EPR Studies of Recombinant Horse L-Chain Apoferritin and its Mutant (E 53,56,57,60 Q) with Haemin

Structural similarities between ferritins and bacterioferritins have been extensively demonstrated. However, there is an essential difference between these two types of ferritins: whereas bacterioferritins bind haem, in-vivo, as Fe(II)-protoporphyrin IX (this haem is located in a hydrophobic pocket along the 2-fold symmetry axes and is liganded by two axial Met 52 residues), eukaryotic ferritins are non-haem iron proteins. However, in in-vivo studies, a cofactor has been isolated from horse spleen apoferritin similar to protoporphyrin IX; in in-vitro experiments, it has been shown that horse spleen apoferritin is able to interact with haemin (Fe(III)-protoporphyrin IX). Studies of haemin incorporation into horse spleen apoferritin have been carried out, which show that the metal free porphyrin is found in a pocket similar to that which binds haem in bacterioferritins (Précigoux et al. 1994 Acta Cryst D50, 739–743). A mechanism of demetallation of haemin by L-chain apoferritins was subsequently proposed (Crichton et al. 1997 Biochem 36, 15049–15054) which involved four Glu residues (E 53,56,57,60) situated at the entrance of the hydrophobic pocket and appeared to be favoured by acidic conditions. To verify this mechanism, these four Glu have been mutated to Gln in recombinant horse L-chain apoferritin. We report here the EPR spectra of recombinant horse L-chain apoferritin and its mutant with haemin in basic and acidic conditions. These studies confirm the ability of recombinant L-chain apoferritin and its mutant to incorporate and demetallate the haemin in acidic and basic conditions.     

Ferritins,iron uptake and storage from the bacterioferritin viewpoint

Ferritins constitute a broad superfamily of iron storage proteins, widespread in all domains of life, in aerobic or anaerobic organisms. Ferritins isolated from bacteria may be haem-free or contain a haem. In the latter case they are called bacterioferritins. The primary function of ferritins inside cells is to store iron in the ferric form. A secondary function may be detoxification of iron or protection against O(2) and its radical products. Indeed, for bacterioferritins this is likely to be their primary function. Ferritins and bacteroferritins have essentially the same architecture, assembling in a 24mer cluster to form a hollow, roughly spherical construction. In this review, special emphasis is given to the structure of the ferroxidase centres with native iron-containing sites, since oxidation of ferrous iron by molecular oxygen takes place in these sites. Although present in other ferritins, a specific entry route for iron, coupled with the ferroxidase reaction, has been proposed and described in some structural studies. Electrostatic calculations on a few selected proteins indicate further ion channels assumed to be an entry route in the later mineralization processes of core formation.     

Purification and characterization of phycoferritin from the blue-green alga, Arthrospira (Spirulina) platensis

Phycoferritin from the nutritionally important blue-green alga Arthrospira platensis has been isolated, by application of conventional biochemical techniques. The molecular mass, yield, iron and total neutral carbohydrate contents of the purified protein were 470 kDa, 0.044 mg g⁻¹ of Arthrospira, 1.4 and 20%, respectively. The iron content was much lower when compared to bacterial and mammalian ferritins. The P: Fe ratio of Arthrospira phycoferritin was 1: 3.5, a value akin to bacterioferritins. Native gel-electrophoresis revealed the presence of isoforms. Subunit analysis by SDS-PAGE and Western blotting showed a protein subunit with an apparent molecular mass of 18 kDa. Oligomeric forms of the protein subunit were also present. The phycoferritin exhibited cross-reactivity with anti-pea seed ferritin suggesting phylogenetic relationship with that of higher plants. Carbohydrate analysis of phycoferritin by GC-MS revealed the presence of sugars such as galactose, glucose and mannose similar to that of mammalian ferritins. Interestingly, the analysis also revealed sugars such as rhamnose, xylose and talose, which has not been reported in the structure of ferritins. Except for very low histidine content in phycoferritin, the rest of the amino acid composition resembled to ferritins of other species. UV-visible spectral analysis of the phycoferritin revealed the presence of haem groups, a property characteristic of bacterioferritins. The fluorescence intensity of phycoferritin was higher than equine spleen ferritin. Circular dichroic spectra revealed a lower degree of helicity.     

