Efficient RNA 5'-adenylation by T4 DNA ligase to facilitate practical applications

We describe a simple procedure for RNA 5'-adenylation using T4 DNA ligase. The 5'-monophosphorylated terminus of an RNA substrate is annealed to a complementary DNA strand that has a 3'-overhang of 10 nucleotides. Then, T4 DNA ligase and ATP are used to synthesize 5'-adenylated RNA (5'-AppRNA), which should find use in a variety of practical applications. In the absence of an acceptor nucleic acid strand, the two-step T4 DNA ligase mechanism is successfully interrupted after the adenylation step, providing 40%-80% yield of 5'-AppRNA after PAGE purification with few side products (the yield varies with RNA sequence). Optimized reaction conditions are described for 5'-adenylating RNA substrates of essentially any length including long and structured RNAs, without need for sequestration of the RNA 3'-terminus to avoid circularization. The new procedure is applicable on the preparative nanomole scale. This 5'-adenylation strategy using T4 DNA ligase is a substantial improvement over our recently reported adenylation method that uses T4 RNA ligase, which often leads to substantial amounts of side products and requires careful optimization for each RNA substrate. Efficient synthetic access to 5'-adenylated RNA will facilitate a range of applications by providing substrates for in vitro selection; by establishing a new protocol for RNA 5'-capping; and by providing an alternative approach for labeling RNA with (32)P or biophysical probes at the 5'-terminus.     

Specificity and fidelity of strand joining by Chlorella virus DNA ligase.

Chlorella virus PBCV-1 DNA ligase seals nicked duplex DNA substrates consisting of a 5'-phosphate-terminated strand and a 3'-hydroxyl-terminated strand annealed to a bridging template strand, but cannot ligate a nicked duplex composed of two DNAs annealed on an RNA template. Whereas PBCV-1 ligase efficiently joins a 3'-OH RNA to a 5'-phosphate DNA, it is unable to join a 3'-OH DNA to a 5'-phosphate RNA. The ligase discriminates at the substrate binding step between nicked duplexes containing 5'-phosphate DNA versus 5'-phosphate RNA strands. PBCV-1 ligase readily seals a nicked duplex DNA containing a single ribonucleotide substitution at the reactive 5'-phosphate end. These results suggest a requirement for a B-form helical conformation of the polynucleotide on the 5'-phosphate side of the nick. Single base mismatches at the nick exert disparate effects on DNA ligation efficiency. PBCV-1 ligase tolerates mismatches involving the 5'-phosphate nucleotide, with the exception of 5'-A:G and 5'-G:A mispairs, which reduce ligase activity by two orders of magnitude. Inhibitory configurations at the 3'-OH nucleotide include 3'-G:A, 3'-G:T, 3'-T:T, 3'-A:G, 3'-G:G, 3'-A:C and 3'-C:C. Our findings indicate that Chlorella virus DNA ligase has the potential to affect genome integrity by embedding ribonucleotides in viral DNA and by sealing nicked molecules with mispaired ends, thereby generating missense mutations.     

Identification of essential residues in Thermus thermophilus DNA ligase.

DNA ligases play a pivotal role in DNA replication, repair and recombination. Reactions catalyzed by DNA ligases consist of three steps: adenylation of the ligase in the presence of ATP or NAD+, transferring the adenylate moiety to the 5'-phosphate of the nicked DNA substrate (deadenylation) and sealing the nick through the formation of a phosphodiester bond. Thermus thermophilus HB8 DNA ligase (Tth DNA ligase) differs from mesophilic ATP-dependent DNA ligases in three ways: (i) it is NAD+ dependent; (ii) its optimal temperature is 65 instead of 37 degrees C; (iii) it has higher fidelity than T4 DNA ligase. In order to understand the structural basis underlying the reaction mechanism of Tth DNA ligase, we performed site-directed mutagenesis studies on nine selected amino acid residues that are highly conserved in bacterial DNA ligases. Examination of these site-specific mutants revealed that: residue K118 plays an essential role in the adenylation step; residue D120 may facilitate the deadenylation step; residues G339 and C433 may be involved in formation of the phosphodiester bond. This evidence indicates that a previously identified KXDG motif for adenylation of eukaryotic DNA ligases [Tomkinson, A.E., Totty, N.F., Ginsburg, M. and Lindahl, T. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 88, 400-404] is also the adenylation site for NAD+-dependent bacterial DNA ligases. In a companion paper, we demonstrate that mutations at a different Lys residue, K294, may modulate the fidelity of Tth DNA ligase.     

