Neuron death in the developing avian isthmo–optic nucleus,and its relation to the establishment of functional circuitry

The present review covers all the published data on neuron death in the developing avian isthmo–optic nucleus (ION), which provides a particularly convenient situation for studying the causes and consequences of neuron death in the development of the vertebrate central nervous system. The main conclusions are as follows: The naturally occurring neuron death in the ION is related both temporally and causally to the ION's formation of afferent and efferent connections. The ION neurons need to obtain both anterograde and retrograde survival signals in order to survive during a critical period in embryogenesis. They may compete, at least for the retrograde signals, but the nature of the competition is still unclear. The retrograde signals are modified by action potentials. Neurons dying from a lack of anterograde survival signals can be distinguished morphologically from ones dying from a lack of retrograde signals. The neuron death refines circuitry by selectively eliminating neurons with “aberrant” axons projecting to the “wrong” (i.e., ipsilateral) retina or to the “wrong” (topographically inappropriate) part of the contralateral retina. © 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Differential effects of the trophic factors BDNF, NT-4, GDNF, and IGF-I on the isthmo-optic nucleus in chick embryos

The isthmo-optic nucleus (ION) of chick embryos is a model system for the study of retrograde trophic signaling in developing CNS neurons. The role of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is well established in this system. Recent work has implicated neurotrophin-4 (NT-4), glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF), and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) as additional trophic factors for ION neurons. Here it was examined in vitro and in vivo whether these factors are target-derived trophic factors for the ION in 13- to 16-day-old chick embryos. Unlike BDNF, neither GDNF, NT-4, nor IGF-I increased the survival of ION neurons in dissociated cultures identified by retrograde labeling with the fluorescent tracer DiI. BDNF and IGF-I promoted neurite outgrowth from ION explants, whereas GDNF and NT-4 had no effect. Injections of NT-4, but not GDNF, in the retina decreased the survival of ION neurons and accelerated cell death in the ION. NT-4-like immunoreactivity was present in the retina and the ION. Exogenous, radiolabeled NT-4, but not GDNF or IGF-I, was retrogradely transported from the retina to the ION. NT-4 transport was significantly reduced by coinjection of excess cold nerve growth factor (NGF), indicating that the majority of NT-4 bound to p75 neurotrophin receptors during axonal transport. Binding of NT-4 to chick p75 receptors was confirmed in L-cells, which express chick p75 receptors. These data indicate that GDNF has no direct trophic effects on ION neurons. IGF-I may be an afferent trophic factor for the ION, and NT-4 may act as an antagonist to BDNF, either by competing with BDNF for p75 and/or trkB binding or by signaling cell death via p75.     

Differential effects of the trophic factors BDNF,NT‐4, GDNF,and IGF‐I on the isthmo‐optic nucleus in chick embryos

The isthmo‐optic nucleus (ION) of chick embryos is a model system for the study of retrograde trophic signaling in developing CNS neurons. The role of brain‐derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is well established in this system. Recent work has implicated neurotrophin‐4 (NT‐4), glial cell line–derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF), and insulin‐like growth factor I (IGF‐I) as additional trophic factors for ION neurons. Here it was examined in vitro and in vivo whether these factors are target‐derived trophic factors for the ION in 13‐ to 16‐day‐old chick embryos. Unlike BDNF, neither GDNF, NT‐4, nor IGF‐I increased the survival of ION neurons in dissociated cultures identified by retrograde labeling with the fluorescent tracer DiI. BDNF and IGF‐I promoted neurite outgrowth from ION explants, whereas GDNF and NT‐4 had no effect. Injections of NT‐4, but not GDNF, in the retina decreased the survival of ION neurons and accelerated cell death in the ION. NT‐4–like immunoreactivity was present in the retina and the ION. Exogenous, radiolabeled NT‐4, but not GDNF or IGF‐I, was retrogradely transported from the retina to the ION. NT‐4 transport was significantly reduced by coinjection of excess cold nerve growth factor (NGF), indicating that the majority of NT‐4 bound to p75 neurotrophin receptors during axonal transport. Binding of NT‐4 to chick p75 receptors was confirmed in L‐cells, which express chick p75 receptors. These data indicate that GDNF has no direct trophic effects on ION neurons. IGF‐I may be an afferent trophic factor for the ION, and NT‐4 may act as an antagonist to BDNF, either by competing with BDNF for p75 and/or trkB binding or by signaling cell death via p75. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 43: 289–303, 2000     

Motor neuron degeneration after sciatic nerve avulsion in adult rat evolves with oxidative stress and is apoptosis.

