Cartilage is a metazoan tissue; integrating data from nonvertebrate sources

Connective tissues are responsible for much of the variation in morphology that we see today. Cartilage is a type of connective tissue that is often considered to be restricted to vertebrates, however, cartilaginous tissues are also found within invertebrates. Unfortunately, most definitions and classification schemes for cartilages suffer from a strong vertebrate bias, severely hampering the efforts of those who have attempted to include invertebrate tissues as cartilage. To encompass all types of cartilage, current classification systems need to be expanded. Here we present vesicular cell‐rich as a new cartilage classification. Invertebrate cartilages, comparable to vertebrate cartilages at both cell and tissue levels, are composed of similar molecules, yet the extent to which they may be homologous is unknown. One option for studying the evolution of tissues is to adopt molecular phylogenetic approaches. However, the paucity of published molecular data makes addressing the evolution of cartilage using molecular phylogenetic approaches unrealistic at this time. Cartilage likely evolved from a chondroid connective tissue precursor, and may have been independently derived many times. The appearance of cartilaginous tissues of unknown phylogenetic affinities in such a wide diversity of animal groups warrants further investigation.     

Phosphomonoesterases in growth cartilages of the rat

Summary Epiphyseal plate cartilage, epiphyseal cartilage, synchondroseal cartilage and mandibular condylar cartilage were studied morphologically and histochemically in 14 days old rats. Ordinary decalcified paraffin sections were stained with hematoxylin & eosin, van Giesons connective tissue stain, or toluidine blue, and used for morphological studies of the different cartilaginous structures. Undecalcified cryostat sections were used for demonstration of acid and alkaline phosphatase. The enzyme activity was tested for at regular intervals during incubation from 15 sec to 120 min.The morphologic study revealed that a marked similarity of construction exists between epiphyseal plate cartilage and synchrondroseal cartilage. The construction of epiphyseal and condylar cartilage differ from that of the other two structures and also differ mutually.With small variations the reaction for both alkaline and acid phosphatase was found to be identical in the zones of erosion, hypertrophy and maturation of the four structures. Intercellularly, acid phosphatase is present in all zones in the synchondroseal and the epiphyseal plate cartilage, while in the epiphyseal and condylar cartilages it is only present in the zones of erosion, hypertrophy and maturation.The identical reaction for acid phosphatase in the epiphyseal and the condylar cartilage is thought, in all likelihood, to be accidental. When kinetic conditions are taken into account, epiphyseal cartilage seems to react like epiphyseal plate and synchondroseal cartilage, while the condylar cartilage takes up an exceptional position among growth cartilages.     

Cartilage on the move: Cartilage lineage tracing during tadpole metamorphosis

The reorganization of cranial cartilages during tadpole metamorphosis is a set of complex processes. The fates of larval cartilage‐forming cells (chondrocytes) and sources of adult chondrocytes are largely unknown. Individual larval cranial cartilages may either degenerate or remodel, while many adult cartilages appear to form de novo during metamorphosis. Determining the extent to which adult chondrocytes/cartilages are derived from larval chondrocytes during metamorphosis requires new techniques in chondrocyte lineage tracing. We have developed two transgenic systems to label cartilage cells throughout the body with fluorescent proteins. One system strongly labels early tadpole cartilages only. The other system inducibly labels forming cartilages at any developmental stage. We examined cartilages of the skull (viscero‐ and neurocranium), and identified larval cartilages that either resorb or remodel into adult cartilages. Our data show that the adult otic capsules, tecti anterius and posterius, hyale, and portions of Meckel's cartilage are derived from larval chondrocytes. Our data also suggest that most adult cartilages form de novo, though we cannot rule out the potential for extreme larval chondrocyte proliferation or de‐ and re‐differentiation, which could dilute our fluorescent protein signal. The transgenic lineage tracing strategies developed here are the first examples of inducible, skeleton‐specific, lineage tracing in Xenopus.     

