Artificial ribonucleases: from combinatorial libraries to efficient catalysts of RNA cleavage

Combinatorial libraries of small organic compounds capable of cleaving RNA were synthesized. The compounds contain benzene ring substituted with two residues of bis quaternary salt of diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) bearing hydrophobic fragments of different length and structure, attached to DABCO at the bridge position. These compounds, lacking traditional functionalities involved in transesterification reaction, exhibit pronounced RNA cleavage activity. To identify the most active artificial ribonucleases, sublibraries and truncated libraries, containing compounds lacking one of substituents were synthesized. Analysis of ribonuclease activity of truncated libraries resulted in identification of the most active compounds, which are characterized by the presence of at least one long oligomethylene substituent.     

Ribonuclease activity of cationic structures conjugated to lipophilic groups

Cationic compounds containing benzene ring substituted with the bis-quaternary salt of diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) bearing a polymethylene fragment at the bridge positions display ribonuclease activity. Efficacy of the catalysis is affected by geometry of the cationic structures and the size of the attached aliphatic fragment. The cleavage occurs primarily within CA sequences. The compounds do not possess tradition groups participating in the transesterification step of RNA cleavage reaction, therefore a speculative mechanism of cleavage could be inducing a conformational stress on the RNA sugar phosphate backbone providing fragility to phosphodiester bonds.     

Ribonuclease Activity of Cationic Structures Conjugated to Lipophilic Groups

Cationic compounds containing benzene ring substituted with the bis‐quaternary salt of diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) bearing a polymethylene fragment at the bridge positions display ribonuclease activity. Efficacy of the catalysis is affected by geometry of the cationic structures and the size of the attached aliphatic fragment. The cleavage occurs primarily within CA sequences. The compounds do not possess tradition groups participating in the transesterification step of RNA cleavage reaction, therefore a speculative mechanism of cleavage could be inducing a conformational stress on the RNA sugar phosphate backbone providing fragility to phosphodiester bonds.     

Unexpected metal ion requirements specific for catalysis of the branching reaction in a group II intron

The splicing process catalyzed by group II intron ribozymes follows the same two-step pathway as nuclear pre-mRNA splicing. In vivo, the first splicing step of wild-type introns is a transesterification reaction giving rise to a branched lariat intron-3'-exon intermediate characteristic of this splicing mode. In the wild-type introns, the ribozyme core and the substrate intron-exon junctions are carried by the same precursor molecule, making it difficult to distinguish between RNA folding and catalysis under normal splicing reactions. To characterize the catalytic step of the first transesterification reaction, we studied the reversal of this reaction, reverse branching. In this reverse reaction, the excised lariat intron and the substrate 5'-exon can be preincubated and folded separately, allowing the measure of the catalytic rate of the reaction. To measure the catalytic rate of the second splicing step, purified lariat intron-3'-exon intermediate molecules were preincubated and folded prior to the addition of 5'-exon. Conditions could be found where chemistry appeared rate limiting for both catalytic steps. Study of the metal ion requirements under these conditions resulted in the unexpected finding that, for the intron studied, substitution of magnesium ions by manganese ions enhanced the rate of the first transesterification reaction by two orders of magnitude but had virtually no effect on the second transesterification reaction or the 5' splice site cleavage by hydrolysis. Finally, the catalytic rates measured under optimal conditions for both splicing steps were faster by three orders of magnitude in the branching pathway than in the hydrolytic pathway.     

RNase activity of a DNA minor groove binder with a minimalist catalytic motif from RNase A

Imidazole and compounds containing imidazole residues have been shown to cleave RNA in an RNase A-mimicking manner. Di-imidazole lexitropsin is a compound which is derived from the polyamide drugs distamycin and netropsin essentially by the replacement of two pyrrole heterocycles with N-methyl-imidazole residues. This enables it to bind to the minor groove of B-DNA in a sequence-specific manner. We demonstrate here that this lexitropsin derivative has RNA cleavage activity, as tested on model RNAs. Optimal cleavage conditions and cleavage specificity resemble those known from other imidazole conjugates and are thus consistent with an RNase A type cleavage mechanism. The optimum concentration of the compound for cleavage is similar to previously investigated imidazole-based RNase mimics. As a whole new class of chemical compounds capable of interacting with nucleic acids through extensive hydrogen bonding, these imidazole containing compounds constitute promising scaffolds and ligands, for the construction of novel RNase mimics with high affinity.     

