The Effect of Incubation Temperature on the Recovery of Spores of Bacillus subtilis 8057

S ummary . The recovery of Bacillus subtilis spores was studied after different heat treatments at 95° and incubation at different temperatures in roll tubes in a gradient temperature incubator. Plate count agar and brain–heart infusion agar were used in the roll tubes. Unheated spores showed similar recoveries at 16–48° whereas heated spores had an optimum recovery temperature of c. 30.9. The rate of germination of untreated spores was greatest at c. 41° and ceased at 50°. Heated spores germinated at 52°5°, suggesting that recovery of heat-treated spores is not limited by their ability to germinate. Outgrowth of spores at different incubation temperatures was similar for germinated and ungerminated spores. Accordingly it is outgrowth rather than germination which is sensitive to temperature.     

Injury and repair in biocide-treated spores of Bacillus subtilis

Abstract Bacillus subtilis NCTC 8236 spores exposed to appropriate concentrations of test biocides (glutaraldehyde, two iodine and two chlorine preparations) were able to repair injury if subsequently held in nutrient broth at 37°C but not in broth at 22°C, sterile filtered water at 4, 22 or 37°C or germination medium at 37°C. Repair appeared to occur primarily during outgrowth and was initiated soonest for iodine-treated spores and latest for glutaraldehyde-treated ones.     

Occurrence and Thermoresistance of Spores of Psychrophilic and Psychrotrophic Aerobic Sporeformers in Soil and Foods

Spores of psychrotrophic (able to grow at 5°C) aerobic sporeformers occurred in soil in high numbers (2 × 10³-5 × 10⁶/g), whereas psychrophilic (able to grow at 0°C) spores were present at significantly lower levels (500–10⁵/g). Psychrotrophic spores were absent in herbs and spices: in pasteurized meals prepared industrially their numbers varied from <10 to 1000/g. For spores harvested from Trypticase Soy Agar (TSA), the heat resistance of the cold-tolerant sporeformers was low with D _90°C-values from 1–11 min. The recovery of heated psychrophilic spores on this medium at 5°C was equal to their recovery at 20°C. However, the recovery of heated psychrotrophic spores was lower at 5°C than at 20°C, whereas unheated spores gave the same counts at both temperatures. The heat resistance of naturally occurring spores of cold-tolerant sporeformers washed from soil was comparable with the resistance of spores formed on TSA.     

Amino Acid Enhancement of Recovery in Dry-heat Damaged Spores of Bacillus subtilis

Spores of Bacillus subtilis MD2 and var. niger were dry-heat damaged at 150°, 160° and 170°C and recovered on media of increasing complexity. The greater the heat dose the more marked was the effect of amino acid supplements on recovery. For strain MD2 maximum germination and outgrowth of unheated spores could be obtained on a minimal salts + glucose medium with alanine, aspartic acid, glycine and methionine; the latter three amino acids served to enhance growth, not germination. The recovery of heat-damaged spores was significantly increased by adding valine plus isoleucine or arginine or glutamine. The increase was probably due to the use of valine and isoleucine as substrates of NAD-linked dehydrogenases to generate reducing power and serve as NH₃-donor, initiating germination in spores which were unable to germinate as a result of inactivation of alanine dehydrogenase. Valine or isoleucine added singly suppressed recovery by feedback inhibition of the pathways to both these amino acids during outgrowth.     

Influence of NaCl, NaNO2 and oxygen on the germination and growth of Bacillus licheniformis, a spoilage organism of chub-packed luncheon meat

The thermal resistance of Bacillus licheniformis spores was increased from a D ₇₀-value of 590 min to one of 900 min by the addition of 4% NaCl to the heating medium [tryptone-yeast extract-glucose (TYG) broth, pH 6.8], but was decreased to 470 min in TYG broth acidified to pH 4.4. Sodium nitrite (0.02%) enhanced spore destruction at 80°C but not at 70°C; addition of 4% NaCl eliminated this effect. Less than half the number of spores surviving heat comparable to commercial cooking were heat-damaged to the extent of being unable to grow aerobically in the presence of 4% NaCl. No growth occurred during anaerobic incubation even when the media contained no added NaCl. Oxygen was not required to trigger spore germination, but trace amounts were needed for the successful outgrowth of germinated spores. Spore germination was accelerated and enhanced by the presence of at least 2% NaCl. Therefore under anaerobic conditions NaCl promotes microbiological stability because the germinated spores cannot develop further and become moribund. It is concluded that the plastic casing of luncheon-meat chubs is not sufficiently oxygen-impermeable to allow the product a long shelf-life other than at chill temperatures unless the chubs are stored in an oxygen-free atmosphere.     

