Rescoring docking hit lists for model cavity sites: predictions and experimental testing

Molecular docking computationally screens thousands to millions of organic molecules against protein structures, looking for those with complementary fits. Many approximations are made, often resulting in low “hit rates.” A strategy to overcome these approximations is to rescore top-ranked docked molecules using a better but slower method. One such is afforded by molecular mechanics-generalized Born surface area (MM-GBSA) techniques. These more physically realistic methods have improved models for solvation and electrostatic interactions and conformational change compared to most docking programs. To investigate MM-GBSA rescoring, we re-ranked docking hit lists in three small buried sites: a hydrophobic cavity that binds apolar ligands, a slightly polar cavity that binds aryl and hydrogen-bonding ligands, and an anionic cavity that binds cationic ligands. These sites are simple; consequently, incorrect predictions can be attributed to particular errors in the method, and many likely ligands may actually be tested. In retrospective calculations, MM-GBSA techniques with binding-site minimization better distinguished the known ligands for each cavity from the known decoys compared to the docking calculation alone. This encouraged us to test rescoring prospectively on molecules that ranked poorly by docking but that ranked well when rescored by MM-GBSA. A total of 33 molecules highly ranked by MM-GBSA for the three cavities were tested experimentally. Of these, 23 were observed to bind—these are docking false negatives rescued by rescoring. The 10 remaining molecules are true negatives by docking and false positives by MM-GBSA. X-ray crystal structures were determined for 21 of these 23 molecules. In many cases, the geometry prediction by MM-GBSA improved the initial docking pose and more closely resembled the crystallographic result; yet in several cases, the rescored geometry failed to capture large conformational changes in the protein. Intriguingly, rescoring not only rescued docking false positives, but also introduced several new false positives into the top-ranking molecules. We consider the origins of the successes and failures in MM-GBSA rescoring in these model cavity sites and the prospects for rescoring in biologically relevant targets.     

Gaussian docking functions

A shape-based Gaussian docking function is constructed which uses Gaussian functions to represent the shapes of individual atoms. A set of 20 trypsin ligand-protein complexes are drawn from the Protein Data Bank (PDB), the ligands are separated from the proteins, and then are docked back into the active sites using numerical optimization of this function. It is found that by employing this docking function, quasi-Newton optimization is capable of moving ligands great distances [on average 7 A root mean square distance (RMSD)] to locate the correctly docked structure. It is also found that a ligand drawn from one PDB file can be docked into a trypsin structure drawn from any of the trypsin PDB files. This implies that this scoring function is not limited to more accurate x-ray structures, as is the case for many of the conventional docking methods, but could be extended to homology models.     

A Fast Flexible Docking Method using an Incremental Construction Algorithm

We present an automatic method for docking organic ligands into protein binding sites. The method can be used in the design process of specific protein ligands. It combines an appropriate model of the physico-chemical properties of the docked molecules with efficient methods for sampling the conformational space of the ligand. If the ligand is flexible, it can adopt a large variety of different conformations. Each such minimum in conformational space presents a potential candidate for the conformation of the ligand in the complexed state. Our docking method samples the conformation space of the ligand on the basis of a discrete model and uses a tree-search technique for placing the ligand incrementally into the active site. For placing the first fragment of the ligand into the protein, we use hashing techniques adapted from computer vision. The incremental construction algorithm is based on a greedy strategy combined with efficient methods for overlap detection and for the search of new interactions. We present results on 19 complexes of which the binding geometry has been crystallographically determined. All considered ligands are docked in at most three minutes on a current workstation. The experimentally observed binding mode of the ligand is reproduced with 0.5 to 1.2 Å rms deviation. It is almost always found among the highest-ranking conformations computed.     

Effective handling of induced-fit motion in flexible docking

For structure-based drug design, where various ligand structures need to be docked to a target protein structure, a docking method that can handle conformational flexibility of not only the ligand, but also the protein, is indispensable. We have developed a simple and effective approach for dealing with the local induced-fit motion of the target protein, and implemented it in our docking tool, ADAM. Our approach efficiently combines the following two strategies: a vdW-offset grid in which the protein cavity is enlarged uniformly, and structure optimization allowing the motion of ligand and protein atoms. To examine the effectiveness of our approach, we performed docking validation studies, including redocking in 18 test cases and foreign-docking, in which various ligands from foreign crystal structures of complexes are docked into a target protein structure, in 22 cases (on five target proteins). With the original ADAM, the correct docking modes (RMSD < 2.0 A) were not present among the top 20 models in one case of redocking and four cases of foreign-docking. When the handling of induced-fit motion was implemented, the correct solutions were acquired in all 40 test cases. In foreign-docking on thymidine kinase, the correct docking modes were obtained as the top-ranked solutions for all 10 test ligands by our combinatorial approach, and this appears to be the best result ever reported with any docking tool. The results of docking validation have thus confirmed the effectiveness of our approach, which can provide reliable docking models even in the case of foreign-docking, where conformational change of the target protein cannot be ignored. We expect that this approach will contribute substantially to actual drug design, including virtual screening.     

