A new experimental approach for the study of cardiopulmonary physiology during early development

In this report, an experimental approach and newly designed apparatus for liquid ventilation of preterm animals are described. Findings of age-related changes in cardiopulmonary function of this animal preparation are presented. Thirty-one lambs, 102-137 days gestation (term 147 +/- 3 days), were studied. The carotid artery, jugular vein, and trachea of the exteriorized fetus were cannulated under local anesthesia. Immediately after cesarean section delivery, ventilation commenced; warmed (39 degrees C) and oxygenated (PIO2 greater than 500 Torr) liquid fluorocarbon (RIMAR 101) was delivered to the lung by a mechanically assisted liquid ventilation system. Skeletal muscle paralysis, low-dose exogenous buffering, and thermal support were maintained during the 3-h experiment. Pulmonary gas exchange, acid-base status, and cardiopulmonary and metabolic function were assessed. By utilizing these techniques, effective arterial oxygenation, CO2 elimination, acid-base status, and cardiovascular stability were supported independent of gestational age. The results demonstrate a developmental increase in specific lung compliance and mean arterial pressure and decrease in heart rate and systemic O2 consumption per kilogram with advancing gestational age. These findings demonstrate that liquid ventilation negates the dependency of effective pulmonary gas exchange on surfactant development, thereby extending the limits of viability of the immature extrauterine lamb. As such this new experimental approach is useful for the study of physiological development over an age range previously limited to fetal animal preparations and, therefore, may provide insight regarding adaptation of the premature to the extrauterine environment.     

Assessment of inhibited alveolar‐capillary membrane structural development and function in bronchopulmonary dysplasia

Bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) is a chronic lung disease of extreme prematurity and is defined clinically by dependence on supplemental oxygen due to impaired gas exchange. Optimal gas exchange is dependent on the development of a sufficient surface area for diffusion. In the mammalian lung, rapid acquisition of distal lung surface area is accomplished in neonatal and early adult life by means of vascularization and secondary septation of distal lung airspaces. Extreme preterm birth interrupts secondary septation and pulmonary capillary development and ultimately reduces the efficiency of the alveolar‐capillary membrane. Although pulmonary health in BPD infants rapidly improves over the first few years, persistent alveolar‐capillary membrane dysfunction continues into adolescence and adulthood. Preventative therapies have been largely ineffective, and therapies aimed at promoting normal development of the air‐blood barrier in infants with established BPD remain largely unexplored. The purpose of this review will be: (1) to summarize the histological evidence of aberrant alveolar‐capillary membrane development associated with extreme preterm birth and BPD, (2) to review the clinical evidence assessing the long‐term impact of BPD on alveolar‐capillary membrane function, and (3) to discuss the need to develop and incorporate direct measurements of functional gas exchange into clinically relevant animal models of inhibited alveolar development. Birth Defects Research (Part A) 100:168–179, 2014. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Comparison of gas and liquid ventilation: clinical, physiological, and histological correlates.

To differentiate the effects of gas and liquid ventilation on cardiopulmonary function during early development, we compared the clinical, physiological, and histological profiles of gas- and liquid-ventilated preterm lambs (n = 16; 108-116 days gestation). Immediately after cesarean section delivery, ventilation commenced using gas delivered by a volume ventilator (n = 9) or liquid perfluorochemical (n = 7) delivered by a mechanically assisted liquid ventilation system. Pulmonary gas exchange, acid-base status, vital signs, and respiratory compliance were assessed during the 3-h protocol; sections of the lungs were obtained for histological analyses when the animals were killed. Six of nine gas-ventilated lambs expired from respiratory failure before 3 h, with the remaining animals experiencing severe respiratory insufficiency, pneumothoraces, and cardiovascular deterioration. Six of seven liquid-ventilated lambs survived with good gas exchange and cardiovascular stability and without fluorothorax; one experienced ventricular fibrillation before 1 h and expired despite pulmonary stability. Respiratory compliance was significantly greater in the liquid- than in the gas-ventilated lambs. Histological analyses of gas-ventilated lungs demonstrated nonhomogeneous lung expansion, with thick-walled gas exchange spaces containing proteinaceous exudate, hemorrhage, and hyaline membranes. In contrast, liquid-ventilated lungs appeared clear, with thin-walled and uniformly expanded gas exchange spaces that were free of hyaline membranes and luminal debris. Morphometric analyses demonstrated that surface area and gas exchange index were greater in the liquid- than in the gas-ventilated lambs. These results indicate that elimination of surface active forces by liquid ventilation during early development provides more effective gas exchange with less barotrauma compared with gas ventilation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Aberrant signaling pathways of the lung mesenchyme and their contributions to the pathogenesis of bronchopulmonary dysplasia

Bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) is a chronic lung disease in infants born extremely preterm, typically before 28 weeks' gestation, characterized by a prolonged need for supplemental oxygen or positive pressure ventilation beyond 36 weeks postmenstrual age. The limited number of autopsy samples available from infants with BPD in the postsurfactant era has revealed a reduced capacity for gas exchange resulting from simplification of the distal lung structure with fewer, larger alveoli because of a failure of normal lung alveolar septation and pulmonary microvascular development. The mechanisms responsible for alveolar simplification in BPD have not been fully elucidated, but mounting evidence suggests that aberrations in the cross-talk between growth factors of the lung mesenchyme and distal airspace epithelium have a key role. Animal models that recapitulate the human condition have expanded our knowledge of the pathology of BPD and have identified candidate matrix components and growth factors in the developing lung that are disrupted by conditions that predispose infants to BPD and interfere with normal vascular and alveolar morphogenesis. This review focuses on the deviations from normal lung development that define the pathophysiology of BPD and summarizes the various candidate mesenchyme-associated proteins and growth factors that have been identified as being disrupted in animal models of BPD. Finally, future areas of research to identify novel targets affected in arrested lung development and recovery are discussed.     

Partial liquid ventilation improves gas exchange and increases EELV in acute lung injury

Gas exchange is improved during partial liquidventilation with perfluorocarbon in animal models of acute lung injury.The specific mechanisms are unproved. We measured end-expiratory lung volume (EELV) by null-point body plethysmography in anesthetized sheep.Measurements of gas exchange and EELV were made before and after acutelung injury was induced with intravenous oleic acid to decrease EELVand worsen gas exchange. Measurements of gas exchange and EELV wereagain performed after partial liquid ventilation with 30 ml/kg ofperfluorocarbon and compared with gas-ventilated controls. Oxygenationwas significantly improved during partial liquid ventilation, and EELV(composite of gas and liquid) was significantly increased, comparedwith preliquid ventilation values and gas-ventilated controls. Weconclude that partial liquid ventilation may directly recruitconsolidated alveoli in the lung-injured sheep and that this may be onemechanism whereby gas exchange is improved.

     

Effect of posture on regional gas exchange in pigs.

Although recent high-resolution studies demonstrate the importance of nongravitational determinants for both pulmonary blood flow and ventilation distributions, posture has a clear impact on whole lung gas exchange. Deterioration in arterial oxygenation with repositioning from prone to supine posture is caused by increased heterogeneity in the distribution of ventilation-to-perfusion ratios. This can result from increased heterogeneity in regional blood flow distribution, increased heterogeneity in regional ventilation distribution, decreased correlation between regional blood flow and ventilation, or some combination of the above (Wilson TA and Beck KC, J Appl Physiol 72: 2298-2304, 1992). We hypothesize that, although repositioning from prone to supine has relatively small effects on overall blood flow and ventilation distributions, regional changes are poorly correlated, resulting in regional ventilation-perfusion mismatch and reduction in alveolar oxygen tension. We report ventilation and perfusion distributions in seven anesthetized, mechanically ventilated pigs measured with aerosolized and injected microspheres. Total contributions of pulmonary structure and posture on ventilation and perfusion heterogeneities were quantified by using analysis of variance. Regional gradients of posture-mediated change in ventilation, perfusion, and calculated alveolar oxygen tension were examined in the caudocranial and ventrodorsal directions. We found that pulmonary structure was responsible for 74.0 +/- 4.7% of total ventilation heterogeneity and 63.3 +/- 4.2% of total blood flow heterogeneity. Posture-mediated redistribution was primarily oriented along the caudocranial axis for ventilation and along the ventrodorsal axis for blood flow. These mismatched changes reduced alveolar oxygen tension primarily in the dorsocaudal lung region.     