Isolation of a ferritin from Bacteroides fragilis

A ferritin was isolated from the obligate anaerobe Bacteroides fragilis. Estimated molecular masses were 400 kDa for the holomer and 16.7 kDa for the subunits. A 30-residue N-terminal amino acid sequence was determined and found to resemble the sequences of other ferritins (human H-chain ferritin, 43% identity; Escherichia coli gen-165 product, 37% identity) and to a lesser degree, bacterioferritins (E. coli bacterioferritin, 20% identity). The protein stained positively for iron, and incorporated 59Fe when B. fragilis was grown in the presence of [59Fe]citrate. However, the isolated protein contained only about three iron atoms per molecule, and contained no detectable haem. This represents the first isolation of a ferritin protein from bacteria. It may alleviate iron toxicity in the presence of oxygen.     

Bacterioferritins and ferritins are distantly related in evolution. Conservation of ferroxidase-centre residues

Iron-storage proteins can be divided into two classes; the bacterioferritins and ferritins. In spite of many apparent structural and functional analogies, no significant amino acid sequence similarity has been detected previously. This report now reveals a distant evolutionary relationship between bacterioferritins and ferritins derived by 'Profile Analysis'. Optimum alignment of bacterioferritin and ferritin sequences suggests that key residues of the ferroxidase centres of ferritins are conserved in bacterioferritins.     

Ferritin structure from Mycobacterium tuberculosis: comparative study with homologues identifies extended C-terminus involved in ferroxidase activity

Ferritins are recognized as key players in the iron storage and detoxification processes. Iron acquisition in the case of pathogenic bacteria has long been established as an important virulence mechanism. Here, we report a 3.0 Å crystal structure of a ferritin, annotated as Bacterioferritin B (BfrB), from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the causative agent of tuberculosis that continues to be one of the world''s deadliest diseases. Similar to the other members of ferritin family, the Mtb BfrB subunit exhibits the characteristic fold of a four-helical bundle that possesses the ferroxidase catalytic centre. We compare the structure of Mtb BfrB with representatives of the ferritin family belonging to the archaea, eubacteria and eukarya. Unlike most other ferritins, Mtb BfrB has an extended C-terminus. To dissect the role of this extended C-terminus, truncated Mtb BfrB was purified and biochemical studies implicate this region in ferroxidase activity and iron release in addition to providing stability to the protein. Functionally important regions in a protein of known 3D-structure can be determined by estimating the degree of conservation of the amino-acid sites with its close homologues. Based on the comparative studies, we identify the slowly evolving conserved sites as well as the rapidly evolving variable sites and analyze their role in relation to structure and function of Mtb BfrB. Further, electrostatic computations demonstrate that although the electrostatic environment of catalytic residues is preserved within the family, extensive variability is exhibited by residues defining the channels and pores, in all likelihood keeping up with the diverse functions executed by these ferritins in varied environments.     

X-ray structures of ferritins and related proteins

Ferritins are members of a much larger superfamily of proteins, which are characterised by a structural motif consisting of a bundle of four parallel and anti-parallel α helices. The ferritin superfamily itself is widely distributed across all three living kingdoms, in both aerobic and anaerobic organisms, and a considerable number of X-ray structures are available, some at extremely high resolution. We describe first of all the subunit structure of mammalian H and L chain ferritins and then discuss intersubunit interactions in the 24-subunit quaternary structure of these ferritins. Bacteria contain two types of ferritins, FTNs, which like mammalian ferritins do not contain haem, and the haem-containing BFRs. The characteristic carboxylate-bridged di-iron ferroxidase sites of H chain ferritins, FTNs and BFRs are compared, as are the potential entry sites for iron and the ‘nucleation’ site of L chain ferritins. Finally we discuss the three-dimensional structures of the 12-subunit bacterial Dps (DNA-binding protein from starved cells) proteins as well as their intersubunit di-iron ferroxidase site.     