A note on the effect of sporulation conditions on the resistance of Bacillus spores to heat and chemicals

Spores of Bacillus subtilis SA22 harvested after 22 d incubation on nutrient agar at 30°C were more resistant to 0–04% peracetic acid at 20°C than spores harvested following 2 d incubation. Similarly, spores of B. subtilis globigii B17, harvested after 7 d incubation on a sporulation agar were up to 10 times less resistant to 0.04% peracetic acid at 20°C than spores harvested after 35 d incubation. An increase in resistance to heating at 100°C and to exposure to 17.7% hydrogen peroxide at 20°C occurred as the age of B. subtilis SA22 spores prior to harvesting increased, whereas differences in resistance were not observed with spores of B. subtilis globigii B17.     

The Behaviour of a Food Poisoning Strain of Clostridium welchii in Beef

S ummary : An inoculum of 10⁵ spores of Clostridium welchii F2985/50 in meat survived steaming at 100° for 5 h, the number being reduced sevenfold for every hour of steaming. They also survived for at least 6 months in frozen meat stored at -5° and -20°, whereas vegetative cells died more rapidly at -5° than at -20°. In beef stored for 13 days at 1°, 5°, 10° and 15° there was no multiplication but a slow destruction of vegetative cells, but there was little change in the spore count. Slow multiplication occurred at 20° but at 25° and 37° growth was rapid. Only about 3% of the spores germinated without prior heat shock, so the majority failed to germinate in raw meat stored at any temperature, but did so once the meat had been heated. In meat which had been heated and allowed to cool almost all of the spores had lost their heat resistance.
It was found that the minimal growth temperature was related to pH and medium, so that meat with a pH higher than that used in these experiments (pH 5°7–5°8) would probably have a lower minimal growth temperature for these organisms and would thus be more susceptible to spoilage.     

Sporulation of Clostridium perfringens (welchii) in Four Laboratory Media

S ummary . Sporulation of 7 strains of Clostridium perfringens ( welchii ) was investigated in 4 laboratory media. A method to induce rapid and simultaneous sporulation was attempted which involved obtaining a purely vegetative culture to inoculate the test media. Heat resistance of spores produced in the individual media by each of 4 selected strains was investigated. The clean spores for the heating tests were obtained by a special procedure which included chilling to 6° for a minimum of 1 week immediately following the usual incubation period, then centrifuging, resuspending to volume in 0.85% NaCl solution and pasteurizing at 75° for 20 min before subjecting to the heating tests. Morphology of each strain was studied using stained microscopic preparations from the 24 h sporulating cultures.
In the Ellner medium spore counts approaching 10⁷/ml were recorded and this medium appeared to be the most efficient when judged in terms of numbers of spores produced. In other media the counts were in the range 10⁴-10⁵ spores/ml. Cooked meat medium yielded slightly higher spore counts than did either SEC broth or modified Wagenaar & Dack medium, the latter contained in a dialysis sac apparatus. A period of chilling to 6° for a minimum of 1 week following incubation enhanced maturation in all cultures except those grown in SEC broth for 24 h or 15 days and those grown 15 days in the modified Wagenaar & Dack medium.
Considerable heat resistance, expressed as percentage spore survival, was recorded for spores of 4 strains when heated at 80°, and heat resistance generally increased with lengthening of incubation time for the culture. Survival of spores heated at 100° for 10 min was usually less than 0.01% but spores in SEC broth after 15 days showed a somewhat greater heat resistance than the others. In no instance did total destruction of spores occur at 100°.     

The use of flash photolysis for a high-resolution temporal and spatial analysis of bacterial chemotactic behaviour: CheZ is not always necessary for chemotaxis

The Bacillus subtilis cell-division protein DivIB is shown to be present at an ≈100-fold higher abundance (≈5000 molecules per cell) than its Escherichia coli FtsQ homologue. B. subtilis contains much more DivIB (at least 60-fold) than is needed to maintain the normal rate of cell division at moderate temperatures (up to 37°C). However, a high level of DivIB is needed to achieve the normal rate of division at high temperature (47°C). It is proposed that membrane-bound DivIB is involved in stabilizing or promoting the assembly of the division complex (which is intrinsically temperature sensitive) in a manner that requires more of the protein at higher temperatures. The (at least) 60-fold accumulation of DivIB and FtsZ from an undetectable level, following germination and outgrowth of spores up until the stage of the first cell division, was unaffected by blocking of initiation of the first round of replication. It is concluded that there is no major synthesis of either of these 'division initiation' proteins linked to initiation, progression or completion of the first round of replication accompanying spore outgrowth.     

