Gaining target access for deoxyribozymes

Antisense oligonucleotides and ribozymes have been used widely to regulate gene expression by targeting mRNAs in a sequence-specific manner. Long RNAs, however, are highly structured molecules. Thus, up to 90% of putative cleavage sites have been shown to be inaccessible to classical RNA based ribozymes or DNAzymes. Here, we report the use of modified nucleotides to overcome barriers raised by internal structures of the target RNA. In our attempt to cleave a broad range of picornavirus RNAs, we generated a DNAzyme against a highly conserved sequence in the 5' untranslated region (5' UTR). While this DNAzyme was highly efficient against the 5' UTR of the human rhinovirus 14, it failed to cleave the identical target sequence within the RNA of the related coxsackievirus A21 (CAV-21). After introduction of 2'-O-methyl RNA or locked nucleic acid (LNA) monomers into the substrate recognition arms, the DNAzyme degraded the previously inaccessible virus RNA at a high catalytic rate even to completion, indicating that nucleotides with high target affinity were able to compete successfully with internal structures. We then adopted this strategy to two DNAzymes that we had found to be inactive in our earlier experiments. The modified DNAzymes proved to be highly effective against their respective target structures. Our approach may be useful for other ribozyme strategies struggling with accessibility problems, especially when being restricted to unique target sites.     

RNA cleaving '10-23' DNAzymes with enhanced stability and activity

‘10-23’ DNAzymes can be used to cleave any target RNA in a sequence-specific manner. For applications in vivo, they have to be stabilised against nucleolytic attack by the introduction of modified nucleotides without obstructing cleavage activity. In this study, we optimise the design of a DNAzyme targeting the 5′-non-translated region of the human rhinovirus 14, a common cold virus, with regard to its kinetic properties and its stability against nucleases. We compare a large number of DNAzymes against the same target site that are stabilised by the use of a 3′-3′-inverted thymidine, phosphorothioate linkages, 2′-O-methyl RNA and locked nucleic acids, respectively. Both cleavage activity and nuclease stability were significantly enhanced by optimisation of arm length and content of modified nucleotides. Furthermore, we introduced modified nucleotides into the catalytic core to enhance stability against endonucleolytic degradation without abolishing catalytic activity. Our findings enabled us to establish a design for DNAzymes containing nucleotide modifications both in the binding arms and in the catalytic core, yielding a species with up to 10-fold enhanced activity and significantly elevated stability against nucleolytic cleavage. When transferring the design to a DNAzyme against a different target, only a slight modification was necessary to retain activity.     

Hairpin DNAzymes: a new tool for efficient cellular gene silencing

BACKGROUND: RNA-based gene silencing is potentially a powerful therapeutic strategy. Catalytic 10-23 DNAzymes bind to target RNA by complimentary sequence arms on a Watson-Crick basis and thus can be targeted to effectively cleave specific mRNA species. However, for in vivo applications it is necessary to stabilise DNAzymes against nucleolytic attack. Chemical modifications can be introduced into the binding arms to increase stability but these may alter catalytic activity and in some cases increase cell toxicity. METHODS: We designed novel 10-23 DNAzyme structures that incorporate stem-loop hairpins at either end on the DNAzyme binding arms. The catalytic activity of hairpin DNAzymes (hpDNAzyme) were tested in vitro against 32P-labelled cRNA encoding the muscle acetylcholine receptor (AChR) alpha-subunit. Resistance of hpDNAzymes to nucleolytic degradation was tested by incubation of the hpDNAzymes with Bal-31, DNase1 or HeLa cell extract. Gene silencing by hpDNAzymes was assessed by measuring reduced fluorescence from DsRed2 and EGFP reporters in cell culture systems, and reduced 125I-alpha-bungarotoxin binding in cells transfected with cDNA encoding the AChR. RESULTS: We show that hpDNAzymes show remarkable resistance to nucleolytic degradation, and demonstrate that in cell culture systems the hpDNAzymes are far more effective than standard 10-23 DNAzymes in down-regulating protein expression from target mRNA species. CONCLUSION: hpDNAzymes provide new molecular tools that, without chemical modification, give highly efficient gene silencing in cells, and may have potential therapeutic applications.     

