Detection of an intermediate during unfolding of bacterial cell division protein FtsZ: loss of functional properties precedes the global unfolding of FtsZ

Using environment-sensitive fluorescence of 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid, polarization of fluorescein 5'-isothiocyanate-labeled FtsZ, and far-UV circular dichroism spectroscopy, the chemical unfolding of FtsZ was found to proceed through two steps. The first step of the urea-induced unfolding produced an intermediate, which then unfolded at higher concentrations of urea. The intermediate state contains native-like secondary structure and much less tertiary structure compared with the native state. It is distinct from the native state as well as from the unfolded state. Similar to urea-induced unfolding of FtsZ, thermal unfolding of FtsZ also occurs in two steps. The midpoints for the first and second thermal unfolding transitions were found to be 38 +/- 4 and 77 +/- 5 degrees C, respectively. Further, the functional properties of FtsZ are extremely sensitive to urea, guanidium chloride, and sodium dodecyl sulfate. For example, 50% inhibition of the FtsZ assembly and GTP hydrolysis occurred at 0.1 and 0.2 m of urea, respectively. FtsZ lost its functional properties before any significant perturbation in the secondary or tertiary structure was detected by using several fluorescence techniques and far UV-CD indicating preferential local unfolding of the functional region(s). In addition, the unfolded FtsZ regains its ability to polymerize fully upon removal of urea. The data taken together suggest that FtsZ unfolds reversibly through a multistep process, and local responses that inhibit functional properties precede the global transition of FtsZ to the unfolded state.     

Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy suggests unfolding of loop structures precedes complete unfolding of pig citrate synthase

Pig citrate synthase (PCS) can be used as a model enzyme to gain some insight into the structural basis of protein thermostability. The thermal unfolding characteristics of the specific secondary structure elements within PCS were monitored in detail by following changes in its amide I band components. The result of our study indicates that PCS undergoes irreversible thermal denaturation. Detailed analysis reveals that the different secondary structures display a multistep transition with a major and a minor transition at different temperatures and a very small initial transition at the same temperature (30 degrees C). A plot of temperature-induced changes in (1)H-(2)H exchange, the decrease in the absorbance of the alpha-helical structures, and the increase in the absorbance of aggregated structures all have in common a multistep transition, the minor one centered at 45 degrees C and the major one around 59 degrees C. In contrast, a band that is tentatively assigned to loop structures displays these same minor and major transitions but at lower temperatures (39 and 52 degrees C, respectively). The transition, which occurs at 39-45 degrees C, is not associated with the appearance of aggregated structures. This transition may reflect a change in the tertiary structure of the protein. However, the final transition, which occurs at a higher temperature (52-59 degrees C), reflects unfolding and aggregation of the polypeptide chains. The Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) analysis suggests that PCS has a thermolabile region that unfolds first, some 7 degrees C below the main unfolding of the protein. We propose that this reflects the unfolding of the highly flexible loop segments, which in turn triggers the unfolding of the predominantly helical core structure of PCS.     

Domain structural flexibility in rhodanese examined by quenching of a phosphorescent probe

Rhodanese (thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase, EC 2.8.1.1) is an enzyme composed of two domains with the catalytic site located in the bottom of the crevice formed by the two domains. In this work, rhodanese was labeled at its catalytic site with the phosphorescence probe eosin isothiocyanide. The accessibility of molecules to the probe was determined by phosphorescence lifetime-quenching studies. The phosphorescent probe was much more accessible to small molecules (I- and thiosulfate, radius about 3-5 A) than to a larger molecule (spin-label probe TEMPO, radius about 8-10 A). It was observed that a temperature-induced change in the rate of quenching occurred at around 28 degrees C. The results are interpreted in terms of structural fluctuations and displacement in the domains.     

