Prenatal stress and increased fluctuating asymmetry in the parietal bones of neonatal rats

Recent studies have reported increased fluctuating dental and long bone asymmetry in neonates as a function of prenatal stress. The present study was designed to assess the effects of prenatal stress on a third calcium-dependent system, membranous bone. Pregnant rats were exposed to cold, heat, or noise from conception through parturition. Bilateral parietal bone lengths were measured in the term neonates. Levels of fluctuating asymmetry were found to be significantly increased (p less than .001) in all three stressed groups compared to unstressed controls. Results support the concept of a generalized stress response, and suggestions are offered for human osteological application.     

Fluctuating asymmetry and stress in a medieval Nubian population

Fluctuating asymmetry is commonly used as a bioindicator of developmental stress. This study addresses asymmetry under nutritional/systemic stress in the human craniofacial skeleton and its utility as an indicator of developmental instability. Crania from the diachronic Christian cemeteries at Kulubnarti (Sudanese Nubia) were chosen as a model for nutrition/systemic stress. Previous studies indicate that individuals from the Early Christian cemetery were subjected to greater developmental stress when compared with individuals from the Late Christian cemetery. Therefore, crania from the Early Christian cemetery should display a greater magnitude of fluctuating asymmetry than crania from the Late Christian cemetery. Thirty adult crania of comparable age and sex were selected from each population. Landmark coordinates were digitized in two separate trials and averaged to minimize error. Euclidean distance matrix analysis (EDMA) was used to measure and compare the magnitude of fluctuating asymmetry in each sample. Results indicate that crania from the Early Christian cemetery display greater amounts of fluctuating asymmetry than those from the Late Christian cemetery, as predicted. The degree of fluctuating asymmetry for each linear distance is highly correlated between the cemeteries, suggesting that all humans may share common patterns of fluctuating asymmetry in the skull. In contrast, there is little correlation between magnitude of fluctuating asymmetry and length of linear distance, between-subject variability, or measurement error. These results support the hypothesis that poor nutrition/systemic stress increases developmental instability in the human skull and that increased fluctuating asymmetry constitutes morphological evidence of this stress.     

Fluctuating asymmetry in mice and rats: evaluation of the method

Fluctuating asymmetry, which reflects small, random deviations from symmetry in otherwise bilaterally symmetrical characters, may be used as an indicator of developmental instability in humans and farm animals, and it may also be applicable as a stress indicator. We intended to find a method to allow the use of fluctuating asymmetry as a stress indicator in laboratory animals. That method had to be reproducible and reliable. Furthermore, its applicability in laboratory animals would be improved if it was possible to obtain measurements on the skin surface that correlated with results obtained by measuring the skeleton directly. Seven traits in mice and five traits in rats were evaluated for their applicability for measuring fluctuating asymmetry in mice and rats. Two out of the seven traits, i.e. the width of the joint between the third metatarsal bone and the digital bone on the hind paw, and the length of the incisor tooth at the top, were found to be reliable and reproducible for detecting fluctuating asymmetry in mice as well as in rats. Three out of the seven traits, i.e. the width of the carpal bones, the width of the joint between the tibia and the tarsal bones, and the length of the incisor tooth at the bottom, did express fluctuating asymmetry, but showed a poor day-to-day reproducibility. If the day-to-day reproducibility could be increased, these three traits might also be suitable for measuring fluctuating asymmetry in mice and rats. The last two traits, i.e. the length of ulna and the length of calcaneus plus metatarsal bone i.v., measured both on the skin surface and directly on the bone, did not express fluctuating asymmetry, and had a poor day-to-day reproducibility. These two traits are not suitable for measuring fluctuating asymmetry in mice and rats.     

FLUCTUATING ASYMMETRY IN CENTRAL AND MARGINAL POPULATIONS OF LYCHNIS VISCARIA IN RELATION TO GENETIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS

Developmental instability in the form of increased fluctuating asymmetry can be caused by either genetic or environmental stress. Because extinctions can be attributed broadly to these factors, fluctuating asymmetry may provide a sensitive tool for detecting such stresses. We studied the level of fluctuating asymmetry of flowers of a perennial outcrossing plant species, Lychnis viscaria, both in natural and common-garden populations. The degree of flower asymmetry was higher in small, isolated, and marginal populations of the species range. These marginal populations also were the most homozygous. In the core area of the species' range, flowers were more symmetrical The level of asymmetry was correlated with both population size and heterozygosity. However, a partial correlation analysis revealed that when the impact of population size was controlled for, there was a negative relationship between fluctuating asymmetry and heterozygosity, whereas when controlling for heterozygosity, no relationship between population size and fluctuating asymmetry was found. This indicates that genetic consequences of small population size probably underlie the relationship between the level of asymmetry and population size. Results from a transplantation experiment showed that individuals subjected to a higher environmental stress had an increased level of asymmetry compared to control plants. In the common-garden conditions the level of fluctuating asymmetry did not differ between the central and marginal populations. This suggests that presumably both genetic and environmental factors affected to the higher level of asymmetry among marginal populations compared to central ones. In all we conclude that even though fluctuating asymmetry seems to be a sensitive tool for detecting stresses, results from studies focusing on only one factor should be interpreted with caution.     

