Chi hotspot activity in Escherichia coli without RecBCD exonuclease activity: implications for the mechanism of recombination

The major pathway of genetic recombination and DNA break repair in Escherichia coli requires RecBCD enzyme, a complex nuclease and DNA helicase regulated by Chi sites (5'-GCTGGTGG-3'). During its unwinding of DNA containing Chi, purified RecBCD enzyme has two alternative nucleolytic reactions, depending on the reaction conditions: simple nicking of the Chi-containing strand at Chi or switching of nucleolytic degradation from the Chi-containing strand to its complement at Chi. We describe a set of recC mutants with a novel intracellular phenotype: retention of Chi hotspot activity in genetic crosses but loss of detectable nucleolytic degradation as judged by the growth of mutant T4 and lambda phages and by assay of cell-free extracts. We conclude that RecBCD enzyme's nucleolytic degradation of DNA is not necessary for intracellular Chi hotspot activity and that nicking of DNA by RecBCD enzyme at Chi is sufficient. We discuss the bearing of these results on current models of RecBCD pathway recombination.     

A domain of RecC required for assembly of the regulatory RecD subunit into the Escherichia coli RecBCD holoenzyme

The heterotrimeric RecBCD enzyme of Escherichia coli is required for the major pathway of double-strand DNA break repair and genetic exchange. Assembled as a heterotrimer, the enzyme has potent nuclease and helicase activity. Analysis of recC nonsense and deletion mutations revealed that the C terminus of RecC is required for assembly of the RecD subunit into RecBCD holoenzyme but not for recombination proficiency; the phenotype of these mutations mimics that of recD deletion mutations. Partial proteolysis of purified RecC polypeptide yielded a C-terminal fragment that corresponds to the RecD-interaction domain. RecD is essential for nuclease activity, regulation by the recombination hotspot Chi, and high affinity for DNA ends. The RecC-RecD interface thus appears critical for the regulation of RecBCD enzyme via the assembly and, we propose, disassembly or conformational change of the RecD subunit.     

Genetic Dissection of the Biochemical Activities of Recbcd Enzyme

RecBCD enzyme of Escherichia coli is required for the major pathway of homologous recombination following conjugation. The enzyme has an ATP-dependent DNA unwinding activity, ATP-dependent single-stranded (ss) and double-stranded (ds) DNA exonuclease activities, and an activity that makes a ss DNA endonucleolytic cut near Chi sites. We have isolated and characterized ten mutations that reduced recombination proficiency and inactivated some, but not all, activities of RecBCD enzyme. One class of mutants had weak ds DNA exonuclease activity and lacked Chi-dependent DNA cleavage activity, a second class lacked only Chi-dependent DNA cleavage activity, and a third class retained all activities tested. The properties of these mutants indicate that the DNA unwinding and ss DNA exonuclease activities of the RecBCD enzyme are not sufficient for recombination. Furthermore, they suggest that the Chi-dependent DNA cleavage activity or another, as yet unidentified activity or both are required for recombination. The roles of the RecBCD enzymatic activities in recombination and exclusion of foreign DNA are discussed in light of the properties of these and other recBCD mutations.     

Homologous pairing in vitro stimulated by the recombination hotspot, Chi.

Genetic recombination in Escherichia coli is stimulated at DNA sequences known as Chi sites, 5'-GCT-GGTGG-3'. We describe the in vitro formation of homologously paired joint molecules that is dependent upon this recombination hotspot. Chi-dependent joint molecule formation requires RecA, RecBCD, and SSB proteins and a Chi site in the donor linear dsDNA. The donor dsDNA is unwound by RecBCD enzyme, and the invasive strand is generated by nicking at Chi. This Chi-dependent invading strand must contain homology to the recipient supercoiled DNA substrate at its newly formed 3' end for efficient joint molecule formation. Action at Chi generates invasive ssDNA from the 5' but not the 3' side of Chi, suggesting that the nuclease activity of RecBCD enzyme is attenuated upon encountering a Chi site. These results support the view that RecBCD enzyme action can precede RecA protein action and reconcile the seemingly opposing degradative and recombination functions of RecBCD enzyme.     

