Chloroplastic ATP synthase builds up a proton motive force preventing production of reactive oxygen species in photosystem I

Over‐reduction of the photosynthetic electron transport (PET) chain should be avoided, because the accumulation of reducing electron carriers produces reactive oxygen species (ROS) within photosystem I (PSI) in thylakoid membranes and causes oxidative damage to chloroplasts. To prevent production of ROS in thylakoid membranes the H⁺ gradient (ΔpH) needs to be built up across the thylakoid membranes to suppress the over‐reduction state of the PET chain. In this study, we aimed to identify the critical component that stimulates ΔpH formation under illumination in higher plants. To do this, we screened ethyl methane sulfonate (EMS)‐treated Arabidopsis thaliana, in which the formation of ΔpH is impaired and the PET chain caused over‐reduction under illumination. Subsequently, we isolated an allelic mutant that carries a missense mutation in the γ‐subunit of chloroplastic CF₀CF₁‐ATP synthase, named hope2. We found that hope2 suppressed the formation of ΔpH during photosynthesis because of the high H⁺ efflux activity from the lumenal to stromal side of the thylakoid membranes via CF₀CF₁‐ATP synthase. Furthermore, PSI was in a more reduced state in hope2 than in wild‐type (WT) plants, and hope2 was more vulnerable to PSI photoinhibition than WT under illumination. These results suggested that chloroplastic CF₀CF₁‐ATP synthase adjusts the redox state of the PET chain, especially for PSI, by modulating H⁺ efflux activity across the thylakoid membranes. Our findings suggest the importance of the buildup of ΔpH depending on CF₀CF₁‐ATP synthase to adjust the redox state of the reaction center chlorophyll P700 in PSI and to suppress the production of ROS in PSI during photosynthesis.     

Factors affecting the development of the capacity for ATP formation in isolated chloroplasts

Full development of the capacity for ATP formation in isolated thylakoid membranes coincides with the beginning of illumination. Indeed, the yield of ATP per ms of illumination is about twice as great during the first 15 ms of high-intensity illumination as it is thereafter. The presence of valinomycin and K⁺ prevents the formation of a membrane potential (as indicated by the obliteration of most of the change in absorbance at 518 nm) and at the same time delays the formation of the capacity for ATP synthesis for many milliseconds. Presumably, phosphorylation is initially dependent on a rapidly formed membrane potential, whereas after a delay a ΔpH sufficient to drive ATP formation forms. The actual duration of this delay depends on the phosphoryl group transfer potential (i.e., ΔG_ATP) of the ATP-synthesizing reaction. If the delay in the presence of valinomycin and K⁺ represents the time required to develop a ΔpH capable of driving phosphorylation by itself, then the effect of ΔG_ATP on the duration of the delay suggests that the onset of phosphorylation is determined by the magnitude of the electrochemical potential of protons and not by factors affecting the activation of the coupling factor enzyme. The initial ATP formation, which is almost entirely dependent on the electrical potential, should not be affected by the electrically neutral exchange of cations catalyzed by nigericin. When the external pH is 7.0 this seems to be true, since the ATP synthesis which is initially sensitive to valinomycin and K⁺ is largely insensitive to nigericin and K⁺. However, when the external pH is 8.0 the response to nigericin is exactly the opposite and the ATP formation which is sensitive to valinomycin is also abolished by nigericin. These data suggest that there may be either an energetic requirement for both a ΔpH and membrane potential at alkaline pH or a non-energetic requirement for a minimum proton activity in the initiation of phosphorylation.     

Chloroplastic ATP synthase optimizes the trade-off between photosynthetic CO2 assimilation and photoprotection during leaf maturation

In the present study, we studied the role of chloroplastic ATP synthase in photosynthetic regulation during leaf maturation. We measured gas exchange, chlorophyll fluorescence, P700 redox state, and the electrochromic shift signal in mature and immature leaves. Under high light, the immature leaves displayed high levels of non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) and P700 oxidation ratio, and higher values for proton motive force (pmf) and proton gradient (ΔpH) across the thylakoid membranes but lower values for the activity of chloroplastic ATP synthase (g_H⁺) than the mature leaves. Furthermore, g_H⁺ was significantly and positively correlated with CO₂ assimilation rate and linear electron flow (LEF), but negatively correlated with pmf and ΔpH. ΔpH was significantly correlated with LEF and the P700 oxidation ratio. These results indicated that g_H⁺ was regulated to match photosynthetic capacity during leaf maturation, and the formation of pmf and ΔpH was predominantly regulated by the alterations in g_H⁺. In the immature leaves, the high steady-state ΔpH increased lumen acidification, which, in turn, stimulated photoprotection for the photosynthetic apparatus via NPQ induction and photosynthetic control. Our results highlighted the importance of chloroplastic ATP synthase in optimizing the trade-off between CO₂ assimilation and photoprotection during leaf maturation.     