Effects of inactivation or overexpression of the sspF gene on properties of Bacillus subtilis spores.

Inactivation of the Bacillus subtilis sspF gene had no effect on sporulation, spore resistance, or germination in a wild-type strain or one lacking DNA protective alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble proteins (SASP). Overexpression of SspF in wild-type spores or in spores lacking major alpha/beta-type SASP (alpha- beta- spores) had no effect on sporulation but slowed spore outgrowth and restored a small amount of UV and heat resistance to alpha- beta- spores. In vitro analyses showed that SspF is a DNA binding protein and is cleaved by the SASP-specific protease (GPR) at a site similar to that cleaved in alpha/beta-type SASP. SspF was also degraded during spore germination and outgrowth, and this degradation was initiated by GPR.     

Effect of thermal treatments in oils on bacterial spore survival

The heat resistance of Bacillus cereus F4165/75, Clostridium sporogenes PA 3679 and Cl. botulinum 62A spores suspended in buffer (pH 7˙2), olive oil and a commercial oil (a mixture of rapeseed oil and soy oil) was investigated. Linear survivor curves were obtained with B. cereus spores in the three menstrua and with 62A and PA 3679 spores suspended in buffer. However, the inactivation kinetics of the clostridial spores suspended in oils were concave upward with a characteristic tailing-off for 62A spores suspended in olive oil. These deviations from the semi-log model could not be ascribed to a heterogeneity in heat resistance of the spore population or to the variation of a_w during heating. Spore resistance to heat increased in the order: buffer ⋖ commercial oil < olive oil. The greater heat resistance of oil-suspended spores was ascribed to the low a_w (0˙479 and 0˙492 for commercial oil and olive oil, respectively) and to the composition of the oils. The difference in z values ( ca 28°C in oils and 10°-12°C in buffer) suggested that the mechanism of inactivation differs for spores suspended in lipids and in aqueous systems. The thermodynamic data were consistent with this hypothesis.     

The Occurrence of Bacillus coagulans with High Heat Resistance

S ummary : The heat resistance of spores of Bacillus coagulans strain Sp. 33, isolated from canned chopped spinach, has been determined. It appeared to be higher in 1/40 M phosphate than in 1/15 M phosphate and higher at pH 6°8 than at pH 6°0. In 1/40 M phosphate buffer of pH 6°8 the calculated D ₁₁₀ was 2°4 min. In chopped spinach of pH 6°2 the calculated D ₁₁₀ was 0°84 min. In addition a simple and reliable method of assessing the thermal resistance of micro-organisms in thermal death time tubes is reported.     

Sporulation temperature affects initiation of germination and inactivation by high hydrostatic pressure of Bacillus cereus

The influence of sporulation temperature (20, 30 and 37 °C) on the heat resistance and initiation of germination and inactivation by high pressure on Bacillus cereus ATCC 14579 spores was investigated. Spores sporulated at 37 °C were the most heat-resistant. However, spores sporulated at 20 °C were more resistant to the initiation of germination and inactivation by high pressure. Spores were more sensitive to pressure at higher treatment temperatures. At 25 °C, there was an optimum pressure (250 MPa) for the initiation of germination for the three suspensions; at higher temperatures an increase of pressure up to 690 MPa caused progressively more germination. Resistance to the germinability and inactivation by high pressure of the spore population was distributed heterogeneously. Semilogarithmic curves of the ungerminated and survival fraction of B. cereus spores were concave. The resistant fraction of the spore population was lower at higher treatment temperatures. At 60 °C after 30 s of treatment at 690 MPa almost 5 log cycles of the population of B. cereus sporulated at 20 °C was germinated, and more than 7 log cycles of the population of B. cereus sporulated at 30 and 37 °C. The same treatment inactivated 4, 6 and 7 log cycles of the population of B. cereus sporulated at 20, 30 and 37 °C, respectively.     

