EU Drinking Water Directive reference methods for enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli compared with alternative methods

AIMS: The reference methods for enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli as stated in the European Drinking Water Directive were compared with alternative methods. METHODS AND RESULTS: Laboratories used the reference method on Lactose TTC agar (LTTC), the Colilert/18 system, Laurysulphate Agar (LSA), Chromocult Coliform Agar and the E. coli Direct Plating (DP) method. They enumerated more total coliforms on LTTC than on LSA. CONCLUSIONS: LTTC is suitable for analysis of very clean water samples only, due to heavy background growth. Colilert/18 is a good alternative but it enumerates a broader group of total coliforms, resulting in higher counts. The DP method appeared to be the best choice for enumeration of E. coli because Colilert/18 produces lower counts and false-negative results. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study shows the limitations of the EU reference method on LTTC due to lack of selectivity and suggests alternative methods for the enumeration of total coliforms and E. coli.     

Failure of the most-probable-number technique to detect coliforms in drinking water and raw water supplies.

A procedure was developed to detect false-negative reactions (interference) in the standard most-probable-number (S-MPN) technique for coliform enumeration of untreated surface water and potable water supplies. This modified MPN (M-MPN) procedure allowed a quantitative assessment of the interference with coliform detection in untreated surface water and potable water supplies. Coliform interference was found to occur in the presumptive, confirmed, and completed tests of the S-MPN technique. When coliforms were present, interference with their detection occurred in over 80% of the samples. The inferior nature of the S-MPN was revealed by the 100% increase in the incidence of completed coliform-positive drinking water samples obtained with the M-MPN technique. The M-MPN procedure was also superior to the standard membrane filter technique. Eight different species of coliforms were recovered from false-negative tests, including Citrobacter, Enterobacter, Klebsiella, and Escherichia coli (in decreasing order of occurrence). The use of standard MPN techniques for monitoring potable water supplies may lead to a false security that the drinking water supply is potable, i.e., free from indicator bacteria.     

Assessment of three indigenous South African herbivores as potential reservoirs and vectors of antibiotic-resistant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis>

Due to limited data available on the presence of antibiotic-resistant (ABR) bacteria in faeces of wild herbivores in South Africa, this study analysed resistance patterns for Escherichia coli isolates from wildebeest, zebra and giraffe in addition to pet and farm pig faeces. Total and faecal coliforms and E. coli were quantified in faecal matter using a most probable number (MPN) guideline procedure. Antibiotic resistance profiles against 12 selected antibiotics representing seven classes were determined for 30 randomly selected E. coli isolates from each animal using the European Committee on Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing (EUCAST) disk diffusion procedure. While log₁₀ MPN values per gram of animal faeces for total/faecal coliforms ranged from 4.51/4.11 to 5.70/5.50, the E. coli MPN values were in a range of 3.43–5.14. The proportion of ABR E. coli isolates ranged from 43% (giraffe) to 93% (zebra). About 47% of E. coli isolates from zebra faeces were categorized as multidrug-resistant (MDR), while for wildebeest and giraffe, no MDR isolates were detected. In comparison, 10% of E. coli isolates from pet pig and about 7% from farm pig faeces were categorized as MDR. Although most MDR isolates were resistant to at least one β-lactam antibiotic, only one MDR isolate from farm pig faeces was resistant to both norfloxacin and ciprofloxacin, the two fluoroquinolones tested. However, no resistance was detected to the tested carbapenems and tigecycline. The results of this study indicate that indigenous South African herbivores may serve as potential reservoirs and vectors for the dissemination of ABR E. coli strains.     

Evaluation of a new medium for the enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in Japanese surface waters

Aim: A new medium, EC‐Blue‐10, containing chromogenic and fluorogenic substrates, KNO₃ and sodium pyruvate has been developed for the rapid simultaneous detection and enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in water. Methods and Results:  Two evaluations of EC‐Blue‐10 were carried out. Firstly, EC‐Blue‐10 was compared with Colilert‐MPN for 96 water samples using MPN for total coliforms and E. coli. Secondly, the detection of coliforms and E. coli were compared using 2400 tubes of EC‐Blue‐10 and Colilert‐MPN. The regression coefficients between EC‐Blue‐10 and Colilert‐MPN for total coliforms and E. coli were 0·91 and 0·89, respectively. For the detection results, the Cohen’s kappa values between the two media were 0·79 for coliforms and 0·72 for E. coli. Conclusions: EC‐Blue‐10 is almost same as Colilert‐MPN for the detection of coliforms and E. coli in surface waters. Further evaluation for EC‐Blue‐10 is needed to verify in different geographical areas. Significance and Impact of the Study: EC‐Blue‐10 is useful method for the rapid and simultaneous detection of total coliforms and E. coli in water sample.     

