Factors affecting formation of cluster roots in Myrica gale seedlings in water culture

The effect of nutrient deficiency, aeration, phosphorus supply, and nitrogen source on the formation of cluster (proteoid) roots was examined in Myrica gale seedlings growing in water culture. Only the omission of phosphorus resulted in the formation of significant numbers to cluster roots when plants were grown in a number of 1/4 strength Hoagland's solutions, each lacking one mineral nutrient. Aeration shortened the time required for cluster root formation and increased the percentage of plants forming cluster roots. The proportion of the root system comprised of cluster roots decreased as the phosphorus concentration in the solution increased and no cluster roots formed in solutions containing 8 mg P/L. Phosphorus supply also affected total plant biomass, proportion of biomass comprising nitrogen-fixing nodules, shoot:root ratio, phosphorus concentration in the leaves and phosphorus content of the plants. The plants showed luxury consumption of phosphorus and were able to produce large amounts of biomass utilizing only stored phosphorus.Nitrogen source also affected cluster root formation. Urea-fed plants produced cluster roots more quickly and devoted a substantially larger proportion of root growth to cluster roots than did nitrate-fed plants. The longest cluster root axes were produced in nitrate-fed plants supplied with no phosphorus and the shortest were in urea-fed plants at 4 mg P L^–1.Four methods for expressing the extent of cluster root formation were examined and it was concluded that cluster roots as a proportion of total fine root dry weight is preferable in many cases. Formation of cluster roots in response to phosphorus deficiency coupled with previously demonstrated traits allows Myrica gale to adapt to a wide range of soil conditions.     

Citrate-permeable channels in the plasma membrane of cluster roots from white lupin

White lupin (Lupinus albus) is well adapted to phosphorus deficiency by developing cluster roots that release large amounts of citrate into the rhizosphere to mobilize the sparingly soluble phosphorus. To determine the mechanism underlying citrate release from cluster roots, we isolated protoplasts from different types of roots of white lupin plants grown in phosphorus-replete (+P) and phosphorus-deficient (-P) conditions and used the patch-clamp technique to measure the whole-cell currents flowing across plasma membrane of these protoplasts. Two main types of anion conductance were observed in protoplasts prepared from cluster root tissue: (1) an inwardly rectifying anion conductance (IRAC) activated by membrane hyperpolarization, and (2) an outwardly rectifying anion conductance (ORAC) that became more activated with membrane depolarization. Although ORAC was an outward rectifier, it did allow substantial inward current (anion efflux) to occur. Both conductances showed citrate permeability, with IRAC being more selective for citrate3- than Cl- (PCit/PCl = 26.3), while ORAC was selective for Cl- over citrate (PCl/PCit = 3.7). Both IRAC and ORAC were sensitive to the anion channel blocker anthracene-9-carboxylic acid. These currents were also detected in protoplasts derived from noncluster roots of -P plants, as well as from normal (noncluster) roots of plants grown with 25 microm phosphorus (+P). No differences were observed in the magnitude or frequency of IRAC and ORAC currents between the cluster roots and noncluster roots of -P plants. However, the IRAC current from +P plants occurred less frequently than in the -P plants. IRAC was unaffected by external phosphate, but ORAC had reduced inward current (anion efflux) when phosphate was present in the external medium. Our data suggest that IRAC is the main pathway for citrate efflux from white lupin roots, but ORAC may also contribute to citrate efflux.     

