Noncanonical cell death programs in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans

Genetic studies of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans have uncovered four genes, egl-1 (BH3 only), ced-9 (Bcl-2 related), ced-4 (apoptosis protease activating factor-1), and ced-3 (caspase), which function in a linear pathway to promote developmental cell death in this organism. While this core pathway functions in many cells, recent studies suggest that additional regulators, acting on or in lieu of these core genes, can promote or inhibit the onset of cell death. Here, we discuss the evidence for these noncanonical mechanisms of C. elegans cell death control. We consider novel modes for regulating the core apoptosis genes, and describe a newly identified cell death pathway independent of all known C. elegans cell death genes. The existence of these noncanonical cell death programs suggests that organisms have evolved multiple ways to ensure appropriate cellular demise during development.     

Apaf1 and the apoptotic machinery

The molecular characterization of the Caenorhabditis elegans cell death genes has been crucial in revealing some of the biochemical mechanisms underlying apoptosis in all animals. Four C. elegans genes, egl-1, ced-9, ced-4 and ced-3 are required for all somatic programmed cell death to occur. This genetic network is highly conserved during evolution. The pro-death gene egl-1 and the anti-death gene ced-9 have structural and functional similarities to the vertebrate Bcl2 gene family. The killer gene ced-3 encodes a cystein-aspartate protease (caspase), which is the archetype of a family of conserved proteins known as effectors of apoptosis in mammals. Zou and collaborators1 reported the biochemical identification of an apoptotic protease activating factor (Apaf1), a human homolog of C. elegans CED-4, providing important clues to how CED-4 and its potential relatives could work. A number of proteins have been shown to interact with Apaf1 or to be determinant for its activity as an apoptotic adapter. The aim of this review is to provide an overview of the recent progress made in the field of developmental apoptosis by means of the murine Apaf1 targeted mutations. The central role of Apaf1 in the cell death machinery (apoptosome) and its involvement in different apoptotic pathways will also be discussed.     

Sculpturing digit shape by cell death

Physiological cell death is a key mechanism that ensures appropriate development and maintenance of tissues and organs in multicellular organisms. Most structures in the vertebrate embryo exhibit defined areas of cell death at precise stages of development. In this regard the areas of interdigital cell death during limb development provide a paradigmatic model of massive cell death with an evident morphogenetic role in digit morphogenesis. Physiological cell death has been proposed to occur by apoptosis, cellular phenomena genetically controlled to orchestrate cell suicide following two main pathways, cytochrome C liberation from the mitochondria or activation of death receptors. Such pathways converge in the activation of cysteine proteases known as caspases, which execute the cell death program, leading to typical morphologic changes within the cell, termed apoptosis. According to these findings it would be expected that caspases loss of function experiments could cause inhibition of interdigital cell death promoting syndactyly phenotypes. A syndactyly phenotype is characterized by absence of digit freeing during development that, when caused by absence of interdigital cell death, is accompanied by the persistence of an interdigital membrane. However this situation has not been reported in any of the KO mice or chicken loss of function experiments ever performed. Moreover histological analysis of dying cells within the interdigit reveals the synchronic occurrence of different types of cell death. All these findings are indicative of caspase alternative and/or complementary mechanisms responsible for physiological interdigital cell death. Characterization of alternative cell death pathways is required to explain vertebrate morphogenesis. Today there is great interest in cell death via autophagy, which could substitute or act synergistically to the apoptotic pathway. Here we discuss what is known about physiological cell death in the developing interdigital tissue of vertebrate embryos, paying special attention to the avian species.     

Analysis of programmed cell death in wheat endosperm reveals differences in endosperm development between cereals

Although maize endosperm undergoes programmed cell death during its development, it is not known whether this developmental feature is common to cereals or whether it arose inadvertently from the selection process that resulted in the enlarged endosperm of modern maize. Examination of wheat endosperm during its development revealed that this tissue undergoes a programmed cell death that shares features with the maize program but differs in some aspects of its execution. Cell death initiated and progressed stochastically in wheat endosperm in contrast to maize where cell death initiates within the upper central endosperm and expands outward. After a peak of ethylene production during early development, wheat endosperm DNA underwent internucleosomal fragmentation that was detectable from mid to late development. The developmental onset and progression of DNA degradation was regulated by the level of ethylene production and perception. These observations suggest that programmed cell death of the endosperm and regulation of this program by ethylene is not unique to maize but that differences in the execution of the program appear to exist among cereals.     

