Genetic analysis of the functional relationship between colicin E3 and its immunity protein.

Partial deletions in the immunity gene of the colicin E3 operon were used to study possible functions of the immunity protein besides protection against exogenous colicin. Nuclease BAL-31 was used to create a series of carboxyl-terminal deletions of the immunity gene. Mutants displaying lowered immunity against exogenous colicin were found, and six that had reduced but detectable levels of immunity were chosen for further analysis. DNA sequence analysis of the deletions showed that all six terminated within the last five codons of the immunity gene. The wild-type immunity gene was replaced by each of the six mutated immunity genes in a plasmid containing an otherwise functional colicin E3 operon. Transformants containing the resulting plasmids produced smaller colonies on solid medium and grew more slowly in liquid culture than transformants carrying the wild-type colicin and immunity genes. This result suggested that immunity protein was required to protect the cell against endogenous colicin E3. This idea was confirmed in experiments in which the colicin E3 and immunity genes were independently cloned on two compatible plasmid vectors.     

Identification of a unique specificity determinant of the colicin E3 immunity protein.

Plasmid immunity to a nuclease-type colicin is defined by the specific binding of an immunity (or inhibitor) protein, Imm, to the C-terminal nuclease domain, T2A, of the colicin molecule. Whereas most regions of colicin operons exhibit extensive sequence identity, the small plasmid region encoding T2A and Imm is exceptionally varied. Since immunity is essential for the survival of the potentially lethal colicin plasmid (Col), we inferred that T2A and Imm must have co-evolved, retaining their mutual binding specificities. To evaluate this co-evolution model for the col and imm genes of ColE3 and ColE6, we attempted to obtain a stabilized clone from a plasmid which had been destabilized with a non-cognate immunity gene. A hybrid Col, in which the immE3 gene of the ColE3 was replaced with immE6 from ColE6, was lethal to the host cells upon SOS induction. From among this suicidal cell population, we isolated a stabilized, i.e., evolved, clone which produced colicin E3 (E3) stably and exhibited immunity to E3. This change arose from only a single mutation in ImmE6, from Trp48 to Cys, the same residue as in the ImmE3 sequence. In addition, we constructed a series of chimeric genes through homologous recombination between immE3 and immE6. Characterization of these chimeric immunity genes confirmed the above finding that colicins E3 and E6 are mostly distinguished by only Cys48 of the ImmE3 protein.     

Inhibition of a ribosome-inactivating ribonuclease: the crystal structure of the cytotoxic domain of colicin E3 in complex with its immunity protein

BACKGROUND: The cytotoxicity of most ribonuclease E colicins towards Escherichia coli arises from their ability to specifically cleave between bases 1493 and 1494 of 16S ribosomal RNA. This activity is carried by the C-terminal domain of the colicin, an activity which if left unneutralised would lead to destruction of the producing cell. To combat this the host E. coli cell produces an inhibitor protein, the immunity protein, which forms a complex with the ribonuclease domain effectively suppressing its activity. RESULTS: We have solved the crystal structure of the cytotoxic domain of the ribonuclease colicin E3 in complex with its immunity protein, Im3. The structure of the ribonuclease domain, the first of its class, reveals a highly twisted central beta-sheet elaborated with a short N-terminal helix, the residues of which form a well-packed interface with the immunity protein. CONCLUSIONS: The structure of the ribonuclease domain of colicin E3 is novel and forms an interface with its inhibitor which is significantly different in character to that reported for the DNase colicin complexes with their immunity proteins. The structure also gives insight into the mode of action of this class of enzymatic colicins by allowing the identification of potentially catalytic residues. This in turn reveals that the inhibitor does not bind at the active site but rather at an adjacent site, leaving the catalytic centre exposed in a fashion similar to that observed for the DNase colicins. Thus, E. coli appears to have evolved similar methods for ensuring efficient inhibition of the potentially destructive effects of the two classes of enzymatic colicins.     

Crystallization and preliminary x-ray investigation of colicin E3 in complex with its immunity protein

Crystals of the colicin E3-immunity protein complex have been grown from solutions of citrate at pH 5.6. The crystals are monoclinic, space group P2(1), with unit cell dimensions a = 67.71, b = 196.67, c = 85.58 A, and beta = 113.67 degrees. The crystals diffract to 3-A resolution and are stable in the x-ray beam for at least a day. Although the stoichiometry of the complex in solution is 1:1 there are two, three, or four such binary complex molecules in the asymmetric unit.     