Phosphatase induction in roots of winter wheat during adaptation to phosphorus deficiency

The effect of phosphate supply during the first 4 weeks of the life cycle of wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Martonvásári-8) was investigated by following growth of seedlings, P levels in roots and shoots, changes of soluble phosphatases in roots and alteration of Ca²⁺ - and Mg²⁺-ATPase activity in the microsomal fraction. Plants were grown in complete nutrient solution supplemented with different levels of phosphate. Maximal growth rate was attained at 0.2 m M phosphate. The total P level in plants increased with increasing phosphate concentration in the growth solution, however, it decreased with age. Microsomal ATPase activity in 14-day-old plants increased with phosphorus deficiency. Using phosphocellulose column chromatography, a phosphatase (EC 3.1.3.2) induced by phosphorus deficiency was purified and partially characterized from the 30 000 g supernatant from roots of 14- to 30-day-old wheat plants. Na-pyrophosphate, p -nitrophenylphosphate, ATP, ADP, AMP, O-phosphoryl- l -serine and glucose-6-phosphate were all substrates for the enzyme. Its native molecular weight was 42 kDa as determined by Sephadex G-200 column chromatography. Readdition of phosphate to the growth solution resulted in a gradual decrease of the phosphatase activity, probably due to repression of its synthesis. We hypothesize that the extra phosphatase may participate in the adaptation mechanism under phosphorus-deficient conditions.     

The alternative respiratory pathway mediates carboxylate synthesis in white lupin cluster roots under phosphorus deprivation

Plant adaptations associated with a high efficiency of phosphorus (P) acquisition can be used to increase productivity and sustainability in a world with a growing population and decreasing rock phosphate reserves. White lupin (Lupinus albus) produces cluster roots that release carboxylates to efficiently mobilize P from P‐sorbing soils. It has been hypothesized that an increase in the activity of the alternative oxidase (AOX) would allow for the mitochondrial oxidation of NAD(P)H produced during citrate synthesis in cluster roots at a developmental stage when there is a low demand for ATP. We used the oxygen‐isotope fractionation technique to study the in vivo respiratory activities of the cytochrome oxidase pathway (COP) and the alternative oxidase pathway (AOP) in different root sections of white lupins grown hydroponically with and without P. In parallel, AOX protein levels and internal carboxylate concentrations were determined in cluster and non‐cluster roots. Higher in vivo AOP activity was measured in cluster roots when malate and citrate concentrations were also high, thus confirming our hypothesis. AOX protein levels were not always correlated with in vivo AOP activity, suggesting post‐translational regulation of AOX.     

Phosphorus deficiency enhances aluminum tolerance of rice (Oryza sativa) by changing the physicochemical characteristics of root plasma membranes and cell walls

The negative charge at the root surface is mainly derived from the phosphate group of phospholipids in plasma membranes (PMs) and the carboxyl group of pectins in cell walls, which are usually neutralized by calcium (Ca) ions contributing to maintain the root integrity. The major toxic effect of aluminum (Al) in plants is the inhibition of root elongation due to Al binding tightly to these negative sites in exchange for Ca. Because phospholipid and pectin concentrations decrease in roots of some plant species under phosphorus (P)-limiting conditions, we hypothesized that rice (Oryza sativa L.) seedlings grown under P-limiting conditions would demonstrate enhanced Al tolerance because of their fewer sites on their roots. For pretreatment, rice seedlings were grown in a culture solution with (+P) or without (−P) P. Thereafter, the seedlings were transferred to a solution with or without Al, and the lipid, pectin, hemicellulose, and mineral concentrations as well as Al tolerance were then determined. Furthermore, the low-Ca tolerance of P-pretreated seedlings was investigated under different pH conditions. The concentrations of phospholipids and pectins in the roots of rice receiving −P pretreatment were lower than those receiving +P pretreatment. As expected, seedlings receiving the −P pretreatment showed enhanced Al tolerance, accompanied by the decrease in Al accumulation in their roots and shoots. This low P-induced enhanced Al tolerance was not explained by enhanced antioxidant activities or organic acid secretion from roots but by the decrease in phospholipid and pectin concentrations in the roots. In addition, low-Ca tolerance of the roots was enhanced by the −P pretreatment under low pH conditions. This low P-induced enhancement of low-Ca tolerance may be related to the lower Ca requirement to maintain PM and cell wall structures in roots of rice with fewer phospholipids and pectins.     

The importance of FeEDTA for reversibility of phosphate-induced chlorosis in maize (Zea mays L.)

