Evolutionary migration of a post-translationally modified active-site residue in the proton-pumping heme-copper oxygen reductases

In the respiratory chains of aerobic organisms, oxygen reductase members of the heme-copper superfamily couple the reduction of O2 to proton pumping, generating an electrochemical gradient. There are three distinct families of heme-copper oxygen reductases: A, B, and C types. The A- and B-type oxygen reductases have an active-site tyrosine that forms a unique cross-linked histidine-tyrosine cofactor. In the C-type oxygen reductases (also called cbb3 oxidases), an analogous active-site tyrosine has recently been predicted by molecular modeling to be located within a different transmembrane helix in comparison to the A- and B-type oxygen reductases. In this work, Fourier-transform mass spectrometry is used to show that the predicted tyrosine forms a histidine-tyrosine cross-linked cofactor in the active site of the C-type oxygen reductases. This is the first known example of the evolutionary migration of a post-translationally modified active-site residue. It also verifies the presence of a unique cofactor in all three families of proton-pumping respiratory oxidases, demonstrating that these enzymes likely share a common reaction mechanism and that the histidine-tyrosine cofactor may be a required component for proton pumping.     

A novel scenario for the evolution of haem-copper oxygen reductases

The increasing sequence information on oxygen reductases of the haem-copper superfamily, together with the available three-dimensional structures, allows a clear identification of their common, functionally important features. Taking into consideration both the overall amino acid sequences of the core subunits and key residues involved in proton transfer, a novel hypothesis for the molecular evolution of these enzymes is proposed. Three main families of oxygen reductases are identified on the basis of common features of the core subunits, constituting three lines of evolution: (i) type A (mitochondrial-like oxidases), (ii) type B (ba3-like oxidases) and (iii) type C (cbb3-type oxidases). The first group can be further divided into two subfamilies, according to the helix VI residues at the hydrophobic end of one of the proton pathways (the so-called D-channel): (i) type A1, comprising the enzymes with a glutamate residue in the motif -XGHPEV-, and (ii) type A2, enzymes having instead a tyrosine and a serine in the alternative motif -YSHPXV-. This second subfamily of oxidases is shown to be ancestor to the one containing the glutamate residue, which in the Bacteria domain is only present in oxidases from Gram-positive or purple bacteria. It is further proposed that the Archaea domain acquired terminal oxidases by gene transfer from the Gram-positive bacteria, implying that these enzymes were not present in the last common ancestor before the divergence between Archaea and Bacteria. In fact, most oxidases from archaea have a higher amino acid sequence identity and similarity with those from bacteria, mainly from the Gram-positive group, than with oxidases from other archaea. Finally, a possible relation between the dihaemic subunit (FixP) of the cbb3 oxidases and subunit II of caa3 oxidases is discussed. As the families of haem-copper oxidases can also be identified by their subunit II, a parallel evolution of subunits I and II is suggested.     

Looking for the minimum common denominator in haem-copper oxygen reductases: towards a unified catalytic mechanism

Haem-copper oxygen reductases are transmembrane protein complexes that reduce dioxygen to water and pump protons across the mitochondrial or periplasmatic membrane, contributing to the transmembrane difference of electrochemical potential. Seven years ago we proposed a classification of these enzymes into three different families (A, B and C), based on the amino acid residues of their proton channels and amino acid sequence comparison, later supported by the so far identified characteristics of the catalytic centre of members from each family. The three families have in common the same general structural fold of the catalytic subunit, which contains the same or analogous prosthetic groups, and proton channels. These observations raise the hypothesis that the mechanisms for dioxygen reduction, proton pumping and the coupling of the two processes may be the same for all these enzymes. Under this hypothesis, they should be performed and controlled by the same or equivalent elements/events, and the identification of retained elements in all families will reveal their importance and may prompt the definition of the enzyme operating mode. Thus, we believe that the search for a minimum common denominator has a crucial importance, and in this article we highlight what is already established for the haem-copper oxygen reductases and emphasize the main questions still unanswered in a comprehensive basis.     