Energy thresholds for ATP synthesis in chloroplasts

We have investigated the ATP synthesis associated with acid-base transitions in chloroplast lamellae under conditions which allow simultaneous control of the thermodynamic variables, ΔpH, membrane potential and ΔG_ATP. These variables have been directly imposed rather than simply inferred. Since the initiation of labeled P_i incorporation seems to measure accurately the initiation of net ATP synthesis, the following conclusions can be drawn: (1) The proton-motive force which is just sufficient for ATP synthesis provides almost exactly the required energy for ΔG_ATP if the efflux of three H⁺ is required for each ATP molecule formed. (2) The membrane potential and the ΔpH contribute to the proton-motive force in a precisely additive way. Thus, the threshold can be reached or exceeded by a ΔpH in the absence of a membrane potential, by a membrane potential in the absence of a ΔpH, or by any combination of membrane potential and ΔpH. With a large enough membrane potential, ATP synthesis occurs even against a small inverse ΔpH. In each instance the combined ΔpH and membrane potential necessary for initiation of ATP synthesis represent the same threshold proton-motive force.     

Mussel and mammalian ATP synthase share the same bioenergetic cost of ATP

The molecular mechanism by which the membrane-embedded F_O sector of the mitochondrial ATP synthase translocates protons, thus dissipating the transmembrane protonmotive force and leading to ATP synthesis, involves the neutralization of the carboxylate residues of the c-ring. Carboxylates are thought to constitute the binding sites for ion translocation. In order to cast light on this mechanism, we exploited N,N’-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, which covalently binds to F_O c-ring carboxylates, and ionophores which selectively modulate the transmembrane electric (Δφ) and chemical (ΔpH) gradients such as valinomycin, nigericin and dinitrophenol. ATP hydrolysis was evaluated in mitochondrial preparations and/or inside-out submitochondrial particles from mussel and mammalian tissues under different experimental conditions. The experiments pointed out striking similarities between mussel and mammalian mitochondrial ATP synthase. Our results support the hypothesis that the ATP synthase of Mytilus galloprovincialis induces intersubunit torque generation and translocates H⁺ by coordinating the hydronium ion (H₃O⁺) in the ion binding site of F_O. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that in mussel mitochondria the main component of the electrochemical gradient driving proton flux and ATP synthesis is Δφ. Therefore, mussel F_O probably contains a small c-ring, which implies a low bioenergetic cost of making ATP as in mammals. These features which make mussel mitochondria as efficient in ATP production as mammalian ones may be especially advantageous in facultative aerobic species which intermittently exploit mitochondrial respiration to generate ATP.     

Effect of methanol on spinach thylakoid ATPase

Methanol at 35% ($\text{v}\text{v}$) overcomes the latency of spinach thylakoid ATPase. Activation is immediate and reversible involving changes in the V_max, not the K_m of the enzyme, MgATP is a much better substrate than CaATP; free Mg²⁺ noncompetitively inhibits activity. This inhibition can be overcome by the addition of Na₂SO₃. While both MgATP and MgGTP act as substrates, free ATP and GTP both inhibit activity. ADP and MgADP are also inhibitory. Insensitivity to certain inhibitors indicates that methanol neither induces the same conformational changes in CF₁ as illumination does, nor does it lead to coupling between H⁺ movement through CF₀ and ATP hydrolysis. Methanol activation provides a much improved method for assaying thylakoid ATPase.     

Standard free energy maps for the hydrolysis of ATP as a function of pH and metal ion concentration: comparison of metal ions

The observed equilibrium constant K_obs for the hydrolysis of ATP to ADP and inorganic phosphate has been calculated as a function of pH and metal ion concentration pM (- log [M]) at 25 °C and μ = 0.2 with the use of literature values of the acid dissociation and complex dissociation constants for the phosphates.The resulting standard free energy changes ΔG °′ are presented by means of contour diagrams for the range pH 4–10 and pM 1–7. These maps summarize the results of some 1900 calculations per diagram, and clearly simulate a differential effect of the metal ions of interest, including Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺, Sr²⁺, Mn²⁺, Li⁺, Na⁺ and K⁺, on the equilibrium hydrolysis of ATP.     