Cranial cartilages: Players in the evolution of the cranium during evolution of the chordates in general and of the vertebrates in particular

The present contribution is chiefly a review, augmented by some new results on amphioxus and lamprey anatomy, that draws on paleontological and developmental data to suggest a scenario for cranial cartilage evolution in the phylum chordata. Consideration is given to the cartilage-related tissues of invertebrate chordates (amphioxus and some fossil groups like vetulicolians) as well as in the two major divisions of the subphylum Vertebrata (namely, agnathans, and gnathostomes). In the invertebrate chordates, which can be considered plausible proxy ancestors of the vertebrates, only a viscerocranium is present, whereas a neurocranium is absent. For this situation, we examine how cartilage-related tissues of this head region prefigure the cellular cartilage types in the vertebrates. We then focus on the vertebrate neurocranium, where cyclostomes evidently lack neural-crest derived trabecular cartilage (although this point needs to be established more firmly). In the more complex gnathostome, several neural-crest derived cartilage types are present: namely, the trabecular cartilages of the prechordal region and the parachordal cartilage the chordal region. In sum, we present an evolutionary framework for cranial cartilage evolution in chordates and suggest aspects of the subject that should profit from additional study.     

Skeletal elements within teleost eyes and a discussion of their homology

Scleral ossicles and scleral cartilages form part of the craniofacial skeleton of many vertebrates. Some vertebrates, including all birds and most reptiles, but excluding most mammals, have scleral cartilages as well as scleral ossicles supporting their eyes. The teleost equivalent of these elements has received little attention in the literature. From radiographic and whole-mount analyses of over 400 individuals from 376 teleost species, we conclude that the teleost scleral skeletal elements (ossicles and cartilage) differ significantly from those of reptiles (including birds). Scleral ossicles in teleosts have different developmental origins, different positions within the eyeball, and different relationships with the scleral cartilaginous element than those in reptiles. From whole-mount staining of a growth series of four species of teleost (Danio rerio, Salmo salar, Esox lucius, and Alosa pseudoharengus), we interpret the development of these elements and show that they arise from within an Alcian blue-staining cartilaginous ring that develops around the eye earlier in development. We present possible scenarios on the evolution of these scleral skeletal elements from a common gnathostome ancestor, and consider that teleost scleral skeletal elements may not be homologous to those in reptiles. Our study indicates that homology cannot be assumed for these elements, despite the fact that they share the same name, scleral ossicles.     

The nature and significance of invertebrate cartilages revisited: distribution and histology of cartilage and cartilage-like tissues within the Metazoa

Tissues similar to vertebrate cartilage have been described throughout the Metazoa. Often the designation of tissues as cartilage within non-vertebrate lineages is based upon sparse supporting data. To be considered cartilage, a tissue should meet a number of histological criteria that include composition and organization of the extracellular matrix. To re-evaluate the distribution and structural properties of these tissues, we have re-investigated the histological properties of many of these tissues from fresh material, and review the existing literature on invertebrate cartilages. Chondroid connective tissue is common amongst invertebrates, and differs from invertebrate cartilage in the structure and organization of the cells that comprise it. Groups having extensive chondroid connective tissue include brachiopods, polychaetes, and urochordates. Cartilage is found within cephalopod mollusks, chelicerate arthropods and sabellid polychaetes. Skeletal tissues found within enteropneust hemichordates are unique in that the extracellular matrix shares many properties with vertebrate cartilage, yet these tissues are completely acellular. The possibility that this tissue may represent a new category of cartilage, acellular cartilage, is discussed. Immunoreactivity of some invertebrate cartilages with antibodies that recognize molecules specific to vertebrate bone suggests an intermediate phenotype between vertebrate cartilage and bone. Although cartilage is found within a number of invertebrate lineages, we find that not all tissues previously reported to be cartilage have the appropriate properties to merit their distinction as cartilage.     

