Glycoalkaloid aglycone accumulations associated with infection by Clavibacter michiganensis ssp. sepedonicus in potato species Solanum acaule and Solanum tuberosum and their interspecific somatic hybrids

Solanum acaule Bitt., a wild potato species, is closely related to cultivated potato (Solanum. tuberosum L.). Incorporation of desirable traits from allotetraploid [2n=4x=48, 2 endosperm balance number (EBN)] S. acaule (acl) into autotetraploid (2n=4x=48, 4EBN) S. tuberosum (tbr) is difficult due to incongruity boundaries. In this study, three hybrid combinations, each with a specific genome constitution, were produced through protoplast fusion: (1) hexaploid 2x acl (+) 4x tbr, (2) tetraploid 2x acl (+) 2x tbr, and (3) hexaploid 4x acl (+) 2x tbr hybrids. In terms of glycoalkaloid aglycones, the hybrids produced demissidine, tomatidine and solanidine, similarly to the S. acaule parental species, but S. tuberosum synthesised only solanidine. Inoculations with Clavibacter michiganensis ssp. sepedonicus (Cms), which is the causal agent of bacterial ring rot in potato, yielded significantly lower total glycoalkaloid aglycone accumulation both in S. acaule plants and in interspecific hybrids in comparison with the corresponding mock-inoculated plants. However, in S. tuberosum the aglycone levels were either higher or unchanged as a result of infection by Cms. To incorporate the desirable traits of the interspecific somatic hybrids into 4EBN S. tuberosum, sexual backcrosses were carried out. The hexaploid 4x acl (+) 2x tbr hybrids with the hypothetical 4EBN showed the greatest capacity to undergo backcrosses with S. tuberosum.     

Using disomic 4x(2EBN) potato species' germplasm via bridge species Solanum commersonii.

The cultivated potato Solanum tuberosum Dunal has many wild related species with desirable traits. Some of these wild tetraploids have disomic chromosome pairing, ready selfing with little inbreeding depression, but have strong crossing barriers with cultivars. They hybridize most easily with 2EBN forms (which include most diploid species). Chromosome doubling to the 8x level, use of 2n gametes, use of 2n gametes of 4x-2x triploid hybrids, and embryo rescue have been proposed to overcome the crossability barrier of these species with S. tuberosum. In this study, 2x S. commersonii (cmm) was used as a bridge species with S. acaule and series Longipedicellata species. Synthetic tetraploid 4x-cmm crossed readily to disomic 4x species, resulting in fertile F1 and F2 hybrids. Some of these had 2n gametes, which enabled direct crossing to tuberosum, resulting in 6x hybrids. The benefits of this scheme are (i) hybrids are relatively fertile, so many progeny may be produced for selection at each step, (ii) hybridization with cmm results in 2n gametes needed for crossing to tuberosum, and breaks up restricted recombination within disomic genomes, and (iii) simple techniques and tools are employed.     

Unilateral and bilateral hybridization barriers in inter-series crosses of 4x 2EBN Solanum stoloniferum, S. pinnatisectum, S. cardiophyllum, and 2x 2EBN S. tuberosum haploids and haploid-species hybrids

