Fine needle cytology--is aspiration suction necessary? A study of 100 masses in various sites

One hundred consecutive superficial mass lesions in various body sites were sampled by both conventional fine needle aspiration (FNA) and by a fine needle without the application of syringe suction. The latter technique is based on the principle of capillarity and may be termed "fine needle capillary" (FNC) sampling. The two sampling techniques were compared using five objective parameters: (1) the amount of diagnostic cellular material present, (2) the retention of appropriate architecture and cellular arrangement, (3) the degree of cellular degeneration, (4) the cellular trauma and (5) the volume of obscuring background blood and clots. There was no statistically significant difference between the efficacies of the two sampling techniques for any of the parameters studied. FNA sampling was diagnostic in a greater number of cases than was FNC sampling, but this difference was not statistically significant at a level of P = .05. When FNC sampling was diagnostic, it more frequently produced superior-quality material; conventional FNA, although diagnostic in a greater number of cases, mostly produced adequate, rather than superior-quality, material. This trend was not, however, statistically significant at a level of P = .05. These findings differ from those of previous studies (which have shown overall superiority of FNC sampling over conventional FNA sampling) and suggest that the technique of fine needle sampling employed for cytodiagnosis can be left to the personal preference of the operator.     

Comparative study of fine needle aspiration and fine needle capillary sampling of thyroid lesions

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether fine needle capillary (FNC) sampling gives quantitatively and qualitatively superior cytologic material as compared to the conventional technique of fine needle aspiration (FNA) when performed by a single aspirator. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional diagnostic test evaluation study. FNA and FNC were performed by a single operator on 200 diffuse and nodular thyroid lesions. RESULTS: A statistically significant difference in favor of FNC was observed for the parameter amount of cellular material. For the rest of the parameters--background blood or clot, degree of cellular degeneration, degree of cellular trauma and retention of architecture--the average score favored FNC but was not statistically significant--i.e., smears prepared from FNC displayed cellular material that was more concentrated, less damaged and less likely to be obscured by blood. CONCLUSION: Although FNC sampling was diagnostic in a greater number of cases than FNA sampling, this study did not prove a clear superiority of FNC over FNA. Until greater experience shows clear sampling superiority of FNC alone, rather than performing only FNA in diffuse or nodular thyroid lesions, incorporating FNC into the second puncture will definitely improve the quality and quantity of material at the patient's first visit.     

Thoracic fine needle aspiration biopsy versus fine needle cutting biopsy. A comparative study of 40 patients

The fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy findings were compared with the results of fine needle cutting (FNC) biopsy in 40 patients. The lesions (38 pulmonary nodules, 1 mediastinal mass and one lytic rib lesion) were biopsied with 22-gauge Greene and 21-gauge E-Z-EM needles through a 19-gauge needle guide. The FNA biopsy findings were based on smears and cell blocks of material obtained with the Greene needles while the FNC biopsy findings were based on tissue cores obtained by the E-Z-EM needles. In 83% of the cases, both techniques yielded specimens with similar cellularity; in seven cases, the FNA samples were more cellular. Malignancy was diagnosed in 80% of the patients: by both techniques in 26 patients, by FNA biopsy only in 5 patients and by FNC biopsy only in 1 patient. The sensitivity of FNA biopsy was higher than that of FNC biopsy (96.8% vs. 84.3%). The specificity and predictive value of positive results were 100% for both techniques. The predictive value of negative results was higher for FNA biopsy (88.8% vs. 54.5%). The majority of FNC biopsy tissue cores consisted mostly of clotted blood, lung tissue and/or fibrous tissue and did not facilitate or improve the diagnosis. Those data suggest that the contribution of FNC biopsy to the diagnosis of thoracic neoplasms is very limited and that the performance of FNC biopsy with an E-Z-EM needle in addition to or instead of FNA biopsy is not justified.     

