Refinement of the geometry of the retinal binding pocket in dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin by heteronuclear solid-state NMR distance measurements

The bacterial proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR) is a 26.5 kDa seven-transmembrane helical protein. Several structural models have been published at > or =1.55 A resolution. The initial cis-trans isomerization of the retinal moiety involves structural changes within <1 A. To understand the chromophore-protein interactions that are important for light-driven proton transport, very accurate measurements of the protein geometry are required. To reveal more structural details at the site of the retinal, we have, therefore, selectively labeled the tryptophan side chains of BR with (15)N and metabolically incorporated retinal, (13)C-labeled at position 14 or 15. Using these samples, heteronuclear distances were measured with high accuracy using SFAM REDOR magic angle spinning solid-state NMR spectroscopy in dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin. This NMR technique is applied for the first time to a high-molecular mass protein. Two retinal conformers are distinguished by their different isotropic 14-(13)C chemical shifts. Whereas the C14 position of 13-cis-15-syn-retinal is 4.2 A from [indole-(15)N]Trp86, this distance is 3.9 A in the all-trans-15-anti conformer. This latter distance allows us to check on the details of the active center of BR in the various published models derived from X-ray and electron diffraction data. The experimental approach and the results reported in this paper enforce the notion that distances between residues of a membrane protein binding pocket and a bound ligand can be determined at subangstrom resolution.     

Tryptophan perturbation in the L intermediate of bacteriorhodopsin: fourier transform infrared analysis with indole-15N shift.

In the photoreaction of bacteriorhodopsin, the L intermediate shows an intense band at 3486 cm-1 which is unaffected by 2H2O (Maeda, A., Sasaki, J., Shichida, Y., & Yoshizawa, T. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 462-467]. This band is shifted to 3477 cm-1 by [indole-15N]tryptophan substitution and therefore is assigned to the N-H stretching vibration of the indole of tryptophan. Free indole in carbon tetrachloride shows its N-H stretching vibration at 3491 cm-1 [Fuson, N., Josien, M.-L., Powell, R. L., & Utterback, E. (1952) J. Chem. Phys. 20, 145-152]. Thus, it is suggested that at least one tryptophan residue in the L intermediate is not hydrogen bonded.     

Changes in hydrogen bonding and environment of tryptophan residues on helix F of bacteriorhodopsin during the photocycle: a time-resolved ultraviolet resonance Raman study

Protein structural changes during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin were examined by time-resolved ultraviolet resonance Raman (UVRR) spectroscopy. Most of the 244-nm UVRR difference signals of Trp were assigned to either Trp182 or Trp189 using the Trp182 --> Phe and Trp189 --> Phe mutants. The W17 mode of Trp182 shows a wavenumber downshift in the M(1) --> M(2) transition, indicating an increase in hydrogen bonding strength at the indole nitrogen. On the other hand, Trp189 shows Raman intensity increases of the W16 and W18 modes ascribable to an increased hydrophobic interaction. These observations suggest that the tilt of helix F, which ensures that reprotonation of the Schiff base is from the cytoplasmic side, occurs in the M(1) --> M(2) transition. In the M(2) --> N transition, the environment of Trp189 returns to the initial state, whereas the hydrophobic interaction of Trp182 decreases drastically. The decrease in hydrophobic interaction of Trp182 in the N state suggests an invasion of water molecules that promote the proton transfer from Asp96 to the Schiff base. Structural reorganization of the protein after the tilt of helix F may be important for efficient reprotonation of the Schiff base.     

Vibrational spectroscopy of bacteriorhodopsin mutants: chromophore isomerization perturbs tryptophan-86

Fourier transform infrared difference spectra have been obtained for the bR----K and bR----M photoreactions of bacteriorhodopsin mutants with Phe replacements for Trp residues 10, 12, 80, 86, 138, 182, and 189 and Cys replacements for Trp residues 137 and 138. None of the tryptophan mutations caused a significant shift in the retinylidene C = C or C-C stretching frequencies of the visible absorption maximum of the chromophore, it is concluded that none of the tryptophan residues are essential for forming a normal bR570 chromophore. However, a 742-cm-1 negative peak attributed previously to the perturbation of a tryptophan residue during the bR----K photoreaction was found to be absent in the bR----K and bR----M difference spectra of the Trp-86 mutant. On this basis, we conclude that the structure or environment of Trp-86 is altered during the bR----K photoreaction. All of the other Trp----Phe mutants exhibited this band, although its frequency was altered in the Trp-189----Phe mutant. In addition, the Trp-182----Phe mutant exhibited much reduced formation of normal photoproducts relative to the other mutants, as well as peaks indicative of the presence of additional chromophore conformations. A model of bR is discussed in which Trp-86, Trp-182, and Trp-189 form part of a retinal binding pocket. One likely function of these tryptophan groups is to provide the structural constraints needed to prevent chromophore photoisomerization other than at the C13 = C14 double bond.     

