ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS ON ANIMALS USED IN BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH

I. Reliability of the results of bio-medical research clearly depends upon the animals used showing as standard responses as is possible.
2. The majority of animals used in this field are small, homoiothermic mammals which have sensitive and strong homeostatic mechanisms. If a change in ambient conditions is of sufficient magnitude to unbalance homeostasis, then the neuroendocrine system is stimulated so as to restore it, and this can interfere with the response to test conditions or agents.
3. The homeostatic effectors involved are diverse and can include both physiological and behavioural changes in the animal. These can affect metabolic rate, body temperature, activity, food consumption, hormone concentration, wake/sleep patterns, maturation, posture, lactation and many other bodily functions. Any of these changes is potentially capable of influencing experimental results.
4. The evidence presented shows how environmental factors may affect the outcome of experiments in the fields of animal behaviour, cancer research, immunology, pathology, pharmacology, psychology, reproduction, teratology and toxicology; particular attention is paid to the effects of ambient temperature, relative humidity, air movement and quality, light and sound.
5. While a constant, reproducible environment would be ideal, there is little possibility of controlling all the variables; nevertheless all investigators should minimize those environmental variables that have been shown to be important.
6. To enable other investigators to repeat experiments or carry out comparative studies, environmental conditions pertaining during an experiment should be adequately described in any publications.     

The effect of energy reserves and food availability on optimal immune defence

In order to avoid both starvation and disease, animals must allocate resources between energy reserves and immune defence. We investigate the optimal allocation. We find that animals with low reserves choose to allocate less to defence than animals with higher reserves because when reserves are low it is more important to increase reserves to reduce the risk of starvation in the future. In general, investment in immune defence increases monotonically with energy reserves. An exception is when the animal can reduce its probability of death from disease by reducing its foraging rate. In this case, allocation to immune defence can peak at intermediate reserves. When food changes over time, the optimal response depends on the frequency of changes. If the environment is relatively stable, animals forage most intensively when the food is scarce and invest more in immune defence when the food is abundant than when it is scarce. If the environment changes quickly, animals forage at low intensity when the food is scarce, but at high intensity when the food is abundant. As the rate of environmental change increases, immune defence becomes less dependent on food availability. We show that the strength of selection on reserve-dependent immune defence depends on how foraging intensity and immune defence determine the probability of death from disease.     

Contrasting fecal corticosterone metabolite levels in captive and free-living colonial tuco-tucos (Ctenomys sociabilis)

The environment in which an animal lives can profoundly influence its biology, including physiological responses to external stressors. To examine the effects of environmental conditions on physiological stress reactions in colonial tuco-tucos (Ctenomys sociabilis), we measured glucocorticoid (GC) levels in captive and free-living members of this species of social, subterranean rodent. Analyses of plasma and fecal samples revealed immunoreactive corticosterone (metabolites) to be the most prevalent GC in this species. An adrenocorticotropic hormone challenge confirmed that fecal corticosterone metabolites are responsive to exogenous stressors and provided validation of the commercial enzyme immunoassay kit used to detect these metabolites. Comparisons of adult female C. sociabilis from natural and captive environments revealed significantly higher baseline concentrations of corticosterone metabolites and significantly greater individual variation in metabolite concentrations among free-living animals. These findings suggest that the natural environment in which these animals occur is more challenging and more variable than the captive housing conditions employed. In addition to providing the first evaluation of GC levels in captive and wild colonial tuco-tucos, our findings indicate that the influence of environmental conditions on stress physiology may have important implications for understanding the social behavior of this species in the laboratory and the field.     

Gene Expression Changes in the Olfactory Bulb of Mice Induced by Exposure to Diesel Exhaust Are Dependent on Animal Rearing Environment

There is an emerging concern that particulate air pollution increases the risk of cranial nerve disease onset. Small nanoparticles, mainly derived from diesel exhaust particles reach the olfactory bulb by their nasal depositions. It has been reported that diesel exhaust inhalation causes inflammation of the olfactory bulb and other brain regions. However, these toxicological studies have not evaluated animal rearing environment. We hypothesized that rearing environment can change mice phenotypes and thus might alter toxicological study results. In this study, we exposed mice to diesel exhaust inhalation at 90 µg/m³, 8 hours/day, for 28 consecutive days after rearing in a standard cage or environmental enrichment conditions. Microarray analysis found that expression levels of 112 genes were changed by diesel exhaust inhalation. Functional analysis using Gene Ontology revealed that the dysregulated genes were involved in inflammation and immune response. This result was supported by pathway analysis. Quantitative RT-PCR analysis confirmed 10 genes. Interestingly, background gene expression of the olfactory bulb of mice reared in a standard cage environment was changed by diesel exhaust inhalation, whereas there was no significant effect of diesel exhaust exposure on gene expression levels of mice reared with environmental enrichment. The results indicate for the first time that the effect of diesel exhaust exposure on gene expression of the olfactory bulb was influenced by rearing environment. Rearing environment, such as environmental enrichment, may be an important contributive factor to causation in evaluating still undefined toxic environmental substances such as diesel exhaust.     

