Binding and activation of rod outer segment phosphodiesterase and guanosine triphosphate binding protein by disc membranes: influence of reassociation method and divalent cations

Attempts to optimize the recovery of light-stimulated phosphodiesterase activity following reassociation of the hypotonically extractable proteins derived from retinal rod segments with hypotonically stripped disc membranes lead to the following observations: the best reassociations were obtained by mixing proteins and stripped disc membranes under hypotonic conditions and slowly increasing the salt concentration; the binding of G-protein and phosphodiesterase to stripped disc membrane occurs in less than 5 minutes and the recovery of light-stimulated phosphodiesterase activation in response to subsaturating stimulus levels requires 2-3 h to plateau. Stripped disc membranes and proteins were reassociated in 'isotonic' buffers containing KCl/NaCl, KCl/NaCl plus Mg2+, or KCl/NaCl plus Ca2+. Large fractional rhodopsin bleaches produced nearly identical light-stimulated phosphodiesterase activities in each of these samples and in the control rod outer segment membranes. Rod outer segment membranes and reassociated stripped disc membrane samples containing divalent cations showed similar phosphodiesterase activities in response to low fractional rhodopsin bleaches (e.g. less than or equal to 0.1%), however, samples devoid of divalent cations during reassociation required rhodopsin bleaches up to 10-fold larger to elicit comparable phosphodiesterase activities. These results suggest that not all phosphodiesterase and/or G-protein molecules bound to the disc membrane surface are equivalent with regard to their efficiency of activation by bleached rhodopsin and that divalent cations can modulate the distribution of G-protein and/or phosphodiesterase between these populations.     

Light-induced phosphorylation of rod outer segments by guanosine triphosphate.

Significant GTP-dependent protein kinase activity is present in isolated photoreceptors of the retina. No transfer of the γ-³²P group from GTP-γ-³²P to ATP was detected. Although no stimulation of GTP-kinase activity by cyclic GMP or cyclic AMP was observed, exposure of dark-adapted photoreceptors to light resulted in a 46-fold increase in protein phosphorylation.     

Lipid-protein interactions in frog rod outer segment disc membranes. Characterization by spin labels

Freely-diffusing phospholipid spin labels have been employed to study rhodopsin-lipid interactions in frog rod outer segment disc membranes. Examination of the ESR spectra leads us to the conclusion that there are two motionally distinguishable populations of lipid existing in frog rod outer segment membranes over a wide physiological temperature range. Each of the spin probes used shows a two-component electron spin resonance (ESR) spectrum, one component of which is motionally restricted on the ESR timescale, and represents between 33 and 40% of the total integrated spectral intensity. The second spectral component which accounts for the remainder of the spectral intensity possesses a lineshape characteristic of anisotropic motion in a lipid bilayer, very similar in shape to that observed from the same spin labels in dispersions of whole extracted frog rod outer segment lipid. The motionally restricted spectral component is attributed to those spin labels in contact with the surface of rhodospin, while the major component is believed to originate from spin labels in the fluid lipid bilayer region of the membranes. Calculations indicate that the motionally restricted lipid is sufficient to cover the protein surface. This population of lipids is shown here and elsewhere (Watts, A., Volotovski, I.D. and Marsh, D. (1979) Biochemistry 18, 5006-5013) to be by no means rigidly immobilized, having motion in the 20 ns time regime as opposed to motions in the one nanosecond time regime found in the fluid bilayer. Little selectivity for the motionally restricted population is observed between the different spin-labelled phospholipid classes nor with a spin-labelled fatty acid or sterol.     

Transverse location of the retinal chromophore of rhodopsin in rod outer segment disc membranes

Diffusion-enhanced fluorescence energy transfer was used to study the structure of photoreceptor membranes from bovine retinal rod outer segments. The fluorescent energy donor was Tb³⁺ chelated to dipicolinate and the acceptor was the 11-cis retinal chromophore of rhodopsin in vesicles made from disc membranes. The rapid-diffusion limit for energy transfer was attained in these experiments because of the long excited state lifetime of the terbium donor (~2 ms). Under these conditions, energy transfer is very sensitive to a, the distance of closest approach between the donor and acceptor (Thomas et al., 1978). Vesicles containing terbium dipicolinate in their inner aqueous space were prepared by sonicating disc membranes in the presence of this chelate and chromatographing this mixture on a gel filtration column. The sidedness of rhodopsin in these vesicles was the same as in native disc membranes. The transfer efficiency from terbium to retinal in this sample was 43%. For an R₀ value of 46.7 Å and an average vesicle diameter of 650 Å, this corresponds to an a value of 22 Å from the inner aqueous space of the vesicle. The distance of closest approach from the external aqueous space, determined by adding terbium dipicolinate to a suspension of already formed vesicles, was found to be 28 Å. These values of a show that the retinal chromophore is far from both aqueous surfaces of the disc membrane. Hence, the transverse location of the retinal chromophore is near the center of the hydrophobic core of the disc membrane. These findings suggest that conformational changes induced by photoisomerization are transmitted through a distance of at least 20 Å within rhodopsin to trigger subsequent events in visual excitation.     