Similarity of cytochrome c oxidases in different organisms

Most of biological oxygen reduction is catalyzed by the heme‐copper oxygen reductases. These enzymes are redox‐driven proton pumps that take part in generating the proton gradient in both prokaryotes and mitochondria that drives synthesis of ATP. The enzymes have been divided into three evolutionarily‐related groups: the A‐, B‐, and C‐families. Recent comparative studies suggest that all oxygen reductases perform the same chemistry for oxygen reduction and comprise the same essential elements of the proton pumping mechanism, such as the proton loading and kinetic gating sites, which, however, appear to be different in different families. All species of the A‐family, however, demonstrate remarkable similarity of the central processing unit of the enzyme, as revealed by their recent crystal structures. Here we demonstrate that cytochrome c oxidases (CcO) of such diverse organisms as a mammal (bovine heart mitochondrial CcO), photosynthetic bacteria (Rhodobacter sphaeroides CcO), and soil bacteria (Paracoccus denitrificans CcO) are not only structurally similar, but almost identical in microscopic electrostatics and thermodynamics properties of their key amino‐acids. By using pK_a calculations of some of the key residues of the catalytic site, D‐ and K‐ proton input, and putative proton output channels of these three different enzymes, we demonstrate that the microscopic properties of key residues are almost identical, which strongly suggests the same mechanism in these species. The quantitative precision with which the microscopic physical properties of these enzymes have remained constant despite different evolutionary routes undertaken is striking. Proteins 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Looking for the minimum common denominator in haem–copper oxygen reductases: Towards a unified catalytic mechanism

Haem–copper oxygen reductases are transmembrane protein complexes that reduce dioxygen to water and pump protons across the mitochondrial or periplasmatic membrane, contributing to the transmembrane difference of electrochemical potential. Seven years ago we proposed a classification of these enzymes into three different families (A, B and C), based on the amino acid residues of their proton channels and amino acid sequence comparison, later supported by the so far identified characteristics of the catalytic centre of members from each family. The three families have in common the same general structural fold of the catalytic subunit, which contains the same or analogous prosthetic groups, and proton channels. These observations raise the hypothesis that the mechanisms for dioxygen reduction, proton pumping and the coupling of the two processes may be the same for all these enzymes. Under this hypothesis, they should be performed and controlled by the same or equivalent elements/events, and the identification of retained elements in all families will reveal their importance and may prompt the definition of the enzyme operating mode. Thus, we believe that the search for a minimum common denominator has a crucial importance, and in this article we highlight what is already established for the haem–copper oxygen reductases and emphasize the main questions still unanswered in a comprehensive basis.     

A tyrosine residue deprotonates during oxygen reduction by the caa3 reductase from Rhodothermus marinus

Heme-copper oxygen reductases catalyze proton translocation across the cellular membrane; this takes place during the reaction of oxygen to water. We demonstrate with attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) difference spectroscopy that a tyrosine residue of the oxygen reductase from the thermohalophilic Rhodothermus marinus becomes deprotonated in the transition from the oxidized state to the catalytic intermediate ferryl state P(M). This tyrosine residue is most probably Y256, the helix VI tyrosine residue proposed to substitute for the D-channel glutamic acid that is absent in this enzyme. Comparison with the mitochondrial like oxygen reductase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides suggests that proton transfer from a strategically situated donor to the active site is a crucial step in the reaction mechanism of oxygen reductases.     

The dual function of flavodiiron proteins: oxygen and/or nitric oxide reductases

Flavodiiron proteins have emerged in the last two decades as a newly discovered family of oxygen and/or nitric oxide reductases widespread in the three life domains, and present in both aerobic and anaerobic organisms. Herein we present the main features of these fascinating enzymes, with a particular emphasis on the metal sites, as more appropriate for this special issue in memory of the exceptional bioinorganic scientist R. J. P. Williams who pioneered the notion of (metal) element availability-driven evolution. We also compare the flavodiiron proteins with the other oxygen and nitric oxide reductases known until now, highlighting how throughout evolution Nature arrived at different solutions for similar functions, in some cases adding extra features, such as energy conservation. These enzymes are an example of the (bioinorganic) unpredictable diversity of the living world.     

