FREEZE-FRACTURE OF MICROTUBULES AND BRIDGES IN MOTILE AXOSTYLES

A freeze-fracture study of the motile axostyles of the flagellate protozoa Saccinobaculus and Pyrsonympha has been undertaken in order to obtain a view of the relationships of microtubules and their cross bridges not dependent on conventional preparative procedures. Reactivation studies using isolated axostyles prepared for freeze-fracture and then thawed demonstrate that we are observing the structure of a potentially functional axostyle. Cross fractures through the axostyle demonstrate more extensive interrow bridging than expected on the basis of observations of thin-sectioned material. Each microtubule has approximately sixfold bridge-binding sites with connections to as many as four interrow bridges. Measurements of microtubule diameter and spacing are significantly larger than those made from sectioned material and may indicate that conventional processing for electron microscopy results in the loss of structurally important water within the microtubule in addition to loss of intertubule material. Longitudinal fractures through the axostyle at various orientations demonstrate a minimum longitudinal periodicity of 160 Å for both the spacing of the globular subunits within the microtubule wall and the spacing of the intrarow bridges. While intrarow bridges are strictly periodic and always oriented in parallel, interrow bridges are not strictly periodic and can be oriented at varying angles to the microtubule axis.     

MICROTUBULES: EVIDENCE FOR 13 PROTOFILAMENTS

When microtubules are fixed in glutaraldehyde in the presence of tannic acid and thin sections cut, the subunit structure of the microtubule is readily observed without the need of image reinforcement. Seven types of microtubules were analyzed: those in the heliozoan axoneme, the mitotic apparatus, the contractile axostyle, repolymerized microtubules derived from the chick brain, the central pair in flagella, and the A tubules of flagella and the basal body. In all cases microtubules were composed of 13 equally spaced protofilaments. The B tubules in flagella and the basal body appear to be composed of 11 subunits. The connections of the B to the A and the C to the B are described. A model of a microtubule is presented.     

Different structural states of a microtubule cross-linking molecule, captured by quick-freezing motile axostyles in protozoa

Freeze-etch preparation of the laminated bundles of microtubules in motile axostyles demonstrates that the cross-bridges populating individual layers or laminae are structurally similar to the dynein arms of cilia and flagellae. Also, like dynein, they are extracted by high salt and undergo a change in tilt upon removal of endogenous ATP (while the axostyle as a whole straightens and becomes stiff). On the other hand, the bridges running between adjacent microtubule laminae in the axostyle turn out to be much more delicate and wispy in appearance, and display no similarity to dynein arms. Thus we propose that the internal or "intra-laminar" cross-bridges are the active force- generating ATPases in this system, and that they generate overall bends or changes in the helical pitch of the axostyle by altering the longitudinal and lateral register of microtubules in each lamina individually; e.g., by "warping" each lamina and creating longitudinal shear forces within it. The cross-links between adjacent laminae, on the other hand, would then simply be force-transmitting elements that serve to translate the shearing forces generated within individual laminae into overall helical shape changes. (This hypothesis differs from the views of earlier workers who considered a more active role for the later cross-links, postulating that they cause an active sliding between adjacent layers that somehow leads to axostyle movement.) Also described here are physical connections between adjacent intra-laminar cross-bridges, structurally analogous to the overlapping components of the outer dynein arms of cilia and flagella. As with dynein, these may represent a mechanism for propagating local changes from cross-bridge to cross-bridge down the axostyle, as occurs during the passage of bends down the length of the organelle.     

Formation of double-walled microtubules and multilayered tubulin sheets by basic proteins

Some basic proteins enable microtubule protein to form special assembly products in vitro, known as double-walled microtubules. Using histones (H1, core histones) as well as the human encephalitogenic protein to induce the formation of double-walled microtubules, we made the following electron microscopic observations: (1) Double-walled microtubules consist of an "inner" microtubule which is covered by electron-dense material, apparently formed from the basic protein, and by a second tubulin wall. (2) The tubulin of the second wall seems to be arranged as protofilaments, surrounding the inner microtubule in a helical or ring-like manner. (3) The surface of double-walled microtubules lacks the projections of microtubule-associated proteins, usually found on microtubules. (4) In the case of protofilament ribbons (incomplete microtubules), H1 binds exclusively to their convex sides that correspond to the surface of microtubules. Zn2+-induced tubulin sheets, consisting in contrast to microtubules of alternately arranged protofilaments, are covered by H1 on both surfaces. Furthermore, multilayered sheet aggregates appeared. The results indicate that the basic proteins used interact only with that protofilament side which represents the microtubule surface. In accordance with this general principle, models on the structure of double-walled microtubules and multilayered tubulin sheets were derived.     