A 31P-NMR study of the cross-membrane pH gradient induced by ATP hydrolysis in mitochondria

³¹P-NMR has been used to study the increase of ΔpH in mitochondria by externally added ATP. Freshly prepared mitochondria was treated with N-ethylmaleimide to inhibit the exchange between internal and external P_i. Upon addition of ATP, phosphocreatine (30 mM) and creatine kinase to a NMR sample of mitochondria suspension (approx. 120 mg protein/ml) at 0°C, an increase of ΔpH by approx. 0.5 pH unit was observed. However the increased ΔpH could not be maintained, but slowly decayed along with the increase of external ADP/ATP ratio. Further addition of valinomycin to the suspension induced a larger ΔpH (approx. 1) which was maintained by the increased rate of internal ATP hydrolysis as seen in the growth of the internal P_i peak intensity in NMR spectra and the concomitant decrease of the external phosphocreatine peak. The external P_i and ATP peaks stayed virtually constant. When carboxyatractyloside was added to inhibit the ATP/ADP translocase, the internal P_i increase was stopped and the ΔpH decayed. These observations in conjunction with those made earlier in respiring mitochondria clearly show the reversible nature of the ATPase function in which the internal ATP hydrolysis is associated with outward pumping of protons.     

Concentration Gradient Effects of Sodium and Lithium Ions and Deuterium Isotope Effects on the Activities of H-ATP Synthase from Chloroplasts

We explored the concentration gradient effects of the sodium and lithium ions and the deuterium isotope's effects on the activities of H⁺-ATP synthase from chloroplasts (CF₀F₁). We found that the sodium concentration gradient can drive the ATP synthesis reaction of CF₀F₁. In contrast, the lithium ion can be an efficient enzyme-inhibitor by blocking the entrance channel of the ion translocation pathway in CF₀. In the presence of sodium or lithium ions and with the application of a membrane potential, unexpected enzyme behaviors of CF₀F₁ were evident. To account for these observations, we propose that both of the sodium and lithium ions could undergo localized hydrolysis reactions in the chemical environment of the ion channel of CF₀. The protons generated locally could proceed to complete the ion translocation process in the ATP synthesis reaction of CF₀F₁. Experimental and theoretical deuterium isotope effects of the localized hydrolysis on the activities of CF₀F₁, and the energetics of these related reactions, support this proposed mechanism. Our experimental observations could be understood in the framework of the well-established ion translocation models for the H⁺-ATP synthase from Escherichia coli, and the Na⁺-ATP synthase from Propionigenium modestum and Ilyobacter tartaricus.     

Met23Lys mutation in subunit gamma of FOF1-ATP synthase from Rhodobacter capsulatus impairs the activation of ATP hydrolysis by protonmotive force

H⁺-F_OF₁-ATP synthase couples proton flow through its membrane portion, F_O, to the synthesis of ATP in its headpiece, F₁. Upon reversal of the reaction the enzyme functions as a proton pumping ATPase. Even in the simplest bacterial enzyme the ATPase activity is regulated by several mechanisms, involving inhibition by MgADP, conformational transitions of the ε subunit, and activation by protonmotive force. Here we report that the Met23Lys mutation in the γ subunit of the Rhodobacter capsulatus ATP synthase significantly impaired the activation of ATP hydrolysis by protonmotive force. The impairment in the mutant was due to faster enzyme deactivation that was particularly evident at low ATP/ADP ratio. We suggest that the electrostatic interaction of the introduced γLys23 with the DELSEED region of subunit β stabilized the ADP-inhibited state of the enzyme by hindering the rotation of subunit γ rotation which is necessary for the activation.     

Differential inhibition of Pi-ATP exchange in relation to ATP synthesis and hydrolysis by modification of chloroplast thylakoid membranes with glutaraldehyde

Limited modification of thylakoid membranes with glutaraldehyde inhibits the P_i-ATP exchange reaction much more than ATP synthesis or hydrolysis. More extensive modification of the membranes results in the inhibition of all activities of the ATP synthetase, but does not affect electron transport. Limited modification also does not have much effect on the tight binding of [³H]ADP or the ΔpH supported by ATP hydrolysis. The modification affects the catalytic process itself and not the activation of the latent enzyme. Cross-linking between thylakoid polypeptides is observed only after extensive treatment with glutaraldehyde, while limited modification does not result in cross-linking between polypeptides. The differential inhibition of the P_i-ATP exchange relative to ATP hydrolysis can be explained by the decrease in only one of the kinetic rate constants involved in these reactions. However, the relative insensitivity of photophosphorylation to the modification suggests that different enzyme conformations may participate in phosphorylation (light) and ATP hydrolysis or P_i-ATP exchange (dark).     