Caspase function in programmed cell death

The first proapoptotic caspase, CED-3, was cloned from Caenorhabditis elegans in 1993 and shown to be essential for the developmental death of all somatic cells. Following the discovery of CED-3, caspases have been cloned from several vertebrate and invertebrate species. As reviewed in other articles in this issue of Cell Death and Differentiation, many caspases function in nonapoptotic pathways. However, as is clear from the worm studies, the evolutionarily conserved role of caspases is to execute programmed cell death. In this article, I will specifically focus on caspases that function primarily in cell death execution. In particular, the physiological function of caspases in apoptosis is discussed using examples from the worm, fly and mammals.     

Caspases in developmental cell death

Caspases are a family of evolutionarily conserved cysteine proteases that constitute the effector arm of the apoptotic machinery. Studies in Caenorhabditis elegans, Drosophila melanogaster, and mouse point to evolutionarily conserved caspase function in developmentally programmed cell death in metazoans. Whereas in the nematode all developmental cell death is mediated by a single caspase, in Drosophila and the mouse some caspases appear to regulate cell death in a spatio-temporally restricted manner. This article reviews what we currently know about the roles of various caspases in the execution of developmentally programmed cell death and what may be expected from future research in this field.     

Early neural cell death: dying to become neurons

The importance of programmed cell death (PCD) during vertebrate development has been well established. During the development of the nervous system in particular, neurotrophic cell death in innervating neurons matches the number of neurons to the size of their target field. However, PCD also occurs during earlier stages of neural development, within populations of proliferating neural precursors and newly postmitotic neuroblasts, all of which are not yet fully differentiated. This review addresses early neural PCD, which is distinct from neurotrophic death in differentiated neurons. Although early neural PCD is observed in a range of organisms, from Caenorhabditis elegans to mouse, the role and the regulation of early neural PCD are not well understood. The regulation of early neural PCD can be inferred from the function of factors such as bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs), Wnts, fibroblast growth factors (FGFs), and Sonic Hedgehog (Shh), which regulate both early neural development and PCD occurring in other developmental processes. Cell number control, removal of damaged or misspecified cells (spatially or temporally), and selection are the proposed roles early neural PCDs play during neural development. Data from developmental PCD in C. elegans and Drosophila provide insights into the possible signaling pathways integrating PCD with other processes during early neural development and the roles they might play.     

Divergence from a dedicated cellular suicide mechanism: exploring the evolution of cell death

The developmental cell death in the nematode C. elegans is controlled by a simple and dedicated genetic program. This genetic program is evolutionarily conserved in higher organisms, including mammals. However, although mammalian homologs of C. elegans cell death gene products continue to regulate apoptosis, they are no longer dedicated regulators of cell death. On the other hand, multiple cellular noncell death-related mechanisms have been recruited to regulate cell death under different conditions. Such evidence suggests that evolution has led to an extensive integration of mammalian apoptosis machinery with multiple cellular physiological processes.     

Interdigital cell death can occur through a necrotic and caspase-independent pathway.

Programmed cell death in animals is usually associated with apoptotic morphology and requires caspase activation. Necrosis and caspase-independent cell death have been reported, but mostly in experimental conditions that lead some to question their existence it in vivo. Loss of interdigital cells in the mouse embryo, a paradigm of cell death during development [1], is known to include an apoptotic [2] and caspase-dependent [3] [4] mechanism. Here, we report that, when caspase activity was inhibited using drugs or when apoptosis was prevented genetically (using Hammertoe mutant mice, or mice homozygous for a mutation in the gene encoding APAF-1, a caspase-activating adaptor protein), interdigital cell death still occurred. This cell death was negative for the terminal-deoxynucleotidyl-mediated dUTP nick end-labelling (TUNEL) assay and there was no overall cell condensation. At the electron microscopy level, peculiar 'mottled' chromatin alterations and marked mitochondrial and membrane lesions, suggestive of classical necrotic cell death, were observed with no detectable phagocytosis and no local inflammatory response. Thus, in this developmental context, although caspase activity confers cell death with an apoptotic morphotype, in the absence of caspase activity an underlying mechanism independent of known caspases can also confer cell death, but with a necrotic morphotype. This cell death can go undetected when using apoptosis-specific methodology, and cannot be blocked by agents that act on caspases.     

