Multiple conformational states of repair patches in chromatin during DNA excision repair

In mammalian cells, newly synthesized DNA repair patches are highly sensitive to digestion by staphylococcal nuclease (SN), but with time, they acquire approximately the same nuclease resistance as the DNA in bulk chromatin. We refer to the process which restores native SN sensitivity to repaired DNA as chromatin rearrangement. We find that during repair of ultraviolet damage in human fibroblasts, repair patch synthesis and ligation occur at approximately the same rate, with ligation delayed by about 4 min, but that chromatin rearrangement is only 75% as rapid. Thus, repair-incorporated nucleotides can exist in at least three distinct states: unligated/unrearranged, ligated/unrearranged, and ligated/rearranged. Inhibition of repair patch synthesis by aphidicolin or hydroxyurea results in inhibition of both patch ligation and chromatin rearrangement, confirming that repair patch completion and/or ligation are prerequisites for rearrangement. We also analyze the kinetics of SN digestion of repair-incorporated nucleotides at various extents of rearrangement and find the data to be consistent with the existence of two or more forms of unrearranged repair patch which have different sensitivities to digestion by SN. These data indicate that the chromatin rearrangement which restores native SN sensitivity to repaired DNA is a multistep process. The multiple forms of unrearranged chromatin with different SN sensitivities may include the unligated/unrearranged and ligated/unrearranged states. If so, the differences in SN sensitivity must arise from differences in chromatin structure, because SN does not differentiate between ligated and unligated repair patches in naked DNA.     

Similar distributions of repaired sites in chromatin of normal and xeroderma pigmentosum variant cells damaged by ultraviolet light

Excision repair of damage from ultraviolet light in both normal and xeroderma pigmentosum variant fibroblasts at early times after irradiation occurred preferentially in regions of DNA accessible to micrococcal nuclease digestion. These regions are predominantly the linker regions between nucleosomes in chromatin. The alterations reported at polymerization and ligation steps of excision repair in the variant are therefore not associated with changes in the relative distributions of repair sites in linker and core particle regions of DNA.     

Nucleosome rearrangement in human cells following short patch repair of DNA damaged by bleomycin.

We have examined the structure of newly repaired regions of chromatin in intact and permeabilized human cells following exposure to bleomycin (BLM). The average repair patch size (in permeabilized cells) was six to nine bases, following doses of 1-25 micrograms/mL BLM, and greater than 80% of the total repair synthesis was resistant to aphidicolin. In both intact and permeabilized cells, nascent repair patches were initially very sensitive to staphylococcal nuclease, analogous to repair induced by "long patch" agents, and are nearly absent from isolated nucleosome core DNA. Unlike long patch repair, however, the loss of nuclease sensitivity during subsequent chase periods was very slow in intact cells, or in permeabilized cells treated with a low dose of BLM (1 microgram/mL), and was abolished by treatment with hydroxyurea (HU) or aphidicolin (APC). The rate of repair patch ligation did not correlate with this slow rate of chromatin rearrangement since greater than 95% of the patches were ligated within 6 h after incorporation (even in the presence of HU or APC). In permeabilized cells, repair patches induced by either 5 or 25 micrograms/mL BLM, where significant levels of strand breaks occur in compact regions of chromatin, lost the enhanced nuclease sensitivity at a rate similar to that observed following long patch repair. This rapid rate of rearrangement was not affected by APC. These results indicate that short patch repair in linker regions of nucleosomes, and/or "open" regions of chromatin, involves much less nucleosome rearrangement than long patch repair or short patch repair in condensed chromatin domains.     

The endogenous nuclease sensitivity of repaired DNA in human fibroblasts

The limited DNA excision repair that occurs in the chromatin of UV-irradiated growth arrested cells isolated from a xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) complementation group C patient is clustered in localized regions. The repaired DNA was found to be more sensitive to nicking by endogenous nucleases than the bulk of the DNA. The extra-sensitivity does not change with increasing amounts of DNA damage or repair activity in the locally-repaired regions and is retained through a 24-h chase period. We suggest that these results are due to the occurrence of DNA repair limited to pre-existing, non-transient chromatin fractions that contain actively transcribed DNA. A similar extra-sensitivity of repaired DNA was not detected in cells of normal or XP complementation group A strains that exhibit either normal or limited repair located randomly throughout their genomes. The association between endogenous nuclease sensitivity and clustered repair probably defines a normal excision repair pathway that is specific for selected chromatin domains. The repair defect in XP-C strains may be one in pathways targeted for other endogenous nuclease-resistant domains.     

