Involvement of Carrot Cell Surface Proteins in Attachment of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The initial step in tumor formation by Agrobacterium tumefaciens is the site-specific attachment of the bacteria to plant cells. A similar attachment to plant tissue culture cells has been observed. Binding to carrot suspension culture cells was not dependent on the presence of divalent cations and was not inhibited by the addition of mannose, α-methyl mannoside, galactose, arabinose, glucosamine, 2-deoxyglucose, or 0.25 molar NaCl to the culture medium. The ability of the carrot cells to bind A. tumefaciens was markedly reduced by elution of the cells with dilute detergent or CaCl₂ or by incubation of the cells with proteolytic enzymes. The carrot cells were not killed by these treatments and recovered the ability to bind A. tumefaciens within 3 to 6 hours. A. tumefaciens did not bind to carrot cells which had been induced to form embryos (AG Matthysse, RHG Gurlitz 1982 Physiol Plant Pathol 21: 381-387). A comparison of the peptides eluted from embryos and from uninduced cells using sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed that there were several changes in extractable polypeptides after embryo induction. One or more of the polypeptides present before embryo induction and absent from embryos may be involved in the binding of A. tumefaciens to the carrot cell surface.     

Conditioned medium promotes the attachment ofAgrobacterium tumefaciens strain NT 1 to carrot cells

Summary Wild-typeAgrobacterium tumefaciens bind to carrot suspension culture cells. Avirulent strain NT 1 did not bind to carrot cells when they were incubated together in Murashige and Skoog medium. Conditioned medium was prepared by incubatingA. tumefaciens virulent strain C 58 with carrot cells and removing the bacteria and carrot cells using filter sterilization. This conditioned medium promoted the binding of NT 1 to carrot cells. Conditioned medium did not promote the nonspecific attachment ofEscherichia coli to carrot cells. These results suggest that when wild-typeA. tumefaciens are incubated with plant host cells, some substance(s) involved in bacterial attachment are released into the medium. Filter-sterilized medium from the incubation of the nonattachingchvB mutant A 1045 with carrot cells promoted the attachment of strain NT 1 even though A 1045 bacteria did not bind to the carrot cells. However, filter-sterilized medium from the incubation of the non-attachingatt mutant Att-B 123 with carrot cells was unable to promote the binding of strain NT 1. This suggests that nonattaching mutants ofA. tumefaciens can be divided into two groups on the basis of the properties of the substances released into the medium when the bacteria are incubated with carrot cells.Abbreviations MS Murashige and Skoog tissue culture medium Dedicated to the memory of Professor John G. Torrey     

Agrobacterium tumefaciens Interaction with Suspension-Cultured Tomato Cells

Adherence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens to suspension-cultured tomato cells has been characterized using a quantitative binding assay. Saturable binding of radiolabeled A. tumefaciens to plant cells resulted in 100 to 300 bacteria bound per cell. Specificity of A. tumefaciens binding was also inferred from two additional results: (a) an initial incubation of plant cells with A. tumefaciens reduced subsequent binding of radiolabeled A. tumefaciens by 60% to 75%; (b) tomato cells bound less than three E. coli per cell. Protease treatment of plant cells had no effect on subsequent bacterial binding, but prior treatment of plant cells with pectinolytic enzymes increased binding 2- to 3-fold. Pectin-enriched and neutral polymer-enriched fractions were obtained from tomato cell walls. The soluble pectin-enriched fraction inhibited binding of bacteria to plant cells by 85% to 95%, whereas the neutral polymer fraction only partially inhibited binding. Preliminary characterization of the activity showed it is heat stable, partially inactivated by protease treatment, and substantially inactivated by acid hydrolysis.     