Similarity-driven flexible ligand docking

A similarity-driven approach to flexible ligand docking is presented. Given a reference ligand or a pharmacophore positioned in the protein active site, the method allows inclusion of a similarity term during docking. Two different algorithms have been implemented, namely, a similarity-penalized docking (SP-DOCK) and a similarity-guided docking (SG-DOCK). The basic idea is to maximally exploit the structural information about the ligand binding mode present in cases where ligand-bound protein structures are available, information that is usually ignored in standard docking procedures. SP-DOCK and SG-DOCK have been derived as modified versions of the program DOCK 4.0, where the similarity program MIMIC acts as a module for the calculation of similarity indices that correct docking energy scores at certain steps of the calculation. SP-DOCK applies similarity corrections to the set of ligand orientations at the end of the ligand incremental construction process, penalizing the docking energy and, thus, having only an effect on the relative ordering of the final solutions. SG-DOCK applies similarity corrections throughout the entire ligand incremental construction process, thus affecting not only the relative ordering of solutions but also actively guiding the ligand docking. The performance of SP-DOCK and SG-DOCK for binding mode assessment and molecular database screening is discussed. When applied to a set of 32 thrombin ligands for which crystal structures are available, SG-DOCK improves the average RMSD by ca. 1 A when compared with DOCK. When those 32 thrombin ligands are included into a set of 1,000 diverse molecules from the ACD, DIV, and WDI databases, SP-DOCK significantly improves the retrieval of thrombin ligands within the first 10% of each of the three databases with respect to DOCK, with minimal additional computational cost. In all cases, comparison of SP-DOCK and SG-DOCK results with those obtained by DOCK and MIMIC is performed.     

Application of docking-based comparative intermolecular contacts analysis to validate Hsp90α docking studies and subsequent in silico screening for inhibitors

Heat shock protein (Hsp90α) has been recently implicated in cancer, prompting several attempts to discover and optimize new Hsp90α inhibitors. Towards this end, we docked 83 diverse Hsp90α inhibitors into the ATP-binding site of this chaperone using several docking-scoring settings. Subsequently, we applied our newly developed computational tool-docking-based comparative intramolecular contacts analysis (dbCICA)-to assess the different docking conditions and select the best settings. dbCICA is based on the number and quality of contacts between docked ligands and amino acid residues within the binding pocket. It assesses a particular docking configuration based on its ability to align a set of ligands within a corresponding binding pocket in such a way that potent ligands come into contact with binding site spots distinct from those approached by low-affinity ligands, and vice versa. The optimal dbCICA models were translated into valid pharmacophore models that were used as 3D search queries to mine the National Cancer Institute's structural database for new inhibitors of Hsp90α that could potentially be used as anticancer agents. The process culminated in 15 micromolar Hsp90α ATPase inhibitors.     

Pre-docking filter for protein and ligand 3D structures

Virtual drug screening using protein-ligand docking techniques is a time-consuming process, which requires high computational power for binding affinity calculation. There are millions of chemical compounds available for docking. Eliminating compounds that are unlikely to exhibit high binding affinity from the screening set should speed-up the virtual drug screening procedure. We performed docking of 6353 ligands against twenty-one protein X-ray crystal structures. The docked ligands were ranked according to their calculated binding affinities, from which the top five hundred and the bottom five hundred were selected. We found that the volume and number of rotatable bonds of the top five hundred docked ligands are similar to those found in the crystal structures and corresponded with the volume of the binding sites. In contrast, the bottom five hundred set contains ligands that are either too large to enter the binding site, or too small to bind with high specificity and affinity to the binding site. A pre-docking filter that takes into account shapes and volumes of the binding sites as well as ligand volumes and flexibilities can filter out low binding affinity ligands from the screening sets. Thus, the virtual drug screening procedure speed is increased.     