Crystallographic structure of the retinal and the protein after deprotonation of the Schiff base: the switch in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

We illuminated bacteriorhodopsin crystals at 210K to produce, in a photostationary state with 60% occupancy, the earliest M intermediate (M1) of the photocycle. The crystal structure of this state was then determined from X-ray diffraction to 1.43 A resolution. When the refined model is placed after the recently determined structure for the K intermediate but before the reported structures for two later M states, a sequence of structural changes becomes evident in which movements of protein atoms and bound water are coordinated with relaxation of the initially strained photoisomerized 13-cis,15-anti retinal. In the K state only retinal atoms are displaced, but in M1 water 402 moves also, nearly 1A away from the unprotonated retinal Schiff base nitrogen. This breaks the hydrogen bond that bridges them, and initiates rearrangements of the hydrogen-bonded network of the extracellular region that develop more fully in the intermediates that follow. In the M1 to M2 transition, relaxation of the C14-C15 and C15=NZ torsion angles to near 180 degrees reorients the retinylidene nitrogen atom from the extracellular to the cytoplasmic direction, water 402 becomes undetectable, and the side-chain of Arg82 is displaced strongly toward Glu194 and Glu204. Finally, in the M2 to M2' transition, correlated with release of a proton to the extracellular surface, the retinal assumes a virtually fully relaxed bent shape, and the 13-methyl group thrusts against the indole ring of Trp182 which tilts in the cytoplasmic direction. Comparison of the structures of M1 and M2 reveals the principal switch in the photocycle: the change of the angle of the C15=NZ-CE plane breaks the connection of the unprotonated Schiff base to the extracellular side and establishes its connection to the cytoplasmic side.     

Water molecule rearrangements around Leu93 and Trp182 in the formation of the L intermediate in bacteriorhodopsin's photocycle

After the chromophore's isomerization in the initial photochemical event in bacteriorhodopsin, the primary photoproduct K makes a thermal transition to the L intermediate, which prepares the pigment for Schiff base deprotonation in the following step (L --> M). Substantial changes in the hydrogen bonding of internal water molecules take place upon L formation. Some of these mobile waters are probably involved in changing the pK of the Schiff base and perhaps that of the proton acceptor Asp85 to allow proton movement [Maeda, A. (2001) Biochemistry (Moscow) 66, 1555-1569]. Here we show that mutations of Leu93 and Trp182, residues close to the 13-methyl group of the chromophore, allow the formation of L at much lower temperatures than in the wild type (80 K instead of 140 K). Moreover, an intense band due to weakly bound water that is peculiar for L was already present in the initial (unphotolyzed) state of each mutant at 2632 cm(-1) (in D2O) but not in the wild type. This unique, intense water band is shifted compared to the L band at 2589 cm(-1) but coincides with the band seen in L', the all-trans photoproduct of wild-type L formed at 80 K. We propose that the L93M and W182F mutations induce changes in the hydrogen bonding of one or more water molecules in the unphotolyzed states of these pigments, which are similar to those H-bonding changes that take place upon formation of L in the wild type, and thus facilitate the formation of L even at 80 K. We infer that L formation involves perturbation of a site which includes retinal, Trp182, and Leu93, and this structure is temporarily stabilized by rearranged hydrogen bonds with water molecules.     

Asp85 is the only internal aspartic acid that gets protonated in the M intermediate and the purple-to-blue transition of bacteriorhodopsin. A solid-state 13C CP-MAS NMR investigation.