Structure, function, and evolution of ferritins.

The ferritins of animals and plants and the bacterioferritins (BFRs) have a common iron-storage function in spite of differences in cytological location and biosynthetic regulation. The plant ferritins and BFRs are more similar to the H chains of mammals than to mammalian L chains, with respect to primary structure and conservation of ferroxidase center residues. Hence they probably arose from a common H-type ancestor. The recent discovery in E. coli of a second type of iron-storage protein (FTN) resembling ferritin H chains raises the question of what the relative roles of these two proteins are in this organism. Mammalian L ferritins lack ferroxidase centers and form a distinct group. Comparison of the three-dimensional structures of mammalian and invertebrate ferritins, as well as computer modeling of plant ferritins and of BFR, indicate a well conserved molecular framework. The characterisation of numerous ferritin homopolymer variants has allowed the identification of some of the residues involved in iron uptake and an investigation of some of the functional differences between mammalian H and L chains.     

Two distinct ferritin-like molecules in Pseudomonas aeruginosa: the product of the bfrA gene is a bacterial ferritin (FtnA) and not a bacterioferritin (Bfr)

Two distinct types of ferritin-like molecules often coexist in bacteria, the heme binding bacterioferritins (Bfr) and the non-heme binding bacterial ferritins (Ftn). The early isolation of a ferritin-like molecule from Pseudomonas aeruginosa suggested the possibility of a bacterioferritin assembled from two different subunits [Moore, G. R., et al. (1994) Biochem. J. 304, 493-497]. Subsequent studies demonstrated the presence of two genes encoding ferritin-like molecules in P. aeruginosa, designated bfrA and bfrB, and suggested that two distinct bacterioferritins may coexist [Ma, J.-F., et al. (1999) J. Bacteriol. 181, 3730-3742]. In this report, we present structural evidence demonstrating that the product of the bfrA gene is a ferritin-like molecule not capable of binding heme that harbors a catalytically active ferroxidase center with structural properties similar to those characteristic of bacterial and archaeal Ftns and clearly distinct from those of the ferroxidase center typical of Bfrs. Consequently, the product of the bfrA gene in P. aeruginosa is a bacterial ferritin, which we propose should be termed Pa FtnA. These results, together with the previous characterization of the product of the bfrB gene as a genuine bacterioferritin (Pa BfrB) [Weeratunga, S. J., et al. (2010) Biochemistry 49, 1160-1175], indicate the coexistence of a bacterial ferritin (Pa FtnA) and a bacterioferritin (Pa BfrB) in P. aeruginosa. In agreement with this idea, we also obtained evidence demonstrating that release of iron from Pa BfrB and Pa FtnA is likely subject to different regulation in P. aerugionsa. Whereas the efficient release of iron stored in Pa FtnA requires only the input of electrons from a ferredoxin NADP reductase (Pa Fpr), the release of iron stored in Pa BfrB requires not only electron delivery by Pa Fpr but also the presence of a "regulator", the apo form of a bacterioferritin-associated ferredoxin (apo Pa Bfd). Finally, structural analysis of iron uptake in crystallo suggests a possible pathway for the internalization of ferroxidase iron into the interior cavity of Pa FtnA.     