Fluctuating Asymmetry in Menidia beryllina before and after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill

Assessing the impacts of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill with a dependable baseline comparison can provide reliable insight into environmental stressors on organisms that were potentially affected by the spill. Fluctuating asymmetry (small, non-random deviations from perfect bilateral symmetry) is an informative metric sensitive to contaminants that can be used to assess environmental stress levels. For this study, the well-studied and common Gulf of Mexico estuarine fish, Menidia beryllina, was used with pre and post-oil spill collections. Comparisons of fluctuating asymmetry in three traits (eye diameter, pectoral fin length, and pelvic fin length) were made pre and post-oil spill across two sites (Old Fort Bayou and the Pascagoula River), as well as between years of collection (2011, 2012)-one and two years, respectfully, after the spill in 2010. We hypothesized that fluctuating asymmetry would be higher in post-Deepwater Horizon samples, and that this will be replicated in both study areas along the Mississippi Gulf coast. We also predicted that fluctuating asymmetry would decrease through time after the oil spill as the oil decomposed and/or was removed. Analyses performed on 1135 fish (220 pre and 915 post Deepwater Horizon) showed significantly higher post spill fluctuating asymmetry in the eye but no difference for the pectoral or pelvic fins. There was also higher fluctuating asymmetry in one of the two sites both pre and post-spill, indicating observed asymmetry may be the product of multiple stressors. Fluctuating asymmetry decreased in 2012 compared to 2011. Fluctuating asymmetry is a sensitive measure of sub lethal stress, and the observed variability in this study (pre vs. post-spill or between sites) could be due to a combination of oil, dispersants, or other unknown stressors.     

Single rays as indicators of fin vestigialization in coho salmon: patterns and perspectives

Although finrays in salmon normally contain a pair of elements (biramous), finrays with a single element (uniramous) occasionally develop. Exposure to chronic stress during character development has been shown to increase fluctuating asymmetry, suggesting the occurrence of single finrays may be stress‐induced. On the other hand, single finrays may be evolutionary atavisms, reflecting fin vestigialization caused by reduced selection pressure. To assess the merits of these hypotheses, cleared and stained paired and median fins were examined for single finrays in juvenile coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch Walbaum) from two compatible hatchery stocks and their reciprocal hybrids which had been exposed to different patterns of chronic temperature fluctuation throughout embryogenesis. In the median fins, uniramous secondary finrays predominated, and single primary finrays were infrequent. Single finrays in the median fins did not respond to thermal treatment or cross, suggesting the fins were evolutionarily stable and under strong developmental control. The paired fins were observed to contain only primary finrays. Frequencies of single pelvic finrays increased under thermal stress, as did fluctuating asymmetry, suggesting increased sensitivity to stress due to reduced developmental control in this fin. However, the presence or absence of single finrays in the paired fins did not alter the statistical significance of the conclusions regarding levels of fluctuating asymmetry, the number of asymmetric fish, or the contribution to meristic variation from asymmetry. Locations of single finrays in the paired fins were unaffected by thermal treatment or cross. Single finrays were most commonly observed in the trailing margins of both paired fins, a finding consistent with vestigialization theory. Frequency histograms of single pectoral finray locations revealed a second peak in the leading quarter of the fin. The esults support the hypothesis that single primary finrays are evolutionary atavisms, and that reduced selection pressure is differentially influencing the paired fins.     

Does fluctuating asymmetry constitute a sensitive biomarker of nutritional stress in house sparrows (Passer domesticus)?