Gamma-irradiated RecD overproducers become permanent recB-/C- phenocopies for extrachromosomal DNA processing due to prolonged titration of RecBCD enzyme on damaged Escherichia coli chromosome

The RecBCD enzyme of Escherichia coli consists of three subunits RecB, RecC and RecD. RecBCD enzyme activities are regulated by its interaction with recombination hotspot Chi. Biochemical and genetic evidence suggest that interaction with Chi affects RecD subunit, and that RecD polypeptide overproduction antagonizes this interaction, suggesting that intact RecD replaces a Chi-modified one. We used bacteria with fragmented chromosomes due to double-strand breaks inflicted by UV and gamma-irradiation to explore in which way increased concentrations of RecBCD's individual subunits affect DNA metabolism. We confirmed that RecD overproduction alters RecBCD-dependent DNA repair and degradation in E. coli. Also, we found that RecB and RecC overproduction did not affect these processes. To determine the basis for the effects of RecD polypeptide overproduction, we monitored activities of RecBCD enzyme on gamma-damaged chromosomal DNA and, in parallel, on lambda and T4 2 phage DNA duplexes provided at intervals. We found that gamma-irradiated wild-type bacteria became transient, and RecD overproducers permanent recB(-)/C(-) phenocopies for processing phage DNA that is provided in parallel. Since this inability of irradiated bacteria to process extrachromosomal DNA substrates coincided in both cases with ongoing degradation of chromosomal DNA, which lasted much longer in RecD overproducers, we were led to conclude that the RecB(-)/C(-) phenotype is acquired as a consequence of RecBCD enzyme titration on damaged chromosomal DNA. This conclusion was corroborated by our observation that no inhibition of RecBCD activity occurs in gamma-irradiated RecBCD overproducers. Together, these results strongly indicate that RecD overproduction prevents dissociation of RecBCD enzyme from DNA substrate and thus increases its processivity.     

Conservation of Chi cutting activity in terrestrial and marine enteric bacteria

Homologous recombination in Escherichia coli occurs at increased frequency near Chi sites, 5'G-C-T-G-G-T-G-G3'. Cutting of DNA close to the Chi sequence by the E. coli RecBC enzyme is essential to Chi's stimulation of recombination. We have detected Chi-dependent cutting activity in extracts of several genera of terrestrial enteric bacteria (family Enterobacteriaceae) and of two genera of marine enteric bacteria (family Vibrionaceae). More distantly related bacteria had no detectable Chi-dependent cutting activity. These results support the view that recognition of this specific nucleotide sequence as a signal activating recombination has been maintained during the evolution of certain groups of bacteria. We discuss the possibility that other sequences play a similar role in other groups of bacteria.     

Cutting of chi-like sequences by the RecBCD enzyme of Escherichia coli

Chi, 5' G-C-T-G-G-T-G-G 3', stimulates coliphage lambda recombination mediated by the major recombination pathway of Escherichia coli, the RecBC pathway. Purified RecBCD enzyme makes a single strand endonuclease cleavage four to six nucleotides to the 3' side of the chi sequence. Three sequences similar to chi, 5' A-C-T-G-G-T-G-G 3', 5' G-T-T-G-G-T-G-G 3' and 5' G-C-T-A-G-T-G-G 3', have partial recombinational hotspot activity in genetic crosses. We report here that purified RecBCD enzyme preferentially cuts four nucleotides to the right of the two most active chi-like octamers. The degree of cutting correlated with the genetic activities of these sequences; this result indicates that these cleavages are essential to the genetic activity of chi and chi-like sequences.     

