The vacuolar transporter chaperone (VTC) complex is required for microautophagy

Microautophagy involves direct invagination and fission of the vacuolar/lysosomal membrane under nutrient limitation. This occurs by an autophagic tube, a specialized vacuolar membrane invagination that pinches off vesicles into the vacuolar lumen. In this study we have identified the VTC (vacuolar transporter chaperone) complex as required for microautophagy. The VTC complex is present on the ER and vacuoles and at the cell periphery. On induction of autophagy by nutrient limitation the VTC complex is recruited to and concentrated on vacuoles. The VTC complex is inhomogeneously distributed within the vacuolar membranes, showing an enrichment on autophagic tubes. Deletion of the VTC complex blocks microautophagic uptake into vacuoles. The mutants still form autophagic tubes but the production of microautophagic vesicles from their tips is impaired. In line with this, affinity-purified antibodies to the Vtc proteins inhibit microautophagic uptake in a reconstituted system in vitro. Our data suggest that the VTC complex is an important constituent of autophagic tubes and that it is required for scission of microautophagic vesicles from these tubes.     

Autophagic tubes: vacuolar invaginations involved in lateral membrane sorting and inverse vesicle budding

Many intracellular compartments of eukaryotic cells do not adopt a spherical shape, which would be expected in the absence of mechanisms organizing their structure. However, little is known about the principles determining the shape of organelles. We have observed very defined structural changes of vacuoles, the lysosome equivalents of yeast. The vacuolar membrane can form a large tubular invagination from which vesicles bud off into the lumen of the organelle. Formation of the tube is regulated via the Apg/Aut pathway. Its lumen is continuous with the cytosol, making this inverse budding reaction equivalent to microautophagocytosis. The tube is highly dynamic, often branched, and defined by a sharp kink of the vacuolar membrane at the site of invagination. The tube is formed by vacuoles in an autonomous fashion. It persists after vacuole isolation and, therefore, is independent of surrounding cytoskeleton. There is a striking lateral heterogeneity along the tube, with a high density of transmembrane particles at the base and a smooth zone devoid of transmembrane particles at the tip where budding occurs. We postulate a lateral sorting mechanism along the tube that mediates a depletion of large transmembrane proteins at the tip and results in the inverse budding of lipid-rich vesicles into the lumen of the organelle.     

Microautophagic vacuole invagination requires calmodulin in a Ca2+-independent function

Microautophagy is the uptake of cytosolic compounds by direct invagination of the vacuolar/lysosomal membrane. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae microautophagic uptake of soluble cytosolic proteins occurs via an autophagic tube, a highly specialized vacuolar membrane invagination. Autophagic tubes are topologically equivalent to the invaginations at multivesicular endosomes. At the tip of an autophagic tube, vesicles (autophagic bodies) pinch off into the vacuolar lumen for degradation. In this study we have identified calmodulin (Cmd1p) as necessary for microautophagy. Temperature-sensitive mutants for Cmd1p displayed reduced frequencies of vacuolar tube formation and/or abnormal tube morphologies. Microautophagic vacuole invagination was sensitive to Cmd1p antagonists as well as to antibodies to Cmd1p. cmd1 mutants with substitutions in the Ca2+-binding domains showed full invagination activity, and vacuolar membrane invagination was independent of the free Ca2+ concentration. Thus, rather than acting as a calcium-triggered switch, Cmd1p has a constitutive Ca2+-independent role in the formation of autophagic tubes. Kinetic analysis indicates that calmodulin is required for autophagic tube formation rather than for the final scission of vesicles from the tip of the tube.     

AUT3, a serine/threonine kinase gene, is essential for autophagocytosis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Autophagocytosis is a starvation-induced process, carrying proteins destined for degradation to the lysosome. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the autophagic process is visualized by the appearance of autophagic vesicles in the vacuoles of proteinase yscB-deficient strains during starvation. aut3-1 mutant cells which exhibit a block in the autophagic process have been isolated previously. By using the drastically reduced sporulation frequency of homozygous aut3-1 diploid cells, the AUT3 gene was cloned by complementation. The Aut3 protein consists of 897 amino acids. The amino-terminal part of the protein shows significant homologies to serine/threonine kinases. aut3 null mutant cells are fully viable on rich media but show a reduced survival rate upon starvation. They are unable to accumulate autophagic vesicles in the vacuole during starvation. Starvation-induced vacuolar protein breakdown is almost completely impaired in aut3-deficient cells. Vacuolar morphology and acidification are not influenced in aut3-deficient cells. Also, secretion of invertase, endocytic uptake of Lucifer Yellow, and vacuolar protein sorting appear wild type like in aut3-deficient cells, suggesting autophagocytosis as a novel route for the transport of proteins from the cytosol to the vacuole. By using a fusion of Aut3p with green-fluorescent protein, Aut3p was localized to the cytosol.     