DNAzyme-mediated catalysis with only guanosine and cytidine nucleotides

Single-stranded DNA molecules have the capacity to adopt catalytically active structures known as DNAzymes, although the fundamental limits of this ability have not been determined. Starting with a parent DNAzyme composed of all four types of standard nucleotides, we conducted a search of the surrounding sequence space to identify functional derivatives with catalytic cores composed of only three, and subsequently only two types of nucleotides. We provide the first report of a DNAzyme that contains only guanosine and cytidine deoxyribonucleotides in its catalytic domain, which consists of just 13 nucleotides. This DNAzyme catalyzes the Mn²⁺-dependent cleavage of an RNA phosphodiester bond ~5300-fold faster than the corresponding uncatalyzed reaction, but ~10 000-fold slower than the parent. The demonstration of a catalytic DNA molecule made from a binary nucleotide alphabet broadens our understanding of the fundamental limits of nucleic-acid-mediated catalysis.     

Brief communication: stability and catalytic activity of novel circular DNAzymes

DNAzymes represent a new generation of catalytic nucleic acids for specific RNA targeting in order to inhibit protein translation from the specifically cleaved mRNA. The 10-23 DNAzyme was found to hydrolyze RNA in a sequence-specific manner both in vitro and in vivo. Although single-stranded DNAzymes may represent the most effective nucleic acid drug to date, they are nevertheless sensitive to nuclease degradation and require modifications for in vivo application. However, previously used stabilization of DNAzymes by site-specific phosphorothioate (PT) modifications reduces the catalytic activity, and the PTO displays toxic side effects when applied in vivo. Thus, improving the stability of DNAzymes without reducing their catalytic activity is essential if the potential of these compounds should be realized in vivo. RESULTS: The Circozyme was tested targeting the mRNA of the most common genetic rearrangement in pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia TEL/AML1 (ETV6/RUNX1). The Circozyme exhibits a stability comparable to PTO-modified DNAzymes without reduction of catalytic activity and specificity and may represent a promising tool for DNAzyme in vivo applications. CONCLUSION: The inclusion of the catalytic site and the specific mRNA binding sequence of the DNAzyme into a circular loop-stem-loop structure (Circozyme) of approximately 70 bases presented here represents a new effective possibility of DNAzyme stabilization.     

Metal ion as both a cofactor and a probe of metal-binding sites in a uranyl-specific DNAzyme: a uranyl photocleavage study

DNAzymes are known to bind metal ions specifically to carry out catalytic functions. Despite many studies since DNAzymes were discovered nearly two decades ago, the metal-binding sites in DNAzymes are not fully understood. Herein, we adopt uranyl photocleavage to probe specific uranyl-binding sites in the 39E DNAzyme with catalytically relevant concentrations of uranyl. The results indicate that uranyl binds between T23 and C25 in the bulge loop, G11 and T12 in the stem loop of the enzyme strand, as well as between T2.4 and G3 close to the cleavage site in the substrate strand. Control experiments using two 39E DNAzyme mutants revealed a different cleavage pattern of the mutated region. Another DNAzyme, the 8–17 DNAzyme, which has a similar secondary structure but shows no activity in the presence of uranyl, indicated a different uranyl-dependent photocleavage as well. In addition, a close correlation between the concentration-dependent photocleavage and enzymatic activities is also demonstrated. Together, these experiments suggest that uranyl photocleavage has been successfully used to probe catalytically relevant uranyl-binding sites in the 39E DNAzyme. As uranyl is the cofactor of the 39E DNAzyme as well as the probe, specific uranyl binding has now been identified without disruption of the structure.     