Channel domain of colicin A modifies the dimeric organization of its immunity protein

Proteins conferring immunity against pore-forming colicins are localized in the Escherichia coli inner membrane. Their protective effects are mediated by direct interaction with the C-terminal domain of their cognate colicins. Cai, the immunity protein protecting E. coli against colicin A, contains four cysteine residues. We report cysteine cross-linking experiments showing that Cai forms homodimers. Cai contains four transmembrane segments (TMSs), and dimerization occurs via the third TMS. Furthermore, we observe the formation of intramolecular disulfide bonds that connect TMS2 with either TMS1 or TMS3. Co-expression of Cai with its target, the colicin A pore-forming domain (pfColA), in the inner membrane prevents the formation of intermolecular and intramolecular disulfide bonds, indicating that pfColA interacts with the dimer of Cai and modifies its conformation. Finally, we show that when Cai is locked by disulfide bonds, it is no longer able to protect cells against exogenous added colicin A.     

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction studies of colicin E3 immunity protein

Immunity protein, an inhibitor of the ribonuclease activity of the protein antibiotic colicin E₃, crystallizes in the orthorhombic space group C222 with cell dimensions $\text{a = 78·7}\text{A}\text{?}\text{, b = 54·1}\text{A}\text{?}\text{, c = 36·1}\text{A}\text{?}$ and one molecule of M_r 9800 per asymmetric unit. The crystals are suitable for high resolution X-ray analysis.     

The crystal structure of the dimeric colicin M immunity protein displays a 3D domain swap

Bacteriocins are proteins secreted by many bacterial cells to kill related bacteria of the same niche. To avoid their own suicide through reuptake of secreted bacteriocins, these bacteria protect themselves by co-expression of immunity proteins in the compartment of colicin destination. In Escherichia coli the colicin M (Cma) is inactivated by the interaction with the Cma immunity protein (Cmi). We have crystallized and solved the structure of Cmi at a resolution of 1.95? by the recently developed ab initio phasing program ARCIMBOLDO. The monomeric structure of the mature 10kDa protein comprises a long N-terminal α-helix and a four-stranded C-terminal β-sheet. Dimerization of this fold is mediated by an extended interface of hydrogen bond interactions between the α-helix and the four-stranded β-sheet of the symmetry related molecule. Two intermolecular disulfide bridges covalently connect this dimer to further lock this complex. The Cmi protein resembles an example of a 3D domain swapping being stalled through physical linkage. The dimer is a highly charged complex with a significant surplus of negative charges presumably responsible for interactions with Cma. Dimerization of Cmi was also demonstrated to occur in vivo. Although the Cmi-Cma complex is unique among bacteria, the general fold of Cmi is representative for a class of YebF-like proteins which are known to be secreted into the external medium by some Gram-negative bacteria.     

The colicin E3 outer membrane translocon: immunity protein release allows interaction of the cytotoxic domain with OmpF porin

The crystal structure previously obtained for the complex of BtuB and the receptor binding domain of colicin E3 forms a basis for further analysis of the mechanism of colicin import through the bacterial outer membrane. Together with genetic analysis and studies on colicin occlusion of OmpF channels, this implied a colicin translocon consisting of BtuB and OmpF that would transfer the C-terminal cytotoxic domain (C96) of colicin E3 through the Escherichia coli outer membrane. This model does not, however, explain how the colicin attains the unfolded conformation necessary for transfer. Such a conformation change would require removal of the immunity (Imm) protein, which is bound tightly in a complex with the folded colicin E3. In the present study, it was possible to obtain reversible removal of Imm in vitro in a single column chromatography step without colicin denaturation. This resulted in a mostly unordered secondary structure of the cytotoxic domain and a large decrease in stability, which was also found in the receptor binding domain. These structure changes were documented by near- and far-UV circular dichroism and intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. Reconstitution of Imm in a complex with C96 or colicin E3 restored the native structure. C96 depleted of Imm, in contrast to the native complex with Imm, efficiently occluded OmpF channels, implying that the presence of tightly bound Imm prevents its unfolding and utilization of the OmpF porin for subsequent import of the cytotoxic domain.     