Analytical limits of four β-glucuronidase and β-galactosidase-based commercial culture methods used to detect Escherichia coli and total coliforms

Colilert^® (Colilert), Readycult^® Coliforms 100 (Readycult), Chromocult^® Coliform agar ES (Chromocult), and MI agar (MI) are β-galactosidase and β-glucuronidase-based commercial culture methods used to assess water quality. Their analytical performance, in terms of their respective ability to detect different strains of Escherichia coli and total coliforms, had never been systematically compared with pure cultures. Here, their ability to detect β-glucuronidase production from E. coli isolates was evaluated by using 74 E. coli strains of different geographic origins and serotypes encountered in fecal and environmental settings. Their ability to detect β-galactosidase production was studied by testing the 74 E. coli strains as well as 33 reference and environmental non-E. coli total coliform strains. Chromocult, MI, Readycult, and Colilert detected β-glucuronidase production from respectively 79.9, 79.9, 81.1, and 51.4% of the 74 E. coli strains tested. These 4 methods detected β-galactosidase production from respectively 85.1, 73.8, 84.1, and 84.1% of the total coliform strains tested. The results of the present study suggest that Colilert is the weakest method tested to detect β-glucuronidase production and MI the weakest to detect β-galactosidase production. Furthermore, the high level of false-negative results for E. coli recognition obtained by all four methods suggests that they may not be appropriate for identification of presumptive E. coli strains.     

A simple and cost-effective method for the quantification of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in potable water

In this study, a new simple and cost-effective method for the study of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in potable water, combining the use of lactose TTC agar and TBX agar, was developed and compared with methods using Chromocult agar and coli ID. The statistical analysis showed no significant difference and a good correlation (R(2)) between the three methods.     

Prevalence and antibiotic resistance of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis> in tropical seafood

Summary The occurrence and antibiotic resistance of Escherichia coli in tropical seafood was studied. A 3-tube MPN method was used for determining the level of faecal contamination of fresh and processed seafood. Of the 188 samples tested which included finfish, shellfish, water and ice, 155 were positive for the presence of faecal coliforms following incubation at 44.5 °C. However, E. coli was isolated from only 47% of the samples positive for faecal coliforms. The antibiotic resistance of 116 strains isolated from seafood was tested using 14 different antibiotics including ampicillin, cephalothin, chloramphenicol, ciprofloxacin, gentamycin, nalidixic acid, streptomycin and vancomycin. Seven strains were resistant to more than five antibiotics of which one was resistant to eight antibiotics. The multiple drug resistant strains harboured plasmids of varying sizes. Antibiotic susceptibility studies revealed that seafood from India contains multiple antibiotic resistant strains of E. coli which may serve as a reservoir for antibiotic resistance genes in the aquatic environment. All the strains used in this study did not harbour any virulence genes commonly associated with pathogenic E. coli, when tested by polymerase chain reaction (PCR).     

Investigation of human sewage pollution and pathogen analysis at Florida Gulf coast beaches

Aims: Water quality at two Florida beaches was compared using faecal indicator bacteria measurements, microbial source tracking (MST) methods for detecting human source pollution and the assessment of pathogen presence. These values were also compared before and after remediation of wastewater infrastructure at one beach. Methods and Results: Faecal coliforms, Escherichia coli and enterococci were enumerated in estuarine water and sediment samples. PCR assays for the human‐associated esp gene of Enterococcus faecium and human polyomaviruses (HPyVs) were used to detect human sewage. Culturable Salmonella and enteric viruses were also analysed. MST identified human sewage contamination at one beach, leading to repair of a sewer main and relocation of portable restrooms. Exceedances of Florida recreational water regulatory standards were significantly reduced after remediation (by 52% for faecal coliforms and 39% for enterococci), and the frequency of detection of MST markers decreased. Coxsackie virus B4 and HPyVs were codetected following a major sewage spill, but Salmonella was not detected during the study. Conclusions: These data indicate that infrastructure remediation significantly reduced pollution from human sewage at the impacted beach. Significance and Impact of the Study: A comprehensive microbial water quality study that can identify contamination sources through the use of MST markers and close collaboration with local/and state agencies can result in tangible actions to improve recreational water quality and safety.     