The mechanisms for motor neuron degeneration and regeneration in adult spinal cord following axotomy and target deprivation are not fully understood. We used a unilateral sciatic nerve avulsion model in adult rats to test the hypothesis that retrograde degeneration of motor neurons resembles apoptosis. By 21 days postlesion, the number of large motor neurons in lumbar spinal cord was reduced by approximately 30%. The death of motor neurons was confirmed using the terminal transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-biotin nick-end labeling method for detecting fragmentation of nuclear DNA. Motor neuron degeneration was characterized by aberrant accumulation of perikaryal phosphorylated neurofilaments. Structurally, motor neuron death was apoptosis. Apoptotic motor neurons undergo chromatolysis followed by progressive cytoplasmic and nuclear condensation with chromatin compaction into uniformly large round clumps. Prior to apoptosis, functionally active mitochondria accumulate within chromatolytic motor neurons, as determined by cytochrome c oxidase activity. These dying motor neurons sustain oxidative damage to proteins and nucleic acids within the first 7 days after injury during the progression of apoptosis, as identified by immunodetection of nitrotyrosine and hydroxyl-modified deoxyguanosine and guanosine. We conclude that the retrograde death of motor neurons in the adult spinal cord after sciatic nerve avulsion is apoptosis. Accumulation of active mitochondria within the perikaryon and oxidative damage to nucleic acids and proteins may contribute to the mechanisms for apoptosis of motor neurons in the adult spinal cord.     

A pathway of signals regulating effector and initiator caspases in the developing Drosophila eye

Regulated cell death and survival play important roles in neural development. Extracellular signals are presumed to regulate seven apparent caspases to determine the final structure of the nervous system. In the eye, the EGF receptor, Notch, and intact primary pigment and cone cells have been implicated in survival or death signals. An antibody raised against a peptide from human caspase 3 was used to investigate how extracellular signals controlled spatial patterning of cell death. The antibody crossreacted specifically with dying Drosophila cells and labelled the activated effector caspase Drice. It was found that the initiator caspase Dronc and the proapoptotic gene head involution defective were important for activation in vivo. Dronc may play roles in dying cells in addition to activating downstream effector caspases. Epistasis experiments ordered EGF receptor, Notch, and primary pigment and cone cells into a single pathway that affected caspase activity in pupal retina through hid and Inhibitor of Apoptosis Proteins. None of these extracellular signals appeared to act by initiating caspase activation independently of hid. Taken together, these findings indicate that in eye development spatial regulation of cell death and survival is integrated through a single intracellular pathway.     

NT-3, like NGF, Is Required for Survival of Sympathetic Neurons, but Not Their Precursors

Superior cervical ganglia of postnatal mice with a targeted disruption of the gene for neurotrophin-3 have 50% fewer neurons than those of wild-type mice. In culture, neurotrophin-3 increases the survival of proliferating sympathetic precursors. Both precursor death (W. ElShamy et al., 1996, Development 122, 491-500) and, more recently, neuronal death (S. Wyatt et al., 1997, EMBO J. 16, 3115-3123) have been described in mice lacking NT-3. Consistent with the second report, we found that, in vivo, neurogenesis and precursor survival were unaffected by the absence of neurotrophin-3 but neuronal survival was compromised so that only 50% of the normal number of neurons survived to birth. At the time of neuron loss, neurotrophin-3 expression, assayed with a lacZ reporter, was detected in sympathetic target tissues and blood vessels, including those along which sympathetic axons grow, suggesting it may act as a retrograde neurotrophic factor, similar to nerve growth factor. To explore this possibility, we compared neuron loss in neurotrophin-3-deficient mice with that in nerve growth factor-deficient mice and found that neuronal losses occurred at approximately the same time in both mutants, but were less severe in mice lacking neurotrophin-3. Eliminating one or both neurotrophin-3 alleles in mice that lack nerve growth factor does not further reduce sympathetic neuron number in the superior cervical ganglion at E17.5 but does alter axon outgrowth and decrease salivary gland innervation. Taken together these results suggest that neurotrophin-3 is required for survival of some sympathetic neurons that also require nerve growth factor.     

