Uncovering the Post-embryonic Role of Embryo Essential Genes in Arabidopsis using the Controlled Induction of Visibly Marked Genetic Mosaics: EMB506, an Illustration

The embryo essential gene EMB506 plays a crucial role in the transition of the Arabidopsis embryo from radial symmetry to bilateral symmetry just prior to the early heart stage of development. In addition to influencing embryo development EMB506 also affects chloroplast biogenesis. To further investigate the role of EMB506 gene expression in Arabidopsis we have generated green fluorescent protein (GFP) marked emb506 mosaic sectors at temporally defined stages during embryogenesis and additionally during various stages of vegetative growth, in otherwise phenotypically wild-type plants. We confirm the essential requirement for EMB506 gene expression in chloroplast biogenesis as reflected by the decreased chlorophyll content in emb506 mosaic sectors. We also show that the influence of EMB506 gene expression as it impinges on chloroplast biogenesis is first relevant at an intermediate stage in embryogenesis and that the role of EMB506 gene expression in chloroplast biogenesis is distinct from the essential role of EMB506 gene expression during early embryo development. By inducing emb506 mosaicism after the essential requirement for EMB506 gene expression in embryogenesis and also during vegetative growth we reveal that EMB506 gene expression additionally is required for correct cotyledon-, true leaf- and cauline leaf margin development. The strategy that we describe can be tailored to the mosaic analysis of any cloned EMB gene for which a corresponding mutant exists and can be applied to the mosaic analysis of mutant lethal genes in general.     

Embryo defective 14 encodes a plastid‐targeted cGTPase essential for embryogenesis in maize

The embryo defective (emb) mutants in maize genetically define a unique class of loci that is required for embryogenesis but not endosperm development, allowing dissection of two developmental processes of seed formation. Through characterization of the emb14 mutant, we report here that Emb14 gene encodes a circular permuted, YqeH class GTPase protein that likely functions in 30S ribosome formation in plastids. Loss of Emb14 function in the null mutant arrests embryogenesis at the early transition stage. Emb14 was cloned by transposon tagging and was confirmed by analysis of four alleles. Subcellular localization indicated that the EMB14 is targeted to chloroplasts. Recombinant EMB14 is shown to hydrolyze GTP in vitro (K_m = 2.42 ± 0.3 μm ). Emb14 was constitutively expressed in all tissues examined and high level of expression was found in transition stage embryos. Comparison of emb14 and WT indicated that loss of EMB14 function severely impairs accumulation of 16S rRNA and several plastid encoded ribosomal genes. We show that an EMB14 transgene complements the pale green, slow growth phenotype conditioned by mutations in AtNOA1, a closely related YqeH GTPase of Arabidopsis. Taken together, we propose that the EMB14/AtNOA1/YqeH class GTPases function in assembly of the 30S subunit of the chloroplast ribosome, and that this function is essential to embryogenesis in plants.     

Partial complementation of embryo defective mutations: a general strategy to elucidate gene function

The EMB 506 gene has been characterised as essential for embryo development. To provide insights into the role of EMB 506, which is hidden by the embryo defective phenotype, the ABI3 promoter was fused to the EMB 506 cDNA. The expression of such a transgene should provide sufficient protein during embryogenesis to ensure normal embryo development in homozygous emb 506 seeds. We show that homozygous emb 506 seedlings, partially complemented with the ABI3::EMB 506 transgene, can be obtained. Most of the rescued emb 506 plants are able to flower and to set normal seeds, but show mild to severe depigmentation of rosette leaves and/or inflorescences. This effect on chloroplast development indicated a putative chloroplast localisation of the EMB 506 protein, which was demonstrated by GFP-protein fusion. However, EMB 506 cannot be considered as a chloroplast housekeeping protein only, since EMB 506 is not present in all photosynthetic tissues. This study demonstrates the power of this simple strategy, which could be widely applied to other emb mutants and which may reveal similar or additional roles for EMB genes at vegetative stages of the life cycle.     

Embryo defective12 encodes the plastid initiation factor 3 and is essential for embryogenesis in maize

Embryo‐specific mutants in maize define a unique class of genetic loci that affect embryogenesis without a significant deleterious impact on endosperm development. Here we report the characterization of an embryo specific12 (emb12) mutant in maize. Embryogenesis in the emb12 mutants is arrested at or before transition stage. The mutant embryo at an early stage exhibits abnormal cell structure with increased vacuoles and dramatically reduced internal membrane organelles. In contrast, the mutant endosperm appears normal in morphology, cell structure, starch, lipid and protein accumulation. The Emb12 locus was cloned by transposon tagging and predicts a protein with a high similarity to prokaryotic translation initiation factor 3 (IF3). EMB12–GFP fusion analysis indicates that EMB12 is localized in plastids. The RNA in situ hybridization and protein immunohistochemical analyses indicate that a high level of Emb12 expression localizes in the embryo proper at early developmental stages and in the embryo axis at later stages. Western analysis indicates that plastid protein synthesis is impaired. These results indicate that Emb12 encodes the plastid IF3 which is essential for embryogenesis but not for endosperm development in maize.     