High-resolution solid-state 13C NMR spectra of the ground state and M intermediate of the bacteriorhodopsin mutant D96N with the isotope label at [4-13C]Asp and [11-13C]Trp were recorded. The NMR spectra show that Asp85 is protonated in the M intermediate. The environment of Asp85 is quite hydrophobic. On the other hand, Asp212 remains deprotonated and a slight shift to lower field indicates a more hydrophilic environment. Asp85 also protonates in the purple-to-blue transition of bacteriorhodopsin in the deionized membrane, where it experiences a similar environment to M. The shift of Trp resonances in M reflect a conformational change of the protein in forming the M intermediate.     

Solid-state NMR investigation of the buried X-proline peptide bonds of bacteriorhodopsin

The role of proline residues in the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is addressed using solid-state NMR. (13)C and (15)N chemical shifts from X-Pro peptide bonds in bR are assigned from REDOR difference spectra of pairwise labeled samples, and correlations of chemical shifts with structure are explored in a series of X-Pro model compounds. Results for the three membrane-embedded X-Pro bonds of bR indicate only slight changes in the transition from the resting state of the protein to either the early or late M state of the protonmotive photocycle. These results suggest that the buried prolines serve a principally structural role in bR.     

Biosynthesis of indole-3-acetic acid in Azospirillum brasilense. Insights from quantum chemistry.

Quantum chemical methods AM1 and PM3 and chromatographic methods were used to qualitatively characterize pathways of bacterial production of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA). The standard free energy changes (delta G(o)'sum) for the synthesis of tryptophan (Trp) from chorismic acid via anthranilic acid and indole were calculated, as were those for several possible pathways for the synthesis of IAA from Trp, namely via indole-3-acetamide (IAM), indole-3-pyruvic acid (IPyA), and indole-3-acetonitrile (IAN). The delta G(o)'sum for Trp synthesis from chorismic acid was -402 (-434) kJ.mol-1 (values in parentheses were calculated by PM3). The delta G(o)'sum for IAA synthesis from Trp were -565 (-548) kJ.mol-1 for the IAN pathway, -481 (-506) kJ.mol-1 for the IAM pathway, and -289 (-306) kJ.mol-1 for the IPyA pathway. By HPLC analysis, the possibility was assessed that indole, anthranilic acid, and Trp might be utilized as precursors for IAA synthesis by Azospirillum brasilense strain Sp 245. The results indicate that there is a high motive force for Trp synthesis from chorismic acid and for IAA synthesis from Trp, and make it unlikely that anthranilic acid and indole act as the precursors to IAA in a Trp-independent pathway.     

pH dependence of individual tryptophan N-1 hydrogen exchange rates in lysozyme and its chemically modified derivatives

Nuclear magnetic resonance analyses have been made of the individual hydrogen-deuterium exchange rates of tryptophan indole N-1 hydrogens in native lysozyme and its chemically modified derivatives including lysozyme with an ester cross-linkage between Glu-35 and Trp-108, lysozyme with an internal amide cross-linking between the epsilon-amino group of Lys-13 and the alpha-carboxyl group of Leu-129, and lysozyme with the beta-aspartyl sequence at Asp-101. The pH dependence curves of the exchange rates for Trp-63 and Trp-108 are different from those expected for tryptophan. The pH dependence curve for Trp-108 exchange exhibits the effects from molecular aggregation at pH above 5 and from a transition between the two conformational fluctuations at around pH 4. The exchange rates for tryptophan residues in native lysozyme and modified derivatives are not correlated with the thermodynamic or kinetic parameters in protein denaturation, suggesting that the fluctuations responsible for the exchange are not global ones. The exchange rates for tryptophan residues remote from the modification site are perturbed. Such tryptophan residues are found to be involved in a small but distinct conformational change due to the modification. Therefore, the perturbations of the N-1 hydrogen exchange rates are related to the minor change in local conformation or in conformational strain induced by the chemical modification.     