Complementary idiotypy in the regulation of the immune response.

A new concept is presented for the interactions of two complementary antibodies in the immune response. These antibodies bind to each other by means of their variable sequence determinants and therefore are designated as complementary idiotypes. Under certain conditions, both complementary idiotypes are produced by the same animal at the same time. An idiotype can drastically affect the expression of the complementary idiotype in the animal, inducing a peripheral quench effect of antibody-binding activity and a central effect on the immunocompetent cell, which produces the complementary idiotype. It is proposed that complementary idiotypes might be induced during every immune response, thus playing an essential role in the regulation of the immune response.     

Relationships between undernutrition,infection, and growth and development

Interactions between undernutrition, infection, and growth and development are complex, and are reviewed in this article. Anthropometry is a common means of nutritional assessment, but the relationship between food availability and anthropometric status is at best very loose, at least at the national level. This suggests that anthropometric assessment is less a measure of nutritional status than of the totality of environmental factors that influence growth, including infectious disease. The effects of diet, nutrition and infection on the nutritional status of a child can vary according to the disease ecology, the age of the child, patterns of feeding and types of food consumed. There are two possible ways in which this relationship can begin; one in which poor nutritional status leads to impaired immunocompetence and reduced resistance to infection, and the other in which exposure to infectious disease can lead to appetite loss and anorexia, malabsorption, and elevated metabolism of energy and other nutrients. Once started, the interactions between these two major environmental stressors becomes increasingly complex, with the nature of the disease ecology influencing the balance of immunoparesis and adaptive immunity its effect on subsequent disease experience, and the extent, if any, of anorexia, fever, and malabsorption during infectious episodes which has an impact on nutritional status. Specific nutritional deficiencies can subsequently influence immune status and responsiveness, and adaptive immunity. In addition, cultural factors can influence patterns of disease management and sickness behaviour, which can in turn affect the incidence, severity and duration of infection, and their effects on nutritional status, while deficiencies of vitamins and trace elements can have major effects on immune responsiveness.     

Dynamics of nutrient uptake strategies: lessons from the tortoise and the hare

Many autotrophs vary their allocation to nutrient uptake in response to environmental cues, yet the dynamics of this plasticity are largely unknown. Plasticity dynamics affect the extent of single versus multiple nutrient limitation and thus have implications for plant ecology and biogeochemical cycling. Here we use a model of two essential nutrients cycling through autotrophs and the environment to determine conditions under which different plastic or fixed nutrient uptake strategies are adaptive. Our model includes environment-independent costs of being plastic, environment-dependent costs proportional to the rate of plastic change, and costs of being mismatched to the environment, the last of which is experienced by both fixed and plastic types. In equilibrium environments, environment-independent costs of being plastic select for tortoise strategies—fixed or less plastic types—provided that they are sufficiently close to co-limitation. At intermediate levels of environmental fluctuation forced by periodic nutrient inputs, more hare-like plastic strategies prevail because they remain near co-limitation. However, the fastest is not necessarily the best. The most adaptive strategy is an intermediate level of plasticity that keeps pace with environmental fluctuations, but is not faster. At high levels of environmental fluctuation, the environment-dependent cost of changing rapidly to keep pace with the environment becomes prohibitive and tortoise strategies again dominate. The existence and location of these thresholds depend on plasticity costs and rate, which are largely unknown empirically. These results suggest that the expectations for single nutrient limitation versus co-limitation and therefore biogeochemical cycling and autotroph community dynamics depend on environmental heterogeneity and plasticity costs.     

Genetic and environmental variation in immune response of collared flycatcher nestlings

This paper aims at partitioning genetic and environmental contribution to the phenotypic variance in nestling immune function measured with the hypersensitivity test after inoculation with phytohaemagglutinin. A cross-fostering experiment with artificial enlargement of some broods was conducted. Variation in nestling immune response was related to their common origin, which suggests heritable component of cell-mediated immunity. A common rearing environment also explained a significant part of variation. However, deterioration of rearing conditions as simulated by enlargement of brood size did not affect nestling immunocompetence, although it affected nestling body mass. Variation in body mass explained some of the variation in immune response related to rearing environment, which means that growth is more sensitive to the shifts in rearing conditions than the development of immune function. Heritable variation in immune response suggests that there should be potential for selection to operate and the micro evolutionary changes in immunity of flycatcher nestlings are possible.     