Determination of four sequential stages during microautophagy in vitro

Microautophagy is the transfer of cytosolic components into the lysosome by direct invagination of the lysosomal membrane and subsequent budding of vesicles into the lysosomal lumen. This process is topologically equivalent to membrane invagination during multivesicular body formation and to the budding of enveloped viruses. Vacuoles are lysosomal compartments of yeasts. Vacuolar membrane invagination can be reconstituted in vitro with purified yeast vacuoles, serving as a model system for budding of vesicles into the lumen of an organelle. Using this in vitro system, we defined different reaction states. We identified inhibitors of microautophagy in vitro and used them as tools for kinetic analysis. This allowed us to characterize four biochemically distinguishable steps of the reaction. We propose that these correspond to sequential stages of vacuole invagination and vesicle scission. Formation of vacuolar invaginations was slow and temperature-dependent, whereas the final scission of the vesicle from a preformed invagination was fast and proceeded even on ice. Our observations suggest that the formation of invaginations rather than the scission of vesicles is the rate-limiting step of the overall reaction.     

Autophagosome closure requires membrane scission

During the intracellular process of macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy), a membrane-bound organelle, the autophagosome, is generated de novo. The remodeling of the autophagic membrane during the life cycle of the organelle is a complex multistep process and involves several changes in the topology of the autophagic membrane. Here, we focus on the final step of autophagosome formation, the closure of the phagophore, during which the inner and outer autophagic membranes become separate entities. We argue that this topological membrane transformation is a membrane scission event. Surprisingly, not a single recent review describes this substep as membrane scission (or membrane fission). In contrast, a number of publications imply that membrane fusion is involved. We discuss the potential sources for misinterpretation and recommend to consistent use of the unambiguous term “membrane scission.”     

Protein aggregates are transported to vacuoles by a macroautophagic mechanism in nutrient-starved plant cells

When a fusion protein of cytochrome b5 (Cyt b5) and the red fluorescent protein (RFP) are expressed in tobacco BY-2 cells, the expressed protein forms intracellular aggregates that emit red fluorescence. When such cells are grown to the stationary phase or incubated in nutrient limited medium, RFP fluorescence can be detected in the vacuolar lumen. We investigated this transport mechanism using a limited-nitrogen model. E-64 and 3-methyladenine, which inhibit autophagic processes, blocked the transport of the RFP signal to the vacuole. We next traced the autophagic process in tobacco cells using YFP fused with the tobacco Atg8 homologue (YFP-NtAtg8) and analyzed the contribution of autophagy to the vacuolar transport of the aggregates. Under limited-nitrogen conditions, the aggregates were degraded in preference to other organelles, and the autophagosomes colocalized with the aggregates at a higher frequency than with mitochondria. This is the first demonstration that selective macroautophagic degradation can occur in plant cells.     

Degradation and turnover of peroxisomes in the yeast Hansenula polymorpha induced by selective inactivation of peroxisomal enzymes

Inactivation of peroxisomal enzymes in the yeast Hansenula polymorpha was studied following transfer of cells into cultivation media in which their activity was no longer required for growth. After transfer of methanol-grown cells into media containing glucose - a substrate that fully represses alcohol oxidase synthesis - the rapid inactivation of alcohol oxidase and catalase was paralleled by a disappearance of alcohol oxidase and catalase protein. The rate and extent of this inactivation was dependent upon conditions of cultivation of cells prior to their transfer. This carbon catabolite inactivation of alcohol oxidase was paralleled by degradation of peroxisomes which occurred by means of an autophagic process that was initiated by the formation of a number of electron-dense membranes around the organelles to be degraded. Sequestration was confined to peroxisomes; other cell-components such as ribosomes were absent in the sequestered cell compartment. Also, cytochemically, hydrolytic enzymes could not be demonstrated in these autophagosomes. The vacuole played a major role in the subsequent peroxisomal breakdown since it provided the enzymes required for proteolysis. Two basically similar mechanisms were observed with respect to the administration of vacuolar enzymes into the sequestered cell compartment. The first mechanism involved incorporation of a small vacuolar vesicle into the sequestered cell compartment. The delimiting membrane of this vacuolar vesicle subsequently disrupted, thereby exposing the contents of the sequestered cell compartment to vacuolar hydrolases which then degraded the peroxisomal proteins. The second mechanism, observed in cells which already contained one or more autophagic vacuoles, included fusion of the delimiting membranes of an autophagosome with the membrane surrounding an autophagic vacuole which led to migration of the peroxisome inside the latter organelle. Peroxisomes of methanol-grown H. polymorpha were degraded individually. In one cell 2 or 3 peroxisomes might be subject to degradation at the same time, but they were never observed together in one autophagosome. However, fusions of autophagic vacuoles in one cell were frequently observed. After inhibition of the cell's energy-metabolism by cyanide ions or during anaerobic incubations the formation of autophagosomes was prevented and degradation was not observed.     