Characterization of nonattaching mutants of Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

The first step in tumor formation by Agrobacterium tumefaciens is the site-specific binding of the bacteria to plant host cells. Transposon mutants of the bacteria which fail to attach to carrot suspension culture cells were isolated. These mutants showed no significant attachment to carrot cells with either microscopic or viable cell count assays of bacterial binding. The nonattaching mutants were all avirulent. When revertants of the mutants were obtained by enriching for bacteria which do bind to carrot cells, the bacteria were found to have regained the ability to bind to carrot cells and virulence simultaneously. These results suggest that the ability of the bacteria to bind to plant cells is required for virulence. Like the parent strain, all of the nonattaching mutants synthesized cellulose, but unlike the parent strain, they failed to aggregate carrot suspension culture cells. The transposon Tn5, which was used to obtain the mutants, was located on a 12-kilobase EcoRI fragment of the bacterial chromosomal DNA in all of the nonattaching mutants from strain C58. That the mutant phenotype was due to the Tn5 insertion was shown by cloning the Tn5-containing DNA fragment from the mutant bacteria and using it to replace the wild-type fragment in the parent strain by marker exchange. The resulting bacteria had the same mutant phenotype as the original Tn5 mutants; they did not attach to carrot cells, they did not cause the aggregation of carrot cells, and they were avirulent. No difference was seen between the parent strain and the nonattaching mutants in hydrophobicity, motility, flagella, fimbriae, beta-2-glucan content, size of lipopolysaccharide, or ability of the lipopolysaccharide to inhibit bacterial attachment to tissue culture cells. Differences were seen between the parent strain and the nonattaching mutants in the polypeptides removed from the bacteria during the preparation of spheroplasts. Three of the mutants were lacking a polypeptide of about 34 kilodaltons (kDa). One mutant was lacking the 34-kDa polypeptide and another polypeptide of about 38 kDa. The fifth mutant was lacking a polypeptide slightly smaller than the 34-kDa polypeptide missing in the other four mutants. These missing polypeptides all reappeared in the revertants of the mutants. Thus, bacterial binding to plant cells appears to require the presence of these polypeptides.     

Suppression of tumorigenicity by the IncW R plasmid pSa in Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Summary The effect of the IncW R plasmid, pSa, on tumorigenicity and on the expression and maintenance of the Ti plasmid in tumorigenic strains of A. tumefaciens was determined. Plasmid pSa could be transferred into and stably maintained by both octopine-and nopaline-utilizing A. tumefaciens strains. The R plasmid had no effect on Ti plasmid maintenance or on Ti plasmid functions, such as octopine utilization or conjugal bacterial transfer. However, A. tumefaciens strains harboring both the R plasmid and the Ti plasmid in most instances failed to induce tumors on a number of plant species. This effect on tumorigenicity is specific to pSa. When pSa is cured from the A. tumefaciens transconjugants or when their Ti plasmids are genetically transferred to an appropriate recipient, the resultant strains lacking the R plasmid regain tumorigenicity. Restriction endonuclease analysis of plasmid DNA isolated from transconjugants harboring pSa showed no difference in Ti plasmid cleavage patterns when compared to plasmid DNA isolated from the tumorigenic parent strain. These results indicate that pSa does not induce detectable permanent genetic alteration of the Ti plasmid. Rather, it appears that the R plasmid suppresses some Ti plasmid function(s) necessary for tumorigenicity.     

Crown gall disease and hairy root disease : a sledgehammer and a tackhammer

The neoplastic diseases crown gall and hairy root are incited by the phytopathogenic bacteria Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Agrobacterium rhizogenes, respectively. Although the molecular mechanism of T-DNA transfer to the plant most likely is the same for both species, the physiological basis of tumorigenesis is fundamentally different. Crown gall tumors result from the over-production of the phytohormones auxin and cytokinin specified by A. tumefaciens T-DNA genes. Although the T-DNA of some Riplasmids of A. rhizogenes contains auxin biosynthetic genes, these loci are not always necessary for hairy root formation. Recent experiments suggest that hairy root tumors result from the increased sensitivity of transformed cells to endogenous auxin levels. An understanding of hairy root tumorigenesis will likely result in an increased knowledge of plant developmental processes.     