Structural basis for unfolding pathway‐dependent stability of proteins: Vectorial unfolding versus global unfolding

Point mutations in proteins can have different effects on protein stability depending on the mechanism of unfolding. In the most interesting case of I27, the Ig‐like module of the muscle protein titin, one point mutation (Y9P) yields opposite effects on protein stability during denaturant‐induced “global unfolding” versus “vectorial unfolding” by mechanical pulling force or cellular unfolding systems. Here, we assessed the reason for the different effects of the Y9P mutation of I27 on the overall molecular stability and N‐terminal unraveling by NMR. We found that the Y9P mutation causes a conformational change that is transmitted through β‐sheet structures to reach the central hydrophobic core in the interior and alters its accessibility to bulk solvent, which leads to destabilization of the hydrophobic core. On the other hand, the Y9P mutation causes a bend in the backbone structure, which leads to the formation of a more stable N‐terminal structure probably through enhanced hydrophobic interactions.     

Domain unfolding plays a role in superfibronectin formation

Superfibronectin (sFN) is a fibronectin (FN) aggregate that is formed by mixing FN with anastellin, a fragment of the first type III domain of FN. However, the mechanism of this aggregation has not been clear. In this study, we found that anastellin co-precipitated with FN in a ratio of approximately 4:1, anastellin:FN monomer. The primary binding site for anastellin was in the segment (III)1-3, which bound three molecules of anastellin and was able to form a precipitate without the rest of the FN molecule. Anastellin binding to (III)3 caused a conformational change in that domain that exposed a cryptic thermolysin-sensitive site. An additional anastellin binds to (III)11, where it enhances thermolysin digestion of (III)11. An engineered disulfide bond in (III)3 inhibited both aggregation and protease digestion, suggesting that the stability of (III)3 is a key factor in sFN formation. We propose a three-step model for sFN formation: 1) FN-III domains spontaneously unfold and refold; 2) anastellin binds to an unfolded domain, preventing its refolding and leaving it with exposed hydrophobic surfaces and beta-sheet edges; and 3) these exposed elements bind to similar exposed elements on other molecules, leading to aggregation. The model is consistent with our observation that the kinetics of aggregation are first order, with a reaction time of 500-700 s. Similar mechanisms may contribute to the assembly of the native FN matrix.     

Tetramer dissociation and monomer partial unfolding precedes protofibril formation in amyloidogenic transthyretin variants

Amyloid fibril formation and deposition is a common feature of a wide range of fatal diseases including spongiform encephalopathies, Alzheimer's disease, and familial amyloidotic polyneuropathies (FAP), among many others. In certain forms of FAP, the amyloid fibrils are mostly constituted by variants of transthyretin (TTR), a homotetrameric plasma protein. Recently, we showed that transthyretin in solution may undergo dissociation to a non-native monomer, even under close to physiological conditions of temperature, pH, ionic strength, and protein concentration. We also showed that this non-native monomer is a compact structure, does not behave as a molten globule, and may lead to the formation of partially unfolded monomeric species and high molecular mass soluble aggregates (Quintas, A., Saraiva, M. J. M., and Brito, R. M. M. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 32943-32949). Here, based on aging experiments of tetrameric TTR and chemically induced protein unfolding experiments of the non-native monomeric forms, we show that tetramer dissociation and partial unfolding of the monomer precedes amyloid fibril formation. We also show that TTR variants with the least thermodynamically stable non-native monomer produce the largest amount of partially unfolded monomeric species and soluble aggregates under conditions that are close to physiological. Additionally, the soluble aggregates formed by the amyloidogenic TTR variants showed morphological and thioflavin-T fluorescence properties characteristic of amyloid. These results allowed us to conclude that amyloid fibril formation by some TTR variants might be triggered by tetramer dissociation to a compact non-native monomer with low conformational stability, which originates partially unfolded monomeric species with a high tendency for ordered aggregation into amyloid fibrils. Thus, partial unfolding and conformational fluctuations of molecular species with marginal thermodynamic stability may play a crucial role on amyloid formation in vivo.     