Three‐dimensional reconstruction of the odontophoral cartilages of Caenogastropoda (Mollusca: Gastropoda) using micro‐CT: Morphology and phylogenetic significance

Odontophoral cartilages are located in the molluscan buccal mass and support the movement of the radula during feeding. The structural diversity of odontophoral cartilages is currently known only from limited taxa, but this information is important for interpreting phylogeny and for understanding the biomechanical operation of the buccal mass. Caenogastropods exhibit a wide variety of feeding strategies, but there is little comparative information on cartilage morphology within this group. The morphology of caenogastropod odontophoral cartilages is currently known only from dissection and histology, although preliminary results suggest that they may be structurally diverse. A comparative morphological survey of 18 caenogastropods and three noncaenogastropods has been conducted, sampling most major caenogastropod superfamilies. Three‐dimensional models of the odontophoral cartilages were generated using X‐ray microscopy (micro‐CT) and reconstruction by image segmentation. Considerable morphological diversity of the odontophoral cartilages was found within Caenogastropoda, including the presence of thin cartilaginous appendages, asymmetrically overlapping cartilages, and reflexed cartilage margins. Many basal caenogastropod taxa possess previously unidentified cartilaginous support structures below the radula (subradular cartilages), which may be homologous to the dorsal cartilages of other gastropods. As subradular cartilages were absent in carnivorous caenogastropods, adaptation to trophic specialization is likely. However, incongruence with specific feeding strategies or body size suggests that the morphology of odontophoral cartilages is constrained by phylogeny, representing a new source of morphological characters to improve the phylogenetic resolution of this group. J. Morphol. 2009. © 2008 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Immunolocalization of matrix proteins in different human cartilage subtypes

Cartilage exerts many functions in different tissues and parts of the body. Specific requirements presumably also account for a specific biochemical composition. In this study, we investigated the presence and distribution pattern of matrix components, in particular collagen types in the major human cartilages (hyaline, fibrous, and elastic cartilage) by histochemical and immunohistochemical means. Macroscopically normal articular cartilages, menisci, disci (lumbar spine), epiglottal, and tracheal tissues were obtained from donors at autopsy. Aurical and nasal cartilages were part of routine biopsy samples from tumor resection specimens. Conventional histology and immunohistochemical stainings with collagen types I, II, III, IV, V, VI, and X and S-100 protein antibodies were performed on paraformaldehyde-fixed and paraffin-embedded specimens. The extracellular matrix is the functional component of all cartilages as indicated by the low cell densities. In particular major scaffold forming collagen types I (in fibrous cartilage) and II (in hyaline and elastic cartilages) as well as collagen type X (in the calcified layer of articular cartilages, the inner part of tracheal clips, and epiglottis cartilage) showed a specific distribution. In contrast, the "minor" collagen types III, V, and VI were found in all, collagen type IV in none of the cartilage subtypes. In this study, we present a biochemical profile of the major cartilage types of the human body which is important for understanding the physiology and the pathophysiology of cartilages.     

Type III Collagen,a Fibril Network Modifier in Articular Cartilage

The collagen framework of hyaline cartilages, including articular cartilage, consists largely of type II collagen that matures from a cross-linked heteropolymeric fibril template of types II, IX, and XI collagens. In the articular cartilages of adult joints, type III collagen makes an appearance in varying amounts superimposed on the original collagen fibril network. In a study to understand better the structural role of type III collagen in cartilage, we find that type III collagen molecules with unprocessed N-propeptides are present in the extracellular matrix of adult human and bovine articular cartilages as covalently cross-linked polymers extensively cross-linked to type II collagen. Cross-link analyses revealed that telopeptides from both N and C termini of type III collagen were linked in the tissue to helical cross-linking sites in type II collagen. Reciprocally, telopeptides from type II collagen were recovered cross-linked to helical sites in type III collagen. Cross-linked peptides were also identified in which a trifunctional pyridinoline linked both an α1(II) and an α1(III) telopeptide to the α1(III) helix. This can only have arisen from a cross-link between three different collagen molecules, types II and III in register staggered by 4D from another type III molecule. Type III collagen is known to be prominent at sites of healing and repair in skin and other tissues. The present findings emphasize the role of type III collagen, which is synthesized in mature articular cartilage, as a covalent modifier that may add cohesion to a weakened, existing collagen type II fibril network as part of a chondrocyte healing response to matrix damage.     

A comparison of the immunohistochemical localization of type I and type II collagens in craniofacial cartilages of the rat.