Active site structure of the aa3 quinol oxidase of Acidianus ambivalens

The membrane bound aa(3)-type quinol:oxygen oxidoreductase from the hyperthermophilic archaeon, Acidianus ambivalens, which thrives at a pH of 2.5 and a temperature of 80 degrees C, has several unique structural and functional features as compared to the other members of the heme-copper oxygen reductase superfamily, but shares the common redox-coupled, proton-pumping function. To better understand the properties of the heme a(3)-Cu(B) catalytic site, a resonance Raman spectroscopic study of the enzyme under a variety of conditions and in the presence of various ligands was carried out. Assignments of several heme vibrational modes as well as iron-ligand stretching modes are made to serve as a basis for comparing the structure of the enzyme to that of other oxygen reductases. The CO-bound oxidase has conformations that are similar to those of other oxygen reductases. However, the addition of CO to the resting enzyme does not generate a mixed valence species as in the bovine aa(3) enzyme. The cyanide complex of the oxidized enzyme of A. ambivalens does not display the high stability of its bovine counterpart, and a redox titration demonstrates that there is an extensive heme-heme interaction reflected in the midpoint potentials of the cyanide adduct. The A. ambivalens oxygen reductase is very stable under acidic conditions, but it undergoes an earlier alkaline transition than the bovine enzyme. The A. ambivalens enzyme exhibits a redox-linked reversible conformational transition in the heme a(3)-Cu(B) center. The pH dependence and H/D exchange demonstrate that the conformational transition is associated with proton movements involving a group or groups with a pK(a) of approximately 3.8. The observed reversibility and involvement of protons in the redox-coupled conformational transition support the proton translocation model presented earlier. The implications of such conformational changes are discussed in relation to general redox-coupled proton pumping mechanisms in the heme-copper oxygen reductases.     

The necessary and the desirable production of radicals in biology

The production of radicals within biological systems can be necessary, as in the coupling of light capture or oxygen-hydride reactions to the generation of proton gradients in thylakoid and mitochondrial membranes; or it can be extremely desirable, to produce an effective catalyst centre in, for example, ribonucleotide reductases. To fit their function the radicals are usually of controlled reactivity, either through their redox properties or through confinement to a limited volume. The more indiscriminate generation of radicals can be of great use too in protective devices, for example, in the production of cross-linked polymers, or in the generation of oxygen radicals. The different distribution and release of initiating enzymes for all these radical processes ensures the spatial and temporal control of their reactions.     

Comparative genomics and site-directed mutagenesis support the existence of only one input channel for protons in the C-family (cbb3 oxidase) of heme-copper oxygen reductases

Oxygen reductase members of the heme-copper superfamily are terminal respiratory oxidases in mitochondria and many aerobic bacteria and archaea, coupling the reduction of molecular oxygen to water to the translocation of protons across the plasma membrane. The protons required for catalysis and pumping in the oxygen reductases are derived from the cytoplasmic side of the membrane, transferred via proton-conducting channels comprised of hydrogen bond chains containing internal water molecules along with polar amino acid side chains. Recent analyses identified eight oxygen reductase families in the superfamily: the A-, B-, C-, D-, E-, F-, G-, and H-families of oxygen reductases. Two proton input channels, the K-channel and the D-channel, are well established in the A-family of oxygen reductases (exemplified by the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidases and by the respiratory oxidases from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Paracoccus denitrificans). Each of these channels can be identified by the pattern of conserved polar amino acid residues within the protein. The C-family (cbb3 oxidases) is the second most abundant oxygen reductase family after the A-family, making up more than 20% of the sequences of the heme-copper superfamily. In this work, sequence analyses and structural modeling have been used to identify likely proton channels in the C-family. The pattern of conserved polar residues supports the presence of only one proton input channel, which is spatially analogous to the K-channel in the A-family. There is no pattern of conserved residues that could form a D-channel analogue or an alternative proton channel. The functional importance of the residues proposed to be part of the K-channel was tested by site-directed mutagenesis using the cbb3 oxidases from R. sphaeroides and Vibrio cholerae. Several of the residues proposed to be part of the putative K-channel had significantly reduced catalytic activity upon mutation: T219V, Y227F/Y228F, N293D, and Y321F. The data strongly suggest that in the C-family only one channel functions for the delivery of both catalytic and pumped protons. In addition, it is also proposed that a pair of acidic residues, which are totally conserved among the C-family, may be part of a proton-conducting exit channel for pumped protons. The residues homologous to these acidic amino acids are highly conserved in the cNOR family of nitric oxide reductases and have previously been implicated as part of a proton-conducting channel delivering protons from the periplasmic side of the membrane to the enzyme active site in the cNOR family. It is possible that the C-family contains a homologous proton-conducting channel that delivers pumped protons in the opposite direction, from the active site to the periplasm.     