Motor neuron degeneration after sciatic nerve avulsion in adult rat evolves with oxidative stress and is apoptosis

The mechanisms for motor neuron degeneration and regeneration in adult spinal cord following axotomy and target deprivation are not fully understood. We used a unilateral sciatic nerve avulsion model in adult rats to test the hypothesis that retrograde degeneration of motor neurons resembles apoptosis. By 21 days postlesion, the number of large motor neurons in lumbar spinal cord was reduced by ∼30%. The death of motor neurons was confirmed using the terminal transferase‐mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate‐biotin nick‐end labeling method for detecting fragmentation of nuclear DNA. Motor neuron degeneration was characterized by aberrant accumulation of perikaryal phosphorylated neurofilaments. Structurally, motor neuron death was apoptosis. Apoptotic motor neurons undergo chromatolysis followed by progressive cytoplasmic and nuclear condensation with chromatin compaction into uniformly large round clumps. Prior to apoptosis, functionally active mitochondria accumulate within chromatolytic motor neurons, as determined by cytochrome c oxidase activity. These dying motor neurons sustain oxidative damage to proteins and nucleic acids within the first 7 days after injury during the progression of apoptosis, as identified by immunodetection of nitrotyrosine and hydroxyl‐modified deoxyguanosine and guanosine. We conclude that the retrograde death of motor neurons in the adult spinal cord after sciatic nerve avulsion is apoptosis. Accumulation of active mitochondria within the perikaryon and oxidative damage to nucleic acids and proteins may contribute to the mechanisms for apoptosis of motor neurons in the adult spinal cord. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 40: 185–201, 1999     

Cell death and neuronal replacement during formation of the avian ciliary ganglion

Programmed cell death is a prominent feature of embryonic development and is essential in matching the number of neurons to the target tissues that are innervated. Although a decrease in neuronal number which coincides with peripheral synaptogenesis has been well documented in the avian ciliary ganglion, it has not been clear whether cell death also occurs earlier. We observed TUNEL-positive neurons as early as stage 24, with a large peak at stage 29. This cell death at stage 29 was followed by a statistically significant (P < 0.0001) decrease in total neuron number at stage 31. The total number of neurons was recovered by stage 33/34. This suggested that dying neurons were replaced by new neurons. This replacement process did not involve proliferation because bromodeoxyuridine applied at stages 29 and 31 was unable to label neurons harvested at stage 33/34. The peak of cell death at stage 29 was increased 2.3-fold by removal of the optic vesicle and was reduced by 50% when chCNTF was overexpressed. Taken together, these results suggest that the regulation of neuron number in the ciliary ganglion is a dynamic process involving both cell death and neural replacement from postmitotic precursors prior to differentiation and innervation of target tissues.     

Treatment with polyamines can prevent monosodium glutamate neurotoxicity in the rat retina

It has been previously shown that treatment of newborn rats with the polyamines putrescine, spermidine and spermine can rescue sympathetic neurons from naturally occurring cell death and from induced death after axotomy or immunosympathectomy. The present study demonstrates that polyamine treatment can also prevent the neurodegenerative effects in the retina and the loss of body weight caused by monosodium glutamate. The findings indicate that polyamine treatment may have a rather general beneficial effect on neuron survival.     