Mass spectrometry studies of demetallation of haemin by recombinant horse L chain apoferritin and its mutant (E 53,56,57,60 Q)

An essential difference between eukaryotic ferritins and bacterioferritins is that the latter contain naturally, in vivo haem as Fe-protoporphyrin IX. This haem is located in a hydrophobic pocket along the 2-fold symmetry axes and is liganded by two Met 52. However, in in vivo studies, a cofactor has been isolated in horse spleen apoferritin similar to protoporphyrin IX; in in vitro experiments, it has been shown that horse spleen apoferritin is able to interact with haem. Studies of haemin (Fe(III)-PPIX) incorporation into horse spleen apoferritin have been carried out, which show that the metal free porphyrin is found in a corresponding pocket to haem in bacterioferritins [Précigoux, G., Yariv, J., Gallois, B., Dautant, A., Courseille, C. and Langlois, d'Estaintot B. (1994) A crystallographic study of haem binding to ferritin. Acta Cryst. D 50, 739-743]. A mechanism of demetallation of haemin by L-chain apoferritin was proposed [Crichton, R.R., Soruco, J.A., Roland, F., Michaux, M.A., Gallois, B., Précigoux, G., Mahy, J.P. and Mansuy. (1997) Remarkable ability of horse spleen apoferritin to demetallate hemin and to metallate protoporphyrin IX as a function of pH. J. P. Biochem. 36, 49, 15049-15054]: this involved four Glu residues (53,56,57,60) situated at the entrance of the hydrophobic pocket and appeared to be favoured by acidic conditions. To verify this mechanism, we have mutated these four Glu to Gln and examined demetallation in both acidic and basic conditions. In this paper, we report the mass spectrometry studies of L-chain apoferritin and its mutant incubated with haemin and analysed after different times of incubation: 15 days, 2 months, 6 months, 9 months and 12 months. These studies show that the recombinant L-chain apoferritin and its mutant are able to demetallate haemin to give a hydroxyethyl protoporphyrin IX derivative in a dimeric form [Macieira, S., Martins, B. M. and Huber, R. (2003) Oxygen-dependent coproporphyrinogen IX oxidase from Escherichia coli: one-step purification and biochemical characterization. FEMS. Microbiology Letters 226, 31-37].     

Physical, chemical and immunological properties of the bacterioferritins of Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Azotobacter vinelandii

The 70-amino-acid-residue N-terminal sequence of the bacterioferritin (BFR) of Azotobacter vinelandii was determined and shown to be highly similar to the N-terminal sequences of the Escherichia coli and Nitrobacter winogradskyi bacterioferritins. Electrophoretic and immunological analyses further indicate that the bacterioferritins of E. coli, A. vinelandii and Pseudomonas aeruginosa are closely related. A novel, two-subunit assembly state that predominates over the 24-subunit form of BFR at low pH was demonstrated. The results indicate that the bacterioferritins form a family of proteins that are distinct from the ferritins of plants and animals.     

A note on the composition and properties of ferritin iron cores

In ferritins and bacterioferritins iron is stored as an inorganic complex within a protein shell. The composition and properties of this complex are surprisingly variable. Factors that may lead to such variability are discussed.     

Fe-haem bound to Escherichia coli bacterioferritin accelerates iron core formation by an electron transfer mechanism

BFR (bacterioferritin) is an iron storage and detoxification protein that differs from other ferritins by its ability to bind haem cofactors. Haem bound to BFR is believed to be involved in iron release and was previously thought not to play a role in iron core formation. Investigation of the effect of bound haem on formation of the iron core has been enabled in the present work by development of a method for reconstitution of BFR from Escherichia coli with exogenously added haem at elevated temperature in the presence of a relatively high concentration of sodium chloride. Kinetic analysis of iron oxidation by E. coli BFR preparations containing various amounts of haem revealed that haem bound to BFR decreases the rate of iron oxidation at the dinuclear iron ferroxidase sites but increases the rate of iron core formation. Similar kinetic analysis of BFR reconstituted with cobalt-haem revealed that this haem derivative has no influence on the rate of iron core formation. These observations argue that haem bound to E. coli BFR accelerates iron core formation by an electron-transfer-based mechanism.     