Structure-function studies on bacteriorhodopsin. IX. Substitutions of tryptophan residues affect protein-retinal interactions in bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin contains 8 tryptophan residues distributed across the membrane-embedded helices. To study their possible functions, we have replaced them one at a time by phenylalanine; in addition, Trp-137 and -138 have been replaced by cysteine. The mutants were prepared by cassette mutagenesis of the synthetic bacterio-opsin gene, expression and purification of the mutant apoproteins, renaturation, and chromophore regeneration. The replacement of Trp-10, Trp-12 (helix A), Trp-80 (helix C), and Trp-138 (helix E) by phenylalanine and of Trp-137 and Trp-138 by cysteine did not significantly alter the absorption spectra or affect their proton pumping. However, substitution of the remaining tryptophans by phenylalanine had the following effects. 1) Substitution of Trp-86 (helix C) and Trp-137 gave chromophores blue-shifted by 20 nm and resulted in reduced proton pumping to about 30%. 2) As also reported previously (Hackett, N. R., Stern, L. J., Chao, B. H., Kronis, K. A., and Khorana, H. G. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 9277-9284), substitution of Trp-182 and Trp-189 (helix F) caused large blue shifts (70 and 40 nm, respectively) in the chromophore and affected proton pumping. 3) The substitution of Trp-86 and Trp-182 by phenylalanine conferred acid instability on these mutants. The spectral shifts indicate that Trp-86, Trp-182, Trp-189, and possibly Trp-137 interact with retinal. It is proposed that these tryptophans, probably along with Tyr-57 (helix B) and Tyr-185 (helix F), form a retinal binding pocket. We discuss the role of tryptophan residues that are conserved in bacteriorhodopsin, halorhodopsin, and the related family of opsin proteins.     

The use of tryptophan mutants in identifying the 296 nm transient absorbing species during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin

The transient absorption at 296 nm was part of the spectroscopic evidence that initiated the proposal that tyrosinate (Tyr-) is formed during, and important to, the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (bR). Recent evidence against such a proposal comes from the results of NMR, UV Raman as well as electron cryo-microscopic structural studies. This makes it credible to assign this absorption to a charge perturbation of the lowest energy absorption of one of the tryptophan (Trp) residues in bR. The transient absorption at 296 nm is examined for each of 8 tryptophan mutants in which Trp is substituted by phenylalanine or cysteine, which absorb at shorter wavelength. It is shown that while all go through the photocycle, all but Trp-182 mutant show this transient absorption. This strongly suggests the assignment of this absorption to a charge perturbaton of the lowest energy absorption of Trp-182 during the photocycle. The chemical identity of the perturbing charge(s) is briefly discussed.     

The preference of tryptophan for membrane interfaces: insights from N-methylation of tryptophans in gramicidin channels

To better understand the structural and functional roles of tryptophan at the membrane/water interface in membrane proteins, we examined the structural and functional consequences of Trp --> 1-methyl-tryptophan substitutions in membrane-spanning gramicidin A channels. Gramicidin A channels are miniproteins that are anchored to the interface by four Trps near the C terminus of each subunit in a membrane-spanning dimer. We masked the hydrogen bonding ability of individual or multiple Trps by 1-methylation of the indole ring and examined the structural and functional changes using circular dichroism spectroscopy, size exclusion chromatography, solid state (2)H NMR spectroscopy, and single channel analysis. N-Methylation causes distinct changes in the subunit conformational preference, channel-forming propensity, single channel conductance and lifetime, and average indole ring orientations within the membrane-spanning channels. The extent of the local ring dynamic wobble does not increase, and may decrease slightly, when the indole NH is replaced by the non-hydrogen-bonding and more bulky and hydrophobic N-CH(3) group. The changes in conformational preference, which are associated with a shift in the distribution of the aromatic residues across the bilayer, are similar to those observed previously with Trp --> Phe substitutions. We conclude that indole N-H hydrogen bonding is of major importance for the folding of gramicidin channels. The changes in ion permeability, however, are quite different for Trp --> Phe and Trp --> 1-methyl-tryptophan substitutions, indicating that the indole dipole moment and perhaps also ring size and are important for ion permeation through these channels.     

Polarized luminescence and mobility of tryptophan residues in polypeptide chains

Polarized luminescence was used to study the mobility of tryptophan residues in polypeptide chains of different chemical composition and structural organization. It has been shown that the luminescence depolarization of tryptophan residues in coillike, helical, and β-structural polypeptide chains is mainly caused by “fast” torsional vibrations and “slow” rotational isomerization of indole groups of tryptophan side chains. The characteristics of these types of motions are practically the same for tryptophan residues included in coillike chains of different chemical structure. Helix–coil transitions in copolymers of glutamic acid and lysine with tryptophan (Glu, Trp) and (Lys, Trp) (where side groups of tryptophan residues weakly interact with the surrounding side groups) do not appreciably change the amplitude of torsional vibrations or rotational isomerization. At the same time, in the helical state of glutamic acid–leucine–tryptophan copolymers (Glu, Leu, Trp) and in the β-structural state of (Lys, Trp) copolymers (where direct interactions of Trp side groups with other side groups are possible), the amplitudes of the torsional vibrations are smaller and the rotational isomerization times larger than in the coil. The transition of (Glu, Leu, Trp) polypeptide chains into a compact state is accompanied by a marked decrease of both “fast” and “slow” intra-molecular mobility and by an increase of the contribution made by the rotation of the macromolecule as a whole, as shown by the decrease of the luminescence polarization.     