Regulation of ATP hydrolysis by the ε subunit, ζ subunit and Mg-ADP in the ATP synthase of Paracoccus denitrificans

F₁F_O-ATP synthase is a crucial metabolic enzyme that uses the proton motive force from respiration to regenerate ATP. For maximum thermodynamic efficiency ATP synthesis should be fully reversible, but the enzyme from Paracoccus denitrificans catalyzes ATP hydrolysis at far lower rates than it catalyzes ATP synthesis, an effect often attributed to its unique ζ subunit. Recently, we showed that deleting ζ increases hydrolysis only marginally, indicating that other common inhibitory mechanisms such as inhibition by the C-terminal domain of the ε subunit (ε-CTD) or Mg-ADP may be more important. Here, we created mutants lacking the ε-CTD, and double mutants lacking both the ε-CTD and ζ subunit. No substantial activation of ATP hydrolysis was observed in any of these strains. Instead, hydrolysis in even the double mutant strains could only be activated by oxyanions, the detergent lauryldimethylamine oxide, or a proton motive force, which are all considered to release Mg-ADP inhibition. Our results establish that P. denitrificans ATP synthase is regulated by a combination of the ε and ζ subunits and Mg-ADP inhibition.     

Inhibition of the transthylakoid gradient of electrochemical proton potential by the local anesthetic dibucaine

The effects of the local anesthetic dibucaine on coupling between electron transport and ATP synthesis-hydrolysis by the coupling-factor complex (CF₀CF₁ ATPase) were investigated in thylakoid membranes from Spinacia oleracea L. cv. Monatol. Evidence is presented that inhibition of ATP synthesis was produced by a specific uncoupling mechanism which was based on dibucaine-membrane surface interactions rather than on the interaction of dibucaine with the ATPase complex. Dibucaine reduced the osmotic space of thylakoid vesicles. At low pH of the medium it stimulated ATP hydrolysis beyond the rates obtained with optimum concentrations of ‘classical’ uncouplers. After addition of dibucaine, there was displacement of membrane-bound Mg²⁺ and strong thylakoid stacking in the presence of only low Mg²⁺ concentrations. Inhibition of ATP synthesis and transmembrane pH gradient increased with medium pH. Hydrolysis of ATP by isolated CF₁ and the CF₀CF₁ complex was only slightly affected by dibucaine. The data are discussed assuming the involvement of localized proton channels on the membrane surface in protonic coupling of electron transport and ATP synthesis. A hypothesis for the mechanisms of action of local anesthetics at the thylakoid membrane is presented.     

Evidence for a high proton translocation stoichiometry of the H+-ATPase complex in well coupled proteoliposomes reconstituted from a thermophilic cyanobacterium

Evidence is presented for a high proton translocation stoichiometry (H+/ATP) of approx. 9 in ATPase proteoliposomes with extremely low permeability for ions, reconstituted from a thermophilic cyanobacterium. A proportional relation between the phosphate potential (ΔG_fp) and the proton-motive force (Δp) was observed in thermodynamic equilibrium. A bulk-to-bulk Δp was imposed by valinomycin-induced K⁻ diffusion potentials of different size while the initial ΔG_fp was varied. In all cases equilibrium was reached in about 1.5 h. A high H⁻/ATP ratio was also deduced from the relation between the initial rates of ATP synthesis or hydrolysis at varying ΔG_fp and Δp. The implications of these results for the mechanism of energy transduction in energy-conserving membranes are discussed.     

Two gears of pumping by the sodium pump

The kinetics of the phosphorylation and subsequent conformational change of Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase was investigated via the stopped-flow technique using the fluorescent label RH421 (pH 7.4, 24°C). The enzyme was preequilibrated in buffer containing 130 mM NaCl to stabilize the E1(Na⁺)₃ state. On mixing with ATP in the presence of Mg²⁺, a fluorescence increase occurred, due to enzyme conversion into the E2P state. The fluorescence change accelerated with increasing ATP concentration until a saturating limit in the hundreds of micromolar range. The amplitude of the fluorescence change (ΔF/F₀) increased to 0.98 at 50 μM ATP. ΔF/F₀ then decreased to 0.82 at 500 μM. The decrease was attributed to an ATP-induced allosteric acceleration of the dephosphorylation reaction. The ATP concentration dependence of the time course and the amplitude of the fluorescence change could not be explained by either a one-site monomeric enzyme model or by a two-pool model. All of the data could be explained by an (αβ)₂ dimeric model, in which the enzyme cycles at a low rate with ATP hydrolysis by one α-subunit or at a high rate with ATP hydrolysis by both α-subunits. Thus, we propose a two-gear bicyclic model to replace the classical monomeric Albers-Post model for kidney Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase.     

