreases appreciably after extensive treatment with nucleases. Soluble fragmented chromatin aggregates in the course of treatment with DNAase. I. Addition to gel chromatin preparations of exogenous products of nuclease treatment of isolated nuclei leads to its aggregation. Pretreatment of nuclear chromatin with RNAase prevents solubilization of DNP by low ionic strength solutions. Some experimental data obtained with the use of severe nuclease treatment are discussed; for a correct interpretation of these data the aggregation of fragmented chromatin by products of its nuclease degradation should be taken into consideration.     

Synthesis and characterization of poly (amino ester) for slow biodegradable gene delivery vector

Many therapeutic carrier materials were exploited for human gene therapy from viral to polymeric vectors. This research describes the evaluation of two biodegradable ester-bonded polymers synthesized by double-monomer polycondensation for a non-viral cationic polymer-based gene delivery system. The backbone was constructed to include inner tertiary amines and outer primary amines. Self-assembly with DNA resulted in the production of regularly nano-sized spherical polyplexes with good transfection efficiency, especially in the presence of serum. The polymers showed a relatively slow degradability for an amine-containing ester polymer, as they maintained DNA/polymer complex for 7 days in physiological buffer conditions. Finally, the low toxicity and slow degradation concluded these polymers reliable for long-term therapeutic applications.     

Methodologies for monitoring nanoparticle formation by self-assembly of DNA with poly(l-lysine)

DNA self-assembly with polycations produces nanoparticles suitable for gene delivery, although there is no standard methodology to measure particle formation and stability. Here we have compared three commonly used assays, namely, light scattering, inhibition of ethidium bromide fluorescence, and modified electrophoretic mobility of DNA. Analysis by light scattering and loss of ethidium bromide fluorescence both showed poly(l-lysine) (pLL)/DNA nanoparticles form over the lysine/phosphate ratio range 0.6-1.0, although retardation of DNA electrophoretic mobility commenced at lower lysine/phosphate ratios. This probably indicates that the first two assays monitor DNA collapse into particles, while the electrophoresis assay measures neutralization of the charge on DNA. Gel analysis of the complexes showed disproportionation during nanoparticle formation, probably reflecting cooperative binding of the polycation. The assays were used to examine stability of complexes to dilution in water and physiological salts. Whereas all pLL/DNA nanoparticles were stable to dilution in water, the presence of physiological salts provoked selective disruption of complexes based on low-molecular-weight pLL. Polyelectrolyte complexes for targeted application in vivo should therefore be based on high-molecular-weight polycations, or should be stabilized to prevent their dissociation under physiological salt conditions.     

Telomeric oligonucleotide complexes with PGEk protein vector: internalization by target cells and antiproliferative properties

The recombinant protein PGEk, containing residual of the human epidermal factor (hEGF) bearing DNA binding sequence, retains ability of hEGF to bind with hEGF receptor and to induce cell proliferation was shown. On an example of PGEk complexes with telomeric mimic-oligodeoxyribonucleotide d(TTAGGG)4 and with its thio-analogue we had found such systems can be effectively and selectively internalized by hEGF receptors super expressing cells. The association of this process with a protein/oligonucleotide ratio in complexes was investigated. The intracellular localization of oligonucleotides was explored. We had shown that PGEk not only promotes intensive delivery of oligonucleotides, but also protects them from degradation by nucleases. The oligonucleotides in composition of complexes have considerably more expressed cytotoxic activity in comparison with free oligonucleotides.     

Novel chitosan derivative nanoparticles enhance the immunogenicity of a DNA vaccine encoding hepatitis B virus core antigen in mice

BACKGROUND: Chitosan has been shown to possess useful properties such as non-toxicity, high biocompatibility and non-antigenicity that offer advantages for vaccine delivery systems. In this study, we prepared novel chitosan derivative nanoparticles as DNA vaccine carriers and the potential and mechanism of the DNA-nanoparticle complexes in inducing augmented immune responses were explored. METHODS: The pVAX(HBc)DNA-nanoparticle complexes as vaccine delivery systems were studied in several aspects: the protection against DNase I degradation was measured by an in vitro inhibition assay; the sustained expression of the plasmid in vivo was determined by RT-PCR; the elevated uptake efficiency by phagocytes was observed with confocal microscopy; the biocompatibility was evaluated by cytotoxicity and histology assay; the complexes were administrated to C57BL/6 mice and the humoral and cellular immune responses were evaluated by ELISA, IFN-gamma production and cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL)-specific lysis assay. RESULTS: The remaining relative activity of DNase I after inhibition varied from 32.3% to 77.6%. The complexes were observed with higher uptake efficiency by phagocytes than naked DNA. Three types of nanoparticles did not induce significant cytotoxicity at concentrations相似文献   