Proteases for cell suicide: functions and regulation of caspases.

Caspases are a large family of evolutionarily conserved proteases found from Caenorhabditis elegans to humans. Although the first caspase was identified as a processing enzyme for interleukin-1beta, genetic and biochemical data have converged to reveal that many caspases are key mediators of apoptosis, the intrinsic cell suicide program essential for development and tissue homeostasis. Each caspase is a cysteine aspartase; it employs a nucleophilic cysteine in its active site to cleave aspartic acid peptide bonds within proteins. Caspases are synthesized as inactive precursors termed procaspases; proteolytic processing of procaspase generates the tetrameric active caspase enzyme, composed of two repeating heterotypic subunits. Based on kinetic data, substrate specificity, and procaspase structure, caspases have been conceptually divided into initiators and effectors. Initiator caspases activate effector caspases in response to specific cell death signals, and effector caspases cleave various cellular proteins to trigger apoptosis. Adapter protein-mediated oligomerization of procaspases is now recognized as a universal mechanism of initiator caspase activation and underlies the control of both cell surface death receptor and mitochondrial cytochrome c-Apaf-1 apoptosis pathways. Caspase substrates have bene identified that induce each of the classic features of apoptosis, including membrane blebbing, cell body shrinkage, and DNA fragmentation. Mice deficient for caspase genes have highlighted tissue- and signal-specific pathways for apoptosis and demonstrated an independent function for caspase-1 and -11 in cytokine processing. Dysregulation of caspases features prominently in many human diseases, including cancer, autoimmunity, and neurodegenerative disorders, and increasing evidence shows that altering caspase activity can confer therapeutic benefits.     

Morphology of mitochondria during apoptosis: worms-to-beetles in worms

Although mitochondria are crucial for most pathways of mammalian cell apoptosis, evidence for their role in classic invertebrate models of programmed cell death has been frustratingly scant. New work showing that inhibition of mitochondrial fragmentation during C. elegans development inhibits programmed cell death bridges this gap and should advance a more detailed understanding of the role of mitochondria in caspase activation.     

Zebrafish genetics and vertebrate heart formation

Forward-genetic analyses in Drosophila and Caenorhabditis elegans have given us unprecedented insights into many developmental mechanisms. To study the formation of organs that contain cell types and structures not present in invertebrates, a vertebrate model system amenable to forward genetics would be very useful. Recent work shows that a newly initiated genetic approach in zebrafish is already making significant contributions to understanding the development of the vertebrate heart, an organ that contains several vertebrate-specific features. These and other studies point to the utility of the zebrafish system for studying a wide range of vertebrate-specific processes.     

Men are but worms: neuronal cell death in C elegans and vertebrates

Awarding the 2002 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine to Sydney Brenner, H Robert Horvitz, and John E Sulston for 'their discoveries concerning the genetic regulation of organ development and programmed cell death (PCD)' highlights the significant contribution that the study of experimental organisms, such as the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, has made to our understanding of human physiology and pathophysiology. Their studies of lineage determination in worms established the 'central dogma' of apoptosis: The BH3-only protein EGL-1 is induced in cells destined to die, interacts with the BCL-2-like inhibitor CED-9, displacing the adaptor CED-4, which then promotes activation of the caspase CED-3. The vast majority of cells undergoing PCD during development in C. elegans, as in vertebrates, are neurons. Accordingly, the genetic regulation of apoptosis is strikingly similar in nematode and vertebrate neurons. This review summarizes these similarities - and the important differences - in the molecular mechanisms responsible for neuronal PCD in C. elegans and vertebrates, and examines the implications that our understanding of physiological neuronal apoptosis may have for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic human neurodegenerative disorders.     

Cell proliferation and growth in C. elegans.