The immunohistochemical localization of types I and II collagen was examined in the following 4 cartilaginous tissues of the rat craniofacial region: the nasal septal cartilage and the spheno-occipital synchondrosis (primary cartilages), and the mandibular condylar cartilage and the cartilage at the intermaxillary suture (secondary cartilages). In both primary cartilages, type II collagen was present in the extracellular matrix (ECM) of the whole cartilaginous area, but type I collagen was completely absent from the ECM. In the secondary cartilages, type I collagen was present throughout the cartilaginous cell layers, and type II collagen was restricted to the ECM of the mature and hypertrophic cell layers. These observations indicate differences in the ECM components between primary and secondary craniofacial cartilages, and that these differences may contribute to their modes of chondrogenesis.     

深低温冻存组织工程化软骨在喉狭窄功能重建中的应用

目的：探讨低温保存组织工程化软骨在喉狭窄功能重建中的应用价值。方法：取3周龄新西兰兔关节软骨细胞,体外培养,取第2代对数生长期培养细胞,制成细胞悬液,调整软骨细胞悬液浓度约为5×10^7个／ml左右,接种于PGA三维支架材料上,复合物体外培养2周后冻存,冻存6个月后解冻复苏,再行体外培养观察,2周后接种于已建立的喉甲状软骨缺损模型的软骨缺损处,并设对照组。术后12周取材,行大体及组织学观察。结果：经低温冻存的组织工程化软骨生长良好,组织学观察有软骨形成,与周围软骨组织结合紧密,与非冻存组相比差异无统计学意义。结论：深低温冻存对组织工程化软骨的生物活性无明显的影响,低温冻存的组织工程化软骨可用于喉软骨缺损的修复,重建喉功能。     

Histochemical identification of sulfation position in chondroitin sulfate in various cartilages

The ability of chondrocytes to synthesize chondroitin-4-sulfate (C4S) as opposed to chondroitin-6-sulfate (C6S) is a phylogenetically related phenomenon seen among adult higher vertebrates and developmentally during the embryogenesis of these vertebrates. While the embryonic cartilage may be initially a C6S matrix, C4S synthesis is seen to develop with time. We have histochemically localized these differences in sulfation with the cationic carbocyanine dye, Stains-all, in a spectrum of cartilages that vary in the sulfation position of their chondroitin sulfate. Cartilages from the rat and rabbit that are predominantly C4S stained magenta at pH 4.3, while the C6S-rich cartilage matrices from the regenerating rabbit ear and lamprey cranium stained blue. Embryonic chicken cartilages develop a gradient of magenta matrix with age, with increased concentration toward the articular surface. Both magenta and blue matrices were absent after pretreatment with chondroitinase ABC but were present after Streptomyces hyaluronidase digestion. The magenta staining was a property of the cartilage matrix as a whole, since isolated C4S and C6S stained blue. The differential staining was seen at pH 4.3, but not at pH 8.8, suggesting an interaction between the chondroitin sulfate and the adjacent tissue proteins.     

Perlecan displays variable spatial and temporal immunolocalisation patterns in the articular and growth plate cartilages of the ovine stifle joint

Perlecan is a modular heparan sulphate and/or chondroitin sulphate substituted proteoglycan of basement membrane, vascular tissues and cartilage. Perlecan acts as a low affinity co-receptor for fibroblast growth factors 1, 2, 7, 9, binds connective tissue growth factor and co-ordinates chondrogenesis, endochondral ossification and vascular remodelling during skeletal development; however, relatively little is known of its distribution in these tissues during ageing and development. The aim of the present study was to immunolocalise perlecan in the articular and epiphyseal growth plate cartilages of stifle joints in 2-day to 8-year-old pedigree merino sheep. Perlecan was prominent pericellularly in the stifle joint cartilages at all age points and also present in the inter-territorial matrix of the newborn to 19-month-old cartilage specimens. Aggrecan was part pericellular, but predominantly an extracellular proteoglycan. Perlecan was a prominent component of the long bone growth plates and displayed a pericellular as well as a strong ECM distribution pattern; this may indicate a so far unrecognised role for perlecan in the mineralisation of hypertrophic cartilage. A significant age dependant decline in cell number and perlecan levels was evident in the hyaline and growth plate cartilages. The prominent pericellular distribution of perlecan observed indicates potential roles in cell-matrix communication in cartilage, consistent with growth factor signalling, cellular proliferation and tissue development.     

The elastin-like protein matrix of lamprey branchial cartilage is cross-linked by lysyl pyridinoline.