Chlorosis induced with a supraoptimum dose of phosphorus in nutrient solution (69 mg P l^-1) was reverted by spraying of leaves of chlorotio maize plants (Zea mays L.) with FeEDTA. Biomass formation, chlorophyll and iron content were decreased in the above-ground parts of plants grown under chlorosis-inducing conditions. Spraying always decreased content of inorganic phosphorus (P_i/Fe ratio was significantly changed), increased chlorophyll content in old plants and stimulated dry mass formation at supraoptimum phosphorus doses. FeEDTA application improved phosphate utilization (portion of phosphate in organic bonds was increased). This may be the basis of chlorosis-reverting effect of FeEDTA.     

The pattern of carboxylate exudation in Banksia grandis (Proteaceae) is affected by the form of phosphate added to the soil

Roots of a wide range of plant species exude carboxylates, e.g. citrate, into the rhizosphere, to mobilise sparingly available phosphate. We investigated the carboxylates in root exudates of Banksia grandisWilld. (Proteaceae), which occurs on severely phosphate-impoverished soils in Western Australia. Plants were grown in pots with a nutrient-poor quartz sand, with phosphate, at 25 g P g^–1, added as either K-phosphate, glycerol phosphate, Fe-phosphate or Al-phosphate.Plants grown on Fe-phosphate or Al-phosphate formed `proteoid' or `cluster' roots, and exuded significant amounts of carboxylates. Plants grown on K-phosphate did not form cluster roots; their leaves were chlorotic, and some of these plants died during the experiment. Plants grown on glycerol phosphate did have cluster roots, but their leaves also became chlorotic, albeit later in the experiment.Tri- and dicarboxylates (citrate, 60%; malate, 25%; trans-aconitate, 14%) were the major carboxylates in root exudates when P was supplied as Al-phosphate. The same tri- and dicarboxylates were also exuded when P was supplied as Fe-phosphate (31, 14 and 12%, respectively). In addition, these plants exuded monocarboxylates (lactate, 30%; acetate, 12%). We analysed the effect of the different carboxylates on the mobilisation of phosphate and Fe in two different types of soils. The ecological significance of the difference in exudate spectrum for the mobilisation of nutrients and for the detoxification of aluminium is discussed.Because the leaves of plants grown with K-phosphate or glycerol-phosphate appeared chlorotic, we analysed the concentrations of P, Fe, Zn, Mn and Cu in these leaves. Only the concentration of total P was considerably higher in leaves of plants grown with K- or glycerol-phosphate than that in leaves of plants grown with Fe- or Al-phosphate. Both the concentration of total Fe and that of reduced Fe was the same in chlorotic leaves as that in leaves of plants grown with Fe- or Al-phosphate, which had a healthy appearance. It is concluded that P-induced chlorosis was not due to a lack of total or reduced Fe; it may have been due to precipitation of Fe by phosphate.     

Differential responses of oat cultivars to phosphate deprivation: plant growth and acid phosphatase activities

The effect of phosphate starvation on growth and acid phosphatases (APases) localization and activity in oat tissues was investigated. Oat cultivars (Avena sativa L.??Arab, Polar, Szakal) were grown for 1?C3?weeks in complete nutrient medium (+P) and without phosphate (?P). Pi concentration in plant tissues decreased strongly after culturing on ?P medium. Pi deficit reduced shoot growth, stimulated root elongation and increased ratio of root/shoot in all oat cultivars. Pi deficit had a greater impact on growth of oat cv. Polar than other varieties. A decrease in the internal Pi status led to an increase of acid phosphatase activities in extracts from shoots and roots, and in root exudates. The highest activity of secreted APases was observed for oat cv. Arab, during the third week of growth under Pi-deficient conditions. The activity of extracellular APase was high in young, growing zones of roots of ?P plants. Histochemical visualization indicated high activity of APases in the epidermis and vascular tissues of ?P plants. Pi deficiency increased intracellular APase activity in shoot mainly in oat cv. Polar, whereas APase activity in roots was the highest in oat cv. Szakal. Protein extracts from roots and shoots were run on native discontinuous PAGE to determine which isoform(s) may be affected by Pi deficiency. Three major APase isoforms were detected in all oat plants; one was strongly induced by Pi deficit. The studied oat cultivars differed in terms of acclimation to deficiency of phosphate??used various pools of APases to acquire Pi from external or internal sources.     