Distribution of DNA damage in chromatin and its relation to repair in human cells treated with 7-bromomethylbenz(a) anthracene.

We have examined the relationship between the distribution of DNA damage and repair in chromatin from confluent human fibroblasts treated with the carcinogen 7-bromomethylbenz (a) anthracene. Analysis of staphylococcal nuclease (SN)4 digestion kinetics and gel electrophoresis revealed that more total damage occurs in nucleosome core DNA (approximately 80-85% of chromatin DNA) than in SN sensitive DNA (APPROXIMATELY15-20%). Furthermore, over a 24 hr period, damage is removed at about the same rate from these two regions. In contrast, virtually all of the nucleotides incorporated during repair synthesis are initially SN sensitive even when measured at 12 hr after damage. With time many repair-incorporated nucleotides become SN resistant and coelectrophorese with nucleosome core DNA. To explain these data we propose a model whereby excision repair occurs in both linker and core DNA; however, in core DNA the repair process induces conformational changes resulting in temporarily increased SN sensitivity; subsequently, rearrangement occurs and results in the re-establishment of native or near-native nucleosome conformation and SN resistance.     

Comparison of the subunit organization of early and late replicating chromatin

A comparison was made of the subunit organization of chromatin from regions of the genome with different metaphase chromosome banding characteristics by analyzing the accessibility of early and late replicating DNA in synchronized Chinese hamster ovary cells to digestion with staphylococcal nuclease. Three measures of nuclease susceptibility were employed: (1) the release of acid-soluble material; (2) a digestion index, P, which corresponds to the proportion of internucleosome segments which experienced at least one cleavage event; and (3) the size distribution of DNA fragments isolated from digested chromatin. Little or no difference was observed in the initial rates with which nuclease converted early and late replicating chromatin to acid-soluble material, although the initial digestion rates varied with time of cell collection in the cycle (metaphase > G1 mid-S > late-S or G2). Measurements of the digestion indices of material isolated from interphase cells suggested that initial cleavage events were more rapid in early replicating chromatin than in late replicating chromatin. In contrast, electrophoretic analysis revealed that oligomer DNA fragments from early labelled metaphase chromatin were slightly larger than corresponding fragments from late labelled metaphase chromatin. The size distribution of DNA in submonomer fragments obtained from extensively digested chromatin appeared to be identical regardless of the timing of replication or cell collection. Those small differences in chromatin digestibility that were observed may reflect subtle variations in the accessibility of internucleosome regions or perhaps in the higher-order arrangement of nucleosomes. However, no gross variation in accessibility to staphylococcal nuclease digestion was observed in chromatin localized to metaphase chromosome regions with vastly different cytological staining properties.     

Transient conformation changes in chromatin during excision repair of ultraviolet damage to DNA.

DNA labeled for 15 minutes during UV induced repair synthesis is two-fold more sensitive to micrococcal nuclease than the bulk nuclear DNA. As the length of the labeling period increases from 15 minutes to 4 hours the nuclease sensitivity of repair labeled DNA approaches that of bulk chromatin. Pulse-chase experiments indicate that the nuclease sensitivity of the repaired DNA labeled during a brief pulse decreases with a half-life of about 15 minutes. In contrast to previous interpretations, we consider these results to mean that immediately after synthesis, chromatin labeled during repair has a conformation which renders it more susceptible to nuclease digestion than the bulk chromatin. With time these repaired regions are assembled into a nucleosome structure with normal nuclease sensitivity.     

The distribution of DNA repair synthesis in chromatin and its rearrangement following damage with N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene.