The cell division and differentiation events that occur during the development of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans are nearly identical between different individuals, a feature that distinguishes this organism from larger and more complex metazoans, such as humans and Drosophila. In view of this discrepancy, it might be expected that the regulation of cell growth, division and differentiation in C. elegans would involve mechanisms separate from those utilized in larger animals. However, the results of recent genetic, molecular and cellular studies indicate that C. elegans employs an arsenal of developmental regulatory mechanisms quite similar to those wielded by its arthropod and vertebrate relatives. Thus, the nematode system is providing both novel and complementary insights into the general problem of how growth and patterning events are integrated in development. This review offers a general perspective on the regulation of cell division and growth in C. elegans, emphasizing recent studies of these crucial aspects of development.     

Genetic control of programmed cell death in the nematode C. elegans

The wild-type functions of the genes ced-3 and ced-4 are required for the initiation of programmed cell deaths in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. The reduction or loss of ced-3 or ced-4 function results in a transformation in the fates of cells that normally die; in ced-3 or ced-4 mutants, such cells instead survive and differentiate, adopting fates that in the wild type and associated with other cells. ced-3 and ced-4 mutants appear grossly normal in morphology and behavior, indicating that programmed cell death is not an essential aspect of nematode development. The genes ced-3 and ced-4 define the first known step of a developmental pathway for programmed cell death, suggesting that these genes may be involved in determining which cells die during C. elegans development.     

Death without caspases, caspases without death

Apoptosis is a conserved cell-death process displaying characteristic morphological and molecular changes including activation of caspase proteases. Recent work challenges the accepted roles of these proteases. New investigations in mice and the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans suggest that there could be caspase-independent pathways leading to cell death. In addition, another type of cell death displaying autophagic features might depend on caspases. Recent studies also indicate that caspase activation does not always lead to cell death and, instead, might be important for cell differentiation. Here, we review recent evidence for both the expanded roles of caspases and the existence of caspase-independent cell-death processes. We suggest that cellular context plays an important role in defining the consequences of caspase activation.     

Shaping organisms with apoptosis

Programmed cell death is an important process during development that serves to remove superfluous cells and tissues, such as larval organs during metamorphosis, supernumerary cells during nervous system development, muscle patterning and cardiac morphogenesis. Different kinds of cell death have been observed and were originally classified based on distinct morphological features: (1) type I programmed cell death (PCD) or apoptosis is recognized by cell rounding, DNA fragmentation, externalization of phosphatidyl serine, caspase activation and the absence of inflammatory reaction, (2) type II PCD or autophagy is characterized by the presence of large vacuoles and the fact that cells can recover until very late in the process and (3) necrosis is associated with an uncontrolled release of the intracellular content after cell swelling and rupture of the membrane, which commonly induces an inflammatory response. In this review, we will focus exclusively on developmental cell death by apoptosis and its role in tissue remodeling.     

OSM-11 facilitates LIN-12 Notch signaling during Caenorhabditis elegans vulval development

Notch signaling is critical for cell fate decisions during development. Caenorhabditis elegans and vertebrate Notch ligands are more diverse than classical Drosophila Notch ligands, suggesting possible functional complexities. Here, we describe a developmental role in Notch signaling for OSM-11, which has been previously implicated in defecation and osmotic resistance in C. elegans. We find that complete loss of OSM-11 causes defects in vulval precursor cell (VPC) fate specification during vulval development consistent with decreased Notch signaling. OSM-11 is a secreted, diffusible protein that, like previously described C. elegans Delta, Serrate, and LAG-2 (DSL) ligands, can interact with the lineage defective-12 (LIN-12) Notch receptor extracellular domain. Additionally, OSM-11 and similar C. elegans proteins share a common motif with Notch ligands from other species in a sequence defined here as the Delta and OSM-11 (DOS) motif. osm-11 loss-of-function defects in vulval development are exacerbated by loss of other DOS-motif genes or by loss of the Notch ligand DSL-1, suggesting that DOS-motif and DSL proteins act together to activate Notch signaling in vivo. The mammalian DOS-motif protein Deltalike1 (DLK1) can substitute for OSM-11 in C. elegans development, suggesting that DOS-motif function is conserved across species. We hypothesize that C. elegans OSM-11 and homologous proteins act as coactivators for Notch receptors, allowing precise regulation of Notch receptor signaling in developmental programs in both vertebrates and invertebrates.