Functional Lung Imaging during HFV in Preterm Rabbits

Although high frequency ventilation (HFV) is an effective mode of ventilation, there is limited information available in regard to lung dynamics during HFV. To improve the knowledge of lung function during HFV we have developed a novel lung imaging and analysis technique. The technique can determine complex lung motion information in vivo with a temporal resolution capable of observing HFV dynamics. Using high-speed synchrotron based phase contrast X-ray imaging and cross-correlation analysis, this method is capable of recording data in more than 60 independent regions across a preterm rabbit lung in excess of 300 frames per second (fps). This technique is utilised to determine regional intra-breath lung mechanics of preterm rabbit pups during HFV. Whilst ventilated at fixed pressures, each animal was ventilated at frequencies of 1, 3, 5 and 10 Hz. A 50% decrease in delivered tidal volume was measured at 10 Hz compared to 1 Hz, yet at the higher frequency a 500% increase in minute activity was measured. Additionally, HFV induced greater homogeneity of lung expansion activity suggesting this ventilation strategy potentially minimizes tissue damage and improves gas mixing. The development of this technique permits greater insight and further research into lung mechanics and may have implications for the improvement of ventilation strategies used to support severe pulmonary trauma and disease.     

Pulmonary hypertension after postlavage lung injury in rabbits: possible role of polymorphonuclear leukocytes.

Previous studies showed that repeated lung lavage leads to a severe lung injury with very poor gas exchange, a substantial protein leak into the alveoli with hyaline membrane formation, pulmonary hypertension, and migration of granulocytes (PMN) into the alveolar spaces. Depletion of PMN leads to a better gas exchange and a markedly decreased protein leak with only scanty hyaline membranes. In this study we show that there is sustained pulmonary hypertension after the lung lavage, but in PMN-depleted rabbits there is no postlavage increase in pulmonary arterial pressure. Changing the shunt fraction by manipulating mean airway pressure still leads to a hypoxic vasoconstriction with increase of pulmonary arterial pressure. Thus, after lung lavage, pulmonary reactivity to hypoxia is still preserved. Comparisons between high-frequency ventilation and conventional mechanical ventilation at the same mean airway pressures showed that equal mean airway pressure in these two very different modes of ventilation do not translate into the same mean functional lung volumes.     

Current Perspectives for Management of Acute Respiratory Insufficiency in Premature Infants with Acute Respiratory Syndrome

Current perspectives for management of acute respiratory insufficiency in premature infants with acute respiratory syndrome and the pathology of acute respiratory insufficiency in the preterm infant, including the current therapy modalities on disposition are presented. Since the therapeutical challenge and primary clinical goal are to normalize ventilation ratio and lung perfusion, when respiratory insufficiency occurs, it is very important to introduce the respiratory support as soon possible, in order to reduce development of pulmonary cyanosis and edema, and intrapulmonary or intracardial shunts. A characteristic respiratory instability that reflects through fluctuations in gas exchange and ventilation is often present in premature infants. Adapting the respiratory support on a continuous basis to the infant’s needs is challenging and not always effective. Although a large number of ventilation strategies for the neonate are available, there is a need for additional consensus on management of acute respiratory distress syndrome in pediatric population lately redefined by Berlin definition criteria, in order to efficiently apply various modes of respiratory support in daily pediatrician clinical use.     

Extended high-frequency partial liquid ventilation in lung injury: gas exchange, injury quantification, and vapor loss.

High-frequency oscillatory ventilation with perflubron (PFB) reportedly improves pulmonary mechanics and gas exchange and attenuates lung injury. We explored PFB evaporative loss kinetics, intrapulmonary PFB distribution, and dosing strategies during 15 h of high-frequency oscillation (HFO)-partial liquid ventilation (PLV). After saline lavage lung injury, 15 swine were rescued with high-frequency oscillatory ventilation (n = 5), or in addition received 10 ml/kg PFB delivered to dependent lung [n = 5, PLV-compartmented (PLV(C))] or 10 ml/kg distributed uniformly within the lung [n = 5, PLV(U)]. In the PLV(C) group, PFB vapor loss was replaced. ANOVA revealed an unsustained improvement in oxygenation index in the PLV(U) group (P = 0.04); the reduction in oxygenation index correlated with PFB losses. Although tissue myeloperoxidase activity was reduced globally by HFO-PLV (P < 0.01) and regional lung injury scores (lung injury scores) in dependent lung were improved (P = 0.05), global lung injury scores were improved by HFO-PLV (P < 0.05) only in atelectasis, edema, and alveolar distension but not in cumulative score. In our model, markers of inflammation and lung injury were attenuated by HFO-PLV, and it appears that uniform intrapulmonary PFB distribution optimized gas exchange during HFO-PLV; additionally, monitoring PFB evaporative loss appears necessary to stabilize intrapulmonary PFB volume.     