Protein Aggregates are Transported to Vacuoles by Macroautophagic Mechanism in Nutrient-Starved Plant Cells

When a fusion protein of cytochrome b5 (Cyt b5) and the red fluorescent protein (RFP) are expressed in tobacco BY-2 cells, the expressed protein forms intracellular aggregates that emit red fluorescence. When such cells are grown to the stationary phase or incubated with nutrient limit medium, RFP fluorescence can be detected in the vacuolar lumen. We investigated this transport mechanism using a limited-nitrogen model. E-64 and 3-methyladenine, which inhibit authophagic processes, inhibited the transport of RFP signal to the vacuole. We next traced the autophagic process in tobacco cells using YFP fused with the tobacco Atg8 homologue (YFP–NtAtg8) and analyzed the contribution of autophagy to the vacuolar transport of the aggregates. Under limited-nitrogen conditions, the aggregates were degraded in preference to otherorganelles, and the autophagosomes colocalized with the aggregates at a higher frequency than with mitochondria. This is the first demonstration that selective macroautophagic degradation occurs in plant cells.     

The dynamic changes of tonoplasts in guard cells are important for stomatal movement in Vicia faba

Stomatal movement is important for plants to exchange gas with environment. The regulation of stomatal movement allows optimizing photosynthesis and transpiration. Changes in vacuolar volume in guard cells are known to participate in this regulation. However, little has been known about the mechanism underlying the regulation of rapid changes in guard cell vacuolar volume. Here, we report that dynamic changes in the complex vacuolar membrane system play a role in the rapid changes of vacuolar volume in Vicia faba guard cells. The guard cells contained a great number of small vacuoles and various vacuolar membrane structures when stomata closed. The small vacuoles and complex membrane systems fused with each other or with the bigger vacuoles to generate large vacuoles during stomatal opening. Conversely, the large vacuoles split into smaller vacuoles and generated many complex membrane structures in the closing stomata. Vacuole fusion inhibitor, (2s,3s)-trans-epoxy-succinyl-l-leucylamido-3-methylbutane ethyl ester, inhibited stomatal opening significantly. Furthermore, an Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) mutation of the SGR3 gene, which has a defect in vacuolar fusion, also led to retardation of stomatal opening. All these results suggest that the dynamic changes of the tonoplast are essential for enhancing stomatal movement.     

A life-span extending form of autophagy employs the vacuole-vacuole fusion machinery

While autophagy is believed to be beneficial for life-span extension, it is controversial which forms or aspects of autophagy are responsible for this effect. We addressed this topic by analyzing the life span of yeast autophagy mutants under caloric restriction, a longevity manipulation. Surprisingly, we discovered that the majority of proteins involved in macroautophagy and several forms of microautophagy were dispensable for life-span extension. The only autophagy protein that is critical for life-span extension was Atg15, a lipase that is located in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and transported to vacuoles for disintegrating membranes of autophagic bodies. We further found that vacuole-vacuole fusion was required for life-span extension, which was indicated by the shortened life span of mutants missing proteins (ypt7Delta, nyv1Delta, vac8Delta) or lipids (erg6Delta) involved in fusion. Since a known function of vacuole-vacuole fusion is the maintenance of the vacuole membrane integrity, we analyzed aged vacuoles and discovered that aged cells had altered vacuolar morphology and accumulated autophagic bodies, suggesting that certain forms of autophagy do contribute to longevity. Like aged cells, erg6Delta accumulated autophagic bodies, which is likely caused by a defect in lipase instead of proteases due to the existence of multiple vacuolar proteases. Since macroautophagy is not blocked by erg6Delta, we propose that a new form of autophagy transports Atg15 via the fusion of vacuoles with vesicles derived from ER, and we designate this putative form of autophagy as secretophagy. Pending future biochemical studies, the concept of secretophagy may provide a mechanism for autophagy in life-span extension.     