Membrane stimulation of cGMP phosphodiesterase activation by transducin: comparison of phospholipid bilayers to rod outer segment membranes.

To clarify the role of phospholipids in G protein-effector interactions of vertebrate phototransduction, transducin activation of cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE) has been reconstituted on the surface of well-defined phosphatidylcholine (PC) vesicles, using purified proteins from bovine rod outer segments (ROS). PC vesicles enhanced PDE stimulation by the GTP-gamma S-bound transducin alpha subunit (T alpha-GTP gamma S) as much as 17-fold over activation in the absence of membranes. In the presence of 3.5 microM accessible PC in the form of large (100 nm) unilamellar vesicles, 500 nM T alpha-GTP gamma S stimulated PDE activity to more than 70% of the maximum activity induced by trypsin. Activation required PC, PDE, and T alpha-GTP gamma S, but did not require prior incubation of any of the components, and occurred within 4 s of mixing. The PC vesicles were somewhat more efficient than urea-washed ROS membranes in enhancing PDE activation. Half-maximal activation occurred at accessible phospholipid concentrations of 3.8 microM for PC vesicles, and 13 microM for ROS membranes. Titrations of PDE with T alpha-GTP gamma S in the presence of membranes indicated a high-affinity (Kact less than 250 pM) activation of PDE by a small fraction (0.5-5%) of active T alpha-GTP gamma S, as did titrations of ROS with GTP gamma S. When activation by PC vesicles was compared to PDE binding to membranes, the results were consistent with activation enhancement resulting from formation of a T alpha-GTP gamma S-dependent PDE-membrane complex with half-maximal binding at phospholipid concentrations in the micromolar range. The value of the apparent dissociation constant, KPL, associated with the activation enhancement was estimated to be in the range of 2.5 nM (assuming an upper limit value of 1600 phospholipids/site) to 80 nM (for a lower limit value of 50 phospholipids/site). Another component of membrane binding was more than 100-fold weaker and was not correlated with activation by T alpha-GTP gamma S. Low ionic strength disrupted the ability of ROS membranes, but not PC vesicles, to bind and activate PDE. Removal of PDE's membrane-binding domain by limited trypsin digestion eliminated both the binding of PDE to vesicles and the ability of PDE to be activated by T alpha-GTP gamma S and membranes. These results suggest that ROS membrane stimulation of PDE activation by T alpha-GTP gamma S is due almost exclusively to the phospholipids in the disk membrane.     

Cation selectivity of and cation binding to the cGMP-dependent channel in bovine rod outer segment membranes

The properties of the cGMP-dependent channel present in membrane vesicles prepared from intact isolated bovine rod outer segments (ROS) were investigated with the optical probe neutral red. The binding of neutral red is sensitive to transport of cations across vesicular membranes by the effect of the translocated cations on the surface potential at the intravesicular membrane/water interface (Schnetkamp, P. P. M. J. Membr. Biol. 88: 249-262). Only 20-25% of ROS membrane vesicles exhibited cGMP-dependent cation fluxes. The cGMP-dependent channel in bovine ROS carried currents of alkali and earth alkali cations, but not of organic cations such as choline and tetramethylammonium; little discrimination among alkali cations (K greater than Na = Li greater than Cs) or among earth alkali cations (Ca greater than Mn greater than Sr greater than Ba = Mg) was observed. The cation dependence of cGMP-induced cation fluxes could be reasonably well described by a Michaelis-Menten equation with a dissociation constant for alkali cations of about 100 mM, and a dissociation constant for Ca2+ of 2 mM. cGMP-induced Na+ fluxes were blocked by Mg2+, but not by Ca2+, when the cations were applied to the cytoplasmic side of the channel. cGMP-dependent cation fluxes showed a sigmoidal dependence on the cGMP concentration with a Hill coefficient of 2.1 and a dissociation constant for cGMP of 92 microM. cGMP-induced cation fluxes showed two pharmacologically distinct components; one component was blocked by both tetracaine and L-cis diltiazem, whereas the other component was only blocked by tetracaine.     

