Mixed cultures: Commensalism and competition with Proteus vulgaris and Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Several modes of interaction are demonstrated and modeled in the Proteus vulgaris–Saccharomyces cerevisiae system, in particular, commensalism (citrate present. glucose limiting, the nicotinic acid required by the bacterium supplied by the yeast), and commensalism and competition [citrate absent, both organisms compete for the same limiting carbon source (glucose) and the yeast supplies the nicotinic acid for the bacterium]. By varying the medium component concentrations, competition (citrate absent, glucose limiting, nicotinic acid not limiting), mutualism (citrate excess, glucose limiting, nicotinic acid absent), and neutralism (citrate limiting, glucose limiting, and nicotinic acid excess) could also be created. Kinetic models for commensalism and commensalism plus competition were developed to describe cell growth, substrate utilization, and nicotinic acid production. Good agreement with experiment was obtained for the commensalism case.     

Commensalism during submerged mixed culture of Geotrichum candidum and Penicillium camembertii on glutamate and lactate

Geotrichum candidum and Penicillium camembertii were cultivated in pure and mixed cultures on glutamate- and lactate-based medium. In pure culture, P. camembertii assimilated simultaneously glutamate, as a nitrogen and carbon source for biosynthesis, and lactate as an energy source. On the contrary, G. candidum grew on glutamate alone. The mixed culture led to higher growth rates and then higher rates of substrate consumption and metabolite production than each pure culture; however, the behaviour recorded was similar to that observed during G. candidum pure culture, in particular the absence of lactate assimilation during growth, illustrating a commensalism between both species. The presence of G. candidum induced a form of “competition” and then a better assimilation by P. camembertii of the sole nitrogen source, glutamate, which was therefore used as an energy source in addition to be a carbon (and nitrogen) source. Lactate was only used for energy supply during stationary state, as also recorded during G. candidum pure culture.     

Parasite-host coevolution

Parasite-host coevolution can have many different endpoints, not simply the commensalism of 'conventional wisdom'. Empirical studies and mathematical models are elucidating the conditions under which parasite-host systems can coevolve to intermediate and high levels of parasite virulence - and when they can coevolve to commensalism and mutualism.     

On the structure and stability of mutualistic systems: Analysis of predator-prey and competition models as modified by the action of a slow-growing mutualist

Two basic models of mutualism are presented in which interactions among three species lead to mutualism between two of them. The models represent 2-species predator-prey or competition systems in which a third species acts as a mutualist with either the predator, the prey, or one of the competitors. The models include the assumptions that there is a cost of associating with the mutualist and that the mutualist population grows much more slowly than the other two populations. Special cases of these two models correspond to six qualitatively different types of mutualistic benefit, all of which are known to occur in nature: deterring predation, increasing prey availability, feeding on (or competing with) a predator, increasing competitive interactions, decreasing competitive interactions, and feeding on (or competing with) a competitor. These models and their special cases are subjected to a local stability analysis. The results show that mutualism based upon deterring predation, competing with a predator, or decreasing competitive interactions enhances local stability, while mutualism based upon increasing prey availability or increasing competitive interactions reduces local stability. These results clearly reject the idea that mutualism is an inherently unstable process, and reinforces the idea that each different kind of mutualism will have to be considered separately. Compared to 2-species models of mutualism, the 3-species models provide a more realistic representation of the structure of many mutualistic systems, the mechanisms by which one species benefits another, and the regulation of the interaction.     

Parasitism,the diversity of life,and paleoparasitology

The parasite-host-environment system is dynamic, with several points of equilibrium. This makes it difficult to trace the thresholds between benefit and damage, and therefore, the definitions of commensalism, mutualism, and symbiosis become worthless. Therefore, the same concept of parasitism may encompass commensalism, mutualism, and symbiosis. Parasitism is essential for life. Life emerged as a consequence of parasitism at the molecular level, and intracellular parasitism created evolutive events that allowed species to diversify. An ecological and evolutive approach to the study of parasitism is presented here. Studies of the origin and evolution of parasitism have new perspectives with the development of molecular paleoparasitology, by which ancient parasite and host genomes can be recovered from disappeared populations. Molecular paleoparasitology points to host-parasite co-evolutive mechanisms of evolution traceable through genome retrospective studies.     