Wild Mexican potato species are an important untapped source of useful variation for potato improvement. Introgression methods such as 2n gametes, chromosome doubling, and crossing with disomic 4x 2 endosperm balance number (EBN) bridge species have been used to overcome post-zygotic endosperm failure according to the EBN hypothesis. Stylar barriers can prevent zygote formation, bilaterally when zygote formation is blocked in both directions of the cross or unilaterally when zygote formation is blocked in self incompatible (SI) × self compatible (SC) crosses. In several Solanaceae species, the S-locus for SI has been implicated in interspecific incompatibility. The objectives of this research were to determine if: (1) disomic 4x 2EBN Solanum stoloniferum can be used as a bridge species for introgression of the Mexican 2x 1EBN species Solanum cardiophyllum and Solanum pinnatisectum, (2) pre- and/or post-zygotic barriers limit hybridization among EBN compatible Solanum inter-series crosses, and (3) reproductive barriers act unilaterally or bilaterally. Fruit formation and seed set was recorded for inter-pollinations of S. stoloniferum, 4x 2EBN chromosome doubled S. cardiophyllum and S. pinnatisectum, and 2x 2EBN S. tuberosum haploids (HAP) or haploid-species hybrids (H-S). In vivo pollen tube growth was analyzed for each cross combination with fluorescence microscopy. Attempts to create bridge hybrids between S. stoloniferum, and S. cardiophyllum or S. pinnatisectum were not successful. Pre- and post-zygotic barriers prevented seed formation in crosses involving S. cardiophyllum and S. pinnatisectum. Self compatibility in S. stoloniferum and S. pinnatisectum suggests that the S-locus does not contribute to the stylar barriers observed with these species. Alternatively, the presence of functional and nonfunctional (SC) S-alleles may explain interspecific incompatibility in intra- and inter-ploidy crosses. A non-stylar unilateral incongruity was discovered in H-S/HAP × S. stoloniferum crosses, indicating either a post-zygotic barrier, or a pre-zygotic barrier acting at or within the ovary. Furthermore, lack of S. stoloniferum pollen rejection may occur through absence of S. stoloniferum pollen-active genes needed to initiate pollen rejection, or through competitive interaction in S-locus heterozygous S. stoloniferum pollen. Introgression strategies using these species would benefit potato breeding by introducing genetic diversity for several traits simultaneously through co-current introgression.     

Frost tolerance in cell cultures of potato

Different methods of freezing and of estimating frost damage in cell cultures of Solanum tuberosum L. and a number of wild Solanum species were compared. Frost-killing temperatures (FKT, i.e. the temperature resulting in 50% of the maximum possible frost damage) in leaves of these species were -6°C ( S. acaule ), 5°C ( S. me-gistacrotobum ), -4.5°C ( S. commersonii ) and -3°C ( S. polytrichon and S. tubero-sum ) No appreciable species differences were found in FKT when cells were submerged in either buffer or medium and frozen. However, differences did exist when cells were frozen in a non-submerged condition: S. acaule and S. commersonii callus were more sensitive to frost than suspensions, whereas suspensions of the other species were the most sensitive. Measurement of freezing damage by either electrolyte leakage or by 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride viability assays revealed similar FKT values. Cell cultures of S. acaule showed better frost tolerance than S. tuberosum (FKT values were -4.5 to -6°C and -2.5°C. respectively), however, frost tolerance of S. megistacrolobum and S. commersonii was only poorly expressed at the cell level (FKT values were between -2 and -3°C). Variant cell lines previously selected for resistance to the amino acid analogues hydroxyprotine, aminoethylcysteine and 5-methyhryptophan appeared to be more tolerant to frost than the wild type S. tuberosum clone.     

Rescuing abortive inter-EBN potato hybrids through double pollination and embryo culture

Summary Regeneration of inter-EBN hybrids among potato species was achieved using embryo rescue techniques. Tetraploid hybrids between 4x(2EBN) Solanum stoloniferum x 4x(4EBN) S. tuberosum Gp. Andigena as well as diploid hybrids between 2x(1EBN) S. chancayense x 2x(2EBN) S. chacoense were obtained by culturing immature hybrid embryos in nutrient medium. Identification of appropriate embryo developmental stages was critical in developing a suitable protocol for rescuing viable hybrid embryos. The use of IVP clones as the second pollinator in 4x(2EBN) x 4x(4EBN) crosses reduced premature fruit drop and helped to identify triploid hybrids. Morphological and cytological examination confirmed true hybridity for a few of the regenerated plants. Male sterility and meiotic abnormalities were characteristic of the hybrids. Several S. stoloniferum-Andigena hybrids were successfully backcrossed to Gp. Andigena.Cooperative investigation of Vegetable Crops Research Unit, USDA, Agricultural Research Service, and the Wisconsin Agricultural Experiment Station Note: Reference to a specific brand or firm name does not constitute endorsement by the U.S. Department of Agriculture over others of similar nature not mentioned     

An interpretation of genomic balance in seed formation in interspecific hybrids of Solanum