The cranial skeleton of the lamprey, a primitive vertebrate, consists of cartilaginous structures that differ from vertebrate cartilages in having a noncollagenous extracellular matrix. Novel matrix proteins found in these cartilages include lamprin in the annular cartilage and an unidentified protein in the branchial cartilages. Both show biochemical similarities to elastin. The inextractability of these proteins, even to chemical cleavage by cyanogen bromide, indicates a polymer with extensive covalent cross-linking. Here we report on the type of cross-linking. Lysyl pyridinoline was found in high concentration in the elastin-like protein of lamprey branchial cartilage at a ratio of 7:1 to hydroxylysyl pyridinoline, the form that dominates in vertebrate collagens. Both forms of pyridinoline cross-link were absent from annular cartilage and desmosine cross-links, which are characteristic of vertebrate elastin, were not detected in either form of lamprey cartilage. Pyridinoline cross-links are considered to be characteristic of collagen, so their presence in an elastin-like protein in a primitive cartilage poses evolutionary questions about the tissue, the protein, and the cross-linking mechanism.     

A comparative microscopic and ultrastructural study of perichondrial tissue in cartilage of Octopus vulgaris (Cephalopoda, Mollusca)

The microscopic and submicroscopic structures of perichondrial tissues in the head cartilages of Octopus vulgaris were studied by polarized light and transmission electron microscopy. The orbital cartilages possess a birefringent layer parallel to the surface of the cartilage; ultrastructurally, this layer, which may be considered perichondrial tissue, has the typical organisation of connective tissue but does not possess the stratification of collagen laminae found in vertebrate perichondria. Perichondrial extracellular matrix is clearly distinct from that of cartilage because its collagen fibrils are of a larger diameter than collagen fibrils from cartilage. In addition, perichondrial fibroblasts are characteristically located at the center of collagen fibers. In the cerebral cartilage, the perichondrium is absent or discontinuous in relation to complex interconnections between cartilage and connective fibres, muscle fibres, blood vessels and nerve. Distinctive cartilage-lining cells, rich in electron dense cytoplasmatic granules, are stratified either along the cartilage surface or along vessels and muscle fibres that penetrate within the cartilage. The perichondrium of cephalopod cartilage, whose structure varies according to the location and function of its skeletal segments, mimics that of vertebrate perichondrium, exemplifying the high level of tissue differentiation attained by cephalopods.     

Retinoic acid given at late embryonic stage depresses sonic hedgehog and Hoxd-4 expression in the pharyngeal area and induces skeletal malformation in flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) embryos

During the development of pharyngeal cartilages, signal molecules, including sonic hedgehog (shh) and various growth factors, as well as Hox genes are expressed in the pharyngeal area. To elucidate whether shh and Hoxd-4 function in pharyngeal cartilage formation in teleost jaw and gill primordia, spatial and temporal patterns of shh expression in flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) embryonic pharynx were examined. The effects of retinoic acid (RA) on shh and Hoxd-4 expression and the patterning of pharyngeal cartilages were analyzed. At the prim-5 stage, when cartilage precursor cells aggregate in the pharyngeal primordia, pharyngeal endoderm expressed shh in two domains, in portions of the mandibular and hyoid primordia and in the gill primordia. After a further 40 h, shh domains expanded at the posterior edge of the endoderm of each mandibular, hyoid and gill primordium, concurrent with the growth of the primordia. A new shh expression domain appeared at the endodermal border of the mouth. Retinoic acid treatment depressed shh and Hoxd-4 expression, and also reduced the amount of expansion of the shh expression domains. Pharyngeal cartilages that formed in these embryos were malformed; their growth direction was shifted posteriorly and size was reduced. This provides the possibility that shh and Hoxd-4 regulate the growth and direction of pharyngeal cartilage precursor cells and that RA disturbs their expression, causing skeletal malformation.     