Observation of a black‐cheeked waxbill (Brunhilda charmosyna) cleaning a Kirk’s dik‐dik (Madoqua kirkii)

The vast majority of interspecific interactions are competitive or exploitative. Yet, some positive interspecies interactions exist, where one (commensalism) or both (mutualism) species benefit. One such interaction is cleaning mutualisms, whereby a cleaner removes parasites from a client. In this note, we document the novel observation of a black‐cheeked waxbill (Brunhilda charmosyna) appearing to clean a Kirk''s dik‐dik (Madoqua kirkii), at the Mpala Research Centre in Laikipia County, Kenya. The purported cleaning took place for over one minute and is notable firstly for the dik‐dik remaining still for the duration of cleaning and secondly for involving two species that are much smaller than those traditionally involved in bird–mammal cleaning interactions. Unfortunately, no further cleaning events were subsequently observed, raising questions about whether this record was opportunistic or a regular occurrence. Future observations may reveal whether this behavior is widespread and whether it involves other small passerines.     

Evolution of dispersal in metacommunities of interacting species

Theoretical studies on the evolution of dispersal in metacommunities are rare despite empirical evidence suggesting that interspecific interactions can modify dispersal behaviour of organisms. To understand the role of species interactions for dispersal evolution, we utilize an individual‐based model of a metacommunity where local population dynamics follows a stochastic version of the Nicholson–Bailey model and dispersal probability is an evolving trait. Our results show that in comparison with a neutral system (commensalism), parasitism promotes dispersal of hosts and parasites, while mutualism tends to reduce dispersal in both partners. Search efficiency of guests (only in the case of parasitism), dispersal mortality and external extinction risk can influence the evolution of dispersal of all partners. In systems composed of two host and two guest species, lower dispersal probabilities evolve under parasitism as well as mutualism than in one host and one guest species systems. This is because of frequency‐dependent modulations of dispersal benefits emerging in such systems for all partners.     

A strategy for an improved separation of mammalian spermatids

A collection procedure has been developed to improve the homogeneity of mammalian spermatid populations separated by elutriation. Trypsinizied ram testis cells were elutriated at 18C. Every cell population was eluted by progressive changes in the flow rate and/or rotor speed, instead of by abrupt changes, to reduce the contamination by cells from the next population. Pure populations were collected alternating with mixed populations corresponding to the overlap between two adjacent pure populations. Furthermore, each pure population was collected into two subfractions, the second of which, contamined by cells from the following population, was pooled with the following fraction. In less than 2 hr after castration, three populations of at least 1 × 10⁸ viable round or elongated or elongating spermatids were obtained with respective purities of 95%, 82%, and 99% of the nucleated cells. In addition, two mixed populations containing only two adjacent spermatid types (round plus elongating spermatids: 98%; elongated plus elongating spermatids: 98%) were obtained, as well as a population containing around 60% pachytene spermatocytes.     

Interspecific interactions and range limits: contrasts among interaction types

There is a great deal of interest in the effects of biotic interactions on geographic distributions. Nature contains many different types of biotic interactions (notably mutualism, commensalism, predation, amensalism, and competition), and it is difficult to compare the effects of multiple interaction types on species’ distributions. To resolve this problem, we analyze a general, flexible model of pairwise biotic interactions that can describe all interaction types. In the absence of strong positive feedback, a species’ ability to be present depends on its ability to increase in numbers when it is rare and the species it is interacting with is at equilibrium. This insight leads to counterintuitive conclusions. Notably, we often predict the same range limit when the focal species experiences competition, predation, or amensalism. Similarly, we often predict the same range margin or when the species experiences mutualism, commensalism, or benefits from prey. In the presence of strong positive density-dependent feedback, different species interactions produce different range limits in our model. In all cases, the abiotic environment can indirectly influence the impact of biotic interactions on range limits. We illustrate the implications of this observation by analyzing a stress gradient where biotic interactions are harmful in benign environments but beneficial in stressful environments. Our results emphasize the need to consider the effects of all biotic interactions on species’ range limits and provide a systematic comparison of when biotic interactions affect distributions.     

The exploitation of mutualisms

Mutualisms (interspecific cooperative interactions) are ubiquitously exploited by organisms that obtain the benefits mutualists offer, while delivering no benefits in return. The natural history of these exploiters is well-described, but relatively little effort has yet been devoted to analysing their ecological or evolutionary significance for mutualism. Exploitation is not a unitary phenomenon, but a set of loosely related phenomena: exploiters may follow mixed strategies or pure strategies at either the species or individual level, may or may not be derived from mutualists, and may or may not inflict significant costs on mutualisms. The evolutionary implications of these different forms of exploitation, especially the threats they pose to the stability of mutualism, have as yet been minimally explored. Studies of this issue are usually framed in terms of a "temptation to defect" that generates a destabilizing conflict of interest between partners. I argue that this idea is in fact rather inappropriate for interpreting most observed forms of exploitation in mutualisms. I suggest several alternative and testable ideas for how mutualism can persist in the face of exploitation.     