Chi Enhances Heteroduplex DNA Levels during Recombination

The major pathway of homologous recombination in Escherichia coli, the RecBCD pathway, is stimulated by Chi sites. To determine whether Chi enhances an early or late step in recombination, we measured formation of heteroduplex DNA (hDNA) in extracts of lambda-infected E. coli. Chi elevated hDNA levels in these extracts, supporting a role for Chi early (before hDNA formation) in recombination. RecA protein and RecBCD enzyme were both necessary for detection of hDNA, indicating that they, too, act early. Analysis of a panel of recBCD mutants indicated that Chi-nicking activity was needed for Chi's stimulation of hDNA formation. These results support a previously proposed model of recombination. Further results suggested that RecBCD enzyme has an additional role late in recombination.     

Unexpected DNA context-dependence identifies a new determinant of Chi recombination hotspots

Homologous recombination occurs especially frequently near special chromosomal sites called hotspots. In Escherichia coli, Chi hotspots control RecBCD enzyme, a protein machine essential for the major pathway of DNA break-repair and recombination. RecBCD generates recombinogenic single-stranded DNA ends by unwinding DNA and cutting it a few nucleotides to the 3′ side of 5′ GCTGGTGG 3′, the sequence historically equated with Chi. To test if sequence context affects Chi activity, we deep-sequenced the products of a DNA library containing 10 random base-pairs on each side of the Chi sequence and cut by purified RecBCD. We found strongly enhanced cutting at Chi with certain preferred sequences, such as A or G at nucleotides 4–7, on the 3′ flank of the Chi octamer. These sequences also strongly increased Chi hotspot activity in E. coli cells. Our combined enzymatic and genetic results redefine the Chi hotspot sequence, implicate the nuclease domain in Chi recognition, indicate that nicking of one strand at Chi is RecBCD''s biologically important reaction in living cells, and enable more precise analysis of Chi''s role in recombination and genome evolution.     

Bacteriophage P22 Abc2 protein binds to RecC increases the 5' strand nicking activity of RecBCD and together with lambda bet, promotes Chi-independent recombination

Bacteriophage P22 Abc2 protein binds to the RecBCD enzyme from Escherichia coli to promote phage growth and recombination. Overproduction of the RecC subunit in vivo, but not RecB or RecD, interfered with Abc2-induced UV sensitization, revealing that RecC is the target for Abc2 in vivo. UV-induced ATP crosslinking experiments revealed that Abc2 protein does not interfere with the binding of ATP to either the RecB or RecD subunits in the absence of DNA, though it partially inhibits RecBCD ATPase activity. Productive growth of phage P22 in wild-type Salmonella typhimurium correlates with the presence of Abc2, but is independent of the absolute level of ATP-dependent nuclease activity, suggesting a qualitative change in the nature of Abc2-modified RecBCD nuclease activity relative to the native enzyme. In lambda phage crosses, Abc2-modified RecBCD could substitute for lambda exonuclease in Red-promoted recombination; lambda Gam could not. In exonuclease assays designed to examine the polarity of digestion, Abc2 protein qualitatively changes the nature of RecBCD double-stranded DNA exonuclease by increasing the rate of digestion of the 5' strand. In this respect, Abc2-modified RecBCD resembles a RecBCD molecule that has encountered the recombination hotspot Chi. However, unlike Chi-modified RecBCD, Abc2-modified RecBCD still possesses 3' exonuclease activity. These results are discussed in terms of a model in which Abc2 converts the RecBCD exonuclease for use in the P22 phage recombination pathway. This mechanism of P22-mediated recombination distinguishes it from phage lambda recombination, in which the phage recombination system (Red) and its anti-RecBCD function (Gam) work independently.     

A stimulatory RNA associated with RecBCD enzyme.

RecBCD enzyme acts in the major pathway of homologous recombination of linear DNA in Escherichia coli. The enzyme unwinds DNA and is an ATP-dependent double-strand and single-strand exonuclease and a single-strand endonuclease; it acts at Chi recombination hotspots (5'-GCTGGTGG-3') to produce a recombinogenic single-stranded DNA 3'-end. We found that a small RNA with a unique sequence of approximately 24 nt was tightly bound to RecBCD enzyme and co-purified with it. When added to native enzyme this RNA, but not four others, increased DNA unwinding and Chi nicking activities of the enzyme. In seven similarly active enzyme preparations the molar ratio of RNA molecules to RecBCD enzyme molecules ranged from 0.2 to <0.008. These results suggest that, although this unique RNA is not an essential enzyme subunit, it has a biological role in stimulating RecBCD enzyme activity.     