Axostyle structure in the termite protozoon Pyrsonympha vertens

The axostyle of Pyrsonympha vertens is a cellular organelle composed of interconnected microtubules. In living organisms the axostyle has waves which originate at the anterior end of the protozoon and traverse the length to the posterior end of the protozoon so that an average of 3–4 waves are present in the organelle at any given point in time. The part of the axostyle between the waves is straight. In sections through the middle of the straight part, the microtubules are hexagonally packed, with predominant connections between tubules in rows across the width of the axostyle, but the microtubules are rectilinearly packed through the wave. The wave appears to involve changes in orientation and arrangement of the microtubules. The general structure of the microtubules, cross-bridges and axostyle in the straight and bent portions are described and related to the wave propagation by this organelle.     

Trichomonas vaginalis: microtubule cytoskeleton distribution using fluorescent taxoid

Trichomonas vaginalis is a flagellated parasitic protist of the human urogenital tract. The parasite has a poorly known cytoskeleton formed by an axostyle and a pelta, which are formed by stable structures such as microtubules, essential for the maintenance of cell shape and organization. FLUTAX-2 is an active fluorescent derivative of Taxol, binds to alphabeta-tubulin dimer polymerized. In this paper we present the analysis of microtubule distribution in living trophozoites of T. vaginalis using FLUTAX-2.     

Bovine platelets contain a 280 kDa microtubule-associated protein antigenically related to brain MAP 2.

Resting bovine platelets contain a microtubule coil which reorganizes into linear arrays upon thrombin activation. Microtubule arrays in both resting and activated platelets are extensively cross-linked. In an effort to determine the proteins responsible for this cross-linking, we have developed a method to isolate taxol-stabilized microtubule coils directly from platelet-rich plasma. Negatively stained coils are still cross-linked, and fine filamentous projections are seen between adjacent microtubules. Critical-point-dried rotary shadowed replicas of these coils most clearly demonstrate the projections radiating from individual microtubules as well as along the microtubule coil. Sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analysis of isolated coils shows many microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) present in addition to tubulin. One of these proteins, a 280 kDa MAP, cross-reacts with an antibody to bovine brain MAP 2 by immunoblot analysis. Immunofluorescence localization of this protein with both monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies demonstrates that it is associated with the microtubule coil in resting platelets and with the linear microtubule array present after thrombin activation. Immunoelectron microscopic localization demonstrates that projections from individual microtubules are labeled by the antibodies. We suggest that this MAP, along with several other potential MAPs, is responsible for the cross-linking and stability of bovine platelet microtubules.     

The fine structure of the axostyle and its associations with organelles in Trichomonads

The fine structure of the axostyle in the protists Tritrichomonas foetus and Monocercomonas sp is described using transmission electron microscopy after quick-freezing techniques and immunocytochemistry. The axostyle microtubules presents a lateral projection formed by two protofilaments in addition to the 13 protofilaments normally found in microtubules. The axostyle is associated with other cell structures such as hydrogenosomes, endoplasmic reticulum, sigmoid filaments and glycogen particles. The microtubules of the pelta-axostylar system are connected to each other by bridges regularly spaced with an interval of 9 nm. Labeling of the axostyle was observed after cell incubation with monoclonal antibodies recognizing alpha-tubulin and acetylated-tubulin.     

Behavior of C-shaped microtubule endings in the cell

The association of incomplete microtubule assemblies with either another incomplete structure or complete microtubules was studied in two organisms, the phytoflagellate Polytoma papillatum and the phorid fly Megaselia scalaris, using transmission electron microscopy. In the alga, hook-shaped appendages on cytoplasmic and spindle microtubules were detected. These resulted from the lateral association of a curved ribbon of protofilaments with the surface of a complete microtubular wall. In the fly, an S-shaped protofilament sheet was found embedded in the kinetochore plate of a prometaphase I spermatocyte. Tracing of the S-shaped element towards the spindle pole revealed that it was formed by the lateral junction of two curved protofilament sheets. In all cases, the C-shaped protofilament sheets represented the endings of complete microtubules. Incomplete microtubules are generally considered as representing intermediates of microtubule assembly and disassembly. Since high molecular weight proteins are believed to be responsible for maintaining microtubule-microtubule spacing, it is hypothesized that the endings of growing and shrinking microtubules are sparsely studded with these proteins; their depletion allows lateral microtubule contacts. In addition, the microtubule-microtubule contacts may be rendered possible by the flexibility of the slender elongated microtubule-associated molecules. Relatively long C-shaped protofilament appendages (0.6-1.4 microns) were detected in this study. Therefore, it is plausible to assume that the protofilament sheets are stabilized by contact with one another or with an intact tubule wall.     