Germination of Heat- and Alkali-Altered Spores of Clostridium perfringens Type A by Lysozyme and an Initiation Protein

The normal system functioning in the utilization of metabolizable germinants by both heat-sensitive and heat-resistant spores of Clostridium perfringens was inactivated by heat or by treatment of the spores with alkali to remove a soluble coat protein layer. Altered spores were incapable of germination (less than 1%) and outgrowth (less than 0.0005%) in complex media without the addition of either lysozyme or an initiation protein produced by C. perfringens. The addition of either of these agents permitted, in the case of alkali-treated spores, both 90 to 95% germination and outgrowth, as measured by colony formation. In the case of heat-damaged spores, only 50% germination and 2% outgrowth resulted from addition of the initiation protein, whereas lysozyme permitted 85% germination and 8% outgrowth. Alteration of the spores by heat or alkali apparently inactivated the normal lytic system responsible for cortical degradation during germination. Kinetics of production of the initiation protein and conditions affecting both its activity and that of lysozyme on altered spores are described.     

Role of DNA repair in Bacillus subtilis spore resistance.

Wet-heat or hydrogen peroxide treatment of wild-type Bacillus subtilis spores did not result in induction of lacZ fusions to three DNA repair-related genes (dinR, recA, and uvrC) during spore outgrowth. However, these genes were induced during outgrowth of wild-type spores treated with dry heat or UV. Wet-heat, desiccation, dry-heat, or UV treatment of spores lacking major DNA-binding proteins (termed alpha-beta- spores) also resulted in induction of the three DNA repair genes during spore outgrowth. Hydrogen peroxide treatment of alpha-beta-spores did not result in induction of dinR- and rerA-lacZ but did cause induction of uvrC-lacZ during spore outgrowth. Spores of a recA mutant were approximately twofold more UV sensitive and approximately ninefold more sensitive to dry heat than were wild-type spores but were no more sensitive to wet heat and hydrogen peroxide. In contrast, alpha-beta- recA spores were significantly more sensitive than were alpha-beta- spores to all four treatments, as well as to desiccation. Surprisingly, RecA levels were quite low in dormant spores, but RecA was synthesized during spore outgrowth. Taken together, these data (i) are consistent with previous suggestions that some treatments (dry heat and UV with wild-type spores; desiccation, dry and wet heat, hydrogen peroxide, and UV with alpha-beta- spores) that kill spores do so in large part by causing DNA damage and (ii) indicate that repair of DNA damage during spore outgrowth is an important component of spore resistance to a number of treatments, as has been shown previously for UV.     

Resistance of Bacillus Spores to Combined Sporicidal Treatments

S ummary . Moist heat at 82° (100° for Bacillus stearothermophilus ) and solutions of 0.2% w/v chlorocresol or 0.01% w/v benzalkonium chloride at 24° separately showed no sporicidal activity against B. pumilis, B. stearothermophilus, B. subtilis and B. subtilis var. niger . Spores of the last organism were the most sensitive to γ radiation, the D value being 0.16 Mrad. Prior irradiation with a dose of 0.16 Mrad brought about only a slight increase in the sensitivity of the spores to moist heat. The presence of bactericide during irradiation did not affect radiation resistance. Inactivation rates were greater when the spores were heated in the presence of a bactericide than in aqueous suspension and benzalkonium chloride was more active than chlorocresol. Chlorocresol enhanced the heat activation of B. stearothermophilus at 100°. Irradiation in the presence of 0.2% w/v chlorocresol or 0.01% w/v benzalkonium chloride had no effect on the subsequent resistance of the spores when heated in the presence of these bactericides. It is concluded that it is unlikely that combinations of moist heat, radiation and bactericides, each less severe than when used in an accepted sterilization process, will lead to an alternative process which, while less damaging to the materials being sterilized, would still maintain the accepted standards of freedom from contamination.     

The Effect of Sodium Chloride on Heat Resistance and Recovery of Heated Spores of Bacillus stearothermophilus

Increasing concentrations (2, 4 and 8% w/v) of sodium chloride in the heating medium progressively reduced the heat resistance of spores of Bacillus stearothermophilus. Storage at 4° in water or in sodium chloride solutions had little effect on viable counts of unheated spores, but with the increase in sodium chloride concentration there was a reduction in the heat activation effect and a small decrease in heat resistance of the spores. Increasing the severity of heat treatment rendered spores increasingly sensitive to sodium chloride in the plating medium.     

Independence of Bacillus subtilis spore outgrowth from DNA synthesis.