How RecBCD Enzyme and Chi Promote DNA Break Repair and Recombination: a Molecular Biologist's View

Summary: The repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) is essential for cell viability and important for homologous genetic recombination. In enteric bacteria such as Escherichia coli, the major pathway of DSB repair requires the RecBCD enzyme, a complex helicase-nuclease regulated by a simple unique DNA sequence called Chi. How Chi regulates RecBCD has been extensively studied by both genetics and biochemistry, and two contrasting mechanisms to generate a recombinogenic single-stranded DNA tail have been proposed: the nicking of one DNA strand at Chi versus the switching of degradation from one strand to the other at Chi. Which of these reactions occurs in cells has remained unproven because of the inability to detect intracellular DNA intermediates in bacterial recombination and DNA break repair. Here, I discuss evidence from a combination of genetics and biochemistry indicating that nicking at Chi is the intracellular (in vivo) reaction. This example illustrates the need for both types of analysis (i.e., molecular biology) to uncover the mechanism and control of complex processes in living cells.     

Inhibition of the recBCD-dependent activation of Chi recombinational hot spots in SOS-induced cells of Escherichia coli.

Nucleotide sequences called Chi (5'-GCTGGTGG-3') enhance homologous recombination near their location by the RecBCD enzyme in Escherichia coli (Chi activation). A partial inhibition of Chi activation measured in lambda red gam mutant crosses was observed after treatment of wild-type cells with DNA-damaging agents including UV, mitomycin, and nalidixic acid. Inhibition of Chi activation was not accompanied by an overall decrease of recombination. A lexA3 mutation which blocks induction of the SOS system prevented the inhibition of Chi activation, indicating that an SOS function could be responsible for the inhibition. Overproduction of the RecD subunit of the RecBCD enzyme from a multicopy plasmid carrying the recD gene prevented the induced inhibition of Chi activation, whereas overproduction of RecB or RecC subunits did not. It is proposed that in SOS-induced cells the RecBCD enzyme is modified into a Chi-independent recombination enzyme, with the RecD subunit being the regulatory switch key.     

Recombination and UV resistance of Escherichia coli with the cloned recA and recBCD genes of Serratia marcescens and Proteus mirabilis: evidence for an advantage of intraspecies combination of P. mirabilis RecA protein and RecBCD enzyme.

In Escherichia coli, constituents of the main recombination pathway are provided by the genes recA (RecA protein) and recBCD (RecBCD enzyme). Recombination in conjugation experiments and repair of UV damage of E. coli mutants deleted for recA, for recBCD or for recA plus recBCD were restored, although to different degrees, by the cloned recA and recBCD genes from Serratia marcescens or Proteus mirabilis. When both recombination enzymes were from the same species, repair and recombination efficiencies had the order E. coli greater than S. marcescens greater than P. mirabilis. However, the P. mirabilis recA plus recBCD genes resulted in higher levels of repair and recombination than those obtained with one component from P. mirabilis (recA or recBCD) and the other from E. coli or S. marcescens. The data provide evidence for the similarity of RecABCD pathways of recombination among enteric bacteria and suggest an in vivo advantage of an intraspecies combination of P. mirabilis RecA protein and RecBCD enzyme over interspecies combinations. This could point to a cooperation between these basic recombination enzymes. The molecular processes which could be involved are discussed.     