Differences in the protein composition of bovine retinal rod outer segment disk and plasma membranes isolated by a ricin-gold-dextran density perturbation method

The plasma membrane and disk membranes of bovine retinal rod outer segments (ROS) have been purified by a novel density-gradient perturbation method for analysis of their protein compositions. Purified ROS were treated with neuraminidase to expose galactose residues on plasma membrane-specific glycoproteins and labeled with ricin-gold-dextran particles. After the ROS were lysed in hypotonic buffer, the plasma membrane was dissociated from the disks by either mild trypsin digestion or prolonged exposure to low ionic strength buffer. The dense ricin-gold-dextran-labeled plasma membrane was separated from disks by sucrose gradient centrifugation. Electron microscopy was used to follow this fractionation procedure. The dense red pellet primarily consisted of inverted plasma membrane vesicles containing gold particles; the membrane fraction of density 1.13 g/cc consisted of unlabeled intact disks and vesicles. Ricin-binding studies indicated that the plasma membrane from trypsin-treated ROS was purified between 10-15-fold. The protein composition of plasma membranes and disks was significantly different as analyzed by SDS gels and Western blots labeled with lectins and monoclonal antibodies. ROS plasma membrane exhibited three major proteins of 36 (rhodopsin), 38, and 52 kD, three ricin-binding glycoproteins of 230, 160, and 110 kD, and numerous minor proteins in the range of 14-270 kD. In disk membranes rhodopsin appeared as the only major protein. A 220-kD concanavalin A-binding glycoprotein and peripherin, a rim-specific protein, were also present along with minor proteins of 43 and 57-63 kD. Radioimmune assays indicated that the ROS plasma membrane contained about half as much rhodopsin as disk membranes.     

Arrestin-rhodopsin binding stoichiometry in isolated rod outer segment membranes depends on the percentage of activated receptors

In the rod cell of the retina, arrestin is responsible for blocking signaling of the G-protein-coupled receptor rhodopsin. The general visual signal transduction model implies that arrestin must be able to interact with a single light-activated, phosphorylated rhodopsin molecule (Rho*P), as would be generated at physiologically relevant low light levels. However, the elongated bi-lobed structure of arrestin suggests that it might be able to accommodate two rhodopsin molecules. In this study, we directly addressed the question of binding stoichiometry by quantifying arrestin binding to Rho*P in isolated rod outer segment membranes. We manipulated the "photoactivation density," i.e. the percentage of active receptors in the membrane, with the use of a light flash or by partially regenerating membranes containing phosphorylated opsin with 11-cis-retinal. Curiously, we found that the apparent arrestin-Rho*P binding stoichiometry was linearly dependent on the photoactivation density, with one-to-one binding at low photoactivation density and one-to-two binding at high photoactivation density. We also observed that, irrespective of the photoactivation density, a single arrestin molecule was able to stabilize the active metarhodopsin II conformation of only a single Rho*P. We hypothesize that, although arrestin requires at least a single Rho*P to bind the membrane, a single arrestin can actually interact with a pair of receptors. The ability of arrestin to interact with heterogeneous receptor pairs composed of two different photo-intermediate states would be well suited to the rod cell, which functions at low light intensity but is routinely exposed to several orders of magnitude more light.     

Calcium-dependent activation and deactivation of rod outer segment phosphodiesterase is calmodulin-independent

ATP-dependent activation and deactivation of retinal rod outer segment phosphodiesterase is affected by calcium [Kawamura, S. and Bownds, M. D., J. Gen. Physiol. 77:571-591(1981)]. Our data demonstrate that although calmodulin has been found in rod outer segments [Liu, Y. P. and Schwartz, H., Biochim. Biophys. Acta 526:186-193(1978); Kohnken, R. E. et al, J. Biol. Chem. 256:12517-12522(1981)], this protein is not involved in calcium-dependent phosphodiesterase activation at light levels at which calcium clearly affects this enzyme's activity. Furthermore, calmodulin does not mediate the calcium-dependent deactivation of phosphodiesterase.     

Membrane bound guanylate cyclase in rat fat cell plasma membranes: influence of divalent cations on calcium activation

Rat fat cell plasma membrane preparations were used to study the effect of Mn2+, Mg2+, Ca2+ on guanylate cyclase activity. Among these three cations, Mn2+ was the most effective in activating the enzyme; Mg2+ and Ca2+ were 23% and 10% respectively as effective as Mn2+ in activating the enzyme. Low concentrations of Ca2+ (1 microM) increased the rate of cGMP formation at MgGTP concentrations ranging from 0.3 to 2 mM. This effect was less at higher concentrations of Ca2+ and was independent of the presence of excess Mg2+. Ca2+ (100 microM) had only a marginal stimulatory effect on the MnGTP-dependent enzyme.     