Cleavage and synthesis function of high and low redox potential laccases towards 4-morpholinoaniline and aminated as well as chlorinated phenols

Laccases are able to mediate both cleavage and synthesis processes. The basis for this dual reaction capability lies in the property of the enzyme laccase to oxidize phenolic, and to some extent non-phenolic substances, to reactive radicals which can undergo on the one hand separations of small substitutents or large molecule parts from the parent compound and on the other hand coupling reactions with other radicals or molecules which are not themselves oxidizable by laccase. The cleavage of the non-phenolic compound 4-morpholinoaniline as well as the deamination of 4-aminophenol and the dechlorination of 4-chlorophenol resulted in the formation of 1,4-hydroquinone which is immediately oxidized by laccase to 1,4-benzoquinone. The formation of the 1,4-hydroquinone/1,4-benzoquinone is the rate limiting step for the synthesis of the heteromolecular dimers and trimers composed of 1,4-benzoquinone and one or two molecules of morpholine. In addition to the synthesis of new compounds from the cleavage products, 4-morpholinoaniline polymerized probably via azo groups and C-N bonds to a homomolecular dimer and trimer. Similarities and differences in cleavage and synthesis reactions catalyzed by the low redox potential laccase of Myceliophthora thermophila (0.46 V) and the high redox potential laccase of Pycnoporus cinnabarinus (0.79 V) were determined. In addition, the dependency of the cleavage and synthesis efficiencies on the (a) structure and redox potential of the laccase, (b) structure and redox potential of the substrate, (c) pH value of the buffer used, (d) incubation temperature, (e) solvent concentration, and (f) laccase activity is discussed in general.     

Mg2+-independent hairpin ribozyme catalysis in hydrated RNA films

The hairpin ribozyme catalyzes RNA cleavage in partially hydrated RNA films in the absence of added divalent cations. This reaction exhibits the characteristics associated with the RNA cleavage reaction observed under standard conditions in solution. Catalysis is a site-specific intramolecular transesterification reaction, requires the 2'-hydroxyl group of substrate nucleotide A(-1), and generates 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. Mutations in both ribozyme and substrate abolish catalysis in hydrated films. The reaction is accelerated by cations that may enhance binding, conformational stability, and catalytic activity, and is inhibited by Tb3+. The reaction has an apparent temperature optimum of 4 degrees C. At this temperature, cleavage is slow (k(obs): 2 d(-1)) and progressive, with accumulation of cleavage products to an extent of 40%. The use of synthetic RNAs, chelators, and analysis of all reaction components by inductively coupled plasma-optical spectrophotometry (ICPOES) effectively rules out the possibility of contaminating divalent metals in the reactions. Catalysis is minimal under conditions of extreme dehydration, indicating that the reaction requires hydration of RNA by atmospheric water. Our results provide a further caution for those studying the biochemical activity of ribozymes in vitro and in cells, as unanticipated catalysis could occur during RNA manipulation and lead to misinterpretation of data.     

In vitro selection of RNAs that undergo autolytic cleavage with Pb2+.