NAD+ is not utilized as a co-factor for DNA ligation by human DNA ligase IV

As nucleotidyl transferases, formation of a covalent enzyme-adenylate intermediate is a common first step of all DNA ligases. While it has been shown that eukaryotic DNA ligases utilize ATP as the adenylation donor, it was recently reported that human DNA ligase IV can also utilize NAD⁺ and, to a lesser extent ADP-ribose, as the source of the adenylate group and that NAD⁺, unlike ATP, enhances ligation by supporting multiple catalytic cycles. Since this unexpected finding has significant implications for our understanding of the mechanisms and regulation of DNA double strand break repair, we attempted to confirm that NAD⁺ and ADP-ribose can be used as co-factors by human DNA ligase IV. Here, we provide evidence that NAD⁺ does not enhance ligation by pre-adenylated DNA ligase IV, indicating that this co-factor is not utilized for re-adenylation and subsequent cycles of ligation. Moreover, we find that ligation by de-adenylated DNA ligase IV is dependent upon ATP not NAD⁺ or ADP-ribose. Thus, we conclude that human DNA ligase IV cannot use either NAD⁺ or ADP-ribose as adenylation donor for ligation.     

DNA strand displacement, strand annealing and strand swapping by the Drosophila Bloom's syndrome helicase

Genetic analysis of the Drosophila Bloom's syndrome helicase homolog (mus309/DmBLM) indicates that DmBLM is required for the synthesis-dependent strand annealing (SDSA) pathway of homologous recombination. Here we report the first biochemical study of DmBLM. Recombinant, epitope-tagged DmBLM was expressed in Drosophila cell culture and highly purified protein was prepared from nuclear extracts. Purified DmBLM exists exclusively as a high molecular weight (~1.17 MDa) species, is a DNA-dependent ATPase, has 3′→5′ DNA helicase activity, prefers forked substrate DNAs and anneals complementary DNAs. High-affinity DNA binding is ATP-dependent and low-affinity ATP-independent interactions contribute to forked substrate DNA binding and drive strand annealing. DmBLM combines DNA strand displacement with DNA strand annealing to catalyze the displacement of one DNA strand while annealing a second complementary DNA strand.     

A strand exchange FRET assay for DNA

A new displacement hybridisation method is reported using a single strand DNA probe, labelled with an acceptor fluorophore (oregon green 488). Detection of double stranded sample target is shown, with discrimination between the probe, duplexed during the assay, and free single stranded probe DNA achieved through the FRET from a donor grove fluorophore (Hoechst 33258). A model for the kinetics of the displacement assay is presented and the course of the assay predicted according to probe/target ratios and sequence. The modelled predictions are consistent with the experimental data showing single base pair mismatch discrimination. The pattern of response according to the mismatch/perfect complement ratio in a mixed sample is also considered with an allele-discrimination ratio lying between the homozygous gene and total mismatch case, according to ratio. The assay is shown to be tolerant of different probe concentrations and ratios and through the dual wavelength recorded signals from donor and FRET acceptor, internal baseline correction is achieved with excellent noise reduction through ratiometric measurement.     

Mutational analyses of Aquifex pyrophilus DNA ligase define essential domains for self-adenylation and DNA binding activity

We constructed nine deletion mutants of NAD+-dependent DNA ligase from Aquifex pyrophilus to characterize the functional domains. All of DNA ligase deletion mutants were analyzed in biochemical assays for NAD+-dependent self-adenylation, DNA binding, and nick-closing activity. Although the mutant lsub1 (91-362) included the active site lysine (KxDG), self-adenylation was not shown. However, the mutants lsub6 (1-362), lsub7 (1-516), and lsub9 (1-635) showed the same adenylation activity as that of wild type. The lsub5 (91-719), which has the C-terminal domain (487-719) as to lsub4 (91-486), showed minimal adenylation activity. These results suggest that the presence of N-terminal 90 residues is essential for the formation of an enzyme-AMP complex, while C-terminal domain (487-719) appears to play a minimal role in adenylation. It was found that the presence of C-terminal domain (487-719) is indispensable for DNA binding activity of lsub5 (91-719). The mutant lsub9 (1-635) showed reduced DNA binding activity compared to that of wild type, suggesting the contribution of the domain (636-719) for the DNA binding activity. Thus, we concluded that the N-terminal 90 residues and C-terminal domain (487-719) of NAD+-dependent DNA ligase from A. pyrophilus are mutually indispensable for binding of DNA substrate.     