Neuronal apoptosis in mouse trisomy 16: mediation by caspases

Hippocampal neurons from the trisomy 16 (Ts16) mouse, a potential animal model of Down's syndrome (trisomy 21) and neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer's disease (AD), die at an accelerated rate in vitro. Here, we present evidence that the accelerated neuronal death in Ts16 occurs by apoptosis, as has been reported for neurons in AD. First, the nuclei of dying Ts16 neurons are pyknotic and undergo DNA fragmentation, as revealed by terminal transferase-mediated dUTP nick end-labeling. Second, the accelerated death of Ts16 neurons is prevented by inhibitors of the caspase family of proteases, which are thought to act at a late, obligatory step in the apoptosis pathway. In the presence of maximally effective concentrations of caspase inhibitors, Ts16 neuron survival was indistinguishable from that of control neurons. These results suggest that overexpression of one or more genes on mouse chromosome 16 leads to caspase-mediated apoptosis in Ts16 neurons.     

Suppression of death receptor signaling in cerebellar Purkinje neurons protects neighboring granule neurons from apoptosis via an insulin-like growth factor I-dependent mechanism

Neuronal apoptosis contributes to the progression of neurodegenerative disease. Primary cerebellar granule neurons are an established in vitro model for investigating neuronal death. After removal of serum and depolarizing potassium, granule neurons undergo apoptosis via a mechanism that requires intrinsic (mitochondrial) death signals; however, the role of extrinsic (death receptor-mediated) signals is presently unclear. Here, we investigate involvement of death receptor signaling in granule neuron apoptosis by expressing adenoviral, AU1-tagged, dominant-negative Fas-associated death domain (Ad-AU1-deltaFADD). Ad-AU1-deltaFADD decreased apoptosis of granule neurons from 65 +/- 5 to 27 +/- 2% (n = 7, p < 0.01). Unexpectedly, immunocytochemical staining for AU1 revealed that <5% of granule neurons expressed deltaFADD. In contrast, deltaFADD was expressed in >95% of calbindin-positive Purkinje neurons ( approximately 2% of the cerebellar culture). Granule neurons in proximity to deltaFADD-expressing Purkinje cells demonstrated markedly increased survival. Both granule and Purkinje neurons expressed insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) receptors, and deltaFADD-mediated survival of granule neurons was inhibited by an IGF-I receptor blocking antibody. These results demonstrate that the selective suppression of death receptor signaling in Purkinje neurons is sufficient to rescue neighboring granule neurons that depend on Purkinje cell-derived IGF-I. Thus, the extrinsic death pathway has a profound but indirect effect on the survival of cerebellar granule neurons.     

Temporal requirement of the alternative-splicing factor Sfrs1 for the survival of retinal neurons

Alternative splicing is the primary mechanism by which a limited number of protein-coding genes can generate proteome diversity. We have investigated the role of the alternative-splicing factor Sfrs1, an arginine/serine-rich (SR) protein family member, during mouse retinal development. Loss of Sfrs1 function during embryonic retinal development had a profound effect, leading to a small retina at birth. In addition, the retina underwent further degeneration in the postnatal period. Loss of Sfrs1 function resulted in the death of retinal neurons that were born during early to mid-embryonic development. Ganglion cells, cone photoreceptors, horizontal cells and amacrine cells were produced and initiated differentiation. However, these neurons subsequently underwent cell death through apoptosis. By contrast, Sfrs1 was not required for the survival of the neurons generated later, including later-born amacrine cells, rod photoreceptors, bipolar cells and Müller glia. Our results highlight the requirement of Sfrs1-mediated alternative splicing for the survival of retinal neurons, with sensitivity defined by the window of time in which the neuron was generated.     