THE AXOSTYLE OF SACCINOBACULUS : I. Structure of the Organism and Its Microtubule Bundle

The axostyle of the flagellate Saccinobaculus is a motile ribbon composed of microtubules, cross-bridged to form interconnected rows. We find a centriole-related row of dark-staining tubules near the nucleus at the anterior end of the axostyle. Other tubule rows bind parallel to this primary row, acquire ordered relationships, and become the tubules of the axostyle proper. The number of tubule rows is constant in Saccinobaculus lata from the region near the nucleus to within a few micrometers of the posterior tip of the cell. In Saccinobaculus ambloaxostylus a few tubule rows are added to the axostyle posterior to the nucleus, giving this axostyle a leaf spring construction. The tubules of S. lata are held in rows by links with a 140 Å periodicity along the tubule axis; bridges between rows of tubules are also seen but are not apparently periodic. Each tubule in S. ambloaxostylus shows an axial periodicity of 150 Å due to pairs of arms, one of which is always part of the intrarow link. Interrow bridges in this species run either from tubule to tubule or from tubule to the free arm, but as in S. lata they do not display an obvious axial periodicity. An average unit cell is presented for the axostyle of each species, and the relation of the intertubule links to the microtubule substructure is discussed.     

Spindle pole mechanics studied in mitotic asters: dynamic distribution of spindle forces through compliant linkages

During cell division, chromosomes must faithfully segregate to maintain genome integrity, and this dynamic mechanical process is driven by the macromolecular machinery of the mitotic spindle. However, little is known about spindle mechanics. For example, spindle microtubules are organized by numerous cross-linking proteins yet the mechanical properties of those cross-links remain unexplored. To examine the mechanical properties of microtubule cross-links we applied optical trapping to mitotic asters that form in mammalian mitotic extracts. These asters are foci of microtubules, motors, and microtubule-associated proteins that reflect many of the functional properties of spindle poles and represent centrosome-independent spindle-pole analogs. We observed bidirectional motor-driven microtubule movements, showing that microtubule linkages within asters are remarkably compliant (mean stiffness 0.025 pN/nm) and mediated by only a handful of cross-links. Depleting the motor Eg5 reduced this stiffness, indicating that Eg5 contributes to the mechanical properties of microtubule asters in a manner consistent with its localization to spindle poles in cells. We propose that compliant linkages among microtubules provide a mechanical architecture capable of accommodating microtubule movements and distributing force among microtubules without loss of pole integrity—a mechanical paradigm that may be important throughout the spindle.     

Microtubule alterations in cultured taiep rat oligodendrocytes lead to deficits in myelin membrane formation

The taiep rat is a myelin mutant in which hypomyelination and progressive demyelination of the CNS are accompanied by an accumulation of microtubules within oligodendrocytes. To investigate whether and how the myelin defects were caused by microtubule abnormalities, we have established a taiep oligodendrocyte culture system in which mutant cells produce abnormally high levels of tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins and exhibit myelin defects. The studies show that abnormal microtubule accumulation and tight microtubule bundles developed in the taiep oligodendrocytes, with a higher ratio of minus-end-distal to plus-end-distal microtubules in their processes. Initially, in culture, immature taiep oligodendrocytes which have higher levels of tubulin than controls extend roughly twice as much membrane sheet as controls. The membrane sheets of the mature taiep oligodendrocytes which display the microtubule accumulation, however, grew much less rapidly compared to controls. By the fifth day in culture, a majority of the taiep oligodendrocytes had ceased the expansion of their membrane sheets and in some cases the sheets retracted. The levels of the myelin proteins, proteolipid protein and myelin-associated glycoprotein, were also markedly diminished in the mature taiep oligodendrocytes. Treatment with the microtubule depolymerizing drug nocodazole prevented not only the accumulation of microtubules but also restored the normal distribution of proteolipid proteins within the taiep oligodendrocytes. These data demonstrate that myelin synthesis in the oligodendrocyte cultures relies on the formation of a normal microtubule array, and the microtubule abnormalities are directly responsible for the myelin deficit in the taiep oligodendrocytes.     