The superfamily of heme-copper oxygen reductases: types and evolutionary considerations

Heme-copper oxygen reductases (HCO) reduce O(2) to water being the last enzymatic complexes of most aerobic respiratory chains. These enzymes promote energy conservation coupling the catalytic reaction to charge separation and charge translocation across the prokaryotic cytoplasmatic or mitochondrial membrane. In this way they contribute to the establishment and maintenance of the transmembrane difference of electrochemical potential, which is vital for solute/nutrient cell import, synthesis of ATP and motility. The HCO enzymes most probably share with the nitric oxide reductases, NORs, a common ancestor. We have proposed the classification of HCOs into three different types, A, B and C; based on the constituents of their proton channels (Pereira, Santana and Teixeira (2001) Biochim Biophys Acta, 1505, 185-208). This classification was recently challenged by the suggestion of other different types of HCOs. Using an enlarged sampling we performed an exhaustive bioinformatic reanalysis of HCOs family. Our results strengthened our previously proposed classification and showed no need for the existence of more divisions. Now, we analyze the taxonomic distribution of HCOs and NORs and the congruence of their sequence trees with the 16S rRNA tree. We observed that HCOs are widely distributed in the two prokaryotic domains and that the different types of enzymes are not confined to a specific taxonomic group or environmental niche.     

Comparative electrochemical study of superoxide reductases

Superoxide reductases are involved in relevant biological electron transfer reactions related to protection against oxidative stress caused by reactive oxygen species. The electrochemical features of metalloproteins belonging to the three different classes of enzymes were studied by potentio-dynamic techniques (cyclic and square wave voltammetry): desulfoferrodoxin from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough, class I superoxide reductases and neelaredoxin from Desulfovibrio gigas and Treponema pallidum, namely class II and III superoxide reductases, respectively. In addition, a small protein, designated desulforedoxin from D. gigas, which has high homology with the N-terminal domain of class I superoxide reductases, was also investigated. A comparison of the redox potentials and redox behavior of all the proteins is presented, and the results show that SOR center II is thermodynamically more stable than similar centers in different proteins, which may be related to an intramolecular electron transfer function.     

Identification of lysine-78 as an essential residue in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae xylose reductase

Yeast xylose reductases are hypothesized as hybrid enzymes as their primary sequences contain elements of both the aldo-keto reductases (AKR) and short chain dehydrogenase/reductase (SDR) enzyme families. During catalysis by members of both enzyme families, an essential Lys residue H-bonds to a Tyr residue that donates proton to the aldehyde substrate. In the Saccharomyces cerevisiae xylose reductase, Tyr49 has been identified as the proton donor. However, the primary sequence of the enzyme contains two Lys residues, Lys53 and Lys78, corresponding to the conserved motifs for SDR and AKR enzyme families, respectively, that may H-bond to Tyr49. We used site-directed mutagenesis to substitute each of these Lys residues with Met. The activity of the K53M variant was slightly decreased as compared to the wild-type, while that of the K78M variant was negligible. The results suggest that Lys78 is the essential residue that H-bonds to Tyr49 during catalysis and indicate that the active site residues of yeast xylose reductases match those of the AKR, rather than SDR, enzymes. Intrinsic enzyme fluorescence spectroscopic analysis suggests that Lys78 may also contribute to the efficient binding of NADPH to the enzyme.     