Enumeration of Escherichia coli and coliforms in surface water by multiple tube fermentation and membrane filter methods

The current investigation was carried out in order to compare directly the multiple tube fermentation method (MTF), using standard procedures (lactose broth, LB) and the Colilert reagent, with the membrane filter method (MF) using Les Endo agar (LEA), m-faecal coliform agar (mFCA) and chromogenic coliform agar (CCA), for recovery of coliforms and Escherichia coli in 80 surface water samples. Total coliforms were isolated from 100% of samples by all methodologies. Faecal coliforms/E. coli were detected in 100% of samples by MTF methods, but only in 75.5% by MF-mFCA and in 86.2% by MF-CCA. Even if MTF-LB counts were consistently higher, the Colilert reagent accurately determined total coliforms and E. coli levels within 24 h with no additional confirmatory tests. Therefore, it could be a powerful tool for rapidly assessing possible faecal contamination and a suitable alternative to the traditional MTF and MF techniques utilized for coliform detection.     

Higher prevalence of Alternaria spp. in marine and river waters than in potable samples

Alternaria species have been recognized as important cause of allergic diseases and are considered opportunistic pathogens for immunocompromised individuals. In order to assess the contribution of waters to the spread of Alternaria, we examined 390 water samples of various origin for the presence of these microorganisms in parallel with the standard pollution indicator bacteria, i.e. total coliforms, faecal coliforms and enterococci. Alternaria spp. were isolated from 42 out of 196 (21.4%) marine water samples, from 13 out of 68 (19.1%) river samples, whereas out of 126 potable waters only two (1.6%) were found positive. The incidence of Alternaria was significantly higher (p < 0.001) in marine and river samples than in potable waters. The mean values of the colony-forming units of the pollution indicator bacteria did not significantly differ between Alternaria-positive and Alternaria-negative samples.     

Quantitative determination of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in marine waters with chromogenic and fluorogenic media

This study compared the performance of LMX(R) broth (LMX), Chromocult Coliform(R) agar (CC) and Chromocult Coliform agar plus cefsulodin (10 microg ml-1) (CC-CFS), with standard methods multiple tube fermentation (MTF), for the enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli from marine recreational waters. LMX and CC are two media designed to concurrently detect total coliform (TC) bacteria and E. coli by the specific action of beta-galactosidase (total coliforms) and beta-glucuronidase (E. coli). Overall results for the TC test showed that LMX, CC and MTF recovered 2.63, 1.95 and 1.90 times as many TCs as CC-CFS, respectively. Data from the multiple range test showed significant differences (P < 0.05) between TC counts on CC-CFS and LMX. The traditional MTF was less sensitive for E. coli enumeration. However, there was no statistically significant differences between LMX, CC, CC-CFS and the MTF method for E. coli enumeration. Background interference was reduced on CC-CFS and the counts obtained reflected more accurately the number of TCs. Therefore, the contribution of beta-galactosidase positive, non coliform bacteria (Aeromonas spp. and Vibrio spp.) to TC counts should not be neglected.     

Evaluation of Chromocult enterococci agar for the isolation and selective enumeration of Enterococcus spp. in broilers

AIMS: To investigate the productivity and specificity of a new chromogenic enterococci selective medium (Chromocult enterococci agar) recently developed by Merck. METHODS AND RESULTS: The study was carried out comparing Chromocult enterococci agar with MRS agar (Merck), a basal lactic acid bacteria medium in current use. A total of 216 faecal samples from poultry were collected and enterococci populations were counted. Likewise, 100 randomly selected strains were identified for each medium. The differences found between the two media were analysed and discussed. CONCLUSIONS: A good sensitivity of 98% was obtained for Chromocult agar and all false-positive isolates obtained were identified as Leuconostoc spp. However significant differences (P<0.01) were obtained between the enterococci species isolation rates identified from these two media, suggesting the poor growth of some species in Chromocult enterococci agar. Viable counts of Enterococcus spp. obtained with MRS agar were significantly higher than those obtained with Chromocult enterococci agar. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The use of chromogenic media for microbiological analysis is increasing. Independent studies are important to evaluate newly developed chromogenic media.     