The chloroplastic DEVH‐box RNA helicase INCREASED SIZE EXCLUSION LIMIT 2 involved in plasmodesmata regulation is required for group II intron splicing

INCREASED SIZE EXCLUSION LIMIT 2 (ISE2) encodes a putative DEVH‐box RNA helicase originally identified through a genetic screening for Arabidopsis mutants altered in plasmodesmata (PD) aperture. Depletion of ISE2 also affects chloroplasts activity, decreases accumulation of photosynthetic pigments and alters expression of photosynthetic genes. In this work, we show the chloroplast localization of ISE2 and decipher its role in plastidic RNA processing and, consequently, PD function. Group II intron‐containing RNAs from chloroplasts exhibit defective splicing in ise2 mutants and ISE2‐silenced plants, compromising plastid viability. Furthermore, RNA immunoprecipitation suggests that ISE2 binds in vivo to several splicing‐regulated RNAs. Finally, we show that the chloroplast clpr2 mutant (defective in a subunit of a plastidic Clp protease) also exhibits abnormal PD function during embryogenesis, supporting the idea that chloroplast RNA processing is required to regulate cell–cell communication in plants.     

The chloroplast ribosomal protein L21 gene is essential for plastid development and embryogenesis in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis>

Embryogenesis in higher plants is controlled by a complex gene network. Identification and characterization of genes essential for embryogenesis will provide insights into the early events in embryo development. In this study, a novel mutant with aborted seed development (asd) was identified in Arabidopsis. The asd mutant produced about 25% of albino seeds at the early stage of silique development. The segregation of normal and albino seeds was inherited as a single recessive embryo-lethal trait. The gene disrupted in the asd mutant was isolated through map-based cloning. The mutated gene contains a single base change (A to C) in the coding region of RPL21C (At1g35680) that is predicted to encode the chloroplast 50S ribosomal protein L21. Allele test with other two T-DNA insertion lines in RPL21C and a complementation test demonstrated that the mutation in RPL21C was responsible for the asd phenotype. RPL21C exhibits higher expression in leaves and flowers compared with expression levels in roots and developing seeds. The RPL21C–GFP fusion protein was localized in chloroplasts. Cytological observations showed that the asd embryo development was arrested at the globular stage. There were no plastids with normal thylakoids and as a result no normal chloroplasts formed in mutant cells, indicating an indispensable role of the ASD gene in chloroplasts biogenesis. Our studies suggest that the chloroplast ribosomal protein L21 gene is required for chloroplast development and embryogenesis in Arabidopsis.     

In vitro morphogenesis of arrested embryos from lethal mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana

Summary Arrested embryos from lethal (emb) mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana were rescued on a nutrient medium designed to promote plant regeneration from immature wild-type cotyledons. The best response was observed with mutant embryos arrested at the heart to cotyledon stages of development. Embryos arrested at a globular stage produced callus but failed to turn green or form normal shoots in culture. Many of the mutant plants produced in culture were unusually pale with abnormal leaves, rosettes, and patterns of reproductive development. Other plants were phenotypically normal except for the presence of siliques containing 100% aborted seeds following self-pollination. These results demonstrate that genes with essential functions during plant embryo development differ in their pattern of expression at later stages of the life cycle. Most of the 15 genes examined in this study were essential for embryogenesis but were required again for subsequent stages of development. Only EMB24 appeared to be limited in function to embryo development. These differences in the response of mutant embryos in culture may facilitate the classification of embryonic lethals and the identification of genes with developmental rather than housekeeping functions.     