Mycobacterium thermoresistibile as a source of thermostable orthologs of Mycobacterium tuberculosis proteins

The genus Mycobacterium comprises major human pathogens such as the causative agent of tuberculosis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), and many environmental species. Tuberculosis claims ~1.5 million lives every year, and drug resistant strains of Mtb are rapidly emerging. To aid the development of new tuberculosis drugs, major efforts are currently under way to determine crystal structures of Mtb drug targets and proteins involved in pathogenicity. However, a major obstacle to obtaining crystal structures is the generation of well-diffracting crystals. Proteins from thermophiles can have better crystallization and diffraction properties than proteins from mesophiles, but their sequences and structures are often divergent. Here, we establish a thermophilic mycobacterial model organism, Mycobacterium thermoresistibile (Mth), for the study of Mtb proteins. Mth tolerates higher temperatures than Mtb or other environmental mycobacteria such as M. smegmatis. Mth proteins are on average more soluble than Mtb proteins, and comparison of the crystal structures of two pairs of orthologous proteins reveals nearly identical folds, indicating that Mth structures provide good surrogates for Mtb structures. This study introduces a thermophile as a source of protein for the study of a closely related human pathogen and marks a new approach to solving challenging mycobacterial protein structures.     

Bacterioferritin from Mycobacterium smegmatis contains zinc in its di-nuclear site

Bacterioferritins, also known as cytochrome b (1), are oligomeric iron-storage proteins consisting of 24 identical amino acid chains, which form spherical particles consisting of 24 subunits and exhibiting 432 point-group symmetry. They contain one haem b molecule at the interface between two subunits and a di-nuclear metal binding center. The X-ray structure of bacterioferritin from Mycobacterium smegmatis (Ms-Bfr) was determined to a resolution of 2.7 A in the monoclinic space group C2. The asymmetric unit of the crystals contains 12 protein molecules: five dimers and two half-dimers located along the crystallographic twofold axis. Unexpectedly, the di-nuclear metal binding center contains zinc ions instead of the typically observed iron ions in other bacterioferritins.     

Iron core mineralisation in prokaryotic ferritins

Background

To satisfy their requirement for iron while at the same time countering the toxicity of this highly reactive metal ion, prokaryotes have evolved proteins belonging to two distinct sub-families of the ferritin family: the bacterioferritins (BFRs) and the bacterial ferritins (Ftns). Recently, Ftn homologues have also been identified and characterised in archaeon species. All of these prokaryotic ferritins function by solubilising and storing large amounts of iron in the form of a safe but bio-available mineral.

Scope of review

The mechanism(s) by which the iron mineral is formed by these proteins is the subject of much current interest. Here we review the available information on these proteins, with particular emphasis on significant advances resulting from recent structural, spectroscopic and kinetic studies.

Major conclusions

Current understanding indicates that at least two distinct mechanisms are in operation in prokaryotic ferritins. In one, the ferroxidase centre acts as a true catalytic centre in driving Fe²⁺ oxidation in the cavity; in the other, the centre acts as a gated iron pore by oxidising Fe²⁺ and transferring the resulting Fe³⁺ into the central cavity.

General significance

The prokaryotic ferritins exhibit a wide variation in mechanisms of iron core mineralisation. The basis of these differences lies, at least in part, in structural differences at and around the catalytic centre. However, it appears that more subtle differences must also be important in controlling the iron chemistry of these remarkable proteins.     

Characterization of active site structure in CYP121. A cytochrome P450 essential for viability of Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv

Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) cytochrome P450 gene CYP121 is shown to be essential for viability of the bacterium in vitro by gene knock-out with complementation. Production of CYP121 protein in Mtb cells is demonstrated. Minimum inhibitory concentration values for azole drugs against Mtb H37Rv were determined, the rank order of which correlated well with Kd values for their binding to CYP121. Solution-state spectroscopic, kinetic, and thermodynamic studies and crystal structure determination for a series of CYP121 active site mutants provide further insights into structure and biophysical features of the enzyme. Pro346 was shown to control heme cofactor conformation, whereas Arg386 is a critical determinant of heme potential, with an unprecedented 280-mV increase in heme iron redox potential in a R386L mutant. A homologous Mtb redox partner system was reconstituted and transported electrons faster to CYP121 R386L than to wild type CYP121. Heme potential was not perturbed in a F338H mutant, suggesting that a proposed P450 superfamily-wide role for the phylogenetically conserved phenylalanine in heme thermodynamic regulation is unlikely. Collectively, data point to an important cellular role for CYP121 and highlight its potential as a novel Mtb drug target.     