Inhibitory Effects of a Pectin-Enriched Tomato Cell Wall Fraction on Agrobacterium tumefaciens Binding and Tumor Formation

A pectin-enriched soluble cell wall fraction (CWF) prepared from suspension cultured tomato cells inhibits binding of Agrobacterium tumefaciens to these cells. It was hypothesized that the CWF contains the plant surface binding site for A. tumefaciens (NT Neff, AN Binns 1985 Plant Physiol 77: 35-42). Experiments described here demonstrate that tomato CWF inhibited tumor formation on potato slices and Agrobacterium binding to intact tomato cells in a dose-dependent fashion. Boiling the fraction reduced both its binding and tumor inhibitory activities. Tumor inhibitory activity was titrated out by increased concentrations of bacterial inocula with no inhibition apparent at 1 × 10⁸ bacteria per milliliter. These results indicate that a tomato CWF is enriched for a putative A. tumefaciens binding site which may also be involved in tumor formation in potato.     

Role of bacterial lipopolysaccharide in attachment of agrobacterium to moss

Gametophore induction in moss by Agrobacterium tumefaciens was inhibited by addition of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from A. tumefaciens. The LPS did not affect bacterial viability or appear to bind to bacterial cells. LPS from nonbinding Agrobacterium radiobacter was not effective in reducing gametophore formation. A. tumefaciens LPS, if added 24 hours after addition of viable bacterial cells, had no effect in reducing gametophore formation. The polysaccharide portion of the LPS was identified as the binding component necessary for attachment of agrobacteria for induction of gametophores in moss and tumors in higher plants.     

Modulation of auxin-binding proteins in cell suspensions : I. Differential responses of carrot embryo cultures

This paper shows that the level of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) in the medium determines the level of auxin-binding proteins in the membranes of carrot, Daucus carota, cells grown in suspension. This induction takes slightly more than 2 hours to complete and can be elicited by natural as well as synthetic auxins. The auxin binding sites thus generated, which are pronase-sensitive, bind 2,4-D, indoleacetic acid, and naphthalene-acetic acid (NAA) equally well. However both α- and β-NAA bind, whereas only α-NAA is effective in the inductive process. Cells committed to embryogeny (proembryogenic masses) do not respond to auxin, i.e. their level of auxin-binding proteins remains very low, and they do not seem to synthesize the hormone, as indicated by inhibitor studies. Sensitivity to, and production of, auxin, begins when the embryo becomes polarized, i.e. at postglobular stage.     

Characterisation of root amino acid exudation in white clover (Trifolium repens L.)

Lateral roots are crucial for the plasticity of root responses to environmental conditions in soil. The bacterivorous microfauna has been shown to increase root branching and to foster auxin producing soil bacteria. However, information on modifications of plant internal auxin content by soil bacteria and bacterivores is missing. Therefore, the effects of a rhizosphere bacterial community and a common soil amoeba (Acanthamoeba castellanii) on root branching and on auxin (indole-3-acetic acid) metabolism in Lepidium sativum and Arabidopsis thaliana were investigated. In a first experimental series, bacteria increased conjugated auxin concentrations in L. sativum shoots, but did not alter free bioactive auxin content nor root branching. In contrast, in presence of soil bacteria plus amoebae free auxin concentrations in shoots and root branching increased, demonstrating that effects of bacteria on auxin metabolism in plants were strongly modified by the bacterivorous amoebae. In a second experiment, A. thaliana reporter plants for auxin (DR5) and cytokinin (ARR5) responded similarly with increased root branching in the presence of amoebae. Surprisingly, in reporter plants cytokinin but not auxin responses were detectable, accompanied by higher soil nitrate concentrations in the presence of amoebae. Likely, increased nitrate concentrations in the rhizosphere led to an accumulation of cytokinin and interactions with free auxin in plants and finally to increased root growth in the presence of amoebae. Altogether, the results show that mutual control mechanisms exist between plant hormone metabolism and microbial signalling, and that effects on hormonal concentrations of plants by free-living bacteria are strongly influenced by bacterial grazers like amoebae.     