Protein-protein docking with multiple residue conformations and residue substitutions

The protein docking problem has two major aspects: sampling conformations and orientations, and scoring them for fit. To investigate the extent to which the protein docking problem may be attributed to the sampling of ligand side‐chain conformations, multiple conformations of multiple residues were calculated for the uncomplexed (unbound) structures of protein ligands. These ligand conformations were docked into both the complexed (bound) and unbound conformations of the cognate receptors, and their energies were evaluated using an atomistic potential function. The following questions were considered: (1) does the ensemble of precalculated ligand conformations contain a structure similar to the bound form of the ligand? (2) Can the large number of conformations that are calculated be efficiently docked into the receptors? (3) Can near‐native complexes be distinguished from non‐native complexes? Results from seven test systems suggest that the precalculated ensembles do include side‐chain conformations similar to those adopted in the experimental complexes. By assuming additivity among the side chains, the ensemble can be docked in less than 12 h on a desktop computer. These multiconformer dockings produce near‐native complexes and also non‐native complexes. When docked against the bound conformations of the receptors, the near‐native complexes of the unbound ligand were always distinguishable from the non‐native complexes. When docked against the unbound conformations of the receptors, the near‐native dockings could usually, but not always, be distinguished from the non‐native complexes. In every case, docking the unbound ligands with flexible side chains led to better energies and a better distinction between near‐native and non‐native fits. An extension of this algorithm allowed for docking multiple residue substitutions (mutants) in addition to multiple conformations. The rankings of the docked mutant proteins correlated with experimental binding affinities. These results suggest that sampling multiple residue conformations and residue substitutions of the unbound ligand contributes to, but does not fully provide, a solution to the protein docking problem. Conformational sampling allows a classical atomistic scoring function to be used; such a function may contribute to better selectivity between near‐native and non‐native complexes. Allowing for receptor flexibility may further extend these results.     

Analysis of binding modes of ligands to multiple conformations of CYP3A4

Cytochromes P450 (CYPs) are extremely versatile enzymes capable of catalyzing a vast number of compounds, and CYP3A4 is no exception metabolizing approximately half of the currently marketed drugs, besides endogenous compounds. To metabolize such a variety of compounds, CYP3A4 has to be extremely flexible, which makes interaction studies difficult. We employ a multi-conformational docking setup where conformations are generated by several molecular dynamics simulations to analyze the binding modes of various ligands, and the docking is considered successful if the ligand site of catalysis (SOC) is within 6.0 Å of the haem Fe. While docking with the X-ray structure proved unsuccessful with all ligands, the multi-conformational docking achieved successful binding of each ligand to at least one protein conformation. Analysis of the docked solutions highlights residues in the active site cavity that may have an important role in access, binding and stabilization of the ligand.     

Identification of potential inhibitors for HCV NS5b of genotype 4a by combining dynamic simulation,protein–ligand interaction fingerprint, 3D pharmacophore,docking and 3D QSAR

Abstract

HCV NS5B polymerase has been one of the most attractive targets for developing new drugs for HCV infection and many drugs were successfully developed, but all of them were designed for targeting Hepatitis C Virus genotype 1 (HCV GT1). Hepatitis C virus genotype 4a (HCV GT4a) dominant in Egypt has paid less attention. Here, we describe our protocol of virtual screening in identification of novel potential potent inhibitors for HCV NS5B polymerase of GT4a using homology modeling, protein–ligand interaction fingerprint (PLIF), docking, pharmacophore, and 3D CoMFA quantitative structure activity relationship (QSAR). Firstly, a high-quality 3D model of HCV NS5B polymerase of GT4a was constructed using crystal structure of HCV NS5B polymerase of GT1 (PDB ID: 3hkw) as a template. Then, both the model and the template were simulated to compare conformational stability. PLIF was generated using five crystal structures of HCV NS5B (PDB ID: 4mia, 4mib, 4mk9, 4mka, and 4mkb), which revealed the most important residues and their interactions with the co-crystalized ligands. After that, a 3D pharmacophore model was developed from the generated PLIF data and then used as a screening filter for 17000328 drug-like zinc database compounds. 900 compounds passed the pharmacophore filter and entered the docking-based virtual screening stage. Finally, a 3D CoMFA QSAR was developed using 42 compounds as a training and 19 compounds as a test set. The 3D CoMFA QSAR was used to design and screen some potential inhibitors, these compounds were further evaluated by the docking stage. The highest ranked five hits from docking result (compounds (p1–p4) and compound q1) were selected for further analysis.

Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma     

GEMDOCK: a generic evolutionary method for molecular docking

We have developed an evolutionary approach for flexible ligand docking. This approval, GEMDOCK, uses a Generic Evolutionary Method for molecular DOCKing and an empirical scoring function. The former combines both discrete and continuous global search strategies with local search strategies to speed up convergence, whereas the latter results in rapid recognition of potential ligands. GEMDOCK was tested on a diverse data set of 100 protein-ligand complexes from the Protein Data Bank. In 79% of these complexes, the docked lowest energy ligand structures had root-mean-square derivations (RMSDs) below 2.0 A with respect to the corresponding crystal structures. The success rate increased to 85% if the structure water molecules were retained. We evaluated GEMDOCK on two cross-docking experiments in which each ligand of a protein ensemble was docked into each protein of the ensemble. Seventy-six percent of the docked structures had RMSDs below 2.0 A when the ligands were docked into foreign structures. We analyzed and validated GEMDOCK with respect to various search spaces and scoring functions, and found that if the scoring function was perfect, then the predicted accuracy was also essentially perfect. This study suggests that GEMDOCK is a useful tool for molecular recognition and may be used to systematically evaluate and thus improve scoring functions.     