Summary To investigate the mechanisms of seed failure in intraspecific and interspecific crosses of Solanum two diploid, S. commersonii and Group Phureja, and one tetraploid species, S. acaule, species were crossed and the seeds were analyzed for embryo and endosperm development. Many seeds of certain crosses observed seven days after pollinations were found to contain abnormal embryos and degenerating endosperms. In some cases seeds contained an embryo with no endosperm, or an endosperm with no embryo. Other interspecific crosses which were predicted to fail actually produced seeds with normally developed embryos and endosperms. To further characterize the intra- and interspecific embryos and endosperms the nuclear DNA was measured. There are several ways to explain the ploidy levels of embryos and endosperms among the crosses, the occurrence of unreduced gametes in some cases and genomic instability in other cases. The latter resulted in chromosome loss at meiotic and mitotic divisions. Genomic balance in interspecific seeds is critical to both embryo and endosperm development.Scientific Journal Series Article No. 14636 of the Minnesota Experiment Station     

The genetics of triploid formation and its relationship to endosperm balance number in potato.

The ability of Solanum tuberosum Group Andigena clones to produce triploids (2n = 3x = 36) in 4x(4 endosperm balance number (EBN)) x 2x(2EBN) crosses was investigated. The difference in triploid production among the clones tested, though large, appears to be the result of low heritability. The triploids produced in the 4x x 2x crosses did not seem to bear heritable factors that improved triploid production in 2x and 4x populations derived from them. Yet, the seeds/fruit data from a similar 4x x 2x cross fit a Poisson distribution. It was argued that the low probability nonheritable random events responsible for the triploids from 4x x 2x and 2x x 4x crosses were misfertilizations, mitotic abnormalities in the gametophyte, and (or) mitotic misdivisions in the endosperm.     

Novel inter-series hybrids in Solanum, section Petota

Sexual hybrids between distantly related Solanum species can undergo endosperm failure, a post-zygotic barrier in inter-species hybridizations. This barrier is explained by the endosperm balance number (EBN) hypothesis, which states that parents must have corresponding EBNs for viable seed formation. Tests for inter-crossability were made involving the Mexican species Solanum pinnatisectum Dunal. (series Pinnatisecta, A^piA^pi, 1EBN), autotetraploids of this species, Solanum verrucosum Schlechtd. (series Tuberosa, AA, 2EBN), haploids (2x, 2EBN) of the South American S. tuberosum L. (series Tuberosa, A₁A₁A₂A₂, 4EBN), and F₂ haploid-species hybrids with South American species (AA, 2EBN) S. berthaultii Hawkes, S. sparsipilum (Bitter.) Juz. and Bukasov and S. chacoense Bitter. The development of hybrid endosperms was investigated for these combinations by confocal microscopy with regard to cell-division timing and tissue collapse. Novel sexual diploid (AA^pi) and triploid (AA^piA^pi) inter-series hybrids were generated from S. verrucosum × S. pinnatisectum crosses by using post-pollination applications of auxin. F₁ embryos were rescued in vitro. The hybrid status of recovered plants was verified by microsatellite marker analysis, and the ploidy was determined by chromosome counting. The application of phytohormones in inter-ploidy S. pinnatisectum × S. tuberosum crosses, however, did not delay endosperm collapse, and embryos were not formed. Other diploid, 1EBN species tested in remote hybridizations with Group Tuberosum were S. cardiophyllum Lindl., S. trifidum Correll, and S. tarnii Hawkes and Hjert., series Pinnatisecta, and S. bulbocastanum Dunal., series Bulbocastana. Based on the analysis of post-zygotic reproductive barriers among isolated species of section Petota, we propose strategies to overcome such incompatibilities.     

A genetic model for the endosperm balance number (EBN) in the wild potato Solanum acaule Bitt. and two related diploid species

Solanum acaule Bitt. is a disomic tetraploid potato which has been assigned two endosperm balance numbers (EBN). It readily crosses with diploids but does not cross with other tetraploid species, although exceptions have been reported. The genetic basis of this behavior was studied in intra- and interspecific crosses involving plants of four introductions of this species and plants of one introduction of 2x S. commersonii Dun., one of 2x S. gourlayi Haw., and two of 4x S. gourlayi Haw., which have been assigned one EBN, two EBN, and four EBN respectively. Some of the pollinated pistils were used to analyze pollen-pistil compatibility reactions; the rest were left in the plants for seed production. At harvest, seeds were sorted according to size and plumpness, and the ploidy of the resulting plantlets determined from root tips. A model is proposed to explain the results of these crosses as well as the exceptions previously reported. It is based on the presence of two independent loci controlling the EBN, with two alleles in homozygosity: 1/2 and 0. This model, which is extended to cmm and grl, also explains the behavior of 3x (cmm x grl) hybrids in crosses with one-EBN, two-EBN, and four-EBN species reported in a previous work.     