Effect of artificial surfactant on pulmonary function in preterm and full-term lambs

We hypothesized that agents very different from surfactant may still support lung function. To test this hypothesis, we instilled FC-100, a fluorocarbon, and Tween 20, a detergent, which have higher minimum surface tensions and less hysteresis than surfactant, into 15 full-term and 14 preterm lambs. FC-100 and Tween 20 were as efficient as natural surfactant in improving gas exchange and compliance in preterm lambs with respiratory failure. Dynamic compliance correlated with the equilibrium surface tension of the alveolar wash in both full-term (P less than 0.02) and preterm (P less than 0.008) lambs. Functional residual capacity in full-term and preterm lambs was lower after treatment with the two test agents than with surfactant, findings consistent with qualitative histology. Oxygenation in full-term lambs correlated with mean lung volumes (P less than 0.003), suggesting that the hysteresis and/or low minimum surface tension of surfactant may improve mean lung volume, and hence oxygenation, by maintaining functional residual capacity. The effects of the test agents suggest that agents with biophysical properties different from surfactant may still aid lung expansion.     

Ventilation-perfusion inequality during constant-flow ventilation

Previous work by Lehnert et al. (J. Appl. Physiol. 53:483-489, 1982) has demonstrated that adequate alveolar ventilation can be maintained during apnea in anesthetized dogs by delivering a continuous stream of inspired ventilation through cannulas aimed down the main-stem bronchi. Because an asymmetric distribution of ventilation might introduce ventilation-perfusion (VA/Q) inequality, we compared gas exchange efficiency in nine anesthetized and paralyzed dogs during constant-flow ventilation (CFV) and conventional ventilation (intermittent positive-pressure ventilation, IPPV). Gas exchange was assessed using the multiple inert gas elimination technique. During CFV at 3 l X kg-1 X min-1, lung volume, retention-excretion differences (R-E*) for low- and medium-solubility gases, and the log standard deviation of blood flow (log SD Q) increased, compared with the findings during IPPV. Reducing CFV flow rate to 1 l X kg-1 X min-1 at constant lung volume improved R-E* and log SD Q, but significant VA/Q inequality compared with that at IPPV remained and arterial PCO2 rose. Comparison of IPPV and CFV at the same mean lung volume showed a similar reversible deterioration in gas exchange efficiency during CFV. We conclude that CFV causes significant VA/Q inequality which may be due to nonuniform ventilation distribution and a redistribution of pulmonary blood flow.     

High-frequency partial liquid ventilation in respiratory distress syndrome: hemodynamics and gas exchange

Sukumar, Minakshi, Mahesh Bommaraju, John E. Fisher,Frederick C. Morin III, Michele C. Papo, Bradley P. Fuhrman, Lynn J. Hernan, and Corinne Lowe Leach. High-frequency partial liquidventilation in respiratory distress syndrome: hemodynamics and gasexchange. J. Appl. Physiol. 84(1):327-334, 1998.Partial liquid ventilation using conventionalventilatory schemes improves lung function in animal models ofrespiratory failure. We examined the feasibility of high-frequencypartial liquid ventilation in the preterm lamb with respiratorydistress syndrome and evaluated its effect on pulmonary and systemichemodynamics. Seventeen lambs were studied in three groups:high-frequency gas ventilation (Gas group), high-frequency partialliquid ventilation (Liquid group), and high-frequency partial liquidventilation with hypoxia-hypercarbia (Liquid-Hypoxiagroup). High-frequency partial liquid ventilation increased oxygenation compared with high-frequency gas ventilation over5 h (arterial oxygen tension 253 ± 21.3 vs. 17 ± 1.8 Torr; P < 0.001).Pulmonary vascular resistance decreased 78%(P < 0.001), pulmonary blood flowincreased fivefold (P < 0.001), andaortic pressure was maintained (P < 0.01) in the Liquid group, in contrast to progressive hypoxemia,hypercarbia, and shock in the Gas group. Central venouspressure did not change. The Liquid-Hypoxia group was similar tothe Gas group. We conclude that high-frequency partial liquidventilation improves gas exchange and stabilizes pulmonary and systemichemodynamics compared with high-frequency gas ventilation. Thestabilization appears to be due in large part to improvement in gasexchange.