Modulation of the immune system of fish by their environment

The environment impacts on the physiology and psychology of animals in a wide variety of ways. If we can develop an understanding of how different environmental factors affect different processes we may be able to predict these changes and avoid or moderate deleterious events and the resultant changes in fish health and disease resistance. In this review, advances in the understanding of environmental impacts were identified in relation to specific areas of immune function. The trends, where they can be identified, showed that increases in light, temperature, salinity, oxygen, pH or particulates results in a general increase in immune function.     

Ecological immunology in a fluctuating environment: an integrative analysis of tree swallow nestling immune defense

Evolutionary ecologists have long been interested by the link between different immune defenses and fitness. Given the importance of a proper immune defense for survival, it is important to understand how its numerous components are affected by environmental heterogeneity. Previous studies targeting this question have rarely considered more than two immune markers. In this study, we measured seven immune markers (response to phytohemagglutinin (PHA), hemolysis capacity, hemagglutination capacity, plasma bactericidal capacity, percentage of lymphocytes, percentage of heterophils, and percentage of eosinophils) in tree swallow (Tachycineta bicolor) nestlings raised in two types of agro‐ecosystems of contrasted quality and over 2 years. First, we assessed the effect of environmental heterogeneity (spatial and temporal) on the strength and direction of correlations between immune measures. Second, we investigated the effect of an immune score integrating information from several immune markers on individual performance (including growth, mass at fledging and parasite burden). Both a multivariate and a pair‐wise approach showed variation in relationships between immune measures across years and habitats. We also found a weak association between the integrated score of nestling immune function and individual performance, but only under certain environmental conditions. We conclude that the ecological context can strongly affect the interpretation of immune defenses in the wild. Given that spatiotemporal variations are likely to affect individual immune defenses, great caution should be used when generalizing conclusions to other study systems.     

Comparative immunologic models can enhance analyses of environmental immunotoxicity

To treat immune systems and how environments affect them is a unique challenge especially when the environment is considered in its broadest perspective: internal and external. Internal focuses on relationships between immune, nervous and endocrine systems (neuroendocrine) and how they interact to maintain homeostasis. External considers physical and chemical influences that act to change the internal. Using animal models is based upon phylogeny which focuses on invertebrates, fish, amphibians, and reptiles, including mammalian results and relationships to humans. Emphasizing primitive animals is due to a growing interest in using them as models, sentinels, surrogates—predictors of what may happen when the environment is disturbed. They are inexpensive, socially acceptable, and since they live in diverse habitats under natural conditions, what may happen to them may be more applicable to humans than to laboratory reared models (sometimes inbred) whose controlled habitats may not be considered as natural. Humans do not live in controlled laboratories but like numerous animals, we do live in various climates, under different conditions of light, temperature, crowding, seasons and in different habitats that determine the quality of life including the susceptibility to disease. The immune system is affected by these influences, and it in turn is responsible for the body's surveillance against these threats.     

On the optimality of coarse behavior rules

Animal behavior can be characterized by the degree of responsiveness it has to variations in the environment. Some behavior rules lead to fine-tuned responses that carefully adjust to environmental cues, while other rules fail to discriminate as carefully, and lead to more inflexible responses. In this paper we seek to explain such inflexible behavior. We show that coarse behavior, behavior which appears to be rule-bound and inflexible, and which fails to adapt to predictable changes in the environment, is an optimal response to a particular type of uncertainty we call extended uncertainty. We show that the very variability and unpredictability that arises from extended uncertainty will lead to more rigid and possibly more predictable behavior. We relate coarse behavior to the failures to meet optimality conditions in animal behavior, most notably in foraging behavior, and also address the implications of extended uncertainty and coarse behavior rules for some results in experimental versus naturalistic approaches to ethology.     