An in vitro selection method has been developed to obtain RNA molecules that specifically undergo autolytic cleavage reactions by Pb2+ ion. The method utilizes a circular RNA intermediate which is regenerated following the cleavage reaction to allow amplification and multiple cycles of selection. Pb2+ is known to catalyze a specific cleavage reaction between U17 and G18 of yeast tRNA(Phe). Starting from pools of RNA molecules which have a random distribution of sequences at nine or ten selected positions in the sequence of yeast tRNA(Phe), we have isolated many RNA molecules that undergo rapid and specific self-cleavage with Pb2+ at a variety of different sites. Terminal truncation experiments suggest that most of these self-cleaving RNA molecules do not fold like tRNA. However, two of the variants are cleaved rapidly with Pb2+ at U17 even though they lack the highly conserved nucleotides G18 and G19. Both specific mutations and terminal truncation experiments suggest that the D and T loops of these two variants interact in a manner similar to that of tRNA(Phe) despite the absence of the G18U55 and G19C56 tertiary interactions. A model for an alternate tertiary interaction involving a U17U55 pair is presented. This model may be relevant to the structure of about 100 mitochondrial tRNAs that also lack G18 and G19. The selection method presented here can be directly applied to isolate catalytic RNAs that undergo cleavage in the presence of other metal ions, modified nucleotides, or sequence-specific nucleases.     

Understanding how the V(D)J recombinase catalyzes transesterification: distinctions between DNA cleavage and transposition

The Rag1 and Rag2 proteins initiate V(D)J recombination by introducing site-specific DNA double-strand breaks. Cleavage occurs by nicking one DNA strand, followed by a one-step transesterification reaction that forms a DNA hairpin structure. A similar reaction allows Rag transposition, in which the 3′-OH groups produced by Rag cleavage are joined to target DNA. The Rag1 active site DDE triad clearly plays a catalytic role in both cleavage and transposition, but no other residues in Rag1 responsible for transesterification have been identified. Furthermore, although Rag2 is essential for both cleavage and transposition, the nature of its involvement is unknown. Here, we identify basic amino acids in the catalytic core of Rag1 specifically important for transesterification. We also show that some Rag1 mutants with severe defects in hairpin formation nonetheless catalyze substantial levels of transposition. Lastly, we show that a catalytically defective Rag2 mutant is impaired in target capture and displays a novel form of coding flank sensitivity. These findings provide the first identification of components of Rag1 that are specifically required for transesterification and suggest an unexpected role for Rag2 in DNA cleavage and transposition.     

Ribozyme speed limits

The speed at which RNA molecules decompose is a critical determinant of many biological processes, including those directly involved in the storage and expression of genetic information. One mechanism for RNA cleavage involves internal phosphoester transfer, wherein the 2'-oxygen atom carries out an SN2-like nucleophilic attack on the adjacent phosphorus center (transesterification). In this article, we discuss fundamental principles of RNA transesterification and define a conceptual framework that can be used to assess the catalytic power of enzymes that cleave RNA. We deduce that certain ribozymes and deoxyribozymes, like their protein enzyme counterparts, can bring about enormous rate enhancements.     

Energetics of RNA cleavage: implications for the mechanism of action of ribozymes.

A new class of ribozymes produce 2',3'-cyclic phosphate upon self-catalyzed cleavage of RNA molecules, similar to those observed during enzymatic (RNase-catalyzed) as well as non-enzymatic hydrolyses of RNAs. This product suggests that the reaction intermediate/transition state is a pentacoordinated oxyphosphorane. In order to elucidate the energetics of these RNA cleaving reactions, the reaction coordinate has been simulated and a pentacoordinated intermediate has been characterized via ab initio molecular orbital calculations utilizing the dianionic hydrolysis-intermediate of methyl ethylene phosphate as a model compound. The calculated reaction coordinate indicates that the transition state for the P-O(2') bond cleavage is lower in energy than that for the P-O(5') bond cleavage under uncatalyzed conditions. Thus, the dianionic pentacoordinated phosphorus intermediate tends to revert back to the starting RNA by cleaving the P-O(2') bond rather than productively cleaving the P-O(5') bond. In order for ribozymes to effectively cleave RNA molecules, it is therefore mandatory to stabilize the leaving 5'-oxygen, e.g. by means of a divalent magnesium ion.     