Effects of eimerian (Apicomplexa: Eimeriidae) infections on nutrient assimilation in the Wyoming ground squirrel.

Effects of infection with mixed species of Eimeria (E. callospermophili, E. morainensis, and E. beecheyi) on the digestive physiology of Wyoming ground squirrels (Spermophilus elegans) are described. Infected and uninfected squirrels were administered arginine and methionine in saturated glucose solution. Blood was drawn at time 0 and 30 min postadministration. Significant differences were not found between infected and uninfected squirrels in plasma glucose, arginine, or methionine assimilation. In a second experiment, infected and uninfected squirrels were fed a food slurry of known caloric value. All feces were collected for 24 hr postfeeding. Differences were not detected in fecal caloric content or digestive efficiency. These results in conjunction with results reported in the literature suggest a reassessment of the "parasitic" nature of these squirrel symbionts. We propose that associations of some Eimeria species and hosts that evolve under natural conditions are examples of parasite-host interactions that often evolve toward commensalism.     

Parasitoids, polydnaviruses and endosymbiosis

Symbiotic associations traditionally have been treated as evolutionary curios rather than as a major source of evolutionary innovation. Recent research on a wide variety of organisms is changing this view and is breaking down the barriers between the traditional categories of parasitism, commensalism and mutualism, to produce a more flexible view of multispecific interactions. An especially abundant, but little discussed, mutualism exists between parasitoid wasps in the superfamily Ichneumonoidea and a novel form of DNA viruses known as polydnaviruses. Mutualisms between viruses and eukaryotes are not often reported, although as many as 100 000 species of organisms may exhibit this unusual association. In this review Jim Whitfield considers what is known about the parasitoid-polydnavirus relationship and how (and from what) it might have arisen.     

Biodiversity and evolution in host-parasite associations

Evolutionary relationships in heterospecific associations (parasitoidism, parasitism, commensalism and mutualism) are analysed through a game theory model defined in terms of fitness of hosts and parasites. In front of the game solutions (i.e. ESS) which present a great diversity of evolutionary patterns, we envisage co-evolution between hosts and parasites through the evolution of its two fundamental parameters (i.e. host's resistance and parasite's virulence). We then discuss the reciprocal influence of hosts and parasites on their respective biodiversity.     

Population biology of avena. VI. The role of genetic polymorphisms in the outcome of interspecific competition

Three different series of population samples of two Avena species cooccurring in California were grown for an analysis of the role of genetic variation in interspecies competition: I, samples from mixed fatua-barbata sites in nature, grown in mixed stands; II, samples from pure sites and grown in pure stands, and III, the same sites as in II but grown in mixed stands. Four macroenvironments and four densities were used giving a total of sixteen entries for each genetic/competitive unit in order to measure both mean and variance of survival and reproductive rates as fitness characters. Sites used in each series included low versus high levels of genetic polymorphism within each species. In general, high polymorphism favored A. fatua in competition with monomorphic A. barbata, and high polymorphism in A. barbata allowed it to compete better with monomorphic A. fatua observation fits well into the pattern of reduced polymorphism in natural mixed stands. Mean performance of polymorphic mixed stands was not consistently higher than the monomorphic combinations or pure stands but the greater relative stability over environments seemed to favor polymorphisms in one or both of the competitors. A relatively less regular pattern of density or competitive response in series III was interpreted as evidence for the lack of coadaptedness between samples drawn from pure sites. Several limitations characteristic of such controlled studies were briefly discussed; however, the tentative conclusions from laboratory studies provided several promising clues for more critical field studies.This work was supported in part by a grant from the National Science Foundation (GB 8627).     

The adaptive significance of population differentiation in offspring size of the least killifish,Heterandria formosa

We tested the hypothesis that density‐dependent competition influences the evolution of offspring size. We studied two populations of the least killifish (Heterandria formosa) that differ dramatically in population density; these populations are genetically differentiated for offspring size, and females from both populations produce larger offspring when they experience higher social densities. To look at the influences of population of origin and relative body size on competitive ability, we held females from the high‐density population at two different densities to create large and small offspring with the same genetic background. We measured the competitive ability of those offspring in mesocosms that contained either pure or mixed population treatments at either high or low density. High density increased competition, which was most evident in greatly reduced individual growth rates. Larger offspring from the high‐density population significantly delayed the onset of maturity of fish from the low‐density population. From our results, we infer that competitive conditions in nature have contributed to the evolution of genetically based interpopulation differences in offspring size as well as plasticity in offspring size in response to conspecific density.     