Defining the protective antibody response for HIV-1

The development of an effective HIV-1 vaccine would be greatly facilitated by knowledge regarding the type and quantity of antibodies that are protective. Since definitive immune correlates are established only after a vaccine has been shown to be effective in humans, animal models are often used to guide vaccine development. Experimental lentivirus infection of non-human primates has shown that neutralizing antibodies can protect against infection. Most specifically, studies of passive antibody transfer in the chimeric SIV/HIV-1 immunodeficiency virus (SHIV) model have provided quantitative data on the level of protective antibody required. While direct extrapolation to humans is difficult, these data likely provide important insights into the protection afforded by antibodies against HIV-1. When used alone, high levels of neutralizing antibodies are required to completely block infection. However, even modest levels of antibody can provide partial protection and affect disease course. Understanding the exact level of protective antibody becomes even more complex in the setting of active immunization and coexisting cellular immunity. Despite this uncertainty, recent findings from lentiviral animal models strongly suggest that neutralizing antibodies will contribute to protection against HIV-1. Based on these data, a major goal of HIV-1 vaccine strategies is the induction of neutralizing antibodies against circulating primary HIV-1 strains.     

The stimulation of immune defence accelerates development in the red flour beetle (Tribolium castaneum)

The timing of the transition between life stages is of key importance for an organism. Depending on the environmental conditions, maturing earlier at a smaller size or maturing later at a larger size can be advantageous for fitness. Exposure to parasites and subsequent immune activation may lead to alterations in development. Immune defence often comes at a cost, such as energy drain towards immune function, which is likely to delay development. On the other hand, animals may react to an anticipated risk of infection with a phenotypically plastic shift in life history, which may more likely lead to accelerated development and earlier maturation. We tested these alternatives in the red flour beetle, Tribolium castaneum. Young larvae were exposed to a non-infectious immune challenge with heat-killed bacteria (either Escherichia coli or Bacillus thuringiensis) and they were followed up for their development, survival, adult size and reproduction. We found that animals that had experienced a bacterial challenge developed into adults earlier than sham-treated beetles, while they did not differ significantly in survival or adult size. Beetles exposed to E. coli produced fewer offspring, while exposure to B. thuringiensis did not affect offspring number. Taken together, our results indicate that T. castaneum is able to speed up its development when facing a risk of infection.     

Personality and Information Gathering in Free-Ranging Great Tits

One aspect of animal personality that has been well described in captivity, but received only little attention in studies in the wild, is that personality types may vary in their behavioural flexibility towards environmental changes. A fundamental factor underlying such differences is believed to be the degree to which individual behavior is guided by environmental stimuli. We tested this hypothesis in the wild using free-ranging great tits. Personality variation was quantified using exploratory behaviour in a novel environment, which has previously been shown to be repeatable and correlated with other behaviours in this and other populations of the same species. By temporarily removing food at feeding stations we examined whether birds with different personality differed in returning to visit empty feeders as this may provide information on how birds continue to sample their environment after a sudden change in conditions. In two summer experiments, we found that fast-exploring juveniles visited empty feeders less often compared to slow-exploring juveniles. In winter, sampling behaviour was sex dependent but not related to personality. In both seasons, we found that birds who sampled empty feeders more often were more likely to rediscover food after we again re-baited the feeding stations, but there was no effect of personality. Our results show that personality types may indeed differ in ways of collecting environmental information, which is consistent with the view of personalities as different styles of coping with environmental changes. The adaptive value of these alternative behavioural tactics, however, needs to be further explored.     

Stress and immunity: minireview

Stress, a state of threatened homeostasis, may be induced by various physical or psychological factors (stressors), including antigenic stimulation. Stressful experiences may affect both physical/psychological well being and immune functioning of humans and animals; the ongoing immune reaction may affect other physiological functions and psychological comfort. The molecular basis of these effects involves a network of multidirectional signalling and feedback regulations of neuroendocrine- and immunocyte-derived mediators. The consecutive stages of the multistep immune reactions might be either inhibited or enhanced owing to the previous and/or parallel stress experiences, depending on the kind of stressor and the animal species, strain, gender, or age. Therefore, the final results of stress-induced alteration of immune reactions are difficult to predict. The effect of a particular stressor on immune functions varies according to the previous stress experience of the individual (e.g. social confrontation, sterile saline injection) while various stressors may act in the same or in opposite ways on the same immune parameter. In general, the efficacy of immune response depends on the neuroendocrine environment on which it is superimposed. Conversely, neural and endocrine responses depend on the concurrent immune events upon which they are superimposed. It seems that the consequences of stress on the immune functioning are generally adaptive in the short run but can be damaging when stress is chronic.     