Knockdown of dystrophin Dp71 impairs PC12 cells cycle: localization in the spindle and cytokinesis structures implies a role for Dp71 in cell division

The function of dystrophin Dp71 in neuronal cells remains to be established. Previously, we revealed the involvement of this protein in both nerve growth factor (NGF)-induced neuronal differentiation and cell adhesion by isolation and characterization of PC12 neuronal cells with depleted levels of Dp71. In this work, a novel phenotype of Dp71-knockdown cells was characterized, which is their delayed growth rate. Cell cycle analyses revealed an altered behavior of Dp71-depleted cells, which consists of a delay in G0/G1 transition and an increase in apoptosis during nocodazole-induced mitotic arrest. Dp71 associates with lamin B1 and β-dystroglycan, proteins involved in aspects of the cell division cycle; therefore, we compared the distribution of Dp71 with that of lamin B1 and β-dystroglycan in PC12 cells at mitosis and cytokinesis by means of immunofluorescence and confocal microscopy analysis. All of these three proteins exhibited a similar immunostaining pattern, localized at mitotic spindle, cleavage furrow, and midbody. It is noteworthy that a drastic decreased staining in mitotic spindle, cleavage furrow, and midbody was observed for both lamin B1 and β-dystroglycan in Dp71-depleted cells. Furthermore, we demonstrated the interaction of Dp71 with lamin B1 in PC12 cells by immunoprecipitation and pull-down assays, and importantly, we revealed that knockdown of Dp71 expression caused a marked reduction in lamin B1 levels and altered localization of the nuclear envelope protein emerin. Our data indicate that Dp71 is a component of the mitotic spindle and cytokinesis multi-protein apparatuses that might modulate the cell division cycle by affecting lamin B1 and β-dystroglycan levels.     

Increased Ribozyme Activity in Crowded Solutions

Noncoding RNAs must function in the crowded environment of the cell. Previous small-angle x-ray scattering experiments showed that molecular crowders stabilize the structure of the Azoarcus group I ribozyme, allowing the ribozyme to fold at low physiological Mg²⁺ concentrations. Here, we used an RNA cleavage assay to show that the PEG and Ficoll crowder molecules increased the biochemical activity of the ribozyme, whereas sucrose did not. Crowding lowered the Mg²⁺ threshold at which activity was detected and increased total RNA cleavage at high Mg²⁺ concentrations sufficient to fold the RNA in crowded or dilute solution. After correcting for solution viscosity, the observed reaction rate was proportional to the fraction of active ribozyme. We conclude that molecular crowders stabilize the native ribozyme and favor the active structure relative to compact inactive folding intermediates.     

Structural features of target RNA molecules greatly modulate the cleavage efficiency of trans-acting delta ribozymes

The aim of this work was to shed some more light on factors influencing the effectiveness of delta ribozyme cleavage of structured RNA molecules. An oligoribonucleotide that corresponds to the 3'-terminal region X of HCV RNA and yeast tRNAPhe were used as representative RNA targets. Only a few sites susceptible to ribozyme cleavage were identified in these targets using a combinatorial library of ribozyme variants, in which the region responsible for ribozyme-target interaction was randomized. On the other hand, the targets were fairly accessible for binding of complementary oligonucleotides, as was shown by 6-mer DNA libraries and RNase H approach. Moreover, the specifically acting ribozymes cleaved the targets precisely but with unexpectedly modest efficacy. To explain these observations, six model RNA molecules were designed, in which the same seven nucleotide long sequence recognized by the delta ribozyme was always single stranded but was embedded into different RNA structural context. These molecules were cleaved with differentiated rates, and the corresponding k2 values were in the range of 0.91-0.021 min-1; thus they differed almost 50-fold. This clearly shows that cleavage of structured RNAs might be much slower than cleavage of a short unstructured oligoribonucleotide, despite full accessibility of the targeted regions for hybridization. Restricted possibilities of conformational transitions, which are necessary to occur on the cleavage reaction trajectory, seem to be responsible for these differences. Their magnitude, which was evaluated in this work, should be taken into account while considering the use of delta ribozymes for practical applications.     