The outgrowth of spores of Bacillus subtilis 168 proceeded normally in temperature-sensitive DNA mutants under restrictive conditions and in the absence of DNA synthesis. Two inhibitors of DNA synthesis, nalidoxic acid and 6-(p-hydroxyphenylazo)-uracil, inhibited spore outgrowth under some nutritional conditions; this inhibition of outgrowth however, though not that of DNA synthesis, could be reversed by glucose. The sensitivity of the outgrowing spores to nalidixic acid and 6-(p-hydroxyphenylazo)-uracil inhbition decreased as a function of outgrowth time. The cells became completely resistant to the inhibitors after 90 min. The development of this resistance occurred also in the absence of DNA synthesis. It was concluded that DNA synthesis is not needed for spore outgrowth, and that outgrowing cells and vegetative cells differ in their sensitivity to these inhibitors.     

Effect of Iysozyme concentration, heating at 90°C, and then incubation at chilled temperatures on growth from spores of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum

The heat treatment necessary to inactivate spores of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum in refrigerated, processed foods may be influenced by the occurrence of lysozyme in these foods. Spores of six strains of non-proteolytic Cl. botulinum were inoculated into tubes of an anaerobic meat medium, to give 10⁶ spores per tube. Hen egg white lysozyme (0–50 μg ml^-1) was added, and the tubes were given a heat treatment equivalent to 19·8 min at 90°C, cooled, and incubated at 8°, 12°, 16° and 25°C for up to 93 d. In the absence of added lysozyme, neither growth nor toxin formation were observed. A 6–D inactivation was therefore achieved. In tubes to which lysozyme (5–50 μg ml^-1) had been added prior to heating, growth and toxin formation were observed. With lysozyme added at 50 μg ml^-1, growth was first observed after 68 d at 8°C, 31 d at 12°C, 24 d at 16°C, and 9 d at 25°C. Thus, in these circumstances, a heat treatment equivalent to 19·8 min at 90°C was not sufficient, on its own, to give a 6–D inactivation. A combination of the heat treatment, maintenance at less than 12°C, and a shelf-life not more than 4 weeks reduced the risk of growth of non-proteolytic Cl. botulinum by a factor of 10⁶.     

Spores of Bacillus subtilis: their resistance to and killing by radiation, heat and chemicals

A number of mechanisms are responsible for the resistance of spores of Bacillus species to heat, radiation and chemicals and for spore killing by these agents. Spore resistance to wet heat is determined largely by the water content of spore core, which is much lower than that in the growing cell protoplast. A lower core water content generally gives more wet heat-resistant spores. The level and type of spore core mineral ions and the intrinsic stability of total spore proteins also play a role in spore wet heat resistance, and the saturation of spore DNA with alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble spore proteins (SASP) protects DNA against wet heat damage. However, how wet heat kills spores is not clear, although it is not through DNA damage. The alpha/beta-type SASP are also important in spore resistance to dry heat, as is DNA repair in spore outgrowth, as Bacillus subtilis spores are killed by dry heat via DNA damage. Both UV and gamma-radiation also kill spores via DNA damage. The mechanism of spore resistance to gamma-radiation is not well understood, although the alpha/beta-type SASP are not involved. In contrast, spore UV resistance is due largely to an alteration in spore DNA photochemistry caused by the binding of alpha/beta-type SASP to the DNA, and to a lesser extent to the photosensitizing action of the spore core's large pool of dipicolinic acid. UV irradiation of spores at 254 nm does not generate the cyclobutane dimers (CPDs) and (6-4)-photoproducts (64PPs) formed between adjacent pyrimidines in growing cells, but rather a thymidyl-thymidine adduct termed spore photoproduct (SP). While SP is formed in spores with approximately the same quantum efficiency as that for generation of CPDs and 64PPs in growing cells, SP is repaired rapidly and efficiently in spore outgrowth by a number of repair systems, at least one of which is specific for SP. Some chemicals (e.g. nitrous acid, formaldehyde) again kill spores by DNA damage, while others, in particular oxidizing agents, appear to damage the spore's inner membrane so that this membrane ruptures upon spore germination and outgrowth. There are also other agents such as glutaraldehyde for which the mechanism of spore killing is unclear. Factors important in spore chemical resistance vary with the chemical, but include: (i) the spore coat proteins that likely react with and detoxify chemical agents; (ii) the relative impermeability of the spore's inner membrane that restricts access of exogenous chemicals to the spore core; (iii) the protection of spore DNA by its saturation with alpha/beta-type SASP; and (iv) DNA repair for agents that kill spores via DNA damage. Given the importance of the killing of spores of Bacillus species in the food and medical products industry, a deeper understanding of the mechanisms of spore resistance and killing may lead to improved methods for spore destruction.