Distribution of Chi-Stimulated Recombinational Exchanges and Heteroduplex Endpoints in Phage Lambda

The recombination hotspot Chi, 5' G-C-T-G-G-T-G-G 3', stimulates the RecBCD recombination pathway of Escherichia coli. We have determined, with precision greater than previously reported, the distribution of Chi-stimulated exchanges around a Chi site in phage lambda. Crosses of lambda phages with single base-pair mutations surrounding a Chi site were conducted in and analyzed on mismatch correction-impaired hosts to preserve heteroduplex mismatches for analysis. Among phages recombinant for flanking markers, Chi stimulated exchanges most intensely in the intervals immediately adjacent to the Chi site, both to its right and to its left. Stimulation fell off abruptly to the right but gradually to the left (with respect to the orientation of the Chi sequence written above). We have also determined that Chi stimulated the formation of heteroduplex DNA, which frequently had one endpoint to the right of Chi and the other endpoint to the left. These data support a model of Chi-stimulated recombination in which RecBCD enzyme cuts DNA immediately to the right of Chi and unwinds DNA to the left of Chi; segments of unwound single-stranded DNA are sometimes, but not always, degraded before synapsis with homologous DNA.     

Chi-dependent intramolecular recombination in Escherichia coli.

Homologous recombination in Escherichia coli is enhanced by a cis-acting octamer sequence named Chi (5''-GCTGGTGG-3'') that interacts with RecBCD. To gain insight into the mechanism of Chi-enhanced recombination, we recruited an experimental system that permits physical monitoring of intramolecular recombination by linear substrates released by in vivo restriction from infecting chimera phage. Recombination of the released substrates depended on recA, recBCD and cis-acting Chi octamers. Recombination proficiency was lowered by a xonA mutation and by mutations that inactivated the RuvABC and RecG resolution enzymes. Activity of Chi sites was influenced by their locations and by the number of Chi octamers at each site. A single Chi site stimulated recombination, but a combination of Chi sites on the two homologs was synergistic. These data suggest a role for Chi at both ends of the linear substrate. Chi was lost in all recombinational exchanges stimulated by a single Chi site. Exchanges in substrates with Chi sites on both homologs occurred in the interval between the sites as well as in the flanking interval. These observations suggest that the generation of circular products by intramolecular recombination involves Chi-dependent processing of one end by RecBCD and pairing of the processed end with its duplex homolog.     

The recA-recBCD dependent recombination pathways of Serratia marcescens and Proteus mirabilis in Escherichia coli: functions of hybrid enzymes and hybrid pathways.

The physical maps of cloned recBCD gene regions of Serratia marcescens and Proteus mirabilis were correlated to genes located in this region. The genes thyA, recC, recB, recD and argA were organized as in Escherichia coli. The 3 rec genes code for the 3 different subunits of the RecBCD enzyme and produced enzymes promoting recombination and repair of UV damage in E coli. The recBCD-dependent stimulation of recombination at specific nucleotide sequences called Chi (Chi-activation) was determined in lambda red-gam-crosses. Chi-activation by the different RecBCD enzymes decreased in the order E coli greater than S marcescens greater than P mirabilis. In E coli cloned subunits genes from S marcescens and P mirabilis led to the formation of functional hybrid enzymes consisting of subunits from 2 or even 3 species. The origin of the RecC subunit present in the hybrid enzymes affected the degree of Chi-activation. Further, changes in Chi-activation occurred when the RecD subunit in the enzyme from E coli was replaced by RecD proteins from S marcescens or P mirabilis. This suggested that the RecD subunit determines not only whether or not Chi-activation is possible but also to which extent it occurs. Finally we have reconstituted recombination pathways of S marcescens and P mirabilis by combining the cloned recA and recBCD genes from these species in E coli deleted for recA and recBCD. Both pathways can efficiently promote recombination and repair. Studies are summarized which showed that levels of repair and recombination promoted by the recA-recBCD genes are mostly higher when the recA and recBCD genes came from the same species than from 2 different species (hybrid RecBCD recombination pathway). The data are interpreted to provide evidence that in vivo the RecA protein co-operates with the RecBCD enzyme in recombination and repair of UV damage.     

Recombination initiation: Easy as A, B, C, D… χ?

The octameric Chi (χ) sequence is a recombination hotspot in Escherichia coli. Recent studies suggest a singular mechanism by which χ regulates not only the nuclease activity of RecBCD enzyme, but also the ability of RecBCD to promote loading of the strand exchange protein, RecA, onto χ-containing DNA.