Towards in silico lead optimization: scores from ensembles of protein/ligand conformations reliably correlate with biological activity

Accurately ranking protein/ligand interactions and distinguishing subtle differences between homologous compounds in a virtual focused library in silico is essential in a structure-based drug discovery program. In order to establish a predictive model to design novel inhibitors of dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) from the parasitic protozoa, Cryptosporidium hominis, we docked a series of 30 DHFR inhibitors with measured inhibition constants against the crystal structure of the protein. By including protein flexibility and averaging the energies of the 25 lowest protein/ligand conformers we obtained more accurate total nonbonded energies from which we calculated a predicted biological activity. The calculated and measured biological activities showed reliable correlations of 72.9%. Additionally, visual analysis of the ensemble of protein/ligand conformations revealed alternative ligand binding pockets in the active site. Using the same principles we then created a homology model of DHFR from Toxoplasma gondii and docked 11 inhibitors. A correlation of 50.2% between docking score and activity validates both the method and the model. The correlations presented here are particularly compelling considering the high structural similarity of the ligands and the fact that we have used structures derived from crystallographic data and homology modeling. These docking principles may be useful in any lead optimization study where accurate ranking of similar compounds is desired.     

Synthesis,binding and bioactivity of γ-methylene γ-lactam ecdysone receptor ligands: Advantages of QSAR models for flexible receptors

Nuclear hormone receptors, such as the ecdysone receptor, often display a large amount of induced fit to ligands. The size and shape of the binding pocket in the EcR subunit changes markedly on ligand binding, making modelling methods such as docking extremely challenging. It is, however, possible to generate excellent 3D QSAR models for a given type of ligand, suggesting that the receptor adopts a relatively restricted number of binding site configurations or ‘attractors’. We describe the synthesis, in vitro binding and selected in vivo toxicity data for γ-methylene γ-lactams, a new class of high-affinity ligands for ecdysone receptors from Bovicola ovis (Phthiraptera) and Lucilia cuprina (Diptera). The results of a 3D QSAR study of the binding of methylene lactams to recombinant ecdysone receptor protein suggest that this class of ligands is indeed recognised by a single conformation of the EcR binding pocket.     

Ligand recognition by the vitamin D receptor.

Three-dimensional structure of the ligand binding domain (LBD) of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) docked with the natural ligand 1 alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) [1,25-(OH)(2)D(3)] has been mostly solved by the X-ray crystallographic analysis of the deletion mutant (VDR-LBD Delta 165-215). The important focus, from now on, is how the VDR recognizes and interacts with potent synthetic ligands. We now report the docking models of the VDR with three functionally and structurally interesting ligands, 22-oxa-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) (OCT), 20-epi-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) and 20-epi-22-oxa-24,26,27-trihomo-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3). In parallel with the computational docking studies, we prepared twelve one-point mutants of amino acid residues lining the ligand binding pocket of the VDR and examined their transactivation potency induced by 1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) and these synthetic ligands. The results indicate that L233, R274, W286, H397 and Y401 are essential for holding the all ligands tested, S278 and Q400 are not important at all, and the importance of S237, V234, S275, C288 and H305 is variable depending on the side-chain structure of the ligands. Based on these studies, we suggested key structural factors to bestow the selective action on OCT and the augmented activities on 20-epi-ligands. Furthermore, the docking models coincided well with our proposed active space-region theory of vitamin D based on the conformational analyses of ligands.     

Fragment-Based flexible ligand docking by evolutionary optimization.

A new computational approach for the efficient docking of flexible ligands in a rigid protein is presented. It exploits the binding modes of functional groups determined by an exhaustive search with solvation. The search in ligand conformational space is performed by a genetic algorithm whose scoring function approximates steric effects and intermolecular hydrogen bonds. Ligand conformations generated by the genetic algorithm are docked in the protein binding site by optimizing the fit of their fragments to optimal positions of chemically related functional groups. We show that the use of optimal binding modes of molecular fragments allows to dock known inhibitors with about ten rotatable bonds in the active site of the uncomplexed and complexed conformations of thrombin and HIV-1 protease.