The impacts of comparative anatomy of electric rays (Batoidea: Torpediniformes) on their systematic hypotheses

The Comparative anatomy of the 11 recognized genera within Torpediniformes is described, systematically categorized, and illustrated in a comprehensive photo‐atlas. Data are compiled into a character matrix and cladistically analyzed using parsimony to test hypotheses about the previously recognized subfamilies, while reconstructing the possible evolutionary history of Torpediniformes. Results are consistent with the previous rank‐based classifications, regardless of the parsimony criteria used to generate the phylogenetic hypothesis, with one notable exception: a monophyletic Narcininae was never recovered. Torpedinoidea (=Hypnos + Torpedo) is supported by the presence of long, slender, flexible jaw cartilages, absence of a large rostral fontanelle, presence of suprascapular antimeres that are each shorter than the scapular process of the scapulocoracoid, antorbital cartilages that articulate on the anterior aspect of the nasal capsules and absence of a frontoparietal fontanelle. Subfamilial names Hypninae and Torpedininae are redundant with the genus names Hypnos and Torpedo and are not adopted here. Narcinoidea (=nontorpedinoid torpediniforms) is supported by unambiguous character transformations to the presence of a divided lower lip, labial cartilages, laterolingually compressed palatoquadrates, bifurcated antorbital cartilages, a rostral fontanelle, ventrally projecting nasal capsules, a dorsal rim of the synarcual mouth posterior to occipital condyle, posteriorly positioned lateral stays, and obtuse anterior margins of lateral stays. Narkidae is supported by unambiguous character transformations to the presence of an uncovered eye that protrudes above dorsal surface, a shared rim between the spiracle and the eye, an anterior nasal turret that projects ventrally, a nasal curtain that covers the upper lip and dentition when the mouth is closed, tab‐like prepelvic processes, a mesopterygium that is shorter than propterygium but longer than metapterygium, a slender median rostral cartilage, and a basibranchial cartilage with an anterior margin that is depressed medially and a posterior margin that tapers. J. Morphol. 275:597–612, 2014. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Lack of association between avian cartilages of different embryological origins when maintained in vitro.

The possibility that cartilages of differing embryological origins behave as separate types with respect to cell-to-cell associations was tested by placing the cut ends of transversely sectioned embryonic chick tibial cartilages (of mesodermal origin) in apposition to transversely sectioned Meckel's cartilages (neural crest (ectodermal) cartilage) on the surface of a semi-solid organ culture medium and maintaining the combinations in vitro for five to ten days. Tibia-tibia and Meckel's cartilage-Meckel's cartilage (homotypic) combinations, which served as controls, became united by a common extracellular matrix and by the proliferation of chondroblasts. Analysis of combinations where one partner had been prelabelled with 3H-thymidine indicated that chondroblasts intermingled at the contact zone. In contrast, tibia-Meckel's cartilage (heterotypic) combinations became separated by a layer of fibrous tissue. The chondroblasts at the contact zone failed to intermingle. We conclude that avian embryonic chondrocytes are not all equivalent and that part of their nonequivalence could be related to their embryological origin either from the mesoderm or from the ectodermal neural crest.     

Gross morphology and topographical relationships of the hyobranchial apparatus and laryngeal cartilages in the ostrich (Struthio camelus)

The ostrich hyobranchial apparatus consists of the centrally positioned paraglossalia and basiurohyale and paired caudo‐lateral elements (horns), each consisting of the ceratobranchiale and epibranchiale. The paraglossalia lie within the tongue parenchyma and consist of paired, flat, caudo‐laterally directed cartilages joined rostrally. The basiurohyale forms a single dorso‐ventrally flattened unit composed of an octagonal‐shaped body from which extend rostral (the rostral process) and caudal (the urohyale) projections. The laryngeal skeleton consists of cricoid, procricoid and paired arytenoid cartilages. The large ring‐shaped cricoid cartilage displays a body and paired wings which articulate with each other and with the procricoid. The blunt, ossified, rostral projection of the cricoid and the scalloped nature of the arytenoid cartilages are unique to the ostrich. The procricoid is a single structure which links the paired arytenoids and wings of the cricoid. The hyobranchial apparatus is firmly attached to the tongue parenchyma and to the larynx and proximal trachea. In contrast to previous reports in this species, the horns of the hyobranchial apparatus are not related to the skull. Ossification of the body of the basihyale, the ceratobranchials and the rostral process and body of the cricoid cartilage of the larynx lends stability to these structures.