Adaptive indirect effects: the fitness of burying beetles with and without their phoretic mites

Summary Any behavior that equally affects a group of organisms cannot be selected by the evolutionary forces operating within that group. The evolution of such behaviors requires a population structure consisting of many groups that vary in their genetic and/or species composition. In this paper we present evidence for the evolution of behaviors with shared consequences in phoretic mites that utilizeNicrophorus beetles (Silphidae) for transport. Eighteen experiments, totalling over 1500 beetle broods, demonstrate that the mites (1) have no negative effects on the beetles at normal densities, (2) occasionally have short-term beneficial effects, (3) appear to have long-term beneficial effects that require a period of time to manifest themselves, and (4) themselves have negative effects at abnormal densities. A survey of other phoretic associations indicates a similar mix of commensalism and mutualism. We conclude that most phoretic associations have evolved to eliminate their own negative effects on the carrier, and also have evolved positive effects when the ecological situation permits.     

A simple model of host-parasite evolutionary relationships. Parasitism: compromise or conflict?

The evolutionary biology of host-parasite relationships are considered here using a simple game-theory model in which hosts play against parasite and vice versa. In this model, the players can choose between two strategies (aggressive or not aggressive) and the utility of the game is envisaged in terms of fitness and selective costs. The game solutions suggest that the two types of confrontation are encountered in symbiotic relationships and thus constitute two Evolutionary Stable Strategies (ESS). These observations lead us to discuss: (i) the status of different kinds of symbiotic relationships (i.e. parasitoidism; parasitism, commensalism and mutualism) related to selective costs and (ii) the position of coevolution in this game theory context.     

不同营养条件对东海原甲藻和中肋骨条藻竞争参数的影响

以东海原甲藻和中肋骨条藻为研究对象,采用室内单种培养和混合培养,设置不同的氮、磷营养条件,研究了不同营养条件对两种微藻的生长状况和种间竞争参数的影响.结果表明:随着氮、磷浓度的增加,两种藻的最大生物量均呈增加趋势,混合培养中两种微藻的比生长率低于单独培养.在混合培养中,生长前期中肋骨条藻是优势种,随着培养时间的延长,东海原甲藻成为优势种,且优势种发生变化的时间与营养条件有关.混合培养中,东海原甲藻拐点出现时间在0.5 ～4.9 d,中肋骨条藻为0～2.6d,东海原甲藻拐点出现时间晚于中肋骨条藻.在各营养条件下,东海原甲藻对中肋骨条藻的竞争抑制参数β均高于中肋骨条藻对东海原甲藻的竞争抑制参数α,当N为128μmol·L-1、P为32 μmol·L-1时,东海原甲藻的竞争能力是中肋骨条藻的3.8倍,两者差异最为明显.     

Ecological correlates of feather mite prevalence in passerines

The relationship between host ecology and feather mite prevalence was analysed in birds. Feather mites are small arthropods (fam. Pterolichoidea and Analgoidea) commonly found on birds, although the nature of their interactions with the host (commensalism, mutualism or parasitism), still remains unclear. Host body mass and migratory behaviour were unrelated to feather mite prevalence. Contrary to expectation, there was no differences in mite prevalence between colonial and solitary-breeding species. However, winter sociality was associated with increased prevalence, suggesting that winter and breeding sociality affected the distribution patterns of feather mites in different ways. Plumage dichromatism was negatively correlated with feather mite prevalence, a result that is opposite to that predicted by the Hamilton and Zuk hypothesis for the evolution of host secondary sexual characteristics in relation to parasitism.     

Control of phytoplankton–bacteria interactions by stoichiometric constraints

In aquatic ecosystems, phytoplanktonic organisms are the major primary producers and bacteria the major decomposers. The interactions between phytoplankton and bacteria may be dependent on nutrient resources. Anthropogenic inputs, by modifying nutrient status and stoichiometry of lakes, might induce changes in these interactions, and thus, could have many consequences on some ecological processes such as primary production or importance of microbial recycling activity.
To test this hypothesis, we grew an axenic strain of a green alga, Scenedesmus obliquus , in a range of stoichiometric situations, in absence and in presence of a natural bacterial community. Here, we show that different phytoplankton limiting factors can generate between algae and bacteria either competition for nutrients in phosphorus-limited conditions, commensalism in nitrogen-limited conditions, or mutualism in eutrophic nutrient-unlimited conditions. Causes of these different interaction types are discussed, in particular the hypothesis that in very eutrophic systems with high primary production, mutualism between algae and bacteria could be due to CO₂ supply by heterotrophic respiration to inorganic carbon limited algae. Some probable consequences for aquatic ecosystems functioning are proposed.