Biosynthesis of violacein: intact incorporation of the tryptophan molecule on the oxindole side, with intramolecular rearrangement of the indole ring on the 5-hydroxyindole side

Feeding experiments with a mixture of [2-13C]- and [indole-3-13C]tryptophans, of [3-13C]- and [indole-3-13 C]tryptophans (1:1 molar ratio) and of others have proved that the 1,2-shift of the indole ring occurred via an intramolecular process for formation of the left part (5-hydroxyindole side) of the violacein skeleton and demonstrated that the C-C bond from C2 of the indole ring to C2 of the side chain was completely retained for formation of the right part (oxindole side) during the entire biosynthetic process. Due to the involvement of transaminase, it has remained unresolved whether indolylpyruvic acid is the biosynthetic intermediate and/or from where the nitrogen atom of the pyrrolidone ring originates. An incorporation experiment with a mixture of [2-13C]- and [alpha-15N]tryptophans (1:1 molar ratio) verified that the nitrogen atom in the central ring was exclusively derived from the right-side tryptophan. Thus, all the carbon and nitrogen atoms in the right part of the violacein skeleton were constructed by intact incorporation of the tryptophan molecule, with decarboxylation probably occurring at a later biosynthetic stage.     

Structural investigation of the active site in bacteriorhodopsin: geometric constraints on the roles of Asp-85 and Asp-212 in the proton-pumping mechanism from solid state NMR

Constraints on the proximity of the carboxyl carbons of the Asp-85 and Asp-212 side chains to the 14-carbon of the retinal chromophore have been established for the bR(555), bR(568), and M(412) states of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) using solid-state NMR spectroscopy. These distances were examined via (13)C-(13)C magnetization exchange, which was observed in two-dimensional RF-driven recoupling (RFDR) and spin diffusion experiments. A comparison of relative RFDR cross-peak intensities with simulations of the NMR experiments yields distance measurements of 4.4 +/- 0.6 and 4.8 +/- 1.0 A for the [4-(13)C]Asp-212 to [14-(13)C]retinal distances in bR(568) and M(412), respectively. The spin diffusion data are consistent with these results and indicate that the Asp-212 to 14-C-retinal distance increases by 16 +/- 10% upon conversion to the M-state. The absence of cross-peaks from [14-(13)C]retinal to [4-(13)C]Asp-85 in all states and between any [4-(13)C]Asp residue and [14-(13)C]retinal in bR(555) indicates that these distances exceed 6.0 A. For bR(568), the NMR distance constraints are in agreement with the results from recent diffraction studies on intact membranes, while for the M state the NMR results agree with theoretical simulations employing two bound waters in the region of the Asp-85 and Asp-212 residues. The structural information provided by NMR should prove useful for refining the current understanding of the role of aspartic acid residues in the proton-pumping mechanism of bR.     

The transverse location of tryptophan residues in the purple membranes of Halobacterium halobium studied by fluorescence quenching and energy transfer

Fluorescence quenching by a series of spin-labelled fatty acids is used to map the transverse disposition of tryptophan residues in bacteriorhodopsin (the sole protein in the purple membranes of Halobacterium halobium). A new method of data analysis is employed which takes into account differences in the uptake of the quenchers into the membrane. Energy transfer from tryptophan to a set of $\text{n-(9-}\text{anthroyloxy)}$ fatty acids is used as a second technique to confirm the transverse map of tryptophan residues revealed by the quenching experiments. The relative efficiencies of quenching and energy transfer obtained experimentally are compared with those predicted on the basis of current models of bacteriorhodopsin structure. Most of the tryptophan fluorescence is located near the surface of the purple membrane. When the retinal chromophore of bacteriorhodopsin is removed, tryptophan residues deep in the membrane become fluorescent. These results indicate that the deeper residues transfer their energy to retinal in the native membrane. The retinal moiety is therefore located deep within the membrane rather than at the membrane surface.     