On the surface lattice of microtubules: helix starts, protofilament number, seam, and handedness

The tubulin monomers of brain microtubules reassembled in vitro are arranged on a 3-start helix, irrespective of whether the number of protofilaments is 13 or 14. The dimer packing is that of the B-lattice described for flagellar microtubules. This implies that the tubulin core of microtubules contains at least one helical discontinuity. Neither 5-start nor 8-start helices have a physical significance and thus cannot be implicated in models of microtubule elongation, but the structure is compatible with elongation of protofilaments by dimers or protofilamentous oligomers. The inner and outer surfaces of the microtubule wall can be visualized by propane jet freezing, freeze fracturing, and metal replication, at a resolution of at least 4 nm. The 3-start helix is left-handed, in contrast to a previous study based on negative staining and shadowing. The reasons for this discrepancy are discussed.     

Firm structural associations between migratory pigment granules and microtubules in crayfish retinula cells

The morphology of associations between mobile pigment granules and microtubules of the crayfish retinula cells was examined with transmission electron microscopy. Many pigment granules were found associated with microtubules through linkages of fuzzy appearance in thin sections. The linkages were revealed as discrete strands of variable shape in rotary-shadowed replicas of freeze-fractured and deep- etched specimens. The only feature of constant morphology among these connections consisted of 2-4-nm filaments projecting laterally from the microtubules. The firmness of the pigment granule-microtubule associations was judged by their ability to hold up during cell disruption procedures of increasing disaggregation effects in a low- Ca++ stabilization buffer. The results of these tests were inspected with scanning electron microscopy and with transmission electron microscopy of negatively stained preparations. Numerous pigment granules remained associated with a stable microtubule framework after the plasma membrane had been stripped away. Moreover, granule- microtubule attachments survived breakdown of this framework into free fascicles of microtubules. The pigment granules were associated with the free microtubules either individually or as clusters entangled in a fibrous material interwoven with 10-nm filaments. These findings attest that many pigment granules are bound to microtubules through linkages that constitute effective attachments. Further, it is demonstrated that a highly cohesive substance associates the pigment granules with one another. These conclusions are discussed in terms of a pigment transport mechanism in which a network of interconnected granules would establish firm transient interactions with a supporting skeleton of microtubules.     

BRIDGES BETWEEN MICROTUBULES

Bridges between microtubules have been studied with the electron microscope in the axostyle of Saccinobaculus and in various tubule systems of chicken testis, including the helix of tubules surrounding the elongating spermatid nucleus and the flagellum of the sperm tail. In addition to the previously described periodic bridges, evidence is presented that nonperiodic bridges exist between certain tubules. An analysis of axial spacing between adjacent nonperiodic bridges suggests that these structures are attached to periodic binding sites on the microtubule wall, but that not all the binding sites are filled. The bridges appear nonperiodic as a result of random occupancy of some fraction of the periodic sites. The distribution of these binding sites is related to the substructure of the microtubule wall as seen with negative staining and optical diffraction.     

An <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis> tubulin mutant with conditional root-skewing phenotype

Low doses of microtubule-interacting drugs cause wild-type Arabidopsis thaliana seedling roots to twist in a left-handed helical direction. We here report molecular characterization of an A. thaliana tubulin mutant whose roots twist in a right-handed direction and have shallow left-handed cortical microtubule arrays when challenged with low doses of microtubule drugs. In the absence of the drug, growth and development of the mutant was apparently normal. In this conditional twisting mutant, Cys213 of α-tubulin6 was exchanged with Tyr. The mutant tubulin was incorporated into the microtubule polymer with wild-type tubulins, and thus acted as a dominant-negative mutation. These results suggest that compromised microtubules in wild-type and mutant roots are qualitatively distinct and affect skewing direction differently.     

Tubulin hooks as probes for microtubule polarity: an analysis of the method and an evaluation of data on microtubule polarity in the mitotic spindle