The superfamily of heme–copper oxygen reductases: Types and evolutionary considerations

Heme–copper oxygen reductases (HCO) reduce O₂ to water being the last enzymatic complexes of most aerobic respiratory chains. These enzymes promote energy conservation coupling the catalytic reaction to charge separation and charge translocation across the prokaryotic cytoplasmatic or mitochondrial membrane. In this way they contribute to the establishment and maintenance of the transmembrane difference of electrochemical potential, which is vital for solute/nutrient cell import, synthesis of ATP and motility. The HCO enzymes most probably share with the nitric oxide reductases, NORs, a common ancestor. We have proposed the classification of HCOs into three different types, A, B and C; based on the constituents of their proton channels (Pereira, Santana and Teixeira (2001) Biochim Biophys Acta, 1505, 185–208). This classification was recently challenged by the suggestion of other different types of HCOs. Using an enlarged sampling we performed an exhaustive bioinformatic reanalysis of HCOs family. Our results strengthened our previously proposed classification and showed no need for the existence of more divisions. Now, we analyze the taxonomic distribution of HCOs and NORs and the congruence of their sequence trees with the 16S rRNA tree. We observed that HCOs are widely distributed in the two prokaryotic domains and that the different types of enzymes are not confined to a specific taxonomic group or environmental niche. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Respiratory Oxidases.     

Expression of denitrification enzymes in response to the dissolved oxygen level and respiratory substrate in continuous culture of Pseudomonas stutzeri

The onset and cessation of the synthesis of denitrification enzymes of Pseudomonas stutzeri were investigated by using continuous culture and defined dissolved oxygen levels covering the full range of transition from air saturation to complete anaerobiosis. Expression of nitrate reductase, nitrite reductase (cytochrome cd1), and N2O reductase was controlled by discrete oxygen levels and by the nature of the nitrogenous oxide available for respiration. N2O reductase was synthesized constitutively at a low level; for enhanced expression, oxygen concentrations were required to decrease below 5 mg of O2 per liter. The threshold values for synthesis of nitrate reductase and cytochrome cd1 in the presence of nitrate were ca. 5 and ca. 2.5 mg of O2 per liter, respectively. With nitrous oxide as the respiratory substrate, nitrite reductase was again the most sensitive to oxygen concentration; however, thresholds for all denitrification enzymes shifted to lower oxygen levels. Whereas the presence of nitrate resulted in maximum expression and nearly uniform induction of all reductases, nitrite and nitrous oxide stimulated preferably the respective enzyme catalyzing reduction. In the absence of a nitrogenous oxide, anaerobiosis did not induce enzyme synthesis to any significant degree. The accumulation of nitrite seen during both the aerobic-anaerobic and anaerobic-aerobic transition phases was caused by the differences in onset or cessation of synthesis of nitrate and nitrite reductases and an inhibitory effect of nitrate on nitrite reduction.     

Expression of denitrification enzymes in response to the dissolved oxygen level and respiratory substrate in continuous culture of Pseudomonas stutzeri.

The onset and cessation of the synthesis of denitrification enzymes of Pseudomonas stutzeri were investigated by using continuous culture and defined dissolved oxygen levels covering the full range of transition from air saturation to complete anaerobiosis. Expression of nitrate reductase, nitrite reductase (cytochrome cd1), and N2O reductase was controlled by discrete oxygen levels and by the nature of the nitrogenous oxide available for respiration. N2O reductase was synthesized constitutively at a low level; for enhanced expression, oxygen concentrations were required to decrease below 5 mg of O2 per liter. The threshold values for synthesis of nitrate reductase and cytochrome cd1 in the presence of nitrate were ca. 5 and ca. 2.5 mg of O2 per liter, respectively. With nitrous oxide as the respiratory substrate, nitrite reductase was again the most sensitive to oxygen concentration; however, thresholds for all denitrification enzymes shifted to lower oxygen levels. Whereas the presence of nitrate resulted in maximum expression and nearly uniform induction of all reductases, nitrite and nitrous oxide stimulated preferably the respective enzyme catalyzing reduction. In the absence of a nitrogenous oxide, anaerobiosis did not induce enzyme synthesis to any significant degree. The accumulation of nitrite seen during both the aerobic-anaerobic and anaerobic-aerobic transition phases was caused by the differences in onset or cessation of synthesis of nitrate and nitrite reductases and an inhibitory effect of nitrate on nitrite reduction.     