A protein carboxylate coordinated oxo-centered tri-nuclear iron complex with possible implications for ferritin mineralization

The crystal structure of an oxo-centered tri-nuclear iron complex formed on a protein surface is presented. The cluster forms when crystals of the class Ib ribonucleotide reductase R2 protein from Corynebacterium ammoniagenes are subjected to iron soaking. The tri-iron-oxo complex is coordinated by protein-derived carboxylate ligands arranged in a motif similar to the one found on the inner surface of ferritins and may mimic an early stage in the mineralization of iron in ferritins. In addition, the structure adds to the very limited data on protein-mineral interfaces.     

Iron incorporation into Escherichia coli Dps gives rise to a ferritin-like microcrystalline core

Escherichia coli Dps belongs to a family of bacterial stress-induced proteins to protect DNA from oxidative damage. It shares with Listeria innocua ferritin several structural features, such as the quaternary assemblage and the presence of an unusual ferroxidase center. Indeed, it was recently recognized to be able to oxidize and incorporate iron. Since ferritins are endowed with the unique capacity to direct iron deposition toward formation of a microcrystalline core, the structure of iron deposited in the E. coli Dps cavity was studied. Polarized single crystal absorption microspectrophotometry of iron-loaded Dps shows that iron ions are oriented. The spectral properties in the high spin 3d(5) configuration point to a crystal form with tetrahedral symmetry where the tetrahedron center is occupied by iron ions and the vertices by oxygen. Crystals of iron-loaded Dps also show that, as in mammalian ferritins, iron does not remain bound to the site after oxidation has taken place. The kinetics of the iron reduction/release process induced by dithionite were measured in the crystal and in solution. The reaction appears to have two phases, with t(12) of a few seconds and several minutes at neutral pH values, as in canonical ferritins. This behavior is attributed to a similar composition of the iron core.     

Critical roles of bacterioferritins in iron storage and proliferation of cyanobacteria

Cyanobacteria are key contributors to global photosynthetic productivity, and iron availability is essential for cyanobacterial proliferation. While iron is abundant in the earth's crust, its unique chemical properties render it a limiting factor for photoautotrophic growth. As compared to other nonphotosynthetic organisms, oxygenic photosynthetic organisms such as cyanobacteria, algae, and green plants need large amounts of iron to maintain functional PSI complexes in their photosynthetic apparatus. Ferritins and bacterioferritins are ubiquitously present iron-storage proteins. We have found that in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 (Synechocystis 6803), bacterioferritins are responsible for the storage of as much as 50% of cellular iron. Synechocystis 6803, as well as many other cyanobacterial species, have two bacterioferritins, BfrA and BfrB, in which either the heme binding or di-iron center ligating residues are absent. Purified bacterioferritin complex from Synechocystis 6803 has both BfrA and BfrB proteins. Targeted mutagenesis of each of the two bacterioferritin genes resulted in poor growth under iron-deprived conditions. Inactivation of both genes did not result in a more severe phenotype. These results support the presence of a heteromultimeric structure of Synechocystis bacterioferritin, in which one subunit ligates a di-iron center while the other accommodates heme binding. Notably, the reduced internal iron concentrations in the mutant cells resulted in a lower content of PSI. In addition, they triggered iron starvation responses even in the presence of normal levels of external iron, thus demonstrating a central role of bacterioferritins in iron homeostasis in these photosynthetic organisms.