Chloroplast‐targeted Hsp90 plays essential roles in plastid development and embryogenesis in Arabidopsis possibly linking with VIPP1

The Arabidopsis genome contains seven members of Hsp90. Mutations in plastid AtHsp90.5 were reported to cause defects in chloroplast development and embryogenesis. However, the exact function of plastid AtHsp90.5 has not yet been defined. In this study, albino seedlings were found among AtHsp90.5 transformed Arabidopsis, which were revealed to be AtHsp90.5 co‐suppressed plants. The accumulation of photosynthetic super‐complexes in the albinos was decreased, and expression of genes involved in photosynthesis was significantly down‐regulated. AtHsp90.5 T‐DNA insertion mutants were embryo‐lethal with embryo arrested at the heart stage. Further investigation showed AtHsp90.5 expression was up‐regulated in the siliques at 4 days post anthesis (DPA). Confocal microscopy proved AtHsp90.5 was located in the chloroplasts. Plastid development in the AtHsp90.5 mutants and co‐suppressed plants was seriously impaired, and few thylakoid membranes were observed, indicating the involvement of AtHsp90.5 in chloroplast biogenesis. AtHsp90.5 was found to interact with vesicle‐inducing protein in plastids 1 (VIPP1) by bimolecular fluorescence complementation system. The ratio between VIPP1 oligomers and monomers in AtHsp90.5 co‐suppressed plants drastically shifted toward the oligomeric state. Our study confirmed that AtHsp90.5 is vital for chloroplast biogenesis and embryogenesis. Further evidence also suggested that AtHsp90.5 may help in the disassembly of VIPP1 for thylakoid membrane formation and/or maintenance.     

Variegation mutants and mechanisms of chloroplast biogenesis

Variegated plants typically have green‐ and white‐sectored leaves. Cells in the green sectors contain normal‐appearing chloroplasts, whereas cells in the white sectors lack pigments and appear to be blocked at various stages of chloroplast biogenesis. Variegations can be caused by mutations in nuclear, chloroplast or mitochondrial genes. In some plants, the green and white sectors have different genotypes, but in others they have the same (mutant) genotype. One advantage of variegations is that they provide a means of studying genes for proteins that are important for chloroplast development, but for which mutant analysis is difficult, either because mutations in a gene of interest are lethal or because they do not show a readily distinguishable phenotype. This paper focuses on Arabidopsis variegations, for which the most information is available at the molecular level. Perhaps the most interesting of these are variegations caused by defective nuclear gene products in which the cells of the mutant have a uniform genotype. Two questions are of paramount interest: (1) What is the gene product and how does it function in chloroplast biogenesis? (2) What is the mechanism of variegation and why do green sectors arise in plants with a uniform (mutant) genotype? Two paradigms of variegation mechanism are described: immutans (im) and variegated2 (var2). Both mechanisms emphasize compensating activities and the notion of plastid autonomy, but redundant gene products are proposed to play a role in var2, but not in im. It is hypothesized that threshold levels of certain activities are necessary for normal chloroplast development.     

Arabidopsis thaliana Atrab28: a nuclear targeted protein related to germination and toxic cation tolerance

The Arabidopsis gene Atrab28 has been shown to be expressed during late embryogenesis. The pattern of expression of Atrab28 mRNA and protein during embryo development is largely restricted to provascular tissues of mature embryos, and in contrast to the maize Rab28 homologue it cannot be induced by ABA and dehydration in vegetative tissues.Here, we have studied the subcellular location of Atrab28 protein and the effect of its over-expression in transgenic Arabidopsis plants. The Atrab28 protein was mainly detected in the nucleus and nucleolus of cells from mature embryos. In frame fusion of Atrab28 to the reporter green fluorescent protein (GFP) directed the GFP to the nucleus in transgenic Arabidopsis and in transiently transformed onion cells. Analysis of chimeric constructs identified an N-terminal region of 60 amino acids containing a five amino acid motif QPKRP that was necessary for targeting GFP to the nucleus. These results indicate that Atrab28 protein is targeted to the nuclear compartments by a new nuclear localization signal (NLS). Transgenic Arabidopsis plants, with gain of Atrab28 function, showed faster germination rates under either standard or salt and osmotic stress conditions. Moreover, improved cation toxicity tolerance was also observed not only during germination but also in seedlings. These results suggest a role of Atrab28 in the ion cell balance during late embryogenesis and germination.     

The Requirement of WHIRLY1 for Embryogenesis Is Dependent on Genetic Background in Maize

Plastid gene expression is essential to embryogenesis in higher plants, but the underlying mechanism is obscure. Through molecular characterization of an embryo defective 16 (emb16) locus, here we report that the requirement of plastid translation for embryogenesis is dependent on the genetic background in maize (Zea mays). The emb16 mutation arrests embryogenesis at transition stage and allows the endosperm to develop largely normally. Molecular cloning reveals that Emb16 encodes WHIRLY1 (WHY1), a DNA/RNA binding protein that is required for genome stability and ribosome formation in plastids. Interestingly, the previous why1 mutant alleles (why1-1 and why1-2) do not affect embryogenesis, only conditions albino seedlings. The emb16 allele of why1 mutation is in the W22 genetic background. Crosses between emb16 and why1-1 heterozygotes resulted in both defective embryos and albino seedlings in the F1 progeny. Introgression of the emb16 allele from W22 into A188, B73, Mo17, Oh51a and the why1-1 genetic backgrounds yielded both defective embryos and albino seedlings. Similar results were obtained with two other emb mutants (emb12 and emb14) that are impaired in plastid protein translation process. These results indicate that the requirement of plastid translation for embryogenesis is dependent on genetic backgrounds, implying a mechanism of embryo lethality suppression in maize.     