Uses and usefulness of endosperm balance number

 The Endosperm Balance Number (EBN) hypothesis was developed in the early ’80s to explain the basis for normal seed development after intra- and inter-specific crosses, first in the potato and then in several other crop species. According to this hypothesis, each species has a genome-specific effective ploidy, the EBN, which must be in a 2 : 1 maternal to paternal ratio in the hybrid endosperm for normal development of the endosperm itself. This paper reviews how the EBN may act as a powerful isolating mechanism in sexual reproduction, maintaining the genome integrity of the species and playing an important role in the speciation of polyploids from diploids. We also provide further evidence that EBN is more important than chromosome ploidy in determining the success or failure of interspecific crosses. In fact, results from inter-ploidy and inter-EBN crosses to infuse 1EBN Solanum commersonii into 4EBN S. tuberosum demonstrated that the knowledge and manipulation of EBN is a useful tool in designing breeding schemes and in predicting the offspring ploidy and EBN. In this paper we also discuss the exceptions to the 2 : 1 EBN ratio, and report the evidence for endomitosis in the polar nuclei to explain exceptions to the EBN model in the potato. Received: 22 December 1997 / Accepted: 19 May 1998     

Post-zygotic gametic selection due to endosperm balance number explains unusual chromosome numbers of 3×× 2× progeny in Solanum

 Crosses between triploid and diploid genotypes are usually the best sources of trisomics in potato as well as in several other crop species. However, 3×× 2× crosses between triploid (2n=3×=36; 2EBN) Solanum commersonii-S. tuberosum hybrids and diploid (2n= 2×=24; 2EBN) genotypes gave progenies with a high number of extra chromosomes, 29–36, suggesting that only eggs with 17–24 chromosomes produced embryos that reached full development. Our hypothesis is that although triploids produce eggs with a range of chromosome numbers, 3×× 2× crosses involving a 2×(2EBN) parent favor eggs with a high chromosome number. These eggs have higher probabilities of possessing the same endosperm balance number (EBN) value (i.e. 1) of gametes produced by the 2EBN diploid parent to give the required 2:1 maternal to paternal EBN ratio in the hybrid endosperm. Under this model, trisomics are produced only if the diploid parent has an EBN of 1. Based on our results and those reported in the literature, it is proposed that in 3×(2EBN) × 2×(2EBN) crosses the endosperm balance number exercises negative selection for gametes with a low chromosome number, and a corresponding low EBN, and positive selection for gametes with a high chromosome number and EBN. Received: 2 April 1998 / Revision accepted: 27 October 1998     

The significance of genic balance to endosperm development in interspecific crosses

Summary The endosperm has played a significant role in the evolution of angiosperms because of its physiological and genetic relationships to the embryo. One manifestation of this evolutionary role is its abnormal development in interploidy crosses. It is now established that the endosperm develops abnormally in interploidy-intraspecific crosses when the maternal: paternal genome ratio deviates from 21 in the endosperm itself. We propose an Endosperm Balance Number (EBN) hypothesis to explain endosperm development in both interploidy-intraspecific and interspecific crosses. Each species is assigned an EBN on the basis of its crossing behavior to a standard species. It is the EBN which determines the effective ploidy in the endosperm of each species, and it is the EBNs which must be in a 21, maternal:paternal ratio. The EBN of a species may be determined by a few genes rather than the whole genome. This hypothesis brings most intraspecific-interploidy and interspecific crossing data under a single concept with respect to endosperm function. The implications of this hypothesis to isolating mechanisms, 2n gametes, the evolution of disomic polyploids, and reciprocal differences in seed development are discussed.     