Antibiotic resistance of bacteria in raw and biologically treated sewage and in groundwater below leaking sewers

More than 750 isolates of faecal coliforms (>200 strains), enterococci (>200 strains) and pseudomonads (>340 strains) from three wastewater treatment plants (WTPs) and from four groundwater wells in the vicinity of leaking sewers were tested for resistance against 14 antibiotics. Most, or at least some, strains of the three bacterial groups, isolated from raw or treated sewage of the three WTPs, were resistant against penicillin G, ampicillin, vancomycin, erythromycin, triple sulfa and trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole (SXT). Only a few strains of pseudomonads or faecal coliforms were resistant against some of the other tested antibiotics. The antibiotic resistances of pseudomonads, faecal coliforms and enterococci from groundwater varied to a higher extent. In contrast to the faecal coliforms and enterococci, most pseudomonads from all groundwater samples, including those from non-polluted groundwater, were additionally resistant against chloramphenicol and SXT. Pseudomonads from sewage and groundwater had more multiple antibiotic resistances than the faecal coliforms or the enterococci, and many pseudomonads from groundwater were resistant to more antibiotics than those from sewage. The pseudomonads from non-polluted groundwater were the most resistant isolates of all. The few surviving faecal coliforms in groundwater seemed to gain multiple antibiotic resistances, whereas the enterococci lost antibiotic resistances. Pseudomonads, and presumably, other autochthonous soil or groundwater bacteria, such as antibiotic-producing Actinomyces sp., seem to contribute significantly to the gene pool for acquisition of resistances against antibiotics in these environments.     

Evaluation of Chromocult coliform agar for the detection and enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae from faecal samples from healthy subjects

The purpose of this study was to examine the use of Chromocult agar medium for isolation and enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae from human faecal samples, to compare it to MacConkey agar and to evaluate its usefulness as a possible alternative selective medium in human faecal studies. The medium was shown to be effective in identifying Escherichia coli and coliforms in faeces without the need for extensive accompanying biochemical tests for confirmation of identity. A positive correlation (r=0.86) was found between the recovery of Enterobacteriaceae on the two media, and no significant difference (P>0.05) between overall mean bacterial counts for the whole study group or at different intervals of faecal collection were observed. Chromocult agar is an effective replacement for MacConkey agar in human faecal studies and has the advantage of differentiating E. coli from other coliforms.     

Evaluation of recovery methods to detect faecal streptococci in polluted waters

AIMS: This paper compares the faecal streptococci count on 25 samples of polluted waters obtained with three techniques: most probable number (MPN), membrane filtration (MF) and pour plate (PP) methods. Although the PP method is a simple technique, familiar to water bacteriologists, it is not recommended in the international methods. METHODS AND RESULTS: For the MPN method, azide dextrose broth and ethyl violet azide broth were employed. For the MF technique, Millipore filters were placed onto azide maltose agar (KF agar), while for the PP method, 1 ml of a decimal water dilution was added to (Kennel Faecal) KF medium. Regression analysis and Friedman's ANOVA were performed to determine the relationship between faecal streptococci counts obtained with the three techniques. Statistical analysis of the results showed that the MPN, MF and PP techniques were equally valid with respect to faecal streptococci enumeration in polluted waters. CONCLUSION: Since the PP method was found to be as good as the other techniques, it may be preferred in polluted waters. It is more economical in terms of both time and materials than the MPN count, and it is as accurate as the MF count. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study indicates that the PP method, although not recommended internationally, is a reliable alternative to MF and MPN.     

False‐negative β‐d‐glucuronidase reactions in membrane lactose glucuronide agar medium used for the simultaneous detection of coliforms and Escherichia coli from water

Aims: Testing for β‐d ‐glucuronidase activity has become the basis of many methods for the detection of Escherichia coli in both food and water. Used in combination with tests for the presence of β‐d ‐glucuronidase, these tests offer a simple method for simultaneously detecting coliforms and E. coli. The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of several different procedures in detecting β‐d ‐glucuronidase activity and hence in detecting E. coli. Methods and Results: The ability of membrane lactose glucuronide agar (MLGA), Colilert‐18^®, MI agar, Colitag^® and Chromocult agar to detect β‐d ‐glucuronidase activity was tested with over 1000 isolates of E. coli recovered from naturally contaminated water samples. Four of the media gave very similar results but MLGA failed to detect glucuronidase activity in 15·6% of the cultures tested. Conclusions: MLGA had very poor sensitivity for the detection of β‐d ‐glucuronidase activity in strains of E. coli isolated from naturally contaminated water. This is probably because of the fact that β‐d ‐glucuronidase activity is pH‐sensitive and that acid is formed by E. coli during fermentation of lactose in MLGA. Significance and Impact of the Study: The detection of E. coli in drinking water is the primary test used to establish faecal contamination. The poor sensitivity of MLGA in detecting β‐d ‐glucuronidase activity suggests that this medium and others containing high concentrations of fermentable carbohydrate should not be used for the detection of E. coli.     