A fluorescent reporter protein containing AtRMR1 domains is targeted to the storage and central vacuoles in Arabidopsis thaliana and tobacco leaf cells

To develop a new strategy to target recombinant proteins to the vacuolar storage system in transgenic plants, the ability of the transmembrane and cytosolic domains of Arabidopsis receptor homology-transmembrane-RING H2-1 (AtRMR1) was evaluated. A secreted version of RFP (secRFP) and a fusion of it to the transmembrane and cytosolic domains of AtRMR1 (RFP-TMCT) were produced and studied both in transient and stable expression assays. Transient expression in leaves of Nicotiana tabacum showed that secRFP is secreted to the apoplast while its fusion to TMCT of AtRMR1 is sufficient to prevent secretion of the reporter. In tobacco leaves, RFP-TMCT reporter showed an endoplasmic reticulum pattern in early expression stages while in late expression stages, it was found in the vacuolar lumen. For the first time, the role of TM and CT domains of AtRMR1 in stable expression in Arabidopsis thaliana is presented; the fusion of TMCT to secRFP is sufficient to sort RFP to the lumen of the central vacuoles in leaves and roots and to the lumen of PSV in cotyledons of mature embryos. In addition, biochemical studies performed in extract from transgenic plants showed that RFP-TMCT is an integral membrane protein. Full-length RFP-TMCT was also found in the vacuolar lumen, suggesting internalization into destination vacuole. Not colocalization of RFP-TMCT with tonoplast and plasma membrane markers were observed. This membrane vacuolar determinant sorting signal could be used for future application in molecular pharming as an alternative means to sort proteins of interest to vacuoles.     

Aut7p, a soluble autophagic factor, participates in multiple membrane trafficking processes

Aut7p, a protein recently implicated in autophagic events in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, exhibits significant homology to a mammalian protein, p16, herein termed GATE-16 (Golgi-associated ATPase Enhancer of 16 kDa), a novel intra-Golgi transport factor. Here we provide evidence for the involvement of Aut7p in different membrane trafficking processes. Aut7p largely substitutes for the activity of GATE-16 in mammalian intra-Golgi transport in vitro. In vivo, AUT7 interacts genetically with endoplasmic reticulum to Golgi SNAREs, specifically with BET1 and SEC22. Aut7p interacts physically with the following two v-SNAREs: Bet1p, which is involved in endoplasmic reticulum to Golgi vesicular transport, and Nyv1p, implicated in vacuolar inheritance. We suggest that, in addition to its role in autophagocytosis, Aut7p has pleiotropic effects and participates in at least two membrane traffic events.     

Autophagy-related vacuoles in mouse gallbladder epithelium

The mouse gallbladder epithelial cells contain very heterogeneous vacuolar population. In an attempt to classify these vacuoles we identified NADPase and TPPase activity as well as the location of HRP which is used as the endocytotic marker. The results of the present study show that the vacuoles can be classified into three categories: (1) the vacuoles predominantly containing loose membrane coils related to the nascent autophagic vacuoles, (2) vacuoles containing densely packed membranes and exhibiting a positive HRP reaction, indicating the convergence of endocytotic and autophagic pathway, and (3) vacuoles composed of degraded membrane structures and containing the reaction product of NADPase activity, showing that the fusion of the lysosomes with the autophagosome-endosome took place. The highly developed cis, medial and trans Golgi compartments reflect the biosynthetic and endocytotic activity of the gallbladder epithelium.     

A sorting nexin PpAtg24 regulates vacuolar membrane dynamics during pexophagy via binding to phosphatidylinositol-3-phosphate

Diverse cellular processes such as autophagic protein degradation require phosphoinositide signaling in eukaryotic cells. In the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris, peroxisomes can be selectively degraded via two types of pexophagic pathways, macropexophagy and micropexophagy. Both involve membrane fusion events at the vacuolar surface that are characterized by internalization of the boundary domain of the fusion complex, indicating that fusion occurs at the vertex. Here, we show that PpAtg24, a molecule with a phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate-binding module (PX domain) that is indispensable for pexophagy, functions in membrane fusion at the vacuolar surface. CFP-tagged PpAtg24 localized to the vertex and boundary region of the pexophagosome-vacuole fusion complex during macropexophagy. Depletion of PpAtg24 resulted in the blockage of macropexophagy after pexophagosome formation and before the fusion stage. These and other results suggest that PpAtg24 is involved in the spatiotemporal regulation of membrane fusion at the vacuolar surface during pexophagy via binding to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate, rather than the previously suggested function in formation of the pexophagosome.     