Effects of deletion and site-directed mutations on ligation steps of NAD+-dependent DNA ligase: a biochemical analysis of BRCA1 C-terminal domain

DNA strand joining entails three consecutive steps: enzyme adenylation to form AMP-ligase, substrate adenylation to form AMP-DNA, and nick closure. In this study, we investigate the effects on ligation steps by deletion and site-directed mutagenesis of the BRCA1 C-terminal (BRCT) domain using NAD(+)-dependent DNA ligase from Thermus species AK16D. Deletion of the BRCT domain resulted in substantial loss of ligation activity, but the mutant was still able to form an AMP-ligase intermediate, suggesting that the defects caused by deletion of the entire BRCT domain occur primarily at steps after enzyme adenylation. The lack of AMP-DNA accumulation by the domain deletion mutant as compared to the wild-type ligase indicates that the BRCT domain plays a role in the substrate adenylation step. Gel mobility shift analysis suggests that the BRCT domain and helix-hairpin-helix subdomain play a role in DNA binding. Similar to the BRCT domain deletion mutant, the G617I mutant showed a low ligation activity and lack of accumulation of AMP-DNA intermediate. However, the G617I mutant was only weakly adenylated, suggesting that a point mutation in the BRCT domain could also affect the enzyme adenylation step. The significant reduction of ligation activity by G634I appears to be attributable to a defect at the substrate adenylation step. The greater ligation of mismatched substrates by G638I is accountable by accelerated conversion of the AMP-DNA intermediate to a ligation product at the final nick closure step. The mutational effects of the BRCT domain on ligation steps in relation to protein-DNA and potential protein-protein interactions are discussed.     

Enzyme action at 3' termini of ionizing radiation-induced DNA strand breaks

gamma-Irradiation of DNA in vitro produces two types of single strand breaks. Both types of strand breaks contain 5'-phosphate DNA termini. Some strand breaks contain 3'-phosphate termini, some contain 3'-phosphoglycolate termini (Henner, W.D., Rodriguez, L.O., Hecht, S. M., and Haseltine, W. A. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 711-713). We have studied the ability of prokaryotic enzymes of DNA metabolism to act at each of these types of gamma-ray-induced 3' termini in DNA. Neither strand breaks that terminate with 3'-phosphate nor 3'-phosphoglycolate are substrates for direct ligation by T4 DNA ligase. Neither type of gamma-ray-induced 3' terminus can be used as a primer for DNA synthesis by either Escherichia coli DNA polymerase or T4 DNA polymerase. The 3'-phosphatase activity of T4 polynucleotide kinase can convert gamma-ray-induced 3'-phosphate but not 3'-phosphoglycolate termini to 3'-hydroxyl termini that can then serve as primers for DNA polymerase. E. coli alkaline phosphatase is also unable to hydrolyze 3'-phosphoglycolate groups. The 3'-5' exonuclease actions of E. coli DNA polymerase I and T4 DNA polymerase do not degrade DNA strands that have either type of gamma-ray-induced 3' terminus. E. coli exonuclease III can hydrolyze DNA with gamma-ray-induced 3'-phosphate or 3'-phosphoglycolate termini or with DNase I-induced 3'-hydroxyl termini. The initial action of exonuclease III at 3' termini of ionizing radiation-induced DNA fragments is to remove the 3' terminal phosphate or phosphoglycolate to yield a fragment of the same nucleotide length that has a 3'-hydroxyl terminus. These results suggest that repair of ionizing radiation-induced strand breaks may proceed via the sequential action of exonuclease, DNA polymerase, and DNA ligase. The possible role of exonuclease III in repair of gamma-radiation-induced strand breaks is discussed.     