Light-enhanced cross-linking of rhodopsin in rod outer segment membranes as detected by chemical probes

Bovine rod outer segment membranes were treated with cross-linking reagents before and after light exposure. Bleached membranes showed enhanced cross-linking with difluorodinitrobenzene or methyl acetimidate compared to dark-adapted membranes. The light-induced enhancement of cross-linking may be due to increased association of rhodopsin monomers in the light and/or due to increased reactivity of amino and sulfhydryl groups of bleached rhodopsin. In some instances, the band ascribed to the rhodopsin monomer in gel electrophoresis appears as a partially resolved doublet. Treatment of bleached rod outer segment membranes with methyl acetimidate improved the resolution of the doublet into two closely migrating bands.     

Letter: A saccharide ligand on the outer surface of retinal rod disc membranes

Binding of concanavalin A to bleached bovine retinal rod disc membranes is governed by a single association constant of 6.4 × 10⁷ M^?1, at 26 °C. α-Methyl glucoside competes with the saccharide ligand of the membrane for the saccharide-binding site of concanavalin A. The surface density of the saccharide ligand is calculated to be one ligand per 5 × 10⁴Ų of membrane surface.     

Thermal destabilization of rhodopsin and opsin by proteolytic cleavage in bovine rod outer segment disk membranes

The G-protein coupled receptor, rhodopsin, consists of seven transmembrane helices which are buried in the lipid bilayer and are connected by loop domains extending out of the hydrophobic core. The thermal stability of rhodopsin and its bleached form, opsin, was investigated using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The thermal transitions were asymmetric, and the temperatures of the thermal transitions were scan rate dependent. This dependence exhibited characteristics of a two-state irreversible denaturation in which intermediate states rapidly proceed to the final irreversible state. These studies suggest that the denaturation of both rhodopsin and opsin is kinetically controlled. The denaturation of the intact protein was compared to three proteolytically cleaved forms of the protein. Trypsin removed nine residues of the carboxyl terminus, papain removed 28 residues of the carboxyl terminus and a portion of the third cytoplasmic loop, and chymotrypsin cleaved cytoplasmic loops 2 and 3. In each of these cases the fragments remained associated as a complex in the membrane. DSC studies were carried out on each of the fragmented proteins. In all of the samples the scan rate dependence of the Tm indicated that the transition was kinetically controlled. Trypsin-proteolyzed protein differed little from the intact protein. However, the activation energy for denaturation was decreased when cytoplasmic loop 3 was cleaved by papain or chymotrypsin. This was observed for both bleached and unbleached samples. In the presence of the chromophore, 11-cis-retinal, the noncovalent interactions among the proteolytic fragments produced by papain and chymotrypsin cleavage were sufficiently strong such that each of the complexes denatured as a unit. Upon bleaching, the papain fragments exhibited a single thermal transition. However, after bleaching, the chymotrypsin fragments exhibited two calorimetric transitions. These data suggest that the loops of rhodopsin exert a stabilizing effect on the protein.     

Oxidative damage of retinal rod outer segment membranes and the role of vitamin E

Highly purified bovine rod outer segment membranes show loss of structural integrity under an air atmosphere. Obvious ultrastructural changes are preceded by increases in absorbance below 400 nm. These changes are inhibited by Ar or N₂ atmospheres and appear to be due primarily to oxidative damage to the polyunsaturated fatty acids of the membrane lipids. Loss of polyunsaturated fatty acids, formation of malonaldehyde and fluorescent products characteristic of lipid oxidation accompany the spectral alterations. The elevated ultraviolet absorbance can largely be removed from the membranes by gentle extraction of the lipids using phospholipase C and hexane without changing the visible absorbance of rhodopsin.We have found a large seasonal variation in the endogenous level of α-tocopherol (vitamin E) in the bovine rod outer segment preparations. For much of the year we find that the rod outer segment membranes contain higher levels of α-tocopherol than have been previously reported in biological membranes. Rod outer segments which are low in endogenous tocopherol can be protected from oxygen damage by adding exogenous tocopherol. The rod outer segments are extremely susceptible to oxygen damage due to the unusually high content of polyunsaturated fatty acids in the membrane lipids. The presence of tocopherol inhibits oxygen damage but does not eliminate it. The tocopherol in the rod outer segments is consumed in air, thus complete protection from peroxidation in vitro requires an inert atmosphere as well as high levels of tocopherol.This work suggests that extensive precautions against oxidative degradation should also be employed in studies of other membrane systems where important deleterious effects of oxygen may be less obvious.     