The structural polarity of cellular microtubules can be visualized in situ by lysing cells in special buffers containing tubulin. Under these conditions, the tubulin polymerizes to form curved sheets which attach to the walls of the endogenous microtubules. When such decorated microtubules are cut in cross section and viewed in the electron microscope, they appear to bear hooks curving clockwise or counter- clockwise. The direction of hook curvature is defined by the orientation of the decorated microtubule and thus serves as a probe for microtubule polarity. In this paper we describe a way to analyze the relative frequencies of hooks of different curvatures so as to measure the fidelity of the relation between hook curvature and microtubule polarity. The assumptions of the method are tested and found to be valid to a reasonable accuracy. The correlation between hook curvature and microtubule orientation is shown to be at least 0.98 for the spindles of PtK cells and Haemanthus endosperm at all stages of division and at all places in the spindle. The correlation is shown to be valid for each hook that forms, so the polarity of those microtubules that bear multiple hooks is specified with even better certainty than 0.98. This property of hook decoration is used to reinvestigate the possibility that some of the microtubules of the kinetochore fiber might be oriented with their plus ends distal to the kinetochore (opposite to the direction previously shown to predominate). Close analysis fails to identify such oppositely oriented microtubules. The scoring of tubules bearing multiple hooks also shows that individual interzone fibers at anaphase are constructed from clusters of antiparallel microtubules. The method for estimating the correlation between hook decoration and microtubule polarity is shown to be applicable to many structures and circumstances, but we find that the hook decoration assay for microtubule polarity is not uniformly accurate. We suggest that future studies using hook decorations should employ the method of data analysis presented here to assess the accuracy of the results obtained.     

Analysis of the spatial organization of microtubule-associated proteins

We have developed microdensitometer-computer correlation techniques to analyze the arrangement of microtubule arms and bridges (i.e., microtubule-associated proteins [MAPs]). A microdensitometer was used to scan immediately adjacent to the wall of longitudinally sectioned microtubules in positive transparency electron micrographs. Signal enhancement procedures were applied to the digitized densitometer output to produce a binary sequence representing the apparent axial spacing of MAP projections. These enhanced records were analyzed in two ways. (a) Autocorrelograms were formed for each record and correlogram peaks from a group of scans were pooled to construct a peak frequency histogram. (b) Cross-correlation was used to optimize the match between each enhanced record and templates predicted by different models of MAP organization. Seven symmetrical superlattices were considered as well as single axial repeats. The analyses were repeated with randomly generated records to establish confidence levels. Using the above methods, we analyzed the intrarow bridges of the Saccinobaculus axostyle and the MAP2 projections associated with brain microtubules synthesized in vitro. We confirmed a strict 16-nm axial repeat for axostyle bridges. For 26 MAP2 records, the only significant match was to a 12-dimer superlattice model (P less than 0.002). However, we also found some axial distances between MAP2 projections which were compatible with the additional spacings predicted by a 6-dimer superlattice. Therefore, we propose that MAP2 projections are arranged in a "saturated 12-dimer, unsaturated 6-dimer" superlattice, which may be characteristic of a wide variety of MAPs.     

Torque generation of kinesin motors is governed by the stability of the neck domain

In long-range transport of cargo, prototypical kinesin-1 steps along a single protofilament on the microtubule, an astonishing behavior given the number of theoretically available binding sites on adjacent protofilaments. Using a laser trap assay, we analyzed the trajectories of several representatives from the kinesin-2 class on freely suspended microtubules. In stark contrast to kinesin-1, these motors display a wide range of left-handed spiraling around microtubules and thus generate torque during cargo transport. We provide direct evidence that kinesin's neck region determines the torque-generating properties. A model system based on kinesin-1 corroborates this result: disrupting the stability of the neck by inserting flexible peptide stretches resulted in pronounced left-handed spiraling. Mimicking neck stability by crosslinking significantly reduced the spiraling of the motor up to the point of protofilament tracking. Finally, we present a model that explains the physical basis of kinesin's spiraling around the microtubule.     

ISOLATION AND REACTIVATION OF THE AXOSTYLE : Evidence for a Dynein-like ATPase in the Axostyle

The contractile axostyle is a ribbon-shaped organelle present in certain species of flagellates found in the hindgut of wood eating insects. This organelle propagates an undulatory wave whose motion, like flagella and cilia, is related to microtubules. Unlike the axoneme of cilia and flagella, however, the axostyle is composed of singlet microtubules linked together in parallel rows. Axostyles were isolated from Cryptocercus gut protozoa with Triton X-100. Normal motility of the isolated axostyle could be restored with adenosine triphosphate (ATP); the specific conditions necessary for this reactivation were essentially identical with those reported for the reactivation of isolated flagella or whole sperm. ATPase activity of the isolated axostyle was comparable to the values reported for ciliary or flagellar axonemes. The axostyle was reasonably specific for ATP. Most of the proteins of the isolated axostyle comigrated with proteins of the ciliary axoneme on sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) polyacrylamide gels (i e. equivalent molecular weights). These included the following: the higher molecular weight component of dynein, tubulin, linkage protein (nexin), and various secondary proteins. Evidence for dynein in the axostyle is presented and a model proposed to explain how repeated propagated waves can be generated.