Nitrofurazone-reducing enzymes in E. coli and their role in drug activation in vivo.

Earlier work showed that Escherichia coli contains at least two enzymes which reduce nitrofurazone and other nitrofuran derivatives. One of these enzymes is lacking in some nitrofurazone-resistant mutant strains. We now report that there are three separable nitrofuran reductases in this organism: reductase I (mol. wt. approximately 50 000, insensitive to O2), reductase IIa (mol. wt. approximately 120 000, inhibited by oxygen), reductase IIb (mol. wt. approximately 700 000, inhibited by O2). Unstable metabolites formed during the reduction of nitrofurazone by preparations containing reductases IIa and IIb produce breaks in DNA in vitro. In vivo experiments with nitrofurazone-resistant strains, which lack reductase II but contain reductases IIa and IIb, demonstrated that lethality, mutation, and DNA breakage are all greatly increased when cultures are incubated under anaerobic conditions, i.e., conditions such that reductase II is active. These results provide further evidence for the importance of reductive activation of nitrofurazone.     

Octaheme nitrite reductases: Structure and properties

Octaheme oxidoreductases are widespread among various bacterial taxa involved in the biogeochemical nitrogen cycle. The evolution of octaheme oxidoreductases of the nitrogen cycle from the evolutionarily more ancient pentaheme nitrite reductases was accompanied by changes in function from reduction of nitrogen oxides to their oxidation under changing environmental conditions. Octaheme nitrite reductases, which are the subject of the present review, are of a transitional form that combines structural and functional characteristics of pentaheme reductases and octaheme oxidases and possesses a number of unique features typical of only this family of enzymes. The review summarizes data on structure-function investigations of the family of octaheme nitrite reductases. Emphasis is given to comparison of the structures and functions of octaheme nitrite reductases and other multiheme oxidoreductases of the nitrogen cycle.     

Identification of disulfide reductases in Campylobacterales: a bioinformatics investigation

Disulfide reductases of host-colonising bacteria are involved in the expression of virulence factors, resistance to drugs, and elimination of toxic compounds. Large-scale genome analyses of 281 prokaryotes identified CXXC and CXXC-derived motifs in each microorganism. The total number of these motifs showed correlations with genome size and oxygen tolerance of the prokaryotes. Specific bioinformatic analyses served to identify putative disulfide reductases in the Campylobacterales Campylobacter jejuni, Helicobacter pylori, Wolinella succinogenes and Arcobacter butzleri which colonise the gastrointestinal tract of higher animals. Three filters applied to the genomes of these species yielded 35, 25, 28 and 34 genes, respectively, encoding proteins with the characteristics of disulfide reductases. Ten proteins were common to the four species, including four belonging to the thioredoxin system. The presence of thioredoxin reductase activities was detected in the four bacterial species by observing dithiobis-2-nitrobenzoic acid reduction with β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate as cofactor. Phylogenetic analyses of the thioredoxin reductases TrxB₁ and TrxB₂ of the four Campylobacterales were performed. Their TrxB₁ proteins were more closely related to those of Firmicutes than to the corresponding proteins of other Proteobacteria. The Campylobacterales TrxB₂ proteins were closer to glutathione reductases of other organisms than to their respective TrxB₁ proteins. The phylogenetic features of the Campylobacterales thioredoxin reductases suggested a special role for these enzymes in the physiology of these bacteria. Electronic Supplementary Material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Molecular Evolution of Peptide Methionine Sulfoxide Reductases (MsrA and MsrB): On the Early Development of a Mechanism That Protects Against Oxidative Damage

Methionine sulfoxide reductases, enzymes that reverse the oxidation of methionine residues, have been described in a wide range of species. The reduction of the diastereoisomers of oxidized methionine is catalyzed by two different monomeric methionine sulfoxide reductases (MsrA and MsrB) and is best understood as an evolutionary response to high levels of oxygen either in the Earth’s atmosphere or possibly in more localized environments. Phylogenetic analyses of these proteins suggest that their distribution is the outcome of a complex history including many paralogy and lateral gene transfer events. Electronic Supplementary Material Electronic Supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users. [Reviewing Editor: Dr. Martin Kreitman]