Domain unfolding of monoclonal antibody fragments revealed by non-reducing SDS-PAGE

Monoclonal antibodies and derived fragments are used extensively both experimentally and therapeutically. Thorough characterization of such antibodies is necessary and includes assessment of their thermal and storage stabilities. Thus, assessment of the underlying conformational stabilities of the antibodies is also important. We recently documented that non-reducing SDS-PAGE can be used to assess both monoclonal and polyclonal IgG domain thermal unfolding in SDS. Utilizing this same h2E2 anti-cocaine mAb, in this study we generated and analyzed various mAb antibody fragments to delineate the structural domains of the antibody responsible for the observed discrete bands following various heating protocols and analysis by non-reducing SDS-PAGE. Previously, these domain unfolding transitions and gel bands were hypothesized to stem from known mAb structural domains based on the relative thermal stability of those CH2, CH3, and Fab domains in the absence of SDS, as measured by differential scanning calorimetry. In this study, we generated and analyzed F(ab’)₂, Fab, and Fc fragments, as well as a mAb consisting of only heavy chains, and examined the thermally induced domain unfolding in each of these fragments by non-reducing SDS-PAGE. The results were interpreted and integrated to generate an improved model of thermal unfolding for the mAb IgG in SDS. These results and the model presented should be generally applicable to many monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies and allow novel comparisons of conformational stabilities between chemically or genetically modified versions of a given antibody. Such modified antibodies and antibody drug conjugates are commonly utilized and important for experimental and therapeutic applications.     

Domain unfolding and the stability of thermolysin in guanidine hydrochloride

Equilibrium and kinetic studies of the unfolding and autolysis of the two domain protein thermolysin in guanidine hydrochloride are described. Enzyme activity, circular dichroism, fluorescence, sedimentation, size exclusion chromatography, and viscosity measurements were used to monitor conformational transitions and characterize the native and denatured states. The observation of biphasic transitions for the unfolding of apothermolysin and the spectroscopic changes associated with each phase of the overall unfolding process suggest unfolding of the N-terminal domain at less than 1 M guanidine hydrochloride, followed by the unfolding of the C-terminal domain, with the transition midpoint at 3 M guanidine hydrochloride. The refolding of the C-terminal domain is reversible; however, refolding of the N-terminal domain could not be demonstrated owing to protein aggregation. A quantitative analysis of the two transitions suggest that the unfolding of the two structural domains of thermolysin is not completely independent. Attempts to measure the unfolding of holothermolysin were hampered by autolysis. However, it was possible to show that at least three calcium ions serve to stabilize thermolysin against autolysis or unfolding in guanidine hydrochloride. Similar stabilization was observed for thermolysin with a single terbium ion bound at calcium site S(1). This result is consistent with our earlier findings, which suggest that calcium bound at sites S(1)-S(2) are located at a critical point on the unfolding pathway of thermolysin and serve to act as an interdomain lock.     

Native-state interconversion of a metamorphic protein requires global unfolding

Lymphotactin (Ltn) is a unique chemokine that under physiological solution conditions displays large-scale structural heterogeneity, defining a new category of "metamorphic proteins". Previous Ltn studies have indicated that each form is required for proper function, but the mechanism of interconversion remains unknown. Here we have investigated the temperature dependence of kinetic rates associated with interconversion and unfolding by stopped-flow fluorescence to determine transition-state free energies. Comparisons of derived thermodynamic parameters revealed striking similarities between interconversion and protein unfolding. We conclude that Ltn native-state rearrangement proceeds by way of a large-scale unfolding process rather than a unique intermediate structure.     

Domain unfolding in neurofilament sidearms: effects of phosphorylation and ATP

Lateral projections of neurofilaments (NF) called sidearms (SA) affect axon stability and caliber. SA phosphorylation is thought to modulate inter-NF distance and interactions between NF and other subcellular organelles. SA were probed by atomic force microscopy (AFM) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) as a function of phosphorylation and ATP content. DLS shows SA are larger when phosphorylated, and AFM shows four unfoldable domains in SA regardless of phosphorylation state or the presence of ATP. However, the native phosphorylated SA requires three-fold higher force to unfold by AFM than dephosphorylated SA, suggesting a less pliant as well as larger structure when phosphorylated.     