pSa Causes Oncogenic Suppression of Agrobacterium by Inhibiting VirE2 Protein Export

When coresident with the Ti (tumor-inducing) plasmid, the 21-kDa product of the osa gene of the plasmid pSa can suppress crown gall tumorigenesis incited by Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Neither T-DNA processing nor vir (virulence) gene induction is affected by the presence of osa in the bacterium. We used Arabidopsis thaliana root segments and tobacco leaf discs to demonstrate that Osa inhibits A. tumefaciens from transforming these plants to the stable phenotypes of tumorigenesis, kanamycin resistance, and stable β-glucuronidase (GUS) expression. When A. tumefaciens contained osa, the lack of expression of transient GUS activity in infected plant tissues, as well as the lack of systemic viral symptoms following agroinfection of Nicotiana benthamiana by tomato mottle virus, suggested that oncogenic suppression by Osa occurs before T-DNA enters the plant nucleus. The extracellular complementation of an A. tumefaciens virE2 mutant (the T-DNA donor strain) by an A. tumefaciens strain lacking T-DNA but containing a wild-type virE2 gene (the VirE2 donor strain) was blocked when osa was present in the VirE2 donor strain, but not when osa was present in the T-DNA donor strain. These data indicate that osa inhibits VirE2 protein, but not T-DNA export from A. tumefaciens. These data further suggest that VirE2 protein and T-DNA are separately exported from the bacterium. The successful infection of Datura stramonium plants and leaf discs of transgenic tobacco plants expressing VirE2 protein by an A. tumefaciens virE2 mutant carrying osa confirmed that oncogenic suppression by osa does not occur by blocking T-DNA transfer. Overexpression of virB9, virB10, and virB11 in A. tumefaciens did not overcome oncogenic suppression by osa. The finding that the expression of the osa gene by itself, rather than the formation of a conjugal intermediate with pSa, blocks transformation suggests that the mechanism of oncogenic suppression by osa may differ from that of the IncQ plasmid RSF1010.     

Involvement of a vitronectin-like protein in attachment of Agrobacterium tumefaciens to carrot suspension culture cells.

Infections of dicotyledonous plants by Agrobacterium tumefaciens result in the formation of crown gall tumors. Attachment of the bacteria to plant host cells is required for tumor formation. Human vitronectin and antivitronectin antibodies both inhibited the binding of A. tumefaciens to carrot cells. Wild-type bacteria are able to bind radioactive vitronectin; nonattaching mutants showed a reduction in the ability to bind vitronectin. The binding of biotype 1 A. tumefaciens to carrot cells or to radioactive vitronectin was not affected by high ionic strength. Detergent extraction of carrot cells removed the receptor to which the bacteria bind. The extract was found to contain a vitronectin-like protein. These results suggest that A. tumefaciens utilizes a vitronectin-like protein on the plant cell surface as the receptor for its initial attachment to host cells.     

The Effect of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens attR Mutation on Attachment and Root Colonization Differs between Legumes and Other Dicots

Infections of wound sites on dicot plants by Agrobacterium tumefaciens result in the formation of crown gall tumors. An early step in tumor formation is bacterial attachment to the plant cells. AttR mutants failed to attach to wound sites of both legumes and nonlegumes and were avirulent on both groups of plants. AttR mutants also failed to attach to the root epidermis and root hairs of nonlegumes and had a markedly reduced ability to colonize the roots of these plants. However, AttR mutants were able to attach to the root epidermis and root hairs of alfalfa, garden bean, and pea. The mutant showed little reduction in its ability to colonize these roots. Thus, A. tumefaciens appears to possess two systems for binding to plant cells. One system is AttR dependent and is required for virulence on all of the plants tested and for colonization of the roots of all of the plants tested except legumes. Attachment to root hairs through this system can be blocked by the acetylated capsular polysaccharide. The second system is AttR independent, is not inhibited by the acetylated capsular polysaccharide, and allows the bacteria to bind to the roots of legumes.     