Evaluation of fine needle aspiration vs. fine needle capillary sampling on specimen quality and diagnostic accuracy in endoscopic ultrasound-guided biopsy

OBJECTIVE: To compare percutaneous and endoscopic ultrasound (EUS)-guided biopsy techniques. Study DESIGN: From July 2005 to February 2006, all patients referred for EUS-guided fine needle aspiration (FNA) were considered. If inclusion criteria were met, the first 2 biopsy passes were performed without suction (fine needle capillary [FNC] sampling). Two additional passes were performed using the same needle with 10 mL of applied suction (FNA). A single blinded pathologist later retrospectively evaluated each set of slides. Fifty-three patients met inclusion criteria. The study group comprised pancreatic masses (23), lymph nodes (26), subepithelial masses (3) and liver lesion (1). There were 38 malignant and 15 benign lesions. RESULTS: No statistically significant differences were found with the scoring systems considered in the study. In the subgroups of patients with pancreatic masses, lymph nodes, benign disease and malignant disease, no statistically significant outcomes were noted. CONCLUSIONS: No difference exists between quality and diagnostic accuracy of specimens obtained from EUS-guided tissue acquisition via FNC and FNA. The decision to use FNC or FNA should be left to the discretion of the individual endosonographer.     

Nonaspiration fine needle cytology. Application of a new technique to nodular thyroid disease

The basic principle underlying fine needle aspiration (FNA) is the aspiration of cellular material from target masses, often utilizing fairly high suction pressures. The procedure requires a needle and a syringe, advisedly held in a syringe holder, enabling single-handed suction to be exercised. Mastery of the technique is variable, with few operators acquiring consistent skill. A new technique, pioneered in France but essentially unpublicized, eliminates active aspiration, replacing it by the principle of capillary suction of fluid or semifluid material into a thin channel (a fine needle). This nonaspiration sampling method was tested in a consecutive series of 50 solid thyroid nodules. Simultaneously performed conventional FNAs served as controls. Cell samples were cytologically assessed as unsuitable, diagnostic/adequate or diagnostic/superior, without knowledge of the sampling method employed. Diagnostically superior specimens were obtained significantly more frequently by the nonaspiration technique in 36 benign lesions and 13 neoplasms. The method of nonaspiration fine needle cytology ("cytopuncture") is described and illustrated, and the implications for its use in other sites are discussed.     

Cytomorphometry of uveal melanoma. Comparison of fine needle aspiration biopsy samples with histologic sections.

A number of approaches are being investigated to increase the prognostic accuracy for uveal melanoma patients; the standard deviation of nucleolar area measurements and the DNA content appear to correlate better with survival than do classic histologic parameters. The utility of performing cytomorphometric measurements on fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy samples was prospectively analyzed for 24 eyes containing uveal melanomas that were examined with both 25-gauge FNA biopsy and standard histologic techniques. "Masked" analysis of the cellular composition of the 24 cases showed the presence or absence of epithelioid cells to be accurately predicted on the FNA samples in all cases. Image analysis cytomorphometric measurements of nucleolar area showed marked variability (with r less than 0.4) when FNA and histologic samples from the same case were compared. The relationship between these measurements was affected by cell type, sampling, specimen processing and investigator experience.     

Flow cytometric DNA ploidy analysis of soft tissue sarcomas. A comparative study of preoperative fine needle aspirates and postoperative fresh tissues and archival material

Flow cytometric (FCM) DNA ploidy measurements on frozen fresh samples of soft tissue sarcomas were compared with the corresponding analyses on preoperative fine needle aspirates and postoperative formalin-fixed archival tissues from the same tumors. A concordance in ploidy status (diploid versus non-diploid) was obtained for 63% of the fresh tissue-fine needle aspiration (FNA) sample comparisons and for 85% of the fresh tissue-archival material comparisons. The majority of discordances in the fresh tissue-FNA sample comparisons could be explained by FNA sampling errors. In the remaining discordant cases (3 of 27 FNA sample comparisons and 6 of 40 archival material comparisons), sampling errors could not explain the differences in ploidy status. The discordant cases were evenly distributed among the different sampling methods. Method reproducibility was not responsible for the differences in ploidy determinations; tumor heterogeneity may be an explanation for the discrepancies. This study showed that archival soft tissue sarcoma samples are as well suited for DNA ploidy analysis as are fresh frozen tissues.     