Early development of the rat precerebellar system: migratory routes, selective aggregation and neuritic differentiation of the inferior olive and lateral reticular nucleus neurons. An overview

The migration, cytoarchitectonic segregation and neuritogenesis of the inferior olive (ION) and lateral reticular (LRN) neurons are described in the rat. Generated in the same primary precerebellar neuroepithelium, at embryonic days 12-13 (E12-E13) for the ION and E12-E14 for the LRN, the postmitotic cells take either the intraparenchymal (smms, for ION neurons) or the subpial migratory streams (mms, for LRN neurons and other populations, as those of the external cuneate nucleus, ECN). The ION neurons settle in their ultimate domain from E16 to E18, ipsilaterally to their proliferation side. The LRN (and ECN) neurons cross the midline at the "floor plate" (FP) level, and settle contralaterally to their birthplace between E17 and E19. In both cases, the acquisition of a mature dendritic tree is a late event when compared to the precocious axonogenesis. The FP structure may play a major role in i) attracting the axons of the precerebellar neurons, and ii) instructing these neurons whether to cross the midline or not. Thus, ultimately the FP may govern the pattern (crossed or uncrossed) of the projections of the ION and LRN to their common cerebellar target.     

Distinct neurotrophic factors from skeletal muscle and the central nervous system interact synergistically to support the survival of cultured embryonic spinal motor neurons

Motor neurons isolated from 6-day-old embryonic chick spinal cords require muscle extract for survival in culture; however, it was found, that some motor neurons, identified by retrograde labeling with rhodamine, will survive in mixed spinal cell cultures in the absence of the extract. The motor neuron survival-promoting activity produced by spinal cells is soluble and differs from the factor present in muscle extract, the two activities acting in a synergistic manner: the spinal cell activity potentiated that of muscle to decrease its ED50 by an order of magnitude, the motor neuronal survival (30%) seen in the presence of both factors being more than the sum of their individual activities. This synergism was shown to be restricted to the action of the spinal cell factor on motor neurons, no effect of the factor being noted with sympathetic neurons. As a series of defined growth and survival factors present in the central nervous system (nerve growth factor, brain-derived neurotrophic factor, acidic and basic fibroblast growth factors) had no effect on motor neuron survival, we conclude that the molecule responsible for the motor neuron survival-promoting activity of the spinal cells is a previously undefined factor.     

Regulation and effects of GDF-15 in the retina following optic nerve crush

Growth/differentiation factor-15 (GDF-15) is a distant member of the transforming growth factor-β superfamily and is ubiquitously expressed in the central nervous system. It is prominently upregulated in cerebral cortical and ischemic lesion paradigms. GDF-15 robustly promotes the survival of lesioned nigrostriatal dopaminergic neurons in vivo; GDF-15-deficient mice exhibit progressive postnatal motor and sensory neuron losses implying essential functions of GDF-15 in neuronal survival. We show that GDF-15 mRNA and protein are, respectively, six-fold and three-fold upregulated in the murine retina at 1 day after optic nerve crush, slightly elevated mRNA levels being maintained until day 28. However, the magnitude and time course of retinal ganglion cell (RGC) death are indistinguishable in knockout and control mice. Selected mRNAs implicated in the regulation of the death vs. survival of RGCs, including ATF3, Bad, Bcl-2 and caspase-8, were similarly regulated in both knockout and control retinae. Immunohistochemistry for tyrosine hydroxylase and choline acetyltransferase revealed no differences in staining patterns in the two genotypes. mRNA and protein levels of galanin, a putative neuroprotective factor and positive regulator of neuron survival and axonal regeneration, were prominently upregulated after crush in knockout retinae at day 3, as compared with control retinae, suggesting that GDF-15 acts as a physiological regulator of galanin. GDF-15 is therefore prominently upregulated in the retina after optic nerve crush but does not directly interfere with the magnitude and temporal progression of RGC death.     