Reversible heat inactivation of copper sites precedes thermal unfolding of molluscan (Rapana thomasiana) hemocyanin

Hemocyanin (Hc) is a type-3 copper protein, containing dioxygen-binding active sites consisting of paired copper atoms. In the present study the thermal unfolding of the Hc from the marine mollusc Rapana thomasiana (RtH) has been investigated by combining differential scanning calorimetry, Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and UV-vis absorption spectroscopy. Two important stages in the unfolding pathway of the Hc molecule were discerned. A first event, with nonmeasurable heat absorption, occurring around 60°C, lowers the binding of dioxygen to the type-3 copper groups. This pretransition is reversible and is ascribed to a slight change in the tertiary structure. In a second stage, with midpoint around 80°C, the protein irreversibly unfolds with a loss of secondary structure and formation of amorphous aggregates. Experiments with the monomeric structural subunits, RtH1 and RtH2, indicated that the heterogeneity in the process of thermal denaturation can be attributed to the presence of multiple 50kDa functional units with different stability. In accordance, the irreversible unfolding of a purified functional unit (RtH2-e) occurred at a single transition temperature. At slightly alkaline pH (Tris buffer) the C-terminal β-sheet rich domain of the functional unit starts to unfold before the α-helix-rich N-terminal (copper containing) domain, triggering the collapse of the global protein structure. Even around 90°C some secondary structure is preserved as shown by the FTIR spectra of all investigated samples, confirming the high thermostability of molluscan Hc.     

Sequence grammar underlying the unfolding and phase separation of globular proteins

1. Download : Download high-res image (220KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Burst-phase expansion of native protein prior to global unfolding in SDS

Although numerous studies have been directed at understanding early folding events through the characterization of folding intermediates, there are few reports on the very late folding events, i.e. on the events taking place on the native side of the folding barrier and on alternative conformations of the folded state. To shed further light on these issues, we have characterized by protein engineering the structure of an expanded but native-like intermediate that accumulates transiently in the unfolding reaction of the small protein S6 in the presence of SDS. The results show that the SDS micelles attack the native protein in the dead-time of the denaturation experiment, causing an expansion of the hydrophobic core prior to the major unfolding transition. We distinguish two forms of the unfolding intermediate that are correlated with the micellar structure. With spherical micelles, the expansion is seen mainly as a weakening of the interactions which anchor the two alpha-helices to the core of the S6 structure. With cylindrical micelles, prevalent at higher SDS concentrations, the expansion is more global and produces a species which closely resembles the transition-state structure for unfolding in GdmCl. Despite the highly weakened core, the micelle-associated intermediate displays cooperative unfolding, indicating a significant structural plasticity of the species on the native side of the folding barrier in the presence of SDS.     

Immunohistochemical localization of rhodanese

Summary The role of rhodanese in the detoxication of acute cyanide exposure is controversial. The debate involves questions of the availability of rhodanese to cyanide in the peripheral circulation. Blood-borne cyanide will distribute to the brain and may induce lesions or even death. The present study addresses the dispute by determining the distribution of rhodanese in tissues considered to have the highest rhodanese activity and thought to serve as major detoxication sites. The results indicate that rhodanese levels are highest in (1) hepatocytes that are in close proximity to the blood supply of the liver (2) epithelial cells surrounding the bronchioles (a major entry route for gaseous cyanide) and (3) proximal tubule cells of the kidney (serving to facilitate cyanide detoxication and elimination as thiocyanate). Rhodanese activity in the brain is low compared with liver and kidney (Mimoriet al., 1984; Drawbaugh & Marrs, 1987); the brain is not considered to be a major site of cyanide detoxication. The brain, however, is the target for cyanide toxicity. In this study our goal was also to differentiate the distribution of rhodanese in an area of the brain. We found that the enzyme level is highest in fibrous astrocytes of the white matter. Cyanide-induced brain lesions may thus occur in areas of the brain lacking sufficient sites for detoxication.     