Use of 8-azidoguanosine 5'-[gamma-32P]triphosphate as a probe of the guanosine 5'-triphosphate binding protein subunits in bovine rod outer segments

In an in vitro incubation, 8-azidoguanosine 5'-[gamma-32P]triphosphate ( [gamma-32P]-8-azido-GTP) labeled bleached rhodopsin independent of ultraviolet light. Characterization of this labeling indicated that rhodopsin was phosphorylated with [gamma-32P]-8-azido-GTP as a phosphate donor. At low concentrations, ATP increased this labeling activity 5-fold. In the same incubation, [gamma-32P]-8-azido-GTP also labeled G alpha (Mr 40 000). This labeling was ultraviolet light dependent. G beta (Mr 35 000) was also labeled dependent for the most part upon ultraviolet light, but a smaller component of labeling appeared to result from phosphorylation. Differential labeling of G alpha and G beta was found to vary intricately with experimental conditions, especially prebleaching of rhodopsin, tonicity of the medium, and the presence or absence of 2-mercaptoethanol. Affinity labeling of G alpha and G beta by [gamma-32P]-8-azido-GTP in competition with ATP or GTP was kinetically complex, consistent with possible multiple binding sites for GTP on both subunits. Independent evidence for two or more binding sites on G alpha has been offered by other laboratories, and recently, at least one binding site on G beta and its analogues among the N proteins of adenylate cyclases has been identified.     

Biochemical aspects of the visual process,XXXV. Calcium binding by cattle rod outer segment membranes studied by means of equilibrium dialysis

The calcium binding capacity of cattle rod outer segment membranes has been studied by means of an equilibrium dialysis technique. The binding is not affected by prior lyophilization of the membranes or by the presence of ionophore A23187, indicating that only passive binding to membranes is involved without active translocation.The amount of calcium bound to the membranes is influenced by the ionic composition of the medium. Both Na⁺ and K⁺ decrease binding to about the same degree, but the size of the effects suggests a rather high specificity of the calcium binding sites on the membrane.From Scatchard plots for the amount of calcium bound as a function of the free calcium concentration, it appears that two types of binding sites exist: high affinity sites which can accommodate 5 nmol calcium per mg protein (0.3 mol. calcium/mol rhodopsin) and low affinity sites which can accommodate 195 nmol calcium per mg protein (13 mol calcium/mol rhodopsin). Depending on the medium composition, the high affinity sites show dissociation constants between 8 and 40 μM, and the low affinity sites between 0.3 and 1.6 mM.Illuminated rod outer segment membranes show a slight decrease of calcium binding as compared to dark-kept membranes, but the effect is independent of the amount of calcium bound and does not appear to be significant.From these findings and the assumption of a free calcium concentration of approx. 1 μM in the extrasaccular space in rod outer segments in vivo, it is concluded that mere passive binding to the rod sac membranes must be insufficient to explain the high calcium contents in rod outer segments.     

Regulation by divalent cations of 3H-baclofen binding to GABAB sites in rat cerebellar membranes

When investigating the effects of divalent cations (Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+, Mn2+ and Ni2+) on 3H-baclofen binding to rat cerebellar synaptic membranes, we found that the specific binding of 3H-baclofen was not only dependent on divalent cations, but was increased dose-dependently in the presence of these cations. The effects were in the following order of potency: Mn2+ congruent to Ni2+ greater than Mg2+ greater than Ca2+ greater than Sr2+ greater than Ba2+. Scatchard analysis of the binding data revealed a single component of the binding sites in the presence of 2.5 mM MgCl2, 2.5 mM CaCl2 or 0.3 mM MnCl2 whereas two components appeared in the presence of 2.5 mM MnCl2 or 1 mM NiCl2. In the former, divalent cations altered the apparent affinity (Kd) without affecting density of the binding sites (Bmax). In the latter, the high-affinity sites showed a higher affinity and lower density of the binding sites than did the single component of the former. As the maximal effects of four cations (Mg2+, Ca2+, Mn2+ and Ni2+) were not additive, there are probably common sites of action of these divalent cations. Among the ligands for GABAB sites, the affinity for (-), (+) and (+/-) baclofen, GABA and beta-phenyl GABA increased 2-6 fold in the presence of 2.5 mM MnCl2, in comparison with that in HEPES-buffered Krebs solution (containing 2.5 mM CaCl2 and 1.2 mM MgSO4), whereas that for muscimol was decreased to one-fifth. Thus, the affinity of GABAB sites for its ligands is probably regulated by divalent cations, through common sites of action.