Spermatogenesis in azoospermic,formerly cryptorchid men. Use of needle aspiration techniques

OBJECTIVE: To assess the use of testicular needle aspiration techniques to evaluate fertility potential in azoospermic, formerly cryptorchid men. STUDY DESIGN: Fifteen consecutive adult azoospermic, formerly cryptorchid patients (eight unilateral and seven bilateral) were examined by needle aspiration techniques, fine (FNA) and large needle (LNAB) testicular aspiration biopsy, for cytologic and histologic analysis. Five of the 15 subsequently underwent surgical biopsy for attempted assisted fertilization. RESULTS: Spermatozoa or spermatids were detected by FNA cytology or LNAB histology in one or both testicles in 87.5% of the unilateral and 28.6% of the bilaterally affected, formerly cryptorchid patients (P = .041, Fisher's exact test). The addition of LNAB to FNA identified spermatids in one patient with unilateral cryptorchidism and only Sertoli cells on FNA cytology. Furthermore, LNAB differentiated testicles with the cytologic finding of only Sertoli cells into those with or without diffuse fibrosis. In the five patients in whom assisted fertilization was attempted, the needle aspiration techniques predicted the presence or absence of spermatozoa in the subsequent surgical biopsy. CONCLUSION: The two needle aspiration techniques can be used to assess the fertility potential of azoospermic, formerly cryptorchid men and to select patients for assisted fertilization.     

Flow cytometric DNA analysis of renal-cell carcinoma. A study of fine needle aspiration biopsies in comparison with multiple surgical samples

The flow cytometric (FCM) DNA analysis of fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy material was compared with the DNA analysis of multiple surgical biopsy material from 44 renal-cell carcinomas. Twenty tumors were heterogeneous with respect to their DNA content. Eleven of the 17 tumors that had both diploid and aneuploid tumor cell clones in the surgical specimens gave a diploid DNA content in the aspiration biopsies; the other 6 cases showed aneuploidy in the aspirate. The fine needle aspirates from 18 homogeneously diploid tumors and 9 tumors with an aneuploid DNA content in all eight surgical samples revealed DNA indices similar to those found in the surgical samples. These findings show that aneuploid clones of renal-cell carcinoma can remain undetected by the use of FNA biopsy as a method for obtaining samples for FCM DNA analysis.     

Fine needle aspiration of the hot thyroid nodule

The use of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in the evaluation of solitary hot thyroid nodules was examined in 24 patients. Satisfactory FNA specimens were obtained from 22 patients. None of the cytologic samples was considered malignant or suspicious for malignancy. The cytologic findings were indeterminate in one instance--a smear with follicular features. The smears from the other 21 patients were judged to be benign. If FNA had been used as the initial diagnostic step, the need for a thyroid scan would thus perhaps have been avoided in 21 of the 24 patients. These results support the idea that FNA is the most effective procedure in the evaluation of the solitary thyroid nodule, whether functional or not.     

Endometriosis of the rectovaginal septum. Diagnosis by fine needle aspiration cytology

The cytologic picture seen in two cases of rectovaginal endometriosis diagnosed by fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology is presented in detail. The cell pattern differed considerably from that previously described in fluid specimens and more closely resembled the exfoliation observed in direct endometrial samples. No previous report appears to exist on the diagnosis of rectovaginal endometriosis by FNA.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of granulomatous prostatitis induced by BCG immunotherapy of bladder cancer

Six patients treated with intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) for superficial bladder cancer had granulomatous prostatitis demonstrated histologically by transperineal needle biopsy. Four of the six patients also underwent transrectal fine needle aspiration (FNA) for cytologic study. The diagnosis of granulomatous prostatitis was made cytologically in all four without knowledge of the histologic findings. Granulomatous prostatitis appears to be common following intravesical BCG treatment; these cases show that FNA cytology can be recommended as a method for diagnosing this complication.     