Reversible heat inactivation of copper sites precedes thermal unfolding of molluscan (Rapana thomasiana) hemocyanin

Hemocyanin (Hc) is a type-3 copper protein, containing dioxygen-binding active sites consisting of paired copper atoms. In the present study the thermal unfolding of the Hc from the marine mollusc Rapana thomasiana (RtH) has been investigated by combining differential scanning calorimetry, Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and UV–vis absorption spectroscopy. Two important stages in the unfolding pathway of the Hc molecule were discerned. A first event, with nonmeasurable heat absorption, occurring around 60 °C, lowers the binding of dioxygen to the type-3 copper groups. This pretransition is reversible and is ascribed to a slight change in the tertiary structure. In a second stage, with midpoint around 80 °C, the protein irreversibly unfolds with a loss of secondary structure and formation of amorphous aggregates. Experiments with the monomeric structural subunits, RtH1 and RtH2, indicated that the heterogeneity in the process of thermal denaturation can be attributed to the presence of multiple 50 kDa functional units with different stability. In accordance, the irreversible unfolding of a purified functional unit (RtH2-e) occurred at a single transition temperature. At slightly alkaline pH (Tris buffer) the C-terminal β-sheet rich domain of the functional unit starts to unfold before the α-helix-rich N-terminal (copper containing) domain, triggering the collapse of the global protein structure. Even around 90 °C some secondary structure is preserved as shown by the FTIR spectra of all investigated samples, confirming the high thermostability of molluscan Hc.     

Local fluctuations vs. global unfolding of proteins investigated by limited proteolysis

The structure of a protein molecule consists of both rigid and flexible sections to satisfy the demands for stability and catalysis. Because the flexibility of a protein segment is indispensable for a proteolytic attack, limited proteolysis is a superb tool to analyse both confined local fluctuations and global unfolding events in proteins. While the identification of the primary cleavage products allows the assignment of the flexible regions to the primary structure, the kinetics of proteolytic degradation enables differentiation between local fluctuations in the native protein molecule and the global unfolding process during denaturation. Modifications of the amino acid sequence in the concerned regions can tune proteolytic susceptibility and alter protein stability. In the present paper, we summarise our results on native-state and unfolded-state proteolysis of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and the effect of mutations in the detected flexible regions on the stability and unfolding of the RNase A molecule.     

Local fluctuations vs. global unfolding of proteins investigated by limited proteolysis

The structure of a protein molecule consists of both rigid and flexible sections to satisfy the demands for stability and catalysis. Because the flexibility of a protein segment is indispensable for a proteolytic attack, limited proteolysis is a superb tool to analyse both confined local fluctuations and global unfolding events in proteins. While the identification of the primary cleavage products allows the assignment of the flexible regions to the primary structure, the kinetics of proteolytic degradation enables differentiation between local fluctuations in the native protein molecule and the global unfolding process during denaturation. Modifications of the amino acid sequence in the concerned regions can tune proteolytic susceptibility and alter protein stability. In the present paper, we summarise our results on native-state and unfolded-state proteolysis of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and the effect of mutations in the detected flexible regions on the stability and unfolding of the RNase A molecule.     

NMR unfolding studies on a liver bile acid binding protein reveal a global two-state unfolding and localized singular behaviors

The folding properties of a bile acid binding protein, belonging to a subfamily of the fatty acid binding proteins, have been here investigated both by hydrogen exchange measurements, using the SOFAST NMR approach, and urea denaturation experiments. The urea unfolding profiles of individual residues, acting as single probes, were simultaneously analyzed through a global fit, according to a two-state unfolding model. The resulting conformational stability ΔG_U(H₂O) = 7.2 ± 0.25 kcal mol⁻¹ is in good agreement with hydrogen exchange stability ΔG_op. While the majority of protein residues satisfy this model, few amino-acids display a singular behavior, not directly amenable to the presence of a folding intermediate, as reported for other fatty acid binding proteins. These residues are part of a protein patch characterized by enhanced plasticity. To explain this singular behavior a tentative model has been proposed which takes into account the interplay between the dynamic features and the formation of transient aggregates. A functional role for this plasticity, related to translocation across the nuclear membrane, is discussed.