     

Comparison of serum levels of seven cytokines in premature newborns undergoing different ventilatory procedures: high frequency oscillatory ventilation or synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation

OBJECTIVE: The severity of pulmonary dysfunction and subsequent development of chronic lung disease (CLD) in preterm neonates depends on several factors, among them oxygen administration. The aim of this report is to compare the effects of high-frequency, oscillatory ventilation (HFOV) versus synchronized, intermittent, mandatory ventilation (sIMV) on serum cytokine levels (IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, MCP-1, PDGF-BB, VEGF and TGF-beta1) and ventilator indices during the first week of life. Moreover, CLD development and several other outcomes were compared between the two groups. DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial. SETTING: Third level NICU. PATIENTS: 40 preterm neonates with a gestational age between 24 and 29 weeks were randomly (20 per group) assigned to one of the two, above-mentioned ventilation strategies within 30 minutes of birth. MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: At 1, 3 and 5 days, neonates were monitored by means of ventilator indices and levels of seven pro-inflammatory or anti-inflammatory (pro-fibrotic) cytokines in serum. No clinical or biochemical differences were observed at baseline. The neonates assigned to HFOV benefited from early and sustained improvement in gas exchange, with earlier extubation and lower incidence of CLD, as compared to the neonates assigned to sIMV treatment, and showed a significant reduction of serum IL-6, IL-8 and IL-10 over time only when the HFOV treatment was administered. In addition, at days 3 and 5, the IL-6 levels were significantly lower in the HFOV group as compared to sIMV patients. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this randomized clinical trial support the hypothesis that early use of HFOV, combined with an optimum volume strategy, has a beneficial effect, reducing serum levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines and consequently the acute phase leading to lung injury.     

External respiration and gas metabolism in orthostatic syncopes

Cardiorespiratory reactions to tilt tests were compared in 80 healthy male subjects with an adequate orthostatic tolerance and in 19 subjects who fainted during tilting. They showed significant differences in the gas exchange, hemodynamics, and external respiration. Variations in the heart rate, pulmonary ventilation and the alveolar CO2 tension were most demonstrative. The findings, particularly the lack of the expected decrease o= oxygen consumption in the presyncopal state contribute to the concepts of the pathogenesis of the orthostatic collapse.     

Pulmonary vascular resistance in the fluorocarbon-filled lung

Pulmonary vascular resistance was investigated in the fluorocarbon-filled lung in an in situ isolated lung preparation. Lungs were perfused at constant flow (100 ml X min-1 X kg-1) with whole blood from a donor cat. left atrial pressure was held constant at zero pressure. Measurements of pulmonary arterial pressure enabled calculation of pulmonary vascular resistance. Regional changes in pulmonary blood flow were determined by the microsphere technique. During quasi-static deflation over a range of 0-30 mmHg, dependent alveolar pressure was consistently greater for a volume of fluorocarbon than for gas, with each pressure-volume curve for the fluorocarbon-filled lung shifted to the right of the curve for the gas-filled lung. In turn, pulmonary vascular resistance was found to increase linearly as a function of increasing alveolar pressure, independent of the medium in the lung. Thus, for a given volume, pulmonary vascular resistance was consistently greater in the fluorocarbon-filled lung compared with the gas-filled lung. This increase in pulmonary vascular resistance was accompanied by a redistribution of pulmonary blood flow in which blood flow to the dependent region was decreased in the fluorocarbon-filled lung compared with the gas-filled lung. Conversely, the less-dependent regions of the lung received a relatively greater percentage of blood flow when filled with fluorocarbon compared with gas. These findings suggest that pulmonary vascular resistance is increased during liquid ventilation, largely as the result of mechanical interaction at the alveolar-vascular interface.     