Brief Communication: Stability and Catalytic Activity of Novel Circular DNAzymes

DNAzymes represent a new generation of catalytic nucleic acids for specific RNA targeting in order to inhibit protein translation from the specifically cleaved mRNA. The 10–23 DNAzyme was found to hydrolyze RNA in a sequence-specific manner both in vitro and in vivo. Although single-stranded DNAzymes may represent the most effective nucleic acid drug to date, they are nevertheless sensitive to nuclease degradation and require modifications for in vivo application. However, previously used stabilization of DNAzymes by site-specific phosphorothioate (PT) modifications reduces the catalytic activity, and the PTO displays toxic side effects when applied in vivo. Thus, improving the stability of DNAzymes without reducing their catalytic activity is essential if the potential of these compounds should be realized in vivo. Results: The Circozyme was tested targeting the mRNA of the most common genetic rearrangement in pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia TEL/AML1 (ETV6/RUNX1). The Circozyme exhibits a stability comparable to PTO-modified DNAzymes without reduction of catalytic activity and specificity and may represent a promising tool for DNAzyme in vivo applications. Conclusion: The inclusion of the catalytic site and the specific mRNA binding sequence of the DNAzyme into a circular loop-stem-loop structure (Circozyme) of approximately 70 bases presented here represents a new effective possibility of DNAzyme stabilization.     

Electroporation-mediated delivery of catalytic oligodeoxynucleotides for manipulation of vascular gene expression

The development of inexpensive and effective approaches to transiently decrease gene expression in vivo would be useful for the study of physiological processes in living animals. DNAzymes are a novel class of DNA oligonucleotides that can catalytically cleave target mRNAs and thereby reduce protein production. However, current methods for their delivery in vivo are limited and inefficient. In this study, we show that electroporation can be used to deliver DNAzymes to the intact mesenteric vasculature of rats. With the use of PKC-epsilon as a target, a set of wild-type and mutant control DNAzymes was designed and shown to reduce both PKC-epsilon mRNA and protein levels in cultured smooth muscle cells in a specific manner. The wild-type DNAzyme reduced PKC-epsilon protein levels by 70% at 24 h in two different cell lines without decreasing the levels of the five other PKC isoforms tested. When delivered to the intact vasculature using electroporation, the DNAzyme reduced PKC-epsilon protein levels by >60% without affecting these other PKC isoforms. Electroporation was required for oligonucleotide transfer and was able to deliver the DNAzymes to multiple cell layers in the vessel wall. Protein levels were reduced maximally by 24 h postelectroporation and returned to normal by 48 h. These results suggest that electroporation can be used to deliver DNAzymes and other DNA oligonucleotides to the vasculature in vivo and can decrease gene expression for a window of time that can be used for experimental studies.     

Targeting insulin-like growth factor I with 10-23 DNAzymes: 2'-O-methyl modifications in the catalytic core enhance mRNA cleavage

Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) and its cognate receptor (IGF-1R) contribute to normal cell function and to tumorigenesis. The role of IGF-I signaling in tumor growth has been demonstrated in vivo using nucleic acid-based strategies. Here, we designed the first 10-23 DNAzymes directed against IGF-I mRNA. Unlike antisense approaches and RNA interference that require protein catalysis, DNAzymes catalyze protein-free RNA cleavage. We identified target sequences and measured catalytic properties of differently designed DNAzymes on short synthetic RNA targets and on in vitro transcribed IGF-I mRNA. The most efficient cleavers were then transfected into cells, and their inhibitory effect was analyzed using reporter gene assays. We found that increasing the size of DNAzyme flanking sequences and modifications of the termini with 2'-O-methyl residues improved cleavage rates of target RNAs. Modification of the catalytic loop with six 2'-O-methyl ribonucleotides at nonessential positions increased or decreased catalytic efficiency depending on the mRNA target site. In cells, DNAzymes with 2'-O-methyl-modified catalytic cores and flanking sequences were able to inhibit reporter gene activity because of specific recognition and cleavage of IGF-I mRNA sequences. Mutant DNAzymes with inactive catalytic cores were unable to block reporter gene expression, demonstrating that the RNA cleaving ability of 10-23 DNAzymes contributed to inhibitory mechanisms. Our results show that nuclease-resistant 2'-O-methyl-modified DNAzymes with high catalytic efficiencies are useful for inhibiting IGF-I gene function in cells.     