Spectral heterogeneity in protein fluorescence of bacteriorhodopsin: evidence for intraprotein aqueous regions

By the use of derivative spectral analysis, the broad tryptophan (Trp) fluorescence emission from aqueous suspensions of bacteriorhodopsin in its native purple membrane may be resolved into contributions from buried, surface, and exposed residues. Addition of glycerol produces a progressive enhancement of the fluorescence yield to a limiting value at about 70% v/v glycerol. Glycerol enhancement of fluorescence is also observed for monomeric Trp, and a good correlation exists between this effect and literature estimates of the fractional degree of Trp exposure in nine globular proteins. The estimate of fractional Trp exposure in bacteriorhodopsin from this correlation (50 +/- 15%) is in agreement with the value obtained by spectral differentiation and also by modified Stern-Volmer curves for quenching by water-soluble acrylamide. The absence of significant quenching by Tb(III) or Eu(III) ions, which may be expected to bind to the purple membrane surface, shows that the exposed Trp residues are in contact with water in intraprotein regions of the membrane and may be the first direct evidence for a transmembrane aqueous channel by which protons are actively transported during the bacteriorhodopsin photochemical cycle.     

Tryptophan solvent exposure in folded and unfolded states of an SH3 domain by 19F and 1H NMR

The isolated N-terminal SH3 domain of the Drosophila signal transduction protein Drk (drkN SH3) is a useful model for the study of residual structure and fluctuating structure in disordered proteins since it exists in slow exchange between a folded (Fexch) and compact unfolded (Uexch) state in roughly equal proportions under nondenaturing conditions. The single tryptophan residue, Trp36, is believed to play a key role in forming a non-native hydrophobic cluster in the Uexch state, with a number of long-range nuclear Overhauser contacts (NOEs) observed primarily to the indole proton. Substitution of Trp36 for 5-fluoro-Trp36 resulted in a substantial shift in the equilibrium to favor the Fexch state. A variety of 19F NMR measurements were performed to investigate the degree of solvent exposure and hydrophobicity associated with the 5-fluoro position in both the Fexch and Uexch states. Ambient T1 measurements and H2O/D2O solvent isotope effects indicated extensive protein contacts to the 5-fluoro position in the Fexch state and greater solvent exposure in the Uexch state. This was corroborated by the measurements of paramagnetic effects (chemical shift perturbations and T1 relaxation enhancement) from dissolved oxygen at a partial pressure of 20 atm. In contrast, paramagnetic effects from dissolved oxygen revealed less solvent exposure to the indole proton of Trp36 in the Uexch state than that observed for the Fexch state, consistent with the model in which Trp36 indole belongs to a non-native cluster. Thus, although the Uexch state may be described as a dynamically interconverting ensemble of conformers, there appears to be significant asymmetry in the environment of the indole group and the six-membered ring or backbone of Trp36. This implied lack of averaging of a side chain position is in contrast to the general view of fluctuating side chains within disordered states.     

Crystallographic studies of phosphonate-based alpha-reaction transition-state analogues complexed to tryptophan synthase.

In an effort to use a structure-based approach for the design of new herbicides, the crystal structures of complexes of tryptophan synthase with a series of phosphonate enzyme inhibitors were determined at 2.3 A or higher resolution. These inhibitors were designed to mimic the transition state formed during the alpha-reaction of the enzyme and, as expected, have affinities much greater than that of the natural substrate indole-3-glycerol phosphate or its nonhydrolyzable analogue indole propanol phosphate (IPP). These inhibitors are ortho-substituted arylthioalkylphosphonate derivatives that have an sp(3)-hybridized sulfur atom, designed to mimic the putative tetrahedral transition state at the C3 atom of the indole, and lack the C2 atom to allow for higher conformational flexibility. Overall, the inhibitors bind in a fashion similar to that of IPP. Glu-49 and Phe-212 are the two active site residues whose conformation changes upon inhibitor binding. A very short hydrogen bond between a phosphonate oxygen and the Ser-235 hydroxyl oxygen may be responsible for stabilization of the enzyme-inhibitor complexes. Implications for the mechanism of catalysis as well as directions for more potent inhibitors are discussed.