Factors in the development of arterial hypoxemia in middle-aged and elderly people

Partial pressure of oxygen and carbon dioxide in alveolar air and arterial blood, lung diffusion capacity and its components, ventilation parameters, ventilation-perfusion ratio were determined in healthy people aged 60-89 (45 subjects) and aged 20-31 (19 subjects, controls). In elderly and old people PO2 in arterial blood was found to decrease with increasing alveolar-arterial PO2 gradient. In other words, arterial hypoxemia was determined by the disturbance in gas exchange between alveolar air and blood of lung capillaries. The diffusion capacity of lung decreased at the expense of membrane factor. Its age-related dynamics was mainly due to a decrease in the pulmonary diffusion surface occurring because of improper coordination of ventilation and perfusion in the lungs. The discrepancy of pulmonary ventilation and perfusion proved to be the leading factor of arterial hypoxemia in late ontogenesis.     

Effect of breath-hold time on DLCO(SB) in patients with airway obstruction

The single-breath diffusing capacity of the lung for CO [DLCO(SB)] is considered a measure of the conductance of CO across the alveolar-capillary membrane and its binding with hemoglobin. Although incomplete mixing of inspired gas with alveolar gas could theoretically influence overall diffusion, conventional calculations of DLCO(SB) spuriously overestimate DLCO(SB) during short breath-holding periods when incomplete mixing of gas within the lung might have the greatest effect. Using the three-equation method to calculate DLCO(SB) which analytically accounts for changes in breath-hold time, we found that DLCO(SB) did not change with breath-hold time in control subjects but increased with increasing breath-hold time in both patients with asthma and patients with emphysema. The increase in DLCO(SB) with increasing breath-hold time correlated with the phase III slope of the single-breath N2 washout curve. We suggest that in patients with ventilation maldistribution, DLCO(SB) may be decreased for the shorter breath-hold maneuvers because overall diffusion is limited by the reduced transport of CO from the inspired gas through the alveolar gas prior to alveolar-capillary gas exchange.     

Distinct patterns of apoptosis in the lung during liquid ventilation compared with gas ventilation

To determine whether liquid ventilation (LV) causes less cell injury and improves lung function compared with conventional gas ventilation (GV), we analyzed pulmonary physiological profiles, lung histology, and cell death in 110- and 120-day preterm lambs, which were randomized to receive either ventilation modality on FI(O(2)) = 1. LV lungs were well expanded with adequate pulmonary function, whereas GV animals exhibited marked atelectasis, poor pulmonary function, and increased mortality. Both ventilatory strategies induced marked lung cell apoptosis, but with distinct patterns of distribution. Although GV induced apoptosis of epithelium primarily in the lining and within the lumina of bronchioles, LV induced significant apoptosis much more homogeneously throughout lung parenchyma including alveoli and interstitial spaces. These studies suggest that although both forms of ventilation cause regional apoptosis, LV more effectively delivers oxygen and recruits the lung more homogeneously than GV.     

A mathematical model of pulmonary gas exchange under inflammatory stress

During a severe local or systemic inflammatory response, immune mediators target lung tissue. This process may lead to acute lung injury and impaired diffusion of gas molecules. Although several mathematical models of gas exchange have been described, none simulate acute lung injury following inflammatory stress. In view of recent laboratory and clinical progress in the understanding of the pathophysiology of acute lung injury, such a mathematical model would be useful. We first derived a partial differential equations model of gas exchange on a small physiological unit of the lung (≈25 alveoli), which we refer to as a respiratory unit (RU). We next developed a simple model of the acute inflammatory response and implemented its effects within a RU, creating a single RU model. Linking multiple RUs with various ventilation/perfusion ratios and taking into account pulmonary venous blood remixing yielded our lung-scale model. Using the lung-scale model, we explored the predicted effects of inflammation on ventilation/perfusion distribution and the resulting pulmonary venous partial pressure oxygen level during systemic inflammatory stresses. This model represents a first step towards the development of anatomically faithful models of gas exchange and ventilation under a broad range of local and systemic inflammatory stimuli resulting in acute lung injury, such as infection and mechanical strain of lung tissue.