Survival of Escherichia coli O157:H7 applied to cantaloupes and the effectiveness of chlorinated water and lactic acid as disinfectants

Initial survey of four packinghouses indicated that bacterial and fungal populations on the surface of cantaloupes were significantly reduced by sanitizing procedures particularly on faecal coliforms. In this study, several combinations of disinfectants were tested in an attempt to obtain a more effective antimicrobial activity on aerobic bacteria, fungi and total coliforms. The efficacy of aqueous chlorine (200 mg l^–1) and lactic acid (1.5%) on inactivation of inoculated Escherichia coli O157:H7 on cantaloupe surfaces was investigated using different temperatures (25 and 35 °C) and immersion times (1 and 10 min). Maximal log reductions were achieved with both sanitizing agents when the initial bacterial population of E. coli was 7.42 log c.f.u. cm^–2. A highly significant 7.2 log reduction (P < 0.01) was obtained with a solution of lactic acid with and without Tergitol (0.3%) surfactant when cantaloupes were immersed for 10 min regardless of the temperature of the solution. Although the sanitizers caused substantial mortality, some bacterial cells remained attached at relatively low numbers on the fruit surface. The development of sanitizers more efficacious than chlorine for total elimination of this pathogen from the surface of cantaloupes is needed.     

The relationships between salmonellas and faecal indicator concentrations in two pools in the Australian wet/dry tropics

S.A. TOWNSEND. 1992. The relationships between total coliform, faecal coliform, enterococci and salmonella concentrations were investigated at Berry and Howard Pools in the Australian wet/dry tropics. Both pools have catchments with minimal human activity and no major point source of faecal pollution. Forty-five indicator and salmonella enumerations were made from each pool over a 1 year period. Salmonellas were isolated from 69% and 96% of samples collected from Howard and Berry Pools respectively, the maximum (MPN) concentration was 110/100 ml. Native fauna were the primary salmonella source. Spearman rank correlations between indicator organisms and salmonella at Howard Pool were significant at the 5% level and approximated 0.6. At Berry Pool, total coliform and enterococci Spearman rank correlations with salmonella were also statistically significant, approximating 0.3; faecal coliforms and salmonella rankings, however, were unrelated. The higher correlation coefficients at Howard Pool were attributed to its small catchment (4 km²) and the more recent nature of faecal contamination compared with Berry Pool which has a catchment of 130 km². The results highlight the spatial variability of the indicator/pathogen numerical relationship. Total coliform and enterococci counts, as indicators of faecal pollution, were similar and more consistent than faecal coliforms.     

Effect of noncoliforms on coliform detection in potable groundwater: improved recovery with an anaerobic membrane filter technique

A total of 529 well and distribution potable water samples were analyzed for total coliforms by the most-probable-number and membrane filter (MF) techniques. Standard plate count bacteria and MF noncoliform bacteria were also enumerated. Frequency of coliform detection, turbidity in most-probable-number tubes, and extensive overgrowth by noncoliforms on MF filters were directly proportional to standard plate counts. Recovery of coliforms was greatest by the MF method at low (less than 100 CFU/ml) standard plate count densities and better by the most-probable-number method (confirming gas and turbid tube) at high (greater than 500 CFU/ml) standard plate count densities. In the latter case, overgrowth by noncoliforms on MF filters suppressed sheen development and, in turn, masked coliform detection. Of 341 atypical (no sheen) MF colonies verified by parallel inoculation of lauryl sulfate broth and billiant green-bile broth, 156 were aerogenic in the latter medium. Of atypical isolates, 84% were identified as either Citrobacter or Enterobacter species. A 4.3-fold reduction in numbers of overgrown MF filters and an 2.2-fold increase in numbers of coliforms recovered from 127 water samples was accomplished by anaerobic incubation of MF cultures. This anaerobic modification of the standard MF technique significantly reduced overgrowth and enhanced recovery of coliforms from potable groundwater. This technique is simple, cost effective, and suitable for monitoring of untreated ground water common to some small water systems and private water supplies.