The distribution of DNA repair synthesis in the chromatin of confluent human diploid fibroblasts damaged with N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene has been studied. Kinetic analysis of staphylococcal nuclease digestion data revealed that initially most of the repair synthesis occurred in nuclease sensitive regions of chromatin. Continuous labeling experiments and pulse chase experiments indicated that with time much of the 3H dThd initially incorporated into nuclease sensitive regions during repair appeared in nuclease resistant regions. Agarose gel electrophoresis was used to demonstrate that these resistant regions were core DNA. In agreement with previous findings [Smerdon, M.J. and Lieberman, M.W., (1978), Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, in press], studies of the time course of this rearrangement and of repair synthesis revealed similar time dependences and suggested a relationship between rates of repair synthesis and chromatin rearrangement.     

The photoaddition of trimethylpsoralen to Drosophila melanogaster nuclei: a probe for chromatin substructure.

Derivatives of the furocoumarin, psoralen, can penetrate intact cells or nuclei and cross-link opposite strands of the chromosomal DNA under the influence of long wave-length ultraviolet light. The potential of trioxsalen (4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen) as a probe for chromatin structure has been investigated. The DNA in both embryo nuclei and tissue culture cells from Drosophila melanogaster was found to be about 90% protected from trioxsalen binding relative to purified DNA. Digestion of trioxsalen-treated nuclei by micrococcal nuclease and gel electrophoresis of the resulting DNA gave the same type of band pattern that is characteristic of native, untreated nuclei are digestion. Nuclease digestion was therefore used to examine the distribution of bound trioxsalen in the DNA. The resulting DNA fragments were analyzed both by radioactivity measurements and quantitative electron microscopy. The nuclease cleaved intact photoreacted nuclei in such a way that preferential excision of trioxsalen containing regions of the DNA occurred, but, when acting upon purified DNA that contained bount trioxsalen, it attacked the trioxsalen-free regions preferentially. It was thus concluded that trixosalen binds at the sites corresponding to the regular nuclease-sensitive regions of the chromatin in nuclei.     

Rearrangements of chromatin structure in newly repaired regions of deoxyribonucleic acid in human cells treated with sodium butyrate or hydroxyurea

The rate and extent of redistribution of repair-incorporated nucleotides within chromatin during very early times (10-45 min) after ultraviolet irradiation were examined in normal human fibroblasts treated with 20 mM sodium butyrate, or 2-10 mM hydroxyurea, and compared to results for untreated cells. Under these conditions, DNA replicative synthesis is reduced to very low levels in each case. However, DNA repair synthesis is stimulated by sodium butyrate and partially inhibited by hydroxyurea. Furthermore, in the sodium butyrate treated cells, the core histones are maximally hyperacetylated. Using methods previously described by us, it was found that treatment with sodium butyrate had little or no effect on either the rate or the extent of redistribution of repair-incorporated nucleotides during this early time interval. On the other hand, there was a 1.7-2.5-fold decrease in the rate of redistribution of these nucleotides in cells treated with hydroxyurea; the extent of redistribution was unchanged in these cells. Since hydroxyurea has been shown to decrease the rate of completion of "repair patches" in mammalian cells, these results indicate that nucleosome rearrangement in newly repaired regions of DNA does not occur until after the final stages of the excision repair process are completed. Furthermore, hyperacetylation of the core histones in a large fraction of the total chromatin prior to DNA damage and repair synthesis does not appear to alter the rate or extent of nucleosome core formation in newly repaired regions of DNA.     

Minichromosome assembly accompanying repair-type DNA synthesis in Xenopus oocytes.

Minichromosomes were assembled by injection of circular DNA into the nucleus of Xenopus oocytes. We observed that, in the course of DNA supercoiling and chromatin assembly, a small percentage of the injected DNA molecules incorporated a radioactive precursor. This DNA synthesis was carried out by aphidicolin-sensitive DNA polymerase, and generated short repair-like patches covalently linked to the injected DNA. We found that the DNA thus repaired was rapidly supercoiled almost to completion within 15 to 30 min after injection, whereas 60 to 120 min were required to supercoil the intact, bulk DNA molecules. Such differential supercoiling kinetics was also observed when UV-damaged DNA was injected. Chromatin assembly, which was characterized by DNA fragment sizes protected from micrococcal nuclease digestion, was consistent with the rapid DNA supercoiling and proceeded more efficiently on the repaired DNA. These results indicate that there are at least two kinetically distinct ways of assembling minichromosomes in the oocyte nucleus, and that the repaired DNA molecules preferentially follow the faster pathway.     