Transesterification of Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt in methanol. Confirmation of Ca2+ mediated catalysis

During the recrystallization of the crude protected tripeptide ester Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt (obtained by an enzymatic coupling reaction) in methanol/water, the transesterification of this compound to methyl ester was observed. The involvement of Ca2+ in this process was indicated by the results obtained in the following experiments: 1) incubation of crude Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt in methanol solutions of o-phenanthroline and EDTA; 2) recrystallization of the crude Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt in ethanol/water followed by incubation in methanol; 3) determination of the Ca2+ content of the crude Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt. After recrystallization Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt lost the ability to be transesterified in methanol. However, in the presence of crude Moz-Asn-Leu-Gly-OEt, or calcium acetate, or a mixture of calcium chloride/sodium acetate, the compound was transesterified, suggesting that the transesterification of crude and recrystallized compounds occurs through different mechanisms. On the basis of these results, and of the conformational data obtained for these peptides by 1H-NMR, we suggest models for the transesterification reactions.     

Thermal degradation processes of end-capped poly(L-lactide)s in the presence and absence of residual zinc catalyst

Thermal degradation processes of end-capped poly(L-lactide)s (PLLAs) were investigated by means of several thermoanalytical techniques under both isothermal and nonisothermal conditions. Based on the thermogravimetric analysis, it was found that two distinct processes at temperatures below and above 330 degrees C were existed in the nonisothermal degradation for PLLA samples depending on the amounts of residual zinc compounds from synthesis process. Isothermal degradation experiments at different temperature regions showed that the sample weight of PLLA decreased linearly with time in both cases, whereas the changes in molecular weight revealed different tendency for the temperature. On the basis of characterization of the residual PLLA molecules after isothermal degradation at 330 degrees C, it was confirmed that the omega chain end of the residual molecules was an acrylic ester unit. Majority of volatile products during thermal degradation of PLLA was the lactide regardless of the degradation temperature. From these results, it is concluded that, during the thermal degradation of PLLA samples in the presence of large amounts of residual zinc compounds, the zinc compounds catalyze both the intermolecular transesterification generating PLLA with low molecular weights and the selective unzipping depolymerization of PLLA with low molecular weights at temperatures below 330 degrees C. In contrast, the primary reaction of thermal degradation for PLLA in the absence of residual zinc compounds above 330 degrees C is a competition between the random chain scission via a cis-elimination reaction and the cyclic rupture via intramolecular transesterification of PLLA molecules. In addition, it was evidenced that the racemization of lactic acid units in the main chain of PLLA molecules occurred at temperatures above 330 degrees C.     

Relationship between internucleotide linkage geometry and the stability of RNA

The inherent chemical instability of RNA under physiological conditions is primarily due to the spontaneous cleavage of phosphodiester linkages via intramolecular transesterification reactions. Although the protonation state of the nucleophilic 2'-hydroxyl group is a critical determinant of the rate of RNA cleavage, the precise geometry of the chemical groups that comprise each internucleotide linkage also has a significant impact on cleavage activity. Specifically, transesterification is expected to be proportional to the relative in-line character of the linkage. We have examined the rates of spontaneous cleavage of various RNAs for which the secondary and tertiary structures have previously been modeled using either NMR or X-ray crystallographic data. Rate constants determined for the spontaneous cleavage of different RNA linkages vary by almost 10,000-fold, most likely reflecting the contribution that secondary and tertiary structures make towards the overall chemical stability of RNA. Moreover, a correlation is observed between RNA cleavage rate and the relative in-line fitness of each internucleotide linkage. One linkage located within an ATP-binding RNA aptamer is predicted to adopt most closely the ideal conformation for in-line attack. This linkage has a rate constant for transesterification that is approximately 12-fold greater than is observed for an unconstrained linkage and was found to be the most labile among a total of 136 different sites examined. The implications of this relationship for the chemical stability of RNA and for the mechanisms of nucleases and ribozymes are discussed.     

Trypanosoma brucei mitochondrial guide RNA-mRNA chimera-forming activity cofractionates with an editing-domain-specific endonuclease and RNA ligase and is mimicked by heterologous nuclease and RNA ligase.