Retrograde transport of neurotrophins: fact and function

Retrograde signals generated by nerve growth factor (NGF) and other neurotrophins promote the survival of appropriately connected neurons during development, and failure to obtain sufficient retrograde signals may contribute to neuronal death occurring in many neurodegenerative diseases. The discovery over 25 years ago that NGF supplied to the axon terminals is retrogradely transported to the cell bodies suggested that NGF must reach the cell body to promote neuronal survival. Research during the intervening decades has produced a refinement of this hypothesis. The current hypothesis is that NGF bound to TrkA at the axon terminal is internalized into signaling endosomes, with NGF in their lumens bound to phosphorylated TrkA in their membranes, which are retrogradely transported to the cell bodies, where TrkA activates downstream signaling molecules that promote neuronal survival and regulate many aspects of neuronal gene expression. This model has been extrapolated to retrograde signaling by all neurotrophins. We consider the evidence for this model, focusing on results of experiments with neurons in compartmented cultures. Results to date indicate that while the transport of signaling endosomes containing NGF bound to TrkA may carry retrograde signals, retrograde survival signals can be carried by another mechanism that is activated by NGF at the axon terminal surface and travels to the cell body unaccompanied by the NGF that initiated it. It is hypothesized that multiple mechanisms of retrograde signaling exist and function under different circumstances. The newly discovered potential for redundancy in retrograde signaling mechanisms can complicate the interpretation of experimental results.     

Distinct susceptibility of developing neurons to death following Bax overexpression in the chicken embryo

Bax is a proapoptotic protein that is required for programmed cell death (PCD) of many neuronal populations. Here we show that, during an early period of retinal PCD and in naturally occurring sensory and motor neuron (MN) death in the spinal cord, Bax delivery results in enhanced death of these neural populations. In contrast, Bax overexpression fails to enhance an early phase of MN death that occurs in the cervical spinal cord, although overexpressed Bax appears to be activated in dying MNs. Bax overexpression does not also affect the survival of immature neurons prior to the PCD period. Taken together, these data provide the first in vivo evidence suggesting that Bax appears to act selectively as an executioner only in neurons undergoing PCD. Furthermore, although Bax appears to mediate the execution pathway for PCD, the effect of Bax overexpression on susceptibility to death differs between different neuronal populations.     

Photoperiod regulation of neuron death in the adult canary

The avian brain undergoes naturally occurring cell death and neuronal replacement in adulthood. Little is known about how neuron survival in adult birds is regulated. However, previous work suggests that this process is open to environmental control. We now report that a reduction in day length from springlike to fall-like conditions can dramatically increase cell death in adult male canaries. Many of the dying cells are projection neurons in the motor pathway controlling song learning and production. Circulating levels of gonadal steroids were not correlated with photoperiod-induced changes in the magnitude of cell death. Our results suggest that neuronal death in adult male canaries is regulated by seasonal changes in photoperiod, and that this occurs independent of chronic changes in gonadal steroid hormone levels. Day length may serve as a predictive environmental cue to time cell death in accordance with seasonal reproduction. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 33: 223–231, 1997

1 This is a US Government work and, as such, is in the public domain in the United States of America.

     

Interactions between beta-neuregulin and neurotrophins in motor neuron apoptosis

Neuregulins play a major role in the formation and stabilization of neuromuscular junctions, and are produced by both motor neurons and muscle. Although the effects and mechanism of neuregulins on skeletal muscle (e.g. regulation of acetylcholine receptor expression) have been studied extensively, the effects of neuregulins on motor neurons remain unknown. We report that neuregulin-1beta (NRGbeta1) inhibited apoptosis of rat motor neurons for up to 7 days in culture by a phosphatidylinositol 3 kinase-dependent pathway and synergistically enhanced motor neuron survival promoted by glial-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF). However, binding of neurotrophins, including brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and nerve growth factor (NGF), to the p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75NTR) abolished the neuregulin anti-apoptotic effect on motor neurons. Inhibitors of the c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) mitogen-activated protein kinase prevented motor neuron death caused by co-incubation of NRGbeta1 and BDNF or NGF, as well as by trophic factor deprivation. Motor neuron apoptosis resulting from both trophic factor deprivation and exposure to NRGbeta1 plus neurotrophins required the induction of neuronal nitric oxide synthase and peroxynitrite formation. Because motor neurons express both p75NTR and neuregulin erbB receptors during the period of embryonic programmed cell death, motor neuron survival may be the result of complex interactions between trophic and death factors, which may be the same molecules acting in different combinations.