Small random deviations from left–right symmetry in bilateral traits, termed fluctuating asymmetry (FA), are theoretically predicted to increase with environmental stress and believed to constitute a potential biomarker in conservation. However, reported relationships between FA and stress are generally weak and variable among organisms, traits and stresses. Here we test if, and to what extent, FA increases with nutritional stress, estimated from independent feather growth measurements, in free-ranging house sparrows (Passer domesticus). Ptilochronological feather marks showed significant heterogeneity among study plots, indicating that house sparrow populations were exposed to variable levels of nutritional stress during development. However, individuals from more stressed populations did not show increased levels of fluctuating asymmetry in tarsus or rectrix length, nor was there evidence for significant between-trait concordance in FA at the individual or the population level. Lack of support for FA in tarsus and rectrix length as estimator of nutritional stress in house sparrows may indicate that developmental instability is insensitive to nutritional stress in this species, poorly reflected in patterns of fluctuating asymmetry due to ecological or statistical reasons, or highly context-specific. Such uncertainty continues to hamper the use of FA as a biomarker tool in conservation planning.     

Heat stress, fluctuating asymmetry and prenatal selection in the laboratory rat

Recent studies have demonstrated that stress may increase the fluctuating asymmetry of teeth and limbs in laboratory animals. The present study investigates the effects of heat on such parameters. Pregnant laboratory rats are exposed to temperatures of 33 degrees C during gestation. Increases in fluctuating asymmetry of dental dimensions as well as bone density are found for the pups of such females when compared to unstressed controls. A general increase in limb lengths is also reported for young of heat stressed animals. Prenatal selection with differential survival is suggested as a possible explanation for differences found between the experimental and control animals.     

The assessment of fluctuating odontometric asymmetry from incomplete hominid fossil data

Problems of small sample size and incompleteness of fossil data in the evaluation of metric asymmetry may be overcome by the application of cluster sampling techniques together with factorial analyses of variance. Degrees of fluctuating odontometric asymmetry are reported in Australopithecus, Homo erectus and Homo neanderthalensis. In all three populations mesiodistal dimensions were shown to be more asymmetric than buccolingual dimensions, with maxillary teeth exhibiting significantly greater degrees of asymmetry than mandibular teeth. Neanderthal teeth were significantly more metrically asymmetric than those of either Australopithecus or H. erectus, with population differences in asymmetry centered in the maxillary teeth.     

Fluctuating asymmetry as an indicator of fitness: can we bridge the gap between studies?

There is growing evidence from both experimental and non-experimental studies that fluctuating asymmetry does not consistently index stress or fitness. The widely held--yet poorly substantiated--belief that fluctuating asymmetry can act as a universal measure of developmental stability and predictor of stress-mediated changes in fitness, therefore staggers. Yet attempts to understand why the reported relationships between fluctuating asymmetry, stress and fitness are so heterogeneous--i.e. whether the associations are truly weak or non-existent or whether they become confounded during different stages of the analytical pathways remain surprisingly scarce. Hence, we attempt to disentangle these causes, by reviewing the various statistical and conceptual factors that are suspected to confound potential relationships between fluctuating asymmetry, stress and fitness. Two main categories of factors are discerned: those associated with the estimation of developmental stability through fluctuating asymmetry and those associated with the effects of genotype and environment on developmental stability. Next, we describe a series of statistical tools that have recently been developed to help reduce this noise. We argue that the current lack of a theoretical framework that predicts if and when relationships with developmental stability can be expected, urges for further theoretical and empirical research, such as on the genetic architecture of developmental stability in stressed populations. If the underlying developmental mechanisms are better understood, statistical patterns of asymmetry variation may become a biologically meaningful tool.     

FLUCTUATING ODONTOMETRIC ASYMMETRY,MORPHOLOGICAL VARIABILITY,AND GENETIC MONOMORPHISM IN THE CHEETAH ACINONYX JUBATUS

The magnitudes of dimensional variability and fluctuating asymmetry in dental dimensions are reported for a sample of South African cheetah Acinonyx jubatus. To test the hypothesis that elevated levels of variability and asymmetry are associated with the increased developmental instability reported for this species, our results were contrasted to those for two other felids: Felis lybica and F. caracal. These findings suggest that dental dimensions in cheetahs are not significantly more variable or asymmetric. Hence, it is concluded that the cheetah may not be as developmentally unstable as was previously supposed.     

Ecological stress memory: Evidence in two out of seven species through the examination of the relationship between leaf fluctuating asymmetry and photosynthesis