Role of bacterial cellulose fibrils in Agrobacterium tumefaciens infection.

During the attachment of Agrobacterium tumefaciens to carrot tissue culture cells, the bacteria synthesize cellulose fibrils. We examined the role of these cellulose fibrils in the attachment process by determining the properties of bacterial mutants unable to synthesize cellulose. Such cellulose-minus bacteria attached to the carrot cell surface, but, in contrast to the parent strain, with which larger clusters of bacteria were seen on the plant cell, cellulose-minus mutant bacteria were attached individually to the plant cell surface. The wild-type bacteria became surrounded by fibrils within 2 h after attachment. No fibrils were seen with the cellulose-minus mutants. Prolonged incubation of wild-type A. tumefaciens with carrot cells resulted in the formation of large aggregates of bacteria, bacterial fibrils, and carrot cells. No such aggregates were formed after the incubation of carrot cells with cellulose-minus A. tumefaciens. The absence of cellulose fibrils also caused an alteration in the kinetics of bacterial attachment to carrot cells. Cellulose synthesis was not required for bacterial virulence; the cellulose-minus mutants were all virulent. However, the ability of the parent bacterial strain to produce tumors was unaffected by washing the inoculation site with water, whereas the ability of the cellulose-minus mutants to form tumors was much reduced by washing the inoculation site with water. Thus, a major role of the cellulose fibrils synthesized by A. tumefaciens appears to be anchoring the bacteria to the host cells, thereby aiding the production of tumors.     

The Conjugal Intermediate of Plasmid RSF1010 Inhibits Agrobacterium tumefaciens Virulence and VirB-Dependent Export of VirE2

Agrobacterium tumefaciens causes crown gall disease by transferring oncogenic, single-stranded DNA (T strand), covalently attached to the VirD2 protein, across the bacterial envelope into plant cells where its expression results in tumor formation. The single-stranded DNA binding protein VirE2 is also transferred into the plant cell, though the location at which VirE2 interacts with the T strand is still under investigation. The movement of the transferred DNA and VirE2 from A. tumefaciens to the plant cell depends on the membrane-localized VirB and VirD4 proteins. Further, the movement of the IncQ broad-host-range plasmid RSF1010 between Agrobacterium strains or from Agrobacterium to plants also requires the virB-encoded transfer system. Our earlier studies showed that the presence of the RSF1010 plasmid in wild-type strains of Agrobacterium inhibits both their virulence and their capacity to transport VirE2, as assayed by coinfection with virE mutants. Here we demonstrate that the capacity to form a conjugal intermediate of RSF1010 is necessary for this inhibition, suggesting that the transferred form of the plasmid competes with the VirD2-T strand and/or VirE2 for a common export site.     

Potential of Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Octopine-Utilizing Fluorescent Pseudomonas Strains To Attach to Susceptible Potato Tissues

The binding characteristics of two octopine-catabolizing pseudomonads, Pseudomonas fluorescens B99A and E175D, which were isolated from crown galls, have been examined. The binding of strain B99A to potato disks was very weak, followed a Freundlich isotherm, and was temperature and pH independent. Strain E175D displayed strong attachment and followed a Langmuir isotherm. Despite these fundamental differences in binding characteristics, when each strain was placed in competitive binding assays with either Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 or A. tumefaciens ATCC 15955, the number of bound pseudomonad cells decreased compared with those obtained in independent trials. Furthermore, the binding of A. tumefaciens cells was increased. In prebinding experiments, in which the potato disks were bound with the pseudomonads before exposure to the agrobacteria, the number of bound pseudomonad cells again decreased. This implies that increased desorption was occurring. In these prebinding studies, the numbers of bound A. tumefaciens ATCC 15955 increased, but the number of bound A. tumefaciens B6 remained the same. The mechanism for this observed synergism on the binding of agrobacterial cells and the depression in bound pseudomonad cells is believed to be alterations in the electrostatic or ionic charges on the plant and bacterial cell surfaces. The synergistic effect on A. tumefaciens undermines the use of these pseudomonads as potential biocontrol agents for crown gall.     