Metastatic tumors in fine needle aspiration biopsy of the thyroid

A series of almost 25,000 thyroids examined by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy was reviewed to ascertain the incidence and presentation of metastatic cancers in thyroid FNA samples. Metastatic cancers in FNA samples from the thyroid were identified in 25 cases (0.1%); the primary tumors were carcinomas of the kidney (8 cases), lung (7 cases), breast (5 cases), cervix uteri (1 case) and colon (1 case) and 1 case each of malignant melanoma, malignant pleural mesothelioma and rhabdomyosarcoma. FNA cytology was positive in all 25 cases. In 11 cases, the primary tumor was clinically known at the time of FNA biopsy; of the other 14 cases, cytology suggested that the malignancy was metastatic in only 5. Metastases of renal and mammary adenocarcinomas were almost indistinguishable from follicular and papillary thyroid carcinomas on cytologic grounds. The results demonstrate the rarity of this finding and the difficulty of diagnosing a metastatic tumor in the thyroid by FNA biopsy, in the absence of a clinical history of a prior primary neoplasm.     

Fine needle aspiration of poorly defined indurated and well-defined breast lesions: a cytopathologic comparative study

OBJECTIVE: To compare the cytologic findings and diagnoses of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) samples of well-defined lesions (WDL) with those of poorly defined indurated lesions. STUDY DESIGN: We examined 371 consecutive breast FNA specimens obtained without diagnostic image guidance. Fifty-eight lesions were described by the examining pathologists as PDILs, and the remaining 313 lesions were described as WDLs. RESULTS: Compared with WDLs, PDILs were more likely to yield hypocellular specimens deemed unsatisfactory for diagnostic evaluation (37.9% vs. 14.1%). However, a substantial number of atypical, suspicious for malignancy and malignant cases (12.1%, 5.2%, and 13.8%, respectively) were identified with PDILs. In addition, benign diagnoses were more frequently rendered with aspirates of WDLs, compared with PDILs (47.9% vs. 31.0%). In our study, FNAs of PDILs were more often diagnostic in white women < 49 years of age and in lesions measuring > 2 cm. CONCLUSION: Given the relatively high frequency of malignant, suspicious and atypical lesions detected with PDILs, FNA is a suitable first diagnostic approach for PDILs, especially considering the relatively low cost and simplicity of FNA procedures without diagnostic imaging guidance.     

Thyroid papillary microcarcinoma. Is it really a pitfall of fine needle aspiration cytology?

OBJECTIVE: To assess the role of fine needle aspiration (FNA) of the thyroid in the diagnosis of papillary microcarcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: Eight cases of papillary microcarcinoma were diagnosed by fine needle aspiration. On histologic examination they were found to be adjacent to larger nodules of interest. The microcarcinomas were inadvertently sampled when sampling the larger, dominant nodules. RESULTS: None of the eight dominant nodules were papillary carcinoma; seven were benign lesions, and one was an angioinvasive Hürthle cell carcinoma. In three cases the microcarcinomas were situated within the capsule of a hyperplastic nodule. On histologic examination, five cases had multifocal microcarcinomas, with one case having multiple lymph node metastases. Based on the clinical findings and morphologic features, there were no definitive cytologic findings that could distinguish between "incidental" microcarcinoma and clinically significant papillary carcinoma. CONCLUSION: The detection of microcarcinoma by FNA should not be considered a false positive finding since the exact nature of the lesion cannot be determined until complete histologic evaluation reveals it to be truly incidental and clinically insignificant.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of sclerosing hemangioma of the lung, a mimicker of bronchioloalveolar carcinoma

A rare "sclerosing hemangioma" of the lung in a 24-year-old man was initially interpreted as a bronchioloalveolar carcinoma by fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology. The similarity of these two tumors in fine needle aspirates is discussed. Benign sclerosing hemangioma should be considered in the differential diagnosis when numerous atypical proliferating bronchiolar or alveolar cells are obtained by FNA.     