RNA editing in trypanosomes has been proposed to occur through transesterification or endonuclease cleavage and RNA ligation reactions. Both models involve a chimeric intermediate in which a guide RNA (gRNA) is joined through its 3' oligo(U) tail to an editing site of the corresponding mRNA. Velocity centrifugation of Trypanosoma brucei mitochondrial extracts had been reported to completely separate the gRNA-mRNA chimera-forming activity from endonuclease activity (V. W. Pollard, M. E. Harris, and S. L. Hajduk, EMBO J. 11:4429-4438, 1992), appearing to rule out the endonuclease-RNA ligase mechanism. However, we show that an editing-domain-specific endonuclease activity does cosediment with the chimera-forming activity, as does the RNA ligase activity, but detection of the specific endonuclease requires reducing assay conditions. This report further demonstrates that the T. brucei chimera-forming activity is mimicked by mung bean nuclease and T4 RNA ligase. Using cytochrome b (CYb) preedited mRNA and a model CYb gRNA, we found that these heterologous enzymes specifically generate CYb gRNA-mRNA chimeras analogous to those formed in the mitochondrial extract. These combined results provide support for the endonuclease-RNA ligase mechanism of chimera formation.     

Photo-induced oxidative cross-linking as a method to evaluate the specificity of protein-ligand interactions.

The isolation of protein-binding synthetic molecules from combinatorial libraries or compound collections is now a common practice in chemical biology. An important, but underdeveloped, aspect of characterizing the binding properties of such molecules is their level of binding specificity. This is often evaluated by simply measuring the equilibrium binding affinity of the compound of interest with its target protein and comparing this value with its affinity to one or a few other purified proteins selected at random. These measurements may not reflect accurately the ability of the compound to seek out its target in a complex mixture of proteins such as a cell extract or serum. A more desirable alternative would be to develop solution assays that measure directly the binding of the molecule of interest to both target and competitor proteins in complex solutions. In this report, we evaluate a rapid and efficient photo-triggered cross-linking reaction for assessing binding specificity of synthetic molecules in protein mixtures. Using peptide-protein complexes, we demonstrate that this reaction provides an unbiased view of the peptide-protein contacts present in solution under a given set of conditions and thus is useful for assessing binding specificity. We also discuss the potential application of this chemistry to the related, but more difficult, problem of the identification of protein targets of bioactive molecules.     

Functional Analysis of Coordinated Cleavage in V(D)J Recombination

V(D)J recombination in vivo requires a pair of signals with distinct spacer elements of 12 and 23 bp that separate conserved heptamer and nonamer motifs. Cleavage in vitro by the RAG1 and RAG2 proteins can occur at individual signals when the reaction buffer contains Mn²⁺, but cleavage is restricted to substrates containing two signals when Mg²⁺ is the divalent cation. By using a novel V(D)J cleavage substrate, we show that while the RAG proteins alone establish a moderate preference for a 12/23 pair versus a 12/12 pair, a much stricter dependence of cleavage on the 12/23 signal pair is produced by the inclusion of HMG1 and competitor double-stranded DNA. The competitor DNA serves to inhibit the cleavage of substrates carrying a 12/12 or 23/23 pair, as well as the cutting at individual signals in 12/23 substrates. We show that a 23/33 pair is more efficiently recombined than a 12/33 pair, suggesting that the 12/23 rule can be generalized to a requirement for spacers that differ from each other by a single helical turn. Furthermore, we suggest that a fixed spatial orientation of signals is required for cleavage. In general, the same signal variants that can be cleaved singly can function under conditions in which a signal pair is required. However, a chemically modified substrate with one noncleavable signal enables us to show that formation of a functional cleavage complex is mechanistically separable from the cleavage reaction itself and that although cleavage requires a pair of signals, cutting does not have to occur simultaneously at both. The implications of these results are discussed with respect to the mechanism of V(D)J recombination and the generation of chromosomal translocations.