Role of Vac8 in formation of the vacuolar sequestering membrane during micropexophagy

Vac8 is a yeast vacuolar membrane protein involved in vacuolar membrane dynamics, e.g., vacuole inheritance and vacuolar membrane fusion. This protein is also necessary for a subset of autophagic pathways that deliver specific cellular components to the vacuole. In this study, we show that the micropexohagy and vacuole inheritance required distinct domain structures of Pichia pastoris Vac8 (PpVac8). Whereas vacuole inheritance required the Armadillo repeat (ARM) region that resides in the middle part of the protein, micropexophagy did not. Deletion of both the ARM and C-terminal domains inhibited a characteristic of vacuolar dynamics during micropexophagy, i.e., formation of the vacuolar sequestering membrane (VSM). Subsequent analyses indicated that PpVAC8 disruption abolished recruitment of PpAtg11, another protein required for formation of the VSM, to the vacuolar membrane. These results present a novel molecular function of PpVac8 in micropexophagy.     

Role of Vac8 in Formation of the Vacuolar Sequestering Membrane during Micropexophagy

Vac8 is a yeast vacuolar membrane protein involved in vacuolar membrane dynamics, e.g., vacuole inheritance and vacuolar membrane fusion. This protein is also necessary for a subset of autophagic pathways that deliver specific cellular components to the vacuole. In this study, we show that the micropexohagy and vacuole inheritance required distinct domain structures of Pichia pastoris Vac8 (PpVac8). Whereas vacuole inheritance required the Armadillo repeat (ARM) region that resides in the middle part of the protein, micropexophagy did not. Deletion of both the ARM and C-terminal domains inhibited a characteristic of vacuolar dynamics during micropexophagy, i.e., formation of the vacuolar sequestering membrane (VSM). Subsequent analyses indicated that PpVAC8 disruption abolished recruitment of PpAtg11, another protein required for formation of the VSM, to the vacuolar membrane. These results present a novel molecular function of PpVac8 in micropexophagy.     

V-ATPase engagement in autophagic processes

The proton pumping activity of V-ATPase is responsible for acidification of the lysosome/vacuole. The low lumenal pH of this organelle stimulates the activity of a battery of resident hydrolases responsible for the degradation of various nonselective and selective cargos delivered by autophagic processes. However, the role of V-ATPase in membrane dynamics required for the uptake of autophagic cargo is far from fully understood. Consideration of the available data leads us to speculate that autophagic processes involving direct membrane-to-membrane contacts between the selected cargo and the vacuolar membrane require functional V-ATPase.     

V-ATPase engagement in autophagic processes

The proton pumping activity of V-ATPase is responsible for acidification of the lysosome/vacuole. The low lumenal pH of this organelle stimulates the activity of a battery of resident hydrolases responsible for the degradation of various nonselective and selective cargos delivered by autophagic processes. However, the role of V-ATPase in membrane dynamics required for the uptake of autophagic cargo is far from fully understood. Consideration of the available data leads us to speculate that autophagic processes involving direct membrane-to-membrane contacts between the selected cargo and the vacuolar membrane require functional V-ATPase.     

A lifespan-extending form of autophagy employs the vacuole-vacuole fusion machinery

While autophagy is believed to be beneficial for lifespan extension, it is controversial which forms or aspects of autophagy are the responsible ones. We addressed this by analyzing the lifespan of yeast autophagy mutants under caloric restriction, a longevity manipulation. Surprisingly, we discovered that the majority of proteins involved in macro-autophagy and several forms of micro-autophagy were dispensable for lifespan extension. The only autophagy protein that is critical for lifespan extension was Atg15p, a lipase that is located in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and transported to vacuoles for disintegrating membranes of autophagic bodies. We further found that vacuole-vacuole fusion was required for lifespan extension, which was indicated by the shortened lifespan of mutants missing proteins (ypt7Δ, nyv1Δ, vac8Δ) or lipids (erg6Δ) involved in fusion. Since a known function of vacuole-vacuole fusion is the maintenance of the vacuole membrane integrity, we analyzed aged vacuoles and discovered that aged cells had altered vacuolar morphology and accumulated autophagic bodies, suggesting that certain forms of autophagy do contribute to longevity. Like aged cells, erg6Δ accumulated autophagic bodies, which is likely caused by a defect in lipase instead of proteases due to the existence of multiple vacuolar proteases. Since macro-autophagy is not blocked by erg6Δ, we propose that a new form of autophagy transports Atg15p via the fusion of vacuoles with vesicles derived from ER, and we designate this putative form of autophagy as secretophagy. Pending future biochemical studies, the concept of secretophagy may provide a mechanism for autophagy in lifespan extension.