Allelism of endosperm balance number (EBN) in Solanum acaule Bitt. and other wild potato species

The inheritance of endosperm balance number (EBN), a genetic, dose-dependent crossability system functioning in tuber-bearing Solanum (potato) species, was investigated for certain wild potato species having an EBN equal to one half of their ploidy. The EBN of Solanum acaule, a disomic 4(2EBN) South American species, was investigated by producing F₁ and F₂ hybrids with artificial 4x(2EBN) S. commersonii. This allowed assessment of recombination among the two genomes of disomic S. acaule and that of S. commersonii. When crossability of the hybrids with 1EBN, 2EBN and 4EBN standards was tested, no variation for EBN was detected. The apparent lack of recombination and segregation for EBN in these hybrids indicates that the genomes of S. acaule and S. commersonii carry EBN in a genetically-similar way. Combined with previous reports, these data indicate that the inheritance of EBN is similar in widely-separated taxa from South America and Mexico.     

Genetic control of Endosperm Balance Number (EBN) in the Solanaceae based on trisomic and mutation analysis.

The genetic control of Endosperm Balance Number (EBN) was studied using trisomics and induced mutation. In order to induce and detect a change in a factor determining the EBN of the male, pollen from tetraploid Datura was irradiated and used to pollinate diploids. No triploids were produced in over 70 000 fertilizations. At least 70 would have been expected if the deletion of the function of a single gene could change the EBN. An attempt was made to find a particular chromosome that could alter the EBN of the female when it was present as the extra chromosome in 2x + 1 x 4x crosses. In tests of trisomics in both Datura and Solanum (potato) no chromosome could be found that changed the EBN. Therefore, it is concluded that more than one gene and more than one chromosome is involved in determining EBN. Key words : crossing barriers, endosperm, Datura, potato, speciation.     

Effects of Parental Embryo and Endosperm Mitotic Cycle Times on Development of Hybrids Between Barley and Rye

Seven different barley/rye crosses were made using genotypeshaving close (predicted compatible) or dissimilar (predictedincompatible) mean cell doubling times. The relative successof the crosses was determined by a cytological study of earlyhybrid seed development and by the yield of 16-day-old hybridembryos. The results support the hypothesis that parental developmentalrates must be similar for successful hybridization. The degenerationof the hybrid endosperm occurred earlier in the predicted incompatiblecrosses than in the more compatible ones. Fewer hybrid embryoswere harvested at day 16 from predicted incompatible crossesthan from compatible crosses. We conclude that development ofhybrid embryos depends on the early stages of endosperm developmentand that mitotic rates in parental endosperms are more importantthan in embryos. Hordeum vulgare L., Secale cereale L., barley, rye, hybrid, mean cell doubling time, embryo, endosperm     

Cytological and breeding behavior of pentaploids derived from 3x × 4x crosses in potato

Cytology and breeding behavior of Solanum commersonii - S. tuberosum hybrids derived from 3 x x 4 x crosses was examined. The chromosome number of hybrids ranged from hypo-pentaploid (2 n=5 x - 8=52), to hyper-pentaploid (2 n=5 x + 7=67), with the euploid pentaploid 2 n=5 x=60 class predominant. The high variability in chromosome number of the 3 x x 4 x hybrids was attributed to the fact that meiotic restitution during megasporogenesis of the 3 x female may have involved poles with various chromosome numbers, resulting in 2 n eggs with 24-48 chromosomes. Microsporogenesis analyses provided evidence that chromosome pairing between S. commersonii and S. tuberosum genomes occurred. In addition, chromosome distribution at anaphase I and anaphase II revealed an average chromosome number of 29.5 and 29.1 per pole, respectively. To further study the extent of transmission of extra genome chromosomes from pentaploids, 5 x x 4 x and 4 x x 5 x crosses were performed, and the chromosome number of resulting progeny was determined. Ploidy ranged from 2 n=4 x=48 to 2 n=5 x=60 following 5 x x 4 x crosses, and from 2 n=4 x + 1=49 to 2 n=5 x=60 following 4 x x 5 x crosses. These results provided indirect evidence that the pentaploid hybrids produced viable aneuploid gametes with a chromosome number ranging from 24 to 36. They also demonstrated that gametes with large numbers of extra chromosomes can be functional, resulting in sporophytes between the 4 x and 5 x ploidy level. Fertility parameters of crosses involving various (aneuploid) pentaploid genotypes were not influenced by chromosome number, suggesting a buffering effect of polyploidy on aneuploidy. The possibility of successfully using (aneuploid) pentaploid genotypes for further breeding efforts is discussed.     