Donor activation in the T4 RNA ligase reaction

T4 RNA ligase catalyzes the adenylation of donor oligonucleotide substrates. These activated intermediates react with an acceptor oligonucleotide which results in phosphodiester bond formation and the concomitant release of AMP. Adenylation of the four common nucleoside 3',5'-bisphosphates as catalyzed by T4 RNA ligase in the absence of an acceptor oligonucleotide has been examined. The extents of product formation indicate that pCp is the best substrate in the reaction and pGp is the poorest. Kinetic parameters for the joining reaction between the preadenylated nucleoside 3',5'-bisphosphates, A(5')pp(5')Cp or A(5')pp(5')Gp, and a good acceptor substrate (ApApA) or a poor acceptor substrate (UpUpU) have been determined. The apparent Km values for both preadenylated donors in the joining reaction are similar, and the reaction velocity is much faster than observed in the overall joining reaction. The nonnucleotide adenylated substrate P1-(5'-adenosyl) P2-(o-nitrobenzyl) diphosphate also exhibits a similar apparent Km but reacts with a velocity 80-fold slower than the adenylated nucleoside 3',5'-bisphosphates. By use of preadenylated donors, oligonucleotide substrates can be elongated more efficiently than occurs with the nucleoside 3',5'-bisphosphates.     

DNA strand transfer reactions catalyzed by vaccinia topoisomerase I.

Vaccinia virus DNA topoisomerase I forms a 3'-phosphoryl intermediate with duplex DNAs containing the conserved binding/cleavage motif 5'CCCTT decreases. Covalently bound enzyme is capable of transferring the incised DNA strand to a heterologous DNA acceptor containing a 5'OH terminus. Both intramolecular and intermolecular religation reactions are catalyzed. Intramolecular strand transfer occurs to the noncleaved strand of the DNA duplex and results in formation of a hairpin loop. Intermolecular religation to an exogenous DNA strand is favored over hairpin formation and requires the potential for base pairing between the acceptor and the noncleaved strand of the donor complex. As few as 4 potential base pairs are sufficient to support intermolecular transfer. These results in vitro are consistent with the proposal that vaccinia topoisomerase can catalyze sequence-specific strand transfer during genetic recombination in vivo (Shuman, S. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 88, 10104-10108.).     

Characterization of an ATP-dependent type I DNA ligase from Arabidopsis thaliana

Here we report the purification and biochemical characterization of recombinant Arabidopsis thaliana DNA ligase I. We show that this ligase requires ATP as a source for adenylation. The calculated K _m [ATP] for ligation is 3 M. This enzyme is able to ligate nicks in oligo(dT)/poly(dA) and oligo(rA)/poly(dT) substrates, but not in oligo(dT)/poly(rA) substrates. Double-stranded DNAs with cohesive or blunt ends are also good substrates for the ligase. These biochemical features of the purified enzyme show the characteristics typical of a type I DNA ligase. Furthermore, this DNA ligase is able to perform the reverse reaction (relaxation of supercoiled DNA) in an AMP-dependent and PPi-stimulated manner.     

Simple and efficient synthesis of 5' pre-adenylated DNA using thermostable RNA ligase

We report a simple method of enzymatic synthesis of pre-adenylated DNA linkers/adapters for next-generation sequencing using thermostable RNA ligase from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum (MthRnl). Using RNA ligase for the reaction instead of the existing chemical or T4 DNA ligase-based methods allows quantitative conversion of 5'-phosphorylated single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) to the adenylated form. The MthRnl adenylation reaction is specific for ATP and either ssDNA or RNA. In the presence of Mg(+2), the reaction has a pH optimum of 6.0-6.5. Unlike reactions that use T4 DNA ligase, this protocol does not require synthesis of a template strand for adenylation. The high yield of the reaction simplifies isolation and purification of the adenylated product. Conducting the adenylation reaction at the elevated temperature (65°C) reduces structural constraints, while increased ATP concentrations allow quantitative adenylation of DNA with a 3'-unprotected end.     