ULTRASTRUCTURE OF ARRESTED EMBRYOS FROM LETHAL MUTANTS OF ARABIDOPSIS THALIANA

The purpose of this study was to examine the extent of cellular differentiation in arrested embryos from lethal mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana. The question to be addressed was whether arrested embryos in heterozygous siliques resembled mature wild-type embryos at the cellular level. Protein bodies were chosen as developmental markers because they appear only during the final stages of embryogenesis. Both the hypocotyl and cotyledons of wild-type embryos contained protein bodies that became filled with storage protein during the cotyledonary stages of development. Some mutant embryos (emb30) contained normal protein bodies and resembled mature wild-type embryos at the cellular level. Other mutant embryos (emb22) contained only immature protein bodies and were therefore blocked in both morphogenesis and cellular differentiation. The formation of protein bodies in emb31 was normal in the hypocotyl but delayed in the cotyledons. In this case the mutant gene appears to disrupt the timing of both morphogenesis and differentiation. This ultrastructural view of arrested embryos has provided additional information on the nature of developmental arrest that should facilitate the classification of embryonic lethals and the identification of mutants with defects in developmental rather than housekeeping functions.     

Emb15 encodes a plastid ribosomal assembly factor essential for embryogenesis in maize

Ribosome assembly factors guide the complex process by which ribosomal proteins and the ribosomal RNAs form a functional ribosome. However, the assembly of plant plastid ribosomes is poorly understood. In the present study, we discovered a maize (Zea mays) plastid ribosome assembly factor based on our characterization of the embryo defective 15 (emb15) mutant. Loss of function of Emb15 retards embryo development at an early stage, but does not substantially affect the endosperm, and causes an albino phenotype in other genetic backgrounds. EMB15 localizes to plastids and possesses a ribosome maturation factor M (RimM) domain in the N-terminus and a predicted UDP-GlcNAc pyrophosphorylase domain in the C-terminus. The EMB15 RimM domain originated in bacteria and the UDP-GlcNAc pyrophosphorylase domain originated in fungi; these two domains came together in the ancestor of land plants during evolution. The N-terminus of EMB15 complemented the growth defect of an Escherichia coli strain with a RimM deletion and rescued the albino phenotype of emb15 homozygous mutants. The RimM domain mediates the interaction between EMB15 and the plastid ribosomal protein PRPS19. Plastid 16S rRNA maturation is also significantly impaired in emb15. These observations suggest that EMB15 functions in maize seed development as a plastid ribosome assembly factor, and the C-terminal domain is not important under normal conditions.     

The Arabidopsis APC4 subunit of the anaphase-promoting complex/cyclosome (APC/C) is critical for both female gametogenesis and embryogenesis

The anaphase‐promoting complex/cyclosome (APC/C) is an E3 ubiquitin ligase that is involved in regulating cell‐cycle progression. It has been widely studied in yeast and animal cells, but the function and regulation of the APC/C in plant cells are largely unknown. The Arabidopsis APC/C comprises at least 11 subunits, only a few of which have been studied in detail. APC4 is proposed to be a connector in the APC/C in yeast and animals. Here, we report the functional characterization of the Arabidopsis APC4 protein. We examined three heterozygous plant lines carrying apc4 alleles. These plants showed pleiotropic developmental defects in reproductive processes, including abnormal nuclear behavior in the developing embryo sac and aberrant cell division in embryos; these phenotypes differ from those reported for mutants of other subunits. Some ovules and embryos of apc4/+ plants also accumulated cyclin B protein, a known substrate of APC/C, suggesting a compromised function of APC/C. Arabidopsis APC4 was expressed in meristematic cells of seedlings, ovules in pistils and embryos in siliques, and was mainly localized in the nucleus. Additionally, the distribution of auxin was distorted in some embryos of apc4/+ plants. Our results indicate that Arabidopsis APC4 plays critical roles in female gametogenesis and embryogenesis, possibly as a connector in APC/C, and that regulation of auxin distribution may be involved in these processes.     