Increased morphological fluctuating asymmetry is considered as an indication that the extent of a natural stress has surpassed the ability of the genotype to maintain the normal symmetry in the body plan. Young leaves can suffer by a variety of stresses, such as nutrient deficiencies, drought, heat and cold in combination with high light. Therefore, increased morphological fluctuating asymmetry in mature leaves may be considered as an ecological indicator of such environmental pressures. Hence, deviations from symmetry in a mature leaf may be a reminder of an adversity having occurred when the leaf was young and developing. We argued that a past stress may stigmatize future photosynthesis and we searched for correlations between leaf fluctuating asymmetry and photosynthetic parameters obtained from fast chlorophyll a fluorescence rise curves in mature leaves from seven tree species. The results were species-specific, with four species (Arbutus unedo, Cercis siliquastrum, Platanus orientalis and Populus alba) showing both maximum quantum yield of photosystem II and photosynthetic performance index (PI_total sensu Strasser) to be independent of the alleged juvenile stress, while in one species (Ceratonia siliqua) the two parameters were negatively correlated to leaf fluctuating asymmetry. Interestingly, in two species (Olea europaea and Pistacia lentiscus), higher leaf asymmetry was linked with lower risk of chronic photoinhibitory damage and higher photosynthetic capacity. An ‘ecological stress memory’ may be inferred for some species improving their tolerance to future adversities and global change.     

Fluctuating asymmetry in antlers of fallow deer (Dama dama): the relative roles of environmental stress and sexual selection

Antler lengths were recorded of a total of 250 male fallow deer (Dama dama (L)). Animals sampled were from marked populations where the majority of individuals were of known age. Asymmetry in antler length was normally distributed with a mean not significantly different from zero, confirming that differences in length between the antler pair constitute a true fluctuating asymmetry (FA). We found no clear relationship between the degree of asymmetry in antler length of an individual male and either population density or actual body mass. We did, however, detect a significant relationship between asymmetry and deviation from maximum cohort bodyweight. If deviation from maximum weight within a cohort may be considered some index of competitive success or increasing environmental stress, this may suggest that asymmetry in antler length relates in some way to developmental stress suffered by the individual concerned. The degree of asymmetry recorded in antler length also showed a significant decline with animal age, with antlers of animals of 2 years or older showing significantly greater symmetry. This is consistent with a hypothesis that despite continued competition for resources, there is a changing balance of selection pressure as animals reach maturity, with increased pressure from sexual selection requiring males to produce significantly more symmetrical ornaments.     

On the meaning of increased fluctuating dental asymmetry: a cross populational study.

Suarez reports a greater magnitude of fluctuating dental asymmetry for Neandertal sample when compared with a sample of modern Ohio whites. He postulates that this greater antimeric variance could be due to a greater degree of inbreeding in the Neandertal populations. In the present investigation, the magnitude of fluctuating dental asymmetry is evaluated for Eskimo and Pueblo populations. These populations were found to exhibit dental variance of equal magnitude to that of the Neandertal population. As these populations are not highly inbred, a stress related mechanism is suggested to explain these observations and the inbreeding hypothesis is rejected. The implications of this mechanism to Brace's Probable Mutation Effect are discussed.     

Parasites increase fluctuating asymmetry of maleDrosophila nigrospiracula: Implications for sexual selection

Fluctuating asymmetry (minor deviations from perfect bilateral symmetry) is manifested by individuals less able to buffer environmental stress during development. I utilized a system of two naturally-occurring parasites ofDrosophila nigrospiracula to test whether parasitic infection during host development yields elevated degrees of fluctuating asymmetry in two morphological traits of males. This hypothesis has important implications for sexual selection, as it may explain why asymmetric males are often found to be sexually disadvantaged. In my system, nematodes infect larvae and therefore are more likely to disrupt development than mites which only parasitize adult flies. As predicted, nematode-infected maleD. nigrospiracula had a higher degree of bristle asymmetry than did mite-infested and control (carrying neither parasite) males. There was also a significant relation between nematode number and degree of asymmetry. There was a significant negative relation between nematode load and size of adult males, implicating a causal link between nutritional stress during host development and fluctuating asymmetry. Patterns of wing length asymmetry were inconsistent with those of bristle asymmetry. Nematode-infected males did not differ in wing length asymmetry relative to mite-infested and control males, nor was there a significant relation between nematode number and wing asymmetry. This inconsistency in expression of asymmetry may reflect different intensities of selection operating on each morphological trait.     

Birth order and fluctuating asymmetry: a first look

We investigated the hypothesis that maternal immunoreactivity to male-specific features of the foetus can increase developmental instability. We predicted that the participants' number of older brothers would be positively related to the fluctuating asymmetry of ten bilateral morphological traits. The participants were 40 adult male psychiatric patients and 31 adult male hospital employees. Consistent with the hypothesis, the participants' number of older brothers--but not number of older sisters, younger brothers or younger sisters--was positively associated with fluctuating asymmetry. The patients had significantly larger fluctuating asymmetry scores and tended to have more older brothers than the employees, but the positive relationship between the number of older brothers and fluctuating asymmetry was observed in both groups.     