Cellular gene transfer mediated by influenza virosomes with encapsulated plasmid DNA

Reconstituted influenza virosomes (virus membrane envelopes) have been used previously to deliver pDNA (plasmid DNA) bound to their external surface to a variety of target cells. Although high transfection efficiencies can be obtained with these complexes in vitro, the virosome-associated DNA is readily accessible to nucleases and could therefore be prone to rapid degradation under in vivo conditions. In the present study, we show a new method for the production of DNA-virosomes resulting in complete protection of the DNA from nucleases. This method relies on the use of the short-chain phospholipid DCPC (dicaproylphosphatidylcholine) for solubilization of the viral membrane. The solubilized viral membrane components are mixed with pDNA and cationic lipid. Reconstitution of the viral envelopes and simultaneous encapsulation of pDNA is achieved by removal of the DCPC from the mixture through dialysis. Analysis by linear sucrose density-gradient centrifugation revealed that protein, phospholipid and pDNA physically associated to particles, which appeared as vesicles with spike proteins inserted in their membranes when analysed by electron microscopy. The DNA-virosomes retained the membrane fusion properties of the native influenza virus. The virosome-associated pDNA was completely protected from degradation by nucleases, providing evidence for the DNA being highly condensed and encapsulated in the lumen of the virosomes. DNA-virosomes, containing reporter gene constructs, transfected a variety of cell lines, with efficiencies approaching 90%. Transfection was completely dependent on the fusogenic properties of the viral spike protein haemagglutinin. Thus, DNA-virosomes prepared by the new procedure are highly efficient vehicles for DNA delivery, offering the advantage of complete DNA protection, which is especially important for future in vivo applications.     

Direct real-time molecular scale visualisation of the degradation of condensed DNA complexes exposed to DNase I

The need to protect DNA from in vivo degradation is one of the basic tenets of therapeutic gene delivery and a standard test for any proposed delivery vector. The currently employed in vitro tests, however, presently provide no direct link between the molecular structure of the vector complexes and their success in this role, thus hindering the rational design of successful gene delivery agents. Here we apply atomic force microscopy (AFM) in liquid to visualise at the molecular scale and in real time, the effect of DNase I on generation 4 polyamidoamine dendrimers (G4) complexed with DNA. These complexes are revealed to be dynamic in nature showing a degree of mobility, in some cases revealing the addition and loss of dendrimers to individual complexes. The formation of the G4–DNA complexes is observed to provide a degree of protection to the DNA. This protection is related to the structural morphology of the formed complex, which is itself shown to be dependent on the dendrimer loading and the time allowed for complex formation.     

Lipid phase control of DNA delivery

Cationic lipids form nanoscale complexes (lipoplexes) with polyanionic DNA and can be utilized to deliver DNA to cells for transfection. Here we report the correlation between delivery efficiency of these DNA carriers and the mesomorphic phases they form when interacting with anionic membrane lipids. Specifically, formulations that are particularly effective DNA carriers form phases of highest negative interfacial curvature when mixed with anionic lipids, whereas less effective formulations form phases of lower curvature. Structural evolution of the carrier lipid/DNA complexes upon interaction with cellular lipids is hence suggested as a controlling factor in lipid-mediated DNA delivery. A strategy for optimizing lipofection is deduced. The behavior of a highly effective lipoplex formulation, DOTAP/DOPE, is found to conform to this "efficiency formula".     

Transformation of Bacillus subtilis by DNA bound on clay in non-sterile soil

Abstract Chromosomal DNA from Bacillus subtilis and different forms of plasmid pHV14 (covalently closed circular (CCC), linear monomer (M), and linear multimer (LM)) were adsorbed and bound on the clay mineral montmorillonite. After extensive washing of the clay-DNA complexes with DNA buffer (pH 7.5), approx. 25% of the chromosomal DNA, and approx. 30, 90, and 5%, respectively, of the CCC, M and LM form remained bound. Chromosomal and plasmid DNA bound on clay were capable of transforming competent cells, with different specific activities. The clay-DNA complexes persisted in non-sterile soil and retained transforming ability up to 15 days after their addition to the soil. DNA bound on montmortillonite was protected from the activity of Eco RI, supporting the evidence that DNA adsorbed on soil components was resistant to degradation by nucleases.     