Spatial and temporal variation in organic acid anion exudation and nutrient anion uptake in the rhizosphere of Lupinus albus L.

We investigated in situ the temporal patterns and spatial extent of organic acid anion exudation into the rhizosphere solution of Lupinus albus, and its relation with the nutrient anions phosphate, nitrate and sulfate by means of a rhizobox micro suction cup method under P sufficient conditions. We compared the soil solution in the rhizosphere of cluster roots with that in the vicinity of normal roots, nodules and bulk soil. Compared to the other rhizosphere and soil compartments, concentrations of organic acid anions were higher in the vicinity of cluster roots during the exudative burst (citrate, oxalate) and nodules (acetate, malate), while concentrations of inorganic nutrient anions were highest in the bulk soil. Both active cluster roots and nodules were most efficient in taking up nitrate and phosphate. The intensity of citrate exudation by cluster roots was highly variable. The overall temporal patterns during the lifetime of cluster roots were overlaid by a diurnal pattern, i.e. in most cases, the exudation burst consisted of one or more peaks occurring in the afternoon. Multiple exudation peaks occurred daily or were separated by 1 or 2 days. Although citrate concentrations decreased with distance from the cluster root apex, they were still significantly higher at a distance of 6 to 10 mm than in the bulk soil. Phosphate concentrations were extremely variable in the proximity of cluster roots. While our results indicate that under P sufficient conditions cluster roots take up phosphate during their entire life time, the influence of citrate exudation on phosphate mobilization from soil could not be assessed conclusively because of the complex interactions between P uptake, organic acid anion exudation and P mobilization. However, we observed indications of P mobilization concurrent with the highest measured citrate concentrations. In conclusion, this study provides semiquantitative in situ data on the reactivity of different root segments of L. albus L. in terms of root exudation and nutrient uptake under nutrient sufficient conditions, in particular on the temporal variability during the lifetime of cluster roots.     

A comparison of structure,development and function in cluster roots of Lupinus albus L. under phosphate and iron stress

Cluster roots are adaptations for nutrient acquisition, found throughout the world in many different plant families and habitats. They arise from changes in root initiation, meristem maintenance and physiology. In Lupinus albus cluster roots form under low internal plant phosphate and low internal plant iron levels. In this study, we compare morphology, structure and physiology of cluster roots formed under –P and –Fe conditions. –Fe cluster roots had a lower density of shorter rootlets than –P roots, and were yellow in colour, probably because of increased phenolics due to down-regulation of peroxidase. Rootlet length and width was reduced in –Fe conditions. The change in exudation of citrate, over time, of –P and –Fe cluster roots shared identical temporal dynamics, with an exudative burst occurring in day 3. However, the –Fe cluster roots displayed much higher rates of exudation than the –P cluster roots. Results are discussed within the context of structural and functional control.     

Identification of mutants in phosphorus metabolism

Phosphorus availability is often limiting for plant growth. However, little is known of the pathways and mechanisms that regulate phosphorus (P) uptake and distribution in plants. We have developed a screen based on the induction of secreted root acid phosphatase activity by low‐P stress to identify mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana with defects in P metabolism. Acid phosphatase activity was detected visually in the roots of A. thaliana seedlings grown in vitro on low‐P medium, using the chromogenic substrate, 5‐bromo‐4‐chloro‐3‐indolyl‐phosphate (BCIP). In low‐P stress conditions the roots of wild‐type plants stained blue, as the induced root acid phosphatase cleaved BCIP to release the coloured product. Potential mutants were identified as having white, or pale blue, roots under these conditions. Out of approximately 79 000 T‐DNA mutagenised seedlings screened, two mutants with reduced acid phosphatase staining were further characterised. Both exhibited reduced growth and differences in their P contents when compared to wild‐type A. thaliana. The mutant with the most severe phenotype, pho3, accumulated high levels of anthocyanins and starch in a distinctive visual pattern within the leaves. The phenotypes of these mutants are distinct from two previously identified phosphorus mutants (phol and pho2) and from an acid phosphatase deficient mutant (pupl) of A. thaliana. This suggested that the screening method was robust and might lead to the identification of further mutants with the potential for increasing our understanding of P nutrition.     