FtsHi1/ARC1 is an essential gene in Arabidopsis that links chloroplast biogenesis and division

The Arabidopsis arc1 (accumulation and replication of chloroplasts 1) mutant has pale seedlings and smaller, more numerous chloroplasts than the wild type. Previous work has suggested that arc1 affects the timing of chloroplast division but does not function directly in the division process. We isolated ARC1 by map‐based cloning and discovered it encodes FtsHi1 (At4g23940), one of several FtsHi proteins in Arabidopsis. These poorly studied proteins resemble FtsH metalloproteases important for organelle biogenesis and protein quality control but are presumed to be proteolytically inactive. FtsHi1 bears a predicted chloroplast transit peptide and localizes to the chloroplast envelope membrane. Phenotypic studies showed that arc1 (hereafter ftsHi1‐1), which bears a missense mutation, is a weak allele of FtsHi1 that disrupts thylakoid development and reduces de‐etiolation efficiency in seedlings, suggesting that FtsHi1 is important for chloroplast biogenesis. Consistent with this finding, transgenic plants suppressed for accumulation of an FtsHi1 fusion protein were often variegated. A strong T‐DNA insertion allele, ftsHi1‐2, caused embryo‐lethality, indicating that FtsHi1 is an essential gene product. A wild‐type FtsHi1 transgene rescued both the chloroplast division and pale phenotypes of ftsHi1‐1 and the embryo‐lethal phenotype of ftsHi1‐2. FtsHi1 overexpression produced a subtle increase in chloroplast size and decrease in chloroplast number in wild‐type plants while suppression led to increased numbers of small chloroplasts, providing new evidence that FtsHi1 negatively influences chloroplast division. Taken together, our analyses reveal that FtsHi1 functions in an essential, envelope‐associated process that may couple plastid development with division.     

The EMB 506 gene encodes a novel ankyrin repeat containing protein that is essential for the normal development of Arabidopsis embryos

The EMB 506 gene of Arabidopsis, required for the normal development of the embryo beyond the globular stage, has been cloned. The gene encodes a protein of predicted size 35 kDa that contains five ankyrin (ANK) repeats within the C terminal moiety. ANK repeats are conserved domains of 33 amino acids involved in specific recognition of protein partners. The EMB 506 protein was detected at different stages of silique development but accumulated preferentially in the mature cauline leaves. The rescue of homozygous emb 506 embryos by complementation with the wild-type sequence cDNA demonstrated that the emb mutation is a consequence of the T-DNA insertion and that integration and expression of the transgene occurred during gametogenesis and/or early embryo development. In addition to the drastic effect of the emb 506 mutation during embryo development, complementation experiments revealed another effect of the gene: emb 506 plants transformed with the wild-type EMB 506 sequence were able to produce viable seeds but showed a reduction of apical dominance and the presence of adventitious buds or bracts along the stem. This result supports the idea that genes essential for embryogenesis may also be required at other stages of the plant life cycle.     

Late embryo-defective mutants of Arabidopsis

The embryo-defective (emb) mutants of Arabidopsis constitute a large and diverse group of mutants disrupted in a broad range of embryonic processes, including morphogonesis, cell differentiation, and maturation programs. This report describes a subset of these mutants, the late embryo defectives, which develop beyond the globular stage of embryogenesis but fail to complete normal morphogenesis. A representative sample of 12 late mutants was chosen for this study, patterns of morphogenesis were characterized, the germination potential of mutant seeds was investigated, and additional mutant alleles within the collection were identified. Morphological defects in mutant embryos became apparent during the heart stage of development, when embryos normally begin the rapid cell division and expansion required for the completion of morphogenesis. Despite their morphological abnormalities, mutant embryos often germinated from dry seed, demonstrating that genetic programs required for the establishment of desiccation tolerance remained intact. Mutant seedlings displayed a wide range of developmental abnormalities, including altered morphology, lack of pigmentation, dwarfism, and disorganized vegetative growth. One late mutant was found to be allelic to an early embryo defective that arrests at the globular stage. These results suggest that a number of late EMB genes encode basic cellular and metabolic functions needed for cell division, enlargement, and embryonic growth. The rapid growth and metabolic changes that occur at the heart stage may present a barrier to normal development in the late mutants, resulting in altered embryo morphology and other developmental defects. It is proposed that many Arabidopsis mutants with abnormal embryo and seedling morphology are not defective in the regulation of pattern formation or morphogenesis, but rather in fundamental physiological and cellular processes required for the completion of normal growth and development. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.