Structural characterization and buffering capacity in relation to the transfection efficiency of biodegradable polyurethane

Inefficient release of polymer/DNA complexes from endocytic vesicles into the cytoplasm and the cytotoxic nature of cationic polymers are two of the primary causes of poor gene delivery. EG-polyurethane [poly(ethylene glycol)-PU, Poly 1], EGDM-polyurethane [poly(ethylene glycol), 2-(dimethylamino)ethylamine-PU, Poly 2], and MDEADM-polyurethane [N-methyldiethanolamine, 2-(dimethylamino)ethylamine-PU, Poly 3] were designed in this study to overcome these obstacles. The structural characteristics of polyurethanes and physicochemical properties of their formed complexes with DNA were determined to correlate their transfection efficiency. The results revealed that Poly 2 and Poly 3 could bind with plasmid DNA and yield positively charged complexes with a size required for transfection. Poly 3 showed the best in buffering capacity and its formed complexes with DNA could transfect COS-7 cells better than those of Poly 2 and Poly 1. This study reveals that the amine groups in the polymeric structure and the buffer capacity of a polymeric transfectant would affect its potential in DNA delivery. Also the size and binding properties of DNA and polymeric transfectants can be in correlation to the transfection efficiency of resulting DNA/polymer complexes.     

Influence of hydrophilicity of cationic polymers on the biophysical properties of polyelectrolyte complexes formed by self-assembly with DNA

To investigate the possibility of producing charge-neutral gene delivery complexes with extended, non-particulate structures, DNA was allowed to self-assemble with a series of hydrophilic cationic polymers containing quaternary charged trimethylammonio ethylmethacrylate (TMAEM, 5, 15, 50, 100 mol%) copolymerised with hydrophilic N-(2-hydroxypropyl)methacrylamide (HPMA, 95, 85, 50, 0 mol%, respectively). Copolymers were all able to bind DNA, assessed using ethidium bromide fluorescence, although copolymers with low TMAEM content did not expel ethidium bromide. Increasing TMAEM content of the copolymers changed the morphology of the complexes from extended (5-15 mol% TMAEM), through partially condensed particles (50 mol%) to discrete nanoparticles (100 mol% TMAEM). Complexes based on copolymers with low TMAEM content (5-50 mol%) showed less resistance to degradation by nucleases and lower surface charge (21.2+/-5.9-45.1+/-3.9 mV) than those formed using 100 mol% TMAEM (57.8+/-8.2 mV). They also showed significantly less association with phagocytic cells in vitro (human leucocytes, uptake decreased by up to 92.3%; murine peritoneal macrophages, uptake decreased by up to 69.6%), although in vivo their hepatic accumulation was only slightly decreased (maximum decrease 27.6%). Finding the appropriate balance of hydrophilicity and stability is key to development of effective vectors for gene delivery.     

Membrane activity and transfection ability of amphipathic polycations as a function of alkyl group size

Cationic membrane disruptive peptides such as melittin would appear to have attributes necessary for DNA delivery: DNA binding via electrostatic interactions and membrane lysis to enable cytoplasmic delivery. However, the relatively small overall charge of membrane disruptive peptides results in weak interactions with DNA. As a model of cationic membrane disruptive peptides, amphiphilic polyvinyl ethers were synthesized. The number of positively charged groups incorporated into these polymers is substantially greater than membrane-active peptides, which enables these polymers to form stable complexes with DNA. By varying the length of the hydrophobic groups incorporated into the polymer from one to four carbons, the dependence of membrane activity on side chain length was established. The ability of these polymers to transfect DNA in tissue culture was tested, and it was found that transfection efficiency is dependent upon the membrane disruptive activity of the polymer. Comparison of melittin and synthetic polymers suggests that transfection and toxicity appear to be dependent upon their affinity for DNA. This demonstration of relationships among membrane lysis, transfection, DNA binding, and polymer side-chain composition establishes a new class of transfection reagents and may guide in the design of polymers and formulations that will enable efficient in vivo transfection.     

Lipid-mediated delivery of peptide nucleic acids to pulmonary endothelium

Peptide nucleic acid (PNA) is a DNA/RNA mimic in which the phosphodiester (PO) linkage is replaced with a peptide bond. It has a number of unique properties compared to currently used oligonucleotides including higher affinity towards RNA or DNA target, resistance to nucleases or proteases, and minimal non-specific interactions with proteins. Clinical applications of PNA, however, are limited by its inefficient intracellular delivery. In this study, we have shown that delivery of PNA to pulmonary endothelium in intact mice can be greatly improved via hybridization with a short PO oligonucleotide that serves as a carrier to form complexes with cationic liposomes. We have also shown for the first time that unlike a CpG DNA oligo that is highly proinflammatory, a CG-containing PNA is inert in triggering TNF-alpha response in cultured macrophages and in mice. Thus delivery of PNA to pulmonary endothelium may prove to be a therapeutically useful for the treatment of pulmonary vascular diseases.     

Oxazole yellow homodimer YOYO-1-labeled DNA: a fluorescent complex that can be used to assess structural changes in DNA following formation and cellular delivery of cationic lipid DNA complexes.