The role of fine needle aspiration cytology in the diagnosis of lymphoma

The accuracy of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology for the diagnosis of lymphoma and other hematolymphoid malignancies was investigated by a review of 158 FNA specimens from 143 patients. Patients included in the study had either a diagnosis of a hematolymphoid malignancy by FNA cytology or a biopsy diagnosis of lymphoma that was preceded by FNA cytology. Biopsy specimens were obtained from 85% of the patients. Of the 158 needle aspirates, 118 (75%) were diagnosed as lymphoma, 13 (8%) as suspicious of lymphoma, 8 (5%) as myelomas, 3 (2%) as leukemias, 12 (8%) as positive for malignancy and 4 (2%) as negative for malignancy. Two of the 118 needle aspirates diagnosed as lymphoma were false positives while 3 of 13 diagnosed as suspicious for lymphoma were found to be benign. Overall, there were four false negatives. Morphologic subclassification of the lymphomas, originally attempted for 60 needle aspirates, was identical to the histologic subclassification in 51 cases (85%). FNA cytology provided the initial diagnosis of a hematolymphoid malignancy in 51% of the cases and allowed the documentation of recurrent disease in 49%. The results demonstrate the usefulness of FNA cytology for the diagnosis and management of patients with lymphoma.     

Hodgkin's disease: diagnostic accuracy of fine needle aspiration; a report based on 62 consecutive cases

We report on our series of 62 cases occurring between January 1977 and December 1990, which were diagnosed as Hodgkin's disease by fine needle aspiration (FNA) samples. the overall accuracy of the cytological diagnosis was high, with only four incorrect diagnoses and a positive predictive value of 93.5%. the value of FNA as a first level diagnostic technique in the screening of lymphadenopathies is discussed, as well as the limitations and pitfalls of the cytological diagnosis.     

Computed tomography-guided fine needle aspiration of peripheral lung opacities. An initial diagnostic procedure?

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the results of computed tomography (CT)-guided fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology following negative fiberoptic bronchoscopy and sputum cytology. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective study of 64 patients who underwent CT-guided needle aspiration of lung opacities over one year. Following a review of the CT studies, patients were selected according to image characteristics of a primary neoplasm and pleural effusion in cases with pleural lesions. The lesions were classified into three categories--intrapulmonary and peripheral pulmonary, pleuropulmonary and pleural--and were localized and aspirated under CT using a fine needle (22-23 gauge) for obtaining cellular material. Lesions diagnosed as benign on FNA cytology were followed by serial CT scans for a period of two years at six-month intervals. RESULTS: Thirty-nine of 64 (61%) lesions were diagnosed as malignant on FNA cytology and 25 of 64 (39%) as benign. There was one false negative case. There were no serious complications from the procedure. CONCLUSION: FNA under CT guidance may be applied as the initial procedure in the diagnosis of peripheral malignant pulmonary lesions, rendering a high diagnostic yield.     

Immunohistochemical studies with monoclonal antibodies B72.3 and MA5 on histologic and cytologic specimens from benign and malignant breast lesions

Monoclonal antibodies B72.3 and MA5 were tested by the avidin-biotin immunoperoxidase method in histologic sections of 38 benign, 22 precancerous and 22 cancerous breast lesions, as well as in fine needle aspiration (FNA) smears and cell blocks of 25 breast carcinomas. Neither B72.3 nor MA5 was specific for breast cancer cells: both also reacted with cells from benign and precancerous conditions. B72.3 as a "detector" of malignant cells or their precursors was superior to MA5, however: it was not reactive to cells in most benign breast lesions (mammary duct ectasia, fibroadenoma and ductal hyperplasia, with and without atypia). Cancerous cells had heterogeneous immunostaining with B72.3, which may lead to false-negative results in relatively hypocellular FNA samples. FNA samples prepared as both smears and cell blocks provided the most abundant cellular samples and the lowest false-negative immunostaining reaction of cancerous cells with B72.3.