Variation in Binding and Virulence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Chromosomal Virulence (chv) Mutant Bacteria on Different Plant Species

Chromosomal virulence (chv) mutants of Agrobacterium tumefaciens have been reported to be deficient in binding to cells of zinnia, tobacco, and bamboo. The mutants are nonpathogenic on stems of Kalanchoë, sunflower, tomato, Jerusalem artichoke, and tobacco, but they cause tumors on tubers of Solanum tuberosum. We used a root cap cell binding assay to test ability of cells from individual plants of 13 different plant species to bind parent or chv mutant bacteria. The same plants were then inoculated to test for disease response. Cells from nine of the plant species were grossly deficient in their abilities to bind mutant bacteria, and the plants inoculated with mutant bacteria failed to form tumors. In contrast, root cap cells as well as root hairs and root surfaces of S. tuberosum, S. okadae, and S. hougasii bound chv mutant bacteria as well as wild type. Nevertheless, S. tuberosum roots inoculated with mutant bacteria did not develop tumors. Although S. okadae plants inoculated with mutant bacteria formed a few tumors, and S. hougasii developed as many tumors in response to chv mutants as in response to the parent strain, the tumors induced by mutant bacteria were smaller.     

Root Colonization by Agrobacterium tumefaciens Is Reduced in cel, attB, attD, and attR Mutants

Root colonization by Agrobacterium tumefaciens was measured by using tomato and Arabidopsis thaliana roots dipped in a bacterial suspension and planted in soil. Wild-type bacteria showed extensive growth on tomato roots; the number of bacteria increased from 10³ bacteria/cm of root length at the time of inoculation to more than 10⁷ bacteria/cm after 10 days. The numbers of cellulose-minus and nonattaching attB, attD, and attR mutant bacteria were less than 1/10,000th the number of wild-type bacteria recovered from tomato roots. On roots of A. thaliana ecotype Landsberg erecta, the numbers of wild-type bacteria increased from about 30 to 8,000 bacteria/cm of root length after 8 days. The numbers of cellulose-minus and nonattaching mutant bacteria were 1/100th to 1/10th the number of wild-type bacteria recovered after 8 days. The attachment of A. tumefaciens to cut A. thaliana roots incubated in 0.4% sucrose and observed with a light microscope was also reduced with cel and att mutants. These results suggest that cellulose synthesis and attachment genes play a role in the ability of the bacteria to colonize roots, as well as in bacterial pathogenesis.     

Genetic map of the crown gall suppressive IncW plasmid pSa

Summary A genetic map of the W incompatibility group plasmid pSa has been prepared through the construction of deletion derivatives of pSa and the cloning of various fragments of pSa in pBR322. Phenotypic analysis of these derivatives has identified the location of genes encoding resistance to chloramphenicol, sulfonamides, spectinomycin, streptomycin, kanamycin, gentamycin, and tobramycin. Information sufficient for the replication of the plasmid in both Escherichia coli and Agrobacterium tumefaciens is contained within a 4 kilobase pair region. Two regions have been identified as involved in the transfer of the plasmid; one of these regions is also involved in the inhibition of oncogenesis by pSa when it is present in an oncogenic strain of A. tumefaciens. Certain of the deletion derivatives of pSa are potential vectors for the cloning and analysis of A. tumefaciens Ti plasmid DNA.