To improve transfection efficiency following delivery of plasmid expression vectors using lipid-based carriers, it is crucial to define structural characteristics of the lipid/DNA complexes that optimize transgene expression. Due to its strong affinity for DNA and high quantum yield, the fluorescent DNA intercalator YOYO-1 was used as a tool to assess changes in DNA that occur following lipid binding and cell delivery. In this study, the stability of the dye/DNA complex following binding of poly-L-lysine or monocationic lipids is characterized. More than 98% of the fluorescence measured for a defined DNA/YOYO-1 complex was lost when DNA was condensed using poly-L-lysine. This loss in fluorescence could be attributed to displacement of bound dye. In contrast, more than 30% of the fluorescence of the dye-labeled DNA was retained after formation of cationic lipid/DNA complexes. Significantly, the results illustrate differences in structural changes cationic lipids and PLL exert on plasmid DNA. The fluorescent lipid/DNA complex was used to assess DNA delivery to murine B16/BL6 cells in vitro. An assay relying on fluorescence resonance energy transfer between bound YOYO-1 and propidium iodide was used to distinguish between DNA attached to the cell surface and internalized DNA.     

Effect of thiol pendant conjugates on plasmid DNA binding, release, and stability of polymeric delivery vectors

Polymers have attracted much attention as potential gene delivery vectors due to their chemical and structural versatility. However, several challenges associated with polymeric carriers, including low transfection efficiencies, insufficient cargo release, and high cytotoxicity levels have prevented clinical implementation. Strong electrostatic interactions between polymeric carriers and DNA cargo can prohibit complete cargo release within the cell. As a result, cargo DNA never reaches the cell's nucleus where gene expression takes place. In addition, highly charged cationic polymers have been correlated with high cytotoxicity levels, making them unsuitable carriers in vivo. Using poly(allylamine) (PAA) as a model, we investigated how pH-sensitive disulfide cross-linked polymer networks can improve the delivery potential of cationic polymer carriers. To accomplish this, we conjugated thiol-terminated pendant chains onto the primary amines of PAA using 2-iminothiolane, developing three new polymer vectors with 5, 13, or 20% thiol modification. Unmodified PAA and thiol-conjugated polymers were tested for their ability to bind and release plasmid DNA, their capacity to protect genetic cargo from enzymatic degradation, and their potential for endolysosomal escape. Our results demonstrate that polymer-plasmid complexes (polyplexes) formed by the 13% thiolated polymer demonstrate the greatest delivery potential. At high N/P ratios, all thiolated polymers (but not unmodified counterparts) were able to resist decomplexation in the presence of heparin, a negatively charged polysaccharide used to mimic in vivo polyplex-protein interactions. Further, all thiolated polymers exhibited higher buffering capacities than unmodified PAA and, therefore, have a greater potential for endolysosomal escape. However, 5 and 20% thiolated polymers exhibited poor DNA binding-release kinetics, making them unsuitable carriers for gene delivery. The 13% thiolated polymers, on the other hand, displayed high DNA binding efficiency and pH-sensitive release.     

Bacterial magnetic particles (BMPs)-PEI as a novel and efficient non-viral gene delivery system

BACKGROUND: Non-viral methods of gene delivery, especially using polyethylenimine (PEI), have been widely used in gene therapy or DNA vaccination. However, the PEI system has its own drawbacks, which limits its applications. METHODS: We have developed a novel non-viral delivery system based on PEI coated on the surface of bacterial magnetic nanoparticles (BMPs). The ability of BMPs-PEI complexes to bind DNA was determined by retardation of plasmid DNA in agarose gel electrophoresis. The transfection efficiency of BMPs-PEI/DNA complexes into eukaryotic cells was determined by flow cytometric analysis. The MTT assay was invited to investigate the cytotoxicity of BMPs-PEI/DNA complexes. The expression efficiency in vivo of BMPs-PEI bound to the plasmid pCMVbeta encoding beta-galactosidase was evaluated intramuscularly inoculated into mice. The immune responses of in vivo delivery of BMPs-PEI bound plasmid pcD-VP1 were determined by MTT assay for T cell proliferation and ELISA for detecting total IgG antibodies. RESULTS: BMPs-PEI complexes could bind DNA and provide protection from DNase degradation. The transfection efficiency of BMPs-PEI/DNA complexes was higher than that in PEI/DNA complexes. Interestingly, in contrast to PEI, the BMPs-PEI complex was less cytotoxic to cells in vitro. We further demonstrated that the BMPs-PEI system can deliver an exogenous gene to animals and allow it to be expressed in vivo. Such expression resulted in higher levels of humoral and cellular immune responses against the target antigen compared to controls. CONCLUSIONS: We have developed a novel BMPs-PEI gene delivery system with a high transfection efficiency and low toxicity, which presents an attractive strategy for gene therapy and DNA vaccination.