Thermodynamic consequences of bipartite immunity protein binding to the ribosomal ribonuclease colicin E3

Colicin E3 is a 60 kDa, multidomain protein antibiotic that targets its ribonuclease activity to an essential region of the 16S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli. To prevent suicide of the producing cell, synthesis of the toxin is accompanied by the production of a 10 kDa immunity protein (Im3) that binds strongly to the toxin and abolishes its enzymatic activity. In the present work, we study the interaction of Im3 with the isolated cytotoxic domain (E3 rRNase) and intact colicin E3 through presteady-state kinetics and thermodynamic measurements. The isolated E3 rRNase domain forms a high affinity complex with Im3 (K(d) = 10(-12) M, in 200 mM NaCl at pH 7.0 and 25 degrees C). The interaction of Im3 with full-length colicin E3 under the same conditions is however significantly stronger (K(d) = 10(-14) M). The difference in affinity arises almost wholly from a marked decrease in the dissociation rate constant for the full-length complex (8 x 10(-7) s(-1)) relative to the E3 rRNase-Im3 complex (1 x 10(-4) s(-1)), with their association rates comparable ( approximately 10(8) M(-1) s(-1)). Thermodynamic measurements show that complex formation is largely enthalpy driven. In light of the recently published crystal structure of the colicin E3-Im3 complex, the additional stabilization of the wild-type complex can be ascribed to the interaction of Im3 with the N-terminal translocation domain of the toxin. These observations suggest a mechanism whereby dissociation of the immunity protein prior to translocation into the target cell is facilitated by the loss of the Im3-translocation domain interaction.     

Structural and mutational studies of the catalytic domain of colicin E5: a tRNA-specific ribonuclease

Colicin E5 specifically cleaves four tRNAs in Escherichia coli that contain the modified nucleotide queuosine (Q) at the wobble position, thereby preventing protein synthesis and ultimately resulting in cell death. Here, the crystal structure of the catalytic domain of colicin E5 (E5-CRD) from E. coli was determined at 1.5 A resolution. Unexpectedly, E5-CRD adopts a core folding with a four-stranded beta-sheet packed against an alpha-helix, seen in the well-studied ribonuclease T1 despite a lack of sequence similarity. Beyond the core catalytic domain, an N-terminal helix, a C-terminal beta-strand and loop, and an extended internal loop constitute an RNA binding cleft. Mutational analysis identified five amino acids that were important for tRNA substrate binding and cleavage by E5-CRD. The structure, together with the mutational study, allows us to propose a model of colicin E5-tRNA interactions, suggesting the molecular basis of tRNA substrate recognition and the mechanism of tRNA cleavage by colicin E5.     

Fine cleavage map of a small colicin E1 plasmid carrying genes responsible for replication and colicin E1 immunity.

A small plasmid (pAO2, 1 megadalton) carrying genes responsible for replication and colicin E1 immunity has been constructed from colicin E1 plasmid (A. Oka, K. Sugimoto, and M. Takanami, Proc. Mol. Biol. Jpn., p. 113-115, 1976). pAO2 DNA was cleaved into unique fragments with seven restriction endonucleases (R.HaeII,R.HaeIII,R.HapII,R.HhaI,R.AluI,R.HgaI, and R.HinfI). R.HaeII cleaved pAO2 DNA at two sites, R.HaeIII at four sites, R.HapII at nine sites, R.HhaI at eight sites, R-AluI at nine sites, R.HgaI at two sites, and R.HinfI at four sites, respectively. The order of HaeIII fragments of pAO2 was deduced from the physical map of colicin E1 plasmid previously reported (A. Oka and M. Takanami, Nature (London) 264:193-196, 1976). HapII, HhaI, and AluI fragments of pAO2 were assigned by analyzing overlapping sets of fragments arising upon digestion of individual HaeIII fragments with one of R.HapII, R.HhaI, or R.AluI, and upon their reciprocal digestion. The cleavage sites for R.HaeII, R.HgaI, and R.HinfI were localized on HapII, HhaI, and AluI fragments by combined digestion. On the basis of these data and estimates of the size of each fragment, a fine cleavage map of pAO2 was constructed.