Regulation of Proton Flow and ATP Synthesis in Chloroplasts

The chloroplast ATP synthase is strictly regulated so that it is very active in the light (rates of ATP synthesis can be higher than 5 mol/min/mg protein), but virtually inactive in the dark. The subunits of the catalytic portion of the ATP synthase involved in activation, as well as the effects of nucleotides are discussed. The relation of activation to proton flux through the ATP synthase and to changes in the structure of enzyme induced by the proton electrochemical gradient are also presented. It is concluded that the and subunits of CF₁ play key roles in both regulation of activity and proton translocation.     

Residue 249 in subunit beta regulates ADP inhibition and its phosphate modulation in Escherichia coli ATP synthase

ATPase activity of proton-translocating F_OF₁-ATP synthase (F-type ATPase or F-ATPase) is suppressed in the absence of protonmotive force by several regulatory mechanisms. The most conservative of these mechanisms found in all enzymes studied so far is allosteric inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by MgADP (ADP-inhibition). When MgADP is bound without phosphate in the catalytic site, the enzyme lapses into an inactive state with MgADP trapped.In chloroplasts and mitochondria, as well as in most bacteria, phosphate prevents MgADP inhibition. However, in Escherichia coli ATP synthase ADP-inhibition is relatively weak and phosphate does not prevent it but seems to enhance it.We found that a single amino acid residue in subunit β is responsible for these features of E. coli enzyme. Mutation βL249Q significantly enhanced ADP-inhibition in E. coli ATP synthase, increased the extent of ATP hydrolysis stimulation by sulfite, and rendered the ADP-inhibition sensitive to phosphate in the same manner as observed in F_OF₁ from mitochondria, chloroplasts, and most aerobic\photosynthetic bacteria.     

Structural and ATP-hydrolyzing properties of the ATP synthase isolated from Wolinella succinogenes

The ATP synthase was isolated from the cytoplasmic membrane of the anaerobic bacterium Wolinella (formerly Vibrio) succinogenes, using a non-ionic detergent. After 20-fold purification the enzyme was homogeneous. The M_r was determined to be 410 000. Gel electrophoresis in the presence of dodecylsulfate separated eight different peptides, seven of which appeared to be subunits of the enzyme (M_r 56 000, 50 000, 36 000, 19 000, 13 000, 11 000 and 8000). Dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (0.6 mol per mol enzyme) was specifically bound to the M_r 8000 subunit. In electron micrographs, after negative staining, the enzyme appeared as a dumb-bell having a globular portion of 10.0–10.8 nm diameter on one end. The K_i for ADP as a competitive inhibitor of ATP hydrolysis was about 10-times smaller than the K_M for ATP. Incorporation of the enzyme into liposomes caused the K_i and K_M to decrease to values that approached those measured with the bacterial membrane. Treatment of the membrane with CHCl₃ was the only procedure found that could split the ATPase from the ATP synthase. The soluble enzyme isolated after this treatment exhibited a 15-times greater specific activity of ATP hydrolysis than ATP synthase. The ATPase was made up of three different subunits (M_r 56 000, 50 000 and 36 000). The M_r was determined to be 340 000. In electron micrographs, after negative staining, the ATPase appeared as spherical particles which were similar to the globular part of the ATP synthase. The particles showed a hexagonal fine structure with a seventh element in the centre of the hexagon, suggesting an α₃β₃ρ composition of the enzyme.     

Modulation of proton efflux from chloroplasts in the light by external pH

The effects of external pH on the efflux of protons from illuminated spinach chloroplasts have been studied by monitoring the rates of proton-pumping electron transport under a variety of steady-state conditions. Phosphorylation-coupled proton efflux through the ATP synthase (CF₀-CF₁), determined from the rates of ATP formation and that portion of the total electron transport attributable to phosphorylation, is strongly dependent upon pH over the range 6–9, with little activity below pH 7 and half-maximal activity at pH ≈ 7.6. Noncoupled proton efflux through the ATP synthase, determined in the absence of ADP and phosphate, was also strongly pH sensitive, with little activity below pH 7.5 and half-maximal activity at pH ～- 7.9. When proton efflux via CF₀ was prevented by triphenyltin, the rate of passive proton leakage across the membrane was very low and practically insensitive to external pH indicating that the major pH-sensitive pathway(s) for proton efflux in the light involves CF₀ · CF₁. Modification of CF₁ sulfhydryls by Ag⁺ resulted in an apparent increase in proton efflux via the normally coupled CF₀ · CF₁ pathway (half-maximal activity = pH 7.6), whereas modification by Hg²⁺ resulted in an apparent increase in proton efflux via the noncoupled CF₀ · CF₁ pathway (half-maximal activity = pH 7.9).