Profiling the selectivity of DNA ligases in an array format with mass spectrometry

This article describes a method for the global profiling of the substrate specificities of DNA ligases and illustrates examples using the Taq and T4 DNA ligases. The method combines oligonucleotide arrays, which offer the benefits of high throughput and multiplexed assays, with mass spectrometry to permit label-free assays of ligase activity. Arrays were prepared by immobilizing ternary biotin-tagged DNA substrates to a self-assembled monolayer presenting a layer of streptavidin protein. The array represented complexes having all possible matched and mismatched base pairs at the 3′ side of the nick site and also included a number of deletions and insertions at this site. The arrays were treated with ligases and adenosine triphosphate or analogs of the nucleotide triphosphate and then analyzed by matrix-assisted laser desorption-ionization mass spectrometry to determine the yields for both adenylation of the 5′-probe strand and joining of the two probe strands. The resulting activity profiles reveal the basis for specificity of the ligases and also point to strategies that use ATP analogs to improve specificity. This work introduces a method that can be applied to profile a broad range of enzymes that operate on nucleic acid substrates.     

MutS inhibits RecA-mediated strand transfer with methylated DNA substrates

DNA mismatch repair (MMR) sensitizes human and Escherichia coli dam cells to the cytotoxic action of N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) while abrogation of such repair results in drug resistance. In DNA methylated by MNNG, MMR action is the result of MutS recognition of O⁶-methylguanine base pairs. MutS and Ada methyltransferase compete for the MNNG-induced O⁶-methylguanine residues, and MMR-induced cytotoxicity is abrogated when Ada is present at higher concentrations than normal. To test the hypothesis that MMR sensitization is due to decreased recombinational repair, we used a RecA-mediated strand exchange assay between homologous phiX174 substrate molecules, one of which was methylated with MNNG. MutS inhibited strand transfer on such substrates in a concentration-dependent manner and its inhibitory effect was enhanced by MutL. There was no effect of these proteins on RecA activity with unmethylated substrates. We quantified the number of O⁶-methylguanine residues in methylated DNA by HPLC-MS/MS and 5–10 of these residues in phiX174 DNA (5386 bp) were sufficient to block the RecA reaction in the presence of MutS and MutL. These results are consistent with a model in which methylated DNA is perceived by the cell as homeologous and prevented from recombining with homologous DNA by the MMR system.     

Polynucleotide 3′-terminal Phosphate Modifications by RNA and DNA Ligases

RNA and DNA ligases catalyze the formation of a phosphodiester bond between the 5′-phosphate and 3′-hydroxyl ends of nucleic acids. In this work, we describe the ability of the thermophilic RNA ligase MthRnl from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum to recognize and modify the 3′-terminal phosphate of RNA and single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). This ligase can use an RNA 3′p substrate to generate an RNA 2′,3′-cyclic phosphate or convert DNA3′p to ssDNA^3′pp^5′A. An RNA ligase from the Thermus scotoductus bacteriophage TS2126 and a predicted T4 Rnl1-like protein from Thermovibrio ammonificans, TVa, were also able to adenylate ssDNA 3′p. These modifications of RNA and DNA 3′-phosphates are similar to the activities of RtcA, an RNA 3′-phosphate cyclase. The initial step involves adenylation of the enzyme by ATP, which is then transferred to either RNA 3′p or DNA 3′p to generate the adenylated intermediate. For RNA ^3′pp^5′A, the third step involves attack of the adjacent 2′ hydroxyl to generate the RNA 2′,3′-cyclic phosphate. These steps are analogous to those in classical 5′ phosphate ligation. MthRnl and TS2126 RNA ligases were not able to modify a 3′p in nicked double-stranded DNA. However, T4 DNA ligase and RtcA can use 3′-phosphorylated nicks in double-stranded DNA to produce a 3′-adenylated product. These 3′-terminal phosphate-adenylated intermediates are substrates for deadenylation by yeast 5′Deadenylase. Our findings that classic ligases can duplicate the adenylation and phosphate cyclization activity of RtcA suggests that they have an essential role in metabolism of nucleic acids with 3′-terminal phosphates.     

Repair of DNA strand gaps and nicks containing 3'-phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini by purified mammalian enzymes.