Methylation of chromatin DNA.

E. coli DNA methylase has been used to methylate chromatin DNA in vitro. At saturation only 50% of the chromatin DNA becomes methylated. The methylated regions of chromatin correspond to that fraction of the chromatin which is sensitive to staphylococcal nuclease. Using in vitro methylated chromatin followed by nuclease digestion movement of chromatin proteins along the DNA can be detected. By this criterion, sonication of chromatin or precipitation with MnCl2 causes 10% of the previously uncovered methylated regions to become covered by protein. Reconstitution of methylated chromatin results in the randomization of the chromatin proteins. Using nuclei which were methylated in vitro we have demonstrated that a small degree of protein sliding does occur during the preparation of chromatin from nuclei. Finally, we have prepared open region DNA by polylysine titration. This procedure does not cause displacement of chromatin proteins.     

Characterization of biotinylated repair regions in reversibly permeabilized human fibroblasts.

We have examined the incorporation of biotinyl-11-deoxyuridine triphosphate (BiodUTP) into excision repair patches of UV-irradiated confluent human fibroblasts. Cells were reversibly permeabilized to BiodUTP with lysolecithin, and biotin was detected in DNA on nylon filters using a streptavidin/alkaline phosphatase colorimetric assay. Following a UV dose of 12 J/m2, maximum incorporation of BioUTP occurred at a lysolecithin concentration (80-100 micrograms/mL) similar to that for incorporation of dTTP. Incorporation of BiodUTP into repair patches increased with UV dose up to 4 and 8 J/m2 in two normal human fibroblast strains, while no incorporation of BiodUTP was observed in xeroderma pigmentosum (group A) human fibroblasts. The repair-incorporated biotin was not removed from the DNA over a 48-h period, and only slowly disappeared after longer times (approximately 30% in 72 h), while little of the biotin remained in cells induced to divide. Furthermore, the stability of the biotin in repaired DNA was unaffected by a second dose of UV radiation several hours after the biotin-labeling period to induce a "second round" of excision repair. Exonuclease III digestion and gap-filling with DNA polymerase I indicate that the majority of biotin-labeled repair patches (approximately 80%) are rapidly ligated in confluent human cells. However, the remaining patches were not ligated after a 24-h chase period, in contrast to dTTP-labeled repair patches. The BiodUMP repair label in both chromatin and DNA is preferentially digested by staphylococcal nuclease, preventing the use of this enzyme for nucleosome mapping in these regions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Clusters of S1 nuclease-hypersensitive sites induced in vivo by DNA damage.

DNA end-labeling procedures were used to analyze both the frequency and distribution of DNA strand breaks in mammalian cells exposed or not to different types of DNA-damaging agents. The 3' ends were labeled by T4 DNA polymerase-catalyzed nucleotide exchange carried out in the absence or presence of Escherichia coli endonuclease IV to cleave abasic sites and remove 3' blocking groups. Using this sensitive assay, we show that DNA isolated from human cells or mouse tissues contains variable basal levels of DNA strand interruptions which are associated with normal bioprocesses, including DNA replication and repair. On the other hand, distinct dose-dependent patterns of DNA damage were assessed quantitatively in cultured human cells exposed briefly to menadione, methylmethane sulfonate, topoisomerase II inhibitors, or gamma rays. In vivo induction of single-strand breaks and abasic sites by methylmethane sulfonate was also measured in several mouse tissues. The genomic distribution of these lesions was investigated by DNA cleavage with the single-strand-specific S1 nuclease. Strikingly similar cleavage patterns were obtained with all DNA-damaging agents tested, indicating that the majority of S1-hypersensitive sites detected were not randomly distributed over the genome but apparently were clustered in damage-sensitive regions. The parallel disappearance of 3' ends and loss of S1-hypersensitive sites during post-gamma-irradiation repair periods indicates that these sites were rapidly repaired single-strand breaks or gaps (2- to 3-min half-life). Comparison of S1 cleavage patterns obtained with gamma-irradiated DNA and gamma-irradiated cells shows that chromatin structure was the primary determinant of the distribution of the DNA damage detected.