Environmental dependence of inbreeding depression and purging in Drosophila melanogaster

Elimination or reduction of inbreeding depression by natural selection at the contributing loci (purging) has been hypothesized to effectively mitigate the negative effects of inbreeding in small isolated populations. This may, however, only be valid when the environmental conditions are relatively constant. We tested this assumption using Drosophila melanogaster as a model organism. By means of chromosome balancers, chromosomes were sampled from a wild population and their viability was estimated in both homozygous and heterozygous conditions in a favourable environment. Around 50% of the chromosomes were found to carry a lethal or sublethal mutation, which upon inbreeding would cause a considerable amount of inbreeding depression. These detrimentals were artificially purged by selecting only chromosomes that in homozygous condition had a viability comparable to that of the heterozygotes (quasi-normals), thereby removing most deleterious recessive alleles. Next, these quasi-normals were tested both for egg-to-adult viability and for total fitness under different environmental stress conditions: high-temperature stress, DDT stress, ethanol stress, and crowding. Under these altered stressful conditions, particularly for high temperature and DDT, novel recessive deleterious effects were expressed that were not apparent under control conditions. Some of these chromosomes were even found to carry lethal or near-lethal mutations under stress. Compared with heterozygotes, homozygotes showed on average 25% additional reduction in total fitness. Our results show that, except for mutations that affect fitness under all environmental conditions, inbreeding depression may be due to different loci in different environments. Hence purging of deleterious recessive alleles can be effective only for the particular environment in which the purging occurred, because additional load will become expressed under changing environmental conditions. These results not only indicate that inbreeding depression is environment dependent, but also that inbreeding depression may become more severe under changing stressful conditions. These observations have significant consequences for conservation biology.     

Framing pictures: A conceptual framework to identify and correct for biases in detection probability of camera traps enabling multi‐species comparison

Obtaining reliable species observations is of great importance in animal ecology and wildlife conservation. An increasing number of studies use camera traps (CTs) to study wildlife communities, and an increasing effort is made to make better use and reuse of the large amounts of data that are produced. It is in these circumstances that it becomes paramount to correct for the species‐ and study‐specific variation in imperfect detection within CTs. We reviewed the literature and used our own experience to compile a list of factors that affect CT detection of animals. We did this within a conceptual framework of six distinct scales separating out the influences of (a) animal characteristics, (b) CT specifications, (c) CT set‐up protocols, and (d) environmental variables. We identified 40 factors that can potentially influence the detection of animals by CTs at these six scales. Many of these factors were related to only a few overarching parameters. Most of the animal characteristics scale with body mass and diet type, and most environmental characteristics differ with season or latitude such that remote sensing products like NDVI could be used as a proxy index to capture this variation. Factors that influence detection at the microsite and camera scales are probably the most important in determining CT detection of animals. The type of study and specific research question will determine which factors should be corrected. Corrections can be done by directly adjusting the CT metric of interest or by using covariates in a statistical framework. Our conceptual framework can be used to design better CT studies and help when analyzing CT data. Furthermore, it provides an overview of which factors should be reported in CT studies to make them repeatable, comparable, and their data reusable. This should greatly improve the possibilities for global scale analyses of (reused) CT data.     

Immunoepigenetics: the unseen side of cancer immunoediting

Cancer immunosurveillance representing, till recently, the explanatory framework relating cancer and the immune system, does not convincingly explain tumor escape. At the beginning of the decade, a new theory emerged, namely the immunoediting theory, and it comprehensively defines the role of the immune system in carcinogenesis. The core of this theory embraces the concept that the immune system on the one hand protects the body from cancer and on the other it shapes the immunogenicity of these cancers, thus presents a persuasive rationalization of the resistance of tumors against the immune response. With the immune system playing, in this context, such a pivotal role in shaping the tumor immune profile and in subsequent oncogenesis, it seems rather paradoxical to accept the immunocompetent host's immune system as a constant moiety. While DNA mutations of immune genes create a rather polymorphic condition, their frequency is much lower than that of other genetic events. Of these, epigenetic alterations give rise to new epialleles, which can reach up to 100% per locus. Bearing in mind that cancer is characterized by a tremendous amount of epigenetic aberrations, in both gene and global level, it is reasonable to postulate that, for the same unknown causes, analogous aberrations could affect the immune genes. Should this be the case, the relation between oncogenesis and the immune system appears much more dynamic and complex. Such an immunoepigenetic approach to carcinogenesis could improve our understanding of a series of common cancer-related aspects, such as environmental risk factors, effectiveness of demethylating agents, failure of current immunotherapies, etc. Moreover, this immunoepigenetic paradigm will take the current perception of the immune system and cancer interrelation further and beyond, constituting that the immunoresistant cancer cell phenotype is not shaped by the immune system acting as a steady and rigid evolutionary pressure, but rather as an extremely dynamic variable.