A putative role for mammalian polynucleotide kinases that possess both 5'-phosphotransferase and 3'-phosphatase activity is the restoration of DNA strand breaks with 5'-hydroxyl termini or 3'-phosphate termini, or both, to a form that supports the subsequent action of DNA repair polymerases and DNA ligases, i.e. 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl termini. To further assess this possibility, we compared the activity of the 3'-phosphatase of purified calf thymus polynucleotide kinase towards a variety of substrates. The rate of removal of 3'-phosphate groups from nicked or short (1 nt) gapped sites in double-stranded DNA was observed to be similar to that of 3'-phosphate groups from single-stranded substrates. Thus this activity of polynucleotide kinase does not appear to be influenced by steric accessibility of the phosphate group. We subsequently demonstrated that the concerted reactions of polynucleotide kinase and purified human DNA ligase I could efficiently repair DNA nicks possessing 3'-phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini, and similarly the combination of these two enzymes together with purified rat DNA polymerase beta could seal a strand break with a 1 nt gap. With a substrate containing a nick bounded by 3'- and 5'-OH termini, the rate of gap filling by polymerase beta was significantly enhanced in the presence of polynucleotide kinase and ATP, indicating the positive influence of 5'-phosphorylation. The reaction was further enhanced by addition of DNA ligase I to the reaction mixture. This is due, at least in part, to an enhancement by DNA ligase I of the rate of 5'-phosphorylation catalyzed by polynucleotide kinase.     

DNA repair patch-mediated double strand DNA break formation in human cells

To investigate the mechanism of double strand DNA break formation in mammalian cells, an in vitro assay was established using closed circular DNA containing two uracils on opposite DNA strands (18 and 30 base pairs apart) and extracts prepared from human cells. In this assay, formation of double strand breaks was detected by the conversion of circular DNA to linear DNA. Approximately 4-fold more double strand DNA breaks were produced by extracts from cells deficient in DNA ligase I (46BR) relative to those produced by extracts from control cells (MRC5, derived from a clinically normal individual). In parallel with the amount of double strand DNA breaks, extracts from 46BR cells produced longer repair patches (up to 24 bases in length) than those from MRC5 cells (typically <5 bases long). When purified DNA ligase I was added to 46BR extracts to complement the DNA ligase deficiency, only a negligible difference was found between the amount of doublestrand DNA breaks or the repair patch size generated in the assay relative to MRC5 extracts. Together, our data demonstrate that double strand DNA breaks are produced through formation of DNA repair patches. We refer to this process of double strand break formation as the "DNA repair patch-mediated pathway."     

Elucidating a key intermediate in homologous DNA strand exchange: structural characterization of the RecA-triple-stranded DNA complex using fluorescence resonance energy transfer

The RecA protein of Escherichia coli plays essential roles in homologous recombination and restarting stalled DNA replication forks. In vitro, the protein mediates DNA strand exchange between single-stranded (ssDNA) and homologous double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) molecules that serves as a model system for the in vivo processes. To date, no high-resolution structure of the key intermediate, comprised of three DNA strands simultaneously bound to a RecA filament (RecA-tsDNA complex), has been reported. We present a systematic characterization of the helical geometries of the three DNA strands of the RecA-tsDNA complex using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) under physiologically relevant solution conditions. FRET donor and acceptor dyes were used to label different DNA strands, and the interfluorophore distances were inferred from energy transfer efficiencies measured as a function of the base-pair separation between the two dyes. The energy transfer efficiencies were first measured on a control RecA-dsDNA complex, and the calculated helical parameters (h approximately 5 A, Omega(h) approximately 20 degrees ) were consistent with structural conclusions derived from electron microscopy (EM) and other classic biochemical methods. Measurements of the helical parameters for the RecA-tsDNA complex revealed that all three DNA strands adopt extended and unwound conformations similar to those of RecA-bound dsDNA. The structural data are consistent with the hypothesis that this complex is a late, post-strand-exchange intermediate with the outgoing strand shifted by about three base-pairs with respect to its registry with the incoming and complementary strands. Furthermore, the bases of the incoming and complementary strands are displaced away from the helix axis toward the minor groove of the heteroduplex, and the bases of the outgoing strand lie in the major groove of the heteroduplex. We present a model for the strand exchange intermediate in which homologous contacts preceding strand exchange arise in the minor groove of the substrate dsDNA.