The DNAzymes Rs6, Dz13, and DzF have potent biologic effects independent of catalytic activity

DNAzymes are catalytic DNA molecules capable of cleaving RNA substrates and therefore constitute a possible gene-suppression technology. We examined whether the previously reported potency of a DNAzyme targeting c-jun (Dz13) could be improved with judicious use of sequence and chemical modifications. Catalytic activity was measured to establish correlations between catalytic activity and biological potency. Surprisingly, Dz13 had significant cytotoxic activity against cells of rodent origin (IC(50) = 20-50 nM) despite having greatly reduced catalytic activity against a rodent target substrate (<25%), the latter being the result of a mismatch to the rodent c-jun sequence. In contrast, a modified Dz13 matching the rodent c-jun sequence (DT1501b) had no activity at similar concentrations against human or rodent cells despite being able to efficiently cleave the rodent c-jun sequence. Overall, catalytic activity against synthetic substrates did not correlate with cytotoxic activity and catalytically inactive mutants had in some cases equal or superior potency in cell cytotoxicity assays. Further examination of other previously published DNAzymes (Rs6 and DzF) revealed other occurrences of this anomalous behaviour. The active sequences all have G-rich 5 termini, suggesting that G-quadruplex formation might be involved. Consistent with this, deaza-guanosine substitutions abrogated cytotoxicity of Dz13. However, Dz13 did not show evidence of quadruplex formation as determined by circular dichroism studies and native electrophoresis. These data reveal that the biologic activity of several published DNAzymes is not mediated through the catalytic degradation of target mRNA.     

DNAzymes targeting the icl gene inhibit ICL expression and decrease Mycobacterium tuberculosis survival in macrophages

Latent infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis presents a big obstacle for tuberculosis therapy. In this study, we investigated the effects of sequence-specific DNAzymes targeting the mRNA of isocitrate lyase (ICL), an enzyme playing a pivotal role in the metabolism of M. tuberculosis in the latent state, on the expression of ICL and survival of M. tuberculosis. In vitro studies showed that four of five designed DNAzymes, DZ1, DZ3, DZ4, and DZ5 could cleave icl mRNA efficiently and specifically. Treatment of virulent M. tuberculosis with 5microM DZ4 plus a subinhibitory concentration of isoniazid (INH) decreased ICL expression and the survival of M. tuberculosis in macrophages but had no obvious influence on the growth of M. tuberculosis in vitro. This study demonstrates that using INH to soften the cell wall of M. tuberculosis and help the entry of biomolecules is an efficient method of improving the uptake of DNAzymes. Silencing the icl gene by DNAzyme is a promising method to combat latent infection of tuberculosis.     

Deletion analysis in the catalytic region of the 10-23 DNA enzyme

In this study, the functional relevance of the core nucleotides of the RNA cleaving 10-23 DNA enzyme (DNAzyme) was investigated. Systematic deletion studies revealed that DNAzymes lacking thymine at position 8 (T8) retain catalytic activity comparable to that of the wild-type enzyme. Deletion of the adjacent cytosine at position 7 (C7) also resulted in a highly active enzyme and even the double deletion mutant C7/T8 displayed cleavage activity, although the catalytic rate under multiple turnover conditions was found to be reduced by one order of magnitude. The identification of non-essential nucleotides in the catalytic core might help to stabilize the DNAzyme against nucleolytic degradation and to overcome problems in elucidating its three-dimensional structure.     

10-23型DNA酶作为鉴定mRNA靶点有效性的新工具

10-23DNA酶是能主动切割mRNA的一类反义寡核苷酸.利用10-23DNA酶的直接切割作用验证mRNA结构靶点的有效性.对筛选的绿色荧光蛋白(GFP)基因mRNA的4个靶点平行设计了4条反义寡核苷酸和4条10-23DNA酶,对照组反义寡核苷酸将最佳靶点——靶点2的反义寡核苷酸突变2个碱基,对照组10-23DNA酶将靶点2的10-23DNA酶结合臂中央突变2个碱基.体外4条10-23DNA酶切割mRNA的结果和相应的4条反义寡核苷酸依赖的RNaseH降解结果完全相似,细胞内4条10-23DNA酶对绿色荧光蛋白的表达抑制作用与相应的4条反义寡核苷酸相似,表明10-23DNA酶显示的最佳作用靶点同样是最佳作用效果的反义寡核苷酸结合靶.10-23DNA酶可以作为评价mRNA结构靶点有效性的新工具.     