Phosphorus source alters host plant response to ectomycorrhizal diversity

We examined the influence of phosphorus source and availability on host plant (Pinus rigida) response to ectomycorrhizal diversity under contrasting P conditions. An ectomycorrhizal richness gradient was established with equimolar P supplied as either inorganic phosphate or organic inositol hexaphosphate. We measured growth and N and P uptake of individual P. rigida seedlings inoculated with one, two, or four species of ectomycorrhizal fungi simultaneously and without mycorrhizas in axenic culture. Whereas colonization of P. rigida by individual species of ectomycorrhizal fungi decreased with increasing fungal richness, colonization of all species combined increased. Plant biomass and N content increased across the ectomycorrhizal richness gradient in the organic but not the inorganic P treatment. Plants grown under organic P conditions had higher N concentration than those grown under inorganic P conditions, but there was no effect of richness. Phosphorus content of plants grown in the organic P treatment increased with increasing ectomycorrhizal richness, but there was no response in the inorganic P treatment. Phosphorus concentration was higher in plants grown at the four-species richness level in the organic P treatment, but there was no effect of diversity under inorganic P conditions. Overall, few ectomycorrhizal composition effects were found on plant growth or nutrient status. Phosphatase activities of individual ectomycorrhizal fungi differed under organic P conditions, but there was no difference in total root system phosphatase expression between the inorganic or organic P treatments or across richness levels. Our results provide evidence that plant response to ectomycorrhizal diversity is dependent on the source and availability of P.     

Cluster Roots: A Curiosity in Context

Cluster roots are an adaptation for nutrient acquisition from nutrient-poor soils. They develop on root systems of a range of species belonging to a number of different families (e.g., Proteaceae, Casuarinaceae, Fabaceae and Myricaceae) and are also found on root systems of some crop species (e.g., albus, Macadamia integrifoliaandCucurbita pepo). Their morphology is variable but typically, large numbers of determinate branch roots develop over very short distances of main root axes. Root clusters are ephemeral, and continually replaced by extension of the main root axes. Carboxylates are released from cluster roots at very fast rates for only a few days during a brief developmental window termed an ‘exudative burst’. Most of the studies of cluster-root metabolism have been carried out using the crop plant L. albus, but results on native plants have provided important additional information on carbon metabolism and exudate composition. Cluster-root forming species are generally non-mycorrhizal, and rely upon their specialised roots for the acquisition of phosphorus and other scarcely available nutrients. Phosphorus is a key plant nutrient for altering cluster-root formation, but their formation is also influenced by N and Fe. The initiation and growth of cluster roots is enhanced when plants are grown at a very low phosphate supply (viz. ≤1 μM P), and cluster-root suppression occurs at relatively higher P supplies. An important feature of some Proteaceae is storage of phosphorus in stem tissues which is associated with the seasonality of cluster-root development and P uptake (winter) and shoot growth (summer), and also maintains low leaf [P]. Some species of Proteaceae develop symptoms of P toxicity at relatively low external P supply. Our findings with Hakea prostrata (Proteaceae) indicate that P-toxicity symptoms result after the capacity of tissues to store P is exceeded. P accumulation in H. prostrata is due to its strongly decreased capacity to down-regulate P uptake when the external P supply is supra-optimal. The present review investigates cluster-root functioning in (1) L.albus (white lupin), the model crop plant for cluster-root studies, and (2) native Proteaceae that have evolved in phosphate-impoverished environments.