Dental arch asymmetry in an isolated Adriatic community

Developmental stability reflects the ability of a genotype to develop in the same way under varying environmental conditions. Deviations from developmental stability, arising from disruptive effects of environmental and genetic stresses, can be measured in terms of fluctuating asymmetry, a particularly sensitive indicator of the ability to cope with these stresses during ontogeny. In an inbred Adriatic island population, we expected dental arch fluctuating asymmetry 1) to be higher than in an outbred sample from the same island, and 2) within this population, to increase with the level of inbreeding. Due to environmental stress, we also expected to find higher fluctuating asymmetry in the outbred island population than in an urban reference group from the same country. The material consisted of 506 dental casts of 253 children from 1) the island of Hvar, and 2) Zagreb, Croatia. Three-dimensional coordinates of 26 landmarks spanning the arches were digitized. The analysis partitioned the asymmetry of arch forms into components for directional and fluctuating bilateral asymmetry, using the appropriate Procrustes method (geometric morphometrics). The results corroborated the hypotheses. Fluctuating asymmetry was found to be higher on the island than in Zagreb in all groups and in both jaws, and increased significantly with endogamy level in the lower jaw. There was no significant directional asymmetry in the Zagreb sample and likewise none in the upper jaws of the outbred island group, but significant directional asymmetry in both jaws of the inbred population and also in the lower jaws of the outbred island group. These results suggest an environmental as well as a genetic influence on dental arch asymmetry. Although the lower jaws expressed these two stresses almost additively, the upper jaws appeared to be better buffered. The role of directional asymmetry as a potential indicator of craniofacial developmental instability clearly merits further attention.     

Genetic and phenotypic correlation between fluctuating asymmetry and two measurements of fear and stress in chickens

The purpose of the present study was to estimate the genetic and phenotypic correlation between fluctuating asymmetry and two measurements of fear and stress in chickens which had not deliberately stressed in any way, using the restricted maximum likelihood procedure. A total of 1073 36-week-old birds from two generations with complete pedigree of the Quail Castellana breed was used. Fluctuating asymmetry of several traits (leg, wing, and feather lengths, and ear-lobe and wattle areas), tonic immobility duration (indicator of fear), and heterophil to lymphocyte ratio (indicator of stress) were measured. The estimated genetic relationship between relative fluctuating asymmetry for the different traits and tonic immobility tended to be positive, that between the combined relative asymmetry of all traits and tonic immobility being near to +1; no significant phenotypic relationship was found between relative fluctuating asymmetry and tonic immobility. The genetic relationship between relative fluctuating asymmetry and heterophil to lymphocyte ratio was not consistent across the traits, ranging from +1 to −1, although the genetic correlation between the combined relative asymmetry and the heterophil to lymphocyte ratio was near to +1 too; no significant phenotypic relationship was found between relative fluctuating asymmetry and heterophil to lymphocyte ratio either. Relative fluctuating asymmetry and body weight were genetically negatively correlated for leg length and ear-lobe area but positively for feather length; the genetic correlation between the combined relative asymmetry and the body weight being near to −1; phenotypic relationships were not significantly different from zero. A significant negative genetic correlation between tonic immobility and heterophil to lymphocyte ratio was found, although the phenotypic association between these two measurements was zero. Phenotypic correlations always near to zero suggest that fluctuating asymmetry was not associated with duration of tonic immobility and heterophil to lymphocyte ratio in birds that have not been deliberately stressed.     

Why do some traits show higher fluctuating asymmetry than others? A test of hypotheses with tail feathers of birds

Certain characters are more susceptible to increased fluctuating asymmetry (FA) than others. This trait-specific susceptibility has normally been attributed to different degrees of developmental stability, which could be caused by different modes of selection, functionality, or the stress experienced during the development process. Recently, it has also been suggested that the expression of FA not only depends on developmental stability, but also on the cost of growth of the trait, defined as the amount of structural components necessary to form a unit of length of a given character. In accordance with this argument, a trait with more structural components per unit of length should show lower asymmetry than a simpler one. To test this hypothesis, we examine the structure (number of barbs, barb length, and rachis width) and asymmetry of the longest tail feathers in 26 bird species. Regression analyses using phylogenetically independent contrasts show that FA is negatively correlated with the number of barbs and feather rachis width in males (including species with elongated tails subjected to sexual selection), and with rachis width in females, whose tails supposedly evolve by natural selection. Moreover, the negative correlation between FA and rachis width persisted when taking only the males of non-dimorphic species. These results confirm the hypothesis, suggesting that a trait's susceptibility to express developmental instability by fluctuating asymmetry depends on its structural composition.