Efficient silencing of gene expression by an ASON-bulge-DNAzyme complex

Background

DNAzymes are DNA molecules that can directly cleave cognate mRNA, and have been developed to silence gene expression for research and clinical purposes. The advantage of DNAzymes over ribozymes is that they are inexpensive to produce and exhibit good stability. The “10-23 DNA enzyme” is composed of a catalytic domain of 15 deoxynucleotides, flanked by two substrate-recognition domains of approximately eight nucleotides in each direction, which provides the complementary sequence required for specific binding to RNA substrates. However, these eight nucleotides might not afford sufficient binding energy to hold the RNA substrate along with the DNAzyme, which would interfere with the efficiency of the DNAzyme or cause side effects, such as the cleavage of non-cognate mRNAs.

Methodology

In this study, we inserted a nonpairing bulge at the 5′ end of the “10–23 DNA enzyme” to enhance its efficiency and specificity. Different sizes of bulges were inserted at different positions in the 5′ end of the DNAzyme. The non-matching bulge will avoid strong binding between the DNAzyme and target mRNA, which may interfere with the efficiency of the DNAzyme.

Conclusions

Our novel DNAzyme constructs could efficiently silence the expression of target genes, proving a powerful tool for gene silencing. The results showed that the six oligo bulge was the most effective when the six oligo bulge was 12–15 bp away from the core catalytic domain.     

Effects of helical structures formed by the binding arms of DNAzymes and their substrates on catalytic activity.

As a part of our efforts to clarify structure-function relationships in reactions catalyzed by deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes), which were recently selected in vitro , we synthesized various chimeras and analyzed the kinetics of the corresponding cleavage reactions. We focused on the binding arms and generated helices composed of binding arms and substrates that consisted of RNA and RNA, of RNA and DNA or of DNA and DNA. As expected for the rate limiting chemical cleavage step in reactions catalyzed by DNAzymes, a linear relationship between log( k cat) and pH was observed. In all cases examined, introduction of DNA into the binding helix enhanced the rate of chemical cleavage. Comparison of CD spectra of DNAzyme. substrate complexes suggested that higher levels of B-form-like helix were associated with higher rates of cleavage of the substrate within the complex. To our surprise, the enhancement of catalytic activity that followed introduction of DNA into the binding helix (enhancement by the presence of more B-form-like helix) was very similar to that observed in the case of the hammerhead ribozymes that we had investigated previously. These data, together with other observations, strongly suggest that the reaction mechanism of metal-ion-dependent DNAzymes is almost identical to that of hammerhead ribozymes.     

Characterizing the secondary structure and identifying functionally essential nucleotides of pH6DZ1, a fluorescence-signaling and RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme

pH6DZ1 is a synthetic deoxyribozyme that is able to couple catalysis with fluorescence signal generation. This deoxyribozyme has the ability to cleave itself at a lone ribonucleotide that is present between a pair of deoxyribothymidines, one modified with a fluorophore (fluorescein) and the other with a quencher (DABCYL). Herein, we report on the sequence truncation and secondary structure characterization of pH6DZ1 as well as the identification of functionally important nucleotides within this deoxyribozyme. Our data indicate that pH6DZ1 has a four-way, junction-like secondary structure comprised of four short duplexes, three hairpin loops, and three interhelical unpaired elements. Ten nucleotides, all located in two separate single-stranded regions, were identified as functionally indispensable nucleotides (complete loss of the catalytic function was obtained upon mutation). Nine nucleotides, most of which are also distributed in three single-stranded DNA elements, were identified as functionally vital nucleotides (at least a 1000-fold activity reduction was obtained upon mutation). Our study has shown that pH6DZ1 has a secondary structure that is more complex than those reported for other RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes. The identification of functionally important nucleotides lays the foundation for future mechanistic studies on this DNAzyme. The elucidation of the secondary structure of pH6DZ1 should facilitate the future exploration of this unique DNAzyme for the development of DNAzyme-based biosensors.     

Locked nucleoside analogues expand the potential of DNAzymes to cleave structured RNA targets

Background  

DNAzymes cleave at predetermined sequences within RNA. A prerequisite for cleavage is that the DNAzyme can gain access to its target, and thus the DNAzyme must be capable of unfolding higher-order structures that are present in the RNA substrate. However, in many cases the RNA target sequence is hidden in a region that is too tightly structured to be accessed under physiological conditions by DNAzymes.