Secondary metabolite profile in induced tetraploids of wild Solanum commersonii Dun

The main aim of this work was to study the leaf secondary metabolite profiles of artificially induced tetraploids (2n=4x=48) of Solanum commersonii, a diploid (2n=2x=24) wild potato species. The tetraploid genotypes of S. commersonii were produced by oryzalin treatment. Both HPLC-UV and LC/MS analyses revealed that there were no qualitative differences in the metabolite profiles between the diploid S. commersonii and its tetraploids. By contrast, the results showed that the phenylpropanoid content was generally significantly higher in the tetraploids than in the diploid S. commersonii. Concerning the glycoalkaloids (GAs), the results provided evidence that the content of minor GAs (solanidenediol triose, solanidadienol lycotetraose, and solanidenol lycotetraose) was higher in tetraploids than in the diploid progenitor, while the content of major GAs (dehydrodemissine and dehydrocommersonine) was significantly higher in diploid S. commersonii than in its tetraploid genotypes. The results are discussed from the practical perspective of potato biodiversity enhancement.     

The use of Endosperm Balance Number and 2n gametes to transfer exotic germplasm in potato

Summary A triploid hybrid (2n=3x=36) between a colchicine-induced 4x(2EBN) Solanum brevidens (a non-tuber-bearing species) and 2x(2EBN) S. chacoense (a tuber-bearing species) was used as a vehicle for germplasm transfer to S. tuberosum Group Tuberosum. The use of 2n gametes from the triploid allowed the unique opportunity for transferring exotic germplasm from Series Etuberosa to Gp. Tuberosum material. The triploid hybrid used had a pollen stainability of less than 0.1%. Observations of microsporogenesis revealed that metaphase I pairing configurations were primarily 12 bivalents and 12 univalents with occasional trivalents. Anaphase I separations were irregular, often with lagging univalents. Meiotic observations and pollen morphology suggest that the stainable pollen produced by the hybrid was 2n=3x=36. A single pentaploid hybrid (2n=5x=60) was produced by the fertilization of a rare 2n egg from the triploid with a normal male gamete from the clone Wis AG 231 (2n=4x=48). Limited crosses to other 1, 2 and 4EBN species and cultivars were unsuccessful. The pentaploid hybrid had a more regular meiosis than the triploid and dramatically improved pollen stainability (37% stainable pollen). Stylar blocks prevented estimates of male fertility in crosses. Female fertility in 47 crosses with nine cultivars averaged 19 seeds per fruit. Although S. brevidens is non-tuber-bearing, and the triploid produced only stolons, the pentaploid hybrid tuberized well under field conditions, despite being very late. Results suggest that the tuberization response is a dosage and/or threshold effect. This approach to the incorporation of 1EBN germplasm indicates the utility of the EBN concept coupled with 2n gametes. Further, it demonstrates a means for the introgression of 1EBN species genes into Gp. Tuberosum material.     

Ectopic AtCBF1 over-expression enhances freezing tolerance and induces cold acclimation-associated physiological modifications in potato

We studied the effect of ectopic AtCBF over-expression on physiological alterations that occur during cold exposure in frost-sensitive Solanum tuberosum and frost-tolerant Solanum commersonii . Relative to wild-type plants, ectopic AtCBF1 over-expression induced expression of COR genes without a cold stimulus in both species, and imparted a significant freezing tolerance gain in both species: 2 °C in S. tuberosum and up to 4 °C in S. commersonii . Transgenic S. commersonii displayed improved cold acclimation potential, whereas transgenic S. tuberosum was still incapable of cold acclimation. During cold treatment, leaves of wild-type S. commersonii showed significant thickening resulting from palisade cell lengthening and intercellular space enlargement, whereas those of S. tuberosum did not. Ectopic AtCBF1 activity induced these same leaf alterations in the absence of cold in both species. In transgenic S. commersonii , AtCBF1 activity also mimicked cold treatment by increasing proline and total sugar contents in the absence of cold. Relative to wild type, transgenic S. commersonii leaves were darker green, had higher chlorophyll and lower anthocyanin levels, greater stomatal numbers, and displayed greater photosynthetic capacity, suggesting higher productivity potential. These results suggest an endogenous CBF pathway is involved in many of the structural